The gentleman asking questions raises a lot of good points which I myself have also had about Islam. When I started trying to practice Islam there were a lot of things that made me uncomfortable because I felt like they went against what is in the Quran. Part of daily prayers includes talking directly to Prophet Muhammad pbuh and saying ‘Peace be on you, O messenger and Gods mercy and blessings’ Why do we directly address the prophet when prayer is worship and worship should be directed to Allah alone? We also ask to honour and bless the prophet and his family as Allah has honoured and blessed Abraham & his family. Does this not contradict 2:285 - “We make no distinction between any of his messengers” by only mentioning Abraham & Muhammad that creates a distinction? If anyone can address these questions I would be very grateful as I genuinely want the answers and these things have been stumbling blocks to my faith. May God guide us all.
saying that 'the majority of people would say that Israel has a right to do what they're doing' is wild when millions all over the world are literally protesting the genocide against Palestinians. And denying Hadith too...
@@mohamedbentarzi9426I believe by the Name you're an Arab so you know the defense between " pray on " and " pray to" . Even in the Tashahud you start with " Greetings are TO Allah and Prayers ..." And then you say " oh allah pray on Muhammad... " The first to Allah is the Act of Worship . The second on Muhammad is Sending prayer and Dua to him " دعاء " . As why we do that in prayer . Muhammad peace and prayers be upon him told us to do so . He was the one to teach us how to pray so.. that's that.
@@dportalino its not pray, Arabic is a very rich language that a verb has so many meanings just as an eskimo has a 100 words for ice. And as why we praise Rasulullah saw during tahhiyat, it’s a prayer to Allah for Rasulullah saw and his family to have all the benefits that Allah bestowed upon Ibrahim as and his family. Allah commands us to do so because the most beloved person to Allah is Rasulullah saw, thats why he is called Habibullah. Any actions we do that pleases Rasulullah pleases Allah and that Allah may be pleased with us. Thats why Shia don’t make sense, they disparaged and cursed the wives and companions of Rasulullah saw, the very people closest and most loved by him. Do you think such actions will pleased Rasulullah saw the very and only person you need help in the day of Judgement ? Or it will pleased Allah?
We Beleive in the hadith (saying of the of prophet Muhammad) because Allah says in the Quran follow me and follow the messenger, so whatever the messenger says it comes from Allah in the beginning companions memorized whatever messenger said but later when companions started dying and people who come after them started forgetting hadith due to the weak memory than there was a need to record those sayings so that's hadith got recorded and fortunately due to that we still have the saying of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam
You spent 8 minutes talking besides each other ... he was asking why is muhammad mentioned in the beginning, middle and end of prayer. First: that is false. And second Muhammad is not mentioned in the "prayer", i.e. not when we pray to god after the ritual worship, which could be any prayer like "Please God give me health" - we don't mentione the Prophet there. You should have simply explained to him that salawat (blessing) are spoken to be sent to the prophet FROM GOD, i.e. we say something like "Peace and blessings be upon the Prophet". It has NOTHING to do with PRAYER.
You accept the transmission of The Qur'An from the same men who you say are not responsible enough to record and transmit the words of Prophet Muhammad ASWS
The Hadiths reveal your prophet to be an immoral man, not worthy of the character that muslims bestow upon him. He ordered the assasinations of poets and others who criticized him, which continues to this day. Is Muhammad's ego really so fragile that he cannot tolerate a little bit of heat?
Hadith are nothing but Islamic version of the bible made by a Russian islamic paul named bukhari. Qur'an is 100 percent sufficient and sects only exists because people are following hadiths more than the Qur'an. Most of the hadiths are man made arab garbage. Some Hadiths are authentic sure... But Qur'an is the miracle of Prophet pbuh, not the hadiths. Nobody needed to know the age of aisha and how she cleaned semens from Prophet's pbuh clothes. (Sahih bukhari) Astagfirullah
When Zeeshan and the other guy start talking about the _Seal_ of the Prophets, the other guy just starts acting like he doesnt have a brain. He's actively being a dumbass, im not sorry. He knows exactly what Zeeshan is saying and refuses to accept it. He keeps trying to force his own definition and it just isnt working. This type of disbeliever in particular will be in the lowest pits of Jahannam. Unless they change their ways.
He seems sincere, may Allah guide him
?????
The gentleman asking questions raises a lot of good points which I myself have also had about Islam. When I started trying to practice Islam there were a lot of things that made me uncomfortable because I felt like they went against what is in the Quran.
Part of daily prayers includes talking directly to Prophet Muhammad pbuh and saying ‘Peace be on you, O messenger and Gods mercy and blessings’
Why do we directly address the prophet when prayer is worship and worship should be directed to Allah alone?
