15& has always been giving me a Davichi vibe, fr. Like Yerin is obviously the better belter/mixer (like Haeri), but Jamie is the all-rounder (competent lows and belting, and great headvoice) just like Minkyung. Overall, a powerful vocal duo. Also, props to Yerin’s agility!
I'll put the remarks here so everyone won't get confused xD - The ranking is listed in descending order. The particular Tiers are as follow: 1. Dia 2. Uji, Yerin, Wendy 3. Jamie, Solar 4. Wheein, Yuju 5. Seunghee, Haena - Minimum 7 perfs for each vocalist - The list took in consideration their career "average skill set" rather than just their peak or current level. - Ones with more balanced mix are rated slightly higher than pure chest dominant mixer (supposedly on par with each other in terms of support and resonance). - The notes shown are either supported or resonant.
Dia is stronger than Wendy? Dia support range is A3-D5/Eb5 right? I though you said that a vocalist should be able to support G3 or lower to be considered competent? Is it because she has Eb5?
@Hexa Wira No I said it specifically for Yechan’s case because she doesn’t necessarily has any other asset aside from her mix. Meanwhile Dia has a head voice that’s resonant up to Bb5.
@@ReggieVu oh yeah, i kinda forgot that she has a supported head voice. Anyway, what do you think about rosé gone performance at sea of hope? I feel like her voice become weaker and thinner, i kinda worried
I don’t exactly remember names of those songs but she sounded fine to me, supported up to Bb4 with a slightly stronger tone production albeit an underwhelming low. Even some of her B4s were not bad.
Yes Dia i love her, that B4 always has me shocked!!! Uji just has this power in her voice i haven’t heard in kpop, her D5’s always sound so clear and always have sooo much honey crisp to them
@@ReggieVu ikrrr!! They would have 4 vocalists out of the 6 who could all support! And they would have 2 above average vocalists and 2 average!!! Like the power that would be!!!
For everyone wondering this is probably not in order or anything, just a compilation of different female vocalists who are great at belting and that are active atm!!
"KPOP idols that opens their mouth as big as they can"(please make a video about this one). I always hear Tara from Tara Simons studios saying that you should own your mouth as big as you can. I do have a question, is Wheein the better belter between her and Solar? I heard from Sam Bradley that Solar is the better belter
Sorry I just saw your comment TT Well generally having a big aperture (including a dropped jaw and lifted soft palate, relaxed tongue,..) would contribute in eliminating nasality, tension and creating space for forward projection. Yeah Solar is a better belter, both in terms of support and resonance consistency.
It’s good to allow the jaw to drop as far as it naturally can, but forcing it open farther than that can create jaw tension and cause problems with focusing resonance in certain registers.
Has Wendy always been a better belter than Solar and Yuju or is it because her recent consistency in resonance around Bb4~C5? I know Wendy always supports higher but I always think her lack of resonance as a major drawback(?)
Hey!!! I wanna ask another question...it's mostly about my vocals and I want to make the comment section 69 *Is it a better move if I train my head voice? I can go up to E5 without hurting my voice *How do I know if k actually Support? *What is vocal fatigue? Sometimes...after I belt or just sing my throat hurts...and sometimes I feel like getting dizzy and my eyesight becomes blurry after singing
1. It depends on what type of singing you're aiming at. Like operatic requires more head voice and contemporary singing requires more chest and mix etc,.. But developing breath support is the most essential aspect. 2. I think it's best to show you're singing to someone who knows about suppport and stuffs. 3. It generally means your voice being tired (due to oversing, dehydration, vocal strains,..)
it's still makes me sad that yuju doesn't support C5 consistent anymore like back in her debut days edit: her voice now sounds alot better than her 2018-2020 era
I'd say she has shown some vocal habits that are affecting her skillset. I'm not entirely sure if it's a stylistic choice but since she made the switch in performing style, she's has become more nasal, straining on notes that she used to slay and head voice seems to weaken too. From resonating C#5 super consistently to straining B4 here and there. The difference is quite significant.
