Taiwan: More likely 'when rather than if' China will take action against Taiwan, says analyst

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 тра 2024
  • China's military has finished two days of military drills around Taiwan in the greatest escalation in tension across the Taiwan Strait since 2022.
    China's military described the drills this week as a simulation of how to “seize power” on the island.
    Taiwan's defence ministry condemned the action, calling them an "irrational provocation and actions that disrupt peace and stability in the region".
    Read more: news.sky.com/topic/china-5869
    #skynews #china #taiwan
    SUBSCRIBE to our UA-cam channel for more videos: / skynews
    Follow us on Twitter: / skynews
    Like us on Facebook: / skynews
    Follow us on Instagram: / skynews
    Follow us on TikTok: / skynews
    For more content go to news.sky.com and download our apps: Apple itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sky-n... Android play.google.com/store/apps/de...
    Sky News Daily podcast is available for free here: podfollow.com/skynewsdaily/
    Sky News videos are now available in Spanish here/Los video de Sky News están disponibles en español aquí: / @skynewsespanol
    To enquire about licensing Sky News content, you can find more information here: news.sky.com/info/library-sales

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @tcsmagicbox
    @tcsmagicbox 22 дні тому +136

    It may take 3 months to take the island, but it won't take 3 months to distrupt global economy and semi-conductor deliveries.

    • @magicsmurfy
      @magicsmurfy 20 днів тому

      No worries, they have already moved to USA or these companies like TSMC will get punished by the Biden Administration. They are all scared of USA. The consequence for having your money frozen by the US govt is too much risks for these people who own TSMC. This is about money.

    • @user-nx1mt7ei3q
      @user-nx1mt7ei3q 20 днів тому +7

      中国的目的不是优先解决台湾,装作一副要打台湾的假象,可以先看一下地图,琉球的地理位置比台湾更好,琉球群岛地理位置更广,向上牵制日本向下牵制台湾菲律宾,向东牵制美国2,3条岛链,而且每次包围台湾美军也要出动,但是要知道一点美国离台湾远,中国离台湾近,中国军舰去台湾更省油。

    • @user-nx1mt7ei3q
      @user-nx1mt7ei3q 20 днів тому

      占领台湾不需要三个月,超过24小时代表解放军无能

    • @Zze_611
      @Zze_611 20 днів тому +7

      @@user-nx1mt7ei3q I don't think they plan to go to war with Japan, the Philippines, or Taiwan. Especially Japan, basically the most popular country in the world, NGL

    • @user-nx1mt7ei3q
      @user-nx1mt7ei3q 20 днів тому

      ​@@Zze_611 中国有句古话叫:“杀鸡儆猴”,意思是杀鸡给猴看,上个月东南亚几乎所有国家都访华了,除了菲律宾,你知道为什么吗?为了孤立他,方便对他动手。日本也是,解决台湾有两种一是直接进攻台湾,二是解决第一岛链其他国家,打狗不一定要直接打狗,你可以打狗绳后面牵绳的主人,这样狗自然就老实了。前几天中国外交部发言人直接引用《开罗宣言》宣布冲绳不属于日本领土,中国走的每一步都是有目的的,中国促成伊朗沙特和解,俄乌战争背后是中美博弈,以色列妨碍了中国的一带一路所以挨打,而一带一路是为了团结欧亚大陆将美国势力剔除,今天明天中东逊尼派领导人全部访华,你可以把自己的视野拉到离地面5000公里的地方去看整个地球,这样你才能把世界局势看清楚,中国的工业产能占全球40%,但现在一直在装人畜无害的小白兔,就是为了让西方产生战略误判。在这个百年未有之大变局下,如果你当不了“棋手”,你就只能是“棋子”。

  • @NeilLitchfield
    @NeilLitchfield 22 дні тому +222

    The world's in such a mess

    • @JonnaJonesOG
      @JonnaJonesOG 22 дні тому +11

      @NeilLitchfield All done by design

    • @NeilLitchfield
      @NeilLitchfield 22 дні тому +5

      @@JonnaJonesOG what a poor design

    • @MrStefangyro
      @MrStefangyro 22 дні тому +9

      Armageddon is coming as predicted by the most read and influential book in history of mankind
      HALLELUJAH

    • @NeilLitchfield
      @NeilLitchfield 22 дні тому

      @@MrStefangyro man the most self destructing animal on earth

    • @u2ber888
      @u2ber888 22 дні тому +10

      Wherever there's Amurikan foot print, there's trouble spot.

  • @wajhussain786able
    @wajhussain786able 22 дні тому +336

    Very soon he will be saying china is running out of missiles.

    • @lokozoa1813
      @lokozoa1813 22 дні тому

      😂😂😂😂 like Ukraine getting they arse kicked atm but before the west keep brainwashing their zitizens that Russia is loosing bad😂😂😂

    • @adriansheldon7778
      @adriansheldon7778 22 дні тому

      Well if the dictatorships around the world hadnt sold theirs to ruSSia the Ukraine war would have been over by now .

    • @dogsam-tw9rk
      @dogsam-tw9rk 22 дні тому +8

      哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 确实

    • @stephenm9285
      @stephenm9285 22 дні тому +8

      …😂 or running out of plastic!

    • @stewmaker3983
      @stewmaker3983 21 день тому

      Lol...

  • @Steven-cq7yq
    @Steven-cq7yq 21 день тому +149

    soon he will be saying china is running out of population

    • @markwilson2583
      @markwilson2583 21 день тому

      They are of young men being born all western countries are suffering the same fewer babies being born . Look up the facts . They invade sooner than leave it years

    • @micarsenijevic2313
      @micarsenijevic2313 20 днів тому +3

      😂

    • @michaelp4122
      @michaelp4122 20 днів тому +5

      What does "running out of population" mean? Grammar is important.

