Tareq, the quality of your work speaks for itself. Every detail was handled with such care and precision it’s clear how much effort you put into this. Kandari Chronicles just keeps getting better, and it's creators like you who keep raising the bar. Grateful for what you do keep it up!
I have been waiting for your commentary. Been a long time since your Ibn Khaldun request and I really was hoping that it tapped into what you expected from my side. It's always a challenge introducing a new angle to content as there is so much out there. I really appreciate your constant support for my channel and work and your kind words mean so much to me. I would like to hear what you enjoyed as well as what you didn't with this last content. Your thoughts are not only welcome but necessary for me to keep on moving upwards on this journey of creativity.
@@thekandarichronicles Tareq,You’ve managed to dissect Ibn Khaldun’s contributions to multiple disciplines in a way that bridges historical gaps and emphasizes the influence he had on future thinkers which people dont give him enough credit for. My only thought would be that perhaps diving a little deeper into specific examples of how his theories directly influenced later Western scholars would further cement the points you made. Overall, you’ve nailed it once again. This kind of content is why Kandari Chronicles is a favourite of mine.
Fantastic as always. I remember a few years ago I came across this lecturer who had researched the link between the Islamic scholars and the renaissance, which was fascinating, though there was a sad part and that is his lecture halls were almost empty. I hope you help break through the “resistance”.
That is sad. Guess we have to all have a hand in resisting the narrative and pushing back the huge momentum inaccurate western history has on its side.
@@thekandarichronicles The tides are very slowly changing and I see the use of “Western centric” in geopolitical comments more and more, which gives me hope. Change is hard, especially when the ego is at play but I have to say that the younger generation also gives me hope, they seem to have more goodness in them and more open than the previous ones, including my own which of course is ostracized and looked upon in the west as weak.
Change can be hard, but also once done its quick to recondition. Thats why the younger generations are able to move on from preconditioning more easily.
Thank you Fazli. I am really glad you are getting something out of the content. Please check out other videos and would love to hear your thoughts on those as well.
I would like to point out that Ancient Greece is actually an Eastern civilization, heavily influenced by the Babylonians and Egyptians. At the time, they would have regarded the West as a region of nomadic tribes. Furthermore, Greece did not play a role in the transformation of current Western civilization; instead, it was the empires that effectively exploited the New World, particularly the French and British.
There is definitely no blaming Ancient Greece by any means, but traditional textbooks would disagree with you on categorising that civilisation as Easter. On the contrary, civilisation like Babylonians and Mesopotamians are identified within Western Civilisation classes in high school.
I think the writings of Moses and the. Prophet's had this view long before any other historical narrative. I also think that many ideas of Jewish origin of the tanakh was borrowed and added its own conclusions, in their own writings in the Koran.
A famous book of Ibn Khaldun that’s still available and translated widely until today is ‘Muqaddimah’. A thick book about development of civilization. Also mentioned in this video.
So would it be fair to say that Ibn Khaldun wouldn't be the greatest advocate for racial/ethnic diversity within a society? It seems like he's describing the current state of US where there seems to be a lack of "togetherness" and high levels of individualism.
@@genovayork2468 no you should go back to your momma's womb. There were literally three at one point, Abbasids of Baghdad, Umayads of Qurtuba, and the Fatimids all claiming Caliphate in the 900s. And by the 1100s-1200s there were officially two claiming it, the Almuwahidun and the Abbasids.
@@thekandarichronicles he's probably referring the the Zenj part on it. Although ibn khaldun likely was inspired of the rise and fall of the Assabiyah from his area in the west north Africa from main examples being the Almurabitun and the Almuwahidun whom started with successful leaders under strong Assabiyah like that under Yusuf bin Tachfin who was renown for smashing back the Christian Iberian powers of the north whilst his successors weren't as efficient as him. And for the Almuwahidun was Abdelmumin Koumia who conquered out almost the entire Maghreb in such a span of time and even kicking out the Normans from what would be Tunisia and Libya and defeating some of the beni Hilal tribes. However non of his successors would come that close in his military success other than al Mansur at best. Although the Ottomans in his time period were still dominating most of the Anatolian and Balkan regions and wouldn't have gotten to North Africa and most of the Levant until the reign of Selim in his campaign against the Mamluks.
I'm only beginning to study his first volume. I feel like his observations of civil society give us insights into how policy is made. Policy can be from making sure everyone is fed to making war. I feel like we can gain insights from his scientific method of observation for understanding policy making.
You have great content, but your videos have a ‘conspiracy’ vibe. Please change it, maybe something more like the arm chair historian or something else, because I think this is the reason why your view count is low.
Well, that's your opinion. His subscriber count has tripled since I started watching not so long ago (after all, he has really only been actively putting out videos since a year ago). I say keep it up! I've learned a lot already and look forward to learning even more!
