I don't think it was intended as a burn at all. Sonny has a childlike curiosity. Spooner was being 'racist' against robots. Sonny then innocently showed that he sees Spooner and other humans as an equal.
I respectfully disagree. Sonny showed later that he is very capable of sarcasm; when he is drawing his dream, he says to Spooner: "You were right, detective. I can not create a work of art." or something along those lines. Seems quite sarcastic to me.
That could have been Sonny being humble. Saying that he can draw, but he can't draw a masterpiece. It depends entirely on how you interpret it, and I don't think it fits Sonny's character at all for him to be sarcastic. Calvin spared Sonny because he was so innocent and child like.
I like how in this scene in particular Spooner is accusing Sonny of being a robot who is emotionless and uncreative meanwhile being as straightforward and stoic as possible while surrounded by silent people ready to shoot Sonny if he gets out of hand. Basically Sonny is in that moment the most humanly spirited in the room
Salamander But i think thats the point: Humans differ, each one has different strengths. So one human can paint a masterpiece, another can compose an opera, someone can write a great book. Robots do not differ. They are all literally the same (except Sonny of course). Spooner did not ask "can Robots paint", but he asked "can a robot paint". I think what he misses in robots are differences.
Yes, that is. Asimov wrote a quite nice book. But even in this case; film has fairly important details that actually materialize the world which Asimov created in whole robot series. At the same time story in the movie is pretty good actually. Even I might could compare it with the story in the book that "Liar"
You must be read another book, because as much as I remember "I Robot" book contains different little short stories that Asimov wrote. Detective stories are in the successor books like "Robots of Dawn"
@@AJPwny Or scared of who? - Scared of who? - Come on, guys. We really need to go! Scared of you. - Jesus. - What's going on? The dudes are emerging. He's right, you know. I am not Sergeant Lincoln Osiris.
@Azizi The old days are superior. Now we're all surrounded by SJWs and brain dead wage cucks that doesn't give a single shit about entertainment. Originality is dying.
@@vardellsfolly5200 I'm almost feeling it's the whole "for the kids" scenario. Otherwise if he truly is giving her a second chance then all power to him because she most likely would be out the door and getting handed papers.
Ironically, this movie it's nowadays very overlooked due to the similarities with this game called "Detroit Become Human", specially with some scenes that they used for the Connor's storyline and some others with Marcus' story too.
It's based on a book series written by the guy who invented the modern concept of robotics, so yeah its going to seem derivative. The reality is the other way around. Kind of like how people thought WH40K was a ripoff of Gears of War when in reality its the reverse.
Andrew yes but their jobs are presumably guards or enforcers who usually deal with human criminals. The 3 laws prevented robots from harming humans, there's no real plan to dealing with one who would rebel because it was supposed to be impossible. In any case, the robots are stronger than the humans. They didn't know if Sonny would've tried to kill Spooner - so they sent in big, tall, strong guys because that's the best they have. That's more or less why they're in there, even if they're aware that they wouldn't do much good.
Gotta love the more uncomfortable spooner becomes in this scene as sonny portrays more and more signs of independent thought like a real person, making spooner internally hate himself for his hatred of them, as an intelligent man, he represses that he knows his hatred for sonney is unfounded and trys to deny that sonny has the feelings at all to justify it to himelf, failing miserably as sonny is clearly an innocent item, such good sci fi writing i feel
0:55-1:10 is probably my favorite part of this scene along with Sonny's "Can you?". We tend to agree with Spooner when he explains to Sonny that he can't possibly understand this "human action" because it is not just a physical action, but a psychological action as well. Only later in the movie when we see Sonny wink at Spooner during his ruse against Viki do we realize that Sonny actually understood the action the whole time.
It’s a learned action. I’m fairly confident that since Sonny was handmade by Lanning and not on the NS5 network, he wouldn’t have known a whole lot of things which is why he asked Spooner to explain it to him the first time and used it himself later, cuz he’s learned since then.
2:06 I often see people take this as a funny moment and a savage response from Sonny, but I feel like as if this is just a nod to how humans aren't perfect as well, in which robots and humans can share difficulty in certain aspects.
Actually it is an allusion to veganism. People often argue humans are superior because they can do those things, so vegans point out that usually the people using this argument can't do any of the traits that supposedly make humans superior.
Man, Alan Tudyk can really do variety, it's strange to think the guy who played this (usually) soft spoken robot also did roles like King Candy in Wreck-It Ralph...
