Production HELL: Chainsaw Man
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
- Abbreviations that I use regularly:
KA: Key Animation
AD: Animation Direction/Director
CAD: Chief Animation Director
SB: Story Board
LO: Lay Out
00:00 - Too Long; Didn't Watch
00:47 - Some video ideas that I had
01:26 - Anime overproduction crysis
05:22 - Nakayama vision
11:37 - Lack of time
14:50 - Why extra time couldn't be given
16:19 - Wasted effort
17:27 - Extensive 2nd KA and melting
19:08 - Episode 9
20:13 - Episode 12
20:50 - When 3D is used
21:21 - The dissapointing state of MAPPA
23:49 - That's about it - Фільми й анімація
I think saying that Nakayama was too ambitious for his own good is a way to discredit what he's actually done for this production in particular and the Mappas second production line as a whole, because, unlike what a lot of people are saying, he clearly knew what he was doing and made a lot of steps to make such an ambitious production possible. Case in point - the Nakayama animators employment program which was a way to address the issue of animator shortage by hiring inhouse animators. Under this program animators such as lington, 10+10 and shoushi joined Mappa and participated heavily in CSM( especially in EDs) This is the way KyoAni and Ufotable(which the current Mappa and the large majority of the industry are a direct opposite of) operate and is the only way for this businesses to sustain themselves and everybody knows it. CSM had dedicated costume designers and animation directors, which is also a rare occurrence to my knowledge. The Photography department had suddenly become more capable and though there's no way to confirm it, I wouldn't doubt the fact that Nakayama worked on that too since his preanimated CSM PV looked 10x better than anything in JJK composite wise and was worked on by the same Dop. The main issue i feel like stems from the conditions Mappa has given them. If they do a movie afterwards I would feel like that would be a much better showing for them and not only quality wise, but also direction wise as i would personally love to see Nakayama's reach go further than his own episodes.
Hopefully it's gonna be a movie
that being said chainsaw man looked amazing
clearly he doesn't know what he's doing now that he's gone lmao
@@dwiatmika9563 Mostly because Japanese fans were not satisfied by the adaptation of the anime and that he did not "respected" the whole vibe of the manga.
@@Lemon3_Worksyeah and that’s a rlly stupid thing to say cause CSM is liter a perfect adaptation from manga to an anime. Just because certain parts aren’t one to one with the mange doesn’t mean it’s bad. The whole point adapting something in a different medium is to take advantage of what anime would have to provide that manga doesn’t. And CSM did that perfectly.
Even with all the production issues, Chainsaw Man still turned out to be one of the most gorgeous anime I've ever seen. I'm honestly really worried that a potential season 2 won't be able to keep up that level of quality.
This video has aged like fine wine
Chainsaw man being made in less then one year is insane. It puts how good it does look in a whole new light. I mean it looks like something so unreal and so ambitious it's crazy to think it had just a normal 1 year schedule. I absolutely love the artistic style and think it elevates the story a ton but it just does not seem possible to be done cosistently for possibly three or four 12 ep seasons.
Thank you for giving me knowledge and sadness over the state of my most anticipated shows.
"everyone wants to work on chainsaw man" is such an interesting concept to me. idk y but when u said that it rlly stuck out to me
KenArto guy who worked on Jojo 5, goku broly movie, said onTrash Taste in 2020: I want to work o Chainsawman
Ita a dream of every animator
I get it. But, why CSM? The talent and staff that CSM had could bring the second coming of mob psycho 100 or even Space Dandy. But the production schedule didn't allowed that. Also, there are many projects, but I wonder why every animator loves CSM? Is it because it's super popular or if it is related to sakuga culture?
I honestly thought before the series aired that it had a RELATIVELY decent schedule compared to other Mappa productions due to the ambition and announcements made about new work conditions. I knew it wouldn't be anywhere near ideal but i at least thought it was better.
But 1 SINGULAR YEAR? Jfc that's terrible. I've been praying that they'd slow down eventually but Jigokuraku got me feeling like those prayers won't be answered for a long while
(sorry for my bad english) 1 to 1.5 year at max. Because of JJK. As he said, The situation that JJK and CSM can exists together is that After JJK season 2 and a CSM movie. Although they funded CSM themselves. I hope they can take their time a bit in this way (a season for one and a movie for another)
You talk about how Spy x Family could be considered "production heaven", but what about the announcement that season 2 and the movie are coming out this year?