    • @benjaminzipser6021
      @benjaminzipser6021 20 днів тому +6

      @@michaelp4122 running out of people bruv

    • @javiercorreapr9977
      @javiercorreapr9977 20 днів тому +1

      @@michaelp4122yes, grammar is very important. regards

  • @claudepoulin8558
    @claudepoulin8558 22 дні тому +403

    It’s never been a better time to stop being made in China and start buying made in your own country.🇨🇦🇺🇸👍

    • @stickmen7117
      @stickmen7117 22 дні тому

      youre so ignorant. the reason everything is affordable is due to chinas cheap labor. If it wasnt for them everythingn would be Too expensive

    • @stephenlowton1911
      @stephenlowton1911 22 дні тому +34

      Taiwan’s Top Trading Partners
      mainland China: US$95.7 billion (22.1% of Taiwan’s total exports)
      United States: $76.3 billion (17.6%)
      Hong Kong: $56.5 billion (13.1%)
      Japan: $31.4 billion (7.3%)
      Singapore: $29.7 billion (6.9%)
      South Korea: $18.2 billion (4.2%)
      Malaysia: $15.2 billion (3.5%)
      Netherlands: $12.9 billion (3%)

    • @mikebird8290
      @mikebird8290 22 дні тому

      If only it was that easy.
      Will take the west age's to prepare for stopping trade with China. SURELY the pandemic taught us that!!!!!🕊️✌🏼

    • @QigongGreyDragon
      @QigongGreyDragon 22 дні тому

      That would be fantastic and would be way easier then to boycott the USA. I'll be buying everything china and nothing yank.

    • @brucelee4357
      @brucelee4357 22 дні тому

      Good luck with that dumbass

  • @punchy1325
    @punchy1325 22 дні тому +138

    Is this the same guy that thinks Russia is losing 😂😂😂😂

    • @IusedtohaveausernameIliked
      @IusedtohaveausernameIliked 22 дні тому +55

      Yep. And btw Russia IS losing.

    • @punchy1325
      @punchy1325 22 дні тому +23

      @@IusedtohaveausernameIliked 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @rickywilcox7358
      @rickywilcox7358 22 дні тому +9

      Russia arent losing now. At first they failed in taking kyiv. But now ukraine are stretched and russia are gaining.

    • @fangchen-qj5us
      @fangchen-qj5us 22 дні тому +2

      @@IusedtohaveausernameIlikedfrontline never lie

    • @healthiswealth6797
      @healthiswealth6797 22 дні тому +8

      He gets bonuses to read his propaganda script

  • @friedersmusik-kanal851
    @friedersmusik-kanal851 20 днів тому +12

    A peaceful world seems to be wishful thinking at the moment... :/

    • @dan61131
      @dan61131 17 днів тому

      Now this modern age China is acting & thinking like Britain colonizers or Hitler's empires during ww2!

  • @VitalityMassage
    @VitalityMassage 21 день тому +22

    How can she stand on those heels with that body?

    • @ecoo911
      @ecoo911 21 день тому +5

      Lots of talent

    • @AJ-lk3ky
      @AJ-lk3ky 21 день тому +2

      Opiates

    • @rd8370
      @rd8370 17 днів тому +1

      Good balance.

    • @VitalityMassage
      @VitalityMassage 17 днів тому +1

      @@AJ-lk3ky Best answer! lol

  • @shawnmclean7932
    @shawnmclean7932 22 дні тому +52

    It sounds like announcing a football match. This could be WW3.

    • @HuanLeVuong
      @HuanLeVuong 20 днів тому +6

      I don't like war but I have to admit that wars are getting more interesting these days. News would be boring without modern wars.

    • @oooooooooo3449
      @oooooooooo3449 20 днів тому +5

      @@HuanLeVuong Isn't boring news okay?

    • @MichaelHampton-fn5rl
      @MichaelHampton-fn5rl 20 днів тому +1

      Ww3 began when Russia invaded Ukraine

    • @user-ii2lm6kg2g
      @user-ii2lm6kg2g 20 днів тому

      Nope.. the US will not fight.
      Afterall, the US spent $2 trillion over 20 years, and they couldn't even defeat the Afghan cavemen.
      They lost, the Taliban won..

    • @hukebein92
      @hukebein92 19 днів тому

      ​@@MichaelHampton-fn5rl nope it began when NATO had that idea of shift the Ukraine government into a proxy western government and start the killing of many innocent people in Donbas , this when it started, don't forget

  • @khanh604
    @khanh604 22 дні тому +17

    Let F around and find out

  • @johngalvin8593
    @johngalvin8593 20 днів тому +1

    What's your cruising speed and economy Mic ?

  • @johnkings7044
    @johnkings7044 22 дні тому +254

    Very soon he will be saying Taiwan is winning 🤣🤣

    • @farsiga2899
      @farsiga2899 22 дні тому

      It'll be Taiwan plus the U.S. and Japan winning for they've offered to intervene on Taiwan's behalf.

    • @peterpanini96
      @peterpanini96 22 дні тому

      Yeah sky news only repeating lies all the time and ukraine and taiwan is peacefull retreating and protesting against their governments who wants to go to war with China because they believe they can win... what a bunch of udiots.

    • @douglasnakamura6753
      @douglasnakamura6753 22 дні тому +35

      Taiwan would win.

    • @haixinzheng9759
      @haixinzheng9759 22 дні тому +15

      ​@@AGLTONY Or Taiwanese soldiers fighting with Keyboard?