@@drew-df5vg I haven't heard particular regression signs on her Low, but her head voice got worsen, to say the least. I'll copy a brieft performance analysis from my friends: "ua-cam.com/video/EYZ3OT47WNc/v-deo.html Monster by Red Velvet - Jamie cover 0:25, 0:29 supported A3 0:45 nasal A4 (oh no no no) 0:45, 0:53 pushed B4 1:36 pushed B4 with slight tension, 2:26 B4 supported but could have been better D5 -E5- G5 right after was very strained. So her mix is still oke up to B4 but she was a little too pushy. 2:29 E5 - G5 unsupported, weakly connected head voice with slight airiness. ua-cam.com/video/rhmGtFOKjsk/v-deo.html Compare it with these nicely supported E5 - G5 and the difference is VERY apparent."
@@drew-df5vg okay now I’ve listened to her Young Hae live this year, it seems that she could still maintain a fine head voice placement with support. So perhaps it is only her mix that has taken a considerable dip in support quality.
yeh this list I like a resume of average mix wise for each. Her resonance before was better than Wheein and Solar? Probably around A4 - C5 but she has always had isuses with consistency even in her peak. Solar's a pusher but her resonance has always been huge, like she breaths resonance everytime she sings haha.
@@ReggieVu They're kinda even in mix or Yuju is a bit better, Yuju has a healthier approach before but a bit inconsistent. Solar and the other is pretty consistent up to C#5 but a pusher and a bit chesty. Most of Yuju's C#5 before are supported and half of them are resonant. Yuju's has a bit better mix, again before, she achieved some nice moments above C#5. Yuju's resonance before probably is the best in 3rd Gen.
@@ReggieVu Her volume and resonance is no joke, ha ha. About being a pusher, do you mean she use too much chest connection in her mix? Chesty? She seems to be very consistent to sing with strong mix. Recent examples are her acapella cover of Beliver (her solarsido channel), "I miss you" in Queendom (or in Mamamoo's Killing Voice), or Where Are You know live band version, or Adrendaline (live version in her solarsido channel). In Sam Johnson's reaction to Delilah mentioned that Solar does that in a well-balanced way and hear others argue that it could be equally healthy.
No no as far as I'm aware, she' still more or less the same, supporting around G#3 ~ D5 ~ F#5 with very consistent resonant up to C#5. It's okay for every singer to sound tired every once in a while, especially with someone with hectic schedule like Taeyeon.
@@ReggieVu đúng rồi ạ, nhưng dnay chị đổi phong cách muốn experiment low note hơn, như kiểu bài solo Spit it out này nọ, với bài Aya mới cũng chọn part ko có high note ko à, huhu buồn, thèm nghe bả res
@@SapphireStorm0910 để ý đa số res gần đây cũng là trong mấy đợt đi promo solo hoặc cover, nên chắc chưa có dịp thui, Solar cũng chăm res với ổn định nhất nhì KPop :3
Any body saying rose BP golden voice in korea LOL?, shes only unique voice but bad thecniq vocal Only Shallow support sone time inconsisten , level sub vocal standar korea
![[Knowing Bros] KARA X 2PM X T-ARA X SHINee X SNSD X Highlight 💘 2nd Gen Idols Hit Song Medley](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2ICt6heBwJU/mqdefault.jpg)
Wendy the best for me.
SM vocalist never disappointed 👍🏼
Talking about 15& we can’t forget the other half of the iconic duo!!
I hope people stop sleeping on Seunghee!!
Her vocals are up there with the top literally!!
Yeppp she’s literally has always been in the top 👆🏼
She's awfully underrated
Ikr but knowing that oh my girl is vocally underhyped it doesn't really surprise me.
I think her level vocal techniques same as Hwasa
3rd gen 1.Wendy 2.Wheein 3.Solar 4.Yuju 5.Hwasa,Seunghee ?
@@นู๋รัตน์ไก่ขึ้นลาน definitely not Yuju 5th I'm afraid..
love how wendy is just hitting high notes casually on insta live
15& has always been giving me a Davichi vibe, fr. Like Yerin is obviously the better belter/mixer (like Haeri), but Jamie is the all-rounder (competent lows and belting, and great headvoice) just like Minkyung. Overall, a powerful vocal duo.