And not only that, but even the recent saying from Tetsuya Nakatake talking about how it's planning for both to release on Fall?
Spy x Family has the benefit of being a coproduction between Wit and Cloverworks. Since the work is split, the production schedule is much more forgiving
It's a co-production.
Mappa staff after completing Chainsaw Man: "Phew, well that was a fucking nightmare. But look on the bright side guys, it will never be that bad again"
Mappa executives inb4 JJK S2: "Aight bet"
I love these videos!
Now Production HELL: Attack on Titan (as a whole)
Great to see you back man. Can't believe I have my midsem exam tommorow but here I am, watching your video but I seriously couldn't hold back. Anyway, great video as always. Hope to see a Nozomu abe animation breakdown video or a video about the top 5 action animators of japan in your opinion with a little animation breakdown of each.
The schedule could have been much better I agree. But lets not forget that chainsaw man production happen in the midst of global pandemic where Japan & China were hit super hard resulting in 100s of anime getting delayed even to this day. It might have been enough time to polish everything if the circumtances were normal. And also let's not forget they were using their own money and risking everything in this so they might not have the luxury of delaying it even further.
The pandemic only compounds issues in the industry, because it only affects the negative aspects; large amounts of outsourcing to foreign companies becomes difficult, but that's about it. Projects shouldn't depend on that anyway. Let's not forget we got projects like Yuukaku-hen and mob psycho 3 during the same period, and those shows weren't even a little bit hurt by the pandemic. The freelance and outsourcing industries are to be used as tools, but today for most projects they are necessities.
Im happy to find your channel! I got so much information about the industry that i aspire to enter myself. Im not demotivated, but its still good to acknowledge the reality of possible overwork and stuff. Plus your knowledge about individual animators who work on this series with their own styles is so wide!
Tatsuya yoshihara said that he didn't need to do much because everyone was so good in chainsaw man
And I don't think that yoshihara will do much in the black clover movie
Because the real director for this movie is other guy, Yoshihara is the series director, he will probably animate and maybe storyboard something, but I don't see him doing nearly as much work than he did in CSM
Wild that so many people say this show looked bad. Was practically a 12 episode movie. I get that people didn't like how some moments looked, but a lot of the hate was just weird and exaggerated. People were legit saying that the CGI looks like Playstation 1 graphics.
A lot of it was probably a counterreaction to the massive hype the show had, rather than a genuine opinion about the show's quality.
Am I getting deja-vu or did I see this exact same comment somewhere else?
@@-MankoMan Welcome to the Internet
@@FastCrySquirebullshit opinions always exist, that's why
Wow. Didn't know that the situation was this messed up. As you said only time will tell what's gonna be happening. Even tho there are good to great productions like VS and tondemo skill and probably the Original movie or even AOT. But manabu needs to understand the limits of the Studio and passion of the animators. (why my comment was deleted 💀). Btw Goated video as usual ❤️❤️
The TL;DW at the beginning and the framing that the director chose something that isn't feasible instead of just the other production issues got me to subscribe. Nice content too.
Can you imagine yourself in 2013 making the same video but "Production HELL: Attack on Titan"? Lol would get a lot of hate
@guy x joy oh god the hell arc 💀
Those first half episodes looked downright unreal. I can't even be mad that the quality took a big dip in the big fight scenes. And love these videos, the animators' names need to be more widely known, they're the blood of the anime we love so much.
Thank you for this informative video!
I hope they take a break from JJK after season 2, but that's just wishful thinking.
Anyways it's more likely that they will take a break from CSM since the manga is already extremely popular and pretty far from ending, so they can sacrifice a bit more time on it, even more so if it's a movie which is pretty much guaranteed to receive an amazing audience reception.
I wonder what direction the AoT team would go after the S4 P3 Ep2 though, and the Jigokuraku and Campfire Cooking teams.
So currently MAPPA must have 4 teams and the ones under the most pressure are probably the JJK CSM team. I hope the AoT team gets dissipated and goes on to reinforce the Jigokuraku and JJK teams, which would kind of fix some of the production issues.
The Campfire Cooking team would probably end up creating Idaten Deities but idk.
I hope that one day Hayashi will continue Dorohedoro.
Yeah it really is a shame. We can only hope that Manabu has some sort of plan we're not seeing, but right now that seems unlikely. The final product had episodes far greater than what most animes will ever achieve in their runtime however it makes me think what if they pushed for more?
