GTA Trilogy Release vs Now - Physics and Details Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 тра 2024
  • In this video, I will show you the differences between the old Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - The Definitive Edition version (2021) and the new version 1.04.5 (2023) in terms of physics and details.
    The free update 1.04.5 for GTA Trilogy: Definitive Edition includes fixes for individual games and specific platforms, as well as general improvements across the entire collection.
    Timings:
    00:00 Animation
    00:39 Rain
    00:57 First-person view
    01:58 Fog
    02:49 Mirrors
    03:34 Map boundary
    04:33 Flamethrower
    05:42 Invisible bridge
    06:38 Gang jerseys
    07:32 Shooting garbages
    08:27 Burger shot logo
    08:45 Los Santos barber
    09:01 Claude vs drivers
    09:38 Lifeguard cabin
    10:17 Walking on water
    GTA Trilogy: Definitive Edition Last Patch
    GTA Trilogy: Definitive Edition Release vs Now
    Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - The Definitive Edition Release vs Last Patch
    Fixes in GTA Trilogy Update
    #gtatrilogy #gta #gtatrilogydefinitiveedition
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @fuzzygoesboom
    @fuzzygoesboom 6 місяців тому +5586

    Bro, ngl CJ's face in first person got me laughing a lil too much 😂😂

    • @ChaynesNooders
      @ChaynesNooders 6 місяців тому +193

      CJ rizz moment

    • @granzon7396
      @granzon7396 6 місяців тому +4

      lmfao

    • @sirmurphy2250
      @sirmurphy2250 6 місяців тому +72

      Nah Fr I was dyin laughin😂😂😂

    • @ArleyTriana-bc8de
      @ArleyTriana-bc8de 5 місяців тому +52

      He says not smoking but that face does not say the same

    • @Ypnos-dy3uv
      @Ypnos-dy3uv 5 місяців тому +35

      I remember laughing too much at it before like I think it was the fat cj riding a quad bike with music 😂😂

  • @mvlpix4419
    @mvlpix4419 5 місяців тому +601

    I. Hate. Fake. Thumbnails.💀

    • @toasterowens8916
      @toasterowens8916 2 місяці тому +77

      Shit lIke that is why there used to be a visible dislike button

    • @paulie33
      @paulie33 Місяць тому +3

      @@toasterowens8916everything is bad nowadays lol no visible dislike button ,gta de etc etc

    • @regie9181
      @regie9181 29 днів тому +3

      I thought she really looked like Rochelle from l4d2 lmao

    • @mvlpix4419
      @mvlpix4419 29 днів тому

      @@regie9181 i can see that lmao

    • @masterk5066
      @masterk5066 28 днів тому

      That’s a mod. Ped mod that mods almost every box in the game. I have it in my OG version it’d be nice if it works on definitive edition lol

  • @zw7my
    @zw7my 7 місяців тому +6308

    I'm amazed at how poorly Definitive Edition was done. R* should have stopped being lazy and did it themselves instead of handing it off to a studio who only makes mobile ports.

    • @dja1647
      @dja1647 6 місяців тому +577

      They’re literally making GTA6 you have no idea what you’re talking about they’re literally not even being lazy its smart if anything

    • @anthonyeasley1727
      @anthonyeasley1727 6 місяців тому +75

      It was literally not that bad no game-breaking glit is killed up early the noticed anything 100% completion had fun was worth it

    • @xx_zkanuf_xx1457
      @xx_zkanuf_xx1457 6 місяців тому +18

      ​@@dja1647and rdr3 I think

    • @shrekrealista5045
      @shrekrealista5045 6 місяців тому +262

      @@dja1647 they are making gta 6, but they don't respect their history :D

    • @YoungBasedChefBeezy
      @YoungBasedChefBeezy 6 місяців тому +411

      @@dja1647yeah. Releasing undercooked garbage on your studios dime is definitely smart

  • @adingdingdiiing6740
    @adingdingdiiing6740 5 місяців тому +531

    I think we can all agree that we didn't want the first person issue patched.😂😂😂😂

  • @CyriuX7
    @CyriuX7 6 місяців тому +1056

    I knew these releases were broken, but I didn't knew they were THAT broken.

    • @The_Blue_Otaku
      @The_Blue_Otaku 5 місяців тому +56

      I find it both funny and sad that people made mods for the original PC port of GTA San Andreas that make the game look and play 1000 times better then the Definitve Edition

    • @PinnuskaTV
      @PinnuskaTV 5 місяців тому +9

      @@The_Blue_Otaku Definitive edition still looks better most of the time (especially nights) and there is no shimmering and aliasing which is so horrible on original pc port

    • @Frank-qn7de
      @Frank-qn7de 5 місяців тому +11

      and this is just a fraction of the glitches and graphical oversights... even oversights present in that 10 year old android port (yeah, this triology is a copy paste of that port and im not joking, look it up if you don't believe me) they didnt bother to even do the bare minimum, this is the sort of effort you expect from a guy doing this as a hobby for free, not from a actual developers with wages

    • @PinnuskaTV
      @PinnuskaTV 5 місяців тому +1

      @@Frank-qn7de Ye ofc it is copy paste of android port, 100%. They literally had to remake 3 games on new engine in such short time, so its clearly Rockstar fault. And if u mod these games, they are pretty playable and not bare minimum at all. Just cause there are some glitches and stuff, doesn't mean it's instantly bare minimum and worst game ever. Like Trilogy GFX Mod v0.2 for GTA San Andreas Definitive Edition will always outshine any graphics mod for original GTA SA. Original GTA SA engine is outdated and very limited and has so much shimmering (especially with those graphics mods like DirectX 3.0) that it's just starting to hurt eyes.