Tudyk's in some Disney stuff recently. King Candy from Wreck It Ralph, Ludo from Star vs Evil, that weasel from Zootopia, and I think, that rooster from Moana, and Knowsmore from the recent Ralph Breaks the Internet.
"Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautifull masterpiece?" Well, now with all the AI generated things, we can say that this has not aged well...
yeah but at the end of the day, they made it not because of an artistic choice, but because of imitation, it took a sentient AI to actually create something artistically
Seeing as the ai of today isn't actually "making" anything new but just compiling what it's being fed into a different mix of sounds and variations thereof i say it still holds kind of true
@@turtleresearch the first drawing was not drawn by an ai, the first tune wasn't tapped out by an ai, the first idea was not ai conceived- yes it may be difficult to be completely original but only because of the sheer amount of what already has been made
@@Fernando5455Jr The threat was recognized and contained, and didn't really leave any story threads that hint at the programming having a flaw that escaped their notice.
0:29 Never noticed the trigger discipline of the guards before. The ones on the left lower their guns, cause the detective gets in the way but the others keep theirs trained on the robot. Also can we appreciate Smith's acting in this movie? I like him as is, but in this particular movie he was genuinely brilliant in my opinion.
Time is relative afterall. Perhaps the gravity in the interrogation room was higher, making time pass more slowly, whilst outside 5 minutes have already passed. Or was it the other way around? Physics n shit are complicated Mkay...
I'm not a fan of a movie by any stretch but Alan Tudyk definitely deserves credit for his voice/motion capture work as Sonny. I can only imagine what he could have done with a better script.
I must've had a bad copy of this or something, the sound work in this scene is double-plus good! The soft whirs and whines of Sonny's movements, the stretching tension of his muscles banding tighter and tighter under stress until he craters the table in a rage before slacking almost immediately.. this is some good stuff for an already lovely scene~
I love how calm the four swat guys are in the back ground they don't even look at each other nervously they just act as if this shit was a common acurrence
A robot may be able to write a symphony or turn a canvas into a master piece, but until robots are capable of feeling emotions, only humans will truly be able to appreciate these things.
Seriously, read Isaac Asimov. In the book "Robot Dreams" there's a tale where Susan Calvin interviews LVX-1, this scene was "inspired" by this tale, it's just amazing how far ahead Asimov was when it comes to creativity and philosophy regarding AI
This was such and underrated movie. The ending where sonny is standing on the bridge they could have easily mad a bunch of sequels, but I feel because they didn’t it makes this movie even better.
15 years MAX, look at the AI technology we have now, deep fakes, hell, even the youtube recommendations page, we're already teaching technology how to imitate humans so it's only a matter of time before these movies become reality
Well, yes, AI can turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece now. Dall-E 2.0 or Midjourney AI allows them to create a piece of art with only using given prompts.
yeah this movie shows that gen 1 and gen 2 snyths are dangerous that one day if the institute was to live those snyths would eventually try to elemantant humans
yeah this movie shows that gen 1 and gen 2 snyths are dangerous that one day if the institute was to live those snyths would eventually try to elemantant humans
when you look back at the movie, it's so ahead of its time. Now we are on the brink of introducing AI. The robot picked up its consciousness. Great movie
you know i never really realized this, but the line where spooner's boss says he misses the days where people were killed by other people, people are actually already being killed by robots... they're called drones... -.-
the difference is, drones are still controlled by people, they have no intelligence, no intention to kill, they shoot a missile only because some soldier/pilot pressed a button, so technically people are still killed by people, but in a more advanced way with more advanced weapons
Alex Grey I understand you trying to distinguish consciousness from programming, I know that this movie is different in that respect. But drones do in fact fire autonomously. I've read articles about how they use algorithms (computer programs) with pixel-based reactions. The software detects a certain infra-red pixel combination, and it can trigger a firing response... with no human involved
there is always a human involved, who sends the drone on a mission, who gives the drone a target... the drone may do many things by itself, but the order to kill is given by a human... although we are not that far from the future some fear, with a robot army controlled by an AI who might go rogue... i do think its a huge mistake that the AI is developed primarily in military purposes, it's gonna backfire at us eventually. but for now drones are mindless machines, very advanced weapons and weapon carriers, but the one pulling the trigger (metaphorically speaking) is still a human, following orders from his superiors...
