Meet Sagarika Chakraborty whose story inspired Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway | WION Wideangle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 бер 2023
- In 2011, Sagarika Chakraborty's kids were taken away by Norway's Child Protection Services.
What followed next in the two-year-long ordeal where one mother's love took on an entire country's system?
Find out with WION Wideangle - The Custody Clash: Culture vs Country
#Norway #SagarikaChakraborty #MrsChatterjeeVsNorway
About Channel:
WION The World is One News examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim is to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to world politics. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalized united world. So for us, the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs and personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for the latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Business:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps: bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
No parent should have to go through this mental torture. I am sickened to see humans treat another human in such a evil manner and get away with it. My prayers go out to this mother and her children.
It's just they want kids to grow in Christian family and to become Christian...
That's very true 😢
My wife did the same shit to me!...basically I am the father who is separated from my son by my wife and her parents...i literally was in tears watching this movie!
It’s normal in Austria too .
@@harikrish6811 my god this is pathetic man! how long has it been since???
After watching this, I have no words. I went through a similar experience here in the Netherlands but they couldn’t get it right to take my daughter away from me. They talk about developing countries behind behind and corrupt but they have the biggest organized crime network . This angered me so much because I lived through this! Never underestimate a mother love!
You are absolutely correct, in name of welfare they are abusing kids it’s so disheartening to see this happening.
Me too im also in the netherlands. In our case a fase claim was made. Uptill this Day im afraid to go the consultatiebureau or even the doctor.
I am sorry for you...
@@asiyabalochistan3558 There's a similar case in France. Also started with a false claim from a doctor (because the mother argued with them). She said she stopped going to the doctors when that whole ordeal came to an end. People don't realise how vulnerable they are once they become parents.
Developed countries have a huge network of scammers and cruel persons who relentlessly want to hurt others and scam them
Just watched mrs Chatterjee vs norway. I thought it was fiction..but the end gave me a total shock. Cheering for the real lady the hero ❤ . Salute to you
how did you think it was fiction when it says in the title that its based on a true story?? smh
Really ?did you think that? Fiction?
Holy cow! Why the heck the title would contain 'Norway' if it was fiction.
The husband betrayed first! His indifferent attitude was a red flag in itself!
He is disgusting.
Who knows why
Nominate this movie to the Oscar's just so that the world takes notice... It's insane but it's happening to many... Raise the matter to the UN do that they can warn such non aligning countries of rap them to shame... India govt had the power to force the Norway govt to reopen the case else it would have been closed chapter for the sad mom... Imagine if it were some other country!
Boycott Norway... Such A Shame Norway still didn't apologize Sagarika
There are people who suffer much worse that they didn't apologize to.
I actually followed the story when it actually happened back in 2011. I couldn't believe the reason of displacing the children. Norway broke an Indian family. What is surprising is that they placed condition of divorce to give back the children to their father. As usual husband & inlaws agreed which obviously refused by wife. I read several Norweigian blogs at that time. The careworkers accused of not giving the elder boy good quality beef. They are so illeterate they dont even know Hindus di not generally consume beef. Also they accused mother of giving curd rice (bengali mixes rice with curd). Norweigian don't consider it as food. My goodness. All scandanevian countries are same. If anyone wants to live better better live alone. Or if your luck runs out you will loose your children forever. For Sagarika's case if Indian govt did not intervene she would have never got back her children. And ovbiously her husband left her like a coward.
Yes, bengalis definitely eat curd mixed with rice
@archer_biotronica9836 I think they are talking about dud bhaath 🥛🍚
Yeah. What a useless husband.
Yup, like a coward, indeed
So glad that good people protested!!!
Proud if the stand that India took.
Eating with hand is not a valid reason to take children away from parents.. Don't we eat fruit, toast etc with hands.. All those who do this should have children taken away from their parents.... Sad world we living in.
Where as Indian's culture see hand as appreciation, extention of ourselves, most western countries whose mentality is constant fighting with nature, see this as disgusting! Shame on their ignorance!!
This is so shocking. I am a mother of 1 and I cannot Imagine my kid being taken from me. I am living in UK and I am from Pakistan. Upbringing of children is quite similar to Indians. We feed kids with hands, keep them in our bed when they are little, like literally my son is sleeping on my left arm while I type this text..etc. I am so sorry that this mother and many other mothers who have gone through this torture. It breaks my heart that a desi mother who is naturally and spiritually attached to her kids had to face this horrible living hell to get custody of her children which she kept in her womb for 9 months. You are one amazing women my darling.