    • @severusrogue259
      @severusrogue259 22 дні тому +19

      Taiwan would resist quite well with full western support mate

  • @briant5685
    @briant5685 22 дні тому +7

    some neurons about to be taken out of our brains by the resident ''analyst''

  • @incedofortis
    @incedofortis 22 дні тому +69

    Och, they ask a guy who was reporting lies abiu Russia Ukraine war from the start.

    • @adriansheldon7778
      @adriansheldon7778 22 дні тому +9

      How many super duper invincble s400 air defence 😂😂😂 systems have been lost in the last 2 weeks ,and what about the black sea fleet being beaten and running away by a country with no navy 😂😂😂😂 oh the shame of it 😂😂😂😂😂.

    • @michaelp4122
      @michaelp4122 20 днів тому +5

      What lies? Russia is losing hundreds of thousands of people for small towns, and Ukraine had trouble defending themselves without western aid.
      Now they have missiles, so let's see what happens.

    • @secretagentcat
      @secretagentcat 16 днів тому

      lmao people who defend russia have bottomless pit heads

  • @INFINITY-oe4is
    @INFINITY-oe4is 19 днів тому +2

    The negatives outweigh the positives in this situation!

  • @carlodivinagracia7432
    @carlodivinagracia7432 22 дні тому

    The Southern PLA drill area is just a few miles from the Mavulis island of Batanes.

  • @sbeast64
    @sbeast64 22 дні тому +35

    Would be funny if all this time everyone is thinking they're going to invade Taiwan, then they invade some random country like Jamaica.

    • @JonnaJonesOG
      @JonnaJonesOG 21 день тому +2

      And are never seen again 🤣

    • @ManPursueExcellence
      @ManPursueExcellence 21 день тому +1

      Art of War 🤣

    • @Ghandi12
      @Ghandi12 21 день тому

      The only country(s) that invade or do coups are usa knesset, and engeland

    • @silvussol8966
      @silvussol8966 21 день тому

      I mean, they have been kind of invading Africa. They have snatched up a lot of mineral rights and own several very large properties in multiple African countries, and likely have some secret bases there.

    • @geofflepper3207
      @geofflepper3207 21 день тому

      Actually no. Not funny at all.
      Last summer China put out a map claiming territory in seven other countries angering all those countries and there are other countries with territory that China seems to have designs on.
      Why the heck does China want to take territory from so many countries or any countries for that matter?
      China is big enough and is facing demographic collapse - it doesn't need any more territory.

  • @jamesj97370
    @jamesj97370 20 днів тому +9

    Imagine having Russia as your primary Ally 💀

    • @danhunt4224
      @danhunt4224 18 днів тому

      That's like saying what if your 5ft 4 250lb 14 yr old nephew with carpal tunnel from gaming and makes videos of himself playing with lightsabres as your primary ally

    • @warweasel2832
      @warweasel2832 16 днів тому

      And now we're seeing a sequel to the Sino-Soviet Split. Xi is horrified by the meatgrinder that is Ukraine. He recognizes how the failure of the 3 day plan has given time to all the European neutral states to reconsider their position. Russia is now just a market to him, not a legitimate ally.

  • @kalbreak
    @kalbreak 20 днів тому

    Is it 30 years of UK oil production or consumption?

  • @springbloom5940
    @springbloom5940 22 дні тому +2

    Well... if the US State Dept has anything to say about it, anyway 🙄

    • @user-ii2lm6kg2g
      @user-ii2lm6kg2g 20 днів тому

      Nope.. the US will not fight.
      Afterall, the US spent $2 trillion over 20 years, and they couldn't even defeat the Afghan cavemen.
      The US lost, the Taliban won..

  • @WeReignWithHim
    @WeReignWithHim 21 день тому +16

    They’ll wait until America can’t react because its own troubles.

    • @russellowen6302
      @russellowen6302 19 днів тому

      America has no right to be active in Asia. Go home and sort out your own collapsing economy, homelessness and dire poverty. Stop scape- goating others and recognise that your economic system has failed.

    • @lemuhuru
      @lemuhuru 16 днів тому

      It's none of Americas business. Focus on your domestic issues and waiting on Jesus.

  • @vitorlopes2064
    @vitorlopes2064 22 дні тому +43

    ” being Friends of the US is fatal”

    • @LawrenceReitan
      @LawrenceReitan 22 дні тому

      Democracy mate, being friend of US means progress and freedom. Tell me what china can give? NOTHING

    • @James-kv6kb
      @James-kv6kb 22 дні тому +3

      Being an ally like Australia is not much better lol

    • @lanzdy9215
      @lanzdy9215 19 днів тому +1

      That was quoted by the one who betrayed Taiwan(ROC), when US recognized Communist China (PRC) as the legitimate government of China. This is why the US has a responsibility to Taiwan. Although they did that they also promised Taiwan support against forced invasion.

    • @vitorlopes2064
      @vitorlopes2064 19 днів тому

      @@lanzdy9215 US should mind its own business. 34 trillions in debt

    • @AnotherPlace
      @AnotherPlace 17 днів тому

      Wumao spotted... Lol

  • @slytherben
    @slytherben 18 днів тому

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but the water is too choppy to invade over sea except in April & October.

  • @magnuslundin682
    @magnuslundin682 18 днів тому

    Finally someone mentions the importance of submarine bases.

