Surprised there are so many detractors, but none of them offer specific evidence of anything wrong! I think its a great video and it has alerted me to the fact that one of my drawings transferred to a canvas for painting involving a circular object was not quite in perspective. Thanks greatly!
I have been trying to figure this out for a week! Finally stumbled upon your video and I drew the round bench in a rendering I needed in 5 minutes! Thanks so much!!
Thank you so much, this was very helpful I was, for some reason, having so much problems with this, but after watching your video and taking notes, it all made it so simple.
I think one reason that the wheel diagram is or looks distorted is because the box that houses it is drawn in 1-pt perspective, whereas it should have been drawn in 2-pt. This is because there are TWO sides of the box which are visible, both of which should be receding into the distance toward their own vanishing points.
@MangaTipoftheDay Will do! I'll put those on my plate for future videos. :) I'm glad you like this. For this tutorial I'm using Photoshop. For specifics on that, I might need to do another tutorial. ;)
Hi Salina, The tutorial is meant as a guide for drawing on paper. In this particular case I explained the process then inserted the ellipse. In my future tutorials I'll be sure to draw in the ellipse so it makes more sense. :)
Sorry to be off topic but does anybody know of a tool to get back into an Instagram account..? I was dumb forgot the login password. I love any help you can give me!
@Malachi Raymond thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site through google and im trying it out now. Takes quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
A lot of the detracting comments here refer to drawing CIRCLES in perspective, which then 'become' ellipses. This video demonstrates an ELLIPSE drawn in perspective. They don't look right if you're expecting to see a circle in perspective. They are correct if you are drawing something which is an elliptical shape in reality, like a tube cut at an angle.
@AsjJohnson127 I use the elliptical marquis tool on a new layer, skew it using the free transform option and then fill the line with a stroke. The tutorial is actually meant to demonstrate the process to be completed freehand. Keep practicing, it will get easier the more you do it.
Thanks bunnygrunt a very helpful video...this method works really well following a helical spiral so I'm a little closer to copying the simpler Rafeal Araujo sketches great help thanks again xx
You just need to create a perfect cube first by using the 45° and Station Point, then use the technique shown above to get the circular cylinder right?
I have a question-- How do you draw an ellipse into the space marked off by the dots? It happened like magic in the video and totally wowed me. This tutorial was mind-blowing. Thank you for it. :) I only hope I can figure out how to draw that perfect ellipse from those dots....
Are you referring to the cross-hairs of the ellipse in a wheel form? Not sure, as you're using 'car-speak' and I work the 'art-speak'. ;) After drawing the perspective center X, the cross-hairs follow suit with the lines parallel to them. So on the wheel, one cross-hair will be vertical, the other will follow the vanishing point (as the sides parallel to it also follow the vanishing point). Let me know if that's even close to what you're asking. :)
How do you decide where to draw the second, horizontal closing line of the rectangle, before drawing the X? That is what I find the most difficult and so far, no instructor on UA-cam has grappled with this important problem. The instructor just draws this line "roughly" where it is supposed to be. What is the secret ?
great video, but I have an issue with the wheel. If: 1. the minor axis of the ellipse is collinear with the axle of the wheel (attached to the chassis) 2. the axle of the wheel is horizontal then it follows the minor axis should be horizontal surely? or have I got that wrong?
Thanks for the tutorial. Here is a question. How do you determine the depth (back end) of the sphere? Say I draw perspective view of a car. How do I determine how deep (far back) the tires end?
@8fantasy19195 I use the elliptical marquis tool on a new layer, skew it using the free transform option and then fill the line with a stroke. In Photoshop. :)
@AndrevwZA There is a method for that, but it's pretty complicated. Maybe another video? Just keep in mind the car would be VERY foreshortened. By using reference images you can get a sense and eyeball it.
totally a novice thing, but: why is the cylinder always in a single orientation? it is always facing upwards, like resting on a table. wouldn't all these rules be 100% subverted if you, for example, allowed the cylinder to rest on top of a pebble? now the orientation of the overall cylinder is offset. and therefore perspective drawing with this technique is impossible...? meesa confused.
