Well, the Movies and GT are the same timeline. Go watch the Super 17 Arc. When the news on the TV shows villains attacking the city from Hell, you see Cooler in the crowd, thus canonizing the movies.
@@Kaptain_Wario ok I will admit you are right. At least the Cooler movies. And going a bit farther into that Vegeta knowing the Fusion Dance could link up Fusion Reborn. And Wrath of the Dragon could link up to GT as well considering in GT Trunks has the same sword he got at the end of the movie. The other movies though I’m not sure.
One of the movie timelines stops after Lord Slug anyways since the Cooler movies basically demand the events on Namek play out as they did in the show whereas the timeline up until Lord Slug demands it must have played out differently, mainly with Piccolo surviving the saiyan invasion arc.
11:32 There is a huge correction here. In this timeline the show and manga state Cell states that Trunks had turned off the androids using the remote. This means that it isn't necessarily a Trunks that went through the Time Chamber Training, especially if it was then there is no way Cell could have sneaked up on him. Cell even said that the Trunks he took out was weaker.
@@MrShaiya96while this is true, this also opens the following question: So Cell didnt change the date of the time machine, yet he still arrives before the Androids are awakened. Why would Trunks go there? He already warned the Z fighters about the androids
The trunks killed by cell was actually the 3rd trip into the past. Trunks was going back to tell him the z fighters how to beat the androids so that implies multiple timelines can connect to multiple different timelines.
@@doppiovinegaro3525 it had already been confirmed that the future trunks that we first see is not the same trunks that meets the Z fighters 3 years later.
I seem to recall in DragonBall xenoverse there was mentioned that the time-line split actually happened because of a flaw in the time machine method/design. This was "fixed" so timeliness could no longer split when the time machines were used to handle time fragments (parralel quests) that spawned from fixing the time-line in the scrolls of eternity. Even tough it is not cannonical to the anime/manga ot is something interesting to take note of.
When was this I've dedicated myself to completing the entire story and all side story's and events but haven't seen this mentioned I want to know if I missed something or forget?
That makes no sense. The time machine was creating an entirely other universe and then traveling there but further back in time? That's pretty nonsensical.
I just spent a whole hour bingeing your work back-to-back and it was a real treat to see someone so dedicated to the franchise, while implementing some really good editing! All the best to you and and I hope that you continue to make quality content like this for even more people to discover.
ThePark 627 did they do something specific that I missed or do you just mean the endless clickbait of little substance that plagues Dragon Ball UA-cam? Either way, thank you so much! I’ve got some cool DB videos in the pipeline that I hope you’ll like!
@@SpellCommander91 hey brother, where did all of your Yu-Gi-Oh! Fan theories go? I was trying to show them to a buddy tonight and couldn't find them anymore. Did they get deleted or something else?
@@robinkern926 my channel came under attack for Copyright by Nihan Ad Systems, a company that represents the studio that produced Duel Monsters through VRAINS. I'm in the process of getting them sorted. Hopefully they'll be back soon.
@@SpellCommander91 oh snap. That's not cool. I'm guessing this is probably along with the same wave like the people getting strikes due to DBZ stuff or the likes. You got this bro. Keep up the amazing work. Your theories really made me think and I can't wait to hear them again and more. You'll overcome this one dude!!! You got this.
The thing is timeline 4 didn’t happen, because trunks DID wait 3 years to go back, that’s why the Z fighters Recognize him! And even though this is technically the original and unseen timeline and not the Main and HOT (history of trunks) timeline we can assume that the original and HOT trunks would behave the same way
Actually he didn't, he simply uses his time machine to go 3 years later but for him it was like a week later, or else we would've seen trunks be 20 when he returned and yet he was still 17 and turns 18 when he trains with vegeta in the time chamber
Actually, no. If memory serves me, Trunks explains to Goku on his original trip to the past that it will take him six months to get the machine fueled for another round trip. He then proceeds to say that he'll join them again on the day the Androids show up "if I'm still alive." So, no. Trunks did NOT wait three years to make a return trip. He did however have to wait six months just to be able to do it.