My main hope now for the sequel is that Nakayama tries to stick to his vision while allowing for some experimentation and exploration. While also being paired with a better schedule and less caught up staff. For me the biggest downside was Yoshihara's lack of appearances. It felt like he wasn't even the action director due to the schedule and his other priorities.
In the end we did get like 65% of the what staff can do, which is about 200% relative to other show's quality, but imagine what a 100% output would've looked like...
Really usefull video. Thank you, bro!
good stuff! just suscribed and liked with notis on, keep doing what u do!
Fantastic video explaining the state of the production, it helped put a lot of the problems in the final product into perspective. If anything, I’m even more impressed it looks THIS GOOD considering everything that was against them. Btw, I was wondering what your thoughts on the actual content of the show are? (Thoughts on characters, writing, story, humor, favorite character, shit like that. It’s fun to hear what people think considering how out there some of the series can be)
Great video
The rumor about opm being under mappa is unsettling, I hope its false. If they could somehow manage a decent schedule then I'd definitely be fine with it but that won't happen. Also I'd like the ANP to be Seshita
Ong 😔
If there opm thats game over for mappa animators and freelancers.
@@catlike9444yeah most of the shows are gonna crash💀. Please be bones.
@@user-og6pb6dd5p Or a co-production between Mappa and Bones
Hell yes I hope something like that happens at this point 😭
@@harman4321 yeah that would be The best opinion honestly. Same with cloverworks and wit situation because they were so busy. Although i think one of the Animation producers of wit was a friend with an Animation producer of cloverworks (I'm not sure). I Don't think it's gonna happen tho
Still waiting on the Nozomu Abe spotlight video, hopefully you'll release it in the near future. Also, can't wait for you to react or breakdown Demon Slayer season 3 episode 1 as Yuichi Terao will be storyboarding the episode. Great video and keep up the good work😁
That infinity castle part was unreal.
Well frik.
Not going to expect anything from Hell's paradise then lol. Sad since the Manga's pog and is honestly one of my favs
Great vid
There is still something else to look forward to it. I'd say just don't have high expectations for it and expect for it to be good or ok. It's not gonna be great or really good like some others but it could be ok or good. I know to some that's not ok as every project or manga should get a good anime adaption like CSM or demon slayer or whatever good series out there but with how the current industry is today. It's hard to afford it unfortunately and we can only hope things will go better somewhat but that'll take a miracle at that point with how this industry is. So don't beat yourself too hard on it. Just have reasonable expectations, give it a try and see if you can have fun who knows maybe you might like it.
It will definitely have some best moments and will look good sometimes that's for sure but it will continuously be ok for the most part which is the best case scenario for Jigo considering it's sandwiched between major IP's around it.
@@bold9291 believe me. My thoughts are the same as yours rn lol.
Ironic though that the anime will probably suffer the same fate as the manga in that regard then lol. A great little story caught between too many other great stories XD
@@badpiggy4177
It's like fate running in circles for Jigo. Isn't it kinda hilariously tragic?
You are right. A year ago when we were told that csm will be released in Autumn, i thought that they had to work on it before jjk 0, cuz i thought that it was unreal for them to finish it all in aa year or so
I miss you man, wish you would upload a video every single week
I wish I did too :(
you are amazing
And keep in mind this is a passion project. How the hell a passion project has production issues.
Only in Mappa 💀
MOB PSYCHO 100 was a passion project and every season took 3 years
@@3esa2003 Yeah Otsuka needs to do something about CSM and JJk tbh,CSM a passion project fuck no I mean it technically is but schedule was really bad.
3 letter answer: J J K
@@NineTnk Or mappa and most of the industry Overproduction madness.
I hope the quality is still the same even though the direction is ambitious.
For visually chainsaw man was better then demon slayer. Demon slayer impressing by static moments and rare sakuga.
Thanks for your vidéo, as always incredible !
I hope the run of Manabu to get all the anime will end…
Where did you get the info that episode 6 have more key frame than DS ? It’s super impressive and I want to know more about this.
Thank your for your video ! Take care !
New series in Mankoman UA-cam channel
Production hell: *put any isekai*
My head started hurting when they picked up hells paradise
Your PfP 💀🗿
i hope u make animation analysis for aot part 3 ;PP
I always wondered about the things you said in the video since it was easy to notice them because after every csm ep was released i downloaded it and looked at it frame by frame and i did it for every episode
Hi, A lot of ppl say that the newest Solo Leveling trailer has mid/bad animation. Can you make a video about it?
