nothing can top the original studio version, but this comes close and is cool for other reasons. David not only giving the backing singers their moment in the spotlight, but him turning to watch and listen in such a respectful and appreciative way. I love watching this.
In music, this is simply called an interpretation (a "cover version"), a second edition; these three ladies take creative inspiration from Clare Torry's original, first edition. It can also be considered a musical "variation on a theme": a lyrical song with no words.
Vorrei andare un po controcorrente, anch'io adoro la versione originale, veramente inarrivabile, voglio dire talmente inarrivabile che persino la sua creatrice è mai riuscita ad eguagliare dal vivo Nessuna delle sue performance live che circolano in rete mi entusiasma, mentre qui Sam Brown mi fa venire i brividi, così come Dourga e Claudia
This is my first time hearing this song and wow I am blown away by the fact that it was just someone just singing that was just incredible and amazing.
Is this your first experience with this song or with Pink Floyd in general? If it's with Pink Floyd in general, then welcome to the rabbit hole. Prepare to discover a unique and extraordinary world.
@@thepragmatic6383 no, my first experience with this song I know who Pink Floyd is I mean, I know another brick in the wall I know who believe me I know who Pink Floyd is. There’s just a few songs there is that I haven’t heard but also I might’ve heard when I was younger, but might not remember.
When you´re the greatest band in the world, you´ve got the best background singers. Sam Brown (the blonde) was a well known singer in the 80ies (had a hit called STOP!), but also background singer for Pink Floyd, David Gilmour, Jon Lord, Deep Purple, Black, Gary Moore, George Harrison, Fish and others.
Some people say that this is supposed to represent in raw emotion the transitions into leaving life, the stages of dying, starting with denial, anger, fear, resistance and finally acceptance, and some say it isn't, the original recording on the album was done by one Lady Claire Torrie, she did it pretty much in one take when recorded, these Ladies do a fine job with this concert version too, Thanks for sharing and looking forward to hearing what you decide to do next, God Bless.
Sam Brown had numerous top ten singles and albums back in the day. Daughter of Joe Brown the 50s pop singer. She was George Harrisons ukulele partner and family friend. Sang Horse to Water at George's memorial concert.
I should imagine that listening to hip-hop and rap after listening to bands like Floyd is like driving is like driving a Ford Fiesta after driving a Bentley Continental GT.
Floyd giving their backing singers their deserved time in the spotlight. On the original album version 1 lady Clair Torry ( a session singer) was called in and paid £30 she recorded all in 2.5 takes then felt she would only be repeating stuff so went home. Much later after she discovered they used her takes on the album and a little legal wrangling she got Co-writer credits and rightly so. Some prefer the album version some prefer this live version. To me they are both equally astounding. Pink Floyd’s keyboard player passed away not long ago but one of these wonderful ladies sang this track at his funeral as per his request.( if I’m missed any important details please feel free to add them )
Shine on You Crazy Diamond- all parts, studio version from Wish you were here. Time from Dark Side of the Moon. Actually, the whole album. Run Like Hell from the Wall.
First 😂 The stages of life and death without saying a word. Chilling and amazing when I saw them live. Led Zeppelin Stairway to heaven live from MSG in 1973 please 🙏. Great reaction as usual my friend and Peace out 🙏 ✌️ ☮️
Try the live in Pompeii version 1971 with Pink Floyd doing "careful with that axe Eugene"!! You'll get to see the all-time scream in rock music from Rodger Waters the main Lyricist for Pink Floyd until he quit in 1985 before the Pulse concert.
Awesome 👏🏻 This one is quite special. If you haven’t heard Run Like Hell, Hey You, or Shine On You Crazy Diamond - or even if you’ve heard them, this concert is worth the watch. Also, I mentioned this before but if you do Time, highly recommend the orig recording.
The 1st singer is Sam Brown, daughter of 60`s singer Joe Brown MBE , who still sings and has his own UA-cam channel. She is/ was a singer songwriter and has 8 albums out , A good interview with her here . ua-cam.com/video/eNg73HzoiDU/v-deo.html
Oh yeah. Also, if you ever go back and listen to the original recording of this song, it’s sung by one woman. Her name is Claire but dang it I don’t recall her last name. She was amazing!!
