just realised that the one big scrap engine with a face was Dudley, nice bit of character use, giving us an idea of what happened to him after the whole incident with him and Bear
he came to Sodor and had a very big hatred for diesels and tried to have Bear sent away by causing confusion and delay by any means necessary and blaming it all on Bear, in the end he got found out and sent away, this was in the time of Dieselization so he'd have most likely been scrapped at some point or another and ended up back at Sodors scrap yard, or at least his ghost did@@catthecommentbothunter6890
@@catthecommentbothunter6890 After getting sent back to his railroad (British Rail) he was sent for scrap and was sent to killdane scrapyards, he’s the same demon engine from demons.
@@evancross9873 In most fan stories that I've seen Bowler tends to meet the same fate as his number's basis, which is to be cut up at Crewe in 1984. Personally I like the idea of him getting a shot at redemption, though I'll admit I'm biased as I like his class and am generally a fan of redemption tales, provided they're well-written.
Hmm...so Dudley is now the "head honcho" of the scrap engines, and 1020/Dane is the kind soul? Interesting choice in characters. I know that this story and Richard the New Engine series two separate storylines, but I'd like to think that this experience was what changed D261 into helping Richard find a new chance at life when Henry made that fateful bargain.
I love this story. The use of the pilot Gordon and Thomas models, Dudley and 1020 (nad maybe the Kildane experiment) makes it seem like if you disrespect the dead. The dead will disrespect you. I like how Dudley and the scrap engines confront Bowler and show who really has more dominance. The use of 1020 as a saviour is really befitting when he encouraged Oliver to keep going and not give up in ‘Spirit of Survival’. Really like the crossover of different characters in this. Great job Shunter!
I think this is one of the best fan stories about D261! The use of the scrap engines to show that engines that we have sympathy for can become the villains themselves if it means seeking revenge on the character we are used to viewing as the bully who always gets what is coming to him. Naturally, a scrapped Dudley had to appear in this. The fandom really does love the idea of him returning as vengeful scrap engine.
Now I wanna see Dane be the guardian angel of these good guy diesels, using his own experience as a restless spirit to help them stay safe from Dudley, who I'm sure won't move on until reverse-dieselization is a thing.
This is very well made, using Dudley and 1020 / Dane is a very nice narrative considering how it shows dane's character growth of wanting to help engines after the events of hawin lake, as well as a result of what happened to dudley after that story. Very nice contrast and great execution. Props to whoever was involved in making this and I cant wait to see more stories like this :)
Really loved this story, gives some nice depth to Bowler and was an interesting change-of-pace. Rather than changing his tune solely because of a scary experience, what changed him were the thoughtful actions of 1020. Now I wish poor 1020 could be saved, though of course it's too late now. Sweet how Bowler still wishes to see him again.
Now THAT was an amazing story, I love that not only did the scrap engines get a chance to be seen as a proper vengeful force, but also managing to show there can be a difference between the kinds of spirits you find here I loved this, and Bowler felt like the near perfect character for this story, the only other two I could see this working for are D199 or Diesel, but I think Bowler works better due to the blank slate his character is and how possible it is to mould him into the position he ended up in, amazing work on the story
I do understand the scrap engines. They were right with their statements, but the ghost of engines past was a s well. D261 had gone too far, but he indeed deserves a 2nd chance + yes. Engines get replaced. Time is the answer.🙂 (Hope it gets a pin. That's a statement for everyone watching it.)😉 Your Shunter Productions fan Lexie.😁
New working theory: Dudley was finally scrapped and his soul lay dormant till Diesel woke his soul up and Dudley remembered his hatred and pain. When Bowler came in, Dudley decided he could get payback and attempted to scrap him. On the other hand, 1020 found peace and saw what was happening in the scrapyard, and remembered the kindness he once had and wished to help those in need
Kinda funny when you think all the horrid diesels are given a fright to change whereas those who show compassion (dereks deathwish comes highly on that theory) are given the blessing not to be afraid of them.
