From what I can remember, Roy's old whistle was so much louder than the new one, it was so loud that I could hear it in the Fort Wilderness campground!
@@WaltsNephew Yeah, I know train whistles are indeed loud but I was always curious on why Roy's old whistle was deafening comparing to others (I remember Strasburg 90's whistle not being as loud).
Good question. Honestly, I think it just depends on which engineer you have on a particular day. Some like to let the engine's whistle scream while other just let steam escape haha
Roy’s whistles were quite a change. It’s a Hancock 3 chime. Sounded to me at first like a Rio Grade 3 chime till it was unclogged in June 2016. Now it has the sound on my ears of a B&O 3 chime. But it’s still only a Hancock 3 chime.
@Pinchy08 That’s not what happened. The Roy had a deep tone whistle that came from a steamboat that has been torn apart a long time ago. This deep tone whistle was originally a temporary whistle while the original whistle wasn’t repaired for a couple of decades. In 2016 the deep tone steamboat whistle was taken off, and the original whistle was put back on. The appearance of both whistles were very different. The original whistle was painted gold when the park opened years ago and is still gold today. The deep tone whistle was coated with a satin black paint, and the chimes on both whistles have different shapes.
The deeper 3 chime (normal whistle too me) is a 4 inch American 3 chime that was originally on the Admiral Joe Fowler riverboat. When the Fowler was scuttled after a dry dock accident, the whistle was put on Roy. For years the high note was plugged off. After Brittons retirement the plug was removed during repair. During the repair the other whistle was on Roy.
@@cple1 That is FASCINATING! I was wondering why her whistle sounded different but was obviously the same one! Do we have any idea as to why the high note was plugged (on purpose or from wear-and-tear)?
Historically, Roy had the loudest whistle until it was recently changed. The other three have always had the buckeye 3 chime whistle. Makes it difficult to tell them apart due to only slight tonal differences.
As of December 23, 2022, the Walt Disney World Railroad has returned! Unfortunately, as early as late January (maybe early February), Roy O. Disney has received a new whistle, although I think it's temporary.
I've been to both Disney theam parks once each when I was a kid. Dont remember much of it. Never thought they had live steam engines. Just saying. Have a great day everyone
Really?! Boy, I'm sorry you missed a wonderful opportunity to ride some of the finest steam locomotives in the world. Hope you get another chance in the future!
It’s easy to tell the difference between the Walter’s and the Lilly Belle’s whistles. The Lilly Belle’s has a higher pitch to it, and it’s louder than the Walter’s. The Walter’s whistle has a lower tone and it sounds a bit softer.
Nowadays Lilly’s whistle sounds like it’s fallen a little out of tune. It still sounds normal, but when opened fully, it doesn’t really sound like a buckeye 3 chime.
I've talked with a friend of mine about how the buckeyes on the WDWRR engines are too much like wooden toy whistles EXCEPT for Roy's since it's a hand-me-down from the Admiral Joe Fowler sternwheeler
From what I can remember, Roy's old whistle was so much louder than the new one, it was so loud that I could hear it in the Fort Wilderness campground!
No kidding! Gosh, that is fantastic
@@WaltsNephew Yeah, I know train whistles are indeed loud but I was always curious on why Roy's old whistle was deafening comparing to others (I remember Strasburg 90's whistle not being as loud).
Good question. Honestly, I think it just depends on which engineer you have on a particular day. Some like to let the engine's whistle scream while other just let steam escape haha
@@WaltsNephew Okay!
Can you please Link me the audio or Roy's old whistle
When I was a little boy, I have never heard something so beautiful and melodic and memorable as the buckeye 3chime.
I love those Buckeye 3 chime whistles on Walter and Lilly.
They are very nice!
@@WaltsNephew, I'm gonna use these whistle on my new video
1:07 favourite whistle of Walter E Disney
Sure is a good one!
My favorite whistle is the first Roy O. Disney, sounds great.
Very great indeed!
I LOVE WHISTLES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love the whistles so much!!
Me too! Although I love Ripley's 3 chime Lunkenheimer above all others haha
I like Roger being equipped with that Crosby Lukehumer 3 chime. How many of you wish Roger still had his Buckeyes whistle to this day?
I like the different whistle only because this acts as a way to audibly differentiate Roger from the rest
Roy’s whistles were quite a change. It’s a Hancock 3 chime. Sounded to me at first like a Rio Grade 3 chime till it was unclogged in June 2016. Now it has the sound on my ears of a B&O 3 chime. But it’s still only a Hancock 3 chime.
Thank you for that! I was trying to research which whistle maker she was fitted with but couldn't find out until you said so
@Pinchy08 That’s not what happened. The Roy had a deep tone whistle that came from a steamboat that has been torn apart a long time ago. This deep tone whistle was originally a temporary whistle while the original whistle wasn’t repaired for a couple of decades. In 2016 the deep tone steamboat whistle was taken off, and the original whistle was put back on. The appearance of both whistles were very different. The original whistle was painted gold when the park opened years ago and is still gold today. The deep tone whistle was coated with a satin black paint, and the chimes on both whistles have different shapes.
