Boost/Overdrive Pedal Comparison! (Dual Rectifier Edition)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 чер 2024
- Timecodes:
00:00 Introduction
01:59 Mesa Rectifier without boost
03:42 Maxon OD808
04:58 Boss SD-1 Super Overdrive
06:20 Electro-Harmonix Soul Food
07:55 Electric Eye Audio Mud Killer
09:25 MXR 10-band EQ
10:42 A/B Back to back comparison
11:32 A/B Back to back comparison ISOLATED
12:12 Final thoughts
Link to the Marshall JCM800 boost comparison:
• Boost Pedal Comparison...
Link to the Mud Killer demo:
• Electric Eye Audio MUD...
Thanks for watching this guitar overdrive/distortion/boost pedal comparison or shootout with my Mesa Boogie Dual Rectifier amp video! Please hit subscribe and follow SDS at:
/ sonicdrivestudio
/ sonicdrivestudio_official
The signal flow was as follows:
-ESP LTD-Elite Eclipse I
-Fractal Audio Axe Fx III (for recording the DI's)
-Pedals
-Mesa Boogie Dual Rectifier
-Fractal Audio LB-2 Loadbox
-Fractal Audio Axe Fx III (for IR loading and noise gate)
-OwnHammer (r)Evolution 412 TRAD V30-MB1 Impulse Responses
-Steven Slate Drums
-Cubase 10.5 pro
The pedals included in this video are the:
- Maxon OD808 Overdrive (tube screamer
- Boss SD-1 Super Overdrive
- Electro-Harmonix Soul Food (klon clone)
- Electric Eye Audio Mud Killer
- MXR 10-band EQ (graphical equalizer)
Find the OwnHammer (r)Evolution IR's here: www.ownhammer.com/store/index...
tag words: boost, overdrive, tube screamer, fortin, grind, 33, metal, rock, comparison, rectifier, tube amp, pedal, pedals, drive, distortion, shootout
![Boss Super Overdrive Or Ibanez Tube Screamer? [In Your Band]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/l7OSahzgd0M/mqdefault.jpg)
![Boss Super Overdrive Or Ibanez Tube Screamer? [In Your Band]](/img/tr.png)
I actually preferred the "tone" with the SD-1, but they all have their flavor. I also liked the "tone" with the Soul Food a lot. The sound without boost is very good also.
Soul Food and straight Eq were my favorites.
The soul food adds some woofiness to it but it sounds amazing with this mesa.
Soul food is so underrated. I use it with my Diezel Herbert and it makes it sound better by no tone change . Just sounds bigger
@@techdeathhippie6319 Is there any difference in tone with the buffer switch on?
Danny B. I go without . To me it’s a lil better
Soul food is great, as you turn the gain up it cuts some of the low end out to tighten things up, but unlike the TS the amount of that low cut is more customizable. I find the 808 too thin for the EMG 81 in my personal case but it's still great with passives, where soul food seems to work well for more guitars perhaps
Finally someone put an EQ 10 to show the huge possibilities it have (I prefer instead overdrive pedals). Thanks 🤗
Você utiliza quais pedais de Overdrive e empurra quais amplificadores?
They all sounded great, but for my taste, I appreciate that the Soul Food somewhat preserved the amp's bottom end.
great for playing alone. sucky in a band tho. I liked the SD1 better
the Maxon and 10-band compliment the amp the best for sure. that mesa sounds huge with those, w both the mids right where they need to be and low end punchy and just present enough
Your content is top notch, brother. Keep it up. You’ll be at 500k in no time.
Perfect pedals! Best combo to try if you have these is the MXR 10 in the effects loop and the SD-1 out front... tonal heaven!
what a great idea. 👍
I have that set up except im using the Precision Drive instead of the SD1. Def considering picking one up as it seems to really do wonders for mesa boogie rectifiers.
Agreed, I use several ODs, one of them being the SD-1 but the real key is the 10 band in the FX loop. In this demo, I liked the SD-1 the best
I liked the SD-1 the most. I have that pedal myself, so I'm biased but I sort of gravitate to it, because it sounds a little bit more agressive, compared to some other pedals.