I imagine that the majority of the scrap engines would attack a diesel but I’d a steam engine were to get lost and stuck in the sidings they would get them out of there or would be silently watching over them to make sure they do not suffer the same faith as them. Plus I think most of the engines that wanted bowler dead were young engine and those who believed they were still in their prime. Over all great story one again by the king of horror himself.
I must say you perfektly captured the old Magic from the first few seasons of the series back when they made so good Halloween Episodes with the models. I am exited about what you will bring out in the hopefully near Future
That beginning felt strangely familiar there. For a moment, I thought it was Class 40's perspective on being in the Smelters during the events of The Spectre's Warning/A Dark Knight for Bert. It kinda looks like an alternate story of it. That scene with the scrape engines is very frightening Especially when a rusty Dudley (I thought it was the Killdane Experiment when I first saw it) was like the leader there. Nice to see a certain engine came to help Class 40 on his way in the end in a way. A very frightening story, but nice in the end. Well done here!
Well, after an encounter like that, I think it's safe to say that old Bowler is scarred for life! Excellent work Shunter! Your work never fails to impress us!
Keep it up ShunterProductions Great Story of Bowler You Made There The Part Where All The Scraped Engines Surrounded Bowler and Dudley Took Him to The Sidings Where They Cut up The Engines Was Scary And The Part Were 1020 Helped Bowler Escape and Took Him to The Fuel Pumps Was Kind of Him
We've seen Bert, Diesel and now Bowler come across the ghosts of steam engines of the past. I really look forward to when it's ’Arry's turn to come buffer to buffer with those ghosts. In my honest opinion, ’Arry’s the worst of the diesels mentioned here.
The scrap engine is dead tho. He’s meant to be the guardian angel to all engines. Also why the heck would they join the steam team being long dead?? Plus the concept of a main character team is irrelevant in ShunterProduction stories.
Yeah but just one thing, behind Dudley, I can see the Killdane experiment making hissing and clanking noises and the prototypes of Thomas and Gordon, pilot Thomas and Gordon that is, but I didn’t think that Dane was a kind engine to save the diesel, it was like when he gave Oliver confidence to keep going to Sodor, not to mention a very kind soul of the spirit
if you think about it steam engines are kinda hypocrites. Before they came along horses pulled wagons. Throughout steams tractions life there were attempts to improve or replace them (oil burning instead of coal, using electric to preheat water making them literal kettles on wheels, full electric heck there was one engine that was powered by diesel whilst the boiler was heating up). They had over a century to become more efficient. Aside from most of them being extremely rude, some diesels such as derrek (I think that's his name the one who kept breaking down on the episode "double teething troubles") were just as prone to malfunction as steam engines maybe more so.
This is a ghost story with realism at its finest! I love the fact the scrapped steam engines include Dudley, The Killdane Experiment and the prototype Thomas and Gordon models. Makes me think that all of those stories are canon to this one! Here’s my reaction to this story if you want to hear more of my thoughts on it: ua-cam.com/video/3RJW68gWc5M/v-deo.htmlsi=sOgpfvZGxYCPHoqZ
Something I wonder about is sodor’s scrap engines. All of em usually look like the same shapes of living charecters.. why did the railway have so many of the same kind?
just realised that the one big scrap engine with a face was Dudley, nice bit of character use, giving us an idea of what happened to him after the whole incident with him and Bear
Or why Dudley hates diesels.
Yeah, that was spooky.
what happened to him?
he came to Sodor and had a very big hatred for diesels and tried to have Bear sent away by causing confusion and delay by any means necessary and blaming it all on Bear, in the end he got found out and sent away, this was in the time of Dieselization so he'd have most likely been scrapped at some point or another and ended up back at Sodors scrap yard, or at least his ghost did@@catthecommentbothunter6890
@@catthecommentbothunter6890
After getting sent back to his railroad (British Rail) he was sent for scrap and was sent to killdane scrapyards, he’s the same demon engine from demons.
One of the few stories where Bowler is not only redeemed, but lives to see the light of day.
Dows he usually die in stories?
@@evancross9873 In most fan stories that I've seen Bowler tends to meet the same fate as his number's basis, which is to be cut up at Crewe in 1984. Personally I like the idea of him getting a shot at redemption, though I'll admit I'm biased as I like his class and am generally a fan of redemption tales, provided they're well-written.
