i really love this documentary. i am in my final year in University of Ghana reading sociology. We had a whole article to read and learn about the Xhosa circumcision tradition and customs and this documentary is nothing but Perfection, i love this masterpiece and the energy put into this work. Im sharing this video to my colleauges ASAP. This is very informative.
It's crucial to understand the impact of revealing confidential cultural practices. When you share such information, you undermine the trust and respect that cultures deserve. These practices often carry deep spiritual or communal significance, and their exposure can cause harm, disrespect, or misunderstanding. It's important to acknowledge the breach of trust and commit to learning about cultural sensitivity and privacy. Building awareness and sensitivity helps us uphold the integrity and dignity of diverse cultural traditions, fostering a more respectful and inclusive world for everyone involved.
i am not a person who comments on social media but this one noko iphambene lento yenziwe ngulomfo.he is a seller. indoda ayiyenzi lento.eyasendle iphelela endle full stop.ngunofotyie lo.
@@readthisnotthat1980the difference between us pedi and Xhosa people is we are allowed to go to the doctor while Xhosa they don't hence why every year they kill their boys
Ladies and gentlemen. I do not think that we will ever solve this problem by attacking the messenger. For the record, personally know Mr Mayenzeke Baza and I can confirm that he is a Xhosa man. Although I recognize that there is a problem, I do not what I would suggest at this stage is that we get to see the entire film and there after establish a platform where we can deliberate on this issue. Hopefully we can find a meaningful and lasting solution.
Im a female Xhosa Ulwaluko yimfihlo nathi mabhinqa asiyazi and asifuni kuyazi , sithanda ukungayaz ....im sure this documentary was made by iGweje, there's no Xhosa man can do this, this is disappointing 🤮
@@sazibaka-jd7om lwena uthetha umqundu swaar 🙄🙄🙄 batho ba shwa everyday but o batla taba eo e felle fela?! We as healthcare workers we feel pain when people die so don’t you dare insult me! You can take your kids if you want but if they die, their death will be on you😎😎
A wonderful doc with major sound issues. I was either forced to read lips because of voice delay or resort to CC ( never makes much sense either ) when voices were barely a whisper. Trying to hear, rewinding scenes multiple times in vain It's upsetting as this is a fascinating, emotional topic in a film that's hard work to watch. Hoping to find a new upload of this soon...
Culture and traditions is not meant to be retrogressive its supposed to be dynamic and progressive not rigid but flexible educative and adoptable and open to new ideas! I say change or change will change you!
yikaka le yava yikaka kaka ...ukungayi esikolweni sengqondo kunje....amaXhosa with a Lost world......ndiyayenysnya le ...amadoda alawulwa ngabafazi...bcz i believe ukuba if uzimele ngelungelo likaRhulumente...uphantsi kolawulo lasebugqwirheni...yerrr amadoda amadala obhuti nootata benza into engazange yenziwe kubo bafuna nje ukuba famous kuthethuba ibingekho enye into ebebenoyenza nje🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Female genital mutilation comes from the same place! If these women fought the men on this issue, and invoked the Punt custom! Then the men would ask " why not bake bread" !
That old man should be prosecuted by all xhosas nd 12 Xhosa speaking tribes fame agwekwe ga chin ubonisa nton uthengisa usiko lwethu emehlweni omlungu wakewabonaphi into enje ama Sotho,pedi,tswana they don't show their cultures roots like that utter bull
Lol the problem is Xhosa are stubborn for example in pedi people most of us do circumcision from a doctor and afterwards go to the initiation school just for culture nothing happens to you in the mountains hence why it's rare to hear about deaths while there are annual deaths in Xhosa people which is a shame
@@gunner4life568 yes there won't be deaths because you go to the hospital and get circumcised Xhosas go to the mountains to get circumcised BIG difference.
@@gunner4life568So you want Xhosas to go to the hospital and not the mountains to get circumcised 😂 that's not "ubudoda" then😂and that's not the Xhosa way
For folks wanting to know how long or when this practice came about, all they have to do is open their bibles to Genesis 17: 11-12, this is a Covenant by way of G-d to Abrahams sons. Let's just say this covenant happened 4,000 years ago.
@@chuckscott4661 Gods Laws on Scrolls is a credible source, and so be it that the Bible thats composed of these scrolls are a credible source. As far as I'm concerned, The God of Abraham is the only source to everything that we all sense by way of our God given 5 senses.
