Heat Miser and Snow Miser: 1974 vs 2006 vs 2008
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- 0:00 - 4:00 2006 Live Action A Year Without a Santa Claus
4:01 - 7:31 1974 Original A Year Without a Santa Claus
7:32 - 10:47 2008 A Miser Brother's Christmas
🎶Lyrics🎶 (these are not the real lyrics. JUST FOR TAGS BABY... that was a joke. Please watch this video I need to feed Aidan and Markus. Oh wait, it got copyright claimed. Please help me feed Aidan).
I'm Mr. White Christmas
I'm Mr. Cool.
I'm Mr. Icicle
I'm Mr. 10 below
Friends call me Snow Miser
Whatever I touch
Turns to snow in my clutch!
I'm too much
He's mister white Christmas
He's mister snow
He's mister icicle
He's mister ten below
Friends call me Snow Miser
Whatever I touch
Turns to snow in my clutch!
I'm too much
I never wanna know a day
That's over 40 degrees.
I'd rather have it 30, 20 then 5.
Let It Freeze!
He's mister white Christmas
He's mister snow
He's mister icicle
He's mister ten below
Friends call me Snow Miser
Whatever I touch
Turns to snow in my clutch!
I'm too much
I'm Mr. green Christmas
I'm Mr. Sun.
I'm Mr. Heat Blister
I'm Mr. One Hundred and one
They call me Heat Miser
Whatever I touch
Starts to melt in my clutch.
I'm too much!
He's mister Heat Miser
He's mister sun
He's mister heat blister
He's mister hundred and one
They call me Heat Miser
Whatever I touch
Starts to melt in my clutch.
He's too much
I never wanna know a day
That's under 60 degrees.
I'd rather have it
80, 90, 100 degrees!
They call me Heat Miser
Whatever I touch
Starts to melt in my clutch.
I'm too much
Too much!
Heat Miser and Snow Miser 2008 Reprise: ua-cam.com/video/iyRQlE8fglA/v-deo.html
Snow Miser dies and gets replaced by Drip Goku (who is a very big ham): ua-cam.com/video/3BZTyOqcc50/v-deo.html
Snow Miser is a Crack Addict??????
ua-cam.com/video/E-J6cfK6EFk/v-deo.html
While the animation in the 2008 version is better it just doesn’t have the right feel to me like the stop motion of the 1974 version
You just can't top the original version if it was perfected out the door.
@@tylerloesch1660 I feel the same exact way, I don't know why but I've always thought of stop motion if somebody mentioned Rudolph the Red nosed Reindeer, or Frosty the Snowman, I just like the stop motion far much better and is immediantley what I think of when it's brought up.
Heat miser is a weed attic.
Mark Hamill should've voiced Snow-Miser in the 2008 one
I wasn’t aware there was a live action and I feel I could have peacefully lived my life never knowing there was a live action.
It's actually quite good
I'm scared now...honestly XD
Agreed
Agree
Snow mizer went hard asf tho
"Friends call me Snow Miser"
"They call me Heat Miser"
Heat Miser has no friends.
Hey me!
Someone noticed!
Hey yea
Oof that's sad
Snow Miser is the coolest guy ever and Heat Miser is a hothead who rhymed "degrees" with "degrees," so it makes sense
Fun fact: in the 2008. The voice for the heat miser is the original actor before he past away. So…that very sweet seeing him doing the big heat again.
*passed
@@blackqweenmars thanks.
That what I meant.
He didn’t pass away until 8 years later. You made it sound like he passed away not long after the movie
@@Y2JHHHDX sorry, I didn’t mean sound like that.
Mickey Rooney also returns as Santa Claus in that movie too!
First one sounds like hes been smoking for 60 years
so true XD
Actually that’s just his voice you should here him in hairspray
If you mean in 1974 I know.
But it just gives them a charm
@@soft_box9331 No the one before that
That’s just Harvey Fiersteins voice. He was the voice of Yao in Mulan (The short army guy with the temper) and Frank Hillard in Mrs. Doubtfire (Robin William’s brother)
Live action: deep sadness
Original: good meme fodder
2008: The lip syncing is scaring me
For me, it's not the lip syncing, it's the puppets. They're oddly expressionless compared with the 1974 ones.
Everett Hmm.. perhaps that's also the case. The higher frame rate is kind of weird to me, too.
I kinda like stiff stop motion
@@TheWittenburgerI agree; somehow, the 1974 version is way more expressive. The 2008 version's eyes are dead and stare into your soul.
Theres a parody of the rudolf one out there.
Fun fact: at 5:22 you can see that Snow Miser keeps spinning when he says "That's Right!" but his head stays pointing the camera. This means that, canonically, Snow Miser can turn his head 360 degrees, although I imagine he much prefers it 20, 10, 5 and then let it freeze.
Hey I see what you did there
👏👏👏 too much
nice dad joke.