Hmm...so Dudley is now the "head honcho" of the scrap engines, and 1020/Dane is the kind soul? Interesting choice in characters.
I know that this story and Richard the New Engine series two separate storylines, but I'd like to think that this experience was what changed D261 into helping Richard find a new chance at life when Henry made that fateful bargain.
Yep I can actually see that and that would be called character development.
But that engine doesn’t look like Dudley to me
@@laurahossack9953 The one with a face is a LNER O2 and said face is quite similar to Dudley's.
I love this story. The use of the pilot Gordon and Thomas models, Dudley and 1020 (nad maybe the Kildane experiment) makes it seem like if you disrespect the dead. The dead will disrespect you. I like how Dudley and the scrap engines confront Bowler and show who really has more dominance. The use of 1020 as a saviour is really befitting when he encouraged Oliver to keep going and not give up in ‘Spirit of Survival’. Really like the crossover of different characters in this. Great job Shunter!
Such a frightening experience for Bowler, He definitely got taught a lesson.
You never cease to spook us, dude. Truly intriguing to see two different scrap engines from two different writers end up in the same story...
I haven’t watched but I hope it’s good form your view
Not only that, but this story especially was a perfect mixture between scary and wholesome.^^
This felt like Diesel’s Demons by Richard Jordan combined with DCG12b’s Xmas Arthur ghost story. Very chilling. Excellent.
I think this is one of the best fan stories about D261! The use of the scrap engines to show that engines that we have sympathy for can become the villains themselves if it means seeking revenge on the character we are used to viewing as the bully who always gets what is coming to him. Naturally, a scrapped Dudley had to appear in this. The fandom really does love the idea of him returning as vengeful scrap engine.
To my surprise, there was no scrap Gary or Tyler (LSWR H15 and Highland Railway 'Castle' types). All of them got scrapped in real life
Nice to see 1020 being nice again after all the events of the Hawin Lake series 😭
Now I wanna see Dane be the guardian angel of these good guy diesels, using his own experience as a restless spirit to help them stay safe from Dudley, who I'm sure won't move on until reverse-dieselization is a thing.
@@BlooMonkiMan oh I like that idea a lot
This is very well made, using Dudley and 1020 / Dane is a very nice narrative considering how it shows dane's character growth of wanting to help engines after the events of hawin lake, as well as a result of what happened to dudley after that story. Very nice contrast and great execution. Props to whoever was involved in making this and I cant wait to see more stories like this :)
Never thought 1020 Dane would act like this, being engine hating engines that replace him and older engines like him. I suppose its some development.
4:21 Well, well. Look who's back again. It's the Sleepy Specter himself, Dudley.
Really loved this story, gives some nice depth to Bowler and was an interesting change-of-pace. Rather than changing his tune solely because of a scary experience, what changed him were the thoughtful actions of 1020. Now I wish poor 1020 could be saved, though of course it's too late now. Sweet how Bowler still wishes to see him again.
Now THAT was an amazing story, I love that not only did the scrap engines get a chance to be seen as a proper vengeful force, but also managing to show there can be a difference between the kinds of spirits you find here
I loved this, and Bowler felt like the near perfect character for this story, the only other two I could see this working for are D199 or Diesel, but I think Bowler works better due to the blank slate his character is and how possible it is to mould him into the position he ended up in, amazing work on the story
What about Old Stuck-Up? Would it work for him, too?
I do understand the scrap engines. They were right with their statements, but the ghost of engines past was a s well. D261 had gone too far, but he indeed deserves a 2nd chance + yes. Engines get replaced. Time is the answer.🙂
(Hope it gets a pin. That's a statement for everyone watching it.)😉
Your Shunter Productions fan Lexie.😁
New working theory: Dudley was finally scrapped and his soul lay dormant till Diesel woke his soul up and Dudley remembered his hatred and pain. When Bowler came in, Dudley decided he could get payback and attempted to scrap him.
