[COMPARE] Which is better? Simple guide to Gundam Marker VS Panel lining Ink

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 40

  • @lordfrankuss
    @lordfrankuss 11 днів тому +7

    To avoid accidentally erasing the color of the lines with alcohol, it is better to use a pencil eraser, it removes the marks well.

  • @relentlesspike979
    @relentlesspike979 14 днів тому +12

    Here's a tip! Use 99% isopropyl alcohol for cleaning! So much cheaper and so much more effective, super quick drying time witch that means almost no smell

    • @nikushim6665
      @nikushim6665 День тому +2

      The main reason a lot of people use alcohol is probably because GSI Creos uses alcohol based acrylics in their gundam branded markers (its the same paint as their Aqueous line pots). Tamiya on the other hand is a oil based enamel, while alcohol will sorta work if you scrub at it you're better off using mineral spirits or naphtha (such as lighter fluid) to remove it. The point of Tamiya's x-20 is to thin paints for airbrushing its just watered down methylated spirits and propylene glycol which acts a retarding agent (slows paint drying time so it doesn't get dry tip when sprayed)
      As for the whole cracking deal, I think most of this comes from people panel lining fully assembled kits where the ink can end up flowing between parts with no place to properly evaporate and cure. This issue is easily solved by disassembling your kit prior to panel lining or just doing it before assembly.

  • @yamirpoke2616
    @yamirpoke2616 17 днів тому +6

    I use the pen 🖊️ and work in all my gundams perfect 👌🏻

  • @aluydpoleno3703
    @aluydpoleno3703 Місяць тому +6

    I use gray, dark gray and light gray for panel lining. Shake it well before using. It's good. It looks like a deep shadowy tone not same with the black that the kit will make looks like a 2Dish or cartonish vibe.

    • @lucamodric4268
      @lucamodric4268 26 днів тому

      Hey on what parts do you use light gray ??

    • @aluydpoleno3703
      @aluydpoleno3703 26 днів тому

      @lucamodric4268 on dark gray parts like inner frames

  • @BattleB3rry
    @BattleB3rry 3 дні тому

    I use Tamiya ink but I dab it on my pieces with a fountain pen for more control vs the included lid brush thingy

  • @yu5016
    @yu5016 7 днів тому

    I have used them for dozen of kits. I actually prefer ink much more because its sticks to the plastic much better. For washing washing use lighter fluid as it doesn't damage the plastic as much as the thinner plus it smells less too. But always remember to wear Ppe and don't apply the lighter fluid too much.

  • @Lucius6666-u2w
    @Lucius6666-u2w 4 дні тому

    question, why don't you use gundams pour type markers? Is there a certain reason? Is the end result worse than Tamiyas and the Pens?

  • @JustAnotherPest
    @JustAnotherPest 22 дні тому +1

    I've used the accent color on about 8 kits without topcoating for protection and I've had exactly one piece crack.
    So it's possible, but it does seem extremely infrequent. I do wonder if it was the result of some other factor, though.

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  18 днів тому

      Thanks for sharing. This is helpful to know.
      Some comments I saw online mentioned it affects bandai's ABS plastic runners (since not all are ABS). So that's a factor to consider / verify

    • @JustAnotherPest
      @JustAnotherPest 18 днів тому

      @@Wonghobby13 Yeah I've heard that too so I don't touch those with the accent color, but it feels like ABS parts are almost always internal anyways so there's not much reason to line them.

    • @Roggitussin8008
      @Roggitussin8008 16 днів тому

      Ive always panel lined while the parts are still on the sprew and ive never had anything crack

  • @akhdannaufaldy1693
    @akhdannaufaldy1693 Місяць тому +1

    A cheaper yet safe alternative for Mr. Hobby or Tamiya thinner is lighter liquid.
    I use Mr. Hobby panel liner for both Bandai and bootleg kits since i've heard/seen that Tamiya panel liner is too strong and will break bootleg kits' plastic, and i use lighter liquid or eucalyptus oil to clean the panel lines.

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  Місяць тому

      I never had a bootleg kit so that’s interesting to know . Thanks for the tips!

  • @lib-modelkitfigure
    @lib-modelkitfigure Місяць тому +1

    Get the best of both world with Gundam Marker Panel Line Pour-type, GM301, 302 and 303

  • @CopperBeardBen
    @CopperBeardBen Місяць тому +4

    You need to shake the gray, all the pigment has settled to the bottom.

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  Місяць тому +2

      Will definitely try again with the shake! Thanks :)

  • @jarosbodytko6462
    @jarosbodytko6462 6 днів тому

    Here's a silly noob question that just occurred to me, but can't you just panel line with thinned down enamel or acrylic black or gray paint? I always see people use markers or Tamiya panel liner which seems to be a bit of a waste of money if you probably already have black or gray paint lying around anyway?

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  5 днів тому

      @@jarosbodytko6462 acrylic paint is too thick when used and needs extra steps to thin down so tamiya panel liner allows painters to control the thickness easier

  • @psnscreamokujo6230
    @psnscreamokujo6230 27 днів тому

    I use panel lining markers grey and black only. I use my scribing tools to try and open the lines a bit more to get deeper in the cracks but its not a good choice....in my opinion anyway. I woukd rather get the panel lining paint than use marker...

  • @heymanchan9007
    @heymanchan9007 18 днів тому +1

    You know ,that pen cannot used over other paint. It will eat away the paint while washing the excess or during applying

  • @irvingmuhammad1791
    @irvingmuhammad1791 Місяць тому

    I used both. Sometime the tamiya panel line not work on some surface.

    • @akhdannaufaldy1693
      @akhdannaufaldy1693 Місяць тому +1

      Pour type panel liner don't work well with shallow surfaces.

  • @piyoweb
    @piyoweb 2 дні тому

    Be aware the bottle panel liner is oil based and it could damage plastic! They're meant to be used for those who painted the kits first...
    You could risk it on MG kit but don't do it RG.

    • @patrickyeary
      @patrickyeary 3 години тому

      I use it on everything and I think it’s just certain plastics like ABS. Just don’t do it when it’s assembled because it likes to puddle if you’re not careful. Good advice though

  • @kneega6647
    @kneega6647 19 днів тому

    I have a rg tall geese as my first gunpla what do you prefer using in these two

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  18 днів тому +1

      I would go with the pen if its my first time to get a feel of it. Also RG tallgeese doesn't have much panelling to do so the pen will be fine as starter.

  • @joshbimthedoctor
    @joshbimthedoctor 17 днів тому

    The pen doesn't eat the plastic, I don't have the patients for painting

    • @jayevox932
      @jayevox932 8 днів тому

      I’ve used the liquid panel liner with an eraser and it works amazingly, depending on the panel lines you do some of them don’t flow as good which would probably have the pen come in handy

  • @thatonedooofus
    @thatonedooofus 12 днів тому

    What about a whiteboard marker?😏

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  8 днів тому

      @@thatonedooofus tried that when I was younger!

  • @wizkerzz
    @wizkerzz Місяць тому

    do you top coating after using tamiya accent color?

    • @akhdannaufaldy1693
      @akhdannaufaldy1693 Місяць тому

      If you want the panel line to last longer then yes

    • @Wonghobby13
      @Wonghobby13  Місяць тому

      I saw many mentioned about using top coat after to protect the plastic. However I don’t use top coating at all. Might be ok for bandai kits without it. Another comment mentioned it affects bootleg kits.