Jack the Ripper (Part 1) - Lemmino - Historian Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 жов 2021
- See the original video by Lemmino here - • The Enduring Mystery o...
Links:
patreon - / vth
merch store - vth-store-3.creator-spring.com/
Instagram - / vloggingthroughhistory
Discord - / discord
Twitter - / thehistoryguy25
For business inquiries contact: vloggingthroughhistory@gmail.com
my history/strategy gaming channel - / @thehistoryguy
Special Thanks to the following who are the official sponsors of this channel:
Executive Producers - John Lindley, James Book, Yani Tomov
Tier 6 - Christian Graves, Elijah Norrick, Han Pol, John Molden, Levi Stevenson, Ziv, Fernando Alonzo, Charles Glawe, Tiberiu Timo
Tier 5 - Edward Guest, Austin Powell, D-Rock, Grant Nystrom, Drunk Binary, J.E. Sandoval, John Ivester, Kieran Francke, Scott Ferguson
YT Sponsors: Insane, Scar 22, Griffen, that one guy, Driftiest follower
Tier 4 - Adam Telladira, Anthony DeFedele, Charles Grist, Derek Wohl, Graham Brown, Kelly Moneymaker, Kryštof Kotásek, Odins_Martyr, Samuel Enns, Shoulder Devil, Sándor Nagy, Scott Miller, Scripted Samurai, Jake Murphy, Rodrigo Fernandez
Tier 3 - Rafal Dubas, Matthew Calderwood, Kyle Hosea, Brandon Grams, Qethsegol, Robin Svensson, Austin White, Chris Curtis, John Molden, Peter Gadja, Raoul Kunz, Typhon, SGTMcAllen, David Storey, Cabo, Sephiroth94, Mikael Elevant, Andreas Christensen, Nate Dogg, Mathew Schrader, Nash Zahm, Jared Mackowski, Logan Cale, Stefan Garza, Zyndel Payne, Bran Flakes, Trunks, Brently Roberson, not me, Leo Strato, James Guyett, Michael Wisebaker, ZJ Johnson, Charles Schwab, WarHistoryBuffz, Wes Wilkins, The Real Larson, Samuel Elliott, J.L.Tillaeo, Joel Gilmore, Dr. Chemical
#History #TrueCrime #Reaction
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
*NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
One good point you raised, was how the regular police patrols allow us to time the murders to minutes. It always had an unfortunate problem, because officers had to walk their route in a very strict amount of time, they would regulate the pace they walked at, giving them a very distinct footstep. It's very likely to my mind, that a local resident could detect the approach of the police by the sound of their footsteps alone, giving the viral seconds needed to calmly walk away.
Anyway, fantastic video, subscribed, and look forward to seeing more
That's actually a good point. If the constables had such regulated patterns it is conceivable that they could be precisely timed and avoided.
@@Priceluked The more I think about this case, the more convinced I become that this is a vital piece of information. The regular patrol or "beat" of officers, along certain routes, must have resulted in gaps. There must have been points where for a span of 5 to 10 minutes, there would be no officer in the immediate area. I believe the risks the killer ran, were done in the knowledge that they had vital minutes to make an escape if detected.
@@ramblingthroughnature9885 While true, I think this is a point we perceive as much more important or easily overlooked than it is. It would be the case for *anyone* living in London at the time - so anyone from the police would be aware of this during their investigation.
I'm not saying you're wrong - it's an important 'feature' of the environment at the time - but the lack of mentioning this during the investigation, is because it was probably considered common knowledge. Like how you don't comment on the fact that people must've been scared during a crime - that's just an assumed fact.
This is incredibly well made. It’s as good as any “professional” documentary I have seen and better than most. Looking forward to the rest of it!
Lemmino is an amazing content creator, I highly recommend you check some of his other stuff out.
@@MBloke agreed. His content is better than TV.
Sad that some multi million companies get outdone by a UA-cam channel
@@MBloke at
I'm not a Ripperologist by any means or even really a huge fan of true crime but after watching the original video awhile back, Charles Cross/Lechmere just seems to me to be the perfect suspect. Being that close to all the victims and being at the scene of the one victim who was the least brutalized? It's circumstantial evidence but if it were a jury trial, I probably would've convicted him.