Interesting video. But yeah, the moment you said that Episode 8 of CSM shows some cracks on the production issues, the moment I admit that I kind of hesitate so much so that I got a bad vibes about CSM even if I still want to support it. This reminds me of something, do you think that Ryu Nakayama is still a good director for CSM or not?
Also yeah, after watching some of your video. I can conclude that the production issues are not an isolated incident not just in one studio but considering the high profile stuff that the anime industry had to pump... I can see why it's a problem.
Still waiting on that Nozumo Abe video
I do hope MAPPA especially can eventually slow down and give their employees proper rest.
I had a bad feeling about it since its anouncement cuz Mappa was doing a lot of projects, and yeah I'm not wrong.
The problem is mostly the schedule. But them picking hell's paradise was Really questionble. The AP is The same with AOT 💀
@@user-og6pb6dd5p Mappa never learn lol.
@@user-og6pb6dd5p look like Mappa just pick popular mangas and ruined them with tight time schedule but people will watch anyway.
It is fascinating to hear about anime production. Thanks! Now, it worries me if JJK S2 will be okay. Is the JJK anime still in production or would it be already done by now?
JJK S2's production is absolutely not over by now. Most anime keep being produced as they're airing. There are only a few outliers, like mob psycho 100 or KyoAni projects that finish production before airing. Tengoku Daimakyou was almost completed by the time the first episode aired, so it should be completed by now, which is also great.
On the other end, there's Bocchi the rock, wonder egg priority, Mha S5 etc where the episodes were being turned in just the day before those episodes were to air, which is really bad. I'm assuming that JJK S2 is not even half finished in its production yet, and will join these shows in terms of horrible production practices.
@@-MankoMan OMG. Now I'm really worried. The latest PV looked great tho. I can't imagine how hard work it must be for all the staff and animators under the terrible schedule. As someone without any deep knowledge about anime/anime production, your analysis and content are really interesting and helpful. Thanks and keep going!
@@user-hy9fc4uk5d Latest PV looked great. So did Bocchi the rock and wonder egg. Having an insanely stacked staff can cancel out a pathetic schedule, though that means they'll have to work to near death continuously.
22:50 and also this situation is not with all of Mappa shows
22:08 i think because wada is not The CEO of wit anymore
17:14 could be that these are BD corrections. I guess
I think that JJK0 didn't have a bad schedule
the production finished 2 months earlier
even JJK didn't have big problems because it has a one-man studio like PARK
And now park is gone.
@@catlike9444 And they have 6 months of production to create 24 episodes for JJK S2. As much as CSM had a massive decrease in animation quality as the season went on, JJK S2 will probably be much worse. I cannot see how MAPPA can continue juggling CSM and JJK like this unless they space out the production schedules more.
@@groceryliszt3346 not to mention also having hell paradise
@@catlike9444 It's done by a separate team than JJK and CSM, so its impact on JJK S2 should be limited
@@catlike9444 Not completely
I mean Sano was AD on AOT and did the OP for isekai anime
I would love a video about other animes production like demon slayer or spy x family.
Ever considered doing a review on bleach TYBW!?
Do you will watch the new demon slayer movie ?
But if CM suffered all of those issues, why they didn't use each animator's cut in the blu rays that ended up unused because of the schedule? And the blu rays were released quickly compared to lets say AOT which is from the same studio (I know they r different teams). AOT blu rays takes around 6 months (from what I remember), and there are a lot of minor changes but does not justify the time taken. On the other hand, we have CM blu rays which got released around 1 months after finishing!
6:30 manko, don't you think The schedule that you're probably guessing is too bad for a production like this? Like if it is, then the schedule is pretty bad for this episode alone. And even in the latter half of the episodes. There was episode 10 and Most of 12 and 8 that were pretty much (specially 10) were like The first half. No matter how talented the team is. They can't produce this near movie like for every episode when the schedule is bad for an episode like 6 itself. Like (yname) said JJK and CSM shares like 20% in the staff. And JJK0 and CSM shares like less than 10% if you look at the Credits as he said. And it's pretty much Normal for big veterans to work on Multiple shows (like outside of CSM and JJK) there were other projects in the other studios as well.
bro no wonder csm was so "oK" amazing video man
Just (ok)?