    • @Frank-qn7de
      @Frank-qn7de 5 місяців тому +10

      @@PinnuskaTV "i-if you mod it..." irrelevant to the point, they didn't remake any of the games, they just picked the android ports and slapped them on to unreal, which in turn created more glitches that they didnt bother to fix before release but please keep enlightening me how totally not lazy they are bro, also please tell me you're atleast getting paid minimum wage for such bold and shameless shilling

  • @abodymody7641
    @abodymody7641 6 місяців тому +2057

    nothing beats the og ps2 version

    • @TheRealAN64
      @TheRealAN64 6 місяців тому +49

      facts

    • @luhwizz
      @luhwizz 6 місяців тому +94

      PS2, og Xbox and PC w/mods are the best

    • @jaya_surya_a5118
      @jaya_surya_a5118 6 місяців тому

      That was dog piss version....pc with multi-player and mods are fun

    • @toronjaAR2717
      @toronjaAR2717 6 місяців тому +8

      na

    • @kad6402
      @kad6402 6 місяців тому +13

      Pc w mods but making him og

  • @HanstheBoss1
    @HanstheBoss1 6 місяців тому +342

    for a group called "Grove Street" developers you would think they'll put more soul to this definition but noooooo

    • @jitjit6877
      @jitjit6877 6 місяців тому +85

      They are called grove Street games and can't even make grove Street 😭

    • @lemmy154
      @lemmy154 6 місяців тому

      ?

    • @DreErdna
      @DreErdna 6 місяців тому +42

      Broke Street

    • @HanstheBoss1
      @HanstheBoss1 6 місяців тому +12

      @@DreErdna for real xD Buster Street

    • @ticktockbam
      @ticktockbam 6 місяців тому +21

      ​@@lemmy154He's saying that, since the studio that made this "Definitive Edition" has a name that references the game, one would think that said team has a passion for said game and therefore respects it enough to make the final product something good, not like the utter steaming pile of garbage they released. Did that made sense now?

  • @TheSirZparity
    @TheSirZparity 6 місяців тому +1852

    I give them credit for still trying to fix the game after years.
    It still doesn't excuse releasing the game in such a godawful buggy, broken and unfinished state and making people pay full price for it...but still...

    • @HylianBean97
      @HylianBean97 6 місяців тому +31

      I was fortunate enough to grab the Switch port for £25 quid on sale lol
      I didn't get the collection on release thankfully, tho £15 quid would've been a better sale price since they are decade old games, least the RDR 1 remake isn't fucked up
      I'm more pissed that TT Games never completed LEGO The Hobbit as a complete Trilogy and STILL charges £40 quid just for the two films, cancelled the DLC which was planned to be the third film (even tho The Hobbit itself is such a short ass story, why Peter Jackson needed to make it into 3 parts was dumb aF still could've just worked as an 6 hour extended cut for a single film lmao) again, I grabbed the game for just under a fiver but even THEN it wasn't worth it because it was just two films not the whole Trilogy 🤦🏼‍♂️
      Plus I think Rockstar should've given the GTA Trilogy remake development to THQThordiac or the deves who remade the Spyro Reignited Trilogy THAT'S how you do a remake!! 🙏🏼 even the SpongeBob Battle For Bikini Bottom remake looks amazing aF

    • @mmd3585
      @mmd3585 6 місяців тому +131

      There is no credit to be given. The game shouldn't be released in the state that it was launched. They earned a lot of money destroying 3 classic games, while taking the original out of the digital stores to force people to play the shitty version instead.
      This bugs me. They are not a company that is desperate to make ends meet and is releasing the game poorly to at least make some money and fix it later. It is fucking Rockstar. Why people keep praising companies that releases games in absolute garbage state just because they are doing the absolute minimal effort to make the game "good enough" to not warrant being removed from sales due to misleading people?
      I don't give a shit on how well games like Jedi Survivor, Starfield or The Last of Us PC Port are being patched (Jedi Survivor is still utter shit as far as I remember seeing in the videos). They are releases from famous and multimilionaire companies. A game like No Man's Sky at least gets a pass because they are using the profit of the game to make the improvements, without added cost, that are true to what was promised before. It is a completely different experience from what was there for the early adopters. And Hello Games needed the money to keep existing. This is not the case with Rockstar, Naughtydog and EA

    • @JackycakesV2
      @JackycakesV2 6 місяців тому +10

      @@mmd3585Jedi survivor had all its bugs patched back in June. It’s a phenomenal game ruined because EA forced a PC Port instead of letting them smooth out everything on console.

    • @thedangerwich5476
      @thedangerwich5476 6 місяців тому +32

      They deserve no credit because it should I have been released like this, not years later.

    • @thornofsociety6857
      @thornofsociety6857 6 місяців тому +8

      This looks at least like how it should have been at release and then updated to improve, what was released seemed like a beta at best and alpha at worst.

  • @AJ-po6up
    @AJ-po6up 6 місяців тому +801

    Besides how lazy, broken and unfinished this thing was and still is, to me its biggest sin is how much it ruins the atmosphere of the originals, which to me is an essential part of the games and a big source of nostalgia, the lightning and post-processing was part of the personality of these games and with this Trilogy DE (Disaster Edition) it's now all gone, replaced by generic UE4 lightning, it makes the games look cheap like a mobile game or UE asset store project.

    • @smward87
      @smward87 5 місяців тому +112

      "Cheap like a mobile game" Well that could be because the team that worked on this were the same guys who ported the games to mobile in the first place like a decade ago lol. So yeah. They literally just ported the mobile ports lol. It's portception.