I may be 7 months late, but you made me smile
Any time is a good time@@RM-mw2xr
It doesn't matter how cringy any of it is. The song is still the catchiest song I know of.
minus Harvey Flindsten the fucking cigarette
@DylanPlayzYT The original
What is more cringy is lazy town and sonamy
@@thomascagnon2894
Don't talk shit about lazy town!
ain't shit cringy about classic Rankin Bass, m'lad.
original is the best by far, but the 2008 remake isn't nearly as bad as the live action one.
The Great Bootleg yeah it had E F O R T put into it
Yeah i agree
Yeah the 2008 was good just like the original but man I really don’t like the live action one
its helps they actually got the guy who voiced heat miser to come back and reprise his role after so many years.
The Great Bootleg I really like the Snow Miser’s design in the 2008 version
The 2008 version is hilarious just because of the fact that snow miser is minions look absolutely miserable while heat miser’s minions seem to be actually happy to some extent for once
You could say the snow miser's minions are a bit...cold
@@Fellkunpun detected
Opinion accepted
@@Fellkun And I should be since I bet their wages are below zero
@@kenjongkilawogg860 I see what you did there
@@Fellkun *du dum tss*
Never saw the live action one
Never wished I did
I regret seeing it as well. Even more so than the Power Rangers: Operation Overdrive versions of the Miser Brothers. Then again, a lot of fans regretted even watching Operation Overdrive in the first place.
drixg555 heat miser in the live action one is the worst, sounds like he has lung cancer
I agree
They don't do snow miser justice
me too dude, me too.
1974: 10/10
Live action: 5/10
2008: 8/10
You forgot to put a decimal before the 5
@@huntercooper8279 better make it a negative decimal
@@sevenawfulcats3260 we might also want a couple zeros after the decimal for good measure
You're being REALLY generous with the live action remake.
@@huntercooper8279 Right! Lol
How humble of George S. Irving to come back, 86 years young, to reprise the role of Heat Miser 34 years after the fact. You know he was doing it for the kids and the adults who are showing their kids what they grew up on. Blessed!
The original was the best. The 2008 wasn't bad, and tons of credit to George S. Irving for coming back (Snow Miser just wasn't quite the same). That live-action -- thing -- oh ye gods, what was that?!
@@thomaswheeler9126 They also got Mickey Rooney back as Santa Claus. Yeah, it's too bad Dick Shawn wasn't around anymore to reprise Snow Miser. I feel like they could have either gotten someone better than Juan Chioran (the new voice of Snow Miser) or had him listen to Shawn's original performance a bit more so he could emulate the singing better. By no means did Chioran do a bad job. It just didn't quite live up to the original. And ye, the live action one...what the hell?
@@dc1313drc I'd forgotten about Rooney, who was certainly the iconic voice of Santa Claus for these special shows. It's almost surprising that he was still alive at that point to do it, but I'm glad he (and Irving) did.
@@thomaswheeler9126 Rooney actually didn't pass until 2014 at 93. Hard to believe there was someone older than Irving working beside him in the same special lol
Especially considering he hadn't acted in over a decade.
Snow miser seems like someone you could hangout with on a Saturday night and get a beer with while heat miser seems like someone the whole neighbourhood would fear
True
You might say, snow miser is chill and heat miser is hot headed?
Heat miser is that one teacher we don't wanna anger cuz they'll kill you
But fire miser for some reason throws his yearly BBQ where he makes his famous ribs and that's why everyone puts up with him lol
One's a chill dude the other is a hot head
i.... Never even knew they had a live action one....
Oh god now I wish I didn't know
Alexandria Nation Lmao I didn't even know they made remakes of it
I feel your pain
Rainy Sunny quick does anyone have any b l e a c h ?
Alexandria Nation Nah. But we got T I D E P O D S
Jamie Buchanan *G I M M I E 2 0*
As legend goes these two constantly duke it out in Missouri, this is why we've had 80 degree Christmases and ice storms in July.
It's the same in Colorado fall and spring don't stand a chance it snows in September but gets 60 in December but then it blizzards in March and is brutally hot in October
yeah
Oh gosh ain’t that the truth
same in you neighbor state ky
You know what they say. *First time's the charm*
tru
No i thought it was Third times the charm
Wow not many likes
STOSHDHDBFBFRJR
Supa Player yeah Justin Y. always gets tons of likes
They put a lot more effort in the stop motion than the live action
It was made with love from the heart and care for the spirit of the holiday and what it was based on
The live action is just **shudders** lets not talk about that
Stop motion for life!
True the stop motion is more superior but this brings a question. Why is the tempo of the song in 2008 version slower? Granted the the original slowed the tempo in the original when they introduce Heatmiser, but if I had to choose which version kept the song to a energetic rhythm and catchy beat it would be the live action version.
