Should Hindi be India's national language? | The Last Word
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Home Minister Amit Shah on the occasion of 'Hindi Diwas' and asked citizens to increase the use of the language in their everyday work. According to him, Hindi is the language that unites the people of our country. Should Hindi be India's national language?
"We do need one language that connects the entire country & it has to be part of a proper policy set-up ", says Santoor Maestro. Listen in!
SUBSCRIBE NOW for more such videos ►bit.ly/2LesD8T
For More Updates ► www.mirrornowne...
Like us on Facebook ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Twitter ► / mirrornow
Mother tongue + English
This should be the formula. English should be the linking national language. Then, everyone needs to learn only two languages. Fair treatment to all.
@Bharat Nanwani It is absurd to compare Nation state with Multinational state.
Learn to Know the differences.
Hindi regionalism is not Indian Nationalism.
@Bharat Nanwani when Hindi is promoted by denying language rights of Non Hindi Ppl. Then wtf i have to prefer Hindi.
@Bharat NanwaniWe won't prefer Hindi until Indian union govt makes all state languages official at Union Level.
i will not learn Hindi until i live atleast 8 months in Hindi speaking state.
FYI i travelled to Jaipur, Noida, Delhi, Ranchi without knowing Hindi.
@Bharat Nanwani sir.... This... Why.... U... Need... Understanding skills........ No one oppose.... The single national.. Language in.. China korea... And. Other countries u mentioned.... Bcz .. Thier all.. Language are similar and.. Have.. A same... Root.... And.... Mainly..... Understandable........ Now....... In our case.... Can... U.. Understand tamil if i speak.. Tamil....like wise i can't understand hindi............ But why we are oppose ...making .. Hindi..national lang was... Very simple....... If... Hindi was. An.. National.. Lang...... Every indian has to.... Learn hindi....... I'm just asking uu...... Wat the... Fucking... Benefit... There is... Frm.. Learning hindi..... U said... Unity we already have... English baiya........ I know.. Now... U gonna.. Say...... Hey.. Its... Not.. Our native.. Lang.. Hindi is. Our native...... Hare.. Baiya.... Do. U... Rly... Think... U can.. Avoid learning english...???...... Are u gonna ... Send ur....children to... Hindi medium....... Or... A school tat not gonna... Teach english............. Pls... Baiya... Accept... It... Or. Not......... Watever... Is.. The... National.. Lang.... We have to learn english........ Then.... Why a... Non hindi.. Speaker have to.. Learn... Hindi .???
@Bharat Nanwani sir.... And... U can... Also....... Take... Example.. Frm.. Singapore Malaysia.... Without.. Imposing... Any lang...... U can... Be.. Better
Why we bengali can't seat for exams in bengali? If Govt. Of India can't organize exams in all 22 official languages. Then they should not organize it in hindi and English. Let everyone face English. Don't favour hindi people with their mothertounge.
Support from South India
This is exactly a point
Full support to My bengali brother from Odisha. Northies get benefited due to paper in hindi. The paper should be in 22 languages nt only hindi and English.
It's too late to cry now. .When TN exactly opposed this policy in 1949 and 1965 , every other state blamed it and prided themselves as broad minded, welcoming etc.. india is overpopulated with limited resources. So to take political control and take the share of resources fully political parties like congress BJP peddled Hindi under the garb of unity , patriotism etc . and fooled everyone . It was initially only for political governance but immediately they converted that into merit criteria handing out advantages to the Hindi speaking people. Then used full government muscle to impose it on all. Everyone kept quiet. So this is the result.
National language is the sole nationality identity of all the citizens. By promoting Hindi the politicians are literally making the nonhindi speaking people as non-nationals. Pl.wait and see.
How all resources goes as per political agenda.
I'm from Tamil Nadu we will never accept Hindi ..... before l liked Hindi I learned also but now it's irritating bcoz of politician🤐....stop imposing Hindi
@Bharat Nanwani Tamil,Telugu,Malayalam,kannada,Bengali are older than hindi.so Hindi is just a kid in diaper.
Tamil people always hate hindi .why I don't know . I have a big dout tamilians are indian ?
@@santoshkumarrath1357 Tamilians are all over the world.. Minorities in many countries and Hindi is mugal language, Pakistani understand more Hindi than south Indians. Hindi is an invader's language.. we are true Indian then you ever will be
@@santoshkumarrath1357 Let it be we are not Indians. Why do u northis still eat our taxes ?