I have a few theories on how the time rings can be correct, though they are a bit shaky and require some fan-justification Theory 1: Changing the date only severs the link if you change it to be earlier than what you already have it set to, this allows timeline 4 and 7 to not be neccesary 7 - 2 = 5, which matches the number of time rings, this would track considering the time rings don't split reality as they only allow you to go forward in time. Theory 2: The whole gods killing eachother thing doesn't break time, what happened is the timeline already split when Goku, Vegeta, and Trunks learned about their timeline's future, splitting it into a reality where Zamasu enacted his plan, and one where Zamasu got hakai'd by beerus, under this assumption, Beerus was not responsible in any capacity for the creation of another timeline, and it had already happened by the time beerus went to destroy Zamasu. So what we have with this logic is Theory 3: The time ring prevented Zamasu's future from being aborted, this is the direct cause of the timeline split that created timeline 6. Timeline 1: Cell's Origin Timeline (Timeline 1) Timeline 2: Future Trunks Timeline (Timeline 2) (Theory 2 Dictates that this timeline doesn't get split 12 times) Timeline 3: Original Present Timeline (Timeline 4) (Theory 1 Prevents another split here) Timeline 4: Cell's Perfect Timeline (Timeline 5) (Theory 1 would not prevent any split here as Cell & Trunks are seperate time travellers in seperate time machines) Timeline 5: Dragon Ball Z/Black Timeline ("Aborted" Timeline 8) (Theory 1 Prevents another split here, Theory 3 prevents this timeline getting aborted) Timeline 6: Dragon Ball Super timeline (Timeline 8) (Theory 2 Dictates that this timeline doesn't get aborted) EDIT: I'm assuming Trunks coming back during the Goku black arc is a return trip to an already linked timeline.
I see dragon ball super and dragon ball gt as two timelines that were the result of universe 12s time travel thus creating the first timeline split ( the rest of the events are exactly the same upto the defeat of Majin buu) then we have bulmas time machine and trunks time traveling creating more splits within these split time lines
I would like to add 2 more actually Gt timeline : where either shin died and beerus never woke up { but this also a buyback theory Where Goku never got revived by old Kai so this theory denies it) Second beerus never woke up or he slept just enough time so that he wakes up after Goku goes with shenron (and Vegeta kinda retires idk like I haven't seen gt and other sagas except last one really don't matter ) Time line 10:::: the DBZ movies saga Where Basically some random trunks from a universe where it really stayed same (excluding dbs broly and super hero happens they don't ) It could also be another way of gt timeline but idk
So odds are, what Whis did was take a more nuaced approach involving the God-on-God violence to take things in a direction to prevent the infinite loops. Beerus likely just did it wrong, or the infinite loop thing/timeline thing is just to ward off God-on-God violence, because that actually sounds like a viable defensive measure.
waiiiiit, if timeline 7 is the real timeline and goku is in Universe 7, that means toriyama did know what he was doing. This confirm the fact that toiyama has an IQ of 9000. Edit: I made this joke half way through the video and now after finishing this video I know now this shits confusing.
Smile blame toriyama for fucked up story( confusin people) I know it his fucked up story. actually future kakarot has died with heart virus remember. The history of trunks. Super?? Doesn't make sense. Father of kakarot is Canon too. New movie doesn't make sense. Baby kakarot was sent to earth never mention about armor?? Explain dis
When it comes to zamasu and goku black, I think they went on a cathartic rampage and that's why they destroyed the mortal population themselves instead of using the dragon to do it.
Given that planet-busting can be done with a flick of a finger in this series, them giving Earth special attention due to it being Goku's homeworld and the source of time travel makes sense. There is absolutely *no* reason for them to be taking so much time with it other than "Because they want to". Trunks was in no position to stop them at the start so it wasn't like they *needed* him dead to pop the Earth like a balloon.
@@manwithaplan5503 "Earth invented time travel beforehand" also explains the entire weird-planet thing Earth has going on. We have no evidence that anyone ever used the Dragon Balls to resurrect dinosaurs or make dogs rule the world, but that sounds exactly like what humans inventing time travel world do.
Brilliant video. Bottom line is it becomes incredibly difficult not to explain it away into infinite universes. Even future trunks says (in super) that a different amount of time has passed in his timeline- likely indicating to us that this is a different future trunks and that we deal with a different future trunks every single time he uses the machine.