Can confirm that this is not accurate. I did the math and those circles are just a tiny bit too stretched out. However, the difference is tiny (6% on the diagonals), so this "technique" can still be used to achieve reasonable results.
Yep, since the square measures are taken with the eye and not with any other method, the circle in perspective (that´s the ellipse) is not perfect, so those are ovals not circles. It could present some proportions problems if you are constructing something out of that. But anyways, if you are aiming for an artistic approach that´s enough.
All those horizontal lines go to second vanishing point. In this video there's only one vanishing point, so all horizontal lines are linear to each other.
I am learning to draw and am stuck on how to determine when and where to place vanishing points in 2 point perspective. When instructors state to place them far apart to prevent distortion, they never give tips on how to decide how far apart - they just state, "Until it looks right". How does a new artist know what looks right? I need a rationale.
The problem your having seems to be with Cone of Vision or CoV for short. The idea behind CoV is that information outside the viewers CoV will become distorted when the information reaches the viewer. This will cause a square in perspective to appear as a rectangle. The cone of vision can literally be thought of as a cone (from the viewers eye being the tip) hitting the picture plane. The standard CoV is about 60 degrees but a smaller or larger CoV can be used for greater/lesser amount of distortion. This explanation is complicated and its difficult to explain using just text as it deals with technical perspective, however if your interested in fields that use strong perspective (such as industrial design) Id recommend getting a good book on the subject as it is a very useful tool in practice. I hope this helps. :)
Please, I think I have everything else down but this: If the ellipse were facing "fwd" it would appear as a circle inside a square, correct? When you place the horizontal line @1:03. How do you know where to place it? I understand how to make an ellipse inside a rectangle now thanks to you. But I don't know where to place the line so that I am drawing a square in perspective. Thanks for the help.
Tutorial - feedback to improve presentation skills. This Presentation is a Demonstration, less description would be the recommendation - by the professional of Public Speaking and Presentations. Note the attitude conveyed to audience through both words and inflections. These points are the cause factors of the negative (thumbs down) audience feedback. FYIFI = For your information for improvements.
French's mechanical drawing. Thus the French curve. page 87-88. Now what about the long and short diameter of an oval in two point perspective. Please use the toolbox so everyone can follow.
but you need to draw a square in perspective in order to draw a circle from it in perspective. that is the most important thing to learn if you want to draw say a wheel of a car or a cocacola can, or a coin etc
@codeb24 Hahah THANKS! You can actually do this method with a ruler and a pencil. I completed this demo for an assignment that is to be completed with pencil on paper. :)
bunnygrunts Mm.. yes its true. Actually its not in the "middle' of those lines. You can get away with it, but the more the ellipse is turned those "middle" dots will become farther from the middle point. This is easy to prove by doing a 2 point perspective Projection drawing.
bunnygrunts I agree that eyeballing that middle point will help someone freehand ellipses.. But you can even see clearly it in the other cylinders you drew.. the points on the closer side of the cylinder's ellipses are slightly south of that "middle" point.. as where the points on the farther side are slightly north of that "middle"
Right. This is why you use the perspective center X to find the middle of a rectangle in perspective, it places the 'middle' dot of a shape in the PERSPECTIVE middle, not the measured middle, making it correctly off-center. It sounds as if you're under the assumption that using the 'X' places the center in the measured center, which it does not.
Surprised there are so many detractors, but none of them offer specific evidence of anything wrong! I think its a great video and it has alerted me to the fact that one of my drawings transferred to a canvas for painting involving a circular object was not quite in perspective. Thanks greatly!
michael greene
10 yrs later and this is still helpful ty
I have been trying to figure this out for a week! Finally stumbled upon your video and I drew the round bench in a rendering I needed in 5 minutes! Thanks so much!!
You have a lovely voice to listen to. I follow your lessons way better than my drawing teacher's lessons.
