In Defence of the Minecraft Mob Vote...

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 80

  • @chf76
    @chf76 Рік тому +3

    Nice to see a different perspective on this. More videos please!

  • @bradhp11
    @bradhp11 Рік тому +12

    my idea to change the mob vote is to have the 2 loser mobs be added to next year's mob vote, and only have 1 new mob added to the options. That way, every mob ALWAYS has a garunteed chance of being added, and mojang doesn't have to haphazardly rush adding 3 mobs to the game.

    • @Lturtle_
      @Lturtle_ Рік тому +1

      Oh my god, finally someone with the same mindset as me. nobody gets this but I think it's the best idea. Even if they remove one mob if it loses 3 times

    • @afly8983
      @afly8983 Рік тому +1

      Terrible idea, it'll get repetetive and people which didnt like the losing mobs will almost be forced to vote the new mob. A better idea is have a mob vote with 3 new mobs and another vote at the same time for the losing mobs.

    • @Lturtle_
      @Lturtle_ Рік тому

      @@afly8983 not really, most of the time people are torn between two mobs, even if that isn't the case, most people liked another mob, sniffer and rascal, allay and Copper golem, glowsquid (not that anyone other than dream liked it) and moobloom. That's where my if a mob loses 3 times it's gone idea comes in, things like the tuff golem most likely will never get added, same with the glare

    • @bradhp11
      @bradhp11 Рік тому

      @@afly8983 then how about only the runner up gets brought to next year’s vote (with the lowest voted mob being brought back to the ideas library). there’s still a large portion of the audience that doesn’t want these mobs to be gone indefinitely.

  • @MiccDev
    @MiccDev Рік тому +5

    By technicality, the frog is and example of pushing mobs till later. It was a mob vote mob, didn't win, now it's in the game!

  • @merkoo7
    @merkoo7 Рік тому +3

    Fully agree. I love the mob vote, but there is no reason to come up with 3 great ideas only to allow 1 of them to ever be implemented. So just let us choose what comes out first. Or even maybe how a certain mob would work. Like say they only added 1 mob but we could choose between 3 different drops.

  • @NotQuite_Frogg
    @NotQuite_Frogg Рік тому +7

    I’m so glad somebody finally said this.

  • @therandomjoshua
    @therandomjoshua Рік тому +21

    This is a breath of fresh air given what I've seen regarding the mob vote this year haha. Never thought about how they could change up the mob vote! having that mystery mob idea sounds pretty cool. Personally, I'd like a year where instead of a new mob being added, the community voted on a mob to receive more functionality and features.

  • @Jamie__ASMR
    @Jamie__ASMR Рік тому +8

    Hey that's my voice

  • @FazBallzz
    @FazBallzz Рік тому +2

    ty for informing everyone ignoring the actual problems at hand, love you

  • @SebbyDoesStuff
    @SebbyDoesStuff Рік тому +4

    This video deserves more recognition! I completely agree with what your saying and believe that somebody at mojang needs to watch this.

  • @nolangerrans6083
    @nolangerrans6083 Рік тому +2

    I totally agree that they need to shake up the mob votes more. I also really wish they made it more clear that the mobs aren’t gone forever. The overly serious way the community views this always kind of frustrates me when the vote is clearly just a small bonus thing to drum up hype. None of the winners or losers have ever been major additions. They’re all just side content that’s supposed to be for our enjoyment. Adding all three mobs at once would just take developer time and attention away from the main update that I care about way more. People act like mojang developers are just sitting around all day and not working on the boring behind the scenes stuff that actually makes the game run

  • @listenhererellati
    @listenhererellati Рік тому +4

    Yeah, pretty much agree with everything...the only thing that would be nice of mojang if they said to the community something in the lines of "the mob vote is a little gift we present to you and it shouldn't be viewed in the sence of something incredibly important/something that we owe you, or something that can potentially change how the game should be played. It's just a little feature that makes the next update a little bit more exciting".

  • @melonpop_5303
    @melonpop_5303 Рік тому +2

    what i want is for all 3 mobs to be added in favor of other mechanics and content, even if that content was better, because it's content we don't get to see. we don't get to feel the pain of them taking away, say, automated crafting in favor of the penguin, because we don't know that automated crafting was going to happen, and thus we don't feel the pain of 'losing' a feature that people have requested since the start of time.

  • @MurcGnilrits
    @MurcGnilrits Рік тому +19

    FINALLY someone that's reasonable. The mob vote is awesome!