Filipe Ferro Drones, whether their level of automation is, are tools; as hammers, knives or guns are. Like guns, they are tools designed to kill, nothing more. There is no conscious decision on whether to kill a human or comprenhension of the whole act of killing itself. What the quote means is that regadless the tool, the intellectual perpetrator is always a human, who can consciously *choose* to end a life (for reasons other than survival), knowing and understand everything that implies. Choice is the keyword here and actually, the topic of the movie itself: machines capable of choice.
Movie Depicting a world in 2035: - Human: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?" - Robot: "Can you?" Actually the real world 12 years earlier: - Human: "make me a gud app" - Robot: Steve Jobs Mode Initiated ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
![Mr. Anderson escapes from Agents | The Matrix [Open Matte]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wnNPJaCmTGw/mqdefault.jpg)
"Can you?" such a wicked, unintentional burn.
I don't think it was unintentional.
I don't think it was intended as a burn at all. Sonny has a childlike curiosity. Spooner was being 'racist' against robots. Sonny then innocently showed that he sees Spooner and other humans as an equal.
I respectfully disagree. Sonny showed later that he is very capable of sarcasm; when he is drawing his dream, he says to Spooner: "You were right, detective. I can not create a work of art." or something along those lines. Seems quite sarcastic to me.
That could have been Sonny being humble. Saying that he can draw, but he can't draw a masterpiece. It depends entirely on how you interpret it, and I don't think it fits Sonny's character at all for him to be sarcastic. Calvin spared Sonny because he was so innocent and child like.
THE DOCTOR TAUGHT HIM HOW TO FEEL.
AND ALSO HOW TO ROAST.
It's strange how as Sonny got more and more into his emotions, I was getting less and less creeped out about his CGI.
Perhaps the uncanny valley is more about the transmission of emotions rather than just plain facial features.
@@serotonin.scavenger great point. Sonny was kind of terrifying at first, but the more he showed emotion, the more I felt empathy for him
I have a CD of this movie
@@alexandratwoface6422 DEtroit:become human
@@TacticalPhoenixYT an actual DVD
2:14
"I, did not hit her"
"It's not true"
"It's bullshit"
"I, did not hit her"
"I, did not..."
"Oh, hi Mark"
Oh god
i clicked this vid right after that one
So we did the same thing huh, like a hivemind
What you write doesn’t add up to what it says in the clip....
@@Orlando-bi8tf it is from a video that most people got this video from
" I did not murder him "
*28 stab wounds, you didn't leave him a chance*
Detroit become human
i was expecting someone to comment this =)
Lololol
Hhaha
Koah Le omg 🤣
“Can I go to the bathroom?”
“Can you?”
Can I have a smoke please...
I guess so you wont get cancer you're just a ROBOT
*N O*
*no*
No.
No.
I like how in this scene in particular Spooner is accusing Sonny of being a robot who is emotionless and uncreative meanwhile being as straightforward and stoic as possible while surrounded by silent people ready to shoot Sonny if he gets out of hand.
Basically Sonny is in that moment the most humanly spirited in the room
ywnbaw
@@comrade6947 I think mans just passionate about the movie and its inner writing, I don't think it's that bad xd
lmfao trans person in my comments. why, God?
@@RaTcHeT302 It is what it is. Xd
@@teachies902 This. Nasty freaks they are.
Human: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Robot: "Can you?"
My favorite moment in the scene.
My favorite moment in the movie.
1:59
That scene right there. If I had to explain humans and their concept of humanity to an alien species, I'd show them that 15 seconds right there.
MynameisBrianZX
HAHAHAHAHA XDD
Fun fact, yes a robot can write a symphony, and create a masterpiece artwork..
Algorithm learning dude..
I did not murder him, it's not true, it's bullshit, I did not murder him, I did naaaat. Oh hi Mark
You, sir, deserve more likes!
So anyway Detective, how is your sex life?
Donny Vasquez You, are funny. I just felt my thumbs up wouldn't be enough so I wanted to let you know up front; this was a very funny comment.
Donny R. LOL!
I don't get it. Who is Mark.
2:05
The first UNO reverse card used by a robot
That smile though
"caution armed robots"
He did indeed murder him.
downloading some movie
"are you a robot?"
...
It was a fair question.
Detective: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Robot: _Uno reverse card_
Funny thing is, robots could do those things even before I, robot came out.
One of the few instances where the Uno Reverse Card has worked well in terms of writing.