This is nonsense. Xa omnye eye wahlelwa lelo lishwa lokuba ayogqibezela esibhedlele does not mean yinkwenkwe. Kufuneka ikhutshwe le ngqondo ebantwaneni because bayabulalana ngobu bubhanxa. Today there are medical conditions ebantwini. Does not mean akolukanga ekugqibeleni. So please teach your young ones to respect abanye abantu. You will be surprise to learn ukuthi the way uyiphakamisa ngayo le ndlela woluke ngayo to kwezinye iintlanga you remain inkwenkwe.
i really love this documentary. i am in my final year in University of Ghana reading sociology. We had a whole article to read and learn about the Xhosa circumcision tradition and customs and this documentary is nothing but Perfection, i love this masterpiece and the energy put into this work. Im sharing this video to my colleauges ASAP. This is very informative.
Just because you made it out alive does not mean everyone will
So
@@eathh_23it is backwards culture maybe hire a real doctor who can perform the circumcision not just any person who might kill you kid
It's crucial to understand the impact of revealing confidential cultural practices. When you share such information, you undermine the trust and respect that cultures deserve. These practices often carry deep spiritual or communal significance, and their exposure can cause harm, disrespect, or misunderstanding. It's important to acknowledge the breach of trust and commit to learning about cultural sensitivity and privacy. Building awareness and sensitivity helps us uphold the integrity and dignity of diverse cultural traditions, fostering a more respectful and inclusive world for everyone involved.
This documentary really hurt my feelings only a person who gave birth will understand what these boys are going through meaning unonzala
Tell me about "dropping the pot."
i am not a person who comments on social media but this one noko iphambene lento yenziwe ngulomfo.he is a seller. indoda ayiyenzi lento.eyasendle iphelela endle full stop.ngunofotyie lo.
Siba true bro...besisayelani ke nyani endle xa ezizidenge ziphinde ziyi publishe kanje hayi siyanyeleka
I'm pedi and we do go to initiation too but this is bullshit.....his not a trustworthy man this person nxn.
@@readthisnotthat1980the difference between us pedi and Xhosa people is we are allowed to go to the doctor while Xhosa they don't hence why every year they kill their boys
Kukusa oku
Udom kakhulu yeva this is an educational video nditsho no Google seychaza nton eyenzakayo sdenge ndini
Ladies and gentlemen. I do not think that we will ever solve this problem by attacking the messenger. For the record, personally know Mr Mayenzeke Baza and I can confirm that he is a Xhosa man. Although I recognize that there is a problem, I do not what I would suggest at this stage is that we get to see the entire film and there after establish a platform where we can deliberate on this issue. Hopefully we can find a meaningful and lasting solution.
Yinkwenkwe kwale yenza le documentary
Some good SA related documentaries they have hey nice man 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿✅💯🇿🇦
Im a female Xhosa
Ulwaluko yimfihlo nathi mabhinqa asiyazi and asifuni kuyazi , sithanda ukungayaz ....im sure this documentary was made by iGweje, there's no Xhosa man can do this, this is disappointing 🤮
Yikaka le Documentary andiyaz uba yinton i use yobukho bayo
No it's not fair the Xhosa traditional 💔🤞... Because this is a traditional style no charge... again never change that...
I don’t understand why people are angry about this Documentary 😂😂😂😂 you guys are mad! People are dying and still you wanted this to be kept a secret
you should keep quiet when you dont fully understand something
Voetsek kwekwe
uthetha umqundu kwedini, sometimes you should just keep quiet if dont understand
@@eathh_23 ftsek nawe 😒😒 o nahana wa ntshosa wena😏😏
@@sazibaka-jd7om lwena uthetha umqundu swaar 🙄🙄🙄 batho ba shwa everyday but o batla taba eo e felle fela?! We as healthcare workers we feel pain when people die so don’t you dare insult me! You can take your kids if you want but if they die, their death will be on you😎😎
Does a person choose if he wants to go or is it a must and also can anyone choose to go in order to become a man
So the man who is telling the story didn't do circumcision
A wonderful doc with major sound issues. I was either forced to read lips because of voice delay or resort to CC ( never makes much sense either ) when voices were barely a whisper. Trying to hear, rewinding scenes multiple times in vain
It's upsetting as this is a fascinating, emotional topic in a film that's hard work to watch. Hoping to find a new upload of this soon...
Cause its filmed in 2000.
Culture and traditions is not meant to be retrogressive its supposed to be dynamic and progressive not rigid but flexible educative and adoptable and open to new ideas! I say change or change will change you!
I’m glad your opinion mean nothing
@Habbit. Circumcision rates are dropping.