I think your correct because because the trunks in super was the same trunks but different at same time. It could easily be trunks from android 13 or Bojack saga even thou it not cannon it's showing a different timelines trunks .from Brolly,Bojack,trunks.movies means some event did not happen
Uhh, no. The DBS manga is the one Toriyama considered as the OFFICIAL continuation of his original story. Even Broly and Super Hero movies are more in line with the manga than they are with the anime. @@captainswagger2838
My personal headcanon as to why there are only 5 Time rings present (6 after Zamasu's death) is actually Xenoverse/Super Dragon Ball heroes/The Time Patrol. The Time Patrol and the Supreme Kai of Time's job are to "Weed" alternate timelines down and adjust them to a point where they can be self-consistent with relation to each other. This likely has something to do with the Time Scrolls and Toki Toki in how it is regulated, but the result is that whenever a timeline that is extraneous is born, Chronoa or the Time Patrol arrive and "reset" the timeline TVA-Style and maybe pick up allies from the timeline to join the Time Patrol, thus why we have Xeno Trunks and the Xeno GT versions of characters. So with this assumption the 6 time rings at the end of the Goku Black arc are the result of Chronoa and the Time Patrol doing timeline spring cleaning of the Goku Black arc in order to keep things in line. These 6 timelines likely are. Timeline 1 (The Main Timeline) Timeline 2 (The History of Trunks Timeline, erased then recreated with a timeline that takes its place with an extra Trunks and Mai in tow) Timeline 3 (Cell's Timeline) Timeline 4 (The Unseen Timeline, aka a timeline where Trunks arrives and helps Goku and pals out with no intervention from Cell) Timeline 5 ( Universe 12 Time Machine Timeline, this timeline and Timeline 2 are conjoined as they are the two timelines with the U12 TIme machine as Infinite Zamasu in the manga stated that he found the U12 Time machine within Timeline 2, so Timeline 2 was split off of this incident) Timeline 6 (Goku Black's *revised* Birth, with the Time Patrol and Chronoa making sure that the offshoot Goku Black from this timeline heads to Timeline 2 and properly becomes the genesis point of Goku Black in future occurrences of the loop as any potential timeline that would be offshoot in repeat loops are self-contained and erased, leaving space for a new timeline 6 to appear) Excess timelines born from improperly done return trips or first entering of timelines are erased by the Time Patrol, with the order of events being -Timeline 5 splits off timeline 2 -Timeline 3 continues from timeline 5 until Trunks travels back in time to make TImeline 4 -The link between Timeline 3 and 4 is locked in place by the time Patrol so Trunks does hop between the two timelines. -Trunks is killed by Cell and cell takes his time machine to go to make Timeline 1 -Timeline 2's version of Trunks is guided to Timeline 1 either via how many timeline wounds there are throwing his time machine off course, or by the intervention of the Time Patrol. -Timeline 1 and 2 are linked now and stay linked. -Zamasu steals Goku's body after an unknown period of time in Timeline 1, becoming Goku Black heading over to Timeline 2 to recruit his counterpart there -Trunks heads back to timeline 1 either via the lock-on tech Pilaf suggested or aid of the Time Patrol, this doesn't split the timeline likely due to the Time Patrol. -The events of the Goku Black arc play out normally as Goku Black is self-consistent still due to his time ring. -Beerus kills Zamasu, due to Timeline 1's future counterpart as Goku Black having his time ring on, it splits the timeline, birthing timeline 6 and erasing the future that would result in Timeline 1's Goku Black. (Calling the erased Future Timeline 1B) -Timeline 6 Zamasu proceeds to reenact the events of Timeline 1B Zamasu, taking Goku's body and heading to Timeline 2 -Goku Black from Timeline 1/1B is actually erased as Beerus stated, but is replaced by the unintended Timeline 6 counterpart, thus solving that apparent paradox. -Timeline 2 is erased by Zeno, destroying the time ring of that universe, only to be recreated by Whis time-traveling one more time, offshoot timelines born from this incident are handled and surpassed by the Time Patrol.
mybe ou update tis as there mroe timelien out there goku black come back in hereos fireza ins emcha and alvie ina nther timeline so the androdi 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 in anther alos the fis kai of time prof this with her tourmn she siad there to many tiemlein and goku black sia dhe kileld 99 gokus o 99 timesline he want to
This is purely incredible, I had myself asking where Trunk's timeline sits at a stupid time in the morning, I wrote it down and went back to sleep. Upon finding your video my mind has been obliterated with the amount of work that went into this. I am thankful but still none the wiser but knowing now of how many "possible" timelines has only left me with more questions. Thank you for breaking this down more than DB ever did.