    • @scrappymations1537
      @scrappymations1537 Рік тому +2

      I agree that the mob vote can be fun but the way they announce the mob is a bit annoying. I think they should at least explain what the mob does a little better

    • @Ethan_Cubed
      @Ethan_Cubed Рік тому

      @@scrappymations1537 thats exactly what they did this year

    • @scrappymations1537
      @scrappymations1537 Рік тому +1

      @@Ethan_Cubed not really we don’t know if dog armour can be upgraded to iron diamond etc they don’t say if the crab claw allows you to break blocks from a distance and they don’t explain if penguins boost boats above land

    • @Terminid_Brood_Emperor
      @Terminid_Brood_Emperor Рік тому

      It makes 2/3rds of the community mad

    • @DraperStan23
      @DraperStan23 Рік тому +1

      @@Ethan_Cubedtwo extra sentences to the description of a mob is not a proper explanation of their usage.

  • @Im.Rae.
    @Im.Rae. Рік тому +8

    We need to get this guy verified

  • @Anonymous-ks1pn
    @Anonymous-ks1pn Рік тому +1

    I like the idea of biome vote style mob vote. where you vote on mobs taht are already in the game to be upgraded.

  • @enzo-lh2iz
    @enzo-lh2iz Рік тому +1

    The only complaint I have is what about the old mobs? Will we ever see them again or are we guaranteeing that we won't see the losers ever in the game. Other than that I really like the mob vote and think its exciting. I just wish minecraft put more resources into their game for how massive it is. I understand it's difficult with their system but something should be worked out to simplify the process. Hiring more employees, reallocating resources, or anything that makes it easier for mojang to focus on more ideas rather than hyperfocusing on one small feature. But at the end of the day I'm not an expert so I don't know. Im happy with whatever they release honestly

  • @JamesterIsDivergent
    @JamesterIsDivergent Рік тому +4

    It’s not that the mob vote itself is bad, the concept is great, the execution is terrible. People ask for things for years, just for mojang to give the options between them, the others never coming back to the game again.
    I saw a good idea someone proposed:
    There be 2 mob votes per year
    1 for a new selection of 3 mobs
    1 for a past mob
    Therefore losing a mob vote doesn’t mean that a hugely requested feature will never release

    • @M00N_IVY
      @M00N_IVY Рік тому

      Exactly my thoughts as well :)

  • @Im.Rae.
    @Im.Rae. Рік тому +3

    I like this episode good job. It was only three minutes on this video so i cant really put three comments like i usually do so im just putting bullshit instead of, WOW I like this video

    • @VaguelyGood
      @VaguelyGood  Рік тому

      10 minute videos shall return soon :D

    • @Im.Rae.
      @Im.Rae. Рік тому

      Yea because i need to keep my three comment grind dude@@VaguelyGood

  • @Cubecly
    @Cubecly Рік тому +1

    This is litterally what ive been telling everyone. The mob vote is a method of promoting the game, and it works. it is only accelerated by all the people complaining about it. it may not be the best way to promote and could be improved thats what we should be fighting for, not to completely get rid of it.
    i think having a longer lasting game with more players is alway gonna be better than just adding one, two or even all three of these mobs into the game. espessially as they are all not that bad this year.

    • @EmperorPenguin1217
      @EmperorPenguin1217 Рік тому

      Getting rid of the vote is the only sensible option. The entire reason the longevity is being harmed is that the game is being flooded with filler that isn't cohesive and the controversies

  • @starbunny7301
    @starbunny7301 Рік тому +2

    I agree!

  • @Groved.
    @Groved. Рік тому +2

    lets eat some double cheesy burgers :]

  • @Leonagraphy
    @Leonagraphy Рік тому +3

    Agreed, it’s getting exhausting watching people screech at Mojang for the silliest reasons

  • @KaedenDunn-rv1hf
    @KaedenDunn-rv1hf 5 місяців тому

    My personal opinion is just save the losers till later, in more updates. that would probaly change the comunitys opinion on the mob vote...

  • @obsidian_citadel437
    @obsidian_citadel437 6 місяців тому

    I think Mojang should listen to their audience and add the three Mobs… …. ….. each from their OWN separate Mob Votes!!!
    (6 mobs lost instead of 2) 🔥👹🔥

  • @Im.Rae.
    @Im.Rae. Рік тому +1

    who are you voting for im going for the penguin

  • @Im.Rae.
    @Im.Rae. Рік тому +5

    I can completely agree with this because its a multimillion dollar company that cant make any mistakes in the code because bugs arent something they want, Also love the video and love your way you decide to change it (Like his video please also sub) (Feed his hunger of internet validation)

    • @Im.Rae.
      @Im.Rae. Рік тому +2

      We need more content its been so long father dont leave us so soon

    • @VaguelyGood
      @VaguelyGood  Рік тому

      new video by the end of the year! :D

  • @boxcat6341
    @boxcat6341 Рік тому +2

    And mine!

