For a guy who doesn't like to play bass, Carlos fucking rocks. His basslines on TOTBL and Antics are smooth and crispy. Guy had a hell of a lot of talent.
In retrospect, he was probably uniquely talented *because* he didn’t like bass. I’ve noticed that when creative people feel limited or even trapped by the limitations of the budget, gear, manpower, etc. at their disposal, they “optimize” their work to the limitations of the hand they’ve been dealt, and sometimes, beautiful things happen as a result.
So I started playing bass in punk bands not taking it seriously until I heard this song specifically Mr Dengler's bass playing. I cannot stress enough how unorthodox his lines are. He's a lead guitar player and plays the bass not like a bass player but like a lead guitarist hence why the bass sounds the way it does.
I can't believe he didn't like playing tbh, you can't write lines like that on sn instrument you dislike. Sounds like he said this as a cop out after regretting leaving the band lol
@@SanchezS1998 100% the truth. When I was a child, I became a very natural, and very talented Violin player. The fact was I was forced by parents and I HATED the Instrument. I dreamed of owning a set of drums but we were very poor and school only had Mariachi Orchestra which I also did not like.
And that's exactly why he was the bassist! He was actually a guitar player and didn't like to play bass _that much._ Daniel (the guitarist) was looking for a bass player for his band and he invited Carlos because "he looked like a bass player". He accepted and the rest was history.
They've started wearing formal wear for the concerts to show that they were taking music seriously, and to differentiate themselves from other bands. Why do I find this little fact so awesome?
That wasn't the reason why actually and i thino the real reason is even cooler. I believe they initially got together as a band because they all shared a similar taste for fashion and they naturally kept up their formal wear when they made it big and it became part of their look. If i remember correctly, the bassist was mistaken to be interested in the band or something because he dressed similarly but thats just how he dressed lol but i might've gotten a little mixed up but yeah i love how they dress
They're all great but really I sometimes just focus on the drums in amazement. I really don't know anyone that plays like this. It's not typical at all. He's doing his thing, really everyone is doing their thing, but it just goes together so well.
This is crazy, they start playing the initial notes of the riff and no one makes a sound. Six months later they're huge and that riff makes the crowd go nuts!! Very cool to see this. And one of the best songs of that decade fo sho.
I was a little fucking kid when this happened, i cant believe this song is from 2002 and im listening to it almost 13 years later, i can't believe is still sounding mighty. This music must last FOREVER.
@@simontrucker3624 his style is the opposite of peter hook, especially in this particular song. peter hook used chords often, which is something carlos only did once for a very short part of stella was a diver. he is more like simon gallup, but a bit better.
the reason why carlos was so evidently content here was simply cause they were barely starting out, this was like the beginning basically when they started to tour and stuff, eventually that just sort of got to him and later down the road years later like I'm talking our love to admire interpol, by then i believe he felt alienated from it all and was ultimately burnt out. thats how i see it.
i can't see why a lot of interpol's fanbase can't be reasonable about it. i love him, but making music is an often emotionally demanding job just like any other, and people change over the years.
+Luna joy I know. I feel so sad. I wish I could go back in time and start over. It's raining today and I was thinking about "Stella was A diver and she Was Always Down." It says Stella was swallowed up in the manhole cover. I feel like that. 14 years I know, its forever now.
This video is honestly legendary. How many bands have live performance videos of one of their best songs from way before they were considered popular or anyone knew the song at all?
BEST BAND EVER. I’ve reviewed and listened to it all, yet I am coming back to this, for there isn’t anything better than this out there and there will never be.
I saw Paul and the boys years ago in Ottawa and it was one of my first concerts in my early 20s. The venue was small and tight like this one and it was probably one of the best shows I've been to.
They say that Carlos D. quit the bass because he had always hated it. I believe this is solid proof that, what has been said is false. Look at him. Flipping look at his movement. You can't hate the bass and move like that. Impossible.
MrjiimmyTARD he got tired because interpol has/had a lack of creativity on bass lines And sam (probably in 2010) told that interpol will never need a bass in the future, so that probably hurt carlos in many ways to, finally, left interpol in that year
He grew up playing regular guitar, and never really played or even owned a bass guitar. He only picked it up because the other members needed a bass player. That being said, he is a badass bass guitarist.
i actually like the sound of this more than the regular album version. the way the guitars build up in the beginning is so satisfying to hear and the way he sounds like he’s suffocating when he sings is just so perfect
at the start, paul says "Some vocals, Harley, please." I've watched this too many times not knowing what he was saying even though I had heard of Harley.