    • @EM_ABS
      @EM_ABS 5 місяців тому +81

      I wouldn't have an issue with it if the originals were still accessible. It blows my mind that they removed ANY way to play the originals digitally. Even my original steam purchases of the OG trilogy from over a decade ago were swapped for the "mobile" ports and I had zero say in that! One day there was an update and the ports were now what was there.

    • @Vontzy
      @Vontzy 5 місяців тому +12

      @@EM_ABS LMAO You're OG versions were swapped? sounds like a personal problem, mine are still working just fine

    • @Kwayjie
      @Kwayjie 5 місяців тому +3

      Didn’t the actor for gta San Andreas have a bad relationship with rockstar, I’m sure they would’ve done everything all over again if they were on good terms

    • @EM_ABS
      @EM_ABS 5 місяців тому +24

      @@Vontzy Hate to break it to you. Unless you have the original discs on ps2/Xbox, yours are swapped too.

  • @That-Will-Do-It
    @That-Will-Do-It 6 місяців тому +1149

    If they could have just taken the originals and upscaled the resolution, 60fps, and increased the draw distance, I would have been happy.
    Edit: If the game cant run at 60fps then atleast make the 30fps stable.

    • @Speed4Runs
      @Speed4Runs 6 місяців тому +93

      60fps? You mean at least 240fps

    • @lemmy154
      @lemmy154 6 місяців тому +6

      😂

    • @ADucksOpinion
      @ADucksOpinion 6 місяців тому +7

      naw see i have done that with mods and the new game is SO much better. i like what they did

    • @Speed4Runs
      @Speed4Runs 6 місяців тому +3

      @@ADucksOpinion there's no need for mods

    • @KLN97
      @KLN97 6 місяців тому +38

      The physics always breaks in the originals when I play at 60fps. I'm sure that is something they could have fixed if they cared at all

  • @ishopops5856
    @ishopops5856 6 місяців тому +371

    Unfortunately, music is the main experience for me
    A majority of the time you’re in a vehicle for these games. I hate they removed songs due to licensing issues it takes away from the whole experience for me

    • @SonOfVenus92494
      @SonOfVenus92494 6 місяців тому +11

      I can still listen to songs on the GTA definitive addition. 🤔

    • @InfoRanker
      @InfoRanker 6 місяців тому +13

      They didn't remove the music. I just watched a few streamers on Twitch and they had the music on in the cars like normal. Emotion 98.3 ftw!

    • @thehwguy4293
      @thehwguy4293 6 місяців тому +101

      ​@@SonOfVenus92494 I think he's referring to certain songs from the original releases of these games not being present.

    • @thehwguy4293
      @thehwguy4293 6 місяців тому +29

      ​@@InfoRanker again, I think he's referring to certain songs from the original releases of these games not being present.

    • @J3strX
      @J3strX 5 місяців тому +13

      Honestly, I just have a Spotify playlist running in the background 24/7

  • @MySadExistence
    @MySadExistence 5 місяців тому +614

    I actually liked it that you saw a close-up of CJ when looking back. The original San Andreas had this too

    • @lynchmaleideal
      @lynchmaleideal 5 місяців тому +18

      No it didn't?

    • @johnowen7302
      @johnowen7302 5 місяців тому +77

      ​@@lynchmaleidealyes it did, i very well remember finding it funny back then too

    • @MySadExistence
      @MySadExistence 5 місяців тому +108

      @@lynchmaleideal I vividly remember me and my friend stealing the lawnmower at the house near the Vinewood sign, have CJ's close-up and driving off mountains and cliffs. We would laugh out asses off at CJ's expressionless face while the world was spinning in the background

    • @eggsbenedict831
      @eggsbenedict831 5 місяців тому +8

      ​@@lynchmaleidealI can't accurately remember, but it does happen. For me I forgot if it was for the planes only or the Hunter apache

    • @largebig79
      @largebig79 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@lynchmaleideali played it today, it does

  • @Namikaze2100
    @Namikaze2100 6 місяців тому +144

    the things they should do is to fix how the protagonist is aiming their guns, just look at CJ"s shotgun, the crosshair is straight but the way he aim his gun was a bit to the left

    • @maxm.m.7219
      @maxm.m.7219 6 місяців тому +14

      That's intentional. CJ aims his guns like a gangsta sometimes. It's a cultural thing. He's a gangbanger from the late 90's, so yeah.

    • @majorborngusfluunduch8694
      @majorborngusfluunduch8694 6 місяців тому +29

      ​@@maxm.m.7219He's not talking about that. The barrel of the gun isn't pointed where the crosshair is.

    • @sdt_dk
      @sdt_dk 5 місяців тому +2

      In this version, Cj has a lot of animations that make him look crooked, what they did to this great protagonist is blasphemous.

  • @shadowcitizen545
    @shadowcitizen545 6 місяців тому +32

    The moral of the story is never buy a game when it's released. Wait 2 years and I'll be how it should've been on release

    • @eclectica1
      @eclectica1 5 місяців тому

      The internet has made developers lazy.

    • @sebastianaliandkulche
      @sebastianaliandkulche 5 місяців тому

      ​@@eclectica1The updates.

    • @sebastianaliandkulche
      @sebastianaliandkulche 5 місяців тому

      Which is a shame because until sixth gen (arguably early seven gen) you could buy a game from launch and still enjoy it to its fullest, even if in a week or a month devs sometimes could release another version, it would still feel complete (plus games back then were cheaper and just better so at least me if i love one i wouldnt have a problem to buy the other version).

    • @CW-rh4jz
      @CW-rh4jz 2 місяці тому

      @@eclectica1I blame we the consumer. Far too often we buy these half baked games and then praise them for fixing it later. It’s not the devs, it’s the suits that are the problem.