@@user-og6pb6dd5p yeah, it wasnt bad but not that good either
@@Hetsu.. bruh
@@heisenberg3206 sure bro, sure
Great video as usual, but I have a question that have been bugging me all day. It's AOT realted but PLEASE I need an answer, ANY kind of answers; I just noticed that AOT Part 3 Ep01 had 7, SEVEN, Producers and I don't understand How and Why is that? I have never seen this many producers on any other project, so what does that imply? AOT has always been weird production-wise but this really stunned me for some reason.
What are you talking about? A show having that many producers is not a sign of anything.
@@carloscauan7967 Are you talking because you have info or experience? Or just throwing words without anything to back it up?
@@scythe9734 Look at the credits for openings of shows like Noragami, MHA, or Blue Lock. Producers are mostly there to serve as representatives for the different companies on the production comittee, a show having a lot of producers does not mean it's going through any type of issues, it just means it has a lot of companies backing it up.
@@carloscauan7967 Okey, thanks for the answer, but I checked AOT The Final Season part 1 and 2 and the production committee didn't change at all but the producers were alot less. Like 3 or 4 producers at most, but now suddenly their are 7? Look I'm not asking this in a negative or a positive way; I simply found it weird and I'm just looking for an answer as to why is it like this all of sudden, and is if there's any meaning behind it.
@@scythe9734 Are you sure about that? I just looked and both had 7 producers.
legend, would love a video on why rezero s2 animation fell a lot compared to s1!
S1 had a lot of episodes completely outsourced to Nexus. For S2 however they did not show up.
@@carloscauan7967 This isnt animation, but the colouring studio also changed from s1 to s2. A large part of rz s2 was also made during Covid.
@@highspeedrailenjoyer1045also to add the fact that hey had to make Studio Bind
I love you mankoman
I love you too!
I don't understand how the Chainsaw Man anime was so well regarded. There was a lot of negativity while it was airing, now, at least from the wider fanbase it seems like it was overwhelmingly liked, why, I have no idea. Subpar animation, subpar direction. It tried to have this cool and soulful atmosphere around itself, and perhaps some of the people that were making it did feel that way, but the end project didn't give me anything with even half the excitement on screen that the manga was able to constantly achieve.
She is full 2d 11:13
I've seen this on sakugabooru
Aot special episode animation breakdown? Would be a nice break from CSM.
Yeah that ep of aot was amazing.
hi brother!! why dont you talk about BAKI ANIME??
Background change again
I'm glad you mentioned MHA. There was a Yutapon cut in one of the recent episodes that looked like he literally gave up halfway through. That show just keeps going downhill and I don't know what Bones is thinking. When someone like Yutapon has no time to make it look good you know something is seriously wrong. Do they even have anything else lined up after Mob Pcycho cause if not then what is going on with them?
Yutapon was clearly rushed during that cut, but I disagree with saying that it "keeps goind downhill". If anything, S6 has been the most consistently good since S2.
Also, you say "what is Bones thinking" but this is not their problem. The problem is the anime having a bad schedule because it gets yearly seasons. They made BSD and Mob recently and both of them finished ahead of schedule.
@@carloscauan7967 The fact that he of all people was rushed tells you all you need to know. It may not be as bad as S5 but I've seen beautifully animated shots that never made it into the final cut because of time constraints. Something is going on with Bones. That said I hope it's because they are working on something else rather than that just being a shitty schedule for no reason cause season 5 was mega rushed and not just in the animation department but in terms of story as well as I'm sure manga readers would agree and that was all (presumably) because of the movie.
@@markomaksimovic7678 What do you mean "for no reason"? I literally JUST said why. The anime gets a consecutive 2-cour production on a YEARLY basis. It does not take a genius to figure out why it can't be as a good as other Bones shows, specially when sub-studio C literally only works on My Hero and nothing else.
@@carloscauan7967 Yeah, I guess you're right. That sounds a lot like the AOT situation. MHA just has a lot more freelancers working on it I guess. Still Mappa's AOT team pulled it off much better imo but I guess you could argue it's due to the use of CGI.
Whoa there was a lot of guesses there 😂
@@markomaksimovic7678 The Aot special episode looked great.
mmm
JinRoh, Gjost in the shell, Satoshi Kon
This is only animes that I cant remember when somebody says KINO
Chainsawman is a freaking diamond in 2022 when its impossible to do
Japan works only on stylized anime like Isekai, mha, KnY, even JJK
This is why I can't enjoy this series (jjk is good)
Chainsawman is masterpiece like a freaking cinema
It would be great if someone could sponsor MAPPA so that they could just slow down.