So much of Interpol was made on Carlos. I think he is Interpol. I hope the band brings him out for a couple of songs when they play TOTBL over the summer
Oh Paul, *"But you're so young,* *You're so young,* *You look in my eyes,* *So young, so sweet, so surprised,* *You look so young like a daisy in my lazy eyes..."* time flies :')
2018 and this is still just great to imagine being there and listening to the first riff without having idea how huge it would become. Lucky the ones who can watch amazing artists being born like this!
I was caught off guard by how great this song/album was bc no one has yet to sound as unique as Interpol. And Paul Banks is as good as it gets, vocally etc.
For a guy who doesn't like to play bass, Carlos fucking rocks. His basslines on TOTBL and Antics are smooth and crispy. Guy had a hell of a lot of talent.
In retrospect, he was probably uniquely talented *because* he didn’t like bass.
I’ve noticed that when creative people feel limited or even trapped by the limitations of the budget, gear, manpower, etc. at their disposal, they “optimize” their work to the limitations of the hand they’ve been dealt, and sometimes, beautiful things happen as a result.
@@SanchezS1998 well said bruh
So I started playing bass in punk bands not taking it seriously until I heard this song specifically Mr Dengler's bass playing. I cannot stress enough how unorthodox his lines are. He's a lead guitar player and plays the bass not like a bass player but like a lead guitarist hence why the bass sounds the way it does.
I can't believe he didn't like playing tbh, you can't write lines like that on sn instrument you dislike. Sounds like he said this as a cop out after regretting leaving the band lol
@@SanchezS1998 100% the truth. When I was a child, I became a very natural, and very talented Violin player. The fact was I was forced by parents and I HATED the Instrument. I dreamed of owning a set of drums but we were very poor and school only had Mariachi Orchestra which I also did not like.
The bass on this song is quite possible the greatest I've ever heard, and it's the main reason I fell in love with this song.
Completely agree.
For someone who didn't like playing bass, yeah
bass and the drums
@Andres Valle the outro of PDA Is orgasmic
Fun fact: the bass player quit interpol because he didn't like the instrument. He decided to pursue a career in acting.
1:29 even Paul is like “how does he do that?”
it's one of the best moments for sure
so true carlos is so good
Lol.
The bassist looks like a vampire
A sexy vampire
@@Wisdawms Beautiful vampire
And that's exactly why he was the bassist! He was actually a guitar player and didn't like to play bass _that much._ Daniel (the guitarist) was looking for a bass player for his band and he invited Carlos because "he looked like a bass player". He accepted and the rest was history.
this is how a bassist must look like
@@Floating.Point. He was a great bassist, too, so I guess it was a decent decision for the music even if Carlos didn't like it.
anyone else think that carlos, paul and daniel's strumming in sync at 2:20 was badass???
rag 415 fuck yeah it was!!
rag 415 oooolishhittt its truuueeee
Just realized about that moment. Fucking epic
I mean all of their strumming was in sync
Bring back Carlos!!!!!!!
They've started wearing formal wear for the concerts to show that they were taking music seriously, and to differentiate themselves from other bands. Why do I find this little fact so awesome?
POST-Punk
That wasn't the reason why actually and i thino the real reason is even cooler. I believe they initially got together as a band because they all shared a similar taste for fashion and they naturally kept up their formal wear when they made it big and it became part of their look. If i remember correctly, the bassist was mistaken to be interested in the band or something because he dressed similarly but thats just how he dressed lol but i might've gotten a little mixed up but yeah i love how they dress
@@Ruby-eq1qg DUDE THAT'S THE SAME BAND FORMING STORY AS RADIOHEAD LOL, and they're my most favourite bands.
like arctic monkeys as well! they started out as pimple faced little punks from Sheffield and gradually evolved into formals and classy suits
@@Spitson7771 they should wear Postman uniforms then.
Everyone: "the bass this... " "the bass that..."
Me: "aah!! The drums!"
YESSS
both
My mind blew when I listened & payed attention to the drums. Instantly went to my drums and tried to play the groove.
They're all great but really I sometimes just focus on the drums in amazement. I really don't know anyone that plays like this. It's not typical at all. He's doing his thing, really everyone is doing their thing, but it just goes together so well.
The drums would happen without the bass. Also who cares.c
it’s crazy how their brains created this song
This is crazy, they start playing the initial notes of the riff and no one makes a sound. Six months later they're huge and that riff makes the crowd go nuts!! Very cool to see this. And one of the best songs of that decade fo sho.