  • @trudylynch6750
    @trudylynch6750 22 дні тому +100

    SKY NEWS = Stop Kidding Yourself Not Everyone Was Stupid

  • @User356-gp9uv
    @User356-gp9uv 22 дні тому +29

    Very soon he will say China has no Balls

  • @user-cf3cr8ki7e
    @user-cf3cr8ki7e 22 дні тому +1

    I don't think so

    • @just4visit
      @just4visit 22 дні тому

      better tell us what ukronazis are doing the parliament???

  • @mike_oe
    @mike_oe 17 днів тому +1

    Best way to prevent this from happening is by whole heartedly helping Ukraine to kick out Ruzzia. How hard can it be?

    • @EYDuff
      @EYDuff 17 днів тому

      Exactly

  • @ntokozolugogo4762
    @ntokozolugogo4762 22 дні тому +163

    Sky news known for propaganda

    • @informedchoice2249
      @informedchoice2249 22 дні тому +3

      ?

    • @Im-mono
      @Im-mono 22 дні тому +8

      @@informedchoice2249Best US warmachine complex advertising contractor award winner.

    • @user-ce6el8tt6e
      @user-ce6el8tt6e 22 дні тому +7

      Western Media is the World Rumor Factory, and his name is Western Media Rumor Manufacturing Co., Ltd., which releases new rumor products from time to time

    • @shubham943
      @shubham943 22 дні тому +2

      Then what is BBC, Al Jazeera, TRT news?

    • @kingswordsc
      @kingswordsc 22 дні тому

      It's just a propaganda machine that deceives ordinary people

  • @saviola5194
    @saviola5194 20 днів тому +3

    I thought Taiwan was apart of china?

    • @christianmarriott3696
      @christianmarriott3696 20 днів тому +1

      Not for over 100 years, which was before the creation of the country that we call China today. Taiwan was once a part of the Qing Dynasty and then Imperial Japan before being taken over by the ROC who still controls it today.

  • @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh
    @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh 22 дні тому

    Yes

  • @SkippyTheRedKangaroo
    @SkippyTheRedKangaroo 21 день тому +1

    In Taiwan the most important school subject is Drone Utilization and Effectiveness.

  • @sallyintucson
    @sallyintucson 22 дні тому +5

    It’s not could, it’s when. The US is well aware of this.

    • @luke9669-0
      @luke9669-0 22 дні тому

      America has never won a war.

    • @user-ii2lm6kg2g
      @user-ii2lm6kg2g 20 днів тому

      Nope.. the US will not fight.
      Afterall, the US spent $2 trillion over 20 years, and they couldn't even defeat the Afghan cavemen.
      They lost, the Taliban won..

  • @GVila2
    @GVila2 22 дні тому +26

    I don't think that " China is running out missiles " will fly this time

  • @chrisgoold9816
    @chrisgoold9816 16 днів тому

    Imagine the amount of drones Tawain has

  • @Bradgilliswhammyman
    @Bradgilliswhammyman 22 дні тому +2

    Sean Bell, simply one of the best military analysts in the business.

  • @stephen.v5122
    @stephen.v5122 22 дні тому +27

    The headline doesn’t make bloody sense !

    • @denu1879
      @denu1879 21 день тому

      "More likely when rather than if" who wrote this and what are they smoking 😂

  • @bowlampar
    @bowlampar 20 днів тому +3

    'When' should be the question, not 'why',' if', 'because' or 'who' .

  • @ishiibughao9300
    @ishiibughao9300 21 день тому +1

    Analysts here and there but no one knew what China's really thinking. These analysts are always playing safe in their comments.

    • @jonathanbowen3640
      @jonathanbowen3640 19 днів тому

      China has said they will take back Taiwan by any means necessary.

  • @American_Traditionalist1527
    @American_Traditionalist1527 21 день тому

    Ohh Boy here we go........

  • @MrManny075
    @MrManny075 21 день тому +37

    As Taiwan is recognized by the world as part of China the Chinese could move into Taiwan and take over without an invasion

    • @user-rb1mc6dk3v
      @user-rb1mc6dk3v 21 день тому +2

      Yes if agreed by the Taiwanese people.

    • @christianmarriott3696
      @christianmarriott3696 20 днів тому +5

      Actually hardly anyone believes the Chinese governments rhetoric, most people quite happily accept Taiwan as an independent nation in my experience. Wether it actually is or not should be a descision made by the people of Taiwan without any external interference from the USA or PRC.

    • @michaelp4122
      @michaelp4122 20 днів тому +7

      No one recognizes Taiwan as a part of China LOL. It may as well be a part of Japan with that logic.

    • @jianfengwu7502
      @jianfengwu7502 20 днів тому

      @@christianmarriott3696你叫台湾人把中国文物还给中国

    • @jianfengwu7502
      @jianfengwu7502 20 днів тому

      @@michaelp4122琉球群岛不是日本得

  • @Blankarte
    @Blankarte 21 день тому +31

    Taiwan's new president = Zelenzky V 2.0

  • @erikvynckier4819
    @erikvynckier4819 21 день тому +1

    Go for it!

  • @danmoreman954
    @danmoreman954 15 днів тому

    Why does the analyst not consider transport, logistics and terrain? His lack of consideration of these factors renders his analysis useless.
    First, China does not have enough troop transport ships. Their sea lift capacity is 50k of troops. With the Taiwanese reserves mobilized they will have more than a half million troops in the field defending a terrain that is described as Afghanistan with tree cover. Standard military doctrine says the attacker will need a 3 to 1 advantage but given the terrain that number would likely be higher. So please tell me how China is going to transfer 1.5 to 2.5 million PLA soldiers across 100 miles of treacherous, highly contested ocean when their sea lift capacity is 50k.
    And even if we suspend disbelief and imagine that 2 million Chinese soldiers magically teleport to the island of Taiwan, how are they going to resupply them? PLA logistics break down once the troops move beyond a railhead and there are no trains running from mainland China to Taiwan.
    The fact that the analyst did not consider these things tells me he is not a serious person. Therefore, this video is a complete waste of time.