Also, props to Yerin’s agility!
i wish yerin would develop her lower register more, she can support up to D5/Eb5 but her her support only goes down to B3, but she’s a great belter
I'll put the remarks here so everyone won't get confused xD
- The ranking is listed in descending order. The particular Tiers are as follow:
1. Dia
2. Uji, Yerin, Wendy
3. Jamie, Solar
4. Wheein, Yuju
5. Seunghee, Haena
- Minimum 7 perfs for each vocalist
- The list took in consideration their career "average skill set" rather than just their peak or current level.
- Ones with more balanced mix are rated slightly higher than pure chest dominant mixer (supposedly on par with each other in terms of support and resonance).
- The notes shown are either supported or resonant.
Excusme
You are a man or girl?
Dia is stronger than Wendy? Dia support range is A3-D5/Eb5 right? I though you said that a vocalist should be able to support G3 or lower to be considered competent? Is it because she has Eb5?
@Hexa Wira
No I said it specifically for Yechan’s case because she doesn’t necessarily has any other asset aside from her mix. Meanwhile Dia has a head voice that’s resonant up to Bb5.
@@ReggieVu oh yeah, i kinda forgot that she has a supported head voice. Anyway, what do you think about rosé gone performance at sea of hope? I feel like her voice become weaker and thinner, i kinda worried
I don’t exactly remember names of those songs but she sounded fine to me, supported up to Bb4 with a slightly stronger tone production albeit an underwhelming low. Even some of her B4s were not bad.
Yes Dia i love her, that B4 always has me shocked!!!
Uji just has this power in her voice i haven’t heard in kpop, her D5’s always sound so clear and always have sooo much honey crisp to them
Imagine if UJi had debuted with EXID 😳😳😳
@@ReggieVu she should’ve stayed but then again then we mightve not gotten to hear Solji’s amazing voice become very appreciated!
@@izonexbae so trueee, but they could have been one of the best vocal line ever 😩😩
@@ReggieVu ikrrr!! They would have 4 vocalists out of the 6 who could all support! And they would have 2 above average vocalists and 2 average!!! Like the power that would be!!!
@@izonexbae I’d put UJi in the Competent tier hehe. That monstrous Low register 😤
Damn 15& girl has pipes, i’ve heard her resonate this one B4 in a chandelier cover it was a bad quality but the resonance made it better heh
Sooo unfortunate they had to split up 😩
@@ReggieVu yeye i found the video if ur interested and yes but they are doing well on their own!!
ua-cam.com/video/ktNgelbpmHk/v-deo.htmlm27s
@@izonexbae that resonance 😩😩..
Yeh it’s really nice seeing Yerin and Jamie doing well, huge fan of Yerin 🤞
OH MY GIRL SEUNGHEE🥰🥰
jung wheein, a talented artist and vocalist indeed ♡
Ahh its a shame you didnt include 2011 since I'd love to hear some of Eunji's heavenly resonance here, great video nonetheless!
Thank you sooo much xD
Well what can we say more about Eunji's resonance ~~~ it'd overpower most of the vocalist here except for maybe Dia haha.
Goosebumps throughout the whole video TT
that Eb5 from DIA is crazy
For everyone wondering this is probably not in order or anything, just a compilation of different female vocalists who are great at belting and that are active atm!!
It’s actually in tiers which I mentioned in the description haha. But the gap is not thatttt big lol.
@@ReggieVu lmaoooooo🤡
DIA's RESONANCE OMGGGGG
holy wow that resonant C♯5 from U.ji
Great video... If you make 2nd part. Please include nayul of 12DAL. She so underrated and great vocalist
Do have a link for Baek Yerin’s C5 at 3:44? Thanks
here~ ua-cam.com/video/2-Wceba-iV4/v-deo.html
"KPOP idols that opens their mouth as big as they can"(please make a video about this one). I always hear Tara from Tara Simons studios saying that you should own your mouth as big as you can.
I do have a question, is Wheein the better belter between her and Solar? I heard from Sam Bradley that Solar is the better belter
Sorry I just saw your comment TT
Well generally having a big aperture (including a dropped jaw and lifted soft palate, relaxed tongue,..) would contribute in eliminating nasality, tension and creating space for forward projection.
