In Islam every woman's family setting dowry price for their daughter, selling her in marriage as much as family can get and then some more, for education, beauty, virginity those extra bonuses, then they add extra for the future children, so the man is in debt till the rest of his life and if he decides to divorce her, he must pay huge amounts of money. Or they marry to close friends and relatives to keep all the wealth in the family. Then comes mutaa as prostitution method and everyone knows it, men usually do this in secret and every one denies it. In month of Ramadan many thousands of wealthy muslims traveling to Thailand and other non muslim areas as tourists to practice mutaa ))))
Raies Siddiqui ..Absolutely it is not allowed and violates what Allah (subhaanahu wata 'aalaa) has revealed.. It is mocking Islam and marriage..! It is Deception and cheating.. betrayal of trust and breaking oand violation of contracts..
.."...For one week or one month.. then it is problematic.. but if it is not mentioned in the contract.. then there is no harm" ..hmmm... however the question arises if it is in the intention to divorce after one hour.. one week.. or one month.. (as we know from the fatwa of sh. Ibn baz and other schools of thoughts) ..and the intentention is not explicitly mentioned but kept hidden "between you and Allah" (as stated in fatwa of sh. Ibn baz .. This is what is ALSO PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE IT IS MOCKING ISLAM AND IS DECEPTION AND BETRAYAL OF TRUST!!
God truly knows best, but to me they both sounds the same because the person has the intention of leaving their temporary partner from before.. after the Man/Woman needs to head back to home if he is traveling or living abroad so its alot like prostitution because their intention is only Casual mostly no strings attached sex lol..
assalamoalaikum bro i f u are urdu speaking then it is good shiekh jalaluddin qasmi in his lecture of tafseer para 5 which is recently uploaded he said in that nikah misyar is haram uploaded by caltotawheed or calltotawheed wallahu aalam
Qur'an only mentions praying 3 times but the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) taught us to pray 5 times. So does that mean just because it's not mentioned in the Qur'an I will only pray 3 times
@@holop100God has said in the Qur'an that our prophet doesn't speak on his own whim but only that which God wants him to speak and God has also commanded us to obey our prophet. Because disobedience to our prophet is disbelief. So even though it is not given in the Qur'an it is still valid. Also, Qur'an also doesn't speak about temporary marriage being permissible so that means one should also not defend it
But in misyaar there is intention to get divorced ...mutta has also.same condition .... Mentioning time limit or not mentionimg time limit Is not major difference
In a mut'a nikkah there is no divorce, as soon as the time limit expires the couple separates, there is no need for a divorce. The expiration date ends the marriage.
Sounds all terribly confusing. Two people want to be together and they consent, they don't have to marry. Two people want to marry, they consent, they share, they stay together. Two people want to end the relationship, they consent and go their seperate ways. Two married people are no longer happy in their marriage, they consent to a divorce, assets may or may not be shared. Married men and women are loyal to each other. Unmarried men and women are also loyal to each other if they want to be. Everyone can cheat....but this causes misery. Do we need sacred scriptures to work this all out?
Then why muslim abusing all the time to sex workers. They’re also doing the same job. This type of marriage is total joke no payment no security just to fulfil the desire of someone. I feel allowing sex workers in society at least ensure their rights and they have some type of social security.
@@comictube1831 you are talking rubbish Go and talk to the prostitutes in countries where this is regulated, their lives are still miserable.how can you even compare to have one long term partner to many in a day? The exposure to diseases and abuse multiplies!
They MUST marry,otherwise if the child is born from that relationship,the father doesnt have legal obligations for that child. Thats why number of fatherless children and single mothers is high in the West.
You dont know what misyar then. Muta is marry to divorce & without wali whereas misyar has to have wali & cant have intention to divorce which is haram. Huge difference.
It is now a good business in gulf countries. Women in gulf countries do masyaar and muta marriage for money. Means do nikah, do sex as much as possible for few days, months and then divorce. ☹️☹️☹️☹️
![Temporary Marriage [Summary] Sayed Jawad Qazwini](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qHQdBLP7BVo/mqdefault.jpg)
Neither muta nor misyar is allowed.... Both are modern form of adultery ... Both are illegal..
Acording to What?
In missiar they dont annouce publicly it is mostly secret as you said also no dowery so it is not allowed?
In Islam every woman's family setting dowry price for their daughter, selling her in marriage as much as family can get and then some more, for education, beauty, virginity those extra bonuses, then they add extra for the future children, so the man is in debt till the rest of his life and if he decides to divorce her, he must pay huge amounts of money. Or they marry to close friends and relatives to keep all the wealth in the family. Then comes mutaa as prostitution method and everyone knows it, men usually do this in secret and every one denies it. In month of Ramadan many thousands of wealthy muslims traveling to Thailand and other non muslim areas as tourists to practice mutaa ))))
Raies Siddiqui ..Absolutely it is not allowed and violates what Allah (subhaanahu wata 'aalaa) has revealed.. It is mocking Islam and marriage..! It is Deception and cheating.. betrayal of trust and breaking oand violation of contracts..
@@abunusaybahahmed2209 how if both parties agree ?