We also ask to honour and bless the prophet and his family as Allah has honoured and blessed Abraham & his family.
Does this not contradict 2:285 - “We make no distinction between any of his messengers” by only mentioning Abraham & Muhammad that creates a distinction?
If anyone can address these questions I would be very grateful as I genuinely want the answers and these things have been stumbling blocks to my faith.
May God guide us all.
saying that 'the majority of people would say that Israel has a right to do what they're doing' is wild when millions all over the world are literally protesting the genocide against Palestinians. And denying Hadith too...
This guy is asking real question, super smart and rational
BS
We don’t pray to the prophet, we pray to Allah to bless the prophet and by doing so as Allah is pleased by our action Allah will bless us back.
please can somebody tell why we say in At-Tahiyyat that we pray to mohamed p.b.u.h and ibrahim if we only are supposed to pray to Allah.
@@mohamedbentarzi9426I believe by the Name you're an Arab so you know the defense between " pray on " and " pray to" . Even in the Tashahud you start with " Greetings are TO Allah and Prayers ..." And then you say " oh allah pray on Muhammad... " The first to Allah is the Act of Worship . The second on Muhammad is Sending prayer and Dua to him " دعاء " .
As why we do that in prayer . Muhammad peace and prayers be upon him told us to do so . He was the one to teach us how to pray so.. that's that.
@@dportalino its not pray, Arabic is a very rich language that a verb has so many meanings just as an eskimo has a 100 words for ice. And as why we praise Rasulullah saw during tahhiyat, it’s a prayer to Allah for Rasulullah saw and his family to have all the benefits that Allah bestowed upon Ibrahim as and his family. Allah commands us to do so because the most beloved person to Allah is Rasulullah saw, thats why he is called Habibullah. Any actions we do that pleases Rasulullah pleases Allah and that Allah may be pleased with us. Thats why Shia don’t make sense, they disparaged and cursed the wives and companions of Rasulullah saw, the very people closest and most loved by him. Do you think such actions will pleased Rasulullah saw the very and only person you need help in the day of Judgement ? Or it will pleased Allah?
We Beleive in the hadith (saying of the of prophet Muhammad) because Allah says in the Quran follow me and follow the messenger, so whatever the messenger says it comes from Allah in the beginning companions memorized whatever messenger said but later when companions started dying and people who come after them started forgetting hadith due to the weak memory than there was a need to record those sayings so that's hadith got recorded and fortunately due to that we still have the saying of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam
You spent 8 minutes talking besides each other ... he was asking why is muhammad mentioned in the beginning, middle and end of prayer. First: that is false. And second Muhammad is not mentioned in the "prayer", i.e. not when we pray to god after the ritual worship, which could be any prayer like "Please God give me health" - we don't mentione the Prophet there.
You should have simply explained to him that salawat (blessing) are spoken to be sent to the prophet FROM GOD, i.e. we say something like "Peace and blessings be upon the Prophet". It has NOTHING to do with PRAYER.
It seems that he's the quranist
I wonder how much ganja he smoked before this conversation.
Brother he is asking real questions
You accept the transmission of The Qur'An from the same men who you say are not responsible enough to record and transmit the words of Prophet Muhammad ASWS
"follow the Sunnah, i understand that, but not the Sunnah AND the Hadith"
Is this guy drunk?
Where do you get the Sunnah from?
Harry Potter books?
The Hadiths reveal your prophet to be an immoral man, not worthy of the character that muslims bestow upon him. He ordered the assasinations of poets and others who criticized him, which continues to this day. Is Muhammad's ego really so fragile that he cannot tolerate a little bit of heat?
Hadith are nothing but Islamic version of the bible made by a Russian islamic paul named bukhari.
Qur'an is 100 percent sufficient and sects only exists because people are following hadiths more than the Qur'an.
Most of the hadiths are man made arab garbage.
Some Hadiths are authentic sure... But Qur'an is the miracle of Prophet pbuh, not the hadiths.
Nobody needed to know the age of aisha and how she cleaned semens from Prophet's pbuh clothes. (Sahih bukhari)
Astagfirullah
When Zeeshan and the other guy start talking about the _Seal_ of the Prophets, the other guy just starts acting like he doesnt have a brain. He's actively being a dumbass, im not sorry. He knows exactly what Zeeshan is saying and refuses to accept it. He keeps trying to force his own definition and it just isnt working.
This type of disbeliever in particular will be in the lowest pits of Jahannam.
Unless they change their ways.
A hadith rejector?..I think I've wasted my time😅
😂 joker 🐷✅