Sure Micheal Mckean nailed as the snowmiser as he sang, and I didn't like Heatmisers voice but if you listen to the rhythm and beat it's really good.
Heck the only way your gonna get heat miser to sing to the same tempo as snow miser in the original is if you sped up the video
I agree stop Montion is better
1974 is by far the best. something about the old animations like rudolph, etc with the painted wooden looking puppets with rough edges, and Snow Meisers hair having that glossy look reminds me of decor you would put around the house during the holidays and gives me nostalgia
funny you mention them looking like painted wood puppets, because that's exactly what they are
Agreed, the old versions had detail, big, and small, making them memorable all these years.
I feel the same as you do, in regards that the 1974 version is the best. The live action one just was... I don't know.. strange. And honestly, the 2008 version was actually kind of creepy... Also... What the HELL was Snow Miser doing with his tongue at Heat Miser's ear at 8:38?! I thought this was a KIDS program!!
I was looking for the originals, I definitely can't afford them but I'd love to own the original puppets, they look so cool
They are clay pal@@CNR.5K
The original is still by far the best, with the remake an honest attempt to appeal to the charms of the original. The live action was... well... Snow Miser was a good attempt. And I like the Hawaiian Shirt Heat Miser. The premise was pretty... bad. And that's putting it mildly, but for what it's worth, having the Snow Miser side fire Icicle Bolts from a Ballista and Heat Mister slingshot Fireballs? That was a nice touch.
Chris Smith BUT, WHY WERE THE WOMAN WEARING SEXUAL CLOTHES!?!?!?
Feminists will mob the creator's house.
Because sex sells.
ChangelingTale the commenter CHILL THE HECK OUT
I have tp change my Identity everytime they find me which results in a hardy change for me
Its not a remake, its meant to be a sequel iirc. It's not bad, but my main issue is that too many designs are different. But its still fun and a good attempt at recreating the magic of Rankin Bass's Christmas classics.
Live Action movie deserves to be forgotten about, i had till this, though it has a few neat ideas but they get drowned out by everything else being pretty awful.
I find heat miser vocal kind of distracting
I think what the remakes miss is how the two verses change in tempo. Snow miser is upbeat and jovial, bouncing and showboaty. Heat miser takes the slower more lethargic but relaxed tempo
Talk to anyone who lives in a hot, and worse muggy, area and you don't do ANYTHING fast if you can help it
To add to this: now this may be my own perspective, but I see them as two types of gays: the forever boy and the old queen.
Snow Miser is , as Mrs. Claus puts it “a ham”. He’s boisterous, a showman, and someone who enjoys the young lead of musical theatre.
Heat Miser is the old bitter queen. He’s slower in movement, more negative outlook on life, but still loves to put on a performance. Not solely for the love of theatre, but also to show he still has it.
Both sides have their valid experiences (wanting to live life and have fun vs wanting to be appreciated for all the hard work they do/did for their community), but both are also extreme ends of the spectrum.
In this paper, I will…
@@NickCevHahahaha! Nice the Sexual and Mental perspectives of the Miser Brothers: A doctoral thesis!
@@NickCev *shrugs and sits down for this TED talk*
It fits their personality
Also the songs make know sense in the others
In the original they're actually introducing themselves so the lyrics work
In the others the lyrics have them introducing themselves too each other or no one
In the original we know at least iggy didn't know them and it's implied that jingle and jangle have never truly met them as people and not obstacles
i just realized, that the main thing missing in 2008 version, is the slight echo/reverb thats added to the vocals. or most likely, they just recorded it in a large echoey room. it really adds alot to making the sound fuller, and not having it makes it feel just kinda odd
I like how the 2008 one actually made it a duet rather then two songs with the exact same rhythm.
The Golden Ninja whereas the live action made it worse and even slightly confusing by trying to switch up the lyrics nonsensically 😖
and a reprise ver
Than*
Yeah that's why I love that one just an itty bit more
I prefer the 2008 one too. I find it fun to imagine the brothers fighting by singing the song.
So in the original, Heat Miser rhymes "degrees" with "a breeze"... and then in later remakes he rhymes "degrees" with "degrees"??? Come _ON!_
Nah if you listen closely to the 2008 version I think he says "a breeze" but they probably purposely made it sound kinda muddy to appease both audiences. Sadly though, in the live action remake and just about every cover ever, he rhymes degrees with degrees.
Can someone please time stamp the part of the song your talking about?
3:20 of the live action. But, that's two different characters using degrees at the end of a line.
9:48 Heat miser rhymes degrees with degrees. But, it's the same lyrics from the original at 6:43.
Man, I watched this video too many times.
