The difference between the FALCHION and MACHETE - why one is a sword and the other is not

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 бер 2023
  • What's the difference between a falchion and machete?
    If you like the content and want to support the channel, you're welcome to do so through Utreon, Subscribe Star or Patreon:
    utreon.com/c/shadiversity
    www.subscribestar.com/shadive...
    / shadbrooks
    Come check out my other channels!
    THE SHADLANDS: / @theshadlands1142
    KNIGHTS WATCH: / knightswatch
    Subscribe to my website so you don't miss an upload: www.shadmbrooks.com/
    Follow me on Facebook: / shadiversity
    Follow me on twitter: / shadmbrooks
    My novel, Shadow of the Conqueror Audio Book affiliate links:
    US: www.audible.com/shadbrooks
    UK: www.audible.co.uk/shadbrooks
    CA: www.audible.ca/shadbrooks
    AU: www.audible.com.au/shadbrooks
    Ebook, Paperback and Hardcover available from most major book retailers, here are a few of the main ones:
    Amazon affiliate link (be sure to navigate to your country's amazon site):
    amzn.to/2XErUaR
    Barnes and Noble:
    www.barnesandnoble.com/w/shad...
    Kobo:
    www.kobo.com/au/en/ebook/shad...
    Awesome Shirts and chainmail print clothing: teespring.com/en-GB/stores/sh...
    Visit Calimacil for the best replica foam swords and LARP weapons: calimacil.com?aff=38
    Buy my sword IMPERIOUS from Calimacil: calimacil.com/products/imperi...
    Community run discord server: / discord

КОМЕНТАРІ • 797

  • @ethannumberc-1379
    @ethannumberc-1379 Рік тому +732

    I'm a professional bladesmith and I was planning on using a machete to make a falchion for myself simply because I knew it was a good steel and a close enough profile that I could make a reasonably good blade out of it, I'm tempted to send it to you now once it's done for abusive testing 😂

  • @zaqzilla1
    @zaqzilla1 Рік тому +423

    I love how there's a warning label on the machete. If you don't know a large sharp blade is dangerous you're not a big reader.

    • @windhelmguard5295
      @windhelmguard5295 Рік тому +60

      expecting someone who doesn't know that a sharp blade is dangerous, to be able to read, is a level of faith in humanity that i can only envy.

    • @harbl99
      @harbl99 Рік тому +45

      Seems to be a "We did warn you, it's on you" precaution.

    • @slimetank394
      @slimetank394 Рік тому +28

      Those label are more to avoid lawsuit tbh.

    • @Benw8888
      @Benw8888 Рік тому +4

      @@windhelmguard5295 the point is to warn the user that the blade is sharp; a normal person might not know whether it's sharp or not, and doesn't feel comfortable testing the sharpness by touching the edge

    • @nathanbrown8680
      @nathanbrown8680 Рік тому +4

      @@Benw8888 You mean the purchaser. The user never knows for sure unless they've just sharpened it because edges blunt with use.

  • @poilboiler
    @poilboiler Рік тому +206

    My favorite wrongly named weapon is the Ogre Morningstar from Gothic 3. It's a big and heavy sledgehammer and the description mentions how it's not actually a morningstar but are you really going to explain that to an ogre?

  • @soopahfly6692
    @soopahfly6692 Рік тому +545

    The machete reminds me of my childhood in the Philippines. When I was young, we were expected to help keep the grounds clean at my school. Students are grouped and are expected to take turns removing weeds growing from the school garden and the premises. Once a week I would board the bus carrying a machete and half of the passengers too would have a group of young teens with blades on them. Nobody bats an eye.
    Well, it was a rural school I attended and we had some kids that were in the agriculture club that actually had to work a 6-hectare land to grow produce or they don't get a grade at the end of the term. The 2 farm water buffalos we were using became our mascots.

    • @Nil_Sama
      @Nil_Sama Рік тому +76

      Same here! Except my "machete" was about as sharp an a baby's butt and was so rusted over that the only real use for it was to dig out deep rooted weeds! Honestly, at that point it would've been more accurate to call it a shovel 😂

    • @Rakanarshi2
      @Rakanarshi2 Рік тому +14

      wow holy shit that is badass. Cool!

    • @windhelmguard5295
      @windhelmguard5295 Рік тому +32

      @@Nil_Sama interestingly, i had worked as a sort of janitor at a public pool and they had a sand box for the small children, that sandbox i had to sort of flatten with a spade once per day in the morning and one thing i had noticed was that thrusting a spade into wet sand over and over actually honed the damn thing to a jagged, but still very sharp edge, that could easily take your toe off if you weren't careful.

    • @Nil_Sama
      @Nil_Sama Рік тому +25

      @@windhelmguard5295 Yeah, I can see that happening because sand is very abrasive. Actually, the only non rusted part of that old thing was the tip I used for digging. 😂

    • @Nil_Sama
      @Nil_Sama Рік тому +27

      @@Rakanarshi2 Souds cool, until the teachers ask you to uproot weeds and till tightly packed soil (and carry buckets of water to water the plants). It's been like 10 years since I last done it and I can still remember how sore my palms and figers were after everything was done. It was a good experience though, taught us hard work and responsibility.

  • @metalchungus6241
    @metalchungus6241 Рік тому +44

    Hi, just a little fact. The machete with the orange grip is from the mexican brand "Truper". Truper is the top brand regarding tools here in Mexico. As a mexican I can confirm that even if you neglect that machete (no maintenance and a lot of work abuse) that machete will keep its shape and will be as easy to sharpen as new. That machete will also exist across generations in your family. Also please note that all brand new machetes sold here in Mexico are always dull. You have to sharpen it. This is primarly to make them a bit cheaper aswell to be sharpened to the user preference

    • @maddraugr4667
      @maddraugr4667 Рік тому +6

      Calidad🇲🇽

    • @juanarredondo9763
      @juanarredondo9763 Рік тому +13

      dont forget the cultural importance of the machete since our grandpas faught the devil on the top of the mountains 🇲🇽

    • @metalchungus6241
      @metalchungus6241 Рік тому +4

      @@juanarredondo9763 The Mata-Chamucos 3000

  • @brothersliutgeryitzchakjea7889
    @brothersliutgeryitzchakjea7889 Рік тому +131

    Unfortunately when it comes to big name manufacturers they don’t know what a falchion is, the condor one in the video is a great example. Windlass actually had a decent model for under 160$ usd for years but they discontinued it as they had quality control issues with the thinner blades warping during heat treatment.
    If you want something good it’s going to hurt the wallet. So we actually did what you are planning with the machete, it works, so good luck and can’t wait to see results.

    • @grbdevnull5611
      @grbdevnull5611 Рік тому +3

      It looks like Windlass may have the "Medieval Falchion" back in production. It is listed on Kult of Athena anyway. It is no Albion (the Windlass Medieval Falchion and the Albion Vassal are the only falchions I have owned, and I ended up having to sell both), but my example was decent.

  • @greatestcait
    @greatestcait Рік тому +208

    Falchions and messers are possibly my absolute favorite kinds of swords/bladed weapons out there. I just love the shape of the blade, its so lovely.

    • @crossfade330
      @crossfade330 Рік тому +5

      I am with you on this one. I find so much beauty in its pretty brutal overall form.

    • @MizraimEvans
      @MizraimEvans Рік тому

      that's nice

    • @johnedgar7956
      @johnedgar7956 Рік тому +1

      I agree! I would love to have a nice Gustav-type messer with a nice scabbard. Sadly, my budget dictates otherwise. One of these days, I WILL have one, for the same aesthetic reasons as yours. 🙂

    • @Raso719
      @Raso719 Рік тому +1

      Yeah Messers have really grown on me on recent years.

    • @code066funkinbird3
      @code066funkinbird3 2 місяці тому

      Same with katana

  • @Gendo3s2k
    @Gendo3s2k Рік тому +87

    The cameraman deserves a lot of credit! The panning and zooming is perfect

  • @titusjuventiuscelsus9758
    @titusjuventiuscelsus9758 Рік тому +20

    Machetes were used as weapons by the Cuban Liberation Army in the Ten Years’ War and the War of 1895 as cavalry weapons and infantry sidearms. The common availability of these instruments combined with the military tactics used by insurgent generals allowed for devastating attacks and conservation of scarce firearm ammunition.

  • @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation
    @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation Рік тому +72

    What if we made a... Machalchion? Or a falchete?

  • @fedorapug8501
    @fedorapug8501 Рік тому +8

    I was feeling bad this morning, but than I saw that Shad uploaded!

  • @Hawk013
    @Hawk013 Рік тому +4

    When I lived in Florida I owned 3 machetes for maintaining my yard. One was a great big 3mm thick plank with a deep bevel, it was an amazing chopper but it was tiring to use. The Fiskars was thin and light, great for grass and weeds, but just couldn't cut deep. The $1 unbranded one from a flea market bucket was balanced and had a nice taper and held an edge well, it was a great compromise. I was rather annoyed when it got stolen.

  • @robertross5201
    @robertross5201 Рік тому +9

    I wasn’t aware that falchions were so thin historically but then that’s not a blade type I’m familiar with. Thanks for the info

  • @jameshamaker9321
    @jameshamaker9321 Рік тому +8

    Since, there's a cutlass in the collection shad has, I'd like to see him cover pirate sword styles. That would be amazing.

  • @mansfieldtime
    @mansfieldtime Рік тому +9

    I'm glad you talked about the weight. Because pictures and movies do not do it justice. I've used a machete before but never a falchion or supposable falchion. I noticed that the machete was a great hacking tool like an ax, so when you started talking about falchion I thought they would be used more like an ax then a sword. Thankyou for correcting that.

  • @LiverpoolReject
    @LiverpoolReject Рік тому +79

    I like how slowly he's moving from leather bound peasant fighter to full plate knight!

    • @SergioLeonardoCornejo
      @SergioLeonardoCornejo Рік тому

      Normally it is the other way around, and ends with unarmored children.

    • @darthjarjar8
      @darthjarjar8 Рік тому +2

      Ikr, loving the transformation!

    • @Ryu1ify
      @Ryu1ify Рік тому +17

      Low-level fighting man accumulates dungeon treasure to pay for better armor, you love to see it

    • @Anegor
      @Anegor Рік тому +7

      What he wears isn't leather, its Brigantine and it's full of steel plates. He wore a gambishon before he got it.

    • @LiverpoolReject
      @LiverpoolReject Рік тому +1

      @@Anegor that pretty cool I'll have to check that out, thanks for the info.

  • @Ranstone
    @Ranstone Рік тому +6

    Shadiversity: *Uploads*
    My left mouse button: "I AM SPEED!"

  • @MephiticMiasma
    @MephiticMiasma Рік тому +6

    "the blades were so thin that the rusting has put holes in them"
    ...sounds like the sheet metal on my first car....

  • @johnedgar7956
    @johnedgar7956 Рік тому +25

    Thank you Shad! This was a GREAT video. (Greetings from Missouri in the USA. 😊) I have actually wondered a few times if a common machete blade is anything approaching the "threshold" of what a falchion should be. I found your video to be EXTREMELY useful on this! I seriously want a short-ish falchion or a messer with a nice scabbard; your expertise on these is just wonderfully helpful.

  • @triumphant39
    @triumphant39 Рік тому +72

    I am extremely familiar with machetes, I own 100-200 of them. For me they are very nimble.. I'm not saying there aren't drawbacks, but I personally feel very confident with them as weapons (I prefer them over swords, because at the end of the day it's a tool), especially in a modern context.

    • @williambennett7935
      @williambennett7935 Рік тому +19

      Why do you have so many?

    • @squiresnake
      @squiresnake Рік тому +16

      I love how you have so many that you dont even know how many you have exactly

    • @windhelmguard5295
      @windhelmguard5295 Рік тому +7

      i own only one machete, but if i had to defend myself it would be my go to over any other tool i own, apart from maybe the felling axe.
      a lot of machetes would make for amazing swords (some are better at being swords than machetes even)
      in many ways just adding a cross guard to some machetes would make them better swords than most reproductions you can buy, for a much lower price too.

    • @triumphant39
      @triumphant39 Рік тому +17

      @@williambennett7935 I have bought surplus packs of them. I own maybe 20 special ones. I love them, but I can also sell the surplus ones if I need to. I may also turn some of the surplus ones into other things, like you could easily use one to make a sword or knife by cutting it or reshaping the blade.

    • @Elmonsoon
      @Elmonsoon Рік тому +19

      I am sure you have a perfectly reasonable explanation for owning hundreds of machetes, but maybe don't mention it on a first date.

  • @Sir_Rioghain
    @Sir_Rioghain Рік тому +28

    It struck me today that Shad's hair/beard combo REALLY looks like a medieval aristocrat or a knight errant. Looking sharp, Shad!

  • @marcussherlock6318
    @marcussherlock6318 Рік тому +7

    I love how you have knowledgeable peers to chat with now. You guys look like you have a lot of fun together making these videos.

  • @Eramiserasmus
    @Eramiserasmus Рік тому +20

    Thank you for the explanation, now to challenge the nearest underbrush with the correct blade!

  • @edgarburlyman738
    @edgarburlyman738 Рік тому +38

    Shad you're the #1 swordtuber now, you can't have things like "falchion stand-in"s anymore.

    • @toddkes5890
      @toddkes5890 Рік тому +13

      So until he gets the correct sword, you'll be on edge?

    • @stevenpetrillo9527
      @stevenpetrillo9527 Рік тому +2

      But only a single beveled edge

    • @DZ-1987
      @DZ-1987 Рік тому +7

      ​@@toddkes5890 Trust me, that's just the tip of it.

    • @hyperion3145
      @hyperion3145 Рік тому +1

      ​@@toddkes5890 Yes, we will riot until he has exactly the proper sword

    • @MrDibara
      @MrDibara Рік тому +1

      ​@@toddkes5890_Ayyyyy!_ 😂

  • @MadNumForce
    @MadNumForce Рік тому +4

    Machetes evolved from sailor's hangers. The "fullers" we still see on many machete patterns are remnants of the fuller from 17th century Dussäge/Sinclair hilt hangers ships were armed with and that were used as bush clearing and bivouac tools when landing in the Caribbean or other parts of Latin America. Blade manufacturing centers like Solingen and Sheffield simplified the design over time to make it easier to manufacture, but the advent of the industrial revolution, mass production of cast steel, steam powered rolling mills and stamping press turned the manually forged blade of the early 19th century into the modern mass produced machete. But while machetes made in Solingen and Sheffield were flat with distal taper, the machetes made in France have no distal taper but a proper grind from spine to edge.

  • @m.shields1270
    @m.shields1270 Рік тому +4

    Falchions always felt super under appreciated to me. It’s not as iconic or flashy as a Longsword, Scimitar, or Katana, but dog goneit if it ain’t a reliable weapon.

  • @goosemanVEVO
    @goosemanVEVO Рік тому +8

    You should DIY a new hilt for that machete to give it a crossguard and a pommel.

  • @johnpavy6130
    @johnpavy6130 Рік тому +5

    Thank you Shad! You have confirmed my decision to make a cheap replica falchion from a 28" Gavilan machete, adding a crossguard and pommel. The handle is messer rather than falchion but easily disguised. It is probably closer to a historic cleaver falchion than anything commercially available. Slices light targets like the proverbial hot knife through butter even if it looks a little clunky. 😊

  • @EthanBlakeProductions
    @EthanBlakeProductions Рік тому +2

    You had me at “swelling at the tip”.

  • @adventureindustries
    @adventureindustries Рік тому +9

    Speaking of the machete, have you ever done a video on movie serial killers, like Jason Voorhees, Michael Myers, Leatherface? I know this isn't Medieval per se but it would be interesting to see a comparison between the effectiveness of using a machete vs a chainsaw vs a large kitchen knife as a weapon. Maybe throw in Freddy Krueger's bladed glove for fun. Just a thought.

  • @jacobweaver368
    @jacobweaver368 Рік тому +4

    Never really thought too hard on how similar the two are but I definitely am now!

  • @WesternIronwoks
    @WesternIronwoks Рік тому +20

    I like how you touch on how much variety in a single type of weapon there would be. The shape and weight of a weapon would depend on the enemy you are fighting. Armored enemies would require heavier weapons.(without considering piercing weapons) The light razor type weapons would do great against unarmored enemies. I use to make swords for Botn and other armored combat groups plus I have spent decades doin mostly SCA and other groups like Botn and some Larp.(I use to be a pro athlete playing american football) So I understand the Combat quiet well.

  • @1thevm1
    @1thevm1 Рік тому +5

    The "Falchion" Shad got looked like they googled what a Falchion was supposed to look like and just mindlessly copied it without understanding its core design principles.

    • @frosticle6409
      @frosticle6409 Рік тому

      Hope Shad looks at the Fire Emblem Falchion: Marth/Lucina/Chrom

  • @johnedgar7956
    @johnedgar7956 Рік тому +5

    I seriously wish I could click the "like" button more than once on this one. 🙂

  • @Kveeni
    @Kveeni Рік тому +1

    Whatever Shad told I take that granted. We could end all disagreement just listening him and agreeing obvious wisdom of his words. So simple so easy.

  • @O_Nao-Conformista
    @O_Nao-Conformista Рік тому +5

    I have the impression that the falchion is a type of sword made to cut through gambeson, I remember from a Skallagrim video where he tests multiple kinds of blades against gambeson that the swords with thicker blades and thicker edges didn't get through the gambeson at all while the thinner swords were able to cut through it, so I'm thinking that's the reason why the historical falchions were razor sharp and the reason why it's a broad sword in profile is so it has more space to get thinner towards the edge, not to be heavier and hit harder, probably a kind of sword more likely to be found as a secondary weapon at the battlefield rather than as a personal defense weapon at the streets, a anti light armor weapon

    • @r.a.4190
      @r.a.4190 Рік тому

      Dont Fall for it. Its a scam

    • @lalli8152
      @lalli8152 Рік тому +1

      I would think falchion would be pretty good civilian sidearm because medieval people wore quite thick clothing in streets, and i think they actually did carry quite lot of falchions, and messers that has similar blades to falchion in civilian life. Not to mention later they carried falchion type blades just with more complex hilt design closer to the cutlass shad used as example for good falchion blade

  • @OverlordIcy
    @OverlordIcy Рік тому +1

    Thank You Shad!!! I'd commented on the last Video you showed us that Machete on(I think it was the Messer Video iirc) asking about that Machete and who made it because I wanted one and couldn't find it online myself. At around 4:50 in this Video you finally answered that question for me by telling us, so thank you very much!!! I very much doubt it, but I'm going to keep telling myself that you were responding to my comment question, knowing you'd be doing another video soon showcasing it again. xP Thanks Shad, love the content, keep it up mate!

  • @danielsieber4809
    @danielsieber4809 Рік тому +22

    Love falchions. Would be interested in an assessment between standard falchions (which were thin and designed to take on gambesons and other lightly armored individuals) and the cleaver falchions (or whatever other names they have) that did seem to be depicted as beefier and being used against armor.

    • @spades9681
      @spades9681 Рік тому +1

      “Cleaver falchions” didn’t exist. They look beefier, but they were just as thin as the rest and thus still quite light.

    • @danielsieber4809
      @danielsieber4809 Рік тому +1

      Well it'd be interesting to see if depictions like in the Maciejowski manuscripts were based on real (is not necessarily popular) weapons that were seemingly used as anti-armor options or if it is not feasible and is artistic exaggeration. I can't say definitively either way but it seems plausible that there were 2 different types that had superficial similarities but different functions.

    • @spades9681
      @spades9681 Рік тому

      @@danielsieber4809 Ah, you’re referring to those somewhat spiky looking falchions often seen in the Maciejowski Bible. I’m not so sure they really served a different function, as in the Maciejowski they’re still primarily being employed against unarmored opponents. The difference in blade profile could just have been an aesthetic choice. Dunno, I’m sure J.G. Elmslie would have an explanation.

    • @spades9681
      @spades9681 Рік тому

      Hm, curiously enough, Elmslie seems, at least in the past, to have labeled it a “proto-messer”, the evidence being a table knife of a very similar form found elsewhere in the Maciejowski. This, of course, tells you nothing about just how heavy or thick they were, but it’s interesting nonetheless.

  • @DarkTau
    @DarkTau Рік тому +1

    My paternal grandfather at one point worked in a steel mill in his life and he got his hands on a chunk of railroad steel that he cut, forged and hardened into a really nice machete (total length was about 23" long) with a wrapped wooden handle that I used to take when I'd go hunting or fishing with my father as a 8 and 9 year old child. Was really lightweight for what it was and quite easy to wield for a small child, did a great job chopping through brush and small trees. Unfortunately it was one of those items that got sold or lost when he passed so I was not able to keep it for myself, which is a shame as it was truly a beautiful blade.

  • @redheadontheinternet6714
    @redheadontheinternet6714 Рік тому

    Your videos have really motivated me to learn more about swords/medieval culture and even working on my health. Thanks shad and crew for everything you do.

    • @r.a.4190
      @r.a.4190 Рік тому +1

      Dont Fall for it. Its a scam

  • @KnifeChatswithTobias
    @KnifeChatswithTobias Рік тому +1

    I have to tell you, the machete also has numerous blade profiles in the family. Depending on what the machete is designed for the blades can be thicker. The one you were flexing was a lighter grass machete and what most people would consider the stereotypical machete. I believe machetes of the Central American region evolved from the Cutlasses via deserters from Spain, France, and England. So it would make sense that there is quite a bit of similarity.
    Thanks for discussing the cross section/distal tapering, etc. and what really makes the difference instead of just basic profile! Learned a lot!

  • @weq3ei8u42
    @weq3ei8u42 Рік тому +1

    these videos on falcons are very helpful to me as someone who has no personal l experience with them outside of silly video games and other stuff.

  • @hawkknight4223
    @hawkknight4223 Рік тому +2

    God bless you and excellent video! These are the types of swords you need to be doing one-handed reverse grip with.

  • @livecatgrenades
    @livecatgrenades Рік тому

    Wow! What a wonderful video! The falcion is one of my favorite sword designs and it's interesting to learn more about it here. I look forward to seeing more on the topic, as well as my other favorite sword someday: The Falcata

  • @defaultytuser
    @defaultytuser Рік тому

    I'm diggin' this new hairstyle Shad

  • @jameshamaker9321
    @jameshamaker9321 Рік тому +1

    I appreciate this, I really need this video right now.

  • @keithrobicheux4749
    @keithrobicheux4749 Рік тому +2

    The best machetes have distal tapers, but I imagine the machetes spine is a little thinner

  • @moisesrosario9716
    @moisesrosario9716 Рік тому +1

    It's interesting to see a truper machete all the way up to Australia, I though they were only sold here in México

  • @paranoidyouth
    @paranoidyouth Рік тому

    I’ve been a fan for a long time I just wanna say you look absolutely amazing. I know you’ve had a lot of hardships and stuff but you look like you are at your best.

  • @trathanstargazer6421
    @trathanstargazer6421 Рік тому +3

    Heres to hoping we get a scythe demonstration video! Wanting them to really debunk how useful it is in a fight.

    • @brumbybailey6599
      @brumbybailey6599 Рік тому +1

      Lindybeige wasn't to your tastes?

    • @ric270
      @ric270 Рік тому

      The scythe is the strongest melee weapon in battle cry of freedom

    • @trathanstargazer6421
      @trathanstargazer6421 Рік тому

      @@brumbybailey6599 I like having multiple view points. I like his takes but like seeing others as well. Also I just love scythe bashing so the more of it I see the better!

    • @brumbybailey6599
      @brumbybailey6599 Рік тому

      Hey, no scythe bashing around me; I love mine😂

    • @trathanstargazer6421
      @trathanstargazer6421 Рік тому +1

      Also just to clarify, I'm not talking about War Scythes, they are great. Just the regular scythes media seems to love misrepresenting.

  • @tons241
    @tons241 Рік тому +2

    Hold up, are we witnessing the beginning of fit Shad? You're looking good mate!

  • @adamstanisaw2892
    @adamstanisaw2892 Рік тому

    Great content shad.

  • @Shirocco7
    @Shirocco7 Рік тому

    Nice content. Great explanation of a sword type I apparently knew nothing about!

  • @ShagadelicBY
    @ShagadelicBY Рік тому +2

    That's Skallagrim's cutlass!
    I recognize the dent he put in the guard

  • @thejmelus
    @thejmelus Рік тому

    Keep making these kinds of videos... Its very interesting 🤔👍🏼

  • @TheShieldery
    @TheShieldery Рік тому +8

    A real expectional Flachion can be seen in the Maciejowski Bible (f.14) , where you can even see a two handed version (first one of ´f. 3). I think that type is for cleaving, because of the top-heavy-ness.

  • @JP-xg6bv
    @JP-xg6bv Рік тому

    As soon as I saw you with the sword in hand I was like "Yes you beautiful beast you gave us a double feature!" We love you Shad, keep it coming

  • @commissarf1196
    @commissarf1196 Рік тому +3

    Machete, or as we call it here in Indonesia: a common farming tool or gangster weapons. Seriously though it's called parang/golok in Indonesian.

  • @eduardoferreiradesa5716
    @eduardoferreiradesa5716 Рік тому +4

    Not a falchion fan myself, none the less it is still very usefull information. Maybe I should create a character which uses one. Thanks Shad!

  • @Flummiification
    @Flummiification Рік тому

    very good video, short informative entertainig and still with thy typical shadiveryity style very very nice

  • @CharlesZane_
    @CharlesZane_ Рік тому

    The Windlass falchion that Matt Easton helped with and also did a video on, is a beautiful piece.

  • @thedmdidit9842
    @thedmdidit9842 Рік тому +1

    worried seeing the fatigue behind Shad's eyes. Thank you for the videos and dedication Mr. Brooks. Stay well.

  • @LeChevalierduLys
    @LeChevalierduLys Рік тому +2

    Loved the video, very informative.
    I would love a video about Scimitars. For the longest time I thought Falchions were bigger Scimitars. I blame D&D.

  • @ferespinoza8053
    @ferespinoza8053 Рік тому +2

    Some time ago I decided to make a falchion with a machete, I've never had a sword but there are things I learned about machetes. The first one is the quality they have, the main brands that distribute them in America are the following and they handle different qualities/characteristics: Acorn, their machetes are of excellent quality, they have a marked distal cone (2/1.5mm at the base and less than 0.7mm at the tip). They use 1060 steel if I remember correctly, with a treatment that makes the blade extremely flexible and resistant, although their models vary in specifications, in this case I am referring to the standard model (known as the Latin machete) with a red handle. Their blades vary in size from 12" to 26" and 28" in the case of Acapulco/Caguayan machetes, they would be one of my first options in the case of starting another similar project. The next brand is Tramontina, until a few years ago their The quality was deplorable but they have already improved their steel (1065) and heat treatment, I don't know if they have a distal cone but their thickness is around 2mm, together with acorn they are the best commercial machetes that can be obtained in North America. There are also brands like Truper, made of steel 1060/1065 with chrome, although its quality is not bad, it is not ideal either because they have an irregular or crooked blade many times, just like the visel, and the chrome makes the blade brittle after long and exhausting days of work. but they are cheap and abound. Other brands that stopped being commercial a long time ago due to the closure/purchase of their company are Legitimus Collins and Campos Hermanos (CH), they used 1095 steel with an excellent heat treatment, they had at least 3mm at the base and a blade with a distal cone (from 3mm at the base to 1.5mm at the tip in the case of my 26" blade CH machete) its edge retention is very good and there were specialized heavy-duty or combat models in the case of both brands. (Collins wielded 4.5 mm thick machetes, 26" long blades and others that were practically sabers, while CH made machetes known in Mexico as "guaparra" with a longer blade, made to be wielded on horseback by charros. Both brands can be found on the second hand market for $40/75/100 dollars depending on the brand and condition. I am personally using a CH 26" blade machete for my project and I am quite happy with the result One more detail, the new machetes are "despalmed" with a triangular file to finish sharpening them, new from the factory they come with an unfinished bevel.

  • @brianp6859
    @brianp6859 Рік тому

    Great info as always shad! I don't know if you normally do this or if it just got missed this video but when you mention another one of your videos (in this case the kriegsmesser review) you should have it pop up on the video side bar (that little i icon that pops up in the top right hand corner) or at the least have a link to that video in the description. I'm gunna go search your channel for that video but i think it might drive more traffic if you had a link in this video to that one. Keep up the great content!

  • @josephmartin1540
    @josephmartin1540 Рік тому

    Excellent video!

  • @alchemik666
    @alchemik666 Рік тому +6

    Now I want to see a full review of the Kult of Athena "falchion" as a machete that it truly is. ;)

  • @piotrnowak7730
    @piotrnowak7730 Рік тому +1

    Great one, thanks.

  • @Benw8888
    @Benw8888 Рік тому

    Great video! Very informative.

    • @camerongunn7906
      @camerongunn7906 Рік тому

      Those things that have been killing men for thousands of years, still kill men.

  • @Joshuazx
    @Joshuazx Рік тому

    I have been waiting for this video since you made the video of you cutting plants on your property. Once this video is finished, your task here on youtube will be complete.

  • @thewinterprince1731
    @thewinterprince1731 Рік тому +1

    2:58 "We're talking about Distilled Tapah! So now Distilled Taper-"
    That moment when you slip your own accent. XD

  • @histhoryk2648
    @histhoryk2648 Рік тому

    Finally, content is back

  • @thomasray9830
    @thomasray9830 Рік тому

    Not that I don't like the other guys, I subscribed this channel because I liked Shad, it's nice to get a more shaddish vid

  • @theupsidedowngame9194
    @theupsidedowngame9194 Рік тому +1

    Hey guys I'm here to watch!!

  • @dlatrexswords
    @dlatrexswords Рік тому +3

    Hey Shad, fun discussion; Falchions as you point out are a very broad topic since there are all sorts of different blade types across the centuries and their cross sections and properties change as we go through time. Since you are focused on earlier types in this discussion, let's stick with these Elmslie F1a style falchion for now. You are spot on about modern production falchions. On the market, as far as affordable flachions are concerned there is basically nothing out there that replicates how an actual medieval falchion operated. They typically exhibit minimal distal taper, and because of the very wide blade profile will carry too much weight far out from the hilt leading the the impression that these were perhaps percussive weapons. To have any idea of how a real falchion handles you will need to have a custom ordered sword at this time; I would always recommend ordering one from James Elmslie himself, but there are a few other bladesmiths that have taken the time and research to make reliable blades from historical examples as well (for example Maciej Kopciuch).
    As to Machetes; the steel used in machete's tends to be durable, but as you have pointed out in part they differ from swords by several notable ways. Their edge is put on completely differently as a secondary bevel to sheet metal body. They exhibit limited (or NO!) distal taper, and their tangs are often slab much like a knife/messer construction. All of these will make it difficult if not impossible to convert a typical machete blade into a faithful sword representation. For example, trying to turn a standard latin style machete into an F1a falchion would need a machete that starts at the shoulders at between 4-6mm. This is very atypical where most machetes as you point out are usually closer to 1-2 mm even at the base. Also, you mention re profiling the edge, in the case of faithful falchions the edge is not just apple seeded as on some other historical swords, but a continuous edge all the way up to the spine, which would require a tremendous amount of fineness in regrinding.
    I look forward to your next project!

  • @alexc8209
    @alexc8209 Рік тому +5

    Its clear that falchions came in all shapes and sizes, it was a feature of the middle ages that everyone was doing their own thing. i have no doubt that some falchions wielded in 1275 somewhere in germany were exactly the same in every respect to a modern machete. Still, its a good video. thanks.

  • @camdenharper7244
    @camdenharper7244 Рік тому +1

    Shad's looking good. Beard game is on point. Hair is good. Armor, as always, is great. Oh and super great analysis

  • @connordwyer1209
    @connordwyer1209 Рік тому

    I was looking this up last week as I have a cheapish machete I wanted to change the handle on, so it was a little more falchion like. Perfect timing

  • @philiplewis8213
    @philiplewis8213 Рік тому

    I look forward to seeing a video with stress testing the falchions and the machetes.

  • @zenstrata
    @zenstrata Рік тому

    Nice video!~ had some useful information to teach people about sword characteristics =)

  • @carnotauruskun742
    @carnotauruskun742 Рік тому +1

    i didn't know the difference now i do thanks shad

  • @trevorgreenough6141
    @trevorgreenough6141 Рік тому +1

    Interesting. A fun comparison.
    I did find the video informative.

  • @myklsteel8486
    @myklsteel8486 Рік тому +1

    Before watching this, I thought falchions were a fire emblem thing lol. Glad to know a lot more now!

  • @maximusjoseppi5904
    @maximusjoseppi5904 Рік тому

    Finally a shad video 🤍

  • @civil4781
    @civil4781 Рік тому

    Hey shad I don't really have any room to recommend video ideas but more of a like to see sometime. I was hoping for a deeper dive on knives/daggers for war, personal defense, survival, and " adventures" or a video on your preferred diy modernized medieval weapons that you could make with stuff from your local hardware store or junkyard.

  • @Ragnar_Wolfgangson
    @Ragnar_Wolfgangson Рік тому

    Great to know the differences ❤

  • @donmilleriii7399
    @donmilleriii7399 Рік тому

    Looking forward to the machete makeover vid!

  • @brandanpalmer9712
    @brandanpalmer9712 Рік тому

    Ever since your video on the weapons a ranger would carry I’ve fallen completely in love with the falcion,

  • @skiveman
    @skiveman Рік тому +1

    I'm like 2 and a half minutes in and my immature ass can't help smirking every time Shad says "swelling at the tip". I just can't help it.

  • @hyliarmetancanira
    @hyliarmetancanira Рік тому +11

    the Falchion is a faaar more stylish name! only that suffice!
    furthermore it is made to "easily cut leeks and enemies" bravo to those with the obscure reference.

  • @dockpowell7461
    @dockpowell7461 Рік тому

    Great video would love to see you do a video on sword and weapon care maybe armor as well could do medival or modern

  • @karmaspromise4626
    @karmaspromise4626 Рік тому

    Simple video but nailed it just the same. Congrats

  • @robertlewis6915
    @robertlewis6915 Рік тому +1

    Well, now I've got to add falchions to my story.

  • @ebofthechill8008
    @ebofthechill8008 Рік тому

    I can't wait to see this with a custom handle and whatever else they have in mind

  • @Hacksaw37
    @Hacksaw37 Рік тому

    I found a picture of a Maciejowski style Falchione with a matching knife. So I chopped the tip off a 14" Machete and ground the shape to match the knife blade but I want to do the same with a 21" Machete. Thanks Shad I was blissfully unaware, now I have my work cut out for me getting that distal tapper, that'll be a battle as I'll have to hand sand it.

  • @papijenkins2595
    @papijenkins2595 Рік тому +12

    If Shad gets isekied into another world, he would dominate and become a god.

  • @ecargfosreya
    @ecargfosreya Рік тому

    Living in the country as a teenager I always loved singing my machete. They just feel so satisfying to swing

  • @tortletrainwrek9335
    @tortletrainwrek9335 Рік тому

    Thanks for talking about this. You know, I never knew how the word Falchion was pronounced. 😂👍

  • @alucarder
    @alucarder Рік тому

    Great video

  • @bretlemieux2489
    @bretlemieux2489 Рік тому

    Shad I was planning on making my own falchon out of one of my machetes maybe making it more like a messer but still having that profile and distal taper. One of my projects.