On the other hand, 1020 found peace and saw what was happening in the scrapyard, and remembered the kindness he once had and wished to help those in need
I love it 😁👏👏👏
Dane the benevolent
&
Dudley the Malevolent
Kinda funny when you think all the horrid diesels are given a fright to change whereas those who show compassion (dereks deathwish comes highly on that theory) are given the blessing not to be afraid of them.
Thank you 1020!!!
5:27 The alternate's laugh really fits with the moment
I imagine that the majority of the scrap engines would attack a diesel but I’d a steam engine were to get lost and stuck in the sidings they would get them out of there or would be silently watching over them to make sure they do not suffer the same faith as them. Plus I think most of the engines that wanted bowler dead were young engine and those who believed they were still in their prime. Over all great story one again by the king of horror himself.
1020 has become one of my favorite characters. We need more of him.
I do like how more and more people seem to be using the smelters yard as a pseudo silent hill for the engines
Amazing adaptation! Scrap engines trying to scrap someone is interesting
I must say you perfektly captured the old Magic from the first few seasons of the series back when they made so good Halloween Episodes with the models. I am exited about what you will bring out in the hopefully near Future
That was amazing. Your adaptations and stories never miss 👍🏻
That beginning felt strangely familiar there.
For a moment, I thought it was Class 40's perspective on being in the Smelters during the events of The Spectre's Warning/A Dark Knight for Bert. It kinda looks like an alternate story of it.
That scene with the scrape engines is very frightening
Especially when a rusty Dudley (I thought it was the Killdane Experiment when I first saw it) was like the leader there. Nice to see a certain engine came to help Class 40 on his way in the end in a way.
A very frightening story, but nice in the end. Well done here!
The king of eerie ttte stories returns for another fantastic tale
I haven't seen very many pieces that are of this high a quality. WELL Done.
Feels like Diesel’s Demons and A Dark Night for Bert all over again, but well done on this chilling tale!
I love this story! It is an amazing message for the modern era, for everyone.
Well, after an encounter like that, I think it's safe to say that old Bowler is scarred for life! Excellent work Shunter! Your work never fails to impress us!
So Dudley became the scrap engine I've seen in Arry Learns A Lesson that's wild and hold on DANE has he become a guardian in this timeline
Dane really became one of sodors angels
Very intersting story, ShunterProductions.
Berts comment about “Strange things happens around here” makes more sense.
One of the better spooky stories I’ve watched recently, very good :)
Crikey... What a story... 0_0
Interesting story by the way!👍
Keep it up ShunterProductions
Great Story of Bowler You Made There
The Part Where All The Scraped Engines Surrounded Bowler and Dudley Took Him to The Sidings Where They Cut up The Engines Was Scary
And The Part Were 1020 Helped Bowler Escape and Took Him to The Fuel Pumps Was Kind of Him
I'm 19 years old and that story in wrapped me!!
Gordon’s ghost story Came out 14yrs ago today 😮 amazing this guys still active after all this time keep up the good work
Oooo I hope to see more of these specters especially dudley
The Killdane Experiment is Dudley’s second in Command Right next to him as he comes out of the fog.
I think they are meant to be different engines but he might have used them as stand ups for regular scrap engines
Maybe, maybe not.
this was actually a really nice story
This is proof not all ghosts are vengeful - even if it is fiction
This is very new, hello.
Question, may we have a series of videos explaining certain concepts of this universe.
Sometimes, all it takes to turn a Horrid Diesel kind is to give them a Little Haunting at the Scrap Yard.
Amazing Spooky Video, Man!
Oh my gosh this was amazing story 👍👍
We've seen Bert, Diesel and now Bowler come across the ghosts of steam engines of the past. I really look forward to when it's ’Arry's turn to come buffer to buffer with those ghosts.
In my honest opinion, ’Arry’s the worst of the diesels mentioned here.
Maybe you could do a story where Bowler finds the kind scrap engine, takes him to the works where is repaired and joins the steam team
The scrap engine is dead tho. He’s meant to be the guardian angel to all engines. Also why the heck would they join the steam team being long dead?? Plus the concept of a main character team is irrelevant in ShunterProduction stories.