Ya thats better stay in own homeland the best
I believe that most of the asian family are slightly similar.. for malaysian we used to be feed by our mothers hand too,.. thats the beauty and lovely bonding mom-kids..
She needs to sue the Norway government for false reports, mental, physical & emotional damages.
I've never cried from a movie until I just watched this masterpiece 😭💔 what an amazing story, the strength and courage this mother had to fight for the love of her children God Bless Her 🙏🏽♥️ I hope she is living her best life filled with so much love and happiness with her beautiful children thank you for sharing your story ♥️ I will never forget it 💯
The story is not amazing but the result is.
This is not story...plz
Shame on Norway for their inhume laws
Not inhumane, but racist.
@@sammas2959 Might as well be both
White People are so dangerous, they decide everything for everyone
@@sammas2959 dont believe everything you see in movies.
@@notoriousj_what did the movie get wrong?
The husband's family should be very embarrassed. But also those Norwegian child service people should also feel endless shame for being part of such a toxic system. Glad she got her children back and that they are safe again. She is a good mother. 🙏🏾❤️
Taking away the children only broke the family. Instead taking the child why dont suport on caunselling or support on other thing parents cannot afford. This is too cruel even for the kids.
I cried so much because of her story. Glad she's now living happily with her children ❤
Shame on Norway govt,,, disgusting
Thank you for taking this dark story to the public. More people need to know these malpractices done by the child wellfare service called “Barnevern” in Norway. She is not the only immigrants who have had terrible experiences from “Barnevern” in Norway. Many children have been taken from their parents for no logical reason.
Remind me never to visit Norway or Sweden!!What absolutely deplorable treatment of this Indian mother by Norwegian Social Services and other agencies. As for the Indian in-laws- that’s a whole other story of dishonesty and trickery! This brave, intelligent woman appears to have been conned by so many people that she had put trust in - her husband, her in-laws and the government of her adopted country … the real victims however were the small children wrenched from their mother and deprived of her love for 3 years! Shame on all who supported, enabled, perpetrated and gained from this human rights violation.
Was it 3 whole years? 😭 how evil!!
Yes, and the mother is still fighting for a divorce from her treacherous husband. I just finished watching the movie and weeping 😭😭 and reading about this great mother. Goes to prove that a Mother's love can go to any extent for the happiness of her children. Glad justice prevailed for her and her little ones
My parents send me to a residential school under the clause of a better future. I cried in pain so much that resulted me to experience anxiety, stress and silence. My parents also rely on government to support my education, food, cloths and all my essential need. They always portraits me as the chosen one in front of all their family members and friends. I compress all that pain just to make my parents proud. My childhood were being ripped off with lots of rules and regulations. We children did not choose to be born but parents chooses to have children. I seriously adore this lady during her fights to have her kids back. She also deny any financial support from the government neither authorities. This is what u called a true mom! Past present and future moms need some classes from this lady. A big salute!!!!
Hats off to the Indian government for such great support 🙌🙌🙌I don’t think so any country will go to this level to protect their citizens🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
This case just breaks my heart in so many pieces! This was a terrible incident not only for the kids but the mother too!
State of Norway should issue formal apologies to all parents involved in this and must reassess all cases without prejudice. Barnevernet should not be a party to the case as their motivations are only financially inclined.
Ya bro totally Norway will steal kids for money their GDP per capita is 89000 dollars compared tour 2300
It's the part of their laws
@@meghanath5045 laws change many times a year in developed nations.
When in Rome, Do as the Romans Do
Depends, if you are visiting Rome for a few days or there for life. A curry eater will be a curry eater for life. You cannot change it.
You are a warrior mom! Hats off to you.
Such inhuman act from Norway. This country must penalise for such acts by UN
This is a white supremism mentality, the Nazi was only a scapegoat. Their hatred for non-white is inexplicable. We acknowledge that there are very few whites who also embrace humanity. Let's hope India also cleaned its act and bring humanity out of this dark time! 🙏 om 🕉
I think UN is ridiculous itself.
Head banging is a sure sign of autism and not child abuse..
I wish the current case of infant girl forcefully taken in Germany is also resolved soon! Govt needs to be more forceful. Indian children belong with their families or extended families - not to be used as tools by foreign Govts due to differences in cultures.
Child Prostitution is the main reason behind this..
Stay in India then!
@@notoriousj_ only an idiot can say something like this.
Going to a new country for economic opportunities doesn’t mean your rights are taken away. This is not Middle Ages. People can follow their own culture, life style, etc in foreign lands - provided they are not harmful to host country/ or unlawful.
And in this German case, the court didn’t find anything against the parents. A case of negligence/ accident led to snatching away the baby.