  • @nycentre
    @nycentre 21 день тому +5

    Invade is the wrong word.
    In civil war, it's called capture.

    • @EYDuff
      @EYDuff 17 днів тому

      It would be invade

    • @wunengqiu2110
      @wunengqiu2110 8 днів тому

      Peacefully reunification of Taiwan province

  • @AgentSmith911
    @AgentSmith911 22 дні тому +29

    This guy doesn't know what he's talking about

    • @JonnaJonesOG
      @JonnaJonesOG 21 день тому +1

      He does. Honest. Rishi and Starmer said so. It must be true 🤔

    • @fallout76nz24
      @fallout76nz24 21 день тому +2

      Thats the whole western media.

    • @dessmith7658
      @dessmith7658 21 день тому +1

      Change happens the world order is changing

    • @fritzraake22
      @fritzraake22 20 днів тому +1

      Oh yeah but Krembots do 🤣

  • @kwakuagyapong2677
    @kwakuagyapong2677 19 днів тому

    this man never got it right

  • @power3545
    @power3545 22 дні тому

    The answer is NOOOO

  • @flesz_
    @flesz_ 22 дні тому +45

    Sky news expert joker , love it

  • @MrNexusboogie
    @MrNexusboogie 22 дні тому +62

    And where are the yanks bases??

    • @alanmorgan7212
      @alanmorgan7212 22 дні тому +22

      All around

    • @mickmacgonigle5021
      @mickmacgonigle5021 22 дні тому +22

      Everywhere

    • @brucelee4357
      @brucelee4357 22 дні тому

      American imperialism is surrounding Asia

    • @IusedtohaveausernameIliked
      @IusedtohaveausernameIliked 22 дні тому +13

      They are situated all over planet Earth, and they have some pretty good mobile ones too.

    • @James-kv6kb
      @James-kv6kb 22 дні тому +9

      It's called pine gap in Australia not even Australians are allowed to go there only the yanks.

  • @tomcook3860
    @tomcook3860 16 днів тому

    China running a military drill on its own trade route. Heaven forbid we in the Uk do a drill in the English channel.

  • @GHOSTDIVISION39
    @GHOSTDIVISION39 22 дні тому

    Can we just get this conflict sorted already

  • @kevanhubbard9673
    @kevanhubbard9673 22 дні тому +28

    No industrially developed islands are very hard to invade and even ones close to the mainland like Great Britain have been virtually impossible to invade once they had developed strong military forces.When they are still rural they aren't so difficult to invade as the Romans and Normans prove.Island groups like Taiwan and Japan are much further out at sea too .

    • @AB-fi5jt
      @AB-fi5jt 22 дні тому +3

      Not only Taiwan is a small but also nowhere near an industrially developed island, your logic doesn’t apply here.

    • @louislux
      @louislux 21 день тому +14

      @@AB-fi5jt Not industrially developed? Mate, it makes the majority of the world's most advanced chips.

    • @russellowen6302
      @russellowen6302 21 день тому +9

      Taiwan has been invaded. Once by Japan and then by the USA. It is not a membrr of the UN because it is not a sovereign nation. It is part of China. It is called Formosa.

    • @geofflepper3207
      @geofflepper3207 21 день тому

      ​@@russellowen6302
      Obviously Taiwan is a sovereign nation.
      Who runs Taiwan? The people of Taiwan.
      Communist China leaders can spout all the nonsense they want but Taiwan is still a sovereign independent nation.

    • @PepeCoinMania
      @PepeCoinMania 21 день тому

      Sure buddy 😂

  • @elifitness1911
    @elifitness1911 21 день тому +23

    This “Military Expert” is as knowledgeable as Bettle juice

    • @WinterRapids
      @WinterRapids 21 день тому +6

      ...here comes the Russian propaganda trolls.

    • @user-ii2lm6kg2g
      @user-ii2lm6kg2g 20 днів тому +1

      I disagree.. Beetle Juice has more brain..

  • @user-re3nl6oy9r
    @user-re3nl6oy9r 18 днів тому

    Isn’t this the guy that was saying Russia was losing the war and now they’ve got him talking about the Chinese. C’mon Sky!

  • @freedomfirst5557
    @freedomfirst5557 19 днів тому +2

    The world reminds me of the conditions in the 1920s and 1930’s

  • @jimbojimbo6873
    @jimbojimbo6873 22 дні тому +4

    Well they should hurry up if they are gonna do it

    • @Gav_80085
      @Gav_80085 22 дні тому

      Why? Why not wait like 5 years when China will have a bigger, more modern navy than the US? And there could be an "America First" President who will let it slide. They are not in a rush.

  • @fresh6993
    @fresh6993 22 дні тому +17

    Taiwan should learn from Ukraine. Gamechangers won't change anything.

    • @robertarevalo-ii3ny
      @robertarevalo-ii3ny 22 дні тому +3

      How it will happen if japan and usa is with taiwa?n

    • @fresh6993
      @fresh6993 21 день тому +1

      @@robertarevalo-ii3ny How did Ukraine lose territory when the entire NATO was with them..still losing btw

    • @christianmarriott3696
      @christianmarriott3696 20 днів тому

      It's a very different scenario, but it's pretty obvious that wether or not a Chinese invasion of Taiwan succeeds the cost to them would be enormous, it's just not worth it for China to take this action and I don't think Xi is that stupid really.