@@santoshkumarrath1357 not an Indian what the Fuck you are going to do hindi bastard
garga and chetan nailed it , those last words of garga were gold truths , hindi is being promoted by the hard earned money of non hindi states.
There is no point in arguing, if you don't know English you're not getting the job. That's it. Scream, Fight do whatever you like, if you're not fluent, all these discussions are pointless.
True Fact !
Yes sister I completely agree with you .. English is a need the world communicates in English. We don't have jobs . Nutrition we Indian take is substandard the first thing is we need is money proper food and clean environment.
@Timer sorry to burst your bubble, to explain and express yourself you'll need to communicate and unfortunately that is English in India. I have not made a comment on journalism. Obviously exceptions are there. And we are talking about India. You don't seem to get the essence of the comment at all. *IF YOU KNOW HINDI IN INDIA, YOU STILL HAVE TO BE WELL SPOKEN IN ENGLISH, THAT IS NOT THE SAME WITH OTHER COUNTRIES.*
@Timer be as ignorant as you can your call.
The BJP goons want to turn India to a lawless land....so less education helps it.....
Garga slammed the hindi speakers in the last statement. Well done. Joy Bangla
True.. This hindi speakers should understand that you should speak in one language which everyone should understand... that is English..
All hindi speaking migrants..in Mumbai & maharashtra arrogantly refuses to learn our local language marathi..
This is what Hindi imposition is
@@Ashish-G- Biharis nd up walas also have its local language as maithili bhijpuri awadhi etc
@@Ashish-G- Even a Bengali tamil or punjabi who lives in mumbai doesnt knows or feels any need to learn marathi there as hindi is alrerady working as the lingua franca of the city, same goes for many other large cities of india.
चल बंगाली फूट इधर से
@@msr7373indeed in Maharashtra marathi is extinct now 😅😊
Million likes for Garga in this debate. He just nailed it from every angle.
Hindi is just a regional language
Malayalam, Tamil, kannada, telugu are older than Hindi
Marathi, bengali,odiya also older than hindi
@@graduationclassesinstitute1522 Hindi is U.P language
And you forgot to mention Hindi is stolen from Sanskrit lol. It's not even original 💀.
Ok crypto Christian 😂😂😂😂
They diverting the topic from financial crisis
Yes sahi kahaa, time pass.
@@Thefatzombie i hope you get paid for writing all this . how long to wait and see already waited 6-7 years
@@Thefatzombie I was right to think that you work in it cell .i know you are trying to frighten me .i am 21st century woman so forget about getting sacred from a child who is father and motherless (that;s you ). if you had good parents wouldn't speak or write such stupidity to anyone ......
@@Jess-gv9gx you need more freedom of speech....
100% True. BJP always doing the same agenda.
I am a bengali and I have learnt Hindi for time pass. I can speak 5 languages. I feel pity to those Hindi speakers that they can't even learn a language just to communicate. Pheww! Shame 🥴
really we have punjabis and up people in our office who speak bengali, gujarati, tamil, kannad, arabic, persian, mandarin, etc
Lots of respect to garga and Chetan from Tamilnadu
@Bharat Nanwani that nation would be in your imagination.
if u impose hindi on us we will separate as a country
@Bharat Nanwani oh come on we are not so dumb to be brainwashed. don't call our love for thamizh as getting brainwashed by politicians. my only question is why can't North Indians learn tamil,telugu, kannada or Malayalam.why only we should learn hindi just because you guys are speaking it. there are many northies working in tamilnadu who don't bother to learn tamil or speak in tamil, but tamilians should learn hindi is it,we only hate that hegemonic mentality
@Bharat Nanwani please make tamil the national language of India. it is older than hindi and sanskrit. I can see that you're a bjp supporter. FYI we don't speak tamil.we breathe tamil. if you guys are hindutva fanatics then we are language fanatics( BTW I'm a staunch hindu but I hate bjp as it's trying to divide india). so please don't you dare impose hindi on tamilians
@Bharat Nanwani seriously north and south Korea share the same language but are arch rivals. if language can unite why was Andhra pradesh split into two ?? why Bangladesh separated from Pakistan bcoz Pakistan did not give importance to bengali. same here if you impose hindi on us we will separate as a country. we are proud Indians but not at the cost of losing our language and culture. india is doing absolutely fine without a national language and will continue to do so
Love from WB
Garga given them their own dose... Speaking in Bangla.