  • @TheSkalker
    @TheSkalker 5 місяців тому +9

    1:04 1:21
    The First-person view bug is basically CJ trying to rizz the player

  • @TheChodex
    @TheChodex 5 місяців тому +64

    I am willing to bet big money that devs knew about these problems but managers/stakeholders forced release anyway for quick money and the "ship it, fix it later" mentality that is present in this industry nowdays.

    • @_lynxninja_4783
      @_lynxninja_4783 5 місяців тому +17

      Remastering 3 games in one go is also a crazy thing to do

    • @CW-rh4jz
      @CW-rh4jz 2 місяці тому +3

      Yep, and cost them money in the long run.

  • @IDyn4m1CI
    @IDyn4m1CI 5 місяців тому +66

    Wait, did they fixed Denise's face or not? You have her on the thumbnail but never showed on the video lol. Its cool that they fixed a lot of the bugs on the atrocity that was "The Definitive Edition" of the games. But I still think the definitive way of playing these old games is just installing the OG releases and using bug fixes and QoL mods to bring them to modern gaming standards, then they still hold up really well.

    • @Left4Coochie
      @Left4Coochie Місяць тому +1

      denise's face is rochelle from l4d2. it's fake

  • @aftermath20
    @aftermath20 6 місяців тому +56

    9:21 Claude in original showed an actual middle finger idk why it's not in Defective, I mean Definitive Edition😊

    • @turututu2113
      @turututu2113 6 місяців тому +12

      Censorship

    • @jelmarcios.b2445
      @jelmarcios.b2445 6 місяців тому +1

      Lack of attention to detail, obviously

    • @MyNameIsRon
      @MyNameIsRon 6 місяців тому +2

      Lame.

    • @ticktockbam
      @ticktockbam 6 місяців тому +4

      Classic. Remasters, remakes and re-releases in general tend to censor many aspects of the games to meet new societal and company standards, and to not get backlash from rabid game journalists and the media in general.

    • @EM_ABS
      @EM_ABS 5 місяців тому

      Its there. He paused it before the middle finger went up. Look closely at the other two examples. He puts his finger up.

  • @bizarroeddie1
    @bizarroeddie1 5 місяців тому +9

    the fog should be even stronger. we're not supposed to see a city from another city. It's what makes the map feel tiny.

  • @Mandude4200
    @Mandude4200 5 місяців тому +38

    I’m so glad I picked up the actual trilogy on psn before it was removed, this edition would sting far less if they kept the original games up still

    • @yahmzmusic2339
      @yahmzmusic2339 5 місяців тому +9

      even the psn editions are missing some songs due to licensing. They also have some cut content, and weirdly, are actually just console ports of the mobile versions. Honestly just use PCSX2 and emulate the original ps2 versions, you'll have a better time.

    • @Stinkyremy
      @Stinkyremy 4 місяці тому +1

      @@yahmzmusic2339 I am not sure about the songs but they are not the mobile ports afaik.
      I know SA lost a lot of the music though, I remember there being an issue about it, pretty sure I have it on xbox 360

  • @WickedFamix
    @WickedFamix 6 місяців тому +35

    I'm baffled at many of these bugs. How does that even happen? Why do objects disappear? Why did the car get wider when people zigzagged them? How is the number seven on every jersey?

    • @PanTaoYuan
      @PanTaoYuan 6 місяців тому +13

      The seven isn’t a bug, it’s just very shoddy work.
      In the original game, that gang member only ever had a seven on his back. In the definitive edition, they tried to give them more variety by having random numbers appear on their backs instead, but did a very lazy job of it by simply pasting the new numbers over the top of the clearly still visible seven.

    • @hexioum
      @hexioum 5 місяців тому +8

      In most games, objects disappear when the player is not looking at them, is an optimization thing.
      Here, the boundary box was so off that the object was invisible even is in the middle of the screen.
      The car thing I'm not sure. But reminds me of a bug in Pokémon Legends: Arceus. Some things stretched there due to rounding errors when the models switched between LODs.
      The number seven seems to be a normal or bump map applied to every texture, but they didn't made different maps for the new textures so the flat texture changes (to different numbers) but the bump does not, so you see different numbers blend with the seven.

  • @seniorsim2754
    @seniorsim2754 5 місяців тому +58

    1:12 First person glitch while on the quad bike was in PS2 original game as well as far as I remember, but not for the other vehicles

  • @slobert
    @slobert 5 місяців тому +41

    Some of the issues you mentioned (jet reverse camera, CJ not holding camera properly) are present in the original version as well.

  • @Univer3eTwist3ers
    @Univer3eTwist3ers 6 місяців тому +56

    1:05
    IDK why people made such a big deal about this when it was like that in the original SA

    • @danberry20
      @danberry20 6 місяців тому +17

      Yeah haha. I remember back in 2004, me & my friends used to do it in the hydra & would make us laugh.

    • @jorgeantoniomerino4737
      @jorgeantoniomerino4737 5 місяців тому +1

      Original SA didn't have 1st person view if I remember correctly.

    • @danberry20
      @danberry20 5 місяців тому +1

      @@jorgeantoniomerino4737 It kind of did, just no cockpit detail.

  • @harishsanjay9304
    @harishsanjay9304 6 місяців тому +48

    We are appreciating them even though they did their bare minimum

    • @CW-rh4jz
      @CW-rh4jz 2 місяці тому +2

      This is why these companies are so emboldened to release half baked games, because we praise them for fixing it years down the line.

  • @Bobaluga9
    @Bobaluga9 6 місяців тому +122

    On those jerseys, the normal map was left over from the #7. The fixed it by completely removing the normal map, which took away detail and depth.