Thank you Adel. I understand where you come from. But when one is dealing with retelling a narrative, no matter what kind of narrative, historic, societal, religious, then one is always susceptible to being labeled "conspiratorial". Its a natural by product of the journey. As for low count. I take what I get. Sometimes its high and many more low. For my channel, it's about building a strong loyal base who add to the equation. Who share their knowledge constantly and also want to be exposed to new ideas and perspectives.
@@thekandarichronicles I understand that; I was simply letting my feedback go through because it is a shame that there are very few creators like you, on top of that -- there are nearly no videos in Arabic to spread this 'awareness of culture' to the Orient. Now, taking into consideration what you said; that you aim to acquire a strong, loyal, and aware fanbase, I see where we do not meet. I am coming from a place of wishing for a grande awareness - in contrast to your given goal. It is your channel, your effort and that goes without saying. I was simply under the impression that the project of the channel was to raise awareness, so I gave a review based on that. Have a good day
Tareq, the quality of your work speaks for itself. Every detail was handled with such care and precision it’s clear how much effort you put into this. Kandari Chronicles just keeps getting better, and it's creators like you who keep raising the bar. Grateful for what you do keep it up!
I have been waiting for your commentary. Been a long time since your Ibn Khaldun request and I really was hoping that it tapped into what you expected from my side. It's always a challenge introducing a new angle to content as there is so much out there. I really appreciate your constant support for my channel and work and your kind words mean so much to me.
I would like to hear what you enjoyed as well as what you didn't with this last content. Your thoughts are not only welcome but necessary for me to keep on moving upwards on this journey of creativity.
@@thekandarichronicles
Tareq,You’ve managed to dissect Ibn Khaldun’s contributions to multiple disciplines in a way that bridges historical gaps and emphasizes the influence he had on future thinkers which people dont give him enough credit for.
My only thought would be that perhaps diving a little deeper into specific examples of how his theories directly influenced later Western scholars would further cement the points you made. Overall, you’ve nailed it once again. This kind of content is why Kandari Chronicles is a favourite of mine.
Fantastic as always. I remember a few years ago I came across this lecturer who had researched the link between the Islamic scholars and the renaissance, which was fascinating, though there was a sad part and that is his lecture halls were almost empty.
I hope you help break through the “resistance”.
That is sad. Guess we have to all have a hand in resisting the narrative and pushing back the huge momentum inaccurate western history has on its side.
@@thekandarichronicles The tides are very slowly changing and I see the use of “Western centric” in geopolitical comments more and more, which gives me hope. Change is hard, especially when the ego is at play but I have to say that the younger generation also gives me hope, they seem to have more goodness in them and more open than the previous ones, including my own which of course is ostracized and looked upon in the west as weak.
Change can be hard, but also once done its quick to recondition. Thats why the younger generations are able to move on from preconditioning more easily.
@@thekandarichronicles The Caliphate didn't exist in Ibn Khaldun's time, restart. 😂
BTW...Fubanaci lived Oran Algeria with his father ... then u can connect the dots. This part of the world... used to be the ornament of the world
12 min and 49 sec. Talking about the person I’m hearing first time in my life…and you’re providing such a deep and detailed explanation..amazing!
Thank you Fazli. I am really glad you are getting something out of the content. Please check out other videos and would love to hear your thoughts on those as well.
Thanks!
ما قصرت على كرمك الدائم. معنوياً والآن مادياً. شكراً جزيلاً والوعد بالاستمرار في العطاء والانتاج المتقن. يعطيك الف عافية!
انت صاحب الفضل استاذ طارق و قد اكرمتنا بعلمك ،ليس من الغريب انك سوف تستمر في الإتقان ،وشكرا لك ولعطائك المستمر
جبل... ع رأسه نار 🔥
Ibn Khaldoun RIP
we need u so much right now
many thx
Great time just start reading his book
Oh that is great timing. It was meant to be. And please do add more thoughts once you've some time in the book's midst.
Salaam thanks my brother this one very important
My pleasure Lama. Yes indeed very important to exhibit the value Islam's polymaths have on our day to day life today.
I would like to point out that Ancient Greece is actually an Eastern civilization, heavily influenced by the Babylonians and Egyptians. At the time, they would have regarded the West as a region of nomadic tribes.
Furthermore, Greece did not play a role in the transformation of current Western civilization; instead, it was the empires that effectively exploited the New World, particularly the French and British.
There is definitely no blaming Ancient Greece by any means, but traditional textbooks would disagree with you on categorising that civilisation as Easter. On the contrary, civilisation like Babylonians and Mesopotamians are identified within Western Civilisation classes in high school.
As always, a great lesson on Islamic history!
Thank you so much. Words that burst with joy for me.
Adam Smith borrowed ideas from Ibn Khaldun that's for sure. Newton's theory on lights came from the book by Ibn Haythem.