Love from Maharashtra.
Love form Bengal
বাংলা থেকে ভালোবাসা❤️
Love from bengal
Yah
Yes good thing that he given their own dose to them.
👍♥️ From Telugu speaking person.
Imagine an occurrence wherein all non Hindi speakers unite and refuse to use Hindi in any situation !
I am a malayali. I speak tamil also. We south indian dont want pani puri language
@Bharat Nanwani sir... Fight against.. English........ 🤣🤣🤣🤣....... Sir.. Can.. U tell.. Me... Who.. Impose.. English on indians......🤣🤣🤣........then..u want to..unity rit....u can't do it without....forcing me...to learn ur ..lang????......as for .english......no one..forced..me......i know......u learned english.......u gonna...make..ur child...learn english......rit????? ....why.......cant u...stop..making ur..child..stop learn...the..foreign lang...........
Tamil is also ''aiyoo Venkateswara ''language,,only aiyayaooo
@@akshitsoni872 your language is filled with abbey
I am a Bengali and I dont want some fuking Dhosa Idli language
@Lakshmanan Raj J K ille ille dhosa seller 😂😂😂😂
They are treating non-Hindi citizens as second class.
Why you spread wrong comment he not saying like that
@@hinduhindu4193 You should visit Mauritius and see how they are catering to only Hindhi citizens. They charged us for Tamil, but Hindhi classes were free of cost. After Indian railway taken over by North Indians through Hindi compulsion, now ISRO is mandating Hindhi on us. Soon there will be Pan-Tapri outside Isro's office in Namma Bengaluru.
@@psuyog I am talking about Hindi become national language In india not in Mauritius, we are indian and here hindi become 1st language
@@hinduhindu4193 Mararhi is more ancient than Hindhi. Marathi has rich literature dating back to 1st century. Hindhi is a recent phenomenon, no history, no culture .
@@hinduhindu4193 there are non Hindi speaking Indians too what about them are they not indians
My mother tongue is Tamil❤
I don't like to learn Hindi
#Tamilan da..
Seriya sollitinga
One question what is mother tongue?
@@naveenchandel8038 A first language, native language or mother/father/parent tongue, is a language that a person has been exposed to from birth
@@javeedhaters1555 OK thanks but can you tell me what is my mother tongue my father is Punjabi mother is dogri speaking so what is my mother tongue tell me how I interact with my parents in whose side I support?
@@naveenchandel8038 what language you are speaking in child
And what language your parents are commonly speak in home
That's your mother tounge
The bengali guy just rocks
Garga... what a response... I 👏👏👏👏😂. Its a tight slap on those hindi speakers. I didn't understand a bit, but completely understood your gesture... way to go dude..👏👏👏👏
@Bharat NanwaniEven "Hindi" is not our language
@Bharat Nanwani Imposing can only lead to disharmony
@@SunLightSunRavi ya because he is speaking the truth. Now tell me one thing may be its easier for you as its ur mother tongue there are many non hindi states for whom the hindi language is very difficult what they will do?
You will say learn it ?
Now the same question why cant hindi ppl learn the native language when they move to non hindi state. You should think unbiased.
Super Chetan bro.. proud as a Kannada.
Garga C rocked.... Support from Tamilnadu
We shoulld do a movement to change the status of hindi as official language, we want only english or all of our languages as national languages.
Love you my bengali brothers
Hindi speaking people are suffering the most of unemployment. Give them ROTI please.
It's not becoz they speak Hindi u dumb fuq ,it's becoz employment is on 45 years low, and half of the Indian
are Hindi speakers.
And panipuri
Shakeeb you're really not worthy to call human you deserve rude but you know one thing Hindi or any other language never teach anyone to disrespect other language or human learn some ethics otherwise your life has no meaning
Who said they are unemployment? 😡😡They are employed, selling Pani poori and vada pav.
@@coolanuj555 idiot 44 percent is hindi speaker while 56 percent non hindi speakers
Garga chattargee brother love you from tamilnadu ...
@Bharat Nanwani keep dreaming
Kudos to Garga & Chetan to clearly voice out on behalf of the non-hindi speakers. - Tamilan
Hindi sign boards on Mars on their own money !!!