You really rock man. These riffs are killer. Keep them coming!
What a amazing job dude! This was one of the best pedals comparison i ever seen! Congrats
Well done. I like how you used the isolated tracks to really show the tonal differences between the amp without a boost and when the boost pedal is on. Thank you.
Man, the snarl on that SD-1. Absolutely fantastic video!
Wooowww! Mudkiller is a beast!
Man, your channel is so useful!
I feel like I may need to get an SD-1 after this. Your videos are just in a different league man, awesome work. Really enjoy your playing/writing, too 🤘
This is an amazingly professional and detailed comparison. I've couldn't image the MXR 10-band EQ and Electric Eye Audio Mud Killer (never heard about it) will be my favorites. These are sound sick. Tons of thanks!
Thanks mate, my favourite guitar and my favourite amp, the sound on these pair together is just astonishing!!! Great idea to add the MXR 10 band eq, I have one and it’s a very versatile tool for tightening this beast and for polishing clean sounds too. I really liked how this eq worked with this pair.
Excellent job as usual Jon. Every different comparison sounds BRUTAL!!!!
Really nice work! You’ve been crushing it lately (actually always)! I like your choices of boosts. In addition to the TS, SD1, and soul food, I’ve been using my OCD (normal pedal but also the Helix models) a lot lately with my Rev G dual rectifier. It’s absolutely killer and gives a tight and aggressive tonality with less of a mid hump. I highly recommend that folks give that combo a try to see if it’s to your liking. Keep up the great work!
Man, the boss is quickly becoming my new favorite these days
Great video. The most helpful of its type. I'd really like to see an updated version comparing the 808, SD-1, Soul Food, Digitech Bad Monkey, and TS-9.
I'm glad I stumbled over this 3 years later. Great starting tone. The sd-1 was surprisingly clear. The boutique screamer I would say was my favourite overall, but the soul food held its own too as a bit of a "sleeper pedal" thanks for the demo
Great review! Best gear demo channel by far! I liked the SD-1 the most. Made it tighter and hotter.
Bought the Soul Food right after that video, very very good sounding and letting the amp breathe his typical fire. Gonna record my band's next album with it plugged on a Single Rectifier. Thanks for that quality video mate o/
Awesome!
@@SonicDriveStudio
P.S. : don't know which IR you used exactly in the (R)evolution bundle but it's so tasty and full, and yet it sits very good in the mix. Damn you're good 🤘
Boss sd1!
SD-1 is pretty tight-I really surprised...
Jason Becker used it.
I struggle with this pedal (SD-1w) and tubescreamers when using it with my Mesa Rectoverb 25. I think the Boss Blues Driver BD2 pushes a wider set of frequencies which add snarl and punch to what a Mesa has lurking inside of it.
It's almost the exact same circuit as a tubescreamer.
@@mrcoatsworth429 the bd2 is nothing like the ts/sd1
@@theallmightyham I didn't say it was. I was replying to the original comment.
This was a great video! I definitely like the way you demonstrated everything.
This is an awesome video! thank you. I am just getting into overdrives, and I happen to have a single rectifier ,a TS 808, and the boss super overdrive. I like playing straight from the Mesa boogie because it’s an awesome amp , but this makes me want to try my ods on them!
I absolutely LOVE your channel, the amount of work you put in your videos is phenomenal! I think the difference between the pedals was really subtle, "Soul Food" was probably the best in my opinion
Sd-1 sounded killer….
all of them sound amazing!!!! Peronally I use a ts9 but in this video I liked the results you got from the sd1. Great video!!!!!
Mannn this channel is awesome!!!! And the riffs are super inspiring!
Thanks! :)
Maxon od 808 1) boss sd-1 2) great video , thanks
Great comparison, as always. I think the Soul Food and the MXR EQ win the day here. I typically love the SD-1 for boosting Marshall/British-type amps, but it's never wowed me boosting American amps, especially Mesas. I have one and love it in front of my JCM800, but can never quite get it to work on my Mesa Mark V 25 on any of the gain channels other than "crunch", which is kind of un-Mesa like anyway.
I've had a MXR 10 band for years now and never thought to use it this way (I typically keep it in the loop). I'm going to try it out!
Your channel = quality. Nice work mate :)
Man I was hoping you were going to do the mud killer vs the normal suspects with a recto. Perfect man, just perfect.
Your videos are just great! Thanks for the entertainment!
Very nice! The Mudkiller is quite tight, and the Maxon has that "boxy sound" without changing the amp's tone too much. I'm personally in love with the Maxon OD-808X and also the Fulltone OCD.
Love these videos. Ok I picked the SD1 in the JCM800 video but definitely not with the Rectifier with those settings. It’s harsh but I think it can be toned down a bit with slightly different settings. My pick here (in order) are the Maxon, then the Soul Food then the EQ. The EQ couldn’t tighten it up as much as the others but it did a good job keeping the tone character. I definitely agree the Soul Food maintained the characteristic bottom end well but I think the Maxon and Mudslinger also pulled that off similarly. This is a tough one...don’t think you can go wrong with any of them really. Well done 👍
Nice Video!
My favorite for boosting is clearly the SD-1. The sound becomes more assertive, which benefits solo playing. I also like the MXR-EQ, but it's ipty for me before the pre-amp. :)
Been using thr MXR10 band for this kind of thing for years, and gives some great flexibility as euther a preamp boost or as a post-preamp tone shaper in the FX loop. If you are looking for versatility, a quality EQ should be in every guitarists arsenal.
Dang, you're running the tube rectifier and it's still fairly tight? Nice! That's sexy
Great video...i own the same exact LTD EC, have the Maxxon SD1, a Klon clone by Warm Audio and the MXR M108 10 band....oh and a blacked out Dual Rectifier Multi watt ...so this really hits home for me!!
Maxon 808 , sound of SUFFOCATION!!! Like!!!!
Really great comparison.
Great tones man !
I really like your vids brother and appreciate ya.
Electro Harmonix win for me.
Didn't really change the original characteristics tone of the amp.
Mud killer is awesome!!!
Great video Man
Currently I am switching from my Rectifier to an JCM 2000, instead of micing the cab I play it through an OX, the reverb room sounds heavenly, not as aggressive as my 4x12 in a small room. Keep the chain simple but think about your room sound also. 🤘🎸🔥
It´s just amazing, how capable the SD-1 is, for the money. You might not like it personally, but it´s just a matter of subjective taste, and not a matter of "sounding cheap".
Great value for sure!
Prefer the SD-1 and MXR EQ sounds. Improves the excellent sound out of the Mesa Dual Rectifier.
Proud owner of the SD-1 but I was surprised by the Soul Food. Might need to test one out for myself.
excellent show case of what a boost can do. i still feel it's more noticeable in a recording situation than say live performance. probably just a bit more pronounces chugs and clarity with mids standing tall and present. i liked all pedals, boss the least, though suprised how good it sounded. soul food was simple and organic with a nice bottom end. eq could be very good to tailer tone, maybe in fx loop too. mud killer very nice. i'll try a soul food into my single rec. thanks and nice riffage
I agree with others here that I am totally fine without any pedal, but to me the only one that I didn't care for at all was the Mud Killer. It seemed to add some kind of digital artifact-ish kind of sound to the DR that I didn't care for. I can see uses for all the rest though, and I was impressed that the Soul Food was so transparent.
All that aside, love your work Sir, please keep up the great videos that you do!
These all sounded great, although the SD-1 was a little over the top for my tastes. It also totally makes sense to use an EQ in this way, that was a nice addition.
I think the mud killer makes that mesa shine by tightening it. Your original video of it made me order it to bring my peavey 6505+ to the next level, thanks for that!
Would love if You made a brief video of mud killer with that peavey of yours ;)
Thanks for the video bro!
I have a triple rectifier and my main guitar is a LTD. The EVH5150 just wasn't doing it for me so this vid was really helpful! Update: I got the Maxon 808 OD with the Keeley mod and it really tightened up my sound!!
I liked the amp without any pedals in front. It just sounds so raw and chewey.
same! for me the amp is the winner in this vid, it sounds amazing with any of the boosters
Yeah I agree. It sounds like the boosts are trying to make the Recto sound like a Mark series. If you want tight, buy the right amp :) There are plenty out there. Recto sounds huge, and I am pretty sure that if you tweak the EQ a tad more, you might get it tighter without loosing any of that BOTTOM!!!!
@Bart Lee I have owned a Dual, Triple and two Single Rectifier solo 50's. I have sold all of them and the only one I have decided to keep is my Series 2 Single. It's stripped down and doesn't have all the bells and whistles, it's simple and gets right to the point. It breaks up sooner which is really nice. I do boost it out front with a Fortin Grind but you can get pretty close without it using just eq. Really all the grind does for me is tighten it up a bit for when I'm using low tunings or extended range guitars. Honestly I could live without boosting the front end and it sounds killer with any guitar I use on it. I really only still use the grind because I paid so much for it. With the solo 50 you don't get as good of a clean because of less headroom but if I'm honest I never got into the rectifier series for the cleans, I fell in love with the crushing metal tones you get out of them. I'll never get rid of my series 2 solo 50. My goal is to fund another series one like I had before just to have around the studio. And trust me, I am definitely buying the Badlander next year!
@@irmasil3 no... all wrong
@@googuser3145 Do you have a Recto? Cos I do, and I know how the machine works, inside out.
Awesome shirt, Jon!
SD1 sounded so good in the rectifier. I love it. I like the Mud killer too.
OK I never really understood why everyone is using whatever overdrive pedal at 0 drive, max volume and some tone. That is what an EQ pedal is for! And this video confirmed. It's all just EQ and clean boost. I bet if you play around a little bit you can reproduce all four OD sounds with just the MXR EQ.
A lot of OD pedals aren't totally clean with the drive on zero.
Dude thank you for making this the boss sd1 actually sounds awesome and for 40 bucks can't beat that
great
thanks for this
very helpful
In this comparison I like the Soul Food best as I don't quite like the signature OD808 mid hump and bass cut. I like to retain low end in my Recto. But I also like to use a bit for Drive on an OD for some nasty saturation. I'd love to hear the Soul Food with more dirt in the drive and a little more Tone brightness. MXR Sugar Drive is also an awesome Klon clone.
I like the Boss, I’m using the Mesa flux five dual drive for a boost on a old line 6 spider half stack using the Slipknot preset EQ’d to taste of course, I got great results using my Ibanez axion label with Fishman fluence pickups, I recommend trying this out. The tone is pretty badass.
12:21 Absolutely! Great video showing why one would want an overdrive pedal,
But yea it's just a refining touch that should come after mastery of the riffs we're playing :) at that point the differences will be really subtle, and the actual usefulness will show in the added ease of mixing rather than audience liking the SD1 better that TS9 etc. etc.,
And that is how you make an amp/pedal review!! I came learn, and learn I did.
Get a Bonsai pedal, more options in one LOL . But seriously nice video about hitting the old Thread-plate with a boost/overdrive/eq. I really liked the powered EQ in there.
Soul Food and EQ sounded the best. My gig back up pedalboard has a 6-bansd MXR and a Soul Food. For me it is a good combination for in front of the amp. Nice job comparing!
とても素晴らしい比較
I love the raw Mesa sound on it's own.
But in the mix all of the od pedals help to better sit the guitar, in the mix, with the Soul food being the winner.
To my tastes, anyway.
Great video, as per usual!
SD-1 or Soul Food both bring a useful illumination. Excellent comparison.
Could you please do a similar kind of boost/overdrive comparison with the Orange Rockerverb? The Rockerverb is a lot more focused in the lower mids, so I'd love to see how all these pedals react with an amp like that, especially the SD-1 which sounds a bit brighter than the others. Great comparison BTW!
The mudkiller sounded awesome. I also like the soul food. It does a pretty decent job for such an affordable pedal. Even used as an overdrive it sounds quite good, I think.