    • @j-rm3uh
      @j-rm3uh 20 днів тому

      Russia invaded ukraine...... ukraine did not go to war with Russia, NATO are indirectly involved in ukraine, they don't have troops on the ground or jets in the sky, if they got involved physically they will push into Moscow

    • @jonathanbowen3640
      @jonathanbowen3640 19 днів тому +1

      @@fresh6993 The entire NATO isn't with Ukraine though, It;s just sending a few billion $ and mostly some old weapons stocks. And a bit of training. NATO could kick Russia out of Ukraine in a few months if it decided to.

  • @Kylepersonal
    @Kylepersonal 19 днів тому +1

    I can't wait! Another reason for all companies to raise the prices of everything again!

  • @vatoloco6536
    @vatoloco6536 20 днів тому +14

    Soon he will be saying chinese soldiers are fighting with dull shovels😂

  • @MrCostas32
    @MrCostas32 22 дні тому +40

    This guy is funny!! 🤣 "The world will stop buying Chinese products" 🤣🤣🤣 I doubt that VERY much....

    • @JonnaJonesOG
      @JonnaJonesOG 21 день тому +1

      The world certainly wouldn't work through technology that's for sure lol

    • @ydy2001001
      @ydy2001001 21 день тому +7

      His world, Western Europe, the United States, Canada, Australia

    • @geofflepper3207
      @geofflepper3207 21 день тому +6

      ​​@@ydy2001001
      China put out a map last summer claiming territory in Russia, India, Malaysia, the Philippines and three other countries angering all those seven countries.
      On top of that China has serious territorial disagreements with Japan and Indonesia and China's last major war was an invasion into Vietnam.
      None of these countries likes the idea of an Imperialist China invading their country and taking land so they will not be happy to see China acting in an Imperialist way.
      And India has major political conflicts with China including anger over a Chinese dam that is going to block a lot of water from flowing into northeast India.
      Plus China is very friendly and close to Pakistan with which India has had major political conflicts bordering on war ever since the 1940s.
      Don't have the delusion that all non-Western countries love China.
      G7 countries alone have close to half the GDP of the world.
      That alone is a lot of business for China to throw away on a stupid, unnecessary invasion.

    • @ydy2001001
      @ydy2001001 21 день тому +1

      @@geofflepper3207 There is no territorial dispute between China and Russia. China sees India as a clown. Look at the Sino-Indian War. The outbreak of the Chinese-Indian War in 1962
      Cuban missile crisis on October 16, 1962
      The Chinese-Indian War began on October 20, 1962. The Cuban missile crisis ended on October 29. The U.S. Navy embargoed Cuba until November 20, 1962。On November 21, 1962, the Chinese government declared a unilateral ceasefire.

    • @tommygun5038
      @tommygun5038 20 днів тому

      The world that matters won't be buying and anyone else will suffer the consequences.

  • @stevesmith1923
    @stevesmith1923 18 днів тому

    This guy is so smart.

  • @goldeagle8051
    @goldeagle8051 19 днів тому

    2006: we are approaching peak oil production, what are we going to do?
    2024: news about every regional tension includes the words: 'there are massive oil/gas reserves in the region'.

  • @ernst91
    @ernst91 20 днів тому +3

    Taiwan has to defend itself. Along with Europe.

  • @Shadowless_Kick
    @Shadowless_Kick 22 дні тому +57

    Taiwan’s official name is still Republic of China. ROC ruled whole China before it lost the civil war and retreated to Taiwan in 1949, ROC vowed to take the mainland of China back until 1980s and its constitution still claims the mainland as its territory. Yes, more people in the island are willing to give up the mainland and become a separate country but the 1.4 billion mainland Chinese people will never allow their motherland to be divided, regardless what their system is.

    • @vanessali1365
      @vanessali1365 22 дні тому +11

      Wrong, the system matters a great deal bc Taiwan people don't want to be ruled by communist CCP. Fact is Taiwan has been separated from mainland China since 1949... not independent country but separate government. Also, CCP never occupied Taiwan (not even 1min) in its entire CCP history from 1921when CCP was created by Mao.

    • @shardovl586
      @shardovl586 22 дні тому +6

      China could have unified peacefully, but dictators lack the correct attributes for such a process to occur.

    • @DigitallyNomad3949
      @DigitallyNomad3949 22 дні тому

      Sorry but Taiwanese people don't give a F what 1.4 billion commies objection and Taiwanese people are to be Taiwanese not Chinese commie.

    • @Shadowless_Kick
      @Shadowless_Kick 22 дні тому +5

      @@vanessali1365 If China had an election system instead the current CCP led system, China would have already reunified the country at any cost. Since the First Emperor established the first united Chinese Kingdom 2200 years ago, all Chinese dynasties had the unification of the country as their highest goal.

    • @normjohnson4629
      @normjohnson4629 22 дні тому +9

      ROC has tasted freedom and they will never give it up. They day that PRC is free, is the only day that peaceful reunification can happen.

  • @antelopegrenade
    @antelopegrenade 19 днів тому

    I just hope there will not be another war. Why do we have to be so territorial? Both people in both countries deserve to live in a peaceful and free environment. These talks about wars break my heart. I think I have to stay away from the internet for the moment. 😢

  • @conorwd9466
    @conorwd9466 22 дні тому +16

    Didn’t realise Rishi Sunak was this desperate

    • @luke9669-0
      @luke9669-0 22 дні тому +2

      If we are at war no general election and the penny drops 😂

    • @SB-dg8hq
      @SB-dg8hq 22 дні тому +1

      Rishi Sunak, our appointed great leader 😂😂😂😂

    • @Gav_80085
      @Gav_80085 22 дні тому

      It'd be the US election making them think about it. They couldn't care less what the UK does.