So I thought it was pretty well explained that once there's a link between the two timelines that's it. They can go between the two without creating a new timeline. Here's how I've always seen it. Timeline 1 is where Cell comes from. Timeline 2 follows the main timeline we see except Cell doesn't show up, so Trunks and Vegeta probably kill the androids after getting out of the time chamber, leaving Trunks to go back to timeline 1 where he gets killed. Timeline 3 is where Cell shows up, and is defeated by Gohan. Now Trunks goes off back to what would be timeline 1 but because of knowledge he didn't have before Cell created timeline 3, Trunks prevents his own death creating timeline 4, where Buu isn't released, he learns super saiyan 2 after seeing the supreme Kai die, and eventually Goku Black shows up because in timeline 5, an alternate to timeline 3, the guy that's trained by Gowasu uses the super dragon balls to become Black, kill Goku's family, and decides to hop between timelines and terrorizes Future Trunks world. I don't think Whis restoring Trunks world created or eliminated everything so we're at 5 timelines for the main heroes. And if you follow the games and the time patrol stuff then we're around 6 if you just want to shove all of GT and the movies into one section.
I'm pretty sure the timeline stuff was explained pretty succinctly with Dragon Ball Super, with time travel creating branching timelines. Each one has its own Time Ring, to help show just how many timelines there are. And, normally, the Kais and the Gods of Destruction can make alterations without creating a new branch... but that was NOT the case with Black since, at the time, he was wearing the Time Ring, meaning that he was basically immune to changes in the timeline, meaning that his existence simply became another branching path instead of him being retconned out of possibility. This fits with Whis' actions in order to make sure Future Trunks could go back home to his 'timeline', even if things would be vastly different.
@@LordTyph I thought I remember seeing that Goku Black only survived because he wore the time ring and because of Beerus’s intervention that timeline where he killed Chichi and Goten was “aborted”. Goku Black basically exists outside of “time and space”, a paradox of some sort. I wonder what would’ve happened if somehow his ring got removed, would he just blip out of existence? The anime did seem to imply heavily that the ring was the reason he still existed like you mentioned. Unfortunately that also brings into question of their ethereal form they took when Future Trunks used his spirit sword. You could say that the mortal Goku Black was finally killed with the spirit sword and the ethereal form was just the immortal Zamasu. In the end I don’t understand why the arc ended how it did with a Future Mai and Future Trunks that exist as survivors of a completely annihilated timeline/ multiverse. Perhaps it may have been better to basically have Zeno intervene and destroy Goku Black since the very beginning before he killed Gowasu. Basically the story never happened at all but we as the viewers know it happened, heck Goku and friends could’ve been allowed to know what happened. But I guess either the editors or Toriyama wanted to make a leeway to make Time Patrol Trunks happen should they ever want to do so.
@@_.El._ 1. He was caught off guard. 2. I've heard theories that Trunks used the shutdown remote on 17 and 18 instead of training to defeat them, which would explain why he was so weak.
I would like to assume that because of Cell’s creation of Timeline 5, Timelines 2 and 3 are erased completely and their Green Time Rings no longer exist, basically resetting the timelines to 5, allowing for the four Green Time Rings in Dragonball Super. Thoughts??