He is from bangla
@Bharat Nanwani lol,even u tell that in english 😁😁😁
@Bharat Nanwani ভাগ বোকা কাছোদা
@Bharat Nanwani same for devnagari script to me
@Bharat Nanwani ok very good if you really want to know about other language,but don't say the bullshit like salvery of English and all.....bro it's 2020,be practical,english is the medium of communication, learning and prosperity ,it's bcz of our comfort in english india produce engineer in the world.....
Bangla bro nailed the arrogant Hindi guy
Boycott Hindi, if you respect your mother tongue. Only learn at your own choice.
Kudos to anchor Tanvi, for keeping the show balanced and saying the right things.
Chetan and Garga demolished those Hindi speakers.
Mr. CHETTEN done an excellent and 100% correct argument people from hindi belt should learn English as like southern people who communicating the entire world with English. If BJP hate foreign language then will they avoid science and technology from foreign land?
democracy came from greece through which BJP came to power.
Q : why hindi
Ans : for uniting india
Q : are we not united now
Ans: no we are always united then
Q : then why hindi
Ans : for better communication
Q : is English bothering you because it make a level playing field for both of us
Ans : But English is a foreign language... Don't be slave under English
Q : then why india is globalized... People are working in MNC'S... need for FDI.... People prone to western dressing style... Ideologies.... Get rid of our own culture and tradition... Etc.. Etc...
Ans : you are linguistic racist
Q : but its you want us to learn hindi
Ans : yes hindi is spoken by many people
Q : but why can't they learn English... How do they survive in this globalized world... Why hindi belt is weak in development and litreacy... And migrating towards south in lakhs... But why are you asking us learn hindi for your convenience..??
Ans : you are an anti indian
Q :,why there is no PM in from north eastern states and only a couple from south
Ans : because they don't know hindi
Q : so you people accept us only after when we know hindi
If answer is yes... Then it's not that important to liver with these kind of racist people
If answer is no.. Then they are wonderful and proven to be the best in accepting india's diverseness
Its all about them.. They are saying that we are not imposing... But repeatedly suggesting to ask us to learn hindi.and wants their language to spread... But we want all indian languages to be spread and recognized internationally... Need government funding without any partialities..
Well said......
Cow belt lawlessness ones don't have any values or culture..
hindi will eip india apart
🎉 excellent 👌👍 the entire Hindi propagation is to get advantage.
Why can't we respect Tamil is the oldest written language in the world with the culture of more than 4000 years . Such a beautiful language which is used in our Indian subcontinent why can't we respect and spread the beauty of this language .. I speak odia and Telugu .. but it makes me feel proud that this land has got a language that is so old ..
@Timer I am a Bengali. I don't know Tamil. But Tamil is indeed the oldest living language in the world.
Search about keezhadi,kumari kandam,poompuhar you'll get to know which is the oldest
Thanks and much love Bengali brother's
Thanks for the support. Tamil might not be the oldest but it is one of the oldest. It is an irony that BJP which hates all things middle eastern promotes a language that has more than 50% Persian and Arabic words!! According to their yardsticks in other matters, Hindi wont even qualify as Indian language let alone national language of India...ha
so what if a language is the oldest? doesn't make any sense so is basque
Ashok C said, Hindi gave us Independence. Lol.
Bengalis were sleeping then.
Ya that's wat I'll happen after imposing , credits to them , y ?
Hindi destroy country
The kind of Hindi he is speaking will not be understood by majority of North Indian population
😂😂
Hindi 💩💩
Didn't know Chetan is such a great orator.
దేశ భాషలందు తెలుగు లెస్స...🙏🙏
🤦 bro understand the reality, in South I see your state is only less voice over Hindi imposition
Garga Chatterjee, RESPECT!!!!
We in South Refuse this narrative and will never except this narrative.
Hindi brought independence to India ??? WOW....really???
ALL 22 LANGUAGE IN 8 TH SCHEDULE OF THE CONSTITUTION ARE OUR NATIONAL LANGUAGE NOT ONLY HINDI .. WE OPPOSE HINDI IMPOSE FROM TAMILNADU ,LOVE TO ALL OTHER NON HINDI SPEAKERS
Don't touch North East region
Juliana Dalbot haha lol👍
South also bro...We support u
GARGA IS THE TIGER OF BENGAL AND INDIA 'S MOST COURAGEOUS PUBLIC FIGURE
If Tamizh and Marathi/Bengali is a regional language, then Hindi is a Pakistani foreign language
Hindi is a borrowed language from Arab and Persia.Hindi is only 500 years old whereas other Regional languages are pure Indian languages which are thousands of years older than Hindi.Tamil is the oldest language in the world and been spoken over 10 million people world wide.We are not fools to nod our head with BJP goon party agenda.
