The best Genesis tribute bands seem to come from the Latin nations Québéc, Argentina & Northern Italy. For some reason this to resonate with us so much.
Remember Peter Gabriel is of Spanish origins...his family hailed from Spain but then arrived in England around the 15th century and was adopted by cornish peasants ...probably this has something to do with it !!!
Oh! what a surprise! I didn´t know that Phil Collins join this tribute band "The musical box", I am very happy of that, it shows how an open and nice persons are Steve Hackett and also Phil Collins, I am very glad of that, really. Best wishes from Argentina!
Best wishes from Barcelona. Bienvenido a mi canal (el del Prog mas Clásico) donde encontrarás otros videos de The Musical Box, Steve Hackett y Phil Collins entre muchos otros. Un placer conocerte.
Like a lot of people on this post, I was not aware that Collins had ever indulged in anything like this, I cannot abide his work with Genesis after 77, but as a drummer in the Gabriel era he was superb - kudos to him for participating. He has risen in my expectations.
Phil was born with incredible talent and an amazing voice. Been with him since 1973 ..... was fed "Going Back" the other day, a Carole King cover. Nobody but Phil could do it like that. Only negative thing I can say about him...... MISUNDERSTANDING
Phil was a brilliant drummer, one of my favourite in fact, I remember the early days when they got started around Guildford when you could see them at the College or the University for about a £1, Phil used to a do backing vocals for Peter. He had a boom mic and after he finished singing he would swing the mic out of the way and get down to business on the drum kit, and what a drummer he was.
You’re welcome. Here it is: Genetics & Steve Hackett - ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.html The Musical Box & Phil Collins - ua-cam.com/video/nWZT0EHKjCk/v-deo.html Have a nice trip over both clips.
@@ToniMartinTCPRIL pero esos no son los videos de las actuaciones, están recortados. ¿Es posible tener los videos completos? // but those are not the videos of the performances, they are cropped, is it possible to have the full videos?
Is there a full version of these? It would be delightful to hear the whole song for each.....especially with Phil drumming. My heart aches for his infirmities. Phil gave us so much of himself. Gracias.
@@rk41gator I’ve never found the complete TMB & Phil Collins video. That’s what I edited Genetics & Steve Hackett this way, to have the same Final Result. Anyway, here it’s the material I worked with: Genetics & Steve Hackett - ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.html The Musical Box & Phil Collins - ua-cam.com/video/nWZT0EHKjCk/v-deo.html Un placer.
I can see it is hard for Phil playing those old songs again. They are quite complicated to say the least. Phil said already in 1987 that he couldn't play like he did in the 70's. That may have to do with not playing that music regulary though.
@@chinchumza tienes toda la razón. La primera parte, efectivamente, es Steve Hackett con los argentinos Genetics. En cualquier caso, entiendo que el anterior comentario se refiere a la segunda parte del video, donde es Phil Collins quien le hace las segundas voces a Denis Gagné, el cantante de los canadienses The Musical Box.
@@ToniMartinTCPRIL Si, tienes razón. Me apuré en la respuesta, tal vez la ansiedad por volver a verlos juntos a los Genetics con Hackett en agosto. Abrazo gigante
This song was composed by Steve entierly said Tony Banks , and the lyrics and all the musics , book Genesis Foxtrot transcription FOR GUITAR by Paulo De Carhvallo
The song was written before Steve joined, as he admits in the full group interview with John Edginton. Ant Phillips and Mike Rutherford wrote the first bit
The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics snd Hackett, to get the final result at the same point.
The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Hackett, to get the final result at the same point.
You’re completely right. The Original one from TMB and Phil Collins is that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Steve Hackett to match both clips. I mean, to have a final result not one better than the other.
@@howardtennenhouse7849 The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Hackett, to get the final result at the same point. In this YT Channel we always like to be very careful and also very respectful at the editing and mixing time. But this Clip is this way.
@@GeneticsBand yes, that’s right. And I even posted the link of this perfotmance in this page: “Hackett: ‘The first show with those talented musicians at the Teatro Coliseo had a magical atmosphere and the Buenos Aires crowd was as enthusiastic as ever. I enjoyed every minute.’ hackettsongs.com ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.htmlsi=rx_5IGCCsyoKUEda “
You’re completely right. The Original one from TMB and Phil Collins is that way (as you can see in the link attached), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Steve Hackett to match both clips. I mean, to have a final result not one better than the other.
hey boy! Didn't the scar above his lip convince you it's Phil? Left handed Drumset! A little fat and out of shape but it's Phil! And of course ... his voice.
Thank you Steve for reviving this music.😁
what a treat for the Band and audience. The Musical Box deserved this moment with P.D.C. COLLINS!
Phil Collins revival !!!! Genetics with Steve Hackett & Phil Collins ....... !!!!!!
my favorite part, phil backing vocals again. shivers.
The best Genesis tribute bands seem to come from the Latin nations Québéc, Argentina & Northern Italy. For some reason this to resonate with us so much.
