Mr. Anchor Raza, Very very good talk show with Dr. Ishtiak Ahmed ji. In your next session please enquire from Dr. Sahib about the fate of Muslim leaders who were opposed to the formation of Pakistan, but were forced by circumstances to migrate to Pakistan. Great Badshah Khan was among them. Thanks.
Who is the most benificiary of partition of India??? The British Imperialism who acted divide and rule. The common man in both countries India and Pak got nothing but insult, helplessness, poverty, disgrace, religious and national extremism and hatred. Feudalists, capitalists, religious dogmas and establishment on both sides have been enjoying freedom in all spectrums of luxury and comfort but at the expense of common man, no matter he is Hindu or Muslim.There seems no light at the end of tunnel unfortunately.
History is what actually happened. It is only acceptable if supported by credible and verifiable evidence. It cannot be changed according to the whims and fancy of some individuals as we are witnessing in this podcast. Unfortunately, there is widespread ignorance about our own history which allows motivated characters and TV channels to try and rewrite it. There are scores of highly authentic and extremely well-researched books by well-known historians that explain in true and fascinating detail, supported by impeccable references, why and how India came to be divided. Included among them are Alex Von Tunzelmann ('Indian Summer'), Patrick French ('Liberty or Death'), Lawrence James ('The Raj'), Stanley Wolpert (‘Shameful Filgh’), Andrew Roberts ('Eminent Churchillians'), Ayesha Jalal (‘The Sole Spokesman’). Unwary readers are strongly urged to take a look at these and not go by the motivated storytelling in questionable publications and TV programmes.
Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah (Chair) Nawabzada Liaquat Ali Khan (Secretary) Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan (Premier of the Punjab) Sir Shahnawaz Khan Mamdot (local host) Raja Sahib of Mahmudabad Maulvi A.K. Fazlul Huq Sir Abdullah Haroon Al-Hajj Sir Khawaja Nazimuddin Amjadi Bano Begum Maulana Mohammad Akram Khan Chaudhry Khaliquzzaman Nawab Mohammad Ismail Khan Sir Currimbhoy Ebrahim Ali Muhammad Khan Dehlvi Qazi Muhammad Essa Sardar Aurangzeb Khan Abdul Mateen Chauhdry Ashiq Mohamed Warsi Haji Abdus Sattar Essak Saith S. M. Sharif Syed Abdul Rauf Shah Mohammad Latif ur Rahman Abdur Rahman Siddiqui Malik Barkat Ali Sadullah Khan Umarzaib
So can we have a session about this subject without the mentioning of Sir Chaudhry Zafrullah Khan? So even an academic is teaching us history through sectarian filters 🤷♀️ Not a mention about the Ahmadiyya connection for freedom❗
پاکستان بن گیا ہزاروں لوگ مر کھپ گئے ارے بھائی اس پاکستان کو بچاو نا کہ فضول باتیں کرو ابھی تمھارا حال روہنگیا، کشمیر یا فلسطین جیسا حال ہوتا تو پتا پڑتا
Sir seyad zafrullah khan sahib k Bina is tareekh ka koi matlub nhe yai Qraardad unho nay heikhi or leqat ali Bay Parhi sabk samny bani Asal ka name lene main Q atkleef hoti unka ziker Q nhe etna kiya jata sirf es liye k unka mazhab kuch tha had hai wese etni choti soch pe
Dr. Ishtiaq has rewritten our political history. He is a genuine scholar. May he live long
Honest historian with serious anchor. Good job by both.
amazing job by naya daur .. hats off to Dr. Ishtiaq sb. for his researches.👍
Great Doctor Ishtiaq sahib
Excellent discussion with Dr Ishtiaq.
Dr ishtiaq a learned historian from whom one learns z lot. During my visit to sweden I missed him. I look forward to a meeting with him. Dawago
Mr. Anchor Raza,
Very very good talk show with Dr. Ishtiak Ahmed ji. In your next session please enquire from Dr. Sahib about the fate of Muslim leaders who were opposed to the formation of Pakistan, but were forced by circumstances to migrate to Pakistan. Great Badshah Khan was among them.
Thanks.
He was forced by Congress, not by Pakistan.
Invite Hussain Haqqani also
Great job, Ali Raza...
The man was Share Bangale Abul Kashem Fazlul Hoque .
1946 me amend Kia tha. Word States ko amend karke State Kia gaya.
واعلیکم السلام
Who is the most benificiary of partition of India???