He’s definitely an intriguing suspect.
One of the most likely suspects but sadly, given the scarce evidence and lack of foresight during that time period, we will never know definitely.....
@@BHuang92 Yeah. It's sad that they never caught whoever the evil madman was in a case where modern forensics absolutely would've done so but the fact is that they didn't have the very refined high-tech tools that modern police do. We can guess but we will never be sure who he was as it's unfortunately been lost to time.
The only problem is... most of the girls were seen accompanied by a young well dressed man before their demise, not an old well dressed bearded geezer.
I also have a theory, we might not only have one "Jack the Ripper".
Same as the fake newspaper stories.
We might have an imitator. We might deal with two killers.
Wouldn't be the first time, a serial killer got copied while he was active.
Plus... there is the posability of a duo. Two killers forming a team.
One teammate is killing, while the others is the lookout.
And they take turns on the killing.
Unfortunately, we will never know.
@@HistoryNerd808 I really would not say that it would have caught him with 100% certainty. Even using much more modern forensics and technology of the time no one could capture the Zodiac killer. Just like Jack the Ripper they had suspected people but never enough evidence to prove anything.
Even with the tech of today there are still killers and murderers that are never caught or found out who they are simply due to lack of evidence to tie any suspect to the crime directly. Even modern forensics as amazing as it is it still has it's limits.
Oh, Lemmino, great channel. His Diatlov pass video is great as well.
Haven't they used techniques from animating the frozen movies to reveal a new possibility of a particular type of avalanche now?
VTH and Lemmino is the perfect youtube combo honeslty 🙏
Finally an expert who knows dates and times and names who has relevant info to add to an already accurate description of the crimes. This is the one to watch to learn the facts of the case
I had to stop the video to say that... From all the people I follow in this forum, no one is so appreciative of others work than you are! 👏🏾 Your reactions are, not only informative, but make history much more interesting. Thank you for your hard work. Does not go unnoticed ❤️❤️👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
🎯🎯
This was such a great video. Netflix needs to hire him
I enjoy listening to his videos :) Has a great disposition I suppose.
Feel like Netflix could control what he does and push him to rush out content. The guys videos are top notch, but he releases like twice a year because of it.
@@_Dingu theres an inside joke that he will upload every 2 decades 🤣
Or rather, Lemmino needs to hire Netflix :D
I disagree somewhat. I think he should receive funding and a higher budget, but I feel like Netflix would funnel him into making a worse version of his UA-cam content. I think Lemmino is probably fine where he is on UA-cam, as long people keep supporting him on Patreon I doubt he'll _need_ to be hired
"Imagine living in a place like that"
Latin americans : yeah... Imagine
I'm willing to believe that Tabram was a ripper victim.
Strangling a person to death with your bare hands is much more difficult than you would think. He probably tried on Tabram, but realized it took too long. So, he stabbed her repeatedly to shut her up. This left him drenched in blood in the middle of a random neighborhood.
He probably brought some sort of ligature or learned a better manual strangulation method for the next murder.
I was rather excited the other day when you said you were going to take this on, as I'm fascinated with the case, and part one didn't disappoint. I don't come anywhere near being a ripperologist, and I certainly haven't ever written papers on it, but I've read a decent amount about it over the years, and I feel that Tabram probably was a victim of the Ripper. I understand the doubts, but there's enough similarity to sell me. Two questions for you: 1) Since you've done so much research yourself, do you have any particular books you'd recommend on the subject? 2) As you're into historical gaming, have you ever played the game "Sherlock Holmes vs Jack the Ripper?" I don't buy their solution as being accurate, but there were a lot of interesting details in it, and it gave me a lot of stuff to check out after playing it several years ago.
Try "one autumn in whitechapel". It is a great book.
@@leeevans2964 I'm slowly working through The Complete Jack the Ripper right now, but I'll check that out. I want to get more than one author's take.
Im so glad you recognize the amazing animations & research that is done for a video like this. That and your own insights make for an amazing watch!