Music wriyyen by Rick Wright ( Keys) for a movie > the director didn't like it. The band put it on DSOTM . got a session singer Claire Torrie who did her own thing in 2 1/2 takes. She didn't think they like it until she heard it on the radio.
I highly recommend you listen to the original recording of this now! Then react to Shine on you crazy Diamond. Then Echoes. And for something different - Nobody, Ratrace or Warning by Skindred
The original version by Clare Torey was a one of a kind she did it two takes one of them things that just cannot be repeated ever but the live version from the three girls probably comes as close as you can get they did an excellent job live listen to the original off the concept album dark side of the moon 1973 and you will see why in fact as with a lot of Floyds music listen to the whole album each track enhances each other they all flow into each other like chapters in a book
Go and listen to the recorded version with the vocals by Clare Torry. That is the best version and she did it in the studio just on her own. It is amazing. I used to get chills listening. It is like birth and death and every emotion through a lifetime. No disrespect to the backup singers, but the original from Dark Side of the Moon is perfect.
@@justm9892 I know, I literally haven't listened to anything else but Ren, The Big Push and Chinchilla and anything he does with other people for ages, can't get enough of him🤣🤣
Great reaction Prada! You earned a new subscriber! If possible, please react to Brain Damage / Eclipse (both songs are "linked") from this same live show, they're awesome! Who would believe that Pulse show happened 30 years ago already... In my opinion, the best live show ever. Cheers from Argentina!
First singer blows you out of the house and then the other two pile on top. I always thought first singer was the best of any to perform this as she has the full sound and visual delivery.
Listen to the studio version. And be blown away by the original singer Clare Torry. That was recorded in 2 takes. This live version is good, but nothing compared to the original. In fact you should probably listen to the full Dark side of the moon album (1973). That will tell you all about who Pink Floyd were. (And then Animals, Meddle)
Tre bravissime coriste come DURGA MC BROOM, SAM BROWN E CLAUDIA FONTAINE ci sono volute ...ma la perfezione è solo nella unica voce originale CLARE TORRY 🔝🔝🔝
Have you reacted to Stevie Ray Vaughn "Texas Flood" live at El Mocombo? If not it's a must see! Also The Edgar Winter Group "Frankenstein" Live at the Old Gray Whistle Test I think it's from 1973.
I hope when you have done your reactions to Pink Floyd you allow yourself time to lay backand listen to Darkside of the moon eginning to end. Its a trip no drugs needed just float away.
Pink Floyd "Echoes (Part 1)" live at Pompeii 1972 No Audience, No Lights, No Pyrotechnics just Gods playing to the Gods (def pick the Part 1 as the full track is really really long so for reaction purposes do Part 1)
The singer is Sam Brown. The song has no lyrics. It is the singers are conveying their feelings about death. This is maximum level performance of this song. Keep in mind the ladies only have one take to perform this song. Pink Floyd tries to give everyone performing at this c😂concert their moment in the spotlight.
Im sure you already know that The Dark Side Of The Moon is a concept album where the message flows from one song through to the next. TIME & The Great Gig end side one, but are really 2 very different parts of the one song. Our own personal TIME ends with The Great Gig. The best version is the original with the vocals of Clare Torre, who created the vocals and melody on the spot and in one take.......dont listen to the trolls who claim it was more than one take. Unfortunately, all the current CD's and videos are digitally remastered and edited.....the latest have even removed the brilliant final notes of death completely. .............. probably considered not politically correct to hear the brilliant vocals of passing on.
Why, why why have you not done Sorrow yet?!? Dude... I'm telling ya... turn the bass up, turn the volume waaayy up, and deal with replacing all the pictures on the walls later...
-The Great Gig In The Sky.... Death. This is the emotional ride, anger, denial, acceptance, no words needed just raw emotion.
3 amazing voices singing what one amazing voice Clare Torry originally sang.
At first I was against it … but I’ve come to appreciate the live version as the years go by
nothing can top the original studio version, but this comes close and is cool for other reasons. David not only giving the backing singers their moment in the spotlight, but him turning to watch and listen in such a respectful and appreciative way. I love watching this.