@@lilolebob thank you for your help
This is why he says “They call me-“
Because unlike Snowmiser, he has no friends
Scientifically speaking, Snow Miser is almost certainly orders of magnitude more powerful than Heat Miser. Heat Miser's touch causes extreme heat that can melt metal very quickly. *Snow Miser* on the other hand not only instantly siphons unfathomable amounts of heat from objects, but also changes their entire subatomic composition and transmutes them into water, and thus snow. Whether or not this ability is limited merely to turning things into snow rather than being able to freely manipulate the atomic structure of an object, this alone makes him leagues more powerful than Heat Miser, because no matter how much heat Heat Miser imparts to an object, Snow Miser can take all of that heat away. And all of the heat has to go *somewhere* to make something cold, so it's possible he absorbs all that heat himself and he's just an eldritch heat sink
In short, my childhood self was completely right to prefer the cold and now I have the armchair scientist chops to prove it
Also Snow Miser can turn the object back into its original form. Aka: hat to snow then back to a hat.
TLDR: snow miser was atom eve before it was cool
I like this analysis, but how do you explain Heat Miser reaching up to melt a part of the moon??? That would surely put him leagues above Snow Miser right?
I've been thinking about this myself. They're basically spirits representing the difference of degrees of temperature in nature, so heat miser makes sense. Heat is just energy after all, so he hoarded an excess of it, since he's a miser. Snow miser doesn't make sense in the slightest, you can't hoard an absence of something. Snow is a totally different substance from pure energy, but I guess you could hoard a substance that has an absence of something, it's just really disconcerting. Like, snow miser is made of snow. If you look at his skin and legs, they're all glittery. What in the good god is heat miser made of, pure energy? Is this incongruity on purpose? Nobody except the writers will ever know. If anything, the idea for both of these chaps was probably pitched with the lowest of confidence to the review team and the supervisor okay'd it but you could probably still hear the discontent in his voice.
Not the Rankin-Bass powerscaling
it's a shame the 2008 version did not have the original Voice actor for Snow Miser. sadly he passed away in the 1980's. but the original voice actor for Heat miser was great glad he was still with us. when they did the 2008 version.... I'm not crazy about the graphics for Snow and Heat Miser the look they had for the 1974 version was better. the same goes for Mrs. Clause.
I like the 2008 version better. I like both,they both have nostalgia for me but I used to love watching the 2008 version when it came on tv. Thought it came out earlier though.
Heat miser looks more friendly and snow miser looks younger in the 2008
they shouldve used the old props of them from the original movie for the 2008 one
@@Godofawesome16 I agree
Can't lie though the guy who voiced snow in 2008 did a great job to live up to the snow miser song
Fun fact:
Snow Miser says,“ *friends* call me Snow Miser.“ while Heat Miser says,” *they* call me Heat Miser.“ implying that Snow Miser has friends and Heat Miser doesn’t.
I think people think of them as a Satan type, considering he lives in a bunch of fire. And lava pits.
It's cuz he's a Hot Head duh
You know, after all these decades, I never picked up on that. And it's a darn good point, and I'm certain it was intentional.
Yeah
I once had friends but they melted in my clutch I'm too much
1974- while I never grew up with this version, I recognize it has its iconic nature and well portrayed openings to the songs. At a storytelling standpoint it made sense to introduce both characters at different intervals, giving more purpose for their unique introductions. I’ll always love the iconic line of “Some like it hot but I like it REALLY hot.”
2008- This was the one I grew up with and I will always remember it. I still remember it but after watching the original I appreciated the new concepts they showed such as having both brothers sing in competition which each other, which made sense for their characters and their enclosed environment. I also love the designs of the minions on both sides, rather than having the minions be smaller versions of the brothers they actually have their own unique designs while still having a uniform to them. Also, the design of snowmiser design in 1974 always unsettled me with how scary he looked.
Live Action- Um…what can I say that hasn’t already been said? Snow miser is ok, not good, he doesn’t do anything new but he’s not harmful in any way. Aside that, the live action clearly tries to do what the 2008 version did except it had no charm to it. They say “starts to melt/snow in my clutch” but never show that which always bothers me. I’ll admit, the joke of “ow! Too much!” At the end was new and makes partial sense for the characters.
Nothing will ever beat the 1974 one
Agreed
Yep
none can be best than the original
Absolutely
Yas
1974: Two bros, chilling on mountain peaks, 5 miles apart cause they’re physically unable to be close to one another without making comical jabs at each other
Live action: Hot babes and cold rivalries, also their lairs just happen to be 5 meters across from each other with a neat ravine in between them
2008: And they were roommates, and their underlings are tired of the rival boss’s bull to the point of engaging in roughhousing and shenanigans alongside their own respective bosses
All three iterations can be defeated by 50° weather
This is a very good comment
Interesting
omg they were roommates...
TWO BROS CHILLIN IN A HOT TUB
@@ToastBoastOfficial that's what i thought too
I love how no matter the version, Snow Miser stays the best
The 1974 stop motion version will always be a great classic.