Thank you so much, this was very helpful I was, for some reason, having so much problems with this, but after watching your video and taking notes, it all made it so simple.
I think one reason that the wheel diagram is or looks distorted is because the box that houses it is drawn in 1-pt perspective, whereas it should have been drawn in 2-pt. This is because there are TWO sides of the box which are visible, both of which should be receding into the distance toward their own vanishing points.
???
This is super well presented. The clacking noise is very hard, however. Much thanks!
The examples are no incorrect, they are just distorted. I can provide evidence if anyone is up for it.
Amazing! This has helped tremendously!!!! I am having a complete lightbulb going off in my brain, eureka moment! Thank you SO MUCH!
@MangaTipoftheDay
Will do! I'll put those on my plate for future videos. :) I'm glad you like this.
For this tutorial I'm using Photoshop. For specifics on that, I might need to do another tutorial. ;)
Hi Salina, The tutorial is meant as a guide for drawing on paper. In this particular case I explained the process then inserted the ellipse. In my future tutorials I'll be sure to draw in the ellipse so it makes more sense. :)
Sorry to be off topic but does anybody know of a tool to get back into an Instagram account..?
I was dumb forgot the login password. I love any help you can give me!
@Omari Kobe instablaster :)
@Malachi Raymond thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site through google and im trying it out now.
Takes quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
@Malachi Raymond it did the trick and I now got access to my account again. I am so happy:D
Thank you so much you saved my ass !
@Omari Kobe Happy to help =)
A lot of the detracting comments here refer to drawing CIRCLES in perspective, which then 'become' ellipses. This video demonstrates an ELLIPSE drawn in perspective. They don't look right if you're expecting to see a circle in perspective. They are correct if you are drawing something which is an elliptical shape in reality, like a tube cut at an angle.
An old video, but still very helpful.
Really enjoyed the video. Thanks!
i'd love to see construction of bent cylinders / tubes in 2 point perspective with shadows added :)
I just love explaining drawing elipses to my students so finally I've prepared similar (but with hand drawing) video :)
you're nuts
@@mickeyromeo these NUTs
Excellent video! Thank you
I can't see where the ellipse's perpendicular major and minor axes are supposed to be. That's what I'm struggling to figure out.
This really helped me, especially drawing the diamond, thank you for putting this up!
@AsjJohnson127
I use the elliptical marquis tool on a new layer, skew it using the free transform option and then fill the line with a stroke. The tutorial is actually meant to demonstrate the process to be completed freehand. Keep practicing, it will get easier the more you do it.
this was so helpful! you just saved me from failing my imaging systems assignment!
Perspective center is different from the center. Thank you.
thanks! I didn't know about the the diamond step and freehanding without it was driving me nuts.
Awesome 👌 Which app or software program are you using?
Thanks bunnygrunt a very helpful video...this method works really well following a helical spiral so I'm a little closer to copying the simpler Rafeal Araujo sketches great help thanks again xx
In the finished ellipse the four intersection points do not lie in the half of the distance!
This was a perfect explanation! Thank you! :)
Came for the screename.
Stayed for the tutorial.
the "wheel" is absolutely wrong. what you drew is elliptic cylinder, not a right circular cylinder..
You just need to create a perfect cube first by using the 45° and Station Point, then use the technique shown above to get the circular cylinder right?
What a useful video. Thank you for your sharing.
Oh yeah! I love this stuff. More please. 😁
this was very helpful. i am going to use this technique in pencil drawing.
I have a question-- How do you draw an ellipse into the space marked off by the dots? It happened like magic in the video and totally wowed me. This tutorial was mind-blowing. Thank you for it. :) I only hope I can figure out how to draw that perfect ellipse from those dots....
Thank you so much ,I'm watching this before my exam ,and I'm so nervous ,because I have to draw a constructive picture ,and I'm really bad at that
Are you referring to the cross-hairs of the ellipse in a wheel form? Not sure, as you're using 'car-speak' and I work the 'art-speak'. ;)
After drawing the perspective center X, the cross-hairs follow suit with the lines parallel to them. So on the wheel, one cross-hair will be vertical, the other will follow the vanishing point (as the sides parallel to it also follow the vanishing point).