Then we can be friends ;)
In music, this is simply called an interpretation (a "cover version"), a second edition; these three ladies take creative inspiration from Clare Torry's original, first edition. It can also be considered a musical "variation on a theme": a lyrical song with no words.
I always love Claudia's smile at the end as she backs out of the light. She knows she nailed it.
They burn it down with live SORROW. Unbelievable intro/outro, and David arguably at the most of his talent with the solo.
Sam had the choice of a world tour as the biggest pop star on the planet. Or this. She should be so proud of her decision.
Woah, I never knew this!
The best band in the world gets the best backup singers in the world.
Vorrei andare un po controcorrente, anch'io adoro la versione originale, veramente inarrivabile, voglio dire talmente inarrivabile che persino la sua creatrice è mai riuscita ad eguagliare dal vivo
Nessuna delle sue performance live che circolano in rete mi entusiasma, mentre qui Sam Brown mi fa venire i brividi, così come Dourga e Claudia
@@martinm1231 Don't aggree.
Clare Torrey did it first, not necessarily the best.
This is my first time hearing this song and wow I am blown away by the fact that it was just someone just singing that was just incredible and amazing.
Is this your first experience with this song or with Pink Floyd in general?
If it's with Pink Floyd in general, then welcome to the rabbit hole.
Prepare to discover a unique and extraordinary world.
@@thepragmatic6383 no, my first experience with this song I know who Pink Floyd is I mean, I know another brick in the wall I know who believe me I know who Pink Floyd is. There’s just a few songs there is that I haven’t heard but also I might’ve heard when I was younger, but might not remember.
No clue how many times I have heard this, both this and the studio version, but likely hundreds and it never gets old.
Check out "Shine On You Crazy Diamond 1-5" and prepare to be blown away. Studio version first please.
Parts 6 to 9 are even better. Studio version!
When you´re the greatest band in the world, you´ve got the best background singers. Sam Brown (the blonde) was a well known singer in the 80ies (had a hit called STOP!), but also background singer for Pink Floyd, David Gilmour, Jon Lord, Deep Purple, Black, Gary Moore, George Harrison, Fish and others.
The original singer to this song is Claire Torrey . It took 3 singers to do what she did because of how much stamina it took to sing the song .
Some people say that this is supposed to represent in raw emotion the transitions into leaving life, the stages of dying, starting with denial, anger, fear, resistance and finally acceptance, and some say it isn't, the original recording on the album was done by one Lady Claire Torrie, she did it pretty much in one take when recorded, these Ladies do a fine job with this concert version too, Thanks for sharing and looking forward to hearing what you decide to do next, God Bless.
Now we're entering the real magic of Pink Floyd. The 1970's. Dive in.
The original studio version is the sickest thing ever and I believe the single vocalist did it in one take then didn’t get royalty for years
Led Zeppelin LIVE In my Time of Dying!!!! In 1975 at Earl’s Court. Fab
Sam Brown had numerous top ten singles and albums back in the day. Daughter of Joe Brown the 50s pop singer. She was George Harrisons ukulele partner and family friend. Sang Horse to Water at George's memorial concert.
I should imagine that listening to hip-hop and rap after listening to bands like Floyd is like driving is like driving a Ford Fiesta after driving a Bentley Continental GT.
Gotta see sorrow and shine on you crazy diamond from this concert
Floyd giving their backing singers their deserved time in the spotlight. On the original album version 1 lady Clair Torry ( a session singer) was called in and paid £30 she recorded all in 2.5 takes then felt she would only be repeating stuff so went home. Much later after she discovered they used her takes on the album and a little legal wrangling she got Co-writer credits and rightly so. Some prefer the album version some prefer this live version. To me they are both equally astounding. Pink Floyd’s keyboard player passed away not long ago but one of these wonderful ladies sang this track at his funeral as per his request.( if I’m missed any important details please feel free to add them )
Clare Torry sued Pink Floyd later to get a share of the rights. I think she won that case.
Shine on You Crazy Diamond- all parts, studio version from Wish you were here. Time from Dark Side of the Moon. Actually, the whole album. Run Like Hell from the Wall.
