Change of Guards Singapore, 1st April 2018

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 бер 2018
  • SPDS COG at Istana Apr 2018

КОМЕНТАРІ • 30

  • @EmeraldQueue
    @EmeraldQueue Рік тому +1

    Whoever filmed this has super sharp camera. Thank you for sharing! 🥰

  • @taiwanSmart
    @taiwanSmart 4 роки тому

    Great sense of entertainment

  • @CANNONusmc
    @CANNONusmc 4 роки тому +13

    don't get me wrong it was very good Just some aspects reminded me of a high school band not military at all , and I kinda know military a little.

  • @Kenchanjun
    @Kenchanjun 6 років тому +3

    Is the white cloth around the neck used to absorb sweat?

    • @shaunw.1173
      @shaunw.1173 3 роки тому +1

      Yes. It's a maxi-pad for necks. 🙄

  • @raytan1661
    @raytan1661 6 років тому +9

    Very good. You need not perform excessive stunts. Quick, sharp and orderly manner performing it like a discipline military soldier and not like an acrobat show will already able to impress people very much. Any single mistake by anyone may spoilt the whole show and leave no good impression for spectators. In taiwan, their guards will not make own extra movenent as they like. This is call well disciplined.

  • @user-rw5ev1ff2b
    @user-rw5ev1ff2b 4 роки тому +1

    멋있어요

  • @phenylmusic
    @phenylmusic 4 роки тому

    they actually played firework

  • @adityajulkifli4000
    @adityajulkifli4000 4 роки тому

    👍👍

  • @user-qu8kj8bi3c
    @user-qu8kj8bi3c 4 роки тому

    아빠는 의장대 행사 마니 했으니 경기도 포천 자주포부대

  • @thanhdinh3179
    @thanhdinh3179 Рік тому

    This seems more like a drill team than a guard change. Seems way too upbeat. Also they all left at the end so where’s the change?

  • @user-qu8kj8bi3c
    @user-qu8kj8bi3c 4 роки тому

    잘하구 있구 건강하다구 부모는 생각하내 ~*

  • @LaughingStockfarm1
    @LaughingStockfarm1 3 роки тому +1

    After watching several videos of the changing of the guard at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in Arlington, I came here. Um...nice, well disciplined dance troupe.

    • @wilfredosoto2722
      @wilfredosoto2722 3 роки тому

      Yeah, right? And I’m really disappointed that they’re actually using fake “cadet training” rifles. It’s pretty sad, but we’re comparing them to unit that has a well earned reputation for its traditions and ceremonies. This definitely more of a show than a solemn demonstration of military customs and courtesies. But on the other hand they look snappy and well their musical selections are nice. Their Navy counterparts are setting up a synchronized swimming honor guard with women in mermaid suits. It promises to be even more entertaining. Of course they’re still working on getting the huge swimming tank on wheels to stop splashing out the water with the bumps in the road. The last test group said that it looked like the old sea world orca attraction with water spraying everywhere. The cleaning crew also ran out of the extra absorbent towels, making cleanup even harder. Oh well, I’m sure that they will get it right, eventually.

    • @SharkbaitOhLala
      @SharkbaitOhLala 3 роки тому +3

      @@wilfredosoto2722 You're comparing a full-time force of regulars with real war experience to a conscripted army of 18 year olds whose main job is to defend an island 170 times smaller than New York?

    • @wilfredosoto2722
      @wilfredosoto2722 3 роки тому

      @@SharkbaitOhLala actually combat experience has nothing to do with precision drill. In fact for a very long time the most of the soldiers in the US Army’s 3rd Infantry Regiment “The Old Guard” that is part of the ceremonial troops in Washington DC weren’t combat experienced soldiers. In fact, unlike some countries like the UK for example, the troops assigned to ceremonial duties in Washington, DC, don’t rotate as whole units. What the US does have however is lots of traditions and a very regimented adherence to them. Likewise, the only actual ceremonial changing of a guard unit is at Arlington, VA, and although there is a rifle and uniform inspection that is very precise and there is precision marching, it’s done with solemnity because it’s at the Tomb of the Unknown. There is no unit drilling about there, the drill units do their drills as demonstrations or exhibitions, not as part of a ceremony. When those units participate in ceremonies it’s just that, ceremonies, and they certainly don’t play pop music to their drills. There are tons of militaries that do the same all over the world. They can do what they want, more power to them, my opinion, and you’re entitled to your own, is that the fancy thing isn’t needed and could be better done as an apart from the ceremonial changing of the guard and not as a floor show. And FYI, I have served as a ceremonial guard for dignitaries, raising and lowering of Post flags on bases, and on funeral details on many occasions in the US Army in my 10 years of service, and I’m proud to have had that honor and privilege. No, there is no comparing these guys with the US Army’s, but there are others that come very close and that I admire. I’m not knocking these guys, but again they don’t have to be battle hardened troops to have a more appropriate and dignified presentation. They don’t have to copy the US military either, that’s not what it’s about. But check out the Greeks changing of the guard at their monument to their fallen. That’s most impressive. The changing of the guard at Buckingham Palace or Edinburgh Castle, the Swiss Guard at the Vatican too, all very impressive. If these had left out the drill team and had them perform separately somewhere else, the changing of the palace guard would have been more impressive. It’s like the drill team is competing for attention and there’s no need. That’s all.

    • @SharkbaitOhLala
      @SharkbaitOhLala 3 роки тому

      @@wilfredosoto2722 OK

    • @kermitkingdom2234
      @kermitkingdom2234 2 роки тому

      @@wilfredosoto2722 my guy wrote a long assed paragraph not knowing what he is saying and didnt give any sources

  • @simonscott1000
    @simonscott1000 Рік тому

    Well if you like that kind of thing, not exactly Horse Guards though. 🤔

  • @youtubeaccount5738
    @youtubeaccount5738 2 роки тому +2

    Can they at least instill original British Drum Major mace drills? This one looks kinda whack. And they should really play OG British Marches like, "Vimy Ridge" or "Punjaub".

  • @user-qu8kj8bi3c
    @user-qu8kj8bi3c 4 роки тому

    믿지 안았던 아들이 이그림 보면 이제는 안다구 한다내 ~~*

  • @user-qu8kj8bi3c
    @user-qu8kj8bi3c 4 роки тому

    아빠는 최고루 앞에 섰었는데 ~~*

  • @firdaus2367
    @firdaus2367 3 роки тому

    Rifle......

  • @IZRElLO747
    @IZRElLO747 4 роки тому +3

    The music here sounded too much like tunes played at a street parade rather than a dignified pomp and circumstance march.🎵🎷🎺

  • @calvinwijaya699
    @calvinwijaya699 3 роки тому +4

    Look like high school marching band, lol

  • @vincentmurray3078
    @vincentmurray3078 3 роки тому

    Changing of the Guard in Singapore like they have an audition that's weird

  • @johnwxh30
    @johnwxh30 4 роки тому +4

    Pretty good. However, I find Taiwan's better.

  • @aquakey9834
    @aquakey9834 5 років тому

    HahA! TriggerLESS Rifle!!!