I thought exactly the same.
How amazing would it have been to stumble upon this unknown band who played a set of one of the great albums of the 21st century
Because no one knew them back then, when i listen a new song that i like live i pay attention the whole time.
They look and play so natural together in such a small space.
Carlos was so into that shit then. The bolo tie ushered in the the "I don't give a shit anymore" Carlos era.
bass player is bad ass. He and the drummer are point on.
Carlos D and Sam make an incredible duo in the band
you do not know what you say
I can't stop looking at Danny's sideburns
Danny "Sidepipes"
Lol
Gotta love that rockabilly style
I was a little fucking kid when this happened, i cant believe this song is from 2002 and im listening to it almost 13 years later, i can't believe is still sounding mighty. This music must last FOREVER.
I was like straight up 1 year old or something lol.
This live version is from 2009 though I think
@@NoUA-camName1 it’s not. It’s from 2002
The Bass Guitarist is so cool
Too bad he isn't an Interpol member anymore.
One of my favorite bassists of all time
Oh Carlos, please just come back.
It surprised me years ago that he quit said that he actually didn't like playing bass. He has one of the most creative and unique bass lines.
I'm he's agent... he said you gotta take a vacation to Morocco first... just you and another female friend
@@saltyshapeervessel2.062 ew
@@itaintmebabe714 sadly correct. He said he just wanted to experiment but just so happened that he was fucking amazing
Please dear god no he’s a massive dick
that part where the two guitars kinda echo each other in this song is so damn awesome it send shivers down my spine
They had the greatest bass lines at this point.
That bass line
addicted to interpol, can't believe i didn't give them an actual listen until now -.-
Yep, you missed out on a lot. Interpol from 2002 to 2005 was something not everyone can claim to have witnessed in person.
Carlos looks so cool jamming on the bass
Appreciating the fifth member on keys that truly brings that atmospheric vibe to Interpol 🙌🏻 love this band man
Yep.
i just love how Carlos D is soo enjoying himself...
I was there. Drove down from Iowa City. Amazing show. The stage was so small.
congrats, extremely torn this was three days before being born so i couldnt make it too
I think the style of playing the bass of carlos it's so difficult to imitate . It's very unique and amazing.
To everyone except Peter Hook
@@simontrucker3624 his style is the opposite of peter hook, especially in this particular song. peter hook used chords often, which is something carlos only did once for a very short part of stella was a diver. he is more like simon gallup, but a bit better.
Paul Banks voice soars in this song.
I agree with everyone on this fact, carlos was one helluva unique bassist.His speciality was playing chords,something many don't do.
Well he did play guitar first before he picked up the bass
Kind of obsessed with Carlos😍😁
the reason why carlos was so evidently content here was simply cause they were barely starting out, this was like the beginning basically when they started to tour and stuff, eventually that just sort of got to him and later down the road years later like I'm talking our love to admire interpol, by then i believe he felt alienated from it all and was ultimately burnt out. thats how i see it.
i can't see why a lot of interpol's fanbase can't be reasonable about it. i love him, but making music is an often emotionally demanding job just like any other, and people change over the years.
Also the fact that he just didn't really like bass
Interpol is what i always listen to on new year´s eve
+Ale Dread That's an awesome new year's tradition.
Aleh Amds interesting! I always seem to listen to them around fall
Christmas/New Years is interpol season for me as well ; NYC and Hands Away just hit diff to shitty saskatchewan Snowfall
OMG this was 14 years ago... letting that sink in.
+Luna joy I know. I feel so sad. I wish I could go back in time and start over. It's raining today and I was thinking about "Stella was A diver and she Was Always Down." It says Stella was swallowed up in the manhole cover. I feel like that. 14 years I know, its forever now.
Yes, the world sucks now. No sarcasm, no irony.
18yrs now. Still strong as ever.
22 years now
Carlos... Bass genius !!!!
This is Interpol from 2002, but the video looks like it's from 1982
This video is honestly legendary. How many bands have live performance videos of one of their best songs from way before they were considered popular or anyone knew the song at all?
Rarely have i seen a band with this much power.God,these guys are good.
This is the best version on UA-cam
I love the bass and drums in this song .
that bassline is just the greatest there is
this is what i call intimacy between a band and the audience
carlos d is style goals, bass line goals.... idk what else to say about that
Most would say the same.
Watching this in 2020 and WOW they look like babies on stage but sound as fierce as ever. Lucky crowd!