@@devshreebhardwaj3096 "Economic opportunities" is another term for lack of integration, refusing to adapt, and bringing in your old outdated and limited ways of thinking. It's no secret that many immigrants beat and abuse their kids. I'm sure Germany and other European countries have had thousands of cases where this is the case. Do you blame them for taking precautions and/or acting in such a way? And you act like India, Pakistan and other such countries are perfect and never do anything like this. Human rights violations are common in that part of the world. If you hate Europe, and European ways so much, why go? Stay in your country and create your own opportunities, or fix your country. Stop expecting Europe to change their laws and traditions to accomodate you. Immigration is not a right, it's a privilege. Europe doesn't owe you anything.
@@devshreebhardwaj3096 "The report said the court stated parental care was being denied to "avert the existing danger to the child". It said it had come to the conviction "that the mother and/or father (had) intentionally caused the serious genital injuries of the child" and that they were unable to "explain the events in question in a sufficiently consistent manner". Here you go incase you had any doubts.
Dropping a criminal investigation doesn't change what happened. It only means the person who did it couldn't be pinpointed.
After watching mrs chattergee vs norway, i tend to dtay miles away from norway !inhumane and cold blooded
Unfortunantly Europe is like this in general, and Norway is the worst offender of this blatant racism. Even Germany, the most inclusive European nation still does stuff like this.
Cold blooded people they are
@@rayexception4590 Not Poland , they give asylum to west europeans who escape with their child.
Poor woman! What a nightmare! Western countries could learn a lot from Indian families.
Vice-versa. They need to respect non-white cultures.
Correct thats y never leave our own country...n miggrate n ...own country always the best
The actor-mother was excellent in her portrayal in the movie. Watch!
It's a world wide problem. This also happens in the Netherlands! The moment your children are born you have to watch out. Everyone has the right to make a claim you are abusing the children also strangers. When the claim is made the investigation will begin. And it's hard to get your children back via court, because court believes cps always, cps are the so called eyes for the judge. It's all about money! This is legally kidnapping your children 😢
Sagarika's story is heart breaking! Like so many parents go through this😢
I believe you are right, but I have been living in the Netherlands for 7 years now and I have two small children. Never have I heard about such an incident though. So I wonder, is it really a common occurrence?
@@dianad1263 yes, i have experienced it myself. I was lucky I got out of it.
I know to many people who experience it.
I mezelf know someone who works as a cps.
That person told me everything how they work. It's scary how they look at families and the home where they live.
I got lucky because i had enough evidence that cps wasn't fair, and that i am a good mom. The judge was also easy on me because i had to many evidence.
There are also not many people, who knows what mother's go through in woman's shelters. If you hear their story's you will get the shivers. What you also don't hear much, are how many mothers kill them self. Because the stress is to much, and this happens in woman shelters.
You can look it up on you tube, how kinderbescherming (cps) takes away children from parents. The kids don't want to be separated from their parents. It's heartbreaking!
Do you think they mostly target single and/ or foreign parents? Because those would definitely be the easiest targets...
@@dianad1263 no, everyone with kids are targets. I heard they get about 2000/3000 euros per child, when they removed them from each home. If you hear the reasons why they are removed, it's ridiculous! And when they are removed, then the real abuse wil begin with your kid. And nobody wil help them. Also foster parents get money for this, they wil get abused, raped etc... It's a big problem! And when the kids turn 18 years, the are free and end up in the streets!
All of them are involved in this. Your doctor, therapy you go to, schools. You have to be careful how you behave and say around them. I myself Don't trust any soul in this world anymore. Because everyone can make a claim about your kids.
really what is wrong with this European countries?? Crazy...
So, Norwegians have the best parenting in the world?
All of these countries are racist by the looks of it. I mean, imagine undia does this to kids of foreigners
Bloody criminals
What do these cold hearted people know what true motherly love is! They dunno anything
Better than Indians, their children don't suffer from malnutrition
This proves mothers love is the best in the world ❤ and a mother can do anything for her children ❤ so respect your mothers
Her utter helplessness broke my heart.
The thing is this is an organized crime...1. the Indian man "husband " should be actually penalised, passport seized " also the family should be black listed. 2. Where is UN???? 3. India should impose sanctions on this pathetic country.
Husband is just a weak human being who only worry about himself interest; getting Norway citizenship. He is a little abusive toward wife. At the end he was exhausted and don't wanted to fight the system. He commited no crimes!
@@sammas2959 wow such a peaceful husband he is !!! 😂😂 These kind of people not belong to india , i hope he should get Norway citizenship as soon as possible!!! 😂😂
@@sammas2959 being abusive is a crime sir.