    • @WickedFamix
      @WickedFamix 6 місяців тому +11

      The jersey clearly doesn't have a normal map, though. Otherwise it wouldn't look flat

  • @Carthage95
    @Carthage95 5 місяців тому +37

    Great video. I agree the fog still doesn’t make the map big enough they should add more

    • @ZenaHashim-kf9hz
      @ZenaHashim-kf9hz 4 місяці тому

      Bro it is enough to make it big

    • @danrise44
      @danrise44 2 місяці тому

      Maybe like ps2 version feel even bigger

  • @maulanaadrian9383
    @maulanaadrian9383 7 місяців тому +57

    1:07 Actually, this glitch is exist in the original too.

    • @ips2124
      @ips2124 7 місяців тому +4

      It's not even a glitch lol

    • @BOMBOCLAAAAT13
      @BOMBOCLAAAAT13 6 місяців тому +10

      @@ips2124it is a glitch lmao, you can't have that camera view without it glitching

    • @ips2124
      @ips2124 6 місяців тому +4

      @@BOMBOCLAAAAT13 you literally just go into the fps camera view in a vehicle and hold L1 + R1 to look behind you. how is it a glitch

    • @TerminatedAcc
      @TerminatedAcc 6 місяців тому

      Anyways it looks weird 😂

    • @zoltanwilson4277
      @zoltanwilson4277 6 місяців тому +1

      @ips I know right. I was just about to say that.

  • @bonniederrico
    @bonniederrico 6 місяців тому +8

    3:17 what is that text 😭😭🗣️🗣️🔥🔥‼️‼️

  • @JohnFDong
    @JohnFDong 6 місяців тому +5

    Immediately subscribed to this channel. Keep it up man!

  • @kitkakot12
    @kitkakot12 6 місяців тому +23

    I don’t played “the definitive edition”, but the whole map still looking bad with that fog, they should add more of it.

    • @hob_channel
      @hob_channel 6 місяців тому +11

      They should have kept the draw distance the same as in the original game

    • @alexbork4250
      @alexbork4250 6 місяців тому +1

      @@hob_channel like trees while you're flying, right?

    • @hob_channel
      @hob_channel 6 місяців тому +6

      @@alexbork4250 Except for the trees😆 But as far as I remember, their loading range has not changed in the Definitive Edition

    • @sebastianaliandkulche
      @sebastianaliandkulche 5 місяців тому

      ​@@hob_channelMaybe not exactly the same since even in the original it was very short. Maybe a bit more like the Xbox or PC original version.

  • @deadturret4049
    @deadturret4049 5 місяців тому +5

    I have an explanation for why there was a strange wall out in the ocean.
    That particular pixel smearing effect occurs on shaders that are not tri-planar. Most of the water shader surface materials as well as what I assume to be a series of gerstner wave functions to create the ocean effect are intended to work on the x and z coordinates. If the water shader had been accidentally wrapped around volume of that ocean object instead of being apllied to a single surface, that pixel smearing effect would appear.
    Realistic waves tend to require fairly high poly meshes, as individual verticies are moved on a sine wave, and many game engines have limitation on how many polygons and object can have. There are likely multiple water volumes snapped together, and one of them has the shader on all surfaces. This would also explain why its culled out on one side.

  • @jacciswacc4335
    @jacciswacc4335 5 місяців тому +4

    This will always feel like Rockstar just came up to a couple of guys, gave them the source code, and said, "You have 6 months." before disappearing into the aether.

    • @sean8102
      @sean8102 3 місяці тому

      Basically yea since they outsourced the DE to a mobile game developer. Same one that did the mobile ports of the GTA games.

  • @przemysawrogalski9225
    @przemysawrogalski9225 7 місяців тому +55

    Ok looks like a can now finally play it and have good time :D I was waiting till now because of all the glitches.

    • @shrekrealista5045
      @shrekrealista5045 6 місяців тому +5

      it doesn't include all previous classic songs tho

    • @romanz5189
      @romanz5189 6 місяців тому +16

      @@shrekrealista5045 exactly plus the original version brings back so much nostalgia this Shitty Nightmare is for today's modern losers who don't know what it was in our day in the 2000s

    • @zoltanwilson4277
      @zoltanwilson4277 6 місяців тому

      ​@@romanz5189Agreed.

    • @AirBRUH
      @AirBRUH 6 місяців тому +1

      I mean it's what you get for buying it without looking at reviews.

    • @quv2035
      @quv2035 6 місяців тому

      @romanz5189 Isn’t gta for losers who wanna play as a criminal and murder civilians and cops?

  • @TheGamerRist
    @TheGamerRist 6 місяців тому +89

    I know people still hate them but I don't mind these remasters. They look nice and have modern updates. Only real problem is the character models don't look that great. However, I don't like playing the San Andreas remaster. It feels really off and the character models are at its worst. I stick with the PS2 version

    • @kilotre9842
      @kilotre9842 6 місяців тому +5

      The san andreas looks great, but so many small bugs that can be fixed. They took our money and ran... Grove street games got balls. I still play the ps2 and og Xbox version no doubt, but the definitive looks pretty with a morden touch.

    • @WickedFamix
      @WickedFamix 6 місяців тому +2

      I never liked the models in San Andreas. I know that they had to lower quality of models for the open world on the PS2, but CJ deserves a higher poly face

    • @khangvinh4656
      @khangvinh4656 6 місяців тому +31

      Honestly, calling it a “remastered” is an overstatement. The game look like someone just download some 4k textures mod that was Ai generated.