For your kind information sir hindi is coming from parsi Urdu and it's Just 250 year old not 500 years
18.44 for the best reply..I love the Bengali panelist..this is the best way to reply to hindi chauvinists..
If govt wants to make hindi national language, then i want my state to be another country.
Iam from Karnataka
I would say that English should be common tongue
And every state promotes it language...
English is the gateway for knowledge (current science)..
Spot on, it is the emphasis on English based education in South that enabled India become back office of the world today and enabled South Indians to head Global giants like Google, Microsoft and PEPSI etc and the good will generated there rubbed off other sectors in South India like Engineering and healthcare...If we had stuck to Hindi we would have ended up like the bimaru states as well.
हिंदी हमारा हुनर हो सकती है, मातृभाषा और राष्ट्रभाषा नही।
We r Marathi..
#StopHindiImpositiononMH.
Salute to Garga Chatterjee
Hindi is weak language in which great poetry can't be written. Punjabi language has produced great poets from Baba Bulleh Shah to Shiv Batalvi. Hindi promotes rape, murder and caste crimes culture whereas Punjabi Unites the humanity Muslim hindu Sikh etc.
Punjabi poets like Allama Iqbal, Faiz ahmed Faiz, Gulzar , Rajendra Singh bedi Etc have also done commendable work in Urdu literature as well.
Kannada is most oldest beautiful and sweetest language in the world.Kannada is the first language in India to have its own script.
ಕನ್ನಡವೇ ಸತ್ಯ ಕನ್ನಡವೇ ನಿತ್ಯ...
Jai Karnataka maathey!.
Resist Hindi Imposition. Love from Tamilnadu. ❣️
The reality is we have a common dravida language 3000 years ago but hindi is a new language formed...
I am from Tamil Nadu, I have listed few details how imposition of Hindi will affect Tamil, this is applicable for other regional language.
Below I have provided explanation as to why the claim that Hindi is good for future survival of tamil culture and prosperity is a false propaganda by the Hindi belt politicians. Their agenda is to strength their political base in the south by imposing their language. In doing so, they will have a political future in the southern states at the expense of regional parties. Already we are losing the use of our language in several fields due to English, with Hindi there will not be any requirement of Tamil in the future.
Let us imagine Tamil language is in a coffin. I will list the nails that has been slowly added to that coffin since the British and Indian independence.
1. Children who study in English medium schools, science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering all are taught in English. English being the world language it is good for our future survival. People who take tamil as secondary language in english medium, will be able to read and write tamil at basic level. They’ll not be creators in tamil as their language of thinking would be English. Their knowledge creation would only be in English. These people live in the cities who jump from one city to another for their economic prosperity and survival.
2. Children who study in tamil medium will have English as their secondary language and will be able to read/write English at basic level. These children live in secondary cities and villages. They find it difficult to pursue higher studies in science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology in English when they join colleges. Forced to create new knowledge in English. To fix this the number of children in English medium in secondary cities and villages has increased in the last 50 years. With this increase, tamil in future will not be required to explain science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology and would only be used for communication, basic reading and writing. If Hindi is going to be introduced, we don’t need tamil for communication, everyone would prefer Hindi after 3-5 generations.
3. In our society, Tamil is currently being used in religion, entertainment and literature (This will fade) with the growth of English and Hindi. Tamil literature will slowly decline as the number of reader move to English and Hindi. If there is no market for tamil literature there will no longer be any creative writing in it. Only copying and translation in the future.
4. No knowledge creation in tamil (i.e. scientific, technical paper, journal) in the following field science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering. All scientific paper has to be published in English. Reference to knowledge is only available in English.
5. Administration will slowly move towards English/hindi.
6. High court in Tamil Nadu cannot use tamil language to interpret the law and provide judgement. Only English/hindi. Tamil vocabulary will not grow in this field of law.
The requirement of tamil language has been reduced to the following field
Communication, religion, entertainment and literature. This will also die in another few generation and would be replaced by other language English/Hindi.