  • @nengdajin7593
    @nengdajin7593 22 дні тому +4

    Put in this way - Taiwan will unify with mainland when US hegemony is over. Then why go after Taiwan at all? The island is always there.

    • @andrewplater1782
      @andrewplater1782 15 днів тому

      Taiwan will be able to buy China once Xi has finished with his wrecking ball.

  • @TheSiyasss
    @TheSiyasss 20 днів тому +1

    What happened to the one China policy?

  • @HuanLeVuong
    @HuanLeVuong 20 днів тому

    Alright, so when?

  • @gangadharandharan2769
    @gangadharandharan2769 22 дні тому +24

    Tell this guy to keep quiet

  • @michaeljiang960
    @michaeljiang960 22 дні тому +4

    When will UK recognize Taiwan as a country?

    • @actionong
      @actionong 21 день тому

      Taiwan or Republic of China?

    • @user-ii2lm6kg2g
      @user-ii2lm6kg2g 20 днів тому

      Will never happen.
      The world will recognize Scotland as a country instead.

  • @EllyLowSwiHoon
    @EllyLowSwiHoon 19 днів тому

    dun't they supposed to ask this question instead " why is taiwan so important to american?" Almost all news group/media in american or europe is so so particular interested in this.

  • @longandshort6639
    @longandshort6639 20 днів тому

    I hope that companies are pivoting away from putting their entire business supply chains in China, HK or Taiwan. This could all get very very nasty quickly.

  • @adamx1748
    @adamx1748 21 день тому +11

    Sean Bellend, calls a 5yr girl a young lady

  • @zhaoraymond8656
    @zhaoraymond8656 22 дні тому +7

    There is no country called Taiwan, only ROC and people's ROC. Both sides are still in civil war. Just like the Southern government and the Northern government in the American Civil War.

    • @fatdoi003
      @fatdoi003 22 дні тому +1

      it's exactly same with east and west germany.... 1 country, different political systems

    • @rogerramjet9505
      @rogerramjet9505 21 день тому +1

      There is a country called Taiwan

    • @seawater1322
      @seawater1322 19 днів тому

      @@rogerramjet9505 wrong couch potato.

    • @x-hale2899
      @x-hale2899 18 днів тому

      China never interfered in the American Civil War. So it's best the US stays the hell away from China and its territory. Taiwan is and has been China since the Qing dynasty and we will not take that away from China.

  • @freedomfirst5557
    @freedomfirst5557 19 днів тому

    I think the American people would stop buying their crap. I always check to see if I’m not buying their stuff anyway

  • @RosenpaulSagape-vp8px
    @RosenpaulSagape-vp8px 22 дні тому +1

    This is a very dangerous more to my country

  • @alphillips5478
    @alphillips5478 22 дні тому +17

    Could they invade taiwan??
    Ofcourse they could
    What a dumb title

    • @willbrink
      @willbrink 20 днів тому +1

      But will they? Very unlikely.

    • @pauliewalnuts6734
      @pauliewalnuts6734 20 днів тому +1

      @@willbrink biding their time, what smart people do

    • @tommygun5038
      @tommygun5038 20 днів тому

      It means are they going to do it soon.

    • @TheCbins
      @TheCbins 19 днів тому

      How can a country invade its own country? Try reading something- UN charter, the three communiques, anything outside mainstream warmongering.

    • @gingmo1
      @gingmo1 18 днів тому

      @@pauliewalnuts6734 70 years?

  • @paulmorgan6269
    @paulmorgan6269 22 дні тому +6

    Who chose her trousers ?

    • @user-vx6nw1db9o
      @user-vx6nw1db9o 21 день тому

      😂😂😂

    • @JonnaJonesOG
      @JonnaJonesOG 21 день тому +1

      Saville left them in his will to the BBC behind closed doors 🤫 😂 😆

  • @kishanchali8752
    @kishanchali8752 20 днів тому

    If this guy says Taiwan is going to win, the opposite will happen Definitely.

  • @mikethebreeze
    @mikethebreeze 20 днів тому

    Obviously important to China the question should be why is it important to the USA? It's like saying usa is going to invade Hawaii except Hawaii is 2400 miles from the USA and Taiwan is 100 miles from China

  • @deano_bites
    @deano_bites 22 дні тому +3

    Won't be fun when everyone is called up to serve will it the washing machines will all run out

  • @michaelkoh2280
    @michaelkoh2280 12 днів тому

    The military analyst missed the most important point of why Taiwan is most important for China. The answer is that it BELONGS to China. No more no less. So the military analyst only has a Western lens that misunderstands China's motive as geopolitics.

  • @michaellovell3145
    @michaellovell3145 20 днів тому

    A very interesting perspective on China’s need of deepwater access for its submarines

  • @gj8550
    @gj8550 22 дні тому +8

    2:45 ‘Taiwan normally plays the long game’. If they invade Taiwan, they would have to deal with a bunch of disgruntled citizens that would cost endless grieve for years to come. That’s why China has always prefer a peaceful unification. In the recent election, the opposition party that favours China has won majority seats. Already it is trying to push through legislations that limit the power of the president. This may be the thin edge that China is looking for.

  • @J3LL05H0T
    @J3LL05H0T 22 дні тому +21

    West Taiwan needs to chill out

  • @meetteel6811
    @meetteel6811 22 дні тому +1

    It‘s highly unlikely that china isn‘t at least going to try, or to even set an example on them.
    At the time china is pretty much on course to achieve its goals.