Believe me they get sponsors. Like shit the isekai cooking show their doing that's airing right now is literally a sponsor for restaurant businesses that made Mappa to make an anime for them with the restaurants products they make into it for those said businesses as a sponsor for both If I am correct based on what I understand about it (if not please correct me).
@@bold9291 Wait is that true??
Wtf I didn't even knew about that
@@harman4321
It's true and that isekai anime by Mappa is called "Campfire cooking in another world with my absurd skill". It looks to be a very successful venture for Mappa atleast based on the anime and what's it's trying to achieve. It definitely did achieved what Mappa is hoping or expecting for with the anime and it continues to be a mini success for the studio.
Edit:
By I mean success I meant profits it's giving to the studio. Japanese folks loves their food and with the anime being about food having delicious delicacy from various big restaurants in Japan as a sponsor making those folks buy those restaurants products or what not because the anime and how it sponsors it is really good and enticing to them. Also the food in the anime and how it's made looks very good and delicious that I sometimes get hungry looking at it with how it's done whenever I watch it. Plus with Mappa being the only one in the committee for that anime they are sure raking in alot of profits from it all by themselves. It's like a mini CSM for them based on how their the only ones in the committee but just a small project from Mappa that is getting a very good success for such a small business venture for the studio.
I know for sure that the staff and the director is really happy from the success their getting from such a small work of theirs. If this anime is lucky it might even get a season 2 but for now it remains unsure for what it's fate will be after it ends.
If you're planning to watch it don't expect it to be a very good well written show like it can be really good but not something special when watching it like any other ok isekai in general. The only thing to look forward into it is if you like isekai and cooking and food in general. It has an ok story that isn't as bad as some other isekai shows but nothing special about it. It's just ok. The characters are fine I guess and the humour is ok. But nothing out of the ordinary except for how it has great animations for food and how it's made and some good animation in some other scenes which of course makes sense as it's just a cooking show so it not having good animation for food and cooking would be a great blunder and miss for the anime and the staff to make. Just have a very reasonable expectations to it that is all.
@@harman4321 Yes, more like a really big supermarket/mall sponsered. Cooking Isekai is their second fully funded shows by Mappa after CSM. If anything, they want less sponsered (from production committee) and want to self-funded every anime project and so, gets all the profit.
@@NineTnk(sorry for my bad english) that's actually better than production committees fuck up their projects. But i hope they will go in a direction that these production issues dosen't exists in the future. Because they definitely want to be independent like kyoani and ufotable although definitely not in their way. And they have a lot more control over their projects because ufotable and kyoto Animation dosen't have The Power to that
people complaining that the next aot episode is coming in October is just dumb
Fr 💀
it could be in october or december.
To be fair they should just change the title. final season part 3 part 2 sounds so dumb.
@@catlike9444 Ask production committee why they didn't change the title,why asking here
Unlike csm it airing later will allow them to work to their full potential hayashi can finally go all out this first part looked incredible
Remind me again in June when MAPPA Stage 2023 event happen and they announces OPMs3, CSMmovie, Dorohedoro2, and one more big project. 💀💀💀
MAPPA is so similar to MARVEL rn, where they are currently the biggest name in their industry and pumping 5+ projects a year of what could’ve been perfect, but no.
As long as JJK, CSM stay popular and profitable, no way Otsuka’s gonna change. Because isn’t that why Wit changed, because AOT was no longer profitable.
That's Manabu Otsuka for you 🗿
@@harman4321 hell yea my goated businessman, my capitalist master, i kneel 🐐🧎🧎🧎💀
I personally hope there will be a dorohedoro 2 when AOT ended tbh
@@user-og6pb6dd5p No let Hayashi rest for some time 😭
WIT dropped AoT most likely because they were given a shit schedule and they wanted to do other things besides AoT for the time being.
The companies that are part of the AoT production committee didn't want a repeat of another 4 years without the anime so they hired MAPPA to do it instead.
Money was probably another lesser factor.
2:33
yellow
Why tondemo skill exist?
This is good story with most beautiful food I've ever seen
But not from damn Mappa
Chainsawman, JJK, Jigokuraku, Dorohedoro, AoT
Stop it goddamn, enough masterpieces!!!
