For 10 years, how have immigrant children grown up in Korea?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 лис 2023
- There's a Multicultural Alternative School in Busan, South Korea. The school serves children of immigrant families. In 2009, KBS aired a documentary about the children attending this school. Ten years later, in 2019, where are they now and what are they doing? We look back at 10 years of the lives of immigrant children in Korea.
All copyrights to this video belong to KBS.
KBS is a public broadcasting service in South Korea.
Air date: Aug 29th, 2019.
#immigrantkids #southkorea #documentary - Розваги
![The Return of Superman - The Triplets Special Ep.10 [ENG/CHN/2017.07.14]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VmRhvmwZF5s/mqdefault.jpg)
The Pakistani family. I think they can get a job of teaching Korean Language in Pakistan. Korean learning is now popular worldwide and their Korean Language is very good.
This is a very emotional episode. I hope they all are doing better.
I am crying from the beginning till end
Those teachers are beautiful souls 🥹
The teachers made me cry... Bless them!
What a great documentary! It broke my heart to see those kids get bullied. They have done nothing wrong to deserve that. Even though some of them have come through a long way but still in a way of healing. Kudos to the parents too, it must been extremely tough for them too. And I’m So sorry for what the Pakistan siblings have been through:(
I am sincerely hoping that you will all get to be the best of yourself and live a happy life.
This happens all the time in the U.S. to foreign kids or non-white citizens.
@@TheWorld4allthat’s absolutely not true. Kids are accepting, adults are not and that’s where they get it from.
Noman's situation should teach parents who live in a foreign country to teach their children their mother tongue.
I agree 100% and I always say this to Korean mixed race families and expats in foreign countries The parents did their children a disservice they should have bought Pakistanian workbooks, dictionary Urdu to English, and exclusively {ONLY} speak to their kids in Urdu so they could understand it at least. They could have let them watch Urdu cartoons online, get Urdu kid apps to help them with grammar, have the children speak to each other only in Urdu at home. The parents could have given them daily homework to read in Urdu for an hour and write in a daily journal entry, as mandatory before you can watch TV(like my mom did with me in reading for an hour a day).
I'm for the United States of America but when people ask me where I am from I say I am Caribbean American. I know that I am Trinidadian and Jamaican and I'm proud of that, so should these three Pakistanis. The parents were on visas the possibility of them going back to Pakistan was high so learning the children learning their native language should have been a big priority no matter what country they would live in. Their parents clearly didn't instill their their culture enough because they feel more Korean than Pakistanian when they should feel Korean Pakistani. I feel for them but they need to accept who they really are and embrace their ethnicity because this is their home for the foreseeable future.
Immigrant life is hard, especially on children who have no choice in their parent's decision. Most immigrants leave their country based on economic survival. We need to show compassion & support, especially to children, so they can be children without the burden of emotionally being hurt by cruel, ugliness of thoughtlessness on part of those choosing to discriminate. I cheer all of these families, & their children on!
Great documentary, K-DOC, it's not an easy task to do the follow up after 10 years. It's fascinating to see the kids all grown up and the struggles they have faced. It's a side of Korean society that we don't often see and it's sad what happened to Noman siblings and also to Jin-uk. I really hope they can find acceptance wherever they are and just blend in, that's all they asked for.
Why is it sad? Isn't it a beautiful thing to be reunited with your people , culture, roots, heritage? What's sad is being forcefully removed from your land of origin into an unknown land where you're foreign , that's sad.
@@AxsIav Yes, I see your point. However, do they feel happy now that they are "back" to "their" people, culture, roots, heritage? Do they really want to be there? Noman's sisters were even born in Korea, made their first contact to the world in Korea, all three grew up, studied and made friends in Korea. They're pretty rooted in Korea from what we see from this clip, aren't they? Forcelly removed? Yes, but what I see is the other way round. They were "forcelly removed" from a land they grew up knowing and considered as their home. That's why they struggle to adapt in a new place you consider their "root" just because they're ethnically from another country. It's nothing against any country, as long as people feel happy and have a sense of belonging in any place they want to be voluntarily.
Korea didn't give them life, who did? So how bout show a little respect to the people that put you on this planet? They are where they're supposed to be, if you can't find happiness in your country, among your people, there is something very wrong about you that you need to fix.
@@AxsIav The concept of your country and belonging is very subjective. Just because your parents are from that country doesn't mean that you necessarily feel a sense of belonging to that country. If according to your argument, then all diasporas must necessarily feel happiness in their historical homeland
If showing appreciation towards the people that gave you life is something u can't do, there is something very wrong with you. They should, after all, it is not wites that birthed them. If your fate was in the hands of wites historically, your ancestors might not have even made it to the day to give you birth.
Poor guys, I feel bad for the indonesian-korean and pakistani kids 😢
Their parents did them both a disservice in not teaching them their mother tongue and/or English and not letting them be in space daily where they saw other mixed or fully Indonesian or Pakistani kids to talk to and make friends. That would have helped both of them with speaking their native mother language to help them move out of Korea AND have them build lasting relationships in South Korea. Who knows they could have meet a Mixed Pakistani or Middle Eastern Korean to marry so they could stay-live in South Korea with a family; it would help in both cases for lasting relations in Korea.
I love this show. Instead of hiding that, reveal the dark side of Korean society.
it make society stonger and heal
저 다큐멘터리 시청했었어요.
너무 이쁘게 큰 소중한 우리 아이들…
계속 행복하고 건강하게 꿈을 향해 자라길 바래요!!!
I think this is the first time I've seen a doc follow up.
진짜 짠하고 마음아프다 .... 미안해요 그냥 내가 미안해요 에고 ... 참 ...
All those kids have reasons for the tough living that are not made or caused by themselves but their parents, and still Korea is not a immigrant country, but empasis their blood, surnames and even clans... So, it will be harder to live as a mixed blood than a fully foreigner... Ha-eun, I'm very much proud of you that you grew up very well, even become a soldier in the Korean Military...
Its difficult to be in their position. I blend in as korean but im chinese american and spent two years in korea. I hope one day he can travel and perhaps live in a place where everyone is accepted easily
Are you half American ?
So sorry for their sadness and the scars that they carry. 😢
The Korean-Pakistani kids nearly made me cry. I lived in Korea for 5 years, and if I was able to, I think I might've lived the rest of my life there, but the immigration laws were getting more complicated and difficult, and the pollution was getting worse and worse every year, so we decided to move to my husband's home country because the infrastructure is better than in my home country, but I feel more homesick sometimes for Korea than I do for my home country, lol
They're not korean. Both of their parents are Pakistan
The parents did their children a disservice they should have bought Pakistani workbooks, dictionary Urdu to English, and exclusively {ONLY} speak to their kids in Urdu so they could understand it at least. They could have let them watch Urdu cartoons online, get Urdu kid apps to help them with grammar, have the children speak to each other only in Urdu at home. The parents could have given them daily homework to read in Urdu for an hour and write in a daily journal entry, as mandatory before you can watch TV(like my mom did with me in reading for an hour a day). I'm for the United States of America but when people ask me where I am from I say I am Caribbean American.
I know that I am Trinidadian and Jamaican and I'm proud of that, so should these three Pakistanis. The parents were on visas the possibility of them going back to Pakistan was high so learning the children learning their native language should have been a big priority no matter what country they would live in. Their parents clearly didn't instill their their culture enough because they feel more Korean than Pakistani when they should feel Korean Pakistani. I feel for them but they need to accept who they really are and embrace their ethnicity because this is their home for the foreseeable future.
Noman could earn lots more than 500 rupees a day giving Korean 1-1 language classes online. So many people are wanting to learn Korean and sometimes do not need a teacher but just someone to practice speaking with...
He can't speak English to be able to teach the vast majority of people. He can't even speak his own language, even if he could, his face will make people question his ability.
참 좋은 방송입니다. 한국인들로 잘 자라주어서 고마워요.
한국은 변화가 너무 심한 사회입니다. 다들 열심히 살고 있고 그안에서 불평등은 존재합니다. 너무 많은 변화들로 중요한 것들도 많이 놓치고 있는 부분이 있습니다. 노력하고 있지만 부족한 것이 현실입니다. 다문화를 지향하는 입장에서 응원합니다. 한국은 계속적으로 개선될 부분에 대해서 깨어있고 좋은 방향으로 발전하기 위해서 노력합니다. 한국을 응원해주세요! 다른문화권을 존중하고 받아들이는데는 시간이 해결해줄 것 입니다. 한국은 어두운 부분도 밝게 만들기 위해 끊임없이 이런 다큐를 만들 것 입니다. 한국은 유일한 원조국에서 원조해주는 나라입니다. 그만큼 귝민들도 그 감사함에 고개 숙여 고맙다고 전달하고 싶네요. 한국에 들어온 모든 사람과 같이 함께해요. 한국은 여러분들의 나라입니다. 더욱 개선하고 발전되도록 개개인이 노력하겠습니다. 한국의 모두가 행복하길... 아니 전세계 모두가 행복하길 기원합니다.
한국은 어떤나라와 달리 문제점을 끄집어내서 계속 공론화 시켜왔기 때문에 발전하고 있습니다. 지금은 또 다릅니다, 많은 혼혈이나 한국애서 나고 자란 와국인들이 한국인라고 느끼는만큼 같이 인정 받고 있습니다. 근데 파키스탄 아이들은 정말 안타깝네요. 정서적으로는 완전 한국아이들인데..얼마나 힘들었을까..
조선족 중국인들한테 혜택이 너무 많이 감 자국민이 우선이 아닌 이들이 우선이 되어버리니까 역차별이 생기고있음 지금 진짜 좀 많이 개선이 필요한듯
So unfair to all children. Kids are kids and usually never see differences and if they do, most times they’re only curious if they look different and will ask. I grew up in Florida and we had every culture in this state. We all grew up together and got along just fine. It’s adults that pass on their prejudices onto the children.
What I don't understand about their foreign parents is why they didn't teach their children native language?! Cause if they know at least two let's say Korean and English there's a big chance for them to work in a better field like a translator or Korean lecturers for foreigners that speak their mom's native language. I'm raising my half-Korean son he just turned 1 but I make sure to use all three languages that I know daily not only Korean.
I am ashamed. I wanted my kids to speak perfect American English… didn’t want them bullied for their pronunciation..유감습니다…I am
So many kids in the US just know English and not their parents native language. It's sad but there's still some misconceptions about language learning across the globe that makes it so people discard the.childs second language. My son is also half Korean and my husband and I are raising him with both languages.
People just don't do bilingualism well. For example, Malta is supposed to be bilingual with native language in English and Maltese. It just ends up they do both sort of poorly. Most educated professionals like doctors and lawyers cannot read or write in Maltese. They only speak it with a liberal dollop of English mixed in. Algeria used to speak excellent French. Now they're trying to do Arabic and they do that rather poorly. And they're losing French. The Philippines is totally losing English. I can't even understand most of them now.
I also have a 15 yo niece whose mother is French. She speaks to her daughter exclusively in French. They also spend every summer in Nice. To me, my niece sounds perfectly fluent. I was shocked to hear her say that she speaks her second tongue like a first grader and that her grammar is bad and that she gets her noun genders wrong all the time and cannot remember them for the life of her. That's not even the writing, which is even more difficult for her. It was kind of shocking but also revealing. To speak at a high level of intelligent fluency in a second language, not just "kitchen Chinese/Russian/etc" is very, very difficult.
@@ampa4989 I think it depends on how children are raised. I was raised in a bilingual household and also taught those languages from age 5 til university age 19 excluding English. It wasn't that bad as long as I use the languages often I don't think I’d forget any of those. I also studied Korean (a year & half) but since I only acquired the language for a short time, there is a big chance I forget it especially if we move out of Korea compared to the languages I learned from a young age.🤭
These kids are from third-world countries and usually are working-class or (much more often) lower class. Their parents often do physically strenuous jobs all day, and after cooking and cleaning, they don't really have time or energy to teach their kids their native language. I know lots of kids who are multicultural, one of their parents coming from a developed country and having a white-collar job. Most of them speak two languages because their mother or father sits down with them daily to teach the language more systematically, give them homework, and check if they have done it. They can also find a hagwon (private tutoring) and pay for it if they don't have time because their languages (English, Japanese, German, French, etc) are taught at least somewhere. But good luck with finding a Vietnamese, Nepalese, etc hagwon.
Jik Un yang kuat dan tabah yah. Semangat!!! Kamu pasti bisa.
I hope Noman and his sisters can be a translator or make a Korean Course and become a teacher
Unfortunately, they are deported to Nepal. After he graduated high school. The family don't live in Korea anymore.
Noman and his family members were deported to Pakistan. Right now Noman was hired by KBS news board for Pakistan
They were deported to Pakistan. Norman has a UA-cam channel now. He only talks in Korean, and idk if he has an Eng sub, though. This doc was aired in Korea first (all of the documentaries on this channel were broadcasted in Korean first) and got pretty famous in Korea too, so he has quite a few followers. He only has 10 videos from the past 6 months but already has 54K followers. His channel is called 노만.
@@davidhan9979glad to hear that
@@user-cx7wf4xv6x What's his youtube channel? Do you know?
Great story….not KDrama…but Reality drama….heart-rending….better than any KDrama currently aired….please do a follow up story on the young couple who’s wife was stricken with cancer…raising two sons in the hospital…please KBS…
This reminds me of Vernon from Seventeen. He was also bullied at school because his mom's genes were more dominant in his apperance making him look more American than Korean. And other kpop artists who were of bicultural/multicultural family.
I think you need to fix your comment on 'making him look more American than Korean' Americans come in all races
@@jtwhiteafrican2854I think they mean European and before you said “they also come in all colors” genetics are different to nationalities
@yolandapaulino5952 'genetics are different to nationalities' can you explain more because I dont understand what that means
@@jtwhiteafrican2854 They just meant more western features.
@em-dj2yx I think they should've just said Vernon looks white
Please follow up with them more! Help Pakistani kids to go back to their home in Korea 🙏🏻. With internet now, they can meet someone in Korea and get married
Hope, all of you find his way, good luck
저 재능이 그리고 교육받은게 너무 아까워요 항상힘내세요!
Legit. Like yeah lets let the kids have a taste of what opportunity looks like then rip it away from them. They shouldve left their kids in korea at least.
i can relate to the pakistani kids. it hurts being a returnee, you feel conflicted
Very good documentary. So sad for the children that had to go back to Pakistani. Especially the girls.
It ‘s really shocking that this kind of resentments are still so present; even with people born in S.Korea. It seems to be indoctrinated in culture. Its not enough to send K-Pop idols abroad for awareness when your country still can’t handle this issue.
Definitely Yes.
lol, I grew up in the US. We had and still have discrimination even though we are a melting pot.
Korea is one of the most homogeneous societies on planet Earth.
It is even more shocking when people who went through discrimination find justice (lol ???) in what happened to those kids. A homogenous society should not be the excuse or justification for it.
@@silviehurlimann6257 The real world isn't some utopia that needs a justification. It's reality.
Damn, I'm explaining it to you why it happens with a reference point and you still are dug into your corner.
Do people make comments for an echo chamber or do they actually want to listen to broaden their horizons?
the most homogeneous in what perspective, if it's regarding immigration law, I'm not discussing further. But if regarding the mindset/behavior, more specific, when it comes to school bullying, I don't think so. Many S.K realistic, malicious cases of bullying have been revealed. Recently, a teacher committed suicide because of parent bullying, which shown us another level of bullying in S.K society. @@HKim0072
may be u can make a private online or offline in teaching korean languanges in your country.
Man i can't even imagine what they had to go through all these years growing up just because they are mixed blood, these days the way koreans regard and treat people of other races has definitely changed a lot in a positive way but still with some certain people like South Asians or Southeast Asians countries, there are still unfair treatment or existing till this day to a certain extent.
So for those people why this kinda discrimination exists in South Korea is because the country is still technically homogeneous, so obviously Koreans aren't really used to or find it comfortable living alongside foreign people or mixed blood people which is honestly understandable, just think about it most Koreans have only seen people of a single race and ethnicity ever since they were born so no wonder why koreans get awkward around people not looking like them and also when it comes to the language, they only speak one which is korean.
and those factors are significant enough to lead to naturally being exclusive from foreign people which could also lead to treating non koreans or non korean looking people in such a discriminative way.
But i'm only saying those kinds of factors could contribute to the issue, i do not justify or glorify koreans being assholes toward people like those in the video because it's stupid and such an uncivilized thing to do. and koreans and its government must put into efforts to exterminate the discrimination but it'd take so much time to be completely free from it
again it's really heartbreaking to hear what they had to experience but i want them to be aware that their hardships and all the struggles they had will undoubtedly pave the road for other mixed bloods and foreigners who would visit or live in South Korea to not end up being prone to what they had to go through in the future.
대한민국 육군 출신은 모두 대한민국 시민 입니다. 같은 육군 출신으로 임하은 병장님의 앞날을 응원 합니다
whoever is narrating is doing an awesome job! You'll go far in life, kid! How about talking to the korean national students and bring up how bullying is inappropriate. this needs to be taught from the ppl above at mgmt level. if this dont accept the non koreans, hhow can you expect the classmates to change.
이거 드디어 kdoc유튜브 영상에 올라왔네요! 옛날에 제가 중학생이였을때 학교 창체시간에 본 영상이거든요
아이들끼리의 차별, 따 는 분명 부모님, 주위로 부터 받은 영향. 어른이 '너 재하고 놀지마 우리랑 다르니까, 다문화니까'라고 차별을 주입시키면 애들은 그렇게 행동 할 수 밖에. 어릴때 받은 차별, 왕따는 성인이 되도 트라마로 남죠. 좀 걱정스러웠던 하은이는 놀랍게 탈바꿈 했네요. 젤 걱정되는 애들은 한국에서 태어나 한국애들로 컸으나, 쫓겨나고 재 입국이 금지되어, 파키스탄에서 언어도 생소한데, 차가운 현실에서 방황하는 노만과 두여동생들. 한국대사관, 공기관들이 재 성찰 하셔서 이들에게 도움을 주시기 바래요. 한국애들이 쫓겨나 재 입국금지 당한 것과 같으니까요.
Please bring back Noman and siblings back to Korea…they are Koreans…대한민국 동료들…
They are not! Apart from speaking language i dont see anything korean in them ! Its better for them continue living in their respective country
They are grown up now and they can try to get visa if they want.
ㄴㄴ 5번 신청했는데 다 거절 당함. 그 담당 공무원이 청화대 명령 안듣고 가라 행정으로 조져서 기록 남음.
They have to work for it like every1 else, no special treatment
There's always some chucklefuck on the interwebs trying to act like you've had to carry mountains on your backs and no one else could ever fathom your pain. What is about their situation that is "just like any one else"? They *are* working for it, but are also very clearly too far beneath the poverty line for their efforts to make a difference. His sisters, at the very least, get to go to school, yet he can't afford the same privileges because he has to work for 3 dollars and some change everyday, and has no chance to study his own mother tongue so that he can go to school and get the necessary qualifications to get a job and then work his way back to Korea. As far as what's most familiar to them, Korea is their home, it's where they were raised, it's whose people they know how to communicate with, it's where they've experienced their most formative years, and none of this by choice because they were CHILDREN when these decisions were made on their behalf. All the work they can be putting towards getting back to their home, they instead have to use on surviving day-by-day. "special treatment" 개불 이 good for nothing 멈청이 뇌썩 뇌없 섀끼야 진짜 빡치게 하잖아 ㄴㅁ 빡치다 진짜 ㅆ발
The Pakistani parents could've done better. It must be emotionally and mentally harsh for the kids. So unfortunate, but the parents aren't wise, follow the rules, look up other multicultural families, look up what other family do, do they do it better, what is to be improved, integration, ect ect. Because you are in a different country, different culture, different rules, different society. Even if it's difficult, you have chosen to go to korea and you are already in the country, now what you have to do is, know and follow the rules, if you know the rules, you follow it and you and your children will be safe. Such a big disappointment from the parents. Like of course you can not stay in a foreign country with a working visa for forever. The parents could've apply for citizenship or if it's not possible, then apply for another working visa, it's just you have to think further and prepare everything before something happens. Be prepared! No matter where we are in a foreign country, it's all the same! You have to adjust yourself to the new country where you are currently in!
They already did better than most people where they're from, you have to be exceptionally lucky or exceptionally skilled to move to a developed country these days. The average person or family won't make it.
@@AxsIav of course they didn't. I can even see it from why their son smells so bad back in the past. The parents didn't even do anything about it and i didn't see that their son used any shower gel ect ect or also a perfume. There are tons of cheap perfumes in the convenience shops and they didn't even eat korean food or didn't even teach their kids how to eat with chopsticks. Obviously the parents should've moved their ass up and done something and integrate themselves so they and their children have a better opportunity, life and situation instead of just surrendering and waiting for what will happen and complaining their kids get bullied at school. No excuse for this! 👎
@@lelugrey1509 The average in that country/region is extremely low. Even low is better than average.
하은이가 군대도 다녀오고
대한민국의 청년으로 잘 성장하길 ^^
The bottom line is that we all do have a right to be happy.
Let's all embrace each other!
Different color od skin, food, customs....
Let's accept all!
That's just cruel, kicking out families just because of one member's expired visa, especially a family with kids who grew up living like a Korean. Should've at least given the children a chance at continue making a living in Korea.
I hope those Pakistani children can at least visit Korea again.
umm, it was incredibly fair. The parents didn't have a visa. They actually let the kids finish their education and high school.
I'm very liberal when it comes to immigration as an ethnic Korean in America, but Korea decision makers are a bit more strict.
How hard it is to renew visa in Korea? It’s an immigration law that if you’re not a citizen of the country you should hold a valid visa.
Even Pakistan is kicking out Afghan migrants that have lived in Pakistan for decades. Cmon now, strict immigration policies must be enforced or else you’ll end up having a migrant crisis like in the EU and US. In the US there are millions of homeless people, yet free housing is given priority to illegal immigrants in this current administration..
@@HKim0072i disagree with your statement….self given, appropriated ‘liberal’ title…incredibly fair??? Where is your Korean-American compassion…still provincial 지방 mindset…let noman and sibling come back to Korea…they are Koreans in my book…
Go home
외국인들을 위한 한국 비자발급이 좀 더 개개인의 일상을, 사정을 배려해줬으면 좋겠네요.. 이런 한국의 어두운 현실을 인지할 때마다 마음이 아픕니다. 다문화가정에서 성장한 한국인들의 의견을 더 존중해주는 방향으로 하루 빨리 제도가 바뀌었으면 좋겠어요.
The world is like a box of choclatetoo. Do not despair . you are all very especial and beautiful . Learn English and a profession and many beautiful doors will open
Tragic how immigrants are used and thrown out with out any human consideration.
there are a lot of on line courses you can learn for free. I mostly blame the parents for not knowing all the Lawes, I guess they had the best intentions. But intentions without actual work ,bring people to such traumas .
Be strong and know that irons are forged through fire, Be strong , positive and really do not look back maybe in the long run it is better you're out of that place. I am a son of immigrants parents . I have been moving all my life. I have a good profession so I can work any where and also from home on my computer and I am doing super well financially. My problem now is I love traveling too much that I cannot stay in any country for too long. and I am happy and love it. Have a profession , build capital and learn English. Go forward full speed. Be Happy
Why Korea is known as Hermit Kingdom?
No land pursued a policy of restricting contacts with the outside world more zealously than Korea under the Chosŏn dynasty, earning it the sobriquet the “Hermit Kingdom.” Koreans were forbidden to travel abroad except on diplomatic missions to China or Japan.
Interesting
38:33 아시아 공동체학교가 있구나 사실 일반학교에서 아이들이 자기와 다르다고 따돌리는 일이 일어나서는 안되지만
아시아공동체학교에서 좀 더 다양한 친구들을 만나보고 나랑 비슷한 환경의 친구들하고 비슷한 상처를 공유하고 친해질 수 있었다면 좋았을 것 같아요
결국 자라나면서 생긴 그늘이 너무 짙어보여서 안타까워요 진욱씨
하은이가 멋있게 잘컷네. 내가 다 흐뭇하네.
People’s clothes will smell it they cook, eat, sleep and prepare food in the same space. Also spices and seasonings, eg garlic used in different diets lead to different odours.
What people eat has a lot to do with body odor. Especially eating a lot of curry. It’s like eating a lot of garlic, no matter how clean a body is on the outside, you can still smell it.
Actually it’s genetic. Most Koreans have a genetic mutation for the gene that causes body odor.
@@kuse166 actually they don’t , there is less body odor in South Koreans, Japanese and Native Americans. It’s a specific gene variant, ABCC11. I just looked it up.
Does anyone know why
Dagyeong has bad memories of Asia Community School
She could not handle or help alleviate the trauma the other kids went through so she just tried to ignore. Implication is that she didn't keep in touch with other kids after.
Its a good to ask because I totally misunderstood I thought she hated them. Thanx for explaining.
😢
Ada orang indonesia juga 🇮🇩
저들을 한국 사회가 잘 포옹해야합니다.
I been reading how foreginer were treated back then especically with vernon,somi how they face racial discrimation snice there were not many foreign kpop idol as well even when hangeng super junior debut he has struggle a lot snice he was one first foreign and chinese idol and nickhun from 2pm struggle as well with hangeng snice they were both first thai and chinese idol one first foreign idol and thanks to them 2 korean start open to foriegner got bit better for foreigner and foriegn kpop idol and include immigration dk how much for them.
Please become youtuber Pakistani. N i Will be the first subsciber.. Your Korean language really fluent please Its unique for the viewers
If you don't brake any rules is actually pretty easy to get the Korean citizenship and after one family member gets it they usually bring their families too. The problem is with people that comes with a tourist visa and stays illegally and later try to use their children's situation as an excuse, that's wrong and the only one to blame should be the parents.
You are an idiot with no compassion! Everyone is trying to make life a little better. A thriving country needs to support people who are trying to survive. Just put yourself as a Korean refugee during the 1950s!
@@j.k1371"Residentship" where did you get this word? 🤭
They went to Korea just to make money and opened a restaurant not for a better and safe place for their Islam! Because Korea is a non Muslim country where alcohol and sexual relationships available for everyone unlike Muslim countries. And Koreans don't like Muslims. The same when Koreans went to work in Muslim countries for money, Saudi, Iraq....erc
The moment I saw the 2019 slide, I thought "oh no, the Shutdown will change their lives, yet again."😢
The government should have KSL Korean as a Second Language program for immigrants so parents can be of assistance to their children when it comes to education.
Great idea!
South Korea still needs a lot more work. No point just looking good on camera if their hearts are filled with hatred.
Discrimination is a human trait, and it is everywhere. The only difference between developed homogeneous East Asian countries and the U.S. is higher education opportunities. My oldest brother was a refugee to Japan and lived there for twelve years. My parents eventually sponsored him to America. All my siblings and I have advanced degrees. Immigrants from poor countries should be grateful to live in developed countries. I hope these homogeneous nations have policies in place to allow talented immigrants to obtain higher education for social mobility and contributing economic growth to each respective nation.
I come from a settler country ad while not perfect such countries ha ve many years of experience including people from all over the world into their societies and making them full citizens. For those countries like Korea which are not so diverse the problems of immigrants are new and their governments need to start putting in programs now that will help integrate these people into the general population. Climate change is going to bring change and movement of people and all of us will have to be better at being inclusive of everyone.
You came from a stolen land that was never yours to begin with, you have no right to even stop others from coming, truthfully . Korea always belonged to the Koreans.
Can someone explain to me why Noman and his siblings can't go back to Korea?
Seems their parents did something illegal and that can affect dependent visas as well
cuz they're foreigners?
@@AxsIav what I mean was, what happened with their visa
All Visas expire, you can't stay in a country forever on a visa, unless you get permanent residency or citizenship.
His parents are believed to have been illegal aliens. Under the , children are entitled to the same level of basic education as Koreans, but must leave the country after that period. Aside from the tragedy of Norman, it is true that the law was enforced well.
😊😊😊😊
로만은 그냥 한국인 인데...안타깝다...
😮😮
미안합니다 정말 정말 너무 미안합니다 ㅜㅜ
Jin-Uk fighting!!!
If you have been born, educated somewhere, then that country should either give you lessons of your home country, or let you stay.
And i hope they can come back to Korea someday.
So unfair for the Pakistani kids. Korea should change its policy in the case of such families. The kids , now young adults, are basically Korean . In the greater interest of human rights and right to life, Korean citizenship should have been given.
But wouldn't that just encourage more non-residents to have children? That might be a financial burden the country cannot bear. It's very sad, but sad things are part of life. I hope they will find success and happiness. I hope Pakistan will develop and become as prosperous as Korea is.
@@ampa4989 You’re right, sadly there is always a downside to sound laws.
@@ampa4989True
That's South Korea and their administration.
감정에 호소하노 역겹다
이 다큐는 한국에서 적응하지 못한 아이들이나 문제가 생긴 대상으로 만들어진 것이예요
잘 적응한 이민자나 다문화가정 친구들은 나오지 않습니다. 물론 문제가 없다고 생각하지 않아요.😢
한국은 오랫동안 다문화국가가 아니라 같은 민족이 대부분이라서 이민 가정이나 다문화가정 아이들이 적응하기 어려웠을 것 같아요
20년 전에는 다문화 가족이 워낙 소수였지요. 지금도 소수지만 외국인들이 많이 유입되면서 그 수가 많아지고 어릴때부터 많은 다문화 프로그램과 정책이 시행되고 있어서 좋아지리라 봅니다. 파키스탄의 노만은 한국에 올 수 없지만 다른 가족은 비자만 있으면 한국으로 다시 들어올 수 있다고 해요 여동생 니말은 한국어를 계속 공부하여 한국에서 공부할 꿈도 있다고 하네요.
여기에 나온 모든 친구들이나 다른 이민자나 다문화가정 친구들도 한국에서 행복하게 살았으면 좋겠습니다.
вау... это очень трогательно и обидно
조금만 불편한 내용 있으면 악플만 남기던 내가 이렇게 울 줄은 몰랐다. 무조건적으로 개방하는 건 문제 있다고 생각하지만 사람 위에 법이 있으면 안된다. 특히 파키스탄 노만 남매들 같은 경우는 정부가 융통성 있게 해야 했다고 생각함
우와! 노만이당!
파키스탄에 있는 한국어 학원에서 선생님으로 일하건ㆍ, 과외는 할수 없나요?
여기 나온 모든 분들이 행복했으면 좋겠네요^^ 홧팅입니다
안타깝고 미안하다.. 청소년기는 인생의 반이상인데..
정말 보기 힘들었습니다.. 한국사회에 있는 한국인으로서 죄송합니다.
제 마음만으로는 사회가 가지고 있는 인식을 바꾸지 못하는 무기력감이 가슴을 짖누릅니다
Sad 😢I’ve been watching KDramas a lot and it seemed like Bullying is the norm in South Korea from school to work place . I was in Seoul last month for a week with my son. We had fun, I’m impressed with the country’s progress but there wasn’t much interaction with locals , maybe due to language barrier. They’re not so friendly, went through immigration , not even a “ welcome to Seoul “. I’m originally from the Philippines where everyone is friendly then emigrated to the U.S. where Americans are welcoming and nice.
It just depends. I've been to Philipines several times, everyone was just normal, not friendly. I mean, why not? Sometimes, I rather felt some of them are kinda rude. Some of the clerks were just lying down on the floor during working hours and didn't care about me at all even tho they noticed me. But I don't wanna say like they're like this and that since I had a good interaction with a Fillipina in Korea. It's just sterotypical to say Koreans aren't so friendly unlike others.
Stop saying bullshit. Since when everyone in the Phillipines is friendly? 😅😅
Lol you judge a whole country based on a highly over-exaggerated dramas like are you serious right now? Stop the bullshit
I know jerk Filipinos and nice koreans.
@@user-fi8xr9pm6i its the NEW GENERATION of gen z or millenials whos at working age now and gays with attitudes, most of them are really spoiled brats especially those working at fast food chains.
And PH doesnt have work ethics unlike korea and japan.
I genuinely feel bad for the Pakistani family. However looking at France, Sweden and other western Europe countries situation right now I believe the strict immigration policy is necessary evil.
do you realized that the western/ european countries bought it upon themselves? most of the immigrant are coming from the countries that they once occupied or stealing from?
During Ellis island when it was undocumented europeans it was okay, but now its brown people trying to get in now you have to think about it. The US and Europe have a of a history of exploiting black and brown immigrants coming to live and work in their countries. Especially people who come from Commonwealth countries. Then creating draconian laws when they don’t like the amount of those immigrants coming in. That’s what they did to the Chinese in America and then they did the same thing with the commonwealth immigrants in Europe. So keep telling yourself how this “necessary evil”.
@@kittychobit The thing is even those brauns and bIeccs and As'ans also don't want more of them. Immigration is opposed by all races, as long as their whole family has come over already.
그래도 갈수록 한국도 발전해간다… 차별이없기를 바란다 선진국을수록
지금 강대국인 나라들은 이민자의 국가이거나 인도적차원에서 눈치보여서 이민 받아준거지
우리는 이민장벽 더더욱 높여야 함
이민자들 다 받아들이면 결국 끝은 유럽 꼴이다
아랍 애들이랑 흑인애들(얘네는 그래도 문화 받아들인 사람들이라도 있지) 지금 유럽깽판치고 있는 거 보셈
이탈리아 애들은 지금 이민자들 다 내쫓아버리자고 난리고 독일 애들도 스멀스멀 그 의견들이 수면 위로 올라오고 있음 스웨덴은 아예 이민자 2세대들이 조직적인 갱 됐음
우리나라와 일본 중국 타이완 홍콩은 멜팅팟이 아님 각 나라의 문화를 받아들일거 아니면 절대 이민자들 받아들이지 말아야함
지금처럼 걍 외노자 몇년만 체류해주고 보내는 식의 방식을 이어나가야함
산업기술분야 문화예술분야의 기적은 이미 보여줬다
향후 10년은 영성 도덕 분야에서의 미라클이 만배 더 세상을 경악케할 것이다
Thats just sad. These parents shouldnt have taken their kids away from a first world country all the way to a 1st world country. Its so sad. So much opportunity was robbed from them.
i wish these kids could go back to korea
Korea’s losing population. It’s stupid to expel these kids who had learned Korean, history and culture. Hope that average Korean people open arms to these korean with different background. Because these kids are other future of Korea.
Thank you for producing this film. I'm an American and learning about the "not so good" aspects of foreign countries when it comes to the way they treat children of darker skin tones. It was not surprising to see the children with the fairest and most Asian-like features assimilate and do well in South Korea while the other children continued struggling into their adulthoods. Norman who was of the darkest hue, was hit the hardest, also not a surprise. Norman might've made a handsome boy band member if allowed to stay, train, and thrive in Korea without discrimination because of his skin tone. He wasn't given the chance.
The difference in outcomes like this happens in many countries around the world, including the USA. It even happened with multicultural families escaping Ukraine at the start of the Russian war. Darker hued children and their parents escaping Ukraine were pushed aside in many European countries unlike white Ukrainian children and their parents. Japan and Australia closed their doors entirely to these children and families. The Phillipines opened their doors wide open, but the distance from the Ukrainian culture made many multicultural refugees turn down the relocation offers. I know because I volunteered and helped some unforutnate children seeking relocation often be denied or declined the help. It was a mess.
The United Nations Declaration of Human Rights procalims that all children and adults in the world are to be treated equally with respect and fairness, and unhindered from living productive lives. Few countries actually are committed to this vision when it comes to the "foreigners" or mixed culture members of their society. Even my country, the USA, falls short. There are a lot of excuses used to justify hurting children from all types of families. I believe there can be no acceptance of this mistrestment by any civilized society. Children and youth are our world's future. We must not continue to mistreat our future with such disapproval, disrespect, disdain, and disregard. Doesn't matter where it's done; it's wrong! Stories like these must stop.🛑 Thank you for helping to bring this troubling situation to light. Your efforts are greatly appreciated.❤
I think the Pakistani children deserve to live back in Korea. There must be protection for these children surely. Also a great kdrama webtoon material, I vouch.
다문화 엄마들도 한국어와 문화 역사 교육을 시켜야합니다 ! ^^
아무렴 한국 사는데 안배우겠습니까? 쓸데없는말 하지마세요
@@soljoo4472 안배움 특히 무슬림들은
군생활 조심히하세요
언제적 방송인데 제대한지 오래
my country is a paradise for immigrants and mixed races. You can master multiple languages in shortest time and food is available 24 hours
Which country?
Malaysia
@@weiyawphuah89873rd world paradise?😂
@@user-lw8tq3qs1p sad but reality
Omg just hearing these siblings talk in korean 50:00 I mean they are korean! Their korean is better than some korean Americans I know! Isn't there any job at the consulate or any job in korea that they could do? I mean if they are fluent in korea, can't they pursue becoming a translator? There has to be options for them?? I mean the guy is wasting his future by making hamburgers! I feel so bad for them!!!
Exactly my thoughts! They can work at the Pakistani consulate and speaking the language like their mother tongue, it would be a win win situation for all.
Only the dude speaks Korean fluently. The rest speak very broken Korean. And no, they are NOT Korean. Just because a Pakistani guy grew up in Korea doesn't change who he is.
@John-hp2hg by 'the rest' are you referring to Noman's sisters?
That's like saying I'm from England, cuz I speak English. Why feel bad? They're reunited with their people, their culture, their roots.
@@AxsIav did you watch the docu? they wished their parents had given them a choice to go back to their country or stay in korea. they wanted to stay in korea... don't even want to move schools but move countries? they aren't living their dream life right now. who cares if it's their country.. a lot of ppl leave "their country" to get better opportunies...
I feel bad for the Pakistani kids😢 can they still return to Korea?
i think they were punished because of what their parents did. but they can leave and go somewhere else and be korean teachers, work at a korean business. tons of koreans here in california. my heart breaks for them.
지금 한국에 있는걸로 알고있습니다.
@@schoolinJOO They were not punished at all, they simply didn't get lucky enough to be given first world citizenship or residency for free, which is how it is for 90% of people in the world. But they can still get it, just not for free.
진욱이 아버지 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ어휴 답답하다
이렇게 되면 안되는거 아닌가요
Noman and sisters need to be back in Korea…You cant expel people who grow up as Koreans in Korea. So sad n So maddening.
They are where they belong, why is it so bad to be reunited with your people and culture?
Regarding visas for Pakistani friends, there is nothing wrong with Korean law right now. Emotionally, I feel sadness, but there were not many children from multicultural families in Korea when the documentary was produced. In just about 10 years, a lot of foreigners came in and started to get used to it. However, Korea had an extreme concept of Korean people and it was a culture that was ostracized against other races. Many young Koreans were educated on racism and were negative about it. Older people were not educated on racism and think it will be difficult to change in the future. I think it will also be the same problem in foreign countries other than Korea. In the end, we will all solve the problem. Korean men will never discriminate against mixed-race children who served in the military in Korea. Being educated in Korea and having Korean nationality despite their different appearances means that they are Koreans just like us
Did that Pakistani family come back to Korea? They had such bright lives that were cut short and that dad am mad why did he do that to his son and daughter they could have thrived.
Gosh thats really difficult. I was born in America but ethically Chinese. I do not associate with the country China at all aside from what I speak and traditions. If I was for some reason sent to a country Ive never been in I dont know how I would adjust.
When you've been a 2nd class citizen your whole life, being a 1st class citizen feels weird.
그러니까 매매혼 좀 하지마라 애들한테 저게 뭐하는 짓이냐?
노인들 진짜 이기적이네
foreigners always suffrering in other countries , choices !!!! all in life choices!!!!