Yeah Solar is a better belter, both in terms of support and resonance consistency.
It’s good to allow the jaw to drop as far as it naturally can, but forcing it open farther than that can create jaw tension and cause problems with focusing resonance in certain registers.
@@ReggieVu Question: I hear from other places saying that she is more close to full lyric soprano, is that wrong?
@@linkazoo No, she is chesty light lyric. Compare her with Eunji, who is full lyric
@@harrykim5391 Thanks🤔
5:14 (go away~) note please
sorry for the late reply~ the note is F5.
@@ReggieVu oke thank you, song?
Who's better ariana or wendy?
@@whynot-sr8wn Cry by Kelly Clarkson ua-cam.com/video/FELE9YcJh6o/v-deo.html
Wendy
@@ReggieVu ok thank you, how about wendy vs demi?
@@whynot-sr8wn still Wendy~
Has Wendy always been a better belter than Solar and Yuju or is it because her recent consistency in resonance around Bb4~C5? I know Wendy always supports higher but I always think her lack of resonance as a major drawback(?)
Yes her improvements in openness plus placement on some Eb5s pushes her slightly above.
Thank you!^^
Wendy’s finally getting more consistent with resonance??
@cultered swine “more” consistent yep.
Hey!!! I wanna ask another question...it's mostly about my vocals and I want to make the comment section 69
*Is it a better move if I train my head voice? I can go up to E5 without hurting my voice
*How do I know if k actually Support?
*What is vocal fatigue? Sometimes...after I belt or just sing my throat hurts...and sometimes I feel like getting dizzy and my eyesight becomes blurry after singing
1. It depends on what type of singing you're aiming at. Like operatic requires more head voice and contemporary singing requires more chest and mix etc,.. But developing breath support is the most essential aspect.
2. I think it's best to show you're singing to someone who knows about suppport and stuffs.
3. It generally means your voice being tired (due to oversing, dehydration, vocal strains,..)
I really dont know but i heard that u know u support when the notes feels open, free, and you feel like you can go higher. If you know what I mean
love it 💕
Why I never see Laboum Soyeon everywhere... :( super under the radar with great talent
Yerin blows me away every fucking time
lol that how I’d describe her vocals mind blowing
do you have the link for yerin’s C5 at 3:44?
it's still makes me sad that yuju doesn't support C5 consistent anymore like back in her debut days
edit: her voice now sounds alot better than her 2018-2020 era
how abt secret ost?
@@mahesajordan935 still strain and added tension
@@onlyforyou6363 the support was still there but the quality isnt same as her prime
She's starting to be consistent and her recent ones has no strain and support like at her hair stylist wedding.
What do you think about Solji from EXID?
Also just gained a new subscriber😌
solji is okay. she can be up her as she resonates c5 consistently and even support few c#5 although she can be pushy because of her chesty approach
my YUJUUUUUUUUU MY BIAAASSSSSSSSS
I didnt even watch it all yet but there will be a 2nd part or smth?
There will be more parts (hopefully) but for other aspects ^^ Next in the line is top head voice list xD
i wanna ask about 15& jimin’s vocal now did she regress? and if yes is it only small or big regression?
I'd say she has shown some vocal habits that are affecting her skillset. I'm not entirely sure if it's a stylistic choice but since she made the switch in performing style, she's has become more nasal, straining on notes that she used to slay and head voice seems to weaken too. From resonating C#5 super consistently to straining B4 here and there. The difference is quite significant.
@@ReggieVu thank you for that and kinda sad she used to be so good and by the way is it only the mix that is affected or other registers too?
@@drew-df5vg I haven't heard particular regression signs on her Low, but her head voice got worsen, to say the least. I'll copy a brieft performance analysis from my friends:
"ua-cam.com/video/EYZ3OT47WNc/v-deo.html Monster by Red Velvet - Jamie cover
0:25, 0:29 supported A3
0:45 nasal A4 (oh no no no)
0:45, 0:53 pushed B4
1:36 pushed B4 with slight tension,
2:26 B4 supported but could have been better
D5 -E5- G5 right after was very strained.