The deeper 3 chime (normal whistle too me) is a 4 inch American 3 chime that was originally on the Admiral Joe Fowler riverboat. When the Fowler was scuttled after a dry dock accident, the whistle was put on Roy. For years the high note was plugged off. After Brittons retirement the plug was removed during repair. During the repair the other whistle was on Roy.
@@cple1 That is FASCINATING! I was wondering why her whistle sounded different but was obviously the same one! Do we have any idea as to why the high note was plugged (on purpose or from wear-and-tear)?
Historically, Roy had the loudest whistle until it was recently changed. The other three have always had the buckeye 3 chime whistle. Makes it difficult to tell them apart due to only slight tonal differences.
As of December 23, 2022, the Walt Disney World Railroad has returned! Unfortunately, as early as late January (maybe early February), Roy O. Disney has received a new whistle, although I think it's temporary.
It sure was great to have another Disney railway return to service
Sounds like Roger whistle
I think the original whistle has been restored recently, as I could hear it all the way from the TTC parking lot the last time I went a few days ago.
@@ThemePark_Nerdo yeah the old whistle is back now.
@@WaltsNephewalso Walter has a new whistle itself.
Love the whistle. Thanks for sharing. Great video
Thanks Wally! Got a little more concerning whistles for the near future ;)
Roy's whistle sounds like Fred Gurley's second whistle and ATSF #3415
Very close to them!
I've been to both Disney theam parks once each when I was a kid. Dont remember much of it. Never thought they had live steam engines. Just saying. Have a great day everyone
Really?! Boy, I'm sorry you missed a wonderful opportunity to ride some of the finest steam locomotives in the world. Hope you get another chance in the future!
I wish they would put the deep tone whistle back on the Roy cause I like it better than the original whistle.
Since I'm more accustomed to the DRR, I can go either way with Roy's whistle haha
Disney sure does like ten-wheelers with loud chime whistles.
Big engines deserve whistles that grab your attention ;)
Disney world train whistle sounds good
They sure do!
I Wish Walt and Lily had different whistles hard to tell them apart
RIGHT?!?!?! You almost have to rely entirely on visual cues to know who's coming into the platform
@@WaltsNephew that and the bells
It’s easy to tell the difference between the Walter’s and the Lilly Belle’s whistles. The Lilly Belle’s has a higher pitch to it, and it’s louder than the Walter’s. The Walter’s whistle has a lower tone and it sounds a bit softer.
Right, at least there is some leeway there haha
The Roger is my fave over all. But Roy at 4.08 takes the win!
Sure is a great moment ;)
My favorite train whistle is Roy o Disney
So long as all of the whistle tubes are open, her whistle is very nice and differentiates herself with the rest of the WDWRR roster
Nowadays Lilly’s whistle sounds like it’s fallen a little out of tune. It still sounds normal, but when opened fully, it doesn’t really sound like a buckeye 3 chime.
Quite true. It's interesting how whistles weather differently under high-pressure steam
4:52 kinda sounds like tweetsie railroad #12's 3 chime
It really did! I wonder if Roy and No.12 have the same whistle
Wasn't the Roy O's whistle taken from the second, retired steamship that used to be on the Rivers of America?
The whistle came from Magic Kingdom's first steam vessel, Admiral Joe Fowler, after the accidental drop at dry dock
Where can I find the clip at 2:42?
0:18 ow your hurting me! walter e disney does aggrisvie whistle noises
She likes to make her presence known ;)
All but #4 sound like they belong on Casey junior trains
I've talked with a friend of mine about how the buckeyes on the WDWRR engines are too much like wooden toy whistles EXCEPT for Roy's since it's a hand-me-down from the Admiral Joe Fowler sternwheeler
This part sounds like the original Casey Jr whistle 0:17
From the Reluctant Dragon, I see why you think that. Good ear!
Yah l actually kinda know what most of the whistle sound like and whare the orgins of the sound used for stock sound comes from.
The ex Unidos de Yucatan Locomotives
Quite right!
Me gusta
Me gusta mucho
Me ha gustado
Haha They are great whistles
you heard they started testing right?
Yes indeed! It was great to see Lilly out in public on the main again
@@WaltsNephew has anybody seen the Walter yet. I haven’t heard anything about it or seen it since that 1 photo at the d23 event back in November.
@@Steamfan1 I know there was a picture from August and then D23 had one in November so, other than that, I don't think she's been spotted
What was roy o disney old whistle
She wore the whistle once worn by the Admiral Fowler paddle sternwheeler
What's the whistle called
Unfortunately I don't rightly know
Casey Jr The Dumbo the disney
He's not featured here, but I think Casey would have done well in Magic Kingdom's Fantasyland besides being a small water park