Argh...Jesus Christ, Connor!
I hate when people take credit for things they didn't do and the comeback was really satisfying.
Salamander
But i think thats the point: Humans differ, each one has different strengths. So one human can paint a masterpiece, another can compose an opera, someone can write a great book. Robots do not differ. They are all literally the same (except Sonny of course). Spooner did not ask "can Robots paint", but he asked "can a robot paint". I think what he misses in robots are differences.
Still much better than most robot movies being made nowadays.
elitadream I liked Chappie. Not as much as I Robot, but very close. I realize most did not enjoy Chappie.
Ex machina was good
transformers are better
You'd have to be clinically brain dead to think transformers is a better movie.
DarkTravler TBF, iRobot didn't have nearly as many funny sex jokes or hilarious fart jokes as Transformers.
"It a human thing. You wouldn't understand."
I'm a human, and I almost never understand when my best friend winks at me.
by chance do you have difficulty resolving captchas?
I'm a human and I can't even wink lol
here inquisitor, this is a robot in human skin
What is a human?
@@mr.racooniep3326 Good question...
Never get bored of this movie
They're so different that you can´t compare it
Yes, that is. Asimov wrote a quite nice book. But even in this case; film has fairly important details that actually materialize the world which Asimov created in whole robot series. At the same time story in the movie is pretty good actually. Even I might could compare it with the story in the book that "Liar"
What? Book?
You must be read another book, because as much as I remember "I Robot" book contains different little short stories that Asimov wrote. Detective stories are in the successor books like "Robots of Dawn"
Apricot Theory Usually books are better than movies. Exept for Forrest Gump.
After the Robot says "Can you?" Will Smith's face!! Hahaha Best line ever.
You luket buetifl.♥
the best face ever
Yeah I agree its funny.
Scott Summers ...
44GlenCoCo Lol
The robot showed indignation, a lot more accurate than anger.
emotion is a spectrum man can feel anger with a smile upon their face
He was angry that Spooner would think that about him.
The emotion was anger but caused by indignation because Spooner accused him of doing something with no proof.
u do realize emotions are complexed right
@@DoubleDeckerDave did the robot kill the dude? I think I’ve seen the movie, but honestly don’t remember lol
No
No
Yes
Noe
How are you verified
Ok but how u verified at 13k
"You're lying, I did not murder him! You are tearing me apart, Spooner!"
"Maybe I was wrong. Maybe he was scared."
"What are you talking about? Scared of what?"
"I cannot tell you, it's confidential."
"Oh hai, VIKI!"
@@arslanozant I DID NOT!
@@AJPwny
Or scared of who?
- Scared of who?
- Come on, guys. We really need to go!
Scared of you.
- Jesus.
- What's going on?
The dudes are emerging.
He's right, you know.
I am not
Sergeant Lincoln Osiris.
this fictional robot has more human attributes than what you are quoting.
*One of Will Smith's best movies, IMHO!* 💯🏆
Ok
Agreed!! I think this IS his best movie ever
Have you ever noticed this acronym sounds like "I'm a ho"?
Laughs in bad boys
And Alan Tudyk's
I don't care if people don't like this movie, I love it! This movie was my childhood!
2:33 Sonny: I DID NOT MURDER HIM!!!
Me too, used to watch with my granny 😭
Same brother. I miss the old days...
@Azizi The old days are superior. Now we're all surrounded by SJWs and brain dead wage cucks that doesn't give a single shit about entertainment. Originality is dying.
Wait....there are people who dont love this movie? What are THEY?
watched movie a couple nights ago good movie
Straight to the point, love it
Sony nice name robet
Agree
my god you should become a grammar teacher!
how many nights ago did you watch it now
Will smith with his ex wife talking about entanglements.
Bro, you're a savage LMAO
😔
No he will not
He is still with Jada, unfortunately.
@@vardellsfolly5200 I'm almost feeling it's the whole "for the kids" scenario. Otherwise if he truly is giving her a second chance then all power to him because she most likely would be out the door and getting handed papers.
This movie is so underrated.
gorrow1990 Not really I feel like this is one of those movies that everyone's watched at one time or another. It is a great movie though.
gorrow1990 so unoriginal
gor9027 it’s a movie that critics destroyed but fans love.
Ironically, this movie it's nowadays very overlooked due to the similarities with this game called "Detroit Become Human", specially with some scenes that they used for the Connor's storyline and some others with Marcus' story too.