Stop abusing children!
Stfu and let's us continue with our culture kwekwe ndini
@donald. Child abuse is not a buzzword.
And neither is misandtry.
Caba imali inqongophele lento nide nibhentsise isiko lethu ezizweni oluhlobo, nixelela bani nifundisa bani ngobudoda bethu. Wafa umzi kaPhalo umzi Karharhabe umzi kaNgqika sijongile. Sukani kulonto niyenzayo. Lukhanyo Kiva i platform yethu isebuhlanti hayi e Thivini okanye ko UA-cam sincedeni madoda.
Bathengise ngalo, limnkile ngoku, laziwa zizizwe, kwalanja yengcibi ngubhonyongo omkhulu.
yikaka le yava yikaka kaka ...ukungayi esikolweni sengqondo kunje....amaXhosa with a Lost world......ndiyayenysnya le ...amadoda alawulwa ngabafazi...bcz i believe ukuba if uzimele ngelungelo likaRhulumente...uphantsi kolawulo lasebugqwirheni...yerrr amadoda amadala obhuti nootata benza into engazange yenziwe kubo bafuna nje ukuba famous kuthethuba ibingekho enye into ebebenoyenza nje🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
What u are doing is wrong nja
This is a nonsense how can you take a video if you want to solve a problem like this
Female genital mutilation comes from the same place! If these women fought the men on this issue, and invoked the Punt custom! Then the men would ask " why not bake bread" !
What does bread have to do with this, I'm genuinely confused
Ngubani isigebenga sakho kwedini?
Please delete this video money doesn’t matter more than our culture ndiyakucela bawo
Psychotic sexual torture ritual. Must be banned ASAP!
@jx. I agree. It must be banned!
This not culture but abuse which can result in death unfortunately
Yikaka le ivezwa ngulo tata umdal
Mlungu Mvuleni mdivumelana nawe
bubunya bodwa nto yakuthi oku
Mlungu Mvuleni yinkwenkwe lomfo
uthengisa ngesiko nesithethe sakwantu lo tata yerrr
Ohw!!!! Lafa ilizwe lethu madoda and ndinayo into endi qinisekileyo ngayo ukubana lenja yekwekwe yalukela edolophini and indoda elaziyo isiko soze elinze elihlazo lingaka. uhlazekile kwaye apha kwaxhosa akekho namunye umuntu obenophinda angene umzini walenja noko uyakrokrisa xayinjena inkosi yalapha noko madoda bahlazeka ubuzwe lemka ilizwe lethu sijongile and akusinguye uMxhosa lona
sinethemba nqwane
ai mna Ndiyndoda yomxhosa kwaye andinasiko linje ndahlale ntabeni mna ndiphethwe zilegends so andnawari abantu xabebhentsisa izinto abazenzayo wrong besithi phofu benza benza isiko lesxhosa thina bantu balo siyazi elethu alibulali lingasi bantwana esbhedlele
ngxatsho ke mkhuluwa wawabeka kakuhle mfo kanantsi
That old man should be prosecuted by all xhosas nd 12 Xhosa speaking tribes fame agwekwe ga chin ubonisa nton uthengisa usiko lwethu emehlweni omlungu wakewabonaphi into enje ama Sotho,pedi,tswana they don't show their cultures roots like that utter bull
Lol the problem is Xhosa are stubborn for example in pedi people most of us do circumcision from a doctor and afterwards go to the initiation school just for culture nothing happens to you in the mountains hence why it's rare to hear about deaths while there are annual deaths in Xhosa people which is a shame
@@gunner4life568 yes there won't be deaths because you go to the hospital and get circumcised Xhosas go to the mountains to get circumcised BIG difference.
@@gunner4life568So you want Xhosas to go to the hospital and not the mountains to get circumcised 😂 that's not "ubudoda" then😂and that's not the Xhosa way
arghh. No man..what are you guys doing..💔🤦
uThixo ..ndiyamthanda amaMpondomise am anqabe nakulamaqonga wamanyala....amaZulu ndiyawathanda ...akangomagwala njengamadoda amaXhosa yoo ngamagwala abobantu...baathngisa ngelizwe tanci...kumabhulu behlulwa...bathinjwa...babambelela kwinto yabo ibikukuphela kwayo abathi phof bubugcisa babo....nabo beyilahla nayo isimka..ngokuba kalok bafuna uthandwa ngabafazi ezinto zingenamqolo zingazazi nokuba zisukaphi...kusemalawini nje.....