Tamil requirement in science, technology, business and law field has been slowly eroded because there is an easy replacement (i.e. english). The question is do we accept that status quo. If we accept it and continue then slowly the tamil language will loose it significance as it’s vocabulary will not grow in the above field and because of that their will not be any new literature and knowledge in tamil language in the coming generation. So it will be avoided by the coming generation for their survival. BJP/RSS peoples are spreading false message through news channel regarding the benefits of learning Hindi, when there is none. I agree the state politicians for their selfish gain has given away the state rights, which is hurting the public. Why should we burden our son/daughter to learn additional language in their childhood when its benefits are minimal in the future, it would be required only for socialising and entertainment.
When we are paying taxes to the central government what has the central government done to promote the regional language so its usage can be strengthen in various fields. In high courts we can't use our language for arguments and judgement. There is a hidden agenda to reduce the use of regional language as official language so that usage of Hindi/English becomes the main language in trade, education, business and administration.
i m guessing english / spanish will be d only language after 100 200 years. globalization is on rise. in bangalre apartmnts kids mostly talk in english .
@@storm7567 All those countries you have stated have only one language. We have about 3 dozen languages. Please understand the dynamics and then speak.
Excellent analysis.. We have to stop the imposition of hindi.. Promote our mother tongue in every field... When china, japan, south korea, france, german and most of the countries are teach their children with their mother tongue why don't we do it... Atleast up to 10th std every subjects should be taught in mother tongue.. English is taught as an additional language next toTamil... This will help the students understand their subjects thoroughly.. This is the only solution to save our culture and heritage.. Otherwise the entire race will become nomadic tribes...
@Bharat Nanwani .. In Tamil nadu there is one language TAMIL.. More over India is not one nation. It is a union of many nations.. Each nation has its own language culture heritage.. As per Constitution India is bharath is the union of states (nations)... Every language is treated equally with respect.. unity in diversity...
Why suddently one fellow not talking in english, im lost. English tranlation pls.
BJP doesn't know English.
English is not BJP's STREANH .
@@wethepeople1680 but big corporate who control them are good in english
He is just showing off, idiot hindiwala
There are 22 good links to link all major languages of our beloved country Removing all but one will lead to weakening of the chain
BJP and English is like bip and science and bjp and education। They're contradictions and can't co exist
When a language has economic value people will start learn that language themselves automatically. Eg mandrin people learning worlwide because of its econimic values and opportunities, likewise hindi has no such commercial
Values within india or in overseas
It's becos Chinese government imposed mandrin as an national language, which is good.
@@coolanuj555 what you say had any relation with the comment or topic?
@@manusabu5839 how mandrin language got it's economic value?
Answer is in my prv comment, how Hindi language will get higher economic value across India , answer is in Amit shah speech
@@coolanuj555 mandrin is only language there here hindi is not . and mandrin help get job there are big corporates there who provide...people focus mandrin when china become a big ecnomy...here hindi sattes are worse...its good for me to learn mandrin than hindi
@@coolanuj555 is the stupied shah doing anything to create jobs or help india to be an ecnomic value no
Hindi can never be a national language..!!
8.50 Ashok starts speaks in hindi..where people are talking in english..he thinks talk in hindi is nationalism..thats the hindi imposition..
Chetan has won our hearts
Lots of love to the people of Tamil Nadu & Karnataka
Indian citizen should remembered how India got independence is through revolution and struggles as many cases revolution had changed the scenerio of many countries. As of now hindi language is another agenda by hindi talking people and dominate with disrespect to other sanctity. So what my main point here is that I do not wish to see a new REVOLUTION that will change the scenerio of Indian Republic Sanctity or New International Boundary Line will newly draw divided to North East South West.
हिंदी हुनर हो सकती है राष्ट्रभाषा और मातृभाषा नही।
जय मराठी जय महाराष्ट्र.💪
Create problem...let the citizens fight with each other...people will live in constant confusion....occassionally fight with each other on road or in courts....and the sarkar has successfully developed the nation ...tackled unemployment, economy...zenda uncha rahe hamara..😎
Ye jo public hai sab janchuki hai,
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊.
70 millions are joblessness.
first distribute tax income based on wealth contribution not population
@Timer still better than corrent dirty population ...look at the hindi belt states they taking no action to control population...farmers and enemployment nice joke..do you think the money is spent on them..no it mainly spent o statues and goes to forions accounts..