  • @mortenmadsen3661
    @mortenmadsen3661 19 днів тому

    If Taiwan is so important to China why do they then not try to be more friendly to them instead of pushing them away?

  • @user-wm7ln1pd7l
    @user-wm7ln1pd7l 22 дні тому +5

    above all it is the South China Sea the name says it all.

  • @petertheboomscott2104
    @petertheboomscott2104 22 дні тому +17

    First this reporter says ‘ what does china’s drills around Taiwan tell us’.
    He she having a laugh.
    It means Taiwan is in trouble.

    • @Shadowless_Kick
      @Shadowless_Kick 22 дні тому +6

      She started with the question “Why is Taiwan so important to China?”, which is equivalent to ask “Why is Hawaii so important to America” and “Why is Falkland Islands so important to UK?” 😅

    • @farsiga2899
      @farsiga2899 22 дні тому

      Taiwan is not in trouble not if the U.S. and Japan can help it.

    • @farsiga2899
      @farsiga2899 22 дні тому +1

      ​@@Shadowless_KickIt is a matter of principle.

    • @jeffhsu7027
      @jeffhsu7027 20 днів тому

      @@Shadowless_Kickexcept, Taiwan has nothing to do with CCP.

    • @Shadowless_Kick
      @Shadowless_Kick 20 днів тому

      @@jeffhsu7027 Regardless if the mainland is ruled by the CCP or not, Taiwan is a part of Ch1na, the reunification is 100x more justified than the UK taking Falkland Islands

  • @ricardosantos4900
    @ricardosantos4900 19 днів тому

    Oh yes. With drones and robot dogs. Never seen before!

  • @ianbray6246
    @ianbray6246 16 днів тому

    Why is Ukraine So important to America?

  • @MrNaKillshots
    @MrNaKillshots 22 дні тому +5

    Funny, that the west won't get involved in this one.

    • @jxmai7687
      @jxmai7687 22 дні тому

      Because they all know Taiwan is part of China as a UN member.

  • @michaelelliott556
    @michaelelliott556 22 дні тому +7

    Britain shouldn't be anywhere near this conflict if it happens

    • @Gav_80085
      @Gav_80085 22 дні тому

      Ok we'll just accept a complete loss of microchip and the affect that will have on our economy and daily lives. Coward.

    • @Eideric
      @Eideric 21 день тому +6

      Already is. A third of the world's trade goes through there and Taiwan produces 90% of the world's semi-conductors. As a G7 country, the UK has a huge economic interest.

    • @KanuniSuleyman4857
      @KanuniSuleyman4857 21 день тому

      ​​​@@Eideric UK has lost all it's old prestige and glory of being the world superpower. Now it should not involve itself in destructive conflicts around the world like ukraine, palestine or taiwan otherwise it will result in utter destruction of their lands

    • @louisea7245
      @louisea7245 21 день тому

      Uk will be part of it cos they will always stick with the power of the USA.

    • @HollandN54
      @HollandN54 20 днів тому +1

      Wrong, we already have a military presence on the island and have committed to defend Taiwan against any Chinese invasion. China won’t risk it

  • @Dethrey_
    @Dethrey_ 22 дні тому +2

    The PRC is using their PLA to test out how to invade taiwan, right now they have 40x PLA naval vessels surrounding Taiwan, they aka the Chinese gov and their military is testing Taiwans defense response and gathering intel.

    • @Stephen-bq4nq
      @Stephen-bq4nq 19 днів тому

      They can test all they want they're going to be sitting ducks for anti ship missiles when they try to cross the Taiwan strait.

  • @kawardt6784
    @kawardt6784 16 днів тому

    Ray 😢

  • @nenadmilosevic5162
    @nenadmilosevic5162 22 дні тому +10

    there is only one thing i want to know...how will Americans know the difference between Chinese and Taiwanese if war brake out 😂😂

    • @brucelee4357
      @brucelee4357 22 дні тому +5

      They don’t that’s the funny part lol

    • @farsiga2899
      @farsiga2899 22 дні тому +2

      Their flags. China and Taiwan have different flags.

    • @fatdoi003
      @fatdoi003 22 дні тому +1

      @@farsiga2899 lol.... no one hoist their standard on battlefield anymore

  • @zw1840
    @zw1840 22 дні тому +9

    Taiwan issue is not about South China Sea nor submarine at all, the "expert" should've learnt more history

    • @Eideric
      @Eideric 21 день тому +4

      Well, strategically, it very much is. Otherwise, China would be boring the world senseless with inevitable historical trend of re-unification of the motherland, and avenging the century of humiliation, with respect to the ~900, 000 sq. km. of outer Manchuria/Amur annexations of 1858 and 1860 by Russia, every time he meets Putin. How many times bigger than Taiwan was that territory again? 25, 26 times? And a hell of a lot easier to invade than crossing the ~180km Taiwan Strait, too.

    •  20 днів тому

      Technically, it is. Coz South China Sea issue is from the republic of china. The sad thing is, Taiwan now is too shamed to fight for their own land.

    • @user-wn1oq6xg5h
      @user-wn1oq6xg5h 20 днів тому

      你们两个都是中国人,还说英语。真搞笑。

    •  20 днів тому

      @@user-wn1oq6xg5h 应该没你搞笑;) 看您多急 。嘻嘻

    • @user-wn1oq6xg5h
      @user-wn1oq6xg5h 20 днів тому

      我急什么?看到俄罗斯的下场,你党爹吓得尿裤子了,根本不敢入侵台湾。

  • @jamescherriman1633
    @jamescherriman1633 21 день тому

    What on earth does the expert think he is on about, sounds like he's talking about the US,