The British Imperialism who acted divide and rule. The common man in both countries India and Pak got nothing but insult, helplessness, poverty, disgrace, religious and national extremism and hatred. Feudalists, capitalists, religious dogmas and establishment on both sides have been enjoying freedom in all spectrums of luxury and comfort but at the expense of common man, no matter he is Hindu or Muslim.There seems no light at the end of tunnel unfortunately.
Thnx GOD jinnah only got one year and in one year he did 6 major blunders if he lives more then 🇵🇰 must end in his own life.
Jinah was English puppy, biggest stupid
nice wow
23 March Constitution Day
Please discuss the reality of Congress government 1937 to 1939. Is it a cruel stage for Muslim or it's just a rumors.
Please
Mr, Dr qrardadadre Pakistan was written by ch. Zafrullah Khan not by chauhdry Rahmet Ali,,,
History is what actually happened. It is only acceptable if supported by credible and verifiable evidence. It cannot be changed according to the whims and fancy of some individuals as we are witnessing in this podcast. Unfortunately, there is widespread ignorance about our own history which allows motivated characters and TV channels to try and rewrite it.
There are scores of highly authentic and extremely well-researched books by well-known historians that explain in true and fascinating detail, supported by impeccable references, why and how India came to be divided. Included among them are Alex Von Tunzelmann ('Indian Summer'), Patrick French ('Liberty or Death'), Lawrence James ('The Raj'), Stanley Wolpert (‘Shameful Filgh’), Andrew Roberts ('Eminent Churchillians'), Ayesha Jalal (‘The Sole Spokesman’). Unwary readers are strongly urged to take a look at these and not go by the motivated storytelling in questionable publications and TV programmes.
I have listen a completely different narrative about this yesterday
@2:02 is that sheikh mujeeb ?
Pakistan movement ka critically analysis kren videos men
Iqbal nain kisi azad muslam state ka Tasawaar nain diya tha 1930 wali bat belkul galat hai
ASSLLAM Allakum
Good comment hay
Who drafted the resolution?
Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah (Chair)
Nawabzada Liaquat Ali Khan (Secretary)
Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan (Premier of the Punjab)
Sir Shahnawaz Khan Mamdot (local host)
Raja Sahib of Mahmudabad
Maulvi A.K. Fazlul Huq
Sir Abdullah Haroon
Al-Hajj Sir Khawaja Nazimuddin
Amjadi Bano Begum
Maulana Mohammad Akram Khan
Chaudhry Khaliquzzaman
Nawab Mohammad Ismail Khan
Sir Currimbhoy Ebrahim
Ali Muhammad Khan Dehlvi
Qazi Muhammad Essa
Sardar Aurangzeb Khan
Abdul Mateen Chauhdry
Ashiq Mohamed Warsi
Haji Abdus Sattar Essak Saith
S. M. Sharif
Syed Abdul Rauf Shah
Mohammad Latif ur Rahman
Abdur Rahman Siddiqui
Malik Barkat Ali
Sadullah Khan Umarzaib
@@vinamrasinghai2339 What happened to the main charachter: Sir Chaudhry Zafrullah Khan 👎
This 🇵🇰 didn't absorb Chaudhri Rehmat Ali and he left 🇵🇰 in few months.
raza saab CIA sy kitny pasy lety ho
Secularism k swa ab koi or rasta nain
So can we have a session about this subject without the mentioning of Sir Chaudhry Zafrullah Khan? So even an academic is teaching us history through sectarian filters 🤷♀️ Not a mention about the Ahmadiyya connection for freedom❗
پاکستان بن گیا ہزاروں لوگ مر کھپ گئے ارے بھائی اس پاکستان کو بچاو نا کہ فضول باتیں کرو ابھی تمھارا حال روہنگیا، کشمیر یا فلسطین جیسا حال ہوتا تو پتا پڑتا
That was objective resolution and it's not about 🇵🇰 resolution.
Iqbal jhina k shaheen dealing with IMF
Sir seyad zafrullah khan sahib k Bina is tareekh ka koi matlub nhe yai Qraardad unho nay heikhi or leqat ali Bay Parhi sabk samny bani Asal ka name lene main Q atkleef hoti unka ziker Q nhe etna kiya jata sirf es liye k unka mazhab kuch tha had hai wese etni choti soch pe
He is not a historian.
Jinnah was a short term opportunistic. His short sightedness is the current status of Pakistan.
So according to your logic Gandhi was shortsighted because he did not realize that India will become a right-wing nationalist state 🤐