Remember Peter Gabriel is of Spanish origins...his family hailed from Spain but then arrived in England around the 15th century and was adopted by cornish peasants ...probably this has something to do with it !!!
S Hacket with Genetics from Argentina, fenomenal tribute band ¡¡¡
Oh! what a surprise! I didn´t know that Phil Collins join this tribute band "The musical box", I am very happy of that, it shows how an open and nice persons are Steve Hackett and also Phil Collins, I am very glad of that, really.
Best wishes from Argentina!
Best wishes from Barcelona. Bienvenido a mi canal (el del Prog mas Clásico) donde encontrarás otros videos de The Musical Box, Steve Hackett y Phil Collins entre muchos otros.
Un placer conocerte.
First band is Genetics whit Hackett in Argentina.
the voice...the voice!!!!! It's Peter Gabriel himself!!!!! Never heard before this singer...It's a magic!!!!!
The singer in _Can Utility And the Coastliners_ could well be cast as a psycho killer in a thriller movie, but the voice similarity is indisputable.
Like a lot of people on this post, I was not aware that Collins had ever indulged in anything like this, I cannot abide his work with Genesis after 77, but as a drummer in the Gabriel era he was superb - kudos to him for participating. He has risen in my expectations.
Phil was born with incredible talent and an amazing voice. Been with him since 1973 ..... was fed "Going Back" the other day, a Carole King cover. Nobody but Phil could do it like that. Only negative thing I can say about him...... MISUNDERSTANDING
Amen to that.@@ghostship85
@@ghostship85 I would argue about the "amazing voice", but as drummer, no doubt he was one of the best all time.
I am very happy for you. After all, it's all about you.
@@MikeyRB77 Ouch! The searing sarcasm and carnival tent analysis. I feel suitably chastised and incredibly small.
excelente guitarrista y compositor, grupo, impulso al rock progresivo a nuestros dias............ wua
Phil thanks the Lord because with Musical Box begins his incredible career.
Phil was a brilliant drummer, one of my favourite in fact, I remember the early days when they got started around Guildford when you could see them at the College or the University for about a £1, Phil used to a do backing vocals for Peter. He had a boom mic and after he finished singing he would swing the mic out of the way and get down to business on the drum kit, and what a drummer he was.
How great to see Phil playing and singing The Musical Box again.
Wow phil singing the backing vox aswell. The band must be absolutely creaming themselves. What a privilege for them and the audience
I love Genesis on its roots
Beautiful.
Thanks.
Can utility is the best song they ever made!
Probably my favorite Genesis song. That's saying a lot since Genesis are my favorite band, and I like ALL "eras."
.....thankyou utube. This and many more videos I've seen, has enriched my musical interests no end. 😊
No, thanks to you. For people like you, that’s the reason why I love making videos. It’s a pleasure.
Interesting, did not know Phil did something like this at the time. (Second clip)
I like this singer, Pete Newer😮
Immer noch tolle Musik.
This singer would suit a Gentle Giant tribute act very well
You're right!
This brought tears to my eyes
Where can i see both performances in full? Both entire concerts?
Thanks very much
I can do a search...
You’re welcome. Here it is:
Genetics & Steve Hackett - ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.html
The Musical Box & Phil Collins - ua-cam.com/video/nWZT0EHKjCk/v-deo.html
Have a nice trip over both clips.
S Hacket with Genetics from Argentina, fenomenal tribute band ¡¡¡
@@ToniMartinTCPRIL pero esos no son los videos de las actuaciones, están recortados. ¿Es posible tener los videos completos? // but those are not the videos of the performances, they are cropped, is it possible to have the full videos?
@@juliogarciadolz4386 todo el material que edité lo extraje de ambos videos. No tengo mas información.
Is there a full version of these? It would be delightful to hear the whole song for each.....especially with Phil drumming. My heart aches for his infirmities. Phil gave us so much of himself. Gracias.
@@rk41gator I’ve never found the complete TMB & Phil Collins video. That’s what I edited Genetics & Steve Hackett this way, to have the same Final Result.
Anyway, here it’s the material I worked with:
Genetics & Steve Hackett - ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.html
The Musical Box & Phil Collins - ua-cam.com/video/nWZT0EHKjCk/v-deo.html
Un placer.
We have played full shows with Steve since 2015, having toured South America in 2023. Check our channel!
Cool very cool ✨️🎶✨️
Usually old prog rocker shows are nostalgic but a let down performance wise. In contrast, I HIGHLY recommend seeing Steve Hackett's show if you can.
It’s noted. Thank you very much.
well... Steve tours with us. It's not nostalgic, just music.
@@GeneticsBand Its nostalgic if you were ripping bong hits before Genesis concerts in the 70's.
I can see it is hard for Phil playing those old songs again. They are quite complicated to say the least. Phil said already in 1987 that he couldn't play like he did in the 70's. That may have to do with not playing that music regulary though.
Muy buenoo
Thanks so much.
You’re welcome. It’s a pleasure, making and sharing what we all love.
I feel happy if you’ve like it.