They announce it for sure. Dower iam not aware of it
They are a form of adultery
.."...For one week or one month.. then it is problematic.. but if it is not mentioned in the contract.. then there is no harm" ..hmmm... however the question arises if it is in the intention to divorce after one hour.. one week.. or one month.. (as we know from the fatwa of sh. Ibn baz and other schools of thoughts) ..and the intentention is not explicitly mentioned but kept hidden "between you and Allah" (as stated in fatwa of sh. Ibn baz .. This is what is ALSO PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE IT IS MOCKING ISLAM AND IS DECEPTION AND BETRAYAL OF TRUST!!
Who’s is this Sheikh? Great BAEKELLAH
God truly knows best, but to me they both sounds the same because the person has the intention of leaving their temporary partner from before..
after the Man/Woman needs to head back to home if he is traveling or living abroad so its alot like prostitution because their intention is only Casual mostly no strings attached sex lol..
assalamoalaikum bro i f u are urdu speaking then it is good shiekh jalaluddin qasmi in his lecture of tafseer para 5 which is recently uploaded he said in that nikah misyar is haram uploaded by caltotawheed or calltotawheed wallahu aalam
No. You need two reputable witnesses.
What woman wants to marry for a week with no dowry and lose her virginity
a good women lmao xD
Virgins are allowed to do it.
Just the widows.
That is Mutah
So.there is not time limit in misyaar right ???
Absolutely no limit.....if there is time limit it's zina , Nikah is not valid
What is the name of this escolar sheikh?
Istagferulah istagferulah istagferulah allah give you Hedayeh ya Arab.
If muta was canceled it should be in the Quran.
Qur'an only mentions praying 3 times but the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) taught us to pray 5 times. So does that mean just because it's not mentioned in the Qur'an I will only pray 3 times
@@blackpink5937 Yes, because it means you are taking the words of man over the words of God
@@holop100God has said in the Qur'an that our prophet doesn't speak on his own whim but only that which God wants him to speak and God has also commanded us to obey our prophet. Because disobedience to our prophet is disbelief. So even though it is not given in the Qur'an it is still valid. Also, Qur'an also doesn't speak about temporary marriage being permissible so that means one should also not defend it
But in misyaar there is intention to get divorced ...mutta has also.same condition ....
Mentioning time limit or not mentionimg time limit Is not major difference
Watch the video again. Don't put your thoughts here.
In a mut'a nikkah there is no divorce, as soon as the time limit expires the couple separates, there is no need for a divorce. The expiration date ends the marriage.
Sounds all terribly confusing. Two people want to be together and they consent, they don't have to marry. Two people want to marry, they consent, they share, they stay together. Two people want to end the relationship, they consent and go their seperate ways. Two married people are no longer happy in their marriage, they consent to a divorce, assets may or may not be shared. Married men and women are loyal to each other. Unmarried men and women are also loyal to each other if they want to be. Everyone can cheat....but this causes misery. Do we need sacred scriptures to work this all out?
Then why muslim abusing all the time to sex workers. They’re also doing the same job. This type of marriage is total joke no payment no security just to fulfil the desire of someone.
I feel allowing sex workers in society at least ensure their rights and they have some type of social security.
@@comictube1831 you are talking rubbish
Go and talk to the prostitutes in countries where this is regulated, their lives are still miserable.how can you even compare to have one long term partner to many in a day? The exposure to diseases and abuse multiplies!
They MUST marry,otherwise if the child is born from that relationship,the father doesnt have legal obligations for that child. Thats why number of fatherless children and single mothers is high in the West.
Clear as mud.
Mutah is still allowed according to Sahih Muslim 1405. Shias still do it
Is this reference from rss school books?
Don't generalize the Shias, akhi. Very few Shias actually do it!😅
Is there an online Misyar?
Are you a muslim?
Misyar is an attraction for youths to become wahhabis.
Name sake muslims like you opt for halala, mutah, living relation and adultery .
Na na nathere is no divorce in muta marriage so dont lie
Form of prostitution. What woman wants to be marriedfoir a
You people have no problem with living relationships, adultery, mutah and halala
EVEN TODAY MUTA IS PRACTISED ALL OVER SAIDI ARABIA.MISHYAR IS PRACTISED WIDELY.
You dont know what misyar then. Muta is marry to divorce & without wali whereas misyar has to have wali & cant have intention to divorce which is haram. Huge difference.
@@gilabola4642 He is doing intentionally. World know only rafidah do mutah. This guy may be rafidah or their supporter
Accept IT , Sunni do IT to , ive Seen a Lot @@cresent1
Both are wrong.
Lol what a bunch of twisted lies
maka ka kuss
It is now a good business in gulf countries. Women in gulf countries do masyaar and muta marriage for money. Means do nikah, do sex as much as possible for few days, months and then divorce. ☹️☹️☹️☹️
LMFAO. Islam is full of confusion. For one sect muta is halal and misyar is not, for other wisversa 😂
HealthyLiving because your stupid
If you are christian, try first figuring out the anonymous authors of the gospels.
If Muslim, we look at evidences, then apply in life