@@suiyeethepinkunicorn7780 well, GT is after Goku retires so, after Super. if you want to count it as canon since it was entirely an anime, not written by Toriyama, but entirely different people so at that point either A. GT is in a timeline all on its own where the events of Super did not happen or B. GT piggybacks off of the end of Super where things realign. Pan is a teenager now, Uub is under Goku's wings (we know Uub is canon to Super btw). also, i believe GT Trunks is Kid Trunks, meaning that Future Trunks is just chilling with his double
I say there’s 7 Timelines 1.5th Timeline: Universe 12s split timeline where the 1st Time Machine is made and destroyed (also the Universe 12 Time Machine is also destroyed) 1st Timeline: Universe 12s original timeline which has The timeline where Cell kills 1st Future Trunks and goes back in time 2nd Timeline: The timeline where 1st Future Trunks gives Goku the Heart Virus Medicine 3rd Timeline: Our Future Trunks’s timeline 4th Timeline: The (So-called) Main timeline where the Cell Saga and everything until the GB Saga and then Future Present Zamasu goes 1 year ahead with the Time Ring and steals Goku’s Body then goes back to the Future Present and then hops to the 3rd Timeline 5th Timeline: after Future Trunks goes back in time in the Main Timeline by mistake in an attempt to get help from the past to stop Goku Black and Beerus erases Zamasu stopping the second Goku Black creation 6th Timeline: Future Trunks and Mai’s new timeline where they live with themselves Edit: 7th Timeline DBGT lol
Late reply I know but How could 1st future trunks give goku the heart medicine if he was killed by cell, wouldn’t that create a paradox creating a new timeline?
@@holdthefridge The Trunks That Cell Killed Already Traveled Back In Time, When He Got Caught Off Guard By Cell He Was Planning To Tell The Z Warriors How He Defeated The Androids, That Is The Whole Reason Cell Even Wanted To Time Travel, Because Future Trunks(Cell) Already Destroyed Them
These alternate timelines are exactly what all the stories in the millions of games SHOULD be, but no, instead we get to fight Raditz for the millionth fucking time.
One alteration I'd make to your video: The Trunks from Timeline 1 that wound up in timeline 4 likely never went into the Hyperbolic Time Chamber to train. What had been theorized to have happened is that he found the Android blueprints in Gero's lab and Bulma created the device to shut them down, which he used in his timeline. I say this because had he gone into the HTC he would have been more than powerful enough to kill Cell like we saw in the anime.
So fun fact: there WAS a time travel event when Zamasu killed his master. That was Whis' do-over ability. Even though it was just the 5 seconds, they traveled back and made a change in those 5 seconds. So now we have to add on a timeline break for every time Whis has used this ability in the cannon! That's an extra 2 at a minimum, as he alludes to using it from before the Golden Freeza arc and ALSO uses it DURING the Golden Freeza arc! So it's not that gods killing gods creates new timelines, it's that Whis is just using Beerus as a scapegoat for his own misdeeds
You have it all wrong lol. Temporal do over does not go back in the past, it literally REWINDS time, meaning Whis’s ability fully rewinds time as if it never happened. I’m sure grand minister it took extra precaution to give angels this ability, I’m sure he was smart enough to prevent more timelines appearing lol
@@moeej6809 This is never specified as being the case. I'm inclined to think you are correct. It would make sense that given time branches are considered aberrations, the ability to lop off undesirable chronological outcomes would be totally consistent with the role of an angel.
A few problems with this: 1. Someone in the comments below stated that Trunks legitimately waited 3 Years before Going Back to Timeline 3. This makes the Total Amount of Timelines to 7 as this happens twice. 2. When Beerus erases Zamasu out of existence it causes a new timeline due to the fact that he had obtained new information through a time traveling Goku and Vegeta, which wouldn't have been known otherwise. In the Timeline Zamasu Doesn't Get Erased but Goku and Vegeta does time travel in he is more than likely the Goku Black who somehow survived the time paradox, thus allowing the continuation of his existence, as Beerus was 100% sure that he got rid of Zamasu, not expecting that another timeline Goku Black could exist and repeat everything and not get erased.