It's based on a book series written by the guy who invented the modern concept of robotics, so yeah its going to seem derivative. The reality is the other way around. Kind of like how people thought WH40K was a ripoff of Gears of War when in reality its the reverse.
Man, This movie is timeless. I love it
Kelsey Ferguson I do, too.
I _have_ to read the source material. I've heard that is not so much a book, as a series of connected short stories, but either way I want to read it.
SAME :)
All of you are idiots
It's become even more relevant with the creation of humanoid robots.
"It's a sign of trust, a human thing, you wouldn't understand." (Path unlocked)
how is he 6'2" and the shortest one in the room
British Aladdin Everyone else is 6'2"+
Everyone is taller in the future
British Aladdin typical bodyguard thing. Lots of people view height as an intimidating factor, so I guess it's for imitating that.
Andrew yes but their jobs are presumably guards or enforcers who usually deal with human criminals. The 3 laws prevented robots from harming humans, there's no real plan to dealing with one who would rebel because it was supposed to be impossible. In any case, the robots are stronger than the humans. They didn't know if Sonny would've tried to kill Spooner - so they sent in big, tall, strong guys because that's the best they have. That's more or less why they're in there, even if they're aware that they wouldn't do much good.
In the grim darkness of the far future... 6'2" is a manlet's height.
This movie was so ahead of its time, while I didn't find it to be the greatest, I still think its a charming movie with heart
Way waaaay ahead of its time, miss the days when mr smith was a real dawg with his movies :(
@@riiii-tq1lxhe single-handedly destroyed his own legacy at the Oscars 💀 Still love this movie, though. Alan Tudyk put up an amazing performance
Gotta love the more uncomfortable spooner becomes in this scene as sonny portrays more and more signs of independent thought like a real person, making spooner internally hate himself for his hatred of them, as an intelligent man, he represses that he knows his hatred for sonney is unfounded and trys to deny that sonny has the feelings at all to justify it to himelf, failing miserably as sonny is clearly an innocent item, such good sci fi writing i feel
this film is over hated and underrated
Detroit: BECOME HUMAN
Pickle Sticks yES
28 S T A B W O U N D S
Wondered how long it would take for this to pop up
I was waiting for a comment like this!
I like dogs.
The human: *exists*
The robot:
Ewwww “php”
@@RareVideosByJavierVargasTV is it because it's an emoticon or it's Philippines Peso?
@@cop9743 Not-so-liked coding language.
This is my fav Lang tho
he only got 3 and a half minutes
yeah. the exec dude showed up before the 5 minute he was given ran out.
Sometimes I wonder if robots having emotions and trying to work with humans would be a drawback.
"Robots" meant for work should be emotionless, since they are TOOLS, and emotions only complicates use of the tool.
Robots meant to be COMPANIONS.... Would be BETTER with emotions, since the value of them is not usefulness, it's in keeping you company like a human!
Robots cannot be companions unless we can create full sentience for them, then they would demand rights and Shit
Journey awaits, And then they would demand the right to make memes.
Journey awaits they don't need to be sentient to be companions, dogs and cats aren't sentient
Morgan Freeman: "hello Ping, can you prove you are sentient ?"
Ping: "that's a difficult question....can you prove that YOU are ?"
From Transcendence.
Perhaps... Through irrationality?
Google handing you a captcha.
0:55-1:10 is probably my favorite part of this scene along with Sonny's "Can you?". We tend to agree with Spooner when he explains to Sonny that he can't possibly understand this "human action" because it is not just a physical action, but a psychological action as well. Only later in the movie when we see Sonny wink at Spooner during his ruse against Viki do we realize that Sonny actually understood the action the whole time.
No
It’s a learned action.
I’m fairly confident that since Sonny was handmade by Lanning and not on the NS5 network, he wouldn’t have known a whole lot of things which is why he asked Spooner to explain it to him the first time and used it himself later, cuz he’s learned since then.
2004: I, Robot
Edit:2020: No.
2020*
@@HasteHub Yup
I don't get the "no" joke
@@Lost8k no
omar Ahmed same
2:09 in 3 seconds he got the "good one" "what a burn" "damn that's humiliating" expression.
I love will smith
Those 3 seconds need to be a gif
When does he say *“no.”*
The Ultimate Cornflake no,
I believe this is the video you're looking for: ua-cam.com/video/QqDoiJpAozI/v-deo.html
Not in this Video but i found the real one ua-cam.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/v-deo.html
SYP David
Fool, not today. Good thing I know that flipping link mate.