    • @messichiquito855
      @messichiquito855 6 місяців тому +13

      @@khangvinh4656 The worst of all is that you are not wrong, they used an AI to make all the model more "smooth", making that some stores had missing letters and a giant bolt model was turned into a circle for example

    • @jupitersnoot4915
      @jupitersnoot4915 6 місяців тому +3

      I'm sorry, I know everyone is entitled to an opinion and all but if you think these games look nice you really need to raise your standards a bit...

  • @Leomerya12
    @Leomerya12 6 місяців тому +125

    So, as a newer game dev, it's really cool that I understand why all these things happen.
    For instance, the boundary wall that is invisible on one side. That's on purpose; so the game doesn't have to render more than it needs. It helps with performance. Most buildings (the ones you cannot enter) are actually transparent on the inside. You're not supposed to be there.

    • @jupitersnoot4915
      @jupitersnoot4915 6 місяців тому +26

      As a newer game dev, perhaps you can enlighten me on how in the hell a game company looked at this remaster in the state it was in at release and honestly thought it was a good idea to release it in that condition. R* honest to god took a look at this remaster and went "Yep, that's ready for release" despite it looking like a pudding-faced AI generated buggy mess where the character models look like something a 10 year old would make the first time they used blender. What in the HELL were they thinking, releasing this mess???? please make me understand how they could possibly think this was ANYWHERE NEAR finished...

    • @AkustikPlaces
      @AkustikPlaces 5 місяців тому +16

      ⁠@@jupitersnoot4915It’s Take-Two Interactive IP and it’s their call to release it that way. As a newer game dev you should know how greedy & profit maximizing publishers tend to be.

    • @realtyrone
      @realtyrone 5 місяців тому +9

      A.k.a back-face culling.

    • @EM_ABS
      @EM_ABS 5 місяців тому +2

      Just like the problem with the jerseys were the normals. It seems like they just put the normal map for the 7 shirt on all the other versions.

    • @GigachadMann
      @GigachadMann 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@jupitersnoot4915I mean we now know what they were really working on all this time. So it makes sense in hindsight why they didn't have time for that, but you're right they made the bad call releasing it like that obviously

  • @fe2k10
    @fe2k10 6 місяців тому +11

    Did they fix the problem where in San Andreas the waves were not synchronized with the physics, and CJ kept flying in the air, or going underwater?

  • @RydenTTV
    @RydenTTV 5 місяців тому +10

    i miss the 3d clouds from OG SA. although adding fog is a step in the right direction some is still missing.

  • @dioaloke
    @dioaloke 5 місяців тому +7

    Glad to see that it's being worked on

  • @jolinar.setesh
    @jolinar.setesh 6 місяців тому +9

    Jesus ! Walking on water is the funniest part !

  • @Yamamoto_Chiko
    @Yamamoto_Chiko 6 місяців тому +3

    *CJ becomes GHOST when using camera on mirror* 💀

  • @Swordslinger-hb1ns
    @Swordslinger-hb1ns 6 місяців тому +73

    Unless they revert the controls to which you jack a car by simply either pressing the triangle button or Y button making it a snap to enter vehicles like the originals, I’m not spending a dime on “the definitive editions”.

    • @TheRedPeril
      @TheRedPeril 6 місяців тому

      You would deny yourself over something so trivial. Pathetic

    • @LoverOfManyArts
      @LoverOfManyArts 6 місяців тому +2

      How does one enter vehicles in the "definitive" edition? I haven't seen the controls for it yet

    • @LHMusicCF
      @LHMusicCF 6 місяців тому +48

      @@LoverOfManyArts Exactly the same. By pressing triangle, Y or X on Switch. No clue what this person is talking about tbh

    • @LoverOfManyArts
      @LoverOfManyArts 6 місяців тому +1

      Oh

    • @Swordslinger-hb1ns
      @Swordslinger-hb1ns 6 місяців тому +7

      @@LoverOfManyArts the definitive edition makes what was once a snap to enter vehicle now an unfun chore. In the originals all you had is press the triangle, Y, or X and you simply run up to the car and steal it. However, in the defective editions you have to manually run up to the vehicle and then press whatever button you use to steal it.

  • @saintsdgessus8823
    @saintsdgessus8823 5 місяців тому +12

    Those fixes are kinda easy to do and should have been done during pre alpha testing. The main issue i have with this remaster is that swapping game engine requires a lot of creative work and not just copypasting assets from the old game, yet they didn't adhere to old gta style and color correction thus remasters look like a generic game made by one person on unreal 4

  • @timecrashv5wu709
    @timecrashv5wu709 5 місяців тому +2

    1:03 Canon CJ mental over the edge while driving

  • @LeyDelYopo
    @LeyDelYopo 5 місяців тому +5

    7:23 CLEAN, LEGIT

  • @NoThing-ec9km
    @NoThing-ec9km 5 місяців тому +2

    *It wasn't released with insufficient testing, it was released without any testing.*

  • @S3verance
    @S3verance 5 місяців тому +2

    the first person face is way too hilarious man wtf

  • @J_C_CH
    @J_C_CH 5 місяців тому +1

    There's something about CJ looking so spaced out whilst flying a jet fighter that's just so freaking funny 😂

  • @negriniraphael
    @negriniraphael 5 місяців тому +4

    Great video, thanks for sharing it !!!

  • @gamerh-pu4lr
    @gamerh-pu4lr 6 місяців тому +6

    CJ jumpscare 1:02

  • @BoldAMATUER
    @BoldAMATUER 5 місяців тому +2

    I liked seeing Carl’s face while looking behind. They should have added the option in the menu

  • @Varun-zm1iw
    @Varun-zm1iw 2 місяці тому +1

    People's face in jet plane : ↖️↗️↙️➡️⬅️⬆️⬇️
    CJ : 🗿

  • @Zodiac3107
    @Zodiac3107 5 місяців тому +4

    Imagine just fixing sh*t that wasn't broken in the originals.