Sam Brown was a singer in her own right, pink Floyd ask her to do the tour with them.
Love it absolutely amazing ❤
First 😂 The stages of life and death without saying a word. Chilling and amazing when I saw them live. Led Zeppelin Stairway to heaven live from MSG in 1973 please 🙏. Great reaction as usual my friend and Peace out 🙏 ✌️ ☮️
What a voices....❤
Try the live in Pompeii version 1971 with Pink Floyd doing "careful with that axe Eugene"!! You'll get to see the all-time scream in rock music from Rodger Waters the main Lyricist for Pink Floyd until he quit in 1985 before the Pulse concert.
Keep up the great work MrvWest I love your reviews ❤ !
Awesome 👏🏻 This one is quite special.
If you haven’t heard Run Like Hell, Hey You, or Shine On You Crazy Diamond - or even if you’ve heard them, this concert is worth the watch. Also, I mentioned this before but if you do Time, highly recommend the orig recording.
The 1st singer is Sam Brown, daughter of 60`s singer Joe Brown MBE , who still sings and has his own UA-cam channel.
She is/ was a singer songwriter and has 8 albums out , A good interview with her here .
ua-cam.com/video/eNg73HzoiDU/v-deo.html
Thanks! I just watched and I thought it was going to end badly, but technology helped her get back to making music in a completely different way.
Dude! You have gone down a great rabbit hole! Off screen, watch The Wall after having some treats :) God Bless!
Since you are starting to feel it. Check out echoes live at Pompeii.
That, basically will be your intro to pink floyd.
Love your reactions, the 3 backing singers in order are Sam brown derga mcbroom and claudia fontaine ! 🇬🇧
Wow!!! ❤
Still loving your reactions bro!!!
Way!! Backing singer
Sam, Durga and Claudia (RIP)
Sam Brown was a guest backing vocalist during the tour, you might remember her from a song called "Stop" tho might be a little before your time 😅 🇬🇧
And to think that initially, this song was only intended to fill the remaining space on the A side of the album.
❤❤❤❤
Please also check out "Sorrow" live in Venice Italy 95. That is amazing!
Oh yeah. Also, if you ever go back and listen to the original recording of this song, it’s sung by one woman. Her name is Claire but dang it I don’t recall her last name. She was amazing!!
Try "Yours is No Disgrace" from the band YES, considered by many to be prog rock at its finest.
great reaction , theres loads more great songs from the pulse concert for you to
try, id recommend "MONEY" "US AND THEM"
Imo. The Great Gig In The Sky. On. Delicate Sound Of Thunder. Is by far the best version. Definitely should check it out.
Thanks for the recommendation! 🙏🏼
Music wriyyen by Rick Wright ( Keys) for a movie > the director didn't like it. The band put it on DSOTM . got a session singer Claire Torrie who did her own thing in 2 1/2 takes. She didn't think they like it until she heard it on the radio.
I highly recommend you listen to the original recording of this now!
Then react to Shine on you crazy Diamond. Then Echoes.
And for something different - Nobody, Ratrace or Warning by Skindred
Try listening to the original with Clair Tory doing all the vocals... mind blowing!
The original version by Clare Torey was a one of a kind she did it two takes one of them things that just cannot be repeated ever but the live version from the three girls probably comes as close as you can get they did an excellent job live listen to the original off the concept album dark side of the moon 1973 and you will see why in fact as with a lot of Floyds music listen to the whole album each track enhances each other they all flow into each other like chapters in a book
Blonde lady is Sam Brown...check out "stop' by her
Go and listen to the recorded version with the vocals by Clare Torry. That is the best version and she did it in the studio just on her own. It is amazing. I used to get chills listening. It is like birth and death and every emotion through a lifetime. No disrespect to the backup singers, but the original from Dark Side of the Moon is perfect.
I prefer the studio version but this live version is also fine
I recommend you the entire album Dark Side of the Moon.
Try Aja by Steely Dan. You won't be disappointed!