Definitely 😌
1974 version will remain the only one I don't have the physical urge to vomit from. though 2008 Snow Meiser is pretty funny Queer-Coding wise XD
Agreed but the 2008 was better than live action because it was closer to the original
Straight facts right there-
@@sabrinaicestaff probably why no one cares about it lol. Oh well guess that doesn't sell. Right Gillette? Oops they went back to showing girls and buff men 😆 🤣 😂 Ahhhhh I love capitalism.
1974 will always be the winner in my book, it may not be well animated but it's by far the best one out of the three
It has good animation.
@@supaplayer Damn Right
its a classic!
Agreed. 1974 one made the characters really engaging mischievous, immature brothers that can't stop squabbling. Live action was just... what? I don't even. 2008 was just bad. Not even bizarre in the sense of the live action one, it just came across as cheap.
@@101jir in the original the brothers feel like Greek Gods, they do their job and don't give a fuck if innocents are hurt in the crossfire of their endless war for global heat, Snow Miser definitively looks the more friendly of the two but still has a mystic aura around him which makes him somewhat intimidating even if after his song he show's that he's willing to help Mrs Claus and guides them to his brother's place so they can come up with a compromise, Heat Miser on the other hand looks evil and devilish, unlike Snow he never restores any of the items he melts during the song, add to the fact that his brother hypes him up to the elves and the viewers by describing him as a compulsive hothead and you've got a great complementary relationship between the two bros as semi-antagonists for the movie, really goes to show how two well written and catchy songs can make the motives and personality of two characters clear as crystal for viewers of all ages
There’s something about the original that has a stronger charm to me more than the rest.
It’s because they add to the story rather then just be a musical time stamp. Also, they have alot of energy to them.
To give a little referent:
1974, the original, is from _A Year Without a Santa Claus_ . It's a good old Rankin/Bass stop-motion number.
2006 is the live-action remake by the same title. There are several added subplots, some plot changes, and you've just heard the only song to make it in. A Warner Brothers production for NBC. That's Michael McKean as Snow Miser, and none other that the appropriately-flaming Harvey Fierstein as Heat Miser.
2008 is _A Miser Brothers Christmas_ . While Heat Miser is voiced by his original actor (George S. Irving, then 86... good set of pipes), Snow Miser's original actor (Dick Shawn) died in 1987, so Mister Ten Below is being voiced by Juan Chioran. This picture is made by Cuppa Coffee Studios for Warner Brothers Animation.
Wanderer Werewolf wish Dick Shawn was alive in 08, to be honest. Chioran was good, I’ll give him that, but Dick Shawn’s sing with George Irving’s was a pure treasure.
The 2008 ones are disgusting
The original is way better EVEN IN GRAPHICS
It took me awhile to get used to the 2008 designs, but in the end, they aren't that terrible, but not as memorable and fascinating as the original designs. Some of the other models in the special compared to them were either too cute or too ugly to match Rankin Bass' old school charm and aesthetic.
@@Antifearn Actually, going off this video I actually found the live action easier to get used to. 2008 just seems... messed up.
RIP to both of the Misers :(
For some reason, live action heatmiser reminds me of an uncle I don’t even have, and snowmiser is just David Bowie as the Goblin King but a little less chaotic and blue.
Snow Miser is freaking Chuck from better call saul and i can't get over it
Heat Miser is downright painful to hear
guy fieri
He reminds me of Rodney Dangerfield for some reason
@@deathknight1239 Yeah. Daniel's brother from Mrs. Doubtfire gets no respect at all.
Can we talk about how live action Snow Miser sounds like he’s having the time of his life?
Heat Miser looks like he's ready for a good time with the backing singers
I'm oddly obsessed with a movie that came out 4 decades before I was alive.
4 decades? You're 4?
DairunCates a decade is 10 years the original came out 1974
DairunCates smartest 4 year in the world
That DoucheRobbingTheBankOnTheCornerOfThirdStreet
Lmao
MJ Animates how old r u
The one from 2008 legit looks like something straight out of Robot Chicken
Well tech improved for stop motion witch is why everyone is a little faster in the 1974 version and because Rankin bass went defunct in the 80s everyone looks different .
The last Rankin/Bass special was _Santa Baby_ in 2001.
Wait it isn’t?
That’s exactly what I thought it was at first 😂
yalp. actually, i was just thinking that earlier!
The 1974 version will ALWAYS be the best, but all of them are charming in their own way. I applaud to those who made each of them.
This is bassicly the north vs the south during Christmas
Oh, you noticed it too?