OPM??????? I hope its.... Fckk I hope its true, But I don't want to animators suffer
maybe after aot ends, their production team will move to the current shows and the hell they are in right now will get a little bit better. but how they already took watanabes next movie and the rumor about opm, im getting kinda worried more than i was already.
but who knows, we can just wait for their stage and see what they got in their pockets already and what they want to take in.
Are talking about that original movie??
For which they released a trailer a year ago
@@harman4321more than a year ago. Looks like it actually has a pretty good schedule
With mappa picking up all the shounen titles under the sun with the ceo wanting mappa to do fire punch as so as possible then things won't change that much.
@@catlike9444 Ain't no way that's true 💀
@@catlike9444
Manabu didn't said he'd wanted to take all of Fujimotos works as soon as possible what he said is that he hopes the studio would adapt other Fujimoto works in the future. I seriously doubt Manabu would go for another high profile show from Fujimoto while juggling up CSM and JJK he's smarter than that yeah he's greedily smart but he ain't no dumbass.
Personally, I get why Ryu Nakayama would want to give a high profile Shonen Jump manga a unique style of direction. However, while a cinematic, realistic style of direction would fit with Fujimoto's core love for movies, I feel like for the actual manga, with the scratchy lineart, exaggerated character expressions and crazy designs, a heavily stylised, wild, raw and sketchy approach to the visuals would've fit much better, and solved the stylised animators not being able to work on it problem.
I feel like the realistic approach to the adaptation could've worked much better for another kind of series, maybe like Vinland Saga or something.
Many of the Japanese fans would agree with you. I personally don't mind the realistic approach but that debate is what started the whole "replace Nakayama" petition. I will say though that his approach somewhat hurts the comedy of the show but to each their own.
@@markomaksimovic7678 Yeah I agree, it does make the comedy feel less impactful.
@@markomaksimovic7678 The way I see it, the cinematic style dampens comedic moments while heightening dramatic moments
This is a take that I never really understood ( P.S read the CSM manga twice )
The art of the manga really only gets dirty/scratchy etc. when it comes to action scenes. It's pretty clean and simple apart from them ( not like Dorohedoro which is dirty 24x7 )
Along with that, the character designs, their personalities and even the world itself is very grounded and human. Fujimoto himself also keeps his art consistent throughout the entire series and there isn't exactly much exaggeration.
And that consistency and human tone is what they focussed whole-heartedly on for the anime.
I also don't really get what people were expecting comedy-wise. It's literally the same as the manga. Heck, some moments had me laughing more in the anime tbh ( eg : that one moment in the hotel arc when Power laughed at Kobeni )
Apologies for the rant, I'm just getting a little tired seeing people say that the anime is different from the manga when it honestly elevated a lot of the manga
@@badpiggy4177 True but there are also other times like when Aki and Denji are kicking katana man in the nuts and Aki says that they're playing a requiem for Himeno. It had me rolling when I read it but in the anime it's a very somber moment with sad music in the background. You could argue that I just interpreted the moment in the wrong way but honestly the manga made it seem like it was supposed to be funny and so I laughed.
I wished Mappa gave up Chainsaw Man and focused on JJK.
Wait, you think I like JJK more than Chainsaw Man? No, I just don't want my favorite manga in the hands of this unstable and crazy studio that is following the same steps of the, now totally broken, Mad House.
I don't care about jjk. I want Chainsaw Man in the hands of a studio that puts this anime in the hands of someone who actually have read and liked the manga, instead of this insane Ryuu Nakayama guy.
Have a nice day.
I didn't like chainsaw man
will the blueray fix these issues? like with the katana man fight
such a waste of potential hype
13:10 1 year is more than enough for them tbh.
now are you still gonna defend mappa after recent controversy 🤡
Did you even watch the video? This isn't a "recent" controversy. Lol.@@jayeshkumar5863
13:10 not really
many directors work on many things months a head before you ever hear of.
its common
11:25 Wrong. if anything it adds more load into prodcution if you have different styles. thays why these only kept for the EDs
different style means keeping track of all.
11:49 You need to stop looking at these studios from a fan perspective.
There is more things that goes behind the scene that just wont make the production smooth regardless if it was pre planned for how long. things get in the way~
You cant assume the production severity from these few points alone.
12:47 if the staff pulled through, it means it was not as bad actually.
There is no such thing as a perfect production pipeline ever.
9:59 i disagree. he made it a reality. good animator can have styles but better animator should able to animate somewhat realistically as well. not everyshow needs kanada crap all over
chain saw man was refreshing and i can not see a different take that works for it than this style