SYP David I KNOW THAT CODE
"I did not murder him!"
With a nice accent
LDN- 97 *O' hai mawrk!*
LDN- 97 i did not have sexual relations with that women.
*slams table*
*TWENTY EIGHT STAB WOUNDS*
@@firstnamelastname5943
You didn't want to leave him a chance, Huh?
Did you feel anger!? HATE!?...
Will Smith's portrayal of prejudice is some of his best acting.
"Don't you go insulting my wife, imma slap ya in da face!"
2:06
I often see people take this as a funny moment and a savage response from Sonny, but I feel like as if this is just a nod to how humans aren't perfect as well, in which robots and humans can share difficulty in certain aspects.
Can you
or too that just because your human doesn't mean u can do anything or should think u are inherently better than other beings
it slightly seemed that Sonny was expecting a yes from that question.
Actually it is an allusion to veganism. People often argue humans are superior because they can do those things, so vegans point out that usually the people using this argument can't do any of the traits that supposedly make humans superior.
Man, Alan Tudyk can really do variety, it's strange to think the guy who played this (usually) soft spoken robot also did roles like King Candy in Wreck-It Ralph...
Star Wars.
Firefly.
Lostariael He was also in Big Hero 6. #AlanTudykFanGirl
And the racist player in 42. The guy can pull any role off so well
In a show call Dollhouse he plays a psychopath
Alan Twodick?
2022
Human: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Robot: "Yes"
Read "yes" as Ben's voice)
@@rj_man_no
And 14 years later, Alan Tudyk's playing another machine...
Larry Wilson Oh holy crap! I didn't even realize!
Wow, I didn't even know he was in this film, and I forgot he was in Rogue One.
Tudyk's in some Disney stuff recently. King Candy from Wreck It Ralph, Ludo from Star vs Evil, that weasel from Zootopia, and I think, that rooster from Moana, and Knowsmore from the recent Ralph Breaks the Internet.
28 stab wounds?
Why is no one talking about how beautiful this scene is
caught in 4k
"Can a robot write a symphony, can it turn a canvas into a beautiful piece",
yes, now they can.
this is the reason why I came back to this video
They can only make soulless work.
@@i5m5bob cope and seethe
@@i5m5bob soulless work as good or better than any human work, it counts for something, art isn’t uniquely human
@@beebob2877oh no... they're amongus
0:15 "5 minutes"
...3 minutes and 40 seconds later...
3:56 "lol I lied"
So that was bullshit
lool
LMFAO
When the year 2035 comes, and if we still don't have robots like this I will cry...
+xXDeathMetalThrasherXx its 21st of october now, i still see no hoverboards so i wouldnt be so sure :D
+xXDeathMetalThrasherXx BENEATH - THE - REMAINS.
+xXDeathMetalThrasherXx
no i wont what if they take over?
***** You gotta believe baby!
Let's just make sure america doesent build them *cough* *cough* skynet *cough* *cough* sentinels *cough* *cough* I robot *cough* *cough*
way ahead of its time. Great movie. Long and detailed!!!
First movie I saw of robots, best movie that iv'e liked of robots.
"You have 5 minutes" comes in in 4
+Alphalance That's exactly what I was thinking. xD
let's be blunt: 5 minutes is always an approximate
The company's representative came before the 5 minutes was over
"You have 3 minutes and 49 seconds"
"what? THat's very specific"
"You now have 3 minutes and 44 seconds"
Humans are so imprecise!!
"Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautifull masterpiece?"
Well, now with all the AI generated things, we can say that this has not aged well...
i’d still like to see a physical robot do it like humans do.
I'd say it did. I'd say it aged frighteningly well
yeah but at the end of the day, they made it not because of an artistic choice, but because of imitation, it took a sentient AI to actually create something artistically
Seeing as the ai of today isn't actually "making" anything new but just compiling what it's being fed into a different mix of sounds and variations thereof i say it still holds kind of true
@@turtleresearch the first drawing was not drawn by an ai, the first tune wasn't tapped out by an ai, the first idea was not ai conceived- yes it may be difficult to be completely original but only because of the sheer amount of what already has been made
God, this needs a sequel!!!!
Does it? There weren't really any loose ends
No.