@@impositive17_07 yes, taking children away is more so, a crime.
@@sammas2959 that is no justification for abuse.
Am sure without the government’s support this wouldn’t have been possible..hats off 🙌🙌🙌
i am shocked at the incompetent father , will do anything to stay in norway, kudos to this lady for fighting for her kids, also the pyacho country norway prove once again how depressing life in west is due to overacting rules
He was greedy for 💰 and better living standards, even if it meant losing his children.
I get the impression Norway is a somewhat Orwellian society and they are accepting as long as you embibe their culture. We met an Indian couple many years ago who had recently moved to our area in the US from Norway. They had a son who was about 6 and they often spoke of how awesome Norway was and frequently wore Norwegian style sweaters. They didn't find much success in the US and ended up moving back to Norway two years later. I think the moral is, Norway is a fine place as long as you drink their Kool-Aid.
She deserved a gold madal of what she done to get her children back so proud😂her ❤
I am worrying how many parents are still struggling 😢
Baapre....
Such a great movie it was....mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway... no other thing can replace a mother's love.... anyway proud to be an Indian....love for India ❤❤❤
Salute and respect to the mother AND the Indian Government !
I have just watched the movie and I cry. I am a mother and I couldn't imagine when this happens to me
Barnevernet should not be allowed to take any kids from their parents. Its inhumane
I have experienced this. It only happens if you have a partner trying to sabotage things. It's a system and it's easy to break systems.
Well that makes sense since her husband didn’t care about the kids or her! Just evil, full of greed!
@@jesslivin_xo its not True, it also happens even if both of the parents are stable. White People are evil
Im happy her kids are finally back to her. I hope her finances get better soon. I wish someone could help her, she has gone through alot already.
Thank you for making this movie happy that’s your children back to you and India stand up for you, thousands of parents suffering in Swidden and Norway
Appreciate the indian government 🎉 they fight for a mother 🎉
After watching this movie i realised how westren countries thinking on immigrants…The Mother who struggled a lot for her children such a brave lady kudos to her🙏🙏
A lot of western countries? This was just Norway which was shown in the movie. It's a small country with less than 1% of the west's whole population. It does not represent the entire west by any means.
For example spanking children is accepted to some extent in UK and USA but not in scandinavian countries so not all western countries are the same either.
Strong women you are ♥️
I am so happy that Indian government helped you.
How is it legal to take a child out of its home and run away with it just like that, that is literally kidnapping. Im so baffled this is legal. An organisation that is meant for the wellbeing of humans, especially child humans that does this. What? They are causing so much trauma for the children
Because Norwegians are leftists who think children are property of the state.
State funded kidnappings. It's all legal in the West.
hats off to you what a brave Mother absolutely stunning
That's why I love my Country 🇮🇳. There is no hard and cruel law for their citizens and immigrants.
I went to watch Northern Lights in this country , am boycotting it forever
The youth welfare office in norway destroyed their family. They put it like they want to guard the children but the truth is they did immense damage to the children and its their fault the parents separated and the family is broken. I hope sagarika and her children will heal and have a good life in the future without further disturbance.
U see mothers love is the only love which unconditional, whole, and pure. father are just joke, man are most selfish.
I see that this movie also encouraged misandry.
Because of this film, which is playing now in Netflix, the NIORWAY was exposed to their being extortioning a foreign family for money due to child custody business 😅🤣😂 what a shame NORWAY 💪💪💪
Please no more case like this...please stop it all over the world!!!
I think Norwegian rules and regulations needs to be updated and erase or obsolete this nonsensical thought process. Please grow up Norwegian govt.
I am watching this movie now ,my blood only boils after seeing the agony this mother had to go through.
Salute to you Sagarika ji 👏🏻👏🏻
Laws are made for people, not the people for laws. Authorities should show some intelligence while solving emotional cases like this. Authorities r humans & have brains & heart. Use them. She is a diamond lady who refused to take compensation even after such trauma. Special thanks to Indian Govt for standing with this diamond mind & gold heart lady. Lots of love from Pakistan.
Norway got problems with ppl from other countries. Don't take their children away if they don't agree with the way they are been raised, is different cultures. Sad that ppl go to that country seeking better opportunities but instead is a nightmare
I watched the movie and couldn't stop crying. What a wonderful mother❤
I hope they return the children with their organs still intact.
Norway you can do better!
Came here after watching the movie 😢😢
Sincere thanks to madam sushma
Imagine. This small women without any grand finances or education, is fighting a war against a nation for HER CHILDREN. Shame on that husband
Theres no way im gonna visit Norway for this inhuman act.