  • @xoxitos
    @xoxitos 5 місяців тому +3

    1:02 CJ Jumpscare

  • @Yoragga206
    @Yoragga206 5 місяців тому

    Ok! Pulling out my switch to play again. Thanks for the news. God bless

  • @zacbakcrak
    @zacbakcrak 5 місяців тому +1

    CJ taking a selfie while flying the Hydra lmfao

  • @lastlvl
    @lastlvl 6 місяців тому +7

    Still no Ragdoll? That’s all I wanted. Fail

  • @dvdbox360
    @dvdbox360 6 місяців тому +6

    claude is jesus in trilogy

  • @TVCHLORD
    @TVCHLORD 5 місяців тому +1

    3:17 holding the camera like a sniper 😂

  • @kazikiksrugim1780
    @kazikiksrugim1780 4 місяці тому +1

    The first version of the game had a huge amount of fog. The fog wasn't a desireable effect though - it was used to limit the number of 3d models to be rendered by the hardware.

  • @Mechaghostman2
    @Mechaghostman2 6 місяців тому +4

    If they released it as early access, it would be one thing. But that's not what happened.

  • @aceblaze8844
    @aceblaze8844 6 місяців тому +4

    2:22 it not fog it a flat smoke texture

  • @theadnanraza
    @theadnanraza 6 місяців тому +1

    walking on water is actually some cool ninja stuff!!

  • @kyerodslove
    @kyerodslove 6 місяців тому +2

    would you recommend getting the trilogy with this new updates?

  • @XxSTACKxX
    @XxSTACKxX 6 місяців тому +3

    That’s just Rochelle’s from l4d2 face in the thumbnail

  • @KIrvin_The_Scholar
    @KIrvin_The_Scholar 6 місяців тому +11

    What system are these comparisons being shown on ?

    • @ThaBotmon
      @ThaBotmon 6 місяців тому +1

      Why does it matter?

    • @eclectica1
      @eclectica1 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@ThaBotmonIt's not an unfair question. Grow up!

    • @ThaBotmon
      @ThaBotmon 5 місяців тому

      @@eclectica1
      It’s irrelevant

  • @AstralWolf86
    @AstralWolf86 5 місяців тому +1

    If you crash into a car in San Andreas the npc driver you crashed into will sometimes turn aggressive and constantly ram your car if you are in it or not.
    Oh and the paramedics don’t spawn.

  • @eternal_guy897
    @eternal_guy897 5 місяців тому

    1:04 When you have a pack of gum in class

  • @javebjorkman
    @javebjorkman 5 місяців тому +3

    Although this was Rockstar’s property, I think a completely different studio did this port. This is not to absolve Rockstar of any responsibility, but helps to contextualize

    • @Proyoska
      @Proyoska 5 місяців тому +1

      Grove street games who did the mobile ports before were in charge of the definitive edition development

  • @jstandhh
    @jstandhh 5 місяців тому +3

    GLAD THEY FIXED IT!

  • @felipevargas2977
    @felipevargas2977 6 місяців тому +2

    1:02 that shit almost killed me bro😂😂😂

  • @pixelmentia
    @pixelmentia 5 місяців тому

    1:00 oh man I was NOT expecting that XD

  • @rangershot
    @rangershot 5 місяців тому +13

    I'm thinking of buying it now since a lot of things have changed now compare when it first released ,and the reviews are almost positive now compare before

    • @giedokaziom
      @giedokaziom 5 місяців тому +1

      yup, its great, especially vice city feels so good

    • @DreamyWoIf
      @DreamyWoIf 5 місяців тому +3

      Watch a video from Vadim M, titled "GTA:SA Why the Definitive Edition is Garbage (Part 1)" to see how badly they ruined the atmosphere of the games and how they unsuccessfully struggled to fix it for several months after the release. The video is over a year old, but but from what I see on this particular video, their version of the map fog is still the same shoddy effort as over a year ago. Other sources report the games still look the same.
      Your call, I guess. Gta3 benefits the most from this remaster while SA the least.

    • @rangershot
      @rangershot 5 місяців тому

      @@DreamyWoIf but did they fix all those issues? I just know it was garbage when it first released but it looks like a lot of things have changed, I need a lot of positive feedbacks from you guys at least you can convince me to buy it LOL

    • @coolguychapman6685
      @coolguychapman6685 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@rangershot honestly I played the original versions and this trilogy remaster and it's not as bad as it once was yea theirs some minor things missing from the original versions and some bugs and glitches present but overall if you don't have a ps2/ps3 and wanna experience the games for yourself and never have I would say just buy it

    • @rangershot
      @rangershot 5 місяців тому

      @@coolguychapman6685 well I have a ps2 emulator and I tried playing it was fun, but I still wanna try new one because for some reason I don't feel like playing the original version anymore because we are all used to the realistic graphics nowadays lol

  • @dinerobanks4961
    @dinerobanks4961 6 місяців тому +5

    What about save points and mission points that disappear causing progression lock? 🤷🏽‍♂️

    • @NoFatChicksPl0x
      @NoFatChicksPl0x 6 місяців тому +1

      Brooo this is literally what killed my playthru of San Andreas! Haven’t seen enough ppl bring it up so thought it was just me…