Let me know if that's even close to what you're asking. :)
Wow. This is exactly what I needed. Thanks!
How do you decide where to draw the second, horizontal closing line of the rectangle, before drawing the X? That is what I find the most difficult and so far, no instructor on UA-cam has grappled with this important problem. The instructor just draws this line "roughly" where it is supposed to be. What is the secret ?
great video, but I have an issue with the wheel. If:
1. the minor axis of the ellipse is collinear with the axle of the wheel (attached to the chassis)
2. the axle of the wheel is horizontal
then it follows the minor axis should be horizontal surely? or have I got that wrong?
Tthat was really great! Thank you :)
Thanks for the tutorial. Here is a question. How do you determine the depth (back end) of the sphere? Say I draw perspective view of a car. How do I determine how deep (far back) the tires end?
How are you drawing with perfect control ?
Is it possible if you could make a video based on 1,2, and 3 perspective point arches?
@8fantasy19195
I use the elliptical marquis tool on a new layer, skew it using the free transform option and then fill the line with a stroke. In Photoshop. :)
I just need to know once you plotted the points, what do you press for it to draw out the circle??
Is this method only for things, or can it be used for drawing characters too? Anime for example.
Greg Trial no you can draw people in perspective too look up tutorials,
If I am drawing the "can of soup", would it be a rule that the longer axis of the ellipse should also always be fully horizontal?
How did you determine where to draw the horizontal line completing the rectangle?
Sooooo thaaaaat's what it's called! Thanks! Ellipses!
@AndrevwZA
There is a method for that, but it's pretty complicated. Maybe another video? Just keep in mind the car would be VERY foreshortened. By using reference images you can get a sense and eyeball it.
It was very helpful. Thanks.
Thank you that was very helpful.
you're a star
How did you draw the circles? :(
I can't seem to make circles in perspective in Photoshop, and I'm not good enough to draw them free-hand.
Great tutorial! Thanks a lot!! ♥
Nice tutor thereby ;)
totally a novice thing, but: why is the cylinder always in a single orientation? it is always facing upwards, like resting on a table. wouldn't all these rules be 100% subverted if you, for example, allowed the cylinder to rest on top of a pebble? now the orientation of the overall cylinder is offset. and therefore perspective drawing with this technique is impossible...?
meesa confused.
Can confirm that this is not accurate. I did the math and those circles are just a tiny bit too stretched out. However, the difference is tiny (6% on the diagonals), so this "technique" can still be used to achieve reasonable results.
scLightO How did you do the math? Can you explain to me or reference me?
Could you do a rut for cylinder in 2 point perspective
This is helpful! Thanks
Is the second one an oblique ??
how are you doing this? what tool are you using to make the dots and draw the ellipse.?
Yep, since the square measures are taken with the eye and not with any other method, the circle in perspective (that´s the ellipse) is not perfect, so those are ovals not circles. It could present some proportions problems if you are constructing something out of that.
But anyways, if you are aiming for an artistic approach that´s enough.
Sorry. I'll draw them manually on my upcoming videos. :)
All those horizontal lines go to second vanishing point. In this video there's only one vanishing point, so all horizontal lines are linear to each other.
@helicoptersrkool
Yes, I understand that. :) For these purposes I was not including reference to the cone of vision.
Thank you!
I am learning to draw and am stuck on how to determine when and where to place vanishing points in 2 point perspective. When instructors state to place them far apart to prevent distortion, they never give tips on how to decide how far apart - they just state, "Until it looks right". How does a new artist know what looks right? I need a rationale.