Absolutely. Ibn Haythem has so much disassociated with him in discovering the theories and innovations in the world of optics.
Great
Great as always 👍
Thanks Ahmed. Your feedback is always greatly appreciated.
*_Masha'Allah_*
Thank you Hussain. Appreciate your support.
First.🎉
Yes you are for sure. Appreciate the launch!
I am a computer scientist from "the West" and I am well aware where the name algorithm comes from; but maybe I am an exception, probably, idk.
More of an exception than you could believe unfortunately.
I think the writings of Moses and the. Prophet's had this view long before any other historical narrative. I also think that many ideas of Jewish origin of the tanakh was borrowed and added its own conclusions, in their own writings in the Koran.
Yet another example of orientalism.
Crazy how even Arab textbooks to a certain extant follow this same method.
where to start at looking at Ibn Khaldun?
A famous book of Ibn Khaldun which is available today is ‘Muqaddimah’, a classic work about the dev of civilization.
A famous book of Ibn Khaldun that’s still available and translated widely until today is ‘Muqaddimah’. A thick book about development of civilization. Also mentioned in this video.
So would it be fair to say that Ibn Khaldun wouldn't be the greatest advocate for racial/ethnic diversity within a society? It seems like he's describing the current state of US where there seems to be a lack of "togetherness" and high levels of individualism.
The Caliphate didn't exist in Ibn Khaldun's time, restart.😂
I think you confuse the Caliphate with the Golden Age of Islam. They are not one and the same.
@@thekandarichronicles No. The second Caliphate (far from an empire to begin with) ended in 1258, decades before ibn Khaldun was born.
@@genovayork2468Hafsids did claim themselves as one
@@zakback9937 1. I said the Caliphate, not a caliphate.
2. No lmao, go back to pre-k.
@@genovayork2468 no you should go back to your momma's womb. There were literally three at one point, Abbasids of Baghdad, Umayads of Qurtuba, and the Fatimids all claiming Caliphate in the 900s. And by the 1100s-1200s there were officially two claiming it, the Almuwahidun and the Abbasids.
He was right about africa
What part?
@@thekandarichronicles he's probably referring the the Zenj part on it.
Although ibn khaldun likely was inspired of the rise and fall of the Assabiyah from his area in the west north Africa from main examples being the Almurabitun and the Almuwahidun whom started with successful leaders under strong Assabiyah like that under Yusuf bin Tachfin who was renown for smashing back the Christian Iberian powers of the north whilst his successors weren't as efficient as him. And for the Almuwahidun was Abdelmumin Koumia who conquered out almost the entire Maghreb in such a span of time and even kicking out the Normans from what would be Tunisia and Libya and defeating some of the beni Hilal tribes. However non of his successors would come that close in his military success other than al Mansur at best. Although the Ottomans in his time period were still dominating most of the Anatolian and Balkan regions and wouldn't have gotten to North Africa and most of the Levant until the reign of Selim in his campaign against the Mamluks.
Is it fair to call him the Father of Political Science?
I think it's fair to call him many names. I would like to know why you would highlight that name in specific. Share your thoughts.
I'm only beginning to study his first volume. I feel like his observations of civil society give us insights into how policy is made. Policy can be from making sure everyone is fed to making war. I feel like we can gain insights from his scientific method of observation for understanding policy making.
Great point Vicki.
You have great content, but your videos have a ‘conspiracy’ vibe. Please change it, maybe something more like the arm chair historian or something else, because I think this is the reason why your view count is low.
Well, that's your opinion. His subscriber count has tripled since I started watching not so long ago (after all, he has really only been actively putting out videos since a year ago). I say keep it up! I've learned a lot already and look forward to learning even more!
Thank you Adel. I understand where you come from. But when one is dealing with retelling a narrative, no matter what kind of narrative, historic, societal, religious, then one is always susceptible to being labeled "conspiratorial". Its a natural by product of the journey.
As for low count. I take what I get. Sometimes its high and many more low. For my channel, it's about building a strong loyal base who add to the equation. Who share their knowledge constantly and also want to be exposed to new ideas and perspectives.
Your support makes me happier and happier. My comment to Adel is exactly echoed by your reply. Amazing.
@@thekandarichronicleshonestly, your one of the most underrated people on this platform.
@@thekandarichronicles I understand that; I was simply letting my feedback go through because it is a shame that there are very few creators like you, on top of that -- there are nearly no videos in Arabic to spread this 'awareness of culture' to the Orient.
Now, taking into consideration what you said; that you aim to acquire a strong, loyal, and aware fanbase, I see where we do not meet. I am coming from a place of wishing for a grande awareness - in contrast to your given goal.
It is your channel, your effort and that goes without saying. I was simply under the impression that the project of the channel was to raise awareness, so I gave a review based on that.
Have a good day
Bro, do you sell toilet paper?