  • @joliebolie1026
    @joliebolie1026 Рік тому +4

    Finnaly someone who respects the mob vote, everyone hates on Mojang, i dont even know why, but they put a lot of work in the mobs, like this video and subscribe so that more people see this video.

    • @EmperorPenguin1217
      @EmperorPenguin1217 Рік тому

      Yeah a lot of work, as in a useless mob who's functions could be transferred to a pre existing mob

  • @MarkIsAwesome
    @MarkIsAwesome 5 місяців тому

    It Gave Armaddilo!

  • @stevefilms1997
    @stevefilms1997 Рік тому

    Ngl I don’t like any of the mobs, they are too weird and too few. It feels weirdly crowded yet not crowded they feel like mods, I don’t think they should be in the base game at all. Like what does the goat do is it just there, that’s the kind of thing you’d add a creatures mod. Although I guess that’s harder for bedrock players. The villager update was cool but there’s a certain point when your just like do we need an update, now I get that Microsoft possibly wants to eventually remove Java support so people have to play bedrock to get updates and then hope micro transactions help them make their money back. But there’s a certain point in a game where you add something and it subtracts from the game, this is honestly probably just me but when I see the archaeology update it just feels wrong it feels like it shouldn’t be there, like it should be a mod that is in some Jurassic modpack that is so big it makes your pc chug but hardly ever used on its own.

  • @Cinemaman_Editz2
    @Cinemaman_Editz2 Рік тому +1

    Hello

  • @Endy_3639
    @Endy_3639 Рік тому +1

    agreed

  • @309electronics5
    @309electronics5 Рік тому +1

    If you get more dislikes, remember its the whole community while you decide what you want so negate them

  • @Pienotpi
    @Pienotpi 6 місяців тому

    I wish mojang would polish less tbh it doesnt seem worth it to me.

    • @VaguelyGood
      @VaguelyGood  6 місяців тому

      Personally, I think a better game that took longer is more enjoyable than a rushed game that doesn't play well.

    • @Pienotpi
      @Pienotpi 6 місяців тому

      I agree I just mean don't spend 3 months pollishing the armadillo, it doesnt need that long. Generrally mods polish less and they turn out fine. (i get that thats a different situation but its similar enough imo)

  • @scrappymations1537
    @scrappymations1537 Рік тому +1

    Yeah I agree the mob vote isn’t terrible at the end of the day at least we are getting extra content. They are doing this for our own enjoyment they don’t have to do this if they wanted to. Most developers don’t even let the community participate in the game but I’m a bit sad cuz all these mobs this year are really good so idk what to vote for

  • @robbert1960
    @robbert1960 Рік тому +2

    Based

  • @the_Rampag3
    @the_Rampag3 Рік тому +3

    I have discovered you in my recommended page some time ago.I explored some of your videos and came to the conclusion you are a good content creator.Since then I enjoy your videos with great pleasure.I hope you will rise to the greatest because man oh man you make great vids.Keep up the great work,I'll keep on watching,I'll keep on comenting,and I'll take part of the journey you are in rigth now.I hope you will remember me and who knows,pin some of my comments😄.
    PS:Can't wait for next video

    • @VaguelyGood
      @VaguelyGood  Рік тому +1

      Thank you so much! Maybe one day you'll find yourself with a pinned comment 😁

    • @the_Rampag3
      @the_Rampag3 Рік тому

      I hope so!Keep up the great work you have a great fan here🤚

    • @Im.Rae.
      @Im.Rae. Рік тому

      Were is my pinned comment dude i want prommises for pinned comments thats rude considering ive been here longer (I am joking but i want validation for being here scince 15 subs)

  • @legendepizza
    @legendepizza Рік тому +2

    E

  • @kristapskrumins5676
    @kristapskrumins5676 Рік тому +1

    The mob votes are just kinda tiring, and just annoying to participate in since somebody can just tweet something and it's immediately rigged. It literally feels like voting in politics, and just like politics the choices this year are crap and boring.

    • @Im.Rae.
      @Im.Rae. Рік тому

      I cant legaly vote so ha screw yoy

    • @Im.Rae.
      @Im.Rae. Рік тому

      FUCK I SPELLED THAT WRONG **YOU**

    • @nickg5341
      @nickg5341 Рік тому

      “Voting in politics”

    • @scrappymations1537
      @scrappymations1537 Рік тому

      This years mob vote is actually good all the mobs are good choices and equal and it isn’t obvious who’s gonna win