The problem your having seems to be with Cone of Vision or CoV for short. The idea behind CoV is that information outside the viewers CoV will become distorted when the information reaches the viewer. This will cause a square in perspective to appear as a rectangle. The cone of vision can literally be thought of as a cone (from the viewers eye being the tip) hitting the picture plane. The standard CoV is about 60 degrees but a smaller or larger CoV can be used for greater/lesser amount of distortion. This explanation is complicated and its difficult to explain using just text as it deals with technical perspective, however if your interested in fields that use strong perspective (such as industrial design) Id recommend getting a good book on the subject as it is a very useful tool in practice. I hope this helps. :)
Ryan Mcphee That you Ryan for this information. I appreciate it!
what tool did you use to create the ellipse? Thanks!
Thank you so muchhhh
Please, I think I have everything else down but this: If the ellipse were facing "fwd" it would appear as a circle inside a square, correct? When you place the horizontal line @1:03. How do you know where to place it? I understand how to make an ellipse inside a rectangle now thanks to you. But I don't know where to place the line so that I am drawing a square in perspective. Thanks for the help.
In 1point perspective, horizontals and verticals exist
@MaverickCook
YES!
That really helped me thanks!
Great tutorial thanks :)
Thank you so much!
Ya know what? I'll work on that this week. :)
Are you doing this on paint?
very helpful thanks
Thanks that helps a lot with car drawing :)
Thanks a lot, this really helped me☺️☺️
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!
wth...
Why did you make the circle magically appear D:
I wanted to see you do it manually....
Are you still making videos
Do you know the way of the circle
thank you
The middle refers to foreshortening. correct.
如果可以運用這種簡單的原理畫出3D轉成2D圖想必運用一段時間了
it's perfectly inside the cone of vision.
應該說答題時間已經結束
裡面有規則
可用軟體程式來實現成重複的功能
已經進化到3D動畫或遊戲裡
想必這是專業版要(代價)
good video thanks !
Tutorial - feedback to improve presentation skills.
This Presentation is a Demonstration, less description would be the recommendation - by the professional of Public Speaking and Presentations.
Note the attitude conveyed to audience through both words and inflections.
These points are the cause factors of the negative (thumbs down) audience feedback.
FYIFI = For your information for improvements.
French's mechanical drawing. Thus the French curve. page 87-88. Now what about the long and short diameter of an oval in two point perspective.
Please use the toolbox so everyone can follow.
Please watch Scott Robertson's Basic Drawing video instead for drawing ellipses in perspective.
Love it!
@deemzila
For this tutorial, I'm using Photoshop. I'm not sure what you're asking, can you clarify? :)
Thanks!
but you need to draw a square in perspective in order to draw a circle from it in perspective. that is the most important thing to learn if you want to draw say a wheel of a car or a cocacola can, or a coin etc
YES. For this assignment we weren't dealing with cone of vision yet. Thanks though. :)
@codeb24
Hahah THANKS!
You can actually do this method with a ruler and a pencil. I completed this demo for an assignment that is to be completed with pencil on paper. :)
sexy voice indeed lol ... just wondering, did you ever do the tutorial in 2 point perspective ?
how can i draw elipses like this in let's say autocad??? i can't just connect 8 dots and end up with an elipse :S
Groovy Mutation I don't know anything about Autocad, I used Photoshop and used the ellipse tool, transforming it to fit the shape. Sorry. :(
Autocad is not made for perspective sketching.
2:58
The "middle"part is simply not true.
Can you clarify? What's not true?
bunnygrunts Mm.. yes its true. Actually its not in the "middle' of those lines. You can get away with it, but the more the ellipse is turned those "middle" dots will become farther from the middle point. This is easy to prove by doing a 2 point perspective Projection drawing.
bunnygrunts I agree that eyeballing that middle point will help someone freehand ellipses.. But you can even see clearly it in the other cylinders you drew.. the points on the closer side of the cylinder's ellipses are slightly south of that "middle" point.. as where the points on the farther side are slightly north of that "middle"
Right. This is why you use the perspective center X to find the middle of a rectangle in perspective, it places the 'middle' dot of a shape in the PERSPECTIVE middle, not the measured middle, making it correctly off-center.
It sounds as if you're under the assumption that using the 'X' places the center in the measured center, which it does not.
you are seven years older now, and i love you :)