😢hayi ndahlulakele ngoku lento xayizawkwenziwa kwelakuthi hayi usihlazile lomfo 😨😨😨kubuyasithengisa ngoku ndincamile elilizwe liyaphi
Akunobakho cebo na ku Mangalelwe le Channel I delete le video .Lihlazo noko olu....
Jirre die documentary lat my yster soma pain 😢💔
lafa ilizwe aze liyaphi masekunje baphi abaphathi bethu bakunje kujeziswe nanku umntu
What he is doing his fuckesd up akalihloniphi Eli lalapha Khaya isiko wenza ububhanxa bakhe yaz loo🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬 poese
What's the purpose of this documentary ? 😠😠msunwakho zukile mangcuka kwedin
ulawulwa ehlathini lo...wathwetyulwa kudala inoba nomkakhe umpha kamandi.. ubevinjwa kalok ...
Le social media ingathi abantu abasazi ba bayisibenzise for ini nxaah
Bububhanxa bodwa obu benziwa yilekwekwe yotata
weh 4 dice khaw'yeke into zabantu man 😭😭😭
For folks wanting to know how long or when this practice came about, all they have to do is open their bibles to Genesis 17: 11-12, this is a Covenant by way of G-d to Abrahams sons. Let's just say this covenant happened 4,000 years ago.
With who are they making this covenant
The bible is not a credible source.
@@chuckscott4661 Gods Laws on Scrolls is a credible source, and so be it that the Bible thats composed of these scrolls are a credible source. As far as I'm concerned, The God of Abraham is the only source to everything that we all sense by way of our God given 5 senses.
🤮🤮
Halala Gobongwana hayi ndincamile soze phinde ndive ndithetha yhuu baphi abafazi ke ngk hayini bafondini chini
Uyanya lomsunu
😂😂 I thought uba naniblamer amampondo nje ngobhentsisa isiko lenu ngoku zikhiphani
Wtf is this 😒
fuck this shit thengisa ngobudodanxa...
Wafotyela lo Qha qwaba, why would you give such information loosely😡
Sisibhanxa esi senze lento
NguGcina Lo sanukuthengisa ngobumi bomXhosa😮😮
Eyi zintoni ezi na MaXhosa funeka nifunde ukugcina usiko pha kwamahlubi nabe Sotho ngeke uve ezizinto ngabo
ingxaki amadoda amaXhosa uba kwatswina omama wofika entantazela bcz ngamagwala la...oyikwa ushiywa ngabafazi ezizinto ...hsy inoba imitshsto yawo iqinile lamadoda...kuba kalok bayabanelisa abafazi..babo...nangok inoba bafumana awona amawonga lamavaka la
kutheni ingacinywa na le kaka
Avumile mafede siyanyelwa nje apha ngaba mabasuse lento
Clicka kweza dots siyirepoteni izocinywa bra
Delete this plz 🥺
Rhaaaaaaaaaaaa bububhanxa bani obuh
Lomntu wabaleka kwayena. Lilulwane eli.
ndiyakuva mna, ba buyindoda buzoyazi ba lelona nyala likhulu ukwenza lento
This is nonsense. Xa omnye eye wahlelwa lelo lishwa lokuba ayogqibezela esibhedlele does not mean yinkwenkwe. Kufuneka ikhutshwe le ngqondo ebantwaneni because bayabulalana ngobu bubhanxa. Today there are medical conditions ebantwini. Does not mean akolukanga ekugqibeleni. So please teach your young ones to respect abanye abantu. You will be surprise to learn ukuthi the way uyiphakamisa ngayo le ndlela woluke ngayo to kwezinye iintlanga you remain inkwenkwe.
Do you have to be this disrespectful to your Culture ubonise umhlaba wonle jikelele isiko elibaluleke kanje? Really! Just for content! Sick!
Wow xhosa neh😮😮😮
MNQANDU WAKHO 👿🦇.
BEKUNYANZELEKILE UBA UVEZE NE PICTURES 😠😡😡😡
kodwa madala usenzani
Yikaka kodwa le
À
Ibuhlungu le yo bhetsiswa kwesiko lethu kwi kundla zoxhomana
bububhanxa obu ubenzileyo .
Ngumnqundu lo
Ndiyayonyanya lento ivezwa apha niyasihlaza ngobububhetyebhetye benu ngobani abanye enibabona besenza lento anisixabisanga isintu sethu ninyolukile
ngumakhelo lo
Makhelo omkhulu
fuck this shit thengisa ngobudodanxa...
fuck this shit thengisa ngobudodanxa...