Wow! Hats of to you!
Remembering late Sushmaji with love and respect
This was a lot to take, very sad indeed 😭😭😭,this is unforgivable
Norwegian Authorities/ The child services or whatever its called, should PAY FOR WHAT THEY HAVE DONE! OMG the Trauma is beyond words!
Im sure all those people that is involve (Especially those two social service girls) will get their Karma, they might be watching the movie right now and I hope you cant sleep and be ASHAMED OF WHAT YOUVE DONE to those families(because im sure theres more). 😡😡😡
No, the main culprit was the husband - his toxic behaviour was why there was a complaint about domestic violence from the neighbours, and that triggered visits from social workers. But he's living the good life (more 💰, better living standards) in Norway.
I have been crying endlessly while watching this 😢😢😢
This story is horrible, what the mother had to go through 😢😮
Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway>>Sound of Freedom>Oppenheimer>>Spiderman Across SpiderVerse>>Super Mario Bros Movie>>Past Lives>>>>>>>>>>Barbie
No words 😢♥️
This is very troubling to say the least. It literally makes no sense. If she was abusive, why would you be dying to get your kids back all to just abuse them. I actually think if she acted like they wanted her to such as give up and walk away, that’s more crazy to me.
She wasn't, the problem was their father
Children cannot be witnesses of domestic violence.
Shame on Norway .
Great
Shame on Norway government and Norway country tis is not the way whereis un and everything... Another reason to believe why my INDIA is greatest among all 😍
India is not the greatest among all tho. Even if this story was 100% true it doesn't suddenly mean India is perfect.
Shame on the husband. What an irresponsible father.!
I cried from the bigging to the end ot the film unless iam amother too😩
I think Norway should actually get themselves checked. This is just out of order like are u seriously gonna say that parents aren't parenting properly just because of them passing down their beliefs onto THEIR OWN children. I'm ashamed.
Shame on Norway
This happens in America as well.
Happens your America!! I don't know what America you're in.
I don’t think in American they snatch children off from their parents just because theirs cultural differences
There are millions of Indians living in the US but we never heard of a case like this so it clearly happens on a much smaller scale.
شيء محزن جدًا جدًا كيف تجارة الاطفال وتفريق العائله والاستهانه بالجنسيات الاخرى
كل فتره تنتشر قصه تخوف عن اوربا ومعاملتهم للجنسيات الاخرى والمهاجرين والسياح وكل قصه تخوف اكثر من الثانيه
علي الاقل النهاية كانت سعيدة و الاولاد عادو الي حظن امهم ، و الحكومة الهندية كان لها دور مهم ايضا
اغلبية قضايا سحب الاطفال نهايتها ماساوية علي الوالدين و الاطفال😰😢
❤❤sagarika lots of love for you
Who set this rule in Norway, excuse me 'children first'? They should put the money on parenting support instead of costing to the foster family.
What a movie!🙌
Irony is that these countries are one of the happiest in terms of human development
Shame on Norway for this racial acts😑..
This movie should be dedicated to our sushama ji😘
As simple as possible
Government should not be using their brains in these matters.
Parents are the best teachers for their children.
Cried so.much. husband only thinking about himself
Don't forget his citizenship.
I never thought I’d say this but W Indian government, Norway has disappointed me greatly.
This scares me to even visit Norway. Never!
Hats off you ma'am 🙏
No visiting Norway after this.. shocking!! Atleast they will never get my money, however little it is.
A sad story. But I wonder why the two children, who are still young and who both returned to India some 10 years ago, are not living with their mother Sagarika Chakraborty.
She has to work in Noida full-time to support them financially, their father's a deadbeat dad
@@cg8397I've read several articles about the case online. Generally the journalism is poor and sensationalist. What is clear is what I said. After succeeding in gaining custody of her children, she and the children returned to India in 2012. However she left the children in the care of elderly relatives, even moving to a different town. I can understand economic pressures to work and provide. But the whole story does not add up. Of course the 2023 film had to make her the victim to serve the narrative film sales and fit the Indian government's nationalist agenda. It is sad that Indians, with so much history, culture and education, could not have produced a more reflective and nuanced film. So many Indians seek to migrate and have limited understanding of how things work. Often after a few years of working abroad, men return to India to be married. Their new brides may not be familiar with life in the West (usual scenario). The women may be housebound, stuck with young children without an adequate support system. That reality could have made for a more balanced film.
There is so many stories like this one ! Social services need to be eliminated! They are a monsters
You are the world best mother for 4evr❤❤❤❤❤
Good movie