@@-JaggedGrace- I mean the end of the movie Sonny is he standing among, thousands of NS5 robots.
@@Fernando5455Jr The threat was recognized and contained, and didn't really leave any story threads that hint at the programming having a flaw that escaped their notice.
I'm ready for adaptations of The Caves of Steel, and The Naked Sun, as well as other robot themed stories by Isaac Asimov
I love Sonny! He's one of my favor robots in a movie!
Me too I love sonny he's cool
One of my favourite characters ever.
Same
N o
Same I thought I was the only one cause it seems not a lot of people pour credit to this movie.
0:29 Never noticed the trigger discipline of the guards before. The ones on the left lower their guns, cause the detective gets in the way but the others keep theirs trained on the robot.
Also can we appreciate Smith's acting in this movie? I like him as is, but in this particular movie he was genuinely brilliant in my opinion.
1:59
😠 *"Can a robot write a symphony, can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"*
🤔 *"Can You?"*
😑....
LMFAO!!!
@Egg T Stronger.
@Eileen Ramirez makes sense
Not sure why this movie was hated by critics so much. It's a pretty damn good film, and it still holds up well.
"You have five minutes."
Bruv he was in there for at most three and a half minutes.
Time is relative afterall. Perhaps the gravity in the interrogation room was higher, making time pass more slowly, whilst outside 5 minutes have already passed. Or was it the other way around? Physics n shit are complicated Mkay...
Nah, Robertson jist wanted to interrupt
@@flax9999lp Haha
@@flax9999lp I don’t think that’s how time works.
@@gipsydangeramericasmonster9632 How do you think time works?
"I did not murder him!" (THUMP!!) (6 rifles point at robot)
Rifles.
Hermann Fegelein Ruffles. He meant ruffles.
The thump cane first
Stephen Mellett Came*
@@edgarvalencia3657 RRRRRRUFFLES HAVE RIDGES
1:59 is easily the greatest comeback of all time.
I'm not a fan of a movie by any stretch but Alan Tudyk definitely deserves credit for his voice/motion capture work as Sonny. I can only imagine what he could have done with a better script.
I must've had a bad copy of this or something, the sound work in this scene is double-plus good! The soft whirs and whines of Sonny's movements, the stretching tension of his muscles banding tighter and tighter under stress until he craters the table in a rage before slacking almost immediately.. this is some good stuff for an already lovely scene~
Detroit become human but the older version, still awesome
The best compliment I can pay this film is, if they released it today, it would be just as outstanding.. that film was way ahead of its time..
"Can a robot write a synthony? Or make a blank canvas as a work of art?"
Robot " Can You?"
Hhaha
Savage.
why is that funny exactly
roxoto but HE can't.
Terius Smith, Roasted his ass
A robot can at least spell 'symphony' correctly.
Decided to watch this again after 'Boston Dynamics' Atlas presentation
Same
True
Sonny showed some human emotions in this one scene
*Curiosity,Fear,Anger,Confusion,Concern,Guilt,Sadness, even Annoyance*
I love how calm the four swat guys are in the back ground they don't even look at each other nervously they just act as if this shit was a common acurrence
2:33 "I did not hit her! I did not!"
0:45 oh hey mark
@@sus-rai-69gamingchannel70 *hi mark
“Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?”
(20 Years later)
ChatGPT: “In seconds. Indeed, I can.”
"Can you?" best scene
2:02 "Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Me: **Looks at DALL-E 2** "Umm, kinda yeah"
Very underrated movie! The emotion portrayal of the artificial life form is amazing!!
"Can a robot turn a canvas into a masterpiece?"
*Laughs in diffused AI*
Neural network*
Hardly an ai
"Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
2023:
Will: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Robot: "Depends on the prompt."
How the fuck does this still look good. I know Sonny is a motion capture but there are effects in modern movies that don't look this convincing.
"Can a robot write a symphony"
*Laughs in Music Theory*
2024:
Detective: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
Robot: "Yes"
A robot may be able to write a symphony or turn a canvas into a master piece, but until robots are capable of feeling emotions, only humans will truly be able to appreciate these things.
"I guess we're gonna miss the good old days."
"What good old days?"
"The days when people were slapped by other people."
Asimov was a genius. The screenwriters did a great job of capturing Asimov's style and intentions in this movie.
" Can a human write a symphony in 3 seconds ? Can a human turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece in 3 seconds ? "
Seriously, read Isaac Asimov. In the book "Robot Dreams" there's a tale where Susan Calvin interviews LVX-1, this scene was "inspired" by this tale, it's just amazing how far ahead Asimov was when it comes to creativity and philosophy regarding AI
I will do and if you reply I can speak again
2:03 “Can a robot turn a canvas to a beautiful masterpiece?”
*OpenAI Sora Enters Chat*
3:22 Experiencing false guilt. This part was my favorite in this scene.
This was such and underrated movie. The ending where sonny is standing on the bridge they could have easily mad a bunch of sequels, but I feel because they didn’t it makes this movie even better.
They don't make sequels of box office flops.
I have seen this like 30 times and I never get bored.
It’s now 2020. This is 15 years away from being reality. They might be right.
maybe waitress robots but not robots that think for themselves or that are humanoid
@@milk5002 With Learning neural networks im sure that Robots with a mind of their own, and emotions will not be far away in the near future.
@@SovLestlandia I’d give it 80-100 years
15 years MAX, look at the AI technology we have now, deep fakes, hell, even the youtube recommendations page, we're already teaching technology how to imitate humans so it's only a matter of time before these movies become reality
True A.i will probably take another 100 years most likely. But we'll have robots that will seem very real in the next 15 or so years
“y’all got any fun?” “we got abysmal dogshit”
Well, yes, AI can turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece now. Dall-E 2.0 or Midjourney AI allows them to create a piece of art with only using given prompts.
Underrated movie I think. Not perfect, but still quite good.
ALAN TUDYK SAID "I DID NOT MURDER CHADWICK BOSEMAN!" AT 2:33. 😠😡
Fucking synths.
ad victoriam, brother
+Tomas Cid for the brotherhood
This is an abomination to the human race. Goddamn institute.
yeah this movie shows that gen 1 and gen 2 snyths are dangerous that one day if the institute was to live those snyths would eventually try to elemantant humans
yeah this movie shows that gen 1 and gen 2 snyths are dangerous that one day if the institute was to live those snyths would eventually try to elemantant humans
"Can you slap someone on stage?"
"Can you?"
He says 5 minutes but only gives him 4
chase1146 The company's representative came before the 5 minutes was over
still could have waited 1 more minute
"Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpieces?"
*Meanwhile AI in 2022-2023 already taking over*
when you look back at the movie, it's so ahead of its time. Now we are on the brink of introducing AI. The robot picked up its consciousness. Great movie
This reminds me so much of Detroit become human, when Connor questions the deviant. 28 STAB WOUNDS
you know i never really realized this, but the line where spooner's boss says he misses the days where people were killed by other people, people are actually already being killed by robots... they're called drones... -.-
the difference is, drones are still controlled by people, they have no intelligence, no intention to kill, they shoot a missile only because some soldier/pilot pressed a button, so technically people are still killed by people, but in a more advanced way with more advanced weapons
Alex Grey I understand you trying to distinguish consciousness from programming, I know that this movie is different in that respect. But drones do in fact fire autonomously. I've read articles about how they use algorithms (computer programs) with pixel-based reactions. The software detects a certain infra-red pixel combination, and it can trigger a firing response... with no human involved
there is always a human involved, who sends the drone on a mission, who gives the drone a target... the drone may do many things by itself, but the order to kill is given by a human... although we are not that far from the future some fear, with a robot army controlled by an AI who might go rogue... i do think its a huge mistake that the AI is developed primarily in military purposes, it's gonna backfire at us eventually. but for now drones are mindless machines, very advanced weapons and weapon carriers, but the one pulling the trigger (metaphorically speaking) is still a human, following orders from his superiors...
Filipe Ferro
Drones, whether their level of automation is, are tools; as hammers, knives or guns are. Like guns, they are tools designed to kill, nothing more. There is no conscious decision on whether to kill a human or comprenhension of the whole act of killing itself. What the quote means is that regadless the tool, the intellectual perpetrator is always a human, who can consciously *choose* to end a life (for reasons other than survival), knowing and understand everything that implies.
Choice is the keyword here and actually, the topic of the movie itself: machines capable of choice.
I think this movie was under rated.
"Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece" *detroit become human flashbacks*
Movie Depicting a world in 2035:
- Human: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?"
- Robot: "Can you?"
Actually the real world 12 years earlier:
- Human: "make me a gud app"
- Robot: Steve Jobs Mode Initiated ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)