The quality of the video, details and animation using the locations/people coming directly from an 1888 map of London, maybe the best documentary I’ve ever seen in terms of factual story telling. Lucky that there’s someone out there that’s willing to put in the time researching and work towards perfecting his craft to put out the highest level of quality for fans/UA-cam audience in General. VTR-I also appreciate your videos, I think the world needs to learn/understand history now more than ever, and you’re ability to guide and breakdown events in your videos is the very best, thank you!
I discovered you a week ago, and I really appreciate that you actually add a lot of context and information to these already great videos.
You don't just sit there and say a couple things like most reactors, you make the already fantastic videos even better.
This is a wonderfully well-made documentary, and I was fascinated by it when I watched it earlier. Very happy to revisit this with your commentary on the side.
I've found so many great history related channels thanks to your reactions! Lemmino is awesome!
first became aware of your work recently with the american civil war videos but , after watching all three parts, this is even better, this is so easy to follow and i think is your best work so far. Its great to see so much enthusiasm tempered with logical thought process and really brought the whole thing to life. Peerless work, i hope there is more to come.
I love this series of videos on Jack the Ripper, and I love your analysis of it too. I keep coming back to watch them over and over again. Thank you for all of the content you put out. I love to get your perspective on things, and it's had an effect on me too, where I have been going back and diving more into not just the history but also the effects of what happened in the future because of it.
I loved this video. Watched the whole thing a couple weeks ago and I'm excited to hear your take on it
Was really excited to see you react to this. Lemmino is one of my favorite UA-cam research/documentary channels
This video you’re reacting to is amazing, and you add so much to it in this series. The reaction works so well in this. Best reaction series you’ve done yet.
I hope when you go to London, whenever you can, that you do a history on location for Jack the Ripper.
It's at the top of my list when I go. Gonna do a Ripper Tour and visit the gravesites & some other associated locations.
I would just love to say thank you VTH, Im a student and I never engage usually in topics of history when im in my history class, but almost every single reaction video that you post I take time out of my day to watch that shit. I believe many people on here agree with me that the oversimplifyed napoleanic series you did was the best series you ever made on this channel, and despite that, your content is continuously becoming better and better. You are doing a wonderful job keeping me entertained and taking some stress off my shoulders while I'm in school. Much love
One of the best ripper analysis ever made, and VTH does a solid job reacting and adding his own information
I love Lemmino, and I have grown to absolutely love your videos too. I'd love to see you react to even more of his content!
Every video on Vlogging through History is like a two for one deal!!! I love it!
Thanks for reacting to this! Wasn't aware of t he is channel and it's infinitely better than even big budget ripper documentaries. I'll have to check out the rest of the channel
You are amazing man! Thank you for blessing us with your knowledge, research, personality and a non-aggressive youtube comment section (mostly). Love from Brazil! Would love to see a video regarding our indigenous people pre-colonization, so much depth to our culture!
I just find jack the ripper such a key figure to london's history and with your discription on jack is amazing
One of the first sensationalized homicides in modern history.
@@BHuang92 I guess Bonnie and Clyde can be considered? They did commit a few.
It blows my mind that Jack was never caught. He was one of the first big serial killers in our history and he got away completely, even with all the exposed bodies he left behind and the creepy letters. He vanished, died long ago, and to this day everyone keeps trying to figure out who he was. He's practically a legendary figure in England's history, in my opinion.
Yes! I was waiting for your reaction to this. I'm excited to see what you'll add to this
Had to come over after hearing this was #1 on the top ten history reactions.
Did not expect you to react to this, but it's awesome you decided to.
LOVED HIS VID! Glad your reviewing this one. Welcome back bud! 👍
Fantastic video by Lemmino and good insight on top. I did a Ripper walk a few years back, and though I'd recommend it, that part of London has changed so much (for the better) since those days it's hard to imagine what it was like back then. If you do go for one, make sure you end it with a pint at the Ten Bells - a nice pub and one of the few landmarks still standing from back then and almost definitely frequented by many victims and probably Jack himself.