Genetics 💖
Looks like Phil playing with the Musical Box?
Yes, it’s Phil Collins himself playing with TMB.
Nooo, es Genetics, banda Argentina tributo a Génesis, con Steve Hackett, en el 2015 en la primera parte.
@@chinchumza tienes toda la razón. La primera parte, efectivamente, es Steve Hackett con los argentinos Genetics.
En cualquier caso, entiendo que el anterior comentario se refiere a la segunda parte del video, donde es Phil Collins quien le hace las segundas voces a Denis Gagné, el cantante de los canadienses The Musical Box.
@@ToniMartinTCPRIL Si, tienes razón. Me apuré en la respuesta, tal vez la ansiedad por volver a verlos juntos a los Genetics con Hackett en agosto. Abrazo gigante
@@chinchumza otro para ti. Y muchas gracias por seguir mi canal, muchas gracias por disfrutar con placeres musicales compartidos.
This song was composed by Steve entierly said Tony Banks , and the lyrics and all the musics , book Genesis Foxtrot transcription FOR GUITAR by Paulo De Carhvallo
The song was written before Steve joined, as he admits in the full group interview with John Edginton. Ant Phillips and Mike Rutherford wrote the first bit
"This is one by our bass player, it's called 'Jazz Odyssey'".
"He wrote this"
❤
Amazed collins agreed to this given his often expressed disdain for the old stuff.
Sorry to be negative, but why so many edits? It frustrated me and spoilt the enjoyment somewhat. Is it possible to repost it fully?
The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics snd Hackett, to get the final result at the same point.
Yeah the edits are irritating and unnecessary
Bravi!
♥️♥️
Who’s the singer ?
Genetics’ singer (the band playing with Hackett): Tomás Price.
The Musical Box’s singer (the band playig with Collins): Denis Gagné.
To
Tomas Price yeah
S Hacket with Genetics from Argentina, fenomenal tribute band ¡¡¡
What? There's a missing verse here. Very weird, all of it.
the complete song in our channel.
God, why is this edited?? Let the whole thing play out!
The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Hackett, to get the final result at the same point.
What was the point in chopping it up like this?
You’re completely right.
The Original one from TMB and Phil Collins is that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Steve Hackett to match both clips. I mean, to have a final result not one better than the other.
If you’re a follower of my YT Channel, sure you perfectly know I try to be as much careful as respectful at the editing and mixing time.
Lol nothing gonna shatter the ego of a lead singer quite like the drummer getting a bigger applause while singing backup
Ce groupe me transperse le Coeur:Tel le Christ crucifié jusqu'à sa mort (il avait dit:C'elui qui boira de mon eau n'aura plus soif!!!)
It's Ray willson marillion
And I prefer Steve Wilson to Nad Sylvan.
Quizás fue la última vez que Phil collins tocó la batería x sus problemas de salud
@@dariochacur3282 seguramente tienes toda la razón. Y si no la última, poco mas tocaría desde entonces.
The AI was strong with this one!
Jajajajaja
Great but songs are so chopped up
@@howardtennenhouse7849 The original clip from The Musical Box and Phil Collins is edited that way (as you can see in the attached link), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Hackett, to get the final result at the same point.
In this YT Channel we always like to be very careful and also very respectful at the editing and mixing time.
But this Clip is this way.
in our channel you will find the complete video... and many more!
@@GeneticsBand yes, that’s right. And I even posted the link of this perfotmance in this page:
“Hackett: ‘The first show with those talented musicians at the Teatro Coliseo had a magical atmosphere and the Buenos Aires crowd was as enthusiastic as ever. I enjoyed every minute.’ hackettsongs.com
ua-cam.com/video/CfAskbKptyY/v-deo.htmlsi=rx_5IGCCsyoKUEda “
edit Heresy
You’re completely right.
The Original one from TMB and Phil Collins is that way (as you can see in the link attached), so I decided to do the same with Genetics and Steve Hackett to match both clips. I mean, to have a final result not one better than the other.
If you’re a follower of my YT Channel, sure you perfectly know I try to be as much careful as respectful at the editing and mixing time.
No Phil Collins
Sir, in the second video of the Clip (TC 2.50), there’s Mr. Collins playing drums and backing vocals with TMB. Geneve, 2005.
Should of gone to spec savers
your attention span is crap
hey boy! Didn't the scar above his lip convince you it's Phil? Left handed Drumset! A little fat and out of shape but it's Phil! And of course ... his voice.
What wonderful slices of butchered music you have posted!
Can't stand any Gabriel imitator, they all sound stuck in the past. Get a life and do sth new
Prefer this guy much better than Nad Sylvian. Just my opinion.
Nad isn't a vocal clone of either Peter or Phil. He exists somewhere in between, and has his own stage presence. I find his performances riveting.
... y Ray Wilson ....
@@teemusidcouldn’t agree more. He allows Steve To cover more than just the Gabriel period.
Yeah, he's come a long way since singing "waters wetweet"😅
Agree 100 %