I live in the north but we usualy get a white christmas. HEAT MISER TOOK OVER AHHHHHHHHH I AM TEAM SNOW MISER
I’m a desert tortoise so I’m on team heat miser
Pretty sure rhe reason they go to heat miser is to get permission for snowmiser to let it snow in south town
I’m Texas and we support both miser
The Snow Miser in the live action wasn't absolutely horrible, but the Heat Miser? Oh gods lol
Sounded like if Mark Hamil's Joker smoked 20 pack a day
Honestly I don't mind that kind of voice. You're supposed to be uncomfortable in that kind of blistering heat so why not
I refuse to accept Harvey Fierstein slander
@@maffieduran fr
@@maffieduran I find that most people who don't like Harvey Fierstein don't know who he is and are too young to know about him in many cases.
Unironically, I really liked the 2006 version. It has that cheesy 2000s era charm to it and the actors are really great too. Not to mention, the surf-rock arrangement is really catchy.
Who else skipped the first one to get to the original
Me
Me
Me
Everyone
Me
4:14 top ten anime entrances
@Icedpepsi hi
That’s actually true because the animation was made in Japan
king shit
Top ten times you say "not again"
Ironically they'd call live action anime in an unironic manner.
I know it's not just me when this movie gets mentioned, the miser brothers song immediately enters your head and can't get it out for a long time do too how catchy it is.
This is literally all I remember about the movie so yes
1974 is the best one (I like the designs of the characters best) but the 2008 one isn't bad
But that live action one
Oh man
I wish one of those icicles shot into my eyes
live action heat miser sounds like he's been smoking for 40 years
@@lunarwhispers LITERALLY 😭🖐
@@lunarwhispers more like 70
@@Thebigshot1997HAEHAEHAE more like 80
@@vanilla5643 more like 101
One of the bigger takeaways you can see - the original 1974 version used them as separate set pieces that were apart, both other versions wanted to shove them together without understanding that the songs were not meant to be played together by design.
The 2008 workers look like they are working in a Soviet factory with their oppressed faced of misery. Am I alone in this opinion
I know right? As the others looked happy to talk about their Masters
Your not
Your not alone
I feel the voice quality in the 2008 is way worse than the 1974 version
MISERy
I love the improvement of stop motion between 1974 and 2008!
Although I feel the original had a little more expression in the face.
The newer version is very good with movement, and everything moves very fluidly!
I actually prefer older stop-motion, it just felt better to me, but i can see why some people would like the new stuff, the technology itself hasn't improved much but the techniques have
@@Baconator5642 the older one had better writing, music and character design, but the new one had much more refined animation. It had just the right amount of camp to it
@@bella_ciao4608 Yeah that's fair
The live action doesn't look perfect, but it actually sounds good!
For one thing, it's a duet. It feel like they've been fighting and singing the exact same song for so long, that they've learned a call and response version.
Second, Heat Miser's voice takes some getting used to; but I like to think that living in a volcano and presumably yelling at his brother has taken a toll on his throat.
And last, it's fun! It's got a fast energy to it.
Overall, it's not my favorite of the three; but it's pretty good.
Fair point
Thats fair, and honestly the actors look like their having fun with the role at least.
The original will always be the best
Nothing can ever beat it
I've never heard more true words in my life
i like stop motion one
the 1974 one
@@blaynec7682 that’s the original
@@Fitness6564378 i know
My favorite thing is that they're just sitting there waiting for them to finish there whole friggin number
Cold Miser seems to be the type of guy you go to the clubs with and everybody knows him. Heat Miser is the guy you meet on the beach during the summer and the two of you drink beer on the beach and chill.
Just found out that Heat Miser's voice actor from the original, George S. Irving reprised his role for the 2008 remake. Even after 30+ years he does a flawless job. Amazing actor
Snow miser: “I’m mister white Christmas!”
Heat miser: “I’m mister green Christmas!”
Texans with freezing cold weather but everything’s still green: *“WHY THE HELL ARE BOTH OF YOU HERE?!!!???”*
Lmaoooo
They worked out their problems in the 2008 version
What is it that Texans consider “freezing cold”?
Lel
this town is big enough for the both of us except its a state and ah heck a lot of people just died
Who thinks that the following is a coincidence?
4:20
I'm Mister White Christmas, I'm high on crack!
Sadly, nothing can compare to the humor and voice of the original Snow Miser. Also, the original Miser brother mini mes of each were so friggin cute.
the 2008 mini snow misers dont look as good as the original ones honestly
Live action was and still is painful. x_x Weirdly enough, the live action Snow Miser and and the newest Heat Miser sounded the closest to the originals to me.
More painful than their Power Rangers: Operation Overdrive versions?
DreKozar that's because the remake was more....swingy
At the end it increased a note
@@drixg555 "excuse me, the fuck did you just say?"
@@superrandomguy-lz4jf I'm sorry. I should never have mentioned Operation Overdrive. It was one of the worst of franchise and it still peeves fans to this day. The Miser Brothers did not deserve to be compared to Moltor and Flurious.