So her mix is still oke up to B4 but she was a little too pushy.
2:29 E5 - G5 unsupported, weakly connected head voice with slight airiness.
ua-cam.com/video/rhmGtFOKjsk/v-deo.html Compare it with these nicely supported E5 - G5 and the difference is VERY apparent."
@@drew-df5vg okay now I’ve listened to her Young Hae live this year, it seems that she could still maintain a fine head voice placement with support. So perhaps it is only her mix that has taken a considerable dip in support quality.
@@ReggieVu She had undergone surgery for possibly nodules, could that be a reason?
Yuju ranked low due to her regression right? Since I'm pretty sure her resonance and placement before is better than Wheein and Solar.
yeh this list I like a resume of average mix wise for each. Her resonance before was better than Wheein and Solar? Probably around A4 - C5 but she has always had isuses with consistency even in her peak. Solar's a pusher but her resonance has always been huge, like she breaths resonance everytime she sings haha.
@@ReggieVu They're kinda even in mix or Yuju is a bit better, Yuju has a healthier approach before but a bit inconsistent. Solar and the other is pretty consistent up to C#5 but a pusher and a bit chesty. Most of Yuju's C#5 before are supported and half of them are resonant. Yuju's has a bit better mix, again before, she achieved some nice moments above C#5. Yuju's resonance before probably is the best in 3rd Gen.
@@ReggieVu Her volume and resonance is no joke, ha ha. About being a pusher, do you mean she use too much chest connection in her mix? Chesty? She seems to be very consistent to sing with strong mix. Recent examples are her acapella cover of Beliver (her solarsido channel), "I miss you" in Queendom (or in Mamamoo's Killing Voice), or Where Are You know live band version, or Adrendaline (live version in her solarsido channel). In Sam Johnson's reaction to Delilah mentioned that Solar does that in a well-balanced way and hear others argue that it could be equally healthy.
3:06 link pls
here~ ua-cam.com/video/_RsVmfLtxRY/v-deo.html
@@ReggieVu thx🥰
Was Wendy resonant throghout her clips?
All the notes from C5 down were resonant ^^ (except for the C5 in KOMS perf and B4 in Happy Me)
May I ask why Taeyeon isn't in this list? Since she's also active in 2012-2020.
Taeyeon debuted in 2nd Gen (2007), this video talks about the girls who debuted in 3rd Gen (roughly around 2012-2017).
Sorry just wanna ask, if taeyeon vocals is better now? Cause i heard she regressed this past view years
No no as far as I'm aware, she' still more or less the same, supporting around G#3 ~ D5 ~ F#5 with very consistent resonant up to C#5. It's okay for every singer to sound tired every once in a while, especially with someone with hectic schedule like Taeyeon.
@@ReggieVu Sorry, I want to ask technique which is better Wendy and Taeyeon?
It’s Tae
@@ReggieVu Whether it's better technically between yesung, kyuhyun, ryeowook, Chen, D.O., baekhyun. ? Can I ask you to tell me who's better?
Kyuhyun > Ryeowook > Chen > prime Yesung > D.O > Baekhyun > current Yesung
u mê Solar
Solar đúng kiểu thở thôi cũng thấy nội lực xD
@@ReggieVu đúng rồi ạ, nhưng dnay chị đổi phong cách muốn experiment low note hơn, như kiểu bài solo Spit it out này nọ, với bài Aya mới cũng chọn part ko có high note ko à, huhu buồn, thèm nghe bả res
@@SapphireStorm0910 để ý đa số res gần đây cũng là trong mấy đợt đi promo solo hoặc cover, nên chắc chưa có dịp thui, Solar cũng chăm res với ổn định nhất nhì KPop :3
Jihyo not here?
@Pinkii Lights so those A4s were resonant?
@@choutzuyu9826 yes
She is the part 2
Any body saying rose BP golden voice in korea LOL?, shes only unique voice but bad thecniq vocal
Only Shallow support sone time inconsisten , level sub vocal standar korea
Rose's technique is actually not bad as people say