Thanks for your comparisons and all the great information you are sharing!
I think i can dial with my mxr eq10 band the character of the soul food or klon Wich I think was the best in this comparisson.love this review.please do 5150 Peavey
Very good comparison! Same results with my amp (JCM800 clone). Conclusion: With that much distortion there is just NO WAY to hear any characteristics of the pedals. It's better to just use cheap clones and boosts. I only use EQ and boost now. !!!!TOP TRICK!!!! - skip OD pedals, and invest in a compressor, some modulation and a good octaver. That will give you a massive room to shape your tone.
great job bro! as accurate and informative as possible! and yet the 808 & SD-1 remain classic. in the first, the middle is a little failed and the lower middle is strengthened, while in the second it is the opposite - the middle protrudes and the lower middle is cut off. and then there are only options for a fleshy gibson SD-1 and a white wood 808, as if compensating for the tonal color ... well, you need a bunch with an amplifier! BUT - the middle register cuts the mix and reads the instrument in a pack, and this is the law ...
To me, eq has more bit higher abundant resolution in all frequnecy. Mud killer makes bit tighter however all sounds are great
Although I like the SD-1 as a boost before Marshall style amps with the Dual Rectifier it just sounded harsh, same was true for the Electric Eye Mud Killer. In this test the OD808 sounds the best followed by the Soul Food. I prefer using the MXR GT-OD with Rectifier series amps though.
More great content. Would you be able to make a future video on how you mix your guitars? Would love a bit more insight into how you capture your sounds
These days I almost don't mix my guitars aside from reverb and delay. I do cut some low end under 80hz ish usually but I don't often use any eq or compression. Just good amp settings and a great IR. If those combinations are good you won't need to do much other than play tight with a good sounding guitar
Sonic Drive Studio awesome, simple but effective techniques are always handy to know
I like the 808 in front of Marshals and the SD-1 boosting Rectifiers.
would love if you can get your hands on a MB Triaxis. Have actual one here and hate it. Perhaps i am more into Marshall, but on the other hand the Rectifier has that distorted top end what i like and miss with the Triaxis.
that's one of the best looking ESP guitars i've seen. what year model is that? BTW you should have tried the Mesa Flux Five pedal in front. I use one in front of my Mark Five 25 and it sounds incredible.
The tone of the SD-1 with the bottom of the Soul Food would do it for me.
AWESOME vídeo!!! E standard?
Soul Food the surprising winner for me. It leaves a slight amount of the low end in tact but not enough to make it flubby making it sound more full plus seemed to have more mids
I got the EHX East River drive. It's a good pedal and it's not priced too high
Nice Intwine poster!
I would prefer rectifier boost with the eq...sounds better compare with others od..
Awsome!!!!
I think I liked the maxon the best, I usually use a Tc nova drive for midi capabilities
Great sound ! What tuning do you use?
Awesome, good job with the weight loss too
Wait a fucking second, you were in Intwine! That was a badass band back in the day!
The SD1 and the EQ sounded the best. I love to use a boss GE7 EQ to boost my 20w JCM800, it allows to exactly choose the frequencies to enhance. Is the MXR 10 band noisy when used as a boost? Did you use any kind of noise suppression/gate for the recording?
Great comparison, thank you! It’s really interesting how the SD1 made the double tracked guitar sound wider apart than the other pedals. Must be some kind of mid/side effect happening with the lack of low-end
They're all great but one thing that I always take away is how classic and effective the Boss SD-1 still sounds and you can find them as low as 60 bucks!
Great video. I know everyone uses IR's but I feel like IR's make everything sound good. I really love the demo's when it is just a simple SM57 set up. Or do you find IR's really are that good at replicating what you would get out of a mic? I ask as when I look to get an amp I am skeptical if the demo is with IR's. Cheers dude
No need to be skeptical of IRs. They can perfectly replicate the sound of real mics on a cab
all boxes are great. Which to choose is personal taste. I personally prefer maxon because giuve to me creamy sound and in the mix mesa sounding very good.
I think i dont know! Its really hard to choose one. But I think I liked more the Maxon!