@@drixg555 no I mean elaborate on what you just said
2006: best idea
1974: best visuals
2008: best execution
Watching this now it seems like Snow Miser is actually the nicer one, while Heat miser just comes off as being hyper aggressive
it makes sense since to stop being cold you just need to go inside or wear a coat, but to stop being hot you have to live inside of a freezer for the entire summer
Well, heat does contain more energy than cold
LOL
Well he is HOT headed
I find while that is true, Snow Miser tends to purposefully hit Heat Miser's buttons to get him to blow his top, perhaps to blame Heat Miser for "starting it"
Guess you call him a *chill* dude
Heat Miser's voice in the 2006 version is terrible. He sounds like the announcer from Crazy Taxi.
George Irving will always be the true version.
Mark Haynes Buy your friends an Easter egg for Christmas!
Easter eggs are useful as can be.
Take your Christmas money
To your local bunny
And you can lay an egg
Beneath the Christmas tree.
Easter eggs no longer just for Easter.
Now that we have Christmas every day.
It’s the universal gift!
So give a pal a lift
And buy a Christmas Easter egg today!
That’s how his voice actually sounds asshole! The world does not deserve Harvey Fierstein he’s too fabulous for us
Bradley Cotton Dude i loved that movie when i was little
Mark Haynes awww but he’s a legend :(((
At least snow miser has a good voice
I saw the 2008 version before the 1974, but the latter is obviously the best one. Both animations were great. I love how the original voice actor for heat miser came back in the spin-off sequel. He sounded almost exactly the same
Snow miser is the most extra person ever and it's amazing
He's too much
Original is by far the best for me! There is so much charm in both performances that you just want to watch it over and over again
10:26-10:27 And 10:28-10:29 Heat Miser: Green Christmas! Snow Miser: White Christmas!
It actually inspired me to buy the movie off of UA-cam since I had lost the original disc for it as a child
I like the 1974 version, they made Snow Miser look like a really fun and friendly guy and made Heat Miser a real grump! And for 2006, I could've lived better never knowing it existed.
full on agree w this
I have learned that no matter what 50 degrees is hated by everyone
I find they finally did Mr.Heat Miser justice in 2008. He got a snazy new outfit and has an overall friendlier look to him now smiling more.
The other ones on the other hand depict him rather badly and being a grump.
played by the original 74’ guy too!
Well yeah not every character needs to be like Pinkie Pie or Spongebob.
@@Bunni504 I am not saying that he needs to be happy all the time just that he can also smile sometimes.
@@davidmartin5483 he does have a positive side. He thanks his mini-mes, seems to take pride in being "too much", and comes up with very creative insults.
It's a little less America-centric, since there are a couple English-speaking countries on the southern-hemisphere that experience their Summer during Christmas, where it's better to have a warm Christmas day for barbecues and outdoor activities to enjoy without rain getting in the way.
I used to sing this a lot as a kid. I liked the Miser brothers, still do at age 20.
I try not think about the live action one
W-why?
@@moretolife2724 what the hell do you mean by "why?" its the worst remake of all time!!!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?
The live action gives me night mares
Pls help get it out of my head
@@jg-tn1or Alright, here: "Spooky, scary skeletons send shivers down your spine."
"When you tell the joke twice, the second time ain't funny anymore"
However, comedy comes in threes
the live-action _Year without a Santa Claus_ is the equivalent of the Live action _Grinch who stole Christmas;_ it's just not quite as good
@@hobomike6935 the live action grinch was 10,000x times better than the live action year without a Santa Claus. Don't even name them in the same breath.
@@hobomike6935 bro wdym the live action grinch was amazing
@@TheMovieCuban in comparison to it’s original counterpart, not in comparison to other Christmas specials
Living in Texas will have you more acquainted with Heat miser then with Snow miser. He's even had his way for Christmas every few years.
Live action snow miser is ok, heat miser is, ew why, the 2008 snow miser voice is just a little grating too,
RedLighting Animation
I, have to agree with that.
Sadly Snow Miser's original voice actor passed away before they could get him to reprise his role.
Even though I don’t mind it I can see your point
UnlimitedEdge sounds like they got the one for Heat Miser though. Am I right?
Heat Miser in the live action one is Harvey Fierstein he was the original Edna Turnblad in Hairspray on Broadway and his voice actually sounds like that, yet he still has a more successful career than any of us XD
I grew up with the 2008 Sequel, as it was called, so I like it more than the rest, but I do give credit where its due and I do appreciate the original! I just have more emotional attachment to the sequel.
This is the exact same for me. The 2008 special holds a special place in my heart, and I consider it on of my favorite Christmas movies of all time, along with Elf and Adam Sandler’s Eight Crazy Nights.
Understand sentimental value since I grew up with the original one, but the 2008 animation actually scares me tho
10:32 We gonna ignore the fact that Heat Miser was about to ANNIHILATE his brother?