I took the tour when I visited London back in 2019. I gotta say I was totally surprised by how good it was. I went in expecting a poorly told story but it was the complete opposite. I also did the tour late at night so that added to the feeling of the story. 10/10 would recommend
Did the same thing in 2015, it was our first night in London and weren’t 100% on using the Underground. Kind of scary getting home that night!
I know the exact tour you’re talking about. Did it in 2017. Amazing tour.
This is soooo good watching it again. He's so right, this is the definitive docu on jack the ripper
Thanks VTH I’ve been waiting for this video and I can assure you that it’s very good, and I am deeply sorry for your loss.
Congratulations on this video! Haha! Only 7 hours in and the stats are great for you! Always happy to see your channel do well!
gosh, this is incredible. really well made! nice to see you react to that. i am gonna give this guy a follow as well!
I love watching your videos. It’s feels like a campfire where we all are watching and reacting. :))
thank you thank you thank you for this video, been waiting for some time for this video and you upload it after i had a tough day, thanks a lot
The Jack the Ripper tours are wonderful, walking London at night really gives you a sense of the atmosphere these people had to traverse each night. I also highly recommend checking out the animals in war memorial in London for your next trip. Just outside of Hyde Park, a touching tribute to the animals that served and died in all conflicts.
Long time fan of your stuff. Historical true crime reactions or shows of yours own should totally be a thing. This documentary is so neat in it's presentation. This is gonna be a fun watch.
It really speaks to how good Lemmino’s work is that I’m interested in seeing a reaction video on it.
First time watching your show within a month of it being posted. Caught up on all your content. Look forward to commenting again to add to the conversation
I am not sure about his process, or how many people are working on that channel, but this has to be one of the highest quality productions on the whole platform. It easily outshines most, if not all, UA-cam Red channels or series out there. All the videos of his that I watched, even though not dealing with any new information and most people knowing all there is to know, still manages to captivate for every single second of the video. It's beyond impressive.
Absolutely. Would love to see Netflix or some other network use some of his stuff. It's good enough to be on those platforms.
So glad to see you enjoy his content so much
Great video! Hope part two comes soon!
OMFGOODNESS I had no idea about ANY of this. I’ve heard the term “Jack the Ripper” but didn’t have any idea what it was about until you told me about these videos! Which are great, BTW. Terrifying. But great. 😂
This video is amazing, as are all of yours. Please watch more Lemmino in the future. Thank you
Always good to see a new video.
Been waiting for you to get to this video, so excited to watch
In England and Wales (NI has something similar to E&W, but Scotland has its own ancient systems of laws), an inquest (like a public enquiry) is always held by a coroner, a crown official position going back to the 11th century, where someone has died in sudden or "unusual" circumstances. It doesn't start with the assumption of guilt somewhere, it looks to see whether any foul play has actually taken place - and if it hasn't then appropriate procedures are followed and if it has then the case will go on to the court system for trial. It's always done publicly to show the people that no "funny business" or cover up is going on by the authorities. It also gives the chance for anyone who has any information about the matter to step forward and give their evidence. Firstly to examine all the evidence and testimony available and to determine whether someone died through natural causes, suicide, accidental death or murder etc. In the last case to determine whether or not someone (even if unidentified) needs to be brought to justice. So, they may come to the conclusion that the death was by "natural causes" or "accidental death" or by "person or persons unknown" (i.e. manslaughter or murder by an unknown assailant) etc. If they determine that death was by "person or persons unknown" (as would be obvious in the Ripper killings) the fact that the coroner's court had determined it as such would then mean that the intention would be then to bring the perpetrator to justice in a full trial, either for manslaughter or murder - however, with the Ripper killings it would be pretty obvious it was murder. This may sound a silly waste of time, but of course especially in the past and even today, especially in cases such as poisonings with things like sleeping drugs etc, it might be quite hard to determine whether or not the person had taken it themself intentionally to kill themself (suicide), accidentally overdosed (death by accidental causes), just died anyway (death by natural causes), or was given it accidentally by someone without meaning to kill them (manslaughter), or someone gave it to them intentionally with the sole purpose of killing them (murder). So the Coroner's inquest is held to determine what has happened, what evidence is available and as a result of that come to the conclusion whether or not anyone needs to be brought to trial.