@Timer i was think about it a lot..after independence the cheap political parties mainly focus on over populating states were they can play cast religion politics easily... to stop it its the best way
@Timer how many years how many govenments..did even shah or modi try to educate people in up no they will come up and say thing like we make hindinational language ..and build statues ...its always bin delhi based politices..a small number rich people will in delhi control the hindi states and from that hindi state votes india...
foremost is education , then infrastructure, then healthcare, if these three are met then automatically, gradually we will progress..good thoughts but the govenment not doing it that why we need to change the income distribution...it may lead to devloping states become more devloping that still better than waste that money
@Timer right now more fund is pumped to under developed states is that funds using for development? until some private news group break the news the income tax of political leaders in up(for 40 years) was payed by govenment.. and look at the funds they waste in name of cow or projects which have no benefit for development ...
Imagine the situation when the fund only get if they developed ..the state will focus on the development not population. it will be rough for starting years but will help India develop
@Timer they need to ask for development. i okey if the govt using the funds to develop the states but so far nothing and not even steps to control population...make the change then we can see atleast few leaders from that states wil talk about jobs and development..not the cast and religionn bbased politics
A North Indian friend of mine who is a college topper said that I’m not a Mallu because I’m a Christian!😒 before one language we need to be educated about the country...
mallu is south india man
@Timer guys there is no double quote for " I'm not a Mallu...
Jeffancy is saying about her and not north Indian
I am a Indian Tamil who can speak and understand Hindi. But I learnt it on my own. I don't want it to be taught mandatorily Hindi. Thank you
Tamils are not Indian
@@banhindipeopleandlanguage and hindis are from urdus and urdus came from muslims and muslim country is pakistan so you are >>>>>>>>>>>
Huge respect from Tamil Nadu for the Telungu Actor Chetan! He made the point! He's a educated person. Other should stop talking.
He is Kannadiga, Kannada actor
Most of writers poets comes from bengal.... Anthem also hav been written in bangla.... How illiterate the hindi poet mother tongue apne ap aja te hain.... And Rabindranath tagores writings have Been more beautiful when it has been translated in Hindi?
Santanab Das aTagore was inspired by Kannada state anthem Kaayo Sree Gowri of the Mysore Wodeyar kingdom
He heard this when he visited Mysore along with Gandhi
This was also the time when Gandhi called Mysore maharajas kingdom as Ramrajya
chethan and garga simply nailed it
My mother tongue is Kannada❤️....we don't want hindi in Karnataka
The BJP person - Why dont the Central govt put boards with all official languages !!!
Why Hindi?????? We have different languages. Why only giving special preference to hindi??????? I'm from Tamil nadu and I want the government to treat every languages equally....
Joy bangla
Bangla amar gorbo
Bangla amar pran
Joy Bangla
@@shaswata1 joy bangla
Joy bangla
The Battleline is drawn already, it's time to decide what the central government and northern states want? Do you want United India or Independent Tamilnadu? Because we are ready for the battle and we are ready to fight till the last man standing.
தனித் தமிழ் நாடு 💪💪
@Harshith Subramaniam It's hard to accept I am Indian first and Tamil next at the current condition of this country.
If this country doesn't change into Federal System, soon it's going to break up. I can see things - slowly and steadily they are grabbing State Powers and Rights. It's infringement into our system. They are trying to push us down.
@Bharat Nanwani What is Indian Culture? There is nothing called Indian culture. Every regional native people has their own culture. That's all.
Learning English will make you equal , learning Hindi will make another slave to Delhi. 😎
@Bharat Nanwani Swiss has 4 national language even though 80% Swiss people speak German.
Love the people, not the country. What is the country Today maybe not be there tomorrow. But people will.
National language plays a crucial part 😂. For intergeration - then let's accept English as a Link language. Everyone can keep their mother tongue in their nhome state.
@Bharat Nanwani Then Change India into Federation. We are done with this Union. No more stealing of our tax money.
Tamil is the oldest language in the world Let's all learn tamil language.
Well said- why should we burden ourselves to learn more language whereby English is taught in every state in india after their mother tongue.
Scheme to scrap English?
No just diversion tactics
Mr.Garga deliberately taunted the Panelist who speaks hindi in english debate by not listening to his speech and minding his phone , cool move ..When you are in a panel to establish a thing , people's understanding matters much than your language comfort. The English news channel better not allow any hindi speaker to speak in hindi in english channel hereafter.
I don't know Hindi.
"Hindi ne hame azadi dilai"
...Yes,Bengalis were sleeping then!!
Tu Pakistani
@@thomasranjit7781 tera baap pakistani.o sorry u don't know who is ur father.