1: trunks didn't wait 3 years, that would've made him 20 when he came back, which doesn't work (he ages in the time chamber and comes out taller, and people don't keep growing into their 20s, including saiyans). 2 edit: originally i said Beerus didn't create a new timeline when he erased Zamasu, but the manga and anime explicitly say he did. oopsies. bad writing :(
Corn boi Whis directly states Beerus created a new timeline too when he destroyed Zamasu. Of course he did, the original timeline from that part of the story would have ended up with Zamasu stealing Goku’s body, killing him and going to Trunks’ timeline, continuing the time loop. How Beerus was able to break the timeloop in our timeline is a plothole, because everything that happened in our timeline should have happened originally as well; in Black’s timeline it seems like Goku and Beerus just stopped investigating Black’s mystery for whatever reason, and Trunks just went home or something, which is why Zamasu had a chance to steal Goku’s body and Goku was just farming again when the body swap happened. That doesn’t make sense though obviously because there was no changing factor in our timeline as to why Beerus killed Zamasu in our timeline but not in Black’s. They screwed up
A plausible plug for that green ring pot hole is; a ring exists for every timeline that directly connects to the timeline in which the rings exist. Thus, as there is 5 rings, that means that 5 other timelines have interacted with the one in which we see the 'main timeline' take place. It is entirely possible that in the future trunks timeline there are more green rings that exist, due to more timelines interacting with that one. This allows for the theoretical infinite timelines concept.
My theory is that one of those timelines eventually led up to trunks being recruited as a time patroller by chronoa and since then they have been working to fix all the timeline mess created by the time machine in different points of time, with the green time rings being just the more recent ones they haven't tackled yet, or the ones created by god's mistakes like what Beerus did, which she's probably not allowed to mess with
I always just figured that if you time travel to a date after the most recent time travel that happened in your timeline, you would end up in the same timeline without causing a new split, while if you go to a date before the most recent time travel, you still would go back to the same timeline, but you'd cause a new split (and depending on certain circumstances, a split in your own timeline as well), and the new timeline that you appeared in would now be the one you travel to, with any time travelers that appeared in that timeline after you coming from any timeline that split off from your own. It made sense to me, anyway. As for the aborted futures... yeah, I got no fricking clue. However, I will say, I think the reason why Beerus killing Zamasu created a new timeline was simply because it was simply a change in history, even if Trunks didn't directly cause it.
I know it’s a year late but yeah that’s it, a new timeline isn’t created just by travelling back in time it’s only created when a change in history is made it creates a paradox example, future trunks coming to timeline 1 during the goku black arc doesn’t do anything it’s only when beerus hakai’s zamasu that’s it creates a paradox and so a new timeline is created timeline 6 which is where zamasu is alive and successfully becomes goku black
Trunks never travels through time - What he does and did is a dimensional jump . Thinks sideways rather than front- back . He states this when Berus and who’s take goku to universe kami from goku black universe. When he goes back to defeat the androids he is still alone . He also says he already defeated boo he says in black storyline
My headcannon to explain this is that if you break a timeline you destroy a timeline. Which means the universe 10 destroyer erased a hell of a bunch of timelines for an entire month and was left with 4 and was just like... "well they don't seem to be duplicating anymore... guess the problem is solved!" Like I bet he did it to hide the other timelines out of shame but it just caused them all to stop existing.
The first main problem you mention is that Trunks going back in time, then FORWARD in time again, creating another alternate reality. Based off of how the rings vs time machines work, isn't there the implication that traveling BACK in time creates a branched reality, but traveling FORWARD in time doesn't? For instance, if I travel travel 10 minutes into the future, there is still only one timeline: one where I disappear and reappear 10 minutes later. There is no alternate timeline where I never got into the machine, and did not reappear in 10 minutes. To create THAT branched reality, I'd have to go back in time AFTERWARDS to go and stop myself from getting into the time machine.
No Going in to the Future in a Multiverse Theory timeline just makes a new Timeline as well since time can’t be rewritten it would just make a new Timeline where you were not around
Nice tackle I'm a very big time-travel nerd and have been analyzing so many my whole life. New mindsets ahdm perspectives have lead to various disgrams for several franchises. Writers for time travel very rarely get all their ducks in a row. The multi-timelines and doorway mechanic is one of most solid out there. It counters most paradoxes. There are some specific mechanics that need decided and certainly some for the base story narrative. Info-dumps of super complex concepts are hard to fight in. Especially when your base story and audience is all about "punchy-fighty beat em up" arcs. The "infinite spaghetti", as I call it, is a tricky one to fix or gloss over and ignore. There certainly were more timelines rendered by all the old Z setting. Fitting them in narratively def is a passing issue even if they were thought of. A mechanic I considered Trunks to have is a "history / destination" log in the time machine. Allowing for a revisiting of a past location. Basically reopening of the doorway. But as for my normal models, any revisit to a past does spawn a new branch. I personally have thought about a whole channel discussing all this and for each franchise. I'm def open to compare models. :)
This becomes even worse when you think about the time Goku time traveled to meet young master roshi and THE OTHER TIME where him and trunks time traveled to meet a younger version of Goku.
11:30 is never mention that Cell changed the time machine date. When Picoolo asked him why did he selected this timeline he simple answered that he did not know, the machine was already set up to appear on his era.
@@QuickPlaysHD Yeah, and despite who Cell is, I wouldn't say it is in his nature to lie about such a thing... So it really doesn't make sense... Could be that because there was already a time machine in that exact time already and Trunks didn't realize he should change the time. Maybe the machine automatically goes back a bit of time to as a glitchy fix... I guess?
You can change the date without severing the link so long as it is any time after your original visit. Trunks creates one new timeline when he kills Frieza and Cold and then returns to it. Cell then makes a new one when he goes farther back then Trunks did. Because of this everything with your timeline 3 model is off. I'm glad that people still try to figure stuff like this out though!
But beerus said when gods destroy someone they completely destroy them in drangon ball super so if the man who original created time travel device was killed by a god of destruction of some one like that wouldn't it mean he was completely destroyed including the alternate timeline versions of him
@@joster6268but in that alternate time line zamasu had surpassed beerus power and the only one who could bring him down was the omni king. he also killed the supreme kai of his universe and replaced him making himself a supreme kai (god of creation). And because he's a supreme kai his life is tied to the new god of destruction who would probably not let him die. So i don't think zamasu' situation is comparable.
@Ethan Kellerman no they don’t Goku Black was just lacking the knowledge of the Time Rings Beerus just wanted Trunks to F Off from his timeline and everyone else was just Gullible enough to believe him
@DatrixTSW2012 Whis is wrong Future Trunks made that Timeline when he traveled back in time since he accidentally went back almost a year to before Zamasu started his 0 Mortal Plan
idk anymore it just doesn't make sense cause the trunks from history of trunks came back to where Android 19's head was blown up by Vegeta's big bang attack instead of that one timeline you talked about where Goku is already dead from the virus
the thing is.. 17 and 18 arrived so late in the present/main timeline where it matches Trunk's 3 year return and Goku's late heart virus so everything in the present comes late because trunks created a new timeline
Awesome video bro. I just came across you channel and I love the content. To see you that dedicated and break down every possible scenario is amazing and you definitely deserve a lot of credit for the time taking to make this video.
13:30 here's the part where I think you got some stuff wrong. When Imperfect Cell went back in time in Timeline 5 he probably had to have gotten killed by the Androids. The Androids had already killed so many people meaning Cell couldn't absorb enough power so when he attempted to absorb the Androids he probably ended up getting Clapped by Android 16. The Androids still ruin the timeline so the Trunks from Timeline 5 goes to Timeline 6 and the same Trunks goes 3 extra years into the future to create Timeline 7. Because Imperfect Cell from Timeline 1 had gone to Timeline 5 and the Future Trunks from Timeline 5 created Timelines 6 and 7; then that means there would be a new version of Imperfect Cell in Timelines 6 and 7, almost as if he was cloned due to time travel. Future Trunks wasn't the one without a home timeline. It was these 2 different versions of Timeline 1 Cell. This version of Cell believes he's from Timeline 1 but actually doesn't have a home timeline. Hopefully this makes sense.
@@alexisislas-gonzalez5991 Not trying to fix the "7 Timelines" stuff. Just tryna make the whole Cell Time Travel thing in the Original Anime/Manga actually make sense.
Not finished yet, but I’ve gotta say: your idea of timeline 7 being the origins of Goku Black makes SO much more sense than the canon explanation. It’s still kinda convoluted, but it works so much better than “time ring makes me immune to having my past changed.”
Now I know what I'm missing for Xenoverse 3 (and why we may never get it): - Instead of revisiting the events of X1 like X2 did for the most part, you're staged to address the Temporal Seams that the Breaker Civilians are currently handling and being trapped in. -- The alternate branching timelines that have blossomed due to time-travel will be the explored scenarios that have more story fleshed out, rather than being reduced to mere Quests you get graded for. --- We potentially have the ