America VS Europe VS Asia XXL - Building a suburb in Cities: Skylines

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 чер 2021
  • Merchandise Shop:
    imperatur.myspreadshop.de/
    America VS Europe VS Asia XXL - Building suburb in Cities: Skylines [Sunset Harbor DLC]
    In this Cities:Skylines [Sunset Harbor DLC] video you can see me building suburbs in three different ways. The first one is in an American Style Build like you would find it in the United States.
    The second one is inspired by Europe, for example, Germany or France.
    The third and last one is a build from Asia. You can find builds like that in japan or China.
    For this video I used barely any mods...
    -------------------------------------------------------------------
    You don't have Cities: Skylines yet?
    But you plan to buy it?
    SUPPORT ME WITH BUYING THE GAME VIA MY AFFILIATE LINK
    paradoxinteractive.i38e.net/c... *
    *Paradox Affiliate Program Advertisement
    -------------------------------------------------------------------
    Music you can find here:
    www.epidemicsound.com
    Tags:
    #citiesskylines #americavseuropevsasia #highway , pg clean , family friendly , vanilla , USA , europe, eu , asia , china ,
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 930

  • @CP3oh322
    @CP3oh322 3 роки тому +541

    As an American, I never fail to be amused that the "America" portion of these vids is always accompanied with slide guitar and harmonica. Throw in about five or six churches and a grain elevator and that suburb could easily be any of one of the small towns scattered across the Great Plains.

    • @Admiral45-10
      @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому +22

      Make a curvy road, some smaller ones going out of it, then some churches and only small houses - that's basically Polish village.

    • @rover9300
      @rover9300 2 роки тому +2

      I don’t enjoy country music as an American, but I guess I should lol

    • @colbymcarthur7871
      @colbymcarthur7871 2 роки тому +14

      As a Kansan, obligatory
      -add a railroad on the edge of town
      -add a town hall and small park near the shopping area and the school

    • @nicholasweaver9550
      @nicholasweaver9550 2 роки тому +2

      @@rover9300 Not all American enjoy country music. I personally can't stand it.

    • @rover9300
      @rover9300 2 роки тому

      @@nicholasweaver9550 yea same

  • @floorburrito7176
    @floorburrito7176 3 роки тому +1488

    While American cities do have strict grid patterns, especially in downtown areas or dense metropolitan areas, but suburbs don't operate like that. There's a lot more curves and cul-de-sacs.
    Source: I have gotten lost in atleast 30 different suburbs in 20 different states.

    • @NJHProductions512
      @NJHProductions512 3 роки тому +13

      yeah, true

    • @CP3oh322
      @CP3oh322 3 роки тому +63

      Take a look at Denver (my home) and it's suburbs. You notice that, on a street level, in residential neighborhoods you'll find a lot of curves and cul-de-sacs like you said. But the main arterial roads and boulevards between them? A grid. This is true of a lot of newer cities west of the Mississippi.
      Since I grew up with this and it's what I know, I like to plot out my C:S this way.

    • @darkcypressactual7585
      @darkcypressactual7585 3 роки тому +64

      I agree, while most arterial and collector roads will follow a grid, a typical American suburb will be contain internally a curvy road structure with many cul-du-sacs. Developers in the US make suburbs and subdivision purposely hard to navigate to make them inconvenient routes to discourage non-local traffic from cutting through them.

    • @NJHProductions512
      @NJHProductions512 3 роки тому +10

      Most newer areas hardly ever are 100 % grid, at least where I have looked in da us. like denver, or dallas. It is mainly older areas that are 100 % grid

    • @SteelForceful
      @SteelForceful 3 роки тому +6

      Yes but you find those in a metropolitan area the grid is usually found right next to a downtown area

  • @Mibris
    @Mibris 2 роки тому +65

    So as a *German* my critical view to the Europe one:
    -The *church* is much rather the center of our villages and suburbs, train station is either at the border of it/near the small local *river* or close to the center.
    -the road layout was perfect! But as others mentioned we love *roundabouts* , in some German towns it's one or two at the center (connecting/fusing other main roads to the real main road that defines the village), some have it outside or none, and there's some which circle the center church.
    -as I mentioned probably a *small river* would fit too
    -fields and forests are accurate
    -industrial/commercial zone is accurate
    -train tracks between trees is a nice detail
    -at a lot of the times the cemetery is not at the church or it has a separate chapel because they're placed more outside of the town where the souls of the deads can rest in peace without noisy traffic or train tracks nearby.
    -It's rather a personal wish but a more unique and/or larger church model would also be nice
    -often there will be a small *village square* centered, usually where the church is and often paired with some small commercials like bakeries, ice-cream shops, restaurants.
    Final verdict:
    Overall it's really accurate and probably a good compromise between all the European countries! Small improvements would make it even better but it's lovely as it is.

    • @ohhoro5004
      @ohhoro5004 2 роки тому +3

      Nobody builds train stations near the church, the church is literally the center of the city, just like the square (as you mentioned). Commerce and offices are also in the center, most of the industry is concentrated either at the entrance to the city or along the railway. And yes, not so random roads, the same grid as in America is often used, the predominance of quarterly buildings over spontaneous rural areas is a distinctive feature of the European style.

  • @Tzeentch91
    @Tzeentch91 3 роки тому +1603

    European suburb needs roundabouts.

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +238

      Yeah true:D

    • @aramisjdd6387
      @aramisjdd6387 3 роки тому +11

      and HLMs too

    • @imcauan_
      @imcauan_ 3 роки тому +88

      European suburb looks like Farming Simulator hahahahaha

    • @kevinytgamer754
      @kevinytgamer754 3 роки тому +8

      @@imcauan_ stop

    • @zefrb
      @zefrb 3 роки тому +124

      @@imcauan_ and America is grid simulator

  • @andreasferenczi7613
    @andreasferenczi7613 3 роки тому +521

    In Europe train tracks almost never go straight through the center of a village. Maybe close to the center, but the road layout would suggest a center that is off of the train tracks. These villages are much much older than the train. And if it's old it won't be touched in Europe.

    • @boomerix
      @boomerix 3 роки тому +48

      That is true in many cases, but the suburb in this video reminded me of a Village in Germany where the Train indeed goes straight through the middle of the village (probably because it also is the center of the valley and you would have otherwise make the train go up a hill).

    • @chrisholst3491
      @chrisholst3491 2 роки тому +18

      Depends in which country ... This could be a number of smaller towns in Denmark which is centered around the train stations

    • @neusteyorgen7922
      @neusteyorgen7922 2 роки тому +3

      Exactement.
      Ae dies depend on da geology ov terrain. In an grand ville, da Station omni centrerd est magis in communes ae village, da Station posstent ester excentrerd.
      Exactement.
      Après tout dépend de la géologie du terrain. Dans une grande ville, la station sera toujours centrale alors que dans les communes et villages, les stations peuvent être excentrées.
      Exactly. After all depends on the geology of the land. In a large city, the station will always be central, while in towns and villages, the stations may be excentred.

    • @vojtechvobruba416
      @vojtechvobruba416 2 роки тому +2

      There is train track that goes straight trough the center of a town - it's built on the square (there is only this square). It's in Neratovice, Czech Republic

    • @andreasferenczi7613
      @andreasferenczi7613 2 роки тому +4

      @@vojtechvobruba416 Neratovice is a perfect example for what I meant. I would put the center of town to the river bend, to that smaller bridge connecting to the island in the river bend. The train tracks go around that central place, coming from the east, they cross the river north of that central bridge, then bend around and continue in south-eastern direction. So you probably misunderstood what I meant by center. I meant the historical center not what is in the middle of the town (often these towns would grow more on the side of the train station, such that the train station eventually will be located in the middle of the town).

  • @szymenxd1
    @szymenxd1 2 роки тому +265

    I love that your European builds are basicly Germany in the nutshell models. Greetings from Poland!

    • @janmeier7433
      @janmeier7433 2 роки тому +8

      The village basically looks like my grandparent's village

    • @eseopu
      @eseopu 2 роки тому +6

      @@janmeier7433 my grandads village is just a narrow road :/

    • @tkb4026
      @tkb4026 2 роки тому +8

      Reminds me of The Netherlands as well. It is Europe after all.

    • @shady4926
      @shady4926 2 роки тому

      Geah the europe build looks almost exactly like they build it except for a couple runabouts

    • @Blackstaralpha
      @Blackstaralpha 2 роки тому

      lmao was thinking the same thing.

  • @razmaknica5794
    @razmaknica5794 3 роки тому +1271

    balkans be like: build where you want land is land

    • @u1k4
      @u1k4 2 роки тому +7

      Yeah

    • @mohammadnuruzzaman8021
      @mohammadnuruzzaman8021 2 роки тому +36

      Bangladeshis also. Land is land

    • @dvmas
      @dvmas 2 роки тому +33

      @@mohammadnuruzzaman8021 na WATER is land

    • @ilham3367
      @ilham3367 2 роки тому +4

      @Daan Vrolijk and japan

    • @phom29
      @phom29 2 роки тому +7

      I'm on holiday in the Balkans rn and I can confirm this

  • @RainHeart257
    @RainHeart257 3 роки тому +282

    I miss more roundabouts in the europe layout :D

    • @kindheart247
      @kindheart247 3 роки тому

      Roundabout

    • @kindheart247
      @kindheart247 3 роки тому

      You name is almost the same

    • @javierhillier4252
      @javierhillier4252 2 роки тому

      I live with my grandparents and live in the countryside village like this

    • @FunkyPhilCovers
      @FunkyPhilCovers 2 роки тому +1

      Trust me in some places there are 2 many roundabouts even if you don’t need

    • @neusteyorgen7922
      @neusteyorgen7922 2 роки тому

      Supple rondponkt in Europe

  • @youfindararegreenmister
    @youfindararegreenmister 2 роки тому +69

    Streets in different places
    USA: ▦
    Europe: ▩
    Asia: ㍼
    Latin America: 𓁆 𓀡

    • @rira0005
      @rira0005 Рік тому

      昭和じゃないけど

    • @sounakchakraboty9700
      @sounakchakraboty9700 Рік тому +2

      Bro mexica
      n cities are one of the best planned in the world

    • @AngelSGG
      @AngelSGG Рік тому

      ​@@sounakchakraboty9700 are one of the worst ones

  • @dotSp0T
    @dotSp0T 3 роки тому +287

    I know you're limited by the game in some ways, but the European suburbs feel very american-y in their design...
    - Industries would have developed along the railway and railside factories/buildings would definitely have railway-access.
    - While there will be some curvy roads, most roads will be straight in nature, because they connect things - even inside villages(!)
    - Passenger stations often developed as an after-thought out of or next to cargo terminals.
    - You will (almost) always have one very clearly recognizable road that is passing right through the village; that's the road connecting this village with others, forming a 'line' towards the next town/larger settlement (first railroads would have developed along these roads, as they were the most efficient connections between villages).
    (- There will most definitely be a (small) lake or river or at least some brook(s) nearby the village; as it would develop where water is available)
    - actual suburbs will have a bunch of multistorey houses or even some apartment-blocks. Also smaller planned-ish neighborhoods with a grid roadpattern (basically the affluent version of apartment blocks). Both will have been developed due to the rising need for worker-housing for new factories and businesses closer to the city...

    • @mrcrabowski
      @mrcrabowski 2 роки тому +8

      - and some roundabouts
      He's kinda mixed village and a town to a stereotypical European suburb... but ngl... I'd still move there...
      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      ---> live in the Czech Republic in a town (ca. 12k people) with several centuries of history behind
      (it's all generalization, some villages and town can be completely different and I definitely forget something)
      - when it's a village, it has, as you said, one "main" road thru the village and then few smaller roads (if any) usually with a dead-end; there is usually no school or kindergarten or only elementary school (sometimes only primary school = only first 5 years); no police; only "voluntary firefighter unit" (that is a "real thing" here, almost every hell hole has one); houses are usually not densely packed next to each other because they're large and often with "barn" and yard around; alsmost always it has a pub and at least one small shop with groceries (sometimes mixed with other consumer goods), in bigger villages sometimes specialty shops like butchery or bakery; Around is often forest, pastures/meadows and farmland (but large farm fields are more common next to roads between towns/villages); sometimes some sport-related stuff (football field, few tennis courts, outside pool etc.)
      - when it's a town, almost always it has a recognizable historical town center with a square (often next to/near the river); around it there are tons of local shops and family houses; several smaller supermarkets like Lidl, Tesco etc. are scattered around the city, few bigger ones (usually only "ground-floor malls") are packed to one place on the outskirts; complexity of roads really depends on the size and history of the town; railroad for commercial use and cargo hauling (next to it is often a sawmill); there's a police, proffesional + voluntary firefighter unit, at least one kindergarten, elementary school and either gymnasium or secondary vocational school; at least few typical communistic prefabs from Eastern block times packed together; several new prefabs and smaller apartment buildings packed together into more grid-lock system; and then newest buildings in entierely grid-lock system (often developer companies buy a large piece of land on the outskirt of the town and build there several rows of overpriced "catalog-style" "eco" family houses); often enough sport-related stuff to cover almost any casual sport

    • @nntflow7058
      @nntflow7058 2 роки тому +1

      Not always. There's differences between Suburbs and small cities close to major cities.
      Suburbs tend to be attached to the city. Most but not all suburbs in Western Europe in particular would be less american-y since the density in those areas would still be high since they are still close to the city and the demand are actually high since the land and housing prices are significantly lower compared to the city core.
      Small european cities are more similar to american suburbs. You are describing small cities that are not part of the large cities.
      Also, in Eastern Europe. Those Commie blocks would be the common type of building in the suburbs.

    • @Immortal_BP
      @Immortal_BP 2 роки тому +6

      as an american i can yell you the European suburubs do not seem american-y at all

    • @styled1281
      @styled1281 2 роки тому

      @@nntflow7058 Commie blocks are spread around a city wherever there was space available, often buildings were destroyed in order to build these blocks, they definitely aren't in the suburbs and are part of the main city.
      Take Bucharest for example, it has a historic old town that doesn't have blocks but go about 1 kilometer in any direction and you'll find a lot of them.

    • @jay4us713
      @jay4us713 2 роки тому

      So true

  • @orsivan5731
    @orsivan5731 2 роки тому +38

    Australian Suburb: Start with an American suburb, switch traffic direction, add a single train station at one edge, convert half of the stores to pubs and Pokies

  • @LEVCKSHK
    @LEVCKSHK 3 роки тому +46

    13:40 Much similar to the housing estate development in Hong Kong starts from 1970s.

  • @Igorbr100
    @Igorbr100 3 роки тому +35

    Imperatur not only masters the game, he already master the mods. Its just another level of Cities

  • @cywlj9998
    @cywlj9998 2 роки тому +17

    In Northeast Asia, especially Korea, 70% of the land is mountainous and there are many high-rise apartments because 20 million people live in the three areas of Seoul, Incheon, and Gyeonggi.

    • @koushikdas657
      @koushikdas657 9 місяців тому

      The the population of Mumbai MMR . 24 million. And keep in mind Delhi NCR has almost 34 million people . And keep growing.

  • @Legionary04
    @Legionary04 2 роки тому +17

    Love the European 'suburb', reminds me of where I live, the UK South East countryside. If you want some inspiration from UK, there would need to be a roundabout and the bridge would need to be made out of brick. Be more random with house placement, they aren't always near each other. Also the roads need a whole load of potholes! I'm thinking of doing something like this, but include British building, cars and trains etc. I just don't have the imagination and creative side that you clearly have been blessed with :D

  • @user-rc4je2rr9d
    @user-rc4je2rr9d 3 роки тому +145

    I'm Japanese.
    Oh my god😱
    I'm very worried about your sleep time,but the reproducibility of the city was
    Very Very Good😊

  • @theidahoan1240
    @theidahoan1240 3 роки тому +27

    America: organized grid pattern
    Europe: country like setting
    Asia: high rise heaven

    • @fadli_1577
      @fadli_1577 2 роки тому +7

      Indonesia : chaotic high density

    • @itsing9947
      @itsing9947 2 роки тому

      @@fadli_1577 HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA

    • @az_lupintawi7023
      @az_lupintawi7023 2 роки тому

      @Valentín por donde esta la libertad?

    • @gilangak4525
      @gilangak4525 2 роки тому

      @@fadli_1577 For real, java island alone is enough to be inhabited by all russian population

    • @byunbaekhyun2283
      @byunbaekhyun2283 2 роки тому

      @@fadli_1577 true lol🤣
      suburb di indo design nya emang messy bgt, rumahnya kecil2 + padat2, jalan juga asal-asal, kadang malah area yang gak ada akses jalannya😂. Kalau public transport mah gak usah ditanya, di pusat kota aja public transport masih jelek, apalagi di suburb, udah sama sekali ga ada public transport, adanya paling cuma angkot doang.

  • @trainmasternik8602
    @trainmasternik8602 3 роки тому +166

    America be like: "Nothing but grid"

    • @MrHenkkkie
      @MrHenkkkie 3 роки тому +15

      And lots of cars 🚗

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +14

      True😂

    • @hf_61
      @hf_61 3 роки тому +9

      Colonial land has no so much historical planning issues

    • @engu1348
      @engu1348 3 роки тому +4

      Grid or Cul de sac.

    • @MuhammedGemci
      @MuhammedGemci 3 роки тому

      It's written America, spelled Grid for a reason.

  • @Livsedan
    @Livsedan 3 роки тому +41

    The asian suburb looks great but there is one problem. Not enough traffic and cars....

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +3

      True.. i don‘t know why:(

    • @holyboxer2.072
      @holyboxer2.072 2 роки тому +7

      Parking is a big problem in big cities in East Asia,
      But these cities usually have better public transport

    • @yvricz1410
      @yvricz1410 2 роки тому +3

      we use public transport such as buses, subway station and more, or walk

    • @yvricz1410
      @yvricz1410 2 роки тому +1

      ​@blablabla Probably only in India.

    • @zefrb
      @zefrb 2 роки тому

      @@yvricz1410 bruh no

  • @kocicijazycky
    @kocicijazycky 3 роки тому +461

    Every European has grandparents that live in a village that looks exactly like in the video, try to prove me wrong

    • @MrHenkkkie
      @MrHenkkkie 3 роки тому +24

      Mine don't anymore, they live in a larger town without railway, although there used to be one. I think the town looked exactly like this around 1930, so technically they lived in one 😉

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +52

      Haha yeah but we have no train station😌

    • @hamish5793
      @hamish5793 3 роки тому

      Mine live in a pretty big city, and my other grandparents live in (i believe) one of the smallest towns in the Netherlands

    • @kocicijazycky
      @kocicijazycky 3 роки тому

      @@hamish5793 Same here lol

    • @kocicijazycky
      @kocicijazycky 3 роки тому

      @@imperatur Same 😌

  • @ulysseslee9541
    @ulysseslee9541 3 роки тому +7

    HK citizen CSL player:
    If build suburb reference from Hong Kong, 1st u need to:
    build the apartments not always facing each other like in the video in "Asian" part :P (Especially those selected neighborhood land for high-rise, high-grade/luxury apartment blocks private estate)
    & in public housing estate, we often have few type of apartment design in one estate, like Trident 3 + New Slab; 1-2 types of Harmony, 3 types of non-standard block layout

  • @user-it1kj3cb4b
    @user-it1kj3cb4b 3 роки тому +135

    I'm also from Asia. I can see that the styles of cities in each continent are different. Therefore, a diversified world is formed. Specifically, in the same Asia, there are obvious differences between different countries! It seems that you may have seen it through Google maps, which is a good video theme.

    • @pianofortesam7951
      @pianofortesam7951 3 роки тому +13

      這影片的亞洲城郊,比較像中國開發商從零打造的那種「睡城」

    • @Admiral45-10
      @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому +12

      There are also such diffrences in Europe - for example, the most important part of Polish suberbs and villages are Roman-Catholic churches almost everywhere.

    • @Marylandbrony
      @Marylandbrony 2 роки тому +1

      I wonder what are the exact differences between countries. Also Asian nations are generally more helmed in by geography (Mountains especially) than European and American ones. As an American suburb design can wildly varry due to things like land planning,climate and age. The one in the video is quite midwestern where the land is more or less a grid with no real barriers.

    • @nonec384
      @nonec384 2 роки тому +2

      its not realy the same in brazil my city is mostly "grid" but is quit cauthic due to the terrain i think not at all like the perfect american grid

    • @Fumbann
      @Fumbann 2 роки тому +2

      @@nonec384 I think by 'America' they only mean the U.S, gringos do that. I'm from Argentina and I agree, The Americas as a continent itself has a lot of differences between countries:/

  • @shacharmarkovich2563
    @shacharmarkovich2563 3 роки тому +1

    Wonderful!!
    You gave me plenty of ideas for my next building!
    Lovely!
    Thanks!

  • @inthesparklingsky
    @inthesparklingsky 2 роки тому +4

    Eurpean cities have always the most interesting layout! They may look like a mess sometimes but most of them now have very strict rules for raising buildings to protect the urban landscape. For example, in my country you can’t build houses too close to each other, in historical neighborhoods the new houses must be built in a way that their exterior esthetics fits the surrounding, signboards use is strictly regulated and prohibited if it has a negative impact on the urban landscape, etc.
    Also parks are not seen as a waste of profitable land like in some Asian countries, because we have a real estate system based more on buying buildings/apartments, not lands, which makes cities administration more inclined to use a land to make green areas and other services for the citizens.
    We also don’t have the concept of zoning, so even in small villages you can sometimes see buildings with mixed use of residential and commercial (in very small villages commercial are very few though and the railway station is usually far from the village center).

  • @gabrielgeroldi4495
    @gabrielgeroldi4495 3 роки тому +6

    in Brazil has the messy streets of Europe in the suburbs, the symmetrical streets of the Usa in the upper-class neighborhoods, and the streets of Asia in the center.

  • @jsalas5400
    @jsalas5400 3 роки тому +15

    Hey imperatur! Another great vid and congrats on being invited to 5b1c! I recommend you on every video! Anyways for the high school have you ever thought of taking the batam football stadium asset and building the high school track around that? I play unmodded so I'm using the tennis courts to achieve the same look but I have seen it done with the football field and it looks awesome! I know most if not all high schools around me with a football field have a track around it

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks for your support ❤️ yeah i could have done that:D

  • @Arkiasis
    @Arkiasis 3 роки тому +2

    American here. American suburbs like that are actually ones closer to the city center and older. Some might not even call them suburbs since they're usually part of the city proper and only a "short" car drive from the center of the city. Mostly post-war suburbs in the 50s as the car dependency went into hyper drive.. Suburbs today have close to no commercial and have windy roads full of mcmansions.

  • @hf_61
    @hf_61 3 роки тому +31

    Good job! Can't wail to see more vids. Asian part is quite similar in China, but Chinese prefer metro underground. If there is a highspeed rail station, it must be a huuuge square Next to the entrance.

  • @Guidest
    @Guidest 3 роки тому +16

    OMG 20 minutes. I'm so excited.

  • @yuvrajsinghrathore3710
    @yuvrajsinghrathore3710 3 роки тому +7

    When music theme matters!nice video concept again 👍

  • @blagoevski336
    @blagoevski336 3 роки тому +22

    The European suburb looks more like a rural town

    • @romanrat5613
      @romanrat5613 Рік тому

      Sometimes I wonder about certain biases that might be included in these videos

  • @shuan9631
    @shuan9631 3 роки тому +12

    I live in Singapore, and I just gotta say that the layout of apartments in the Asian suburb is very accurate! Well done.

    • @givemecookies5078
      @givemecookies5078 2 роки тому +2

      honestly quite similar here in malaysia too! but usually we wont have apartment complexes that look the same over like 2 times lol! only suburbs here usually look like that, built in clusters and have very different architectural styles from one developer and another, very diverse id say!

    • @ianhomerpura8937
      @ianhomerpura8937 2 роки тому +1

      To be fair, that is the ideal. Given how HDB townships are well built, designed and connected to SMRT, I just hope we adopted the same setup in Manila.

  • @svis6888
    @svis6888 3 роки тому +5

    12:17 don't forget to make the lines around the grass pavement ones ! That way they will have curbs and will be more realistic

  • @definitelymaybae4976
    @definitelymaybae4976 3 роки тому +48

    I’m a Korean and that asian suburb is too korean to me.

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +6

      That’s good, that it looks familiar to you:D i wasn’t in asia yet😄

    • @hyun__6942
      @hyun__6942 3 роки тому

      you are very talented

    • @gordonchao3074
      @gordonchao3074 3 роки тому +3

      It also looks very Chinese

    • @dogc8614
      @dogc8614 2 роки тому

      안녕하세요 코리아인 입니다

    • @hazazzzzzzzzzzziii
      @hazazzzzzzzzzzziii 2 роки тому

      당신은 수많은 영어중 한국어를 찾았습니다

  • @SShiJie
    @SShiJie 3 роки тому +56

    As an Asian, that design is very close to what is here in Singapore😁

    • @starcluster2593
      @starcluster2593 2 роки тому

      you saying that is asian as a singaporean? isnt racist

    • @IsaoTakeuchi
      @IsaoTakeuchi 2 роки тому +5

      @@starcluster2593 She didn't say that Asian = Singapore (or anything related to it) tho

    • @starcluster2593
      @starcluster2593 2 роки тому

      @@IsaoTakeuchi she litteraly said asian

    • @IsaoTakeuchi
      @IsaoTakeuchi 2 роки тому +5

      @@starcluster2593 Yeah, but she didn't mean to say that Asian = Singaporean

    • @starcluster2593
      @starcluster2593 2 роки тому

      @@IsaoTakeuchidid i ever say that

  • @gumbyshrimp2606
    @gumbyshrimp2606 3 роки тому +20

    You could have put in a neighborhood pool or park or something for the American suburb…

    • @redditstop1653
      @redditstop1653 3 роки тому +2

      Parks are pretty lacking in U.S suburbs tho

    • @ShaudaySmith
      @ShaudaySmith 3 роки тому

      More often seen in planned communities these days. Cities aren't really investing in parks but housing associations are big time where they would have multiple parks and recreation centers for their residents. This looks like an old 'classic" suburb that was just housing, not community development.

    • @capnsteele3365
      @capnsteele3365 2 роки тому

      @@redditstop1653 no, theyre too much

  • @achmadistawa9965
    @achmadistawa9965 2 роки тому +3

    I think, for Asia, that's in China or Singapore. In Indonesia, we don't have too much flat. We have houses and we are crowded.

  • @BartdeGraaff2007
    @BartdeGraaff2007 3 роки тому +181

    Europe is the best suburb

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому +16

      🥰

    • @redditstop1653
      @redditstop1653 3 роки тому +51

      United States = Low density car centric sprawl
      Asia = High density repetitive car centric sprawl
      Europe = Small walkable Villages
      Europe obviously wins.

    • @LucasFernandez-fk8se
      @LucasFernandez-fk8se 3 роки тому +15

      The europe one is the worst. It’s the ugliest and least effective. ASIA and america had streets that made sense. Even America’s winding culdesac streets are better because at least they are only in subdivisions that aren’t interconnected.

    • @BartdeGraaff2007
      @BartdeGraaff2007 3 роки тому +54

      @@LucasFernandez-fk8se haha stay mad european suburbs are making the best sensen, a small shopping center in the middle and walkable, a church and much more.

    • @BartdeGraaff2007
      @BartdeGraaff2007 3 роки тому +1

      @@redditstop1653 i agree

  • @hustledude
    @hustledude 3 роки тому

    Stunning, once again you show us that you are the master

  • @rons3103
    @rons3103 3 роки тому +3

    Amazing Talent, like no other! Thinking you may have to change your Name to MASTER Imperatur!

  • @TANNAPON
    @TANNAPON 3 роки тому +61

    Europe road be like: Non-asian grid plan

  • @farhanakhtar8252
    @farhanakhtar8252 3 роки тому +3

    Awesome work my man!

  • @MonCoLove
    @MonCoLove 2 роки тому

    These look very realistic to me. Good job!

  • @ErickPramono
    @ErickPramono 3 роки тому +1

    Wow! The asian suburb is really good. Especially the old town. You are awesome!

  • @freelanceauthority
    @freelanceauthority 3 роки тому +16

    4:02 that bridge is the most accurate thing I've ever seen

  • @u1k4
    @u1k4 3 роки тому +11

    As an european i can kinda comfirm this is true. It varies from country to country.

    • @imperatur
      @imperatur  3 роки тому

      Yeah true:)

    • @Admiral45-10
      @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому

      It looks slightly diffrent in Poland.

    • @konstantinoslentaris9656
      @konstantinoslentaris9656 2 роки тому +1

      Maybe, because European has a cultural variety

    • @darwinmagsino190
      @darwinmagsino190 Рік тому

      @@konstantinoslentaris9656 variety 😂😂 everything everything European architecture is look like the same even your culture/religion is the same also😂😂unlike in Asia different architecture and religion it's amazingly vibrant

  • @dogameda
    @dogameda 3 роки тому +1

    your asian city is just amazing! loved this one

  • @CakeboyRiP
    @CakeboyRiP 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for inspiring us time and time again

  • @avrahamr.2412
    @avrahamr.2412 2 роки тому +4

    In bigger European villages there would also be like an old village square were you usually will find some older fancy buildings with old stores owned by families.

  • @shrey5024
    @shrey5024 3 роки тому +4

    This is always interesting

  • @grumpiesttitan7930
    @grumpiesttitan7930 2 роки тому +1

    Great Video!

  • @kayhelmark535
    @kayhelmark535 2 роки тому

    The european suburb looks exactly like the little town i live in Denmark, the only thing thats a bit too much is the bridge over the train, that would be on level with the train for a town of that size. Nice work!

  • @lightninlarry8936
    @lightninlarry8936 3 роки тому +32

    The America suburb isn’t really accurate. The suburbs of America have lots of winding roads with cul de sacs. Look at a satellite image of Phoenix Arizona and you’ll see what I mean.

    • @MrHenkkkie
      @MrHenkkkie 3 роки тому +14

      The one built in the video is an older and more dense type of American suburb, now those suburbs are located in the middle of the city and surrounded by the new ones with cul du sacs

    • @jsalas5400
      @jsalas5400 3 роки тому +4

      Depends on when the area was established and the income of the area. Areas like Dallas and such have lots of straight road suburbs but older areas like in New England that were built around horse and cattle tracks instead of railroad access have lots more winding suburbs but still maintaining long straight main roads, and like Arizona was settled down and established much later has the inner city grids and the "patterned" cul de sacs areas. Then you head out to cali more grids but they contour to the topography alot like in San Francisco grids built right into the hillside......all in all my point is that the majority of the US is built around a grid system in one way or another and a typical suburb would resemble something like the one in the vid!

    • @ITBEurgava
      @ITBEurgava 3 роки тому +1

      @@MrHenkkkie Old stereotype, then?

    • @svis6888
      @svis6888 3 роки тому +1

      The main roads and avenues are still arranged in grid mostly

    • @NJHProductions512
      @NJHProductions512 3 роки тому

      or dallas, or denver, or basically any city

  • @ling5899
    @ling5899 2 роки тому +3

    Actually, in China there are not too many roads around the buildings. and we don't have any farms around the city。the most important is residential and commercial streets go together

  • @flaviohollanda242
    @flaviohollanda242 2 роки тому

    Great job!

  • @NelsonGuedes
    @NelsonGuedes 2 роки тому

    That was great! Which mods did you use? :)

  • @MuhammedGemci
    @MuhammedGemci 3 роки тому +5

    Normal people: Building roads and then zoning/plopping buildings
    Imperatur: 15:00

  • @alexandermaguire6969
    @alexandermaguire6969 3 роки тому +48

    You know, we are all waiting for dream bay

  • @maxtrev5534
    @maxtrev5534 3 роки тому

    Brooo, I've been waiting this vid for months

  • @harkauklan
    @harkauklan 3 роки тому

    That Asian suburb was so Singapore... Arterial roads define housing estates, and the flats are nestled by a small road for services and parking access. This helps to offset them from the arterial roads, which are further lined with trees to shield residents from noise and visual pollution. And it's my first time seeing cross junction slip lanes by a CS UA-camr. Of course those islands were green - not concrete like in America (if I trust other CS UA-camrs). Most importantly, the whole town is built around a metro station. The only thing we don't have here are open-field farms. If we farm at all, we go vertical.
    But of course you weren't recreating Singapore. Going through the comments, some people say they are reminded of Hong Kong and South Korea. So kudos to you!

  • @DualHD
    @DualHD 3 роки тому +3

    Nice, cool suburban

  • @Eskalante
    @Eskalante 3 роки тому +3

    From all of asia, I was only in Shanghai and Beijing. And I can say that your asian suburb is where I was living in Shanghai. Also, one single apartment block would have fence or moat around it with one entre gate with security.

  • @andrewyu3301
    @andrewyu3301 3 роки тому

    Plop a childcare in every apartment complex, integrate more parks within them with a block of commercial on the intersections and it'll be South Korea. Great work as always

  • @rileytimbrell648
    @rileytimbrell648 2 роки тому +1

    I from Wales, and my town is a mix of North American and European, most of the roads are straight and there's a grid, how ever its very walkable, every road has wide pavements(sidewalks) and there's lots of bike and foot paths, there's a foot path along the river which passes through 4 towns 🤣 im in the valleys so all the towns are all in one line, connected by paths and a main road.
    Edit:the reason it's like North America slightly is because some time back (before I was born) the aberfan disaster happened, a bunch of mud, coal, etc fell from the mountain and took out a part of the town, it took out a primary(elementary) school, so a new one was built and I went there, the Queen of the UK visited our school, I got to wave a welsh flag as she walked down the path 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿. She visited because wales is a part of the uk, we boarder England

  • @pelep1509
    @pelep1509 3 роки тому +5

    the roads in the european suburb are a bit inaccurate. old european city centers usually have very narrow roads and mostly without road markings. and since this is a suburb and not just a lone european village it would be more fitting to add modern/social housing outside of the city center aswell as a few more modern shops

    • @K-TheLetter
      @K-TheLetter 3 роки тому +3

      depends where in europe you live

  • @user-yf6lu4ok6w
    @user-yf6lu4ok6w 3 роки тому +4

    와 ㄹㅇ 똑같다,, 특징 잘잡으시네요 이분ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

  • @humanitiesattack4614
    @humanitiesattack4614 2 роки тому

    Nice video. Nice building skills.

  • @Creatim3D
    @Creatim3D 3 роки тому +1

    I like the building style you used

  • @shreyaskaranth8640
    @shreyaskaranth8640 3 роки тому +2

    Well I live in a suburb of Mumbai and yeah it is accurate!!! I mean just outside of apartment there is a township of several 24 story towers and just a few kilometre drive you will see farms and some few kilometre more there are many warehouses and industries so it's like a mix and there is a plan for elevated metro project and we already have a commuter rail which is pretty much crowded all day

    • @zefrb
      @zefrb 2 роки тому

      I live in delhi so can't say the same, but yeah newer areas have more talk apartments

    • @darwinmagsino190
      @darwinmagsino190 Рік тому

      Lots of slums😂

  • @Wasbever_14
    @Wasbever_14 3 роки тому +6

    In the Netherlands we have a lot of terraced houses

  • @KnellMortem
    @KnellMortem 2 роки тому +2

    As an American I have never once seen a strip mall integrated into a suburb. They’re always at least driving distance away, possibly downtown or inside of a commercial district, almost never inside of a suburb.

  • @modernist927
    @modernist927 Рік тому +1

    Europe: What’s a grid?
    Asia: What’s a suburb?
    America: What’s public transport?

  • @sultan_hakim9530
    @sultan_hakim9530 3 роки тому +5

    You haven’t done the Asian downtown

  • @Admiral45-10
    @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому +11

    Actually, I think there's one thing about European suburbs, which cannot be included in Cities:Skylines - they have a lot of churches and at least a couple of bus stations.
    At least in Poland.

  • @spykerKonyn
    @spykerKonyn Рік тому

    Amazing ^^

  • @user-qy7rv1nn6c
    @user-qy7rv1nn6c 3 роки тому

    Nice!👍

  • @Weyird
    @Weyird 2 роки тому +3

    The European one reminds me of where my aunt lives in the far outskirts of London, around a train station. The Asian one reminds me of where I lived in South Korea. The American one does not remind me of the American suburbs I've visited.

    • @vanyac6448
      @vanyac6448 2 роки тому

      For myself personally, the American one reminds me of the streetcar suburb-style neighborhoods of Seattle (think Wallingford, for instance): residences are mostly single family homes laid out on a grid, with businesses on a the occasional main street.
      Only difference is, the parking lots are a lot smaller in the real deal and there's a lot of on-street parking.
      I agree though, an actual American suburb would have, like, a square mile of malls with big stores and big parking lots, surrounded by multiple square miles of winding cul-de-sacs.

  • @armada1290
    @armada1290 3 роки тому +3

    As a korean, that is exactly like the place I live except that the Metro lines are underground for more soul killing concrete highrises to fill the land.

    • @Admiral45-10
      @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому

      The European one also looks similar to my suberb in Poland - except it has more churches, more busses and much uglier train stations.

    • @BartdeGraaff2007
      @BartdeGraaff2007 2 роки тому

      @@Admiral45-10 same here in the netherlands but it has 1 catholic church and 4 or 5 protestant and more houses and kinda those roads

    • @Admiral45-10
      @Admiral45-10 2 роки тому

      @@BartdeGraaff2007 Poland has hardly any Protestant church, but we have a lot of Roman-Catholic ones.

  • @K-TheLetter
    @K-TheLetter 3 роки тому +2

    That European suburb is surprisingly accurate!

  • @railfans-psi
    @railfans-psi 2 роки тому

    Overkill train station design for village 😂 but its very nice build 🔥

  • @pocketdynamo5787
    @pocketdynamo5787 3 роки тому +4

    Good job! That looks really authentic. Only thing I have, for the European suburb, the cemetery wouldn't be in the center of the settlement, but rather on the edge of it, sometimes even a short distance outside. And usually, a village of that size wouldn't have its own railway connection.

    • @username9175
      @username9175 2 роки тому +2

      I think that depends on the European country regarding the rail connection.
      I know here in Ireland, there are towns of that size and some even smaller that have rail connections

    • @Topst_er
      @Topst_er 2 роки тому

      @@username9175 yeah most in the uk are hooked up to rail

    • @username9175
      @username9175 2 роки тому

      @@Topst_er thats right. I noticed that in times I've visited

  • @sijiroy5535
    @sijiroy5535 3 роки тому +4

    Challenge make a indian city 😀😎🇮🇳

    • @CombatHD3
      @CombatHD3 3 роки тому

      just sh*t and unpaved roads, slums, dirty high rises, congested traffic, etc

  • @ykdagamer
    @ykdagamer Рік тому

    The asian suburb you built was really similar to the ones in Singapore, especially with the elevated metros being built very close to the high rise residential buildings. Except for the part where you built farms and excavation sites though… which should be built a little further from the high rise residential buildings. Maybe warehouses may be a better substitute for the extraction buildings. From Singapore! :D

  • @NoemiCBautista
    @NoemiCBautista 3 роки тому

    please put some chapters. this is great content, thank you.

  • @ITBEurgava
    @ITBEurgava 3 роки тому +2

    Well done as always. Must be an asian city suburb in advanced countries. China, perhaps? Lots of people living and working in busy districts.
    Developing countries, still many people living in small houses, with families. Boarding on train or bus to work...

  • @hajde8128
    @hajde8128 3 роки тому +2

    Europe: twisty windy roads, good luck trying to get where you wanna go 😬

  • @aslemsouayed
    @aslemsouayed 2 роки тому

    nice job

  • @dollaramaboy4868
    @dollaramaboy4868 2 роки тому

    Smooth video

  • @therandomviduploader2250
    @therandomviduploader2250 2 роки тому +2

    As Chinese, you forgot something very important: Underground parking

  • @lin.yiming
    @lin.yiming 3 роки тому

    I’m Asian and I live in Asia,Hong Kong specifically,and most residential buildings (not from Hong Kong Island) looks like that,mostly estates on mountains,great job :D

  • @krittawatphanthian8281
    @krittawatphanthian8281 2 роки тому

    This is good idea for build my city. thank you.

  • @christianluis7851
    @christianluis7851 3 роки тому +1

    Latin America is Asian road layout, European style buildings and American building layout
    Africa is American road layout sometimes, Asian buildings and European building layout
    Oceanía is basically a rare mix of all

  • @deco983
    @deco983 3 роки тому +1

    Great job!!!!

  • @MietoK
    @MietoK 2 роки тому

    Nice one. But you shoud finalize subsurbs with little bit of flooding

  • @hudsonbakke8836
    @hudsonbakke8836 2 роки тому

    These all seemed to be based more on stereotypes than actual real samples. American suburbs are almost never 100% gridded, they usually have lots of curves and cul-de-sacs, commercial city centers usually look a lot less methodically planned and don't have parking lots lining the streets, and they definitely would not be right next to the high school. Also, there is usually a freeway either very close to or cutting straight through the suburb. The European one was accurate for a small, relatively isolated town, but not a suburb. Also, we must keep in mind whether we are talking about Western/Northern Europe, Southern Europe, or Eastern Europe. In general, Western European suburbs tend to look very much like American suburbs, with more roundabouts (something you missed) and fewer freeways. Southern European suburbs tend to have narrower streets, and are either somewhat windy or just straight up square grids. Eastern European suburbs share a lot of resemblance with Chinese ones, due to shared influence from the Soviet Union. Lots of dry apartment blocks with services built into them. The Asian suburb you built was Chinese. Very Soviet-inspired with the dry, repetitive apartment blocks with built-in services. If you look in Japan, Taiwan, Philippines, or India you'll see very different styles.

  • @KhakiCap
    @KhakiCap 2 роки тому +2

    European Suburbs are quite spot-on. Well, add some roundabouts and some historical sites/places and it would look better.
    (And by looking at the video, the European Suburb reminds me more of a village or small town.)

    • @ianhomerpura8937
      @ianhomerpura8937 2 роки тому +1

      If I remember correctly, many European suburbs were centered around the church, especially the pre-WW1 ones.

  • @faldijohansyah9267
    @faldijohansyah9267 2 роки тому

    Nice

  • @enso8762
    @enso8762 3 роки тому

    Incredible how powerful mods are.

  • @petrnedved5297
    @petrnedved5297 3 роки тому +2

    As an European (a small car and beer making country in middle Europe, no it is not germany) i feel the european village was a little off. (Could be caused by more than 30 years of communism meaning a lot of unmaintained towns and villages)
    In the country where I live, unlike Germany and Austria there are a lot small houses in plain colors from the 80’ and the 90’, with the main road usually leading through the middle and intersecting with another main road. There would be absolutely no bridge, just a level train crossing with or w/o lights.
    Other than that, usually a small grocery shop in an old building and no other shops. Also some old houses with big gardens, on top of that some parks and a few modern houses built in the last decade either by the city (kindergartens, community centers, sometimes post offices?) or residentials.
    Those are my experiences from a small village with about 500 inhabitants.
    If you want to see a bigger city, search something like Budweis (a bigger city with 100000 people in it and a beautiful historical center surrounded by a few small villages) or Hluboká nad Vltavou (a bigger town with about 5000 people there, a shopping one way avenue and a historical castle, with a huge park in the middle of the city that is surrounded by fields and forests)

    • @Heito686
      @Heito686 3 роки тому

      You're from the Czech republic for sure

    • @petrnedved5297
      @petrnedved5297 3 роки тому

      @@Heito686 you guessed it!

  • @keirongilbert5322
    @keirongilbert5322 2 роки тому

    What mod allows you to edit the road markings like that at 12:09 ?