Kitna azadi diliya hai lol girls are not save here do you know bo derti hai tum jaisai logo sai I am Bengali always be Bengali l love my religion language and you get lost and fuck up 😡😡😡😡
and marathis also
@@JosephStalin-io5fp only gujjus and marwaris were fighting
We dont want hindi as a national language
My mother tongue is telugu rocks
Bangla Bro brutalized these Hindi Chauvinists!!
GARGA C IS absolutely right
We can't effort to learn so many language... In meghalaya we learn garo English .. adding Hindi to our education ..we won't be able to focus on science and maths
Right 3 languages is too much
Main motive should be skill development to youth
English very important
TN follows 2 language policy.
Tamil + English. State govt should determine the language policy.
Bhaad diya hindi ko....Smart Bangali ne...Congrats brother....
Haha when vote class 8 pass ...what else do you expect???
The only place where hindi influence in tamil nadu is where a North indian sell panni puri. And influenced hindi words are baiya eak plate panni puri😊
so this guy wants the future generations to speak hindi, our future generations? no, thank you.
@Bharat Nanwani No doubt you yourself are not native to india, dravidians are and our languages are.
@Bharat Nanwani So now you talk logic and are outraged as I said something outrageous? so now you know how outraged we are of the idea? We will become second class citizens in our country? I am sorry you had to learn the hard way
This is not about English dude, come to your senses and get out of that haze of feeling great about only your language and your culture, and understand how many sacrifices non hindi speakers and non north indians had to do in this country.
@Bharat Nanwani yes buddy, you should get outraged and so are we in our very right to get outraged and you are belittling that outrage whereas im encouraging your outrage, just use your logic for generality rather than your own convenience, you will get it.
Okkay theeeen lets make telugu as national language, everbody should learn telugu and all the official business of goi should be in telugu.
Kerala is OUT of India!
Chethan great...bro u r gift to Karnataka
Iam from karnnataka I don't want to learn your pani puri language
ಸಿರಿ ಕನ್ನಡ is our mother tongue ❤️❤️
.BJP should concentrate on providing more jobs, good health services, and security. Stop wasting time on language.
Chetan gave me goosebumps
The anchor has done a good job
how convenient of hindi speakers to talk against our fight for our languages.
Chetan sir kannadiga❤️❤️❤️
To make you northi Pani puri sellers easy in Tamil nadu, Should we learn Hindi ??????
Chethan love you man
IF panjabi and Marathi accepted even we bangal will never learn or agreed 👍
1952 and 1971 we declared our motive 👍
These people are saying english is a foriegn language and hindi is an indian language that will unite us but for us south indians even hindi is foriegn and why is language taken patriotically..we are happy with english whether it is foriegn or not .We have been using it since ages😝
Tamil should
be a national language how about that, how the north Indians would feel
We are dead. 🤣
What a sarcasm
They are crying😭
@@vikashnandha6121 how many people from North knows Tamil ? Why English became a global language ? Because it has the power to connect the diverse planet and North Indians uses Hindi in that same way , what south India uses as a common language ? English ? Fuck !! Your villagers dont even know how to say hello in English and you guys are fighting over this stupid thing. We dont hate South Indians we just want them to be connected to us and you are just isolating yourself with biased boundaries. Tell UK people to learn Tons of languages since we use their language ... Will they ?
@@wbfootball1211 but Hindi is alien to us.
On one side we are talking about reducing bag weight of school going children on the other side we are imposing Hindi or trying to ..
English is an international language a foreign language to all Indian .. bt that's our need we have to communicate with the world
. Point number 2 - Hindi speaking child will learn English and Hindi
Tamil Telugu oriya kannada Bengali Marathi Gujarati all have to learn their own language along with Hindi and English ..
There's no harm in learning more languages but it need to be optional ..
Eradicate poverty and corruption and then I will learn HINDI. First politicians should do their homework and then we will obey and listen.
Chetan 👏👏👏👏🔥
I am from Odisha. I like be English our national language. Why, this time english is most important to us. Without English our country's international business, diplomacy and geographical change impossible. Who tall Hindi be our national language he don't know english nither his mother tongue is Hindi. I request Amit Saha sir, why he do not lean english.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Chetan's profound speech gave me goosebumps
Everyone praising Chetan and Garga but u also should praise Tanvi Shukla's opening statement in multiple languages.. Awesome u all😀👍