Can't go wrong with the classics (1974) And the (2008) version is a touch of excellency too.
To be honest, the only reason why I like the 2008 version is because of that little shimmy Snow Miser does near the end of the song.
Kerry Bolanos-Shaw That is one of my favorite parts too tbh.
A bit late to the party but I barely caught that and had to go back and watch it again 😂❤ I love it, it's so cute.
The 2008 version was my childhood, and I could never get enough of the little minions that look like them, haha they are all so cute! 😆
I think we can mutually agree the best was 1974
the live action heat miser voice is scary as hell
ME: The live-action version can’t be that bad-
LIVE ACTION VERSION: **Exists**
ME: *Burn it to the ground and freeze the ashes.*
-and then stick it in a 50° Room, just to make them angry
@@violetclinger9325 Put it on the naughty list to make everyone else mad
Most live action recreations tend to… not work well
@@Stupiddumbhead Nah put it on the nice list
The first one
"Lets use ladies to attract attention"
The aundience
Nah...
Yeah, while I put the live action one ahead of the 2008 one personally, that definitely came across as a cheap shot. Although I felt that in the 2008 one everything else came across as cheap.
I remember watching The Miser Brothers' Christmas back in 2008. It's really underrated.
The original is by far the best version. The song is just catchy. The 2008 version was a fan service to the popularity of the Miser Brothers. When I heard they were getting their own special I was excited. For what it was, it was pretty decent. While it can't compare to the original, it was still pretty decent. Another thing is if you listen you can tell George Irving's throughout his part of the song. He lacks the force he had in the original and just sounds winded throughout. In many ways I feel this came a few years too late. Too bad Rankin and Bass never revisited these characters themselves. The live action is something I wish to forget exists. RIP Dick Shawn, George Irving, Shirley Booth, and Mickey Rooney.
The minions in the newer stop motion look like they hate being there
I will never get over how adorable the heat miser minions are
why don't they have a fight to the death? Whoever wins will get their weather
JoJoSoda mother nature wouldn't let them she be pissed off and there to big momma's boys to fight a actual fight
I think that's just about what they were doing at the end there !
Mother Earth
Heat would win right? That’s kinda the way it always works.
Phil Swift’s grandfather Heat Miser just melted stuff. Snow Miser can transmute anything into snow.
Live action heat miser: *exists*
Also live action heat miser: “ＥＡＡＡＡＡＡ”
A W E Y
Man Chuck really went insane if he chose to do this
This man melted the moon
Which is weird when you think about it. You see the 2008 movie takes place after the original 1974 version. In the sequel we get to see a meeting with Mother Nature and her many other children. Two of them are the Tides, which are effected by the moon, which was melted by Heat Miser... So... That's awkward.
Mother Nature: So, how are all my children doing?
Tide 1: Everything was fine.
MN: "Was"?
T 2: Heat Miser Melted the Moon, the MOON! How are we supposed to control the Tides without the Moon?!
MN: You did WHAT?!
HM: I can explain. You see, Mrs. Claus came for a visit and I put on my show as normal and I melted it for a bit of shomanship...
SM: He's so screwed now.
Beat that, gru
Really??!?
1974 snow miser will always be the best version...
I remember watching the 1974 movie every Christmas, in my opinion one of the best old stop motion holiday themed movies.
Liked the 2008 one the best. Love how they made a duet, makes it more dynamic that simply dancing around.
I do not really understand why does everybody else dislike the 2008 version tho, I think it's pretty alright. Just the eyes are a bit weird.
For me 2008 and 1974 Are a tie
1974 version has a better sound, tune, and singing in general
I think that 4:01 has the best singing, while 7:32 has a bit better Stop Motion- Both amazing and both absolute classics.
1 thing I noticed was that in the 2008 remake, the outfits for Snow and Heat miser's minions are callbacks to their 1974 outfits. Which I found cool.
7:59
Snow Miser: Apeears from the ground somehow
Heat Miser: WHAT THE FRICK??
Nothing beats the original, but I always loved the mashup of the 2008 version
Does Supergirl know that Brainiac 5 is actually Snow Miser?🤔
That’s good 😀
Excuse me what?
What?
WHAT?
What’s a supergirl
Or a brainiac 5?
@@Brewski007 supergirl and brainac is fron a dc saturday morning cartoon named "legion of superheroes"
It does not matter which version you watched, you can’t deny that Snow Miser’s song was the GOAT in all 3 versions.
Nah i personally like me heat misers song better no offense
Heat Miser rhymed degrees with degrees therefore Snow Miser is superior
@@switchblade6 not true rappers do that all the time when there is not another word that would make sense to rhyme
Some like it hot Some like it really hot Some people like it cold it's alright to have a preference my brother wears shorts in the winter I wear jackets in the summer
@@HORRORINFINITEdo we have ourselves and Snowmiser Vs. Heatmiser going on?