By far one of the greatest bands live.
I was fortunate to have seen them this same year at the Roxy in Atlanta. My how they've grown....
this video makes me feel good
Damn turn it up all the way Carlos' vibrates your ear.
I love how you can see the camera shaking , maybe the room too once Carlos plays the lower notes
BEST BAND EVER. I’ve reviewed and listened to it all, yet I am coming back to this, for there isn’t anything better than this out there and there will never be.
I saw Paul and the boys years ago in Ottawa and it was one of my first concerts in my early 20s. The venue was small and tight like this one and it was probably one of the best shows I've been to.
when i first heard this song...... i was like.. fuckin bass lines... it made me an Interpol fan instantly.
They say that Carlos D. quit the bass because he had always hated it. I believe this is solid proof that, what has been said is false. Look at him. Flipping look at his movement. You can't hate the bass and move like that. Impossible.
MrjiimmyTARD he got tired because interpol has/had a lack of creativity on bass lines
And sam (probably in 2010) told that interpol will never need a bass in the future, so that probably hurt carlos in many ways to, finally, left interpol in that year
He grew up playing regular guitar, and never really played or even owned a bass guitar. He only picked it up because the other members needed a bass player. That being said, he is a badass bass guitarist.
Late to the party. Carlos said he was up for experimentation but never truly "Loved" playing bass. Sucks seeing what a legend he is on that bass
Man Carlos has a infectious vibe 🔥
Best obstacle 1 live performance ever.
i actually like the sound of this more than the regular album version. the way the guitars build up in the beginning is so satisfying to hear and the way he sounds like he’s suffocating when he sings is just so perfect
Oh god i loved them back then and love they now. Lived my youth era with interpol, strokes, bloc party etc.
This one of my favorite songs ever released to the public
at the start, paul says "Some vocals, Harley, please." I've watched this too many times not knowing what he was saying even though I had heard of Harley.
I'm seeing this for what seems to be the hundredth time, and I'm just noticing daniel is playing a ric. Loving it
Carlos 🖤
Man... I was 2 when they played here.... I'm really glad I got to see them live in Portland, OR two years ago. Was an amazing show!
Carlos if you can read this.......You are by far one of the GREATEST BASS PLAYERS ever!!!!!
Too. Awesome. For. Words.
holy shit man they are so young
Oh Carlos
SuperGuguto I'm a straight male and Oh Carlos
+ShaneKarma376
carlito's topknot dancing while playing is great
So much of Interpol was made on Carlos. I think he is Interpol. I hope the band brings him out for a couple of songs when they play TOTBL over the summer
If they contacted him and asked him he would for sure but no way in hell would they do that
this is one of my favorite live performances ever
Oh Paul, *"But you're so young,*
*You're so young,*
*You look in my eyes,*
*So young, so sweet, so surprised,*
*You look so young like a daisy in my lazy eyes..."*
time flies :')
It's different now that Im poor and aging. I'll never see this face again
2018 and this is still just great to imagine being there and listening to the first riff without having idea how huge it would become. Lucky the ones who can watch amazing artists being born like this!
i love young interpol!
This is so pure🥰
Paul looks like a literal angel here
The ending oh gosh when everything comes together it's so beautiful !!!
The synergy of this quartet… specifically Carlos D and Sam… just incredible.
How can anyone who plays like that hate the bass? I don't...why did Carlos leave?! *despairing moan*
22 years of this
2019 and still rocks!!
thank you
thank you - Seth
I find it delightful that this show is on youtube. they're having so much fun
I was caught off guard by how great this song/album was bc no one has yet to sound as unique as Interpol. And Paul Banks is as good as it gets, vocally etc.
I need more of this in my life 🖤
God i love Interpol! Always have, always will!
Best song of Interpol.
This is amazing. Interpol at their finest. Glad I came across early Interpol.
love playing this one, bass sounds so good and powerful
I love you guys
Thank you, Luis.Just Thanks.
Freaking Carlos was so damn cool… miss that lineup!!
Very tight performance and the sound is spot on.
Sounds great!
One of the best bands of my time. I feel lucky I get to listen to them
dude, carlos my hero!!!!!! even though he doesnt like to play bass, imagine if he did?????
Tht bass is amazing
Daniel's sidburns make him look like a mini Andre the Giant
one of the best songs i know !
great band !
I miss you Carlos D. ❤️
I think best performance of this one :')
So much energy
Those are the nice groove bass lines I love so much
Carlo D miss u
thanks for sharing please dont remove!! :)
I miss them