You need to check out Ren, he's amazing 😁
Oh good to see someone else who likes Ren.ive been stuck down that rabbit hole lol
@@justm9892 I've been down there for 4 years🤣
@kathleenswift7979 oh wow I've only been listening to him a few months.hes so talented it blows my mind
@@justm9892 I know, I literally haven't listened to anything else but Ren, The Big Push and Chinchilla and anything he does with other people for ages, can't get enough of him🤣🤣
@kathleenswift7979 😂 good to know its not just me then 😂 would have loved to see him at SGP.
Great reaction Prada! You earned a new subscriber! If possible, please react to Brain Damage / Eclipse (both songs are "linked") from this same live show, they're awesome! Who would believe that Pulse show happened 30 years ago already... In my opinion, the best live show ever. Cheers from Argentina!
And after this, they go right into money
First singer blows you out of the house and then the other two pile on top. I always thought first singer was the best of any to perform this as she has the full sound and visual delivery.
the first signer is Sam Brown '' stop '' is a must .
Do Sorrow from Pulse. It will blow your shoes off!
Sam Brown is the singer.amazing voice like her mum & dad Joe Brown.
🙋🏿♀️ May I suggest 'Shine on You crazy Diamond Pts 1-5'. Or if you're feeling adventurous 🤗 do Pts 6-9 too! 🥰🐰
The 3 ladies are amazing but I still prefer Clare Torry.
Basta !
Listen to the studio version. And be blown away by the original singer Clare Torry. That was recorded in 2 takes. This live version is good, but nothing compared to the original. In fact you should probably listen to the full Dark side of the moon album (1973). That will tell you all about who Pink Floyd were. (And then Animals, Meddle)
David is looking at her to let her know it's time to wrap it up. Great Reaction!
Tre bravissime coriste come DURGA MC BROOM, SAM BROWN E CLAUDIA FONTAINE ci sono volute ...ma la perfezione è solo nella unica voce originale CLARE TORRY 🔝🔝🔝
Have you reacted to Stevie Ray Vaughn "Texas Flood" live at El Mocombo? If not it's a must see! Also The Edgar Winter Group "Frankenstein" Live at the Old Gray Whistle Test I think it's from 1973.
I hope when you have done your reactions to Pink Floyd you allow yourself time to lay backand listen to Darkside of the moon eginning to end. Its a trip no drugs needed just float away.
You tube needs a heart up there not just a thumb...❤
Tripping music. Not that I would know.
Pink Floyd "Echoes (Part 1)" live at Pompeii 1972
No Audience, No Lights, No Pyrotechnics just Gods playing to the Gods
(def pick the Part 1 as the full track is really really long so for reaction purposes do Part 1)
The singer is Sam Brown. The song has no lyrics. It is the singers are conveying their feelings about death. This is maximum level performance of this song. Keep in mind the ladies only have one take to perform this song. Pink Floyd tries to give everyone performing at this c😂concert their moment in the spotlight.
listen to the studio version a different level of talent on displaay
Sam Brown
Im sure you already know that The Dark Side Of The Moon is a concept album where the message flows from one song through to the next.
TIME & The Great Gig end side one, but are really 2 very different parts of the one song.
Our own personal TIME ends with The Great Gig.
The best version is the original with the vocals of Clare Torre, who created the vocals and melody on the spot and in one take.......dont listen to the trolls who claim it was more than one take.
Unfortunately, all the current CD's and videos are digitally remastered and edited.....the latest have even removed the brilliant final notes of death completely. .............. probably considered not politically correct to hear the brilliant vocals of passing on.
echoes live pompei xD :D
Sam Brown is the singer.
Hey man check Tool - The pot you will like it
Why, why why have you not done Sorrow yet?!? Dude... I'm telling ya... turn the bass up, turn the volume waaayy up, and deal with replacing all the pictures on the walls later...
I have my friend
I look forward to seeing it, as it has yet to appear on your channel...
I think you just learned the value of doing a little research before listening to a Floyd song bro!😊
Social Destortion
Instrumental? Are there any vocals in it? Oh man.... 🤦🤦♂🤦♀🤦♂🤦🤦♂🤦♀
Parla meno
Smoking maybe….more like sit back and drop lots of acid music…..
Domination by Pantera LIVE in Moscow 1991