Amazing
13 minutes ago? huh
YIPPEEE
Nice you use 22 tesla sound form the wandering coach into this video
So in the scrap yard there is a lot of scrap engine with Dudley and 1020/dane
The Killdane Experiment and Dudley try to scrap Bowler, but another steam engine save him.
This reminds me of the one episode of Bert talking with the old spectral engine
Seeing 1020's model with a smile is very cursed I'll be honest
I know. I truly love Dane Model. :)
I know this was inspired by the Buried Trucks story but was just horrifying. The scrap engines just tried to kill them.
Definitely interesting
be cool to Kno who those steam engines were, especially the one who saves bowler
Wow this was dark but thrilling
Sorry I didn’t recognize the models until I read the comments but with my vision I sometimes miss things
Yeah but just one thing, behind Dudley, I can see the Killdane experiment making hissing and clanking noises and the prototypes of Thomas and Gordon, pilot Thomas and Gordon that is, but I didn’t think that Dane was a kind engine to save the diesel, it was like when he gave Oliver confidence to keep going to Sodor, not to mention a very kind soul of the spirit
Excellent story!
MASTERPIECEEEEE
All these stories about the diesels and the scrapyard make me wonder why A & B haven't gone crazy lol
(but this is good, ngl)
Whilst I’m not sure about Bowler being in Diesel’s place in Demons, I can get behind the moral of the story.
Glad I’m not the only one who calls that diesel “Bowler”.
You should do the story From The Mountains next.
Lost In The Smelter! Don’t Mess With The History! Written by The Jolly Mariner!
if you think about it steam engines are kinda hypocrites. Before they came along horses pulled wagons. Throughout steams tractions life there were attempts to improve or replace them (oil burning instead of coal, using electric to preheat water making them literal kettles on wheels, full electric heck there was one engine that was powered by diesel whilst the boiler was heating up). They had over a century to become more efficient. Aside from most of them being extremely rude, some diesels such as derrek (I think that's his name the one who kept breaking down on the episode "double teething troubles") were just as prone to malfunction as steam engines maybe more so.
This is a ghost story with realism at its finest! I love the fact the scrapped steam engines include Dudley, The Killdane Experiment and the prototype Thomas and Gordon models. Makes me think that all of those stories are canon to this one!
Here’s my reaction to this story if you want to hear more of my thoughts on it:
ua-cam.com/video/3RJW68gWc5M/v-deo.htmlsi=sOgpfvZGxYCPHoqZ
do the killdane expirament next pls
Once again the same spirit who inspired Oliver to fight for survival saves another engine and shows them the error of their ways.
4:57 definitely Dudley
Oh it's Dudley!
Hay!
Thats my scrap engine!
This was very fucking good
That stuff creepy man
How about the extended railway series like Stanley, Jim the jinx and closure?
God i got chills
13 NOvembre 2023 thoodles 😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤🎉🎉❤🎉😂🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤🎉🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤🎉🎉❤🎉🎉🎉🎉❤🎉❤🎉
Looks like 1020/dane help bowler just like he help Oliver and toad with courage
Was that 1020/Dane😮
Are you going to do a part 2 of the story with Oliver and endolyn
1020 helps again
Where did the scrap engine models come from? Are they available for download anywhere? I think they fantastic
Something I wonder about is sodor’s scrap engines. All of em usually look like the same shapes of living charecters.. why did the railway have so many of the same kind?
Engine 1020 very friendly saves the disel😢😢
WHO MADE THE Scrapyard route?
2:29 the beginning of the madness
Damn
3:05 that scrap engine looks like Thomas
13 NOVEMBE 2023 THOODLES
what on earth was this made in, and how did you make it
So I was right dudley was scrapped
That was disturbing
Dudley here scrapyard he is back
Ok it’s ether that there’s ghost haunting the scrapyard or bowler is scitzifrenic
There's a big difference between trapped and lost ok? Trapped just means stuck somewhere, and lost just means unable to find anymore
It asham that bowler could have asked while he was being pulled to the fuel pump
Why the title of this video different than the thumbnail
Like the title is 'lost in the smelters' but the thumbnail is 'trapped in the smelters'
Typo but still good
Is it lost or trapped?