The only thing I would add to this excellent summary is that usually these days, if foul play is strongly suspected, the inquest is usually opened and adjourned until the police have investigated . If the case doesn’t go to a trial then the inquest would at least provide an explanation of what happened. Inquests become important when the reason someone died is contentious. Was it a simple accident or was it due to someone’s negligence for example. Or if someone was murdered but the death could have been prevented if authorities had taken different actions. Very often this happens in terrorist attacks for example. There is often a jury and they ultimately decide what happened. This can mean that the police or others have to open investigations or can be publicly embarrassed and have to review procedures.
I took a Jack the Ripper tour last month and witnessing the key sights of the case was surreal.
It still amazed me this guy went from memes and top ten videos to making AMAZING documentaries.
wishing you all a great day, you too Chris, I know you have been through a hard time recently, I hope things get better
I love learning more about Jack the Ripper
Much love to you and yours during these trying times sir
I’m a history teacher, by occupation. I spent hours upon hours studying JTR in college, and the years following, even lately. The time period is fascinating to me, in addition to the mystery. I am super anxious to hear who you think the ripper is! I have my top suspicions, so cannot wait fo see if yours are the same.
I also think this video is well done, love that he includes a map to document the paths of the victims and police. I also really enjoyed the series "Ripper Street"!
Good job Chris love your channel!
That video is so well done! 👌
32:55 I think an important detail to note about Annie Chapman and the killer going to that yard in particular is that, according to the inquest deposition of John Davis (a tenant who had recently moved into the place with his family and was the first to discover her body), neither the door looking out to the street nor the door going into the backyard could be locked or firmly shut. He also mentioned that anyone who "knows where the latch on the front door is could open it", so even though it seems like 29 Hanbury St was a private residence with a couple tenants, you again can kinda see the level of poverty and overcrowding in Whitechapel at the time, that no one had yet decided to try and either fix the door locks or even just add them on so complete strangers wouldn't just walk in off the street, which seems to have been a not infrequent occurrence, and what likely happened in the case of the murder.
I really believe that Martha Tabram is definitely a Ripper Victim. In fact I think she was the first. Stabbing is easier than slashing and so I think the killer went with stabbing because it was easier and he was just experiencing the gory aspect of killing someone maybe for the first time. That is why it wasn't his typical MO was because it was fast and he wasn't thinking about it as much. In fact personally I think there is more evidence for Tabram being ripper victim than Elizabeth Stride. That's not to say that I think Stride wasn't a ripper victim I think she was also its just I think there is more evidence for Tabram being a ripper victim than there is Stride. I think that savage stabbing that was done was in the same spirit of the more methodical mutilations that came after. But I'm not an expert on this stuff I just wanted to throw my two cents in from the limited research I've done.
Whilst I agree Tabram is definitely a Ripper victim and that she was perhaps the first, 39 stab wounds is definitely A LOT. "Jack" may have gone after her first as a personal thing, liked it, and continued. Less brutal due to no personal relation, but brutal nonetheless.
I love your content i hope i can become a member of your patreon soon
Amazing content!
Great reaction, great video!
also i amazed people still havent discovered lemmino, he's been making top tier docs for years
On Netflix, Murdoch Mysteries is a Canadian show starting around that time (but in Toronto, CA). Really interesting to see how murder investigations were done in that time.
There's also an episode with a mimicker of Jack the Ripper in Toronto
Enjoy the content. Not much to say, commenting to appease the algorithm.
Keep up the good work.
This makes me appreciate having a watch a lot
Actually, a coroner's inquest is something that technically still exists in America as well. They are pretty rare but can be invoked when the cause of death is uncertain.
even though i know already wat that née means... for a long time i was clueless and no one explained it ever in a video like you just did... so thanks for taking the time and explaining stuff like that. i know it helped me in some other videos of yours where i didn´t know what you were explaining
If I may add, it's simply French for "born"
nice, lemino is a great youtuber
Great video, Chris and one of my favorite topics.
Could you react to the video Memoirs of WW2 #15?
Very excited for this I know almost nothing about Jack the Ripper
And notifications squad
Favourite part of reaction videos
Pauses to talk about a detail retated to the pick
the video mentions it 5 seconds later
Lol I enjoy it! You can tell he's excited and hoping information isnt being left out and happily surprised when a second later Lemmino covers it.
I've been waiting for this oh my goodness yes.
and i recently played Sherlock holmes vs Jack the ripper lol. laughed as he said "that is impossible" when dark annie time of death was mentioned because one of the major puzzles was fixing up the time of death
lemmino is making the best history documentaries
History + mystery, couldn't GET more interesting!
Fun & Well made video sir!
Your videos are the only "Reaction" content that I believe is acceptable.
You're not just slapping your face on someone's video and saying "damn, that's crazy" when it gets interesting.
You're adding a lot to the video by giving the broader historical context, keep it up!
Wow, a great content creator made great content and another great content creator altered it with pauses and contributions of information that gives a new take on the viewing experience. Transformative content is neat!
i saw a doc on Jack the Ripper when i was 6. i still remember the sketches they showed of the bodies...
part 2 of the best collab ever
Very good analysis, a lot of the biggest mainstream you tubers who cover these events over emphasize small details like Buzzfeed Unsolved emphasizing the surgical ability which takes these theories into one sole direction that ignores other facts
It's no wonder Lemmino uploads so infrequently. His production quality is beyond top-notch. Must take a ton of time.
Not just production, but meticulous research.
Not just research, but captivating writing
Such good work
This and the other parts to this documentary are really interesting, thank you for your reactions to it. You have mentioned Ripper Street - a really excellent series - but I wonder if you have seen the series Whitechapel with Rupert Prenry Jones. It’s connecting thread is the crimes all happen in Whitechapel and are based on historical ones carried out there. The first series centres on a modern day killer who models the murders on Jack the Ripper. The second revolves around the Kray twins and possible twin offspring who are determined to continue their parent’s reign of terror. The third series the killer carries out historical copycat murders. (Look out for Shaun Evans of Endeavour fame.) The fourth series is not quite as good as the others and wanders slightly into the realms of witches and warlock fantasy.
I saw a programme, which unfortunately I can not remember the name of, about two years ago where a great-granddaughter of Mary Ann Nicholas was interviewed. Along with the descendants of others involved in the investigation of the murders.
Re coroner courts in the UK: any unexplained or suspicious death is referred to the coroner court for determination. At one time if the death was determined to be murder and information had been put forward as to who might be the likely suspect the coroner’s jury could name them. This law was changed in about 1978 after a coroner’s jury named Lord Lucan as the murderer of his children’s nanny. (He disappeared the night of the murder and has never been found.) Now they can only bring in a verdict of murder by person or person unknown.
Inquests were held in the U.S., typically without representation which is why is faded out. The Lizzie Borden case is a good example.
Really dope intro🔥🔥
Fantastic! Have you considered taking a look at the Franklin expedition?
definitely something we'll do at some point.
How the final murder was done always gives me the creeps
Yeah, it's pretty horrifying.
I’m definitely intrigued by this case. I’m definitely wanting to know more since I know a small bit. And fun coincidence is Annie the second victim was killed the day my birthday falls on September 8th I wonder if that’s why this case draws me in hehe. Definitely would love to see the tour definitely would if I ever travel to London!
It actually IS the definitive Ripper documentary. It's insane this content is available universally.
It is really well done for sure but with the reaction it's perfection
I should not have begun watching this at 4:30 in the morning. The detailed nature of that video is far too immersive, hot damn. Gotta check out the channel.
I don’t know how much you know about D. B. Cooper, but Lemmino’s video on him is PHENOMENAL and I would LOVE to see you react to it.
I love Ripper Street. It's a great show with a great cast. Matthew Macfadyen, Jerome Flynn(Bronn from GoT), Clive Russell (Blackfish from GoT), Matthew Lewis(Neville Longbottom), Joseph Mawle(Benjen from GoT), Ian McElhinney(Barristan Selmy from GoT). Wow! I just realized how many GoT actors were on this show.
Please react more brother to Lemmino. He is really good at documentaries and you explain very clear make it more interesting and educational. Well done Sir!
great stuff