  • @c-20_v2
    @c-20_v2 Місяць тому

    1:03 dads trying to facetime. Be like 😂

  • @MrMirofl
    @MrMirofl 5 місяців тому

    excellent video

  • @UnofficialXVM
    @UnofficialXVM 6 місяців тому +3

    CJ face when he destroyed toilet at Taco Bell

  • @SnipingIsAGoodJobMate
    @SnipingIsAGoodJobMate 6 місяців тому +4

    Still 0 reasons to not just play the originals

  • @youzer-abuser
    @youzer-abuser 5 місяців тому

    He holds the camera like it's a gun or something xD True og

  • @TheFainter94
    @TheFainter94 Місяць тому

    to this day the fog thing impresses me, because sure in some ways was used due to the limitation of the console at the time, but is also a choise to give the world volume and atmosphere

  • @thongquehanoi
    @thongquehanoi 6 місяців тому +7

    It was created in a new Unreal Engine 4 from new engine with new characters so it's still Remastered for now

    • @rutherford0
      @rutherford0 6 місяців тому

      hopefully modders can fix few stuff on it

  • @andromedamusic9751
    @andromedamusic9751 5 місяців тому +7

    Let’s be honest, it should have been a Remake in the traditional sense… not upscaling and enhancing. These games are iconic and should have been given the proper love.

  • @dondanana9573
    @dondanana9573 6 місяців тому

    feels good to have my OG PS2 Copy, and the xbox 360 version too (the one before they updated it and removed the older version)

  • @asimen1103pl
    @asimen1103pl 6 місяців тому

    thank you!

  • @patoruzitomeh9000
    @patoruzitomeh9000 6 місяців тому +4

    "A look on the right direction" A year later on a remaster of a 20 years old game? Kind of late for that man

  •  6 місяців тому +3

    Why Denise is now Rochelle from Left 4 Dead 2?

  • @Dirtbag333
    @Dirtbag333 4 місяці тому

    Anyone else noticed how in San Andreas, the Wang Cars street racing custom shop vehicles glitch after modifications? EXAMPLE: Modifying the Elegy or the Sultan. parts go missing or change colours by it'self, usually after putting them back into your safe house garage.

  • @PROJECT-yb2iv
    @PROJECT-yb2iv 4 місяці тому

    10:20 oh so he's like Bruce almighty that can walk on water. splendid.

  • @random_kid-gj2bw
    @random_kid-gj2bw 6 місяців тому +4

    Instead of using the mobile version, why dont you bring the whole pc version to unreal engine?

  • @cortezproduction
    @cortezproduction 6 місяців тому +4

    that's rochelle from l4d2

  • @Pyracantic
    @Pyracantic 5 місяців тому +2

    After GTA 6 releases they need take at least 1K devs & shore this fuckery up until it's fixed

    • @Hunter87B
      @Hunter87B 5 місяців тому

      If it will be at least annouced

  • @919M3naxe-dz3ny
    @919M3naxe-dz3ny 6 місяців тому +2

    The only thing I would never forgive rockstar is the Cayo Perico heist nerf

  • @TerminatedAcc
    @TerminatedAcc 6 місяців тому +4

    My expectation is ruining by watching this.💀

    • @TerminatedAcc
      @TerminatedAcc 6 місяців тому +2

      I know it was Grove Street Games but Rockstar Published it anyways it's a garbage do you agree?@@user-cv7kf1hb5z

    • @K3rhos
      @K3rhos 6 місяців тому +2

      @@user-cv7kf1hb5z And What ? R* is still the publisher and they validate this garbage ! There is no excuse lol

    • @TerminatedAcc
      @TerminatedAcc 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@K3rhos Yeah, bro and that kid he talks like he was an employ at Rockstar's 😂

  • @hmrdev-billnye8166
    @hmrdev-billnye8166 6 місяців тому +15

    So is it worth buying it now? And are the devs still releasing updates?

    • @rutherford0
      @rutherford0 6 місяців тому +8

      Devs are not releasing updates, but major bugs have been fixed so far, and i hope that modders can fix the missing stuff and make it more realistic

    • @HollyHartwellWhite
      @HollyHartwellWhite 6 місяців тому +8

      No, save your money

    • @sgtroach1510
      @sgtroach1510 6 місяців тому

      Yeah the controls are better

    • @AJ-po6up
      @AJ-po6up 6 місяців тому +3

      Yes reward them for releasing a broken unfinished mess and barely fixing it while going after modders that will teach them to keep doing it. This crap is not worth buying ever unless you want to condone Take2/Rocktar's behavior.
      Get the original PS2 emulate it or whatever or the PC version and mod it.

    • @HollyHartwellWhite
      @HollyHartwellWhite 6 місяців тому

      I Always Do... Avoid Spending $70 Bucks for nothing @@AJ-po6up

  • @silentopinion
    @silentopinion 3 місяці тому

    Is there still issues with putting fires out, or do the flames still respawn even if you cleared an area?

  • @kurikuraconkuritas
    @kurikuraconkuritas 5 місяців тому +1

    would you recomend to get it now? or stick to the originals

  • @dropking0930
    @dropking0930 6 місяців тому +14

    Damn the map is really that small huh?😅

  • @jasondomican1991
    @jasondomican1991 5 місяців тому +10

    I played through all three of these day one of release and personally didn't experience any issues during a normal gameplay.... I feel like most people just dug and looked around for as many issues as possible but that's just my opinion 🤷

    • @XZ-III
      @XZ-III 5 місяців тому

      No not really week one was shit audio was broken in gta 3 so was rain, sa looked flat... no either you don't notice shit or something idk but it was there

    • @jasondomican1991
      @jasondomican1991 5 місяців тому

      @@XZ-III rain was definitely strange but that's all I noticed during a normal play through of all 3 In my own experience buddy 🤷

  • @big_pingu
    @big_pingu 4 місяці тому +1

    The worst part is that they removed all the originals from digital stores

  • @nothingandnowherebuthere
    @nothingandnowherebuthere 5 місяців тому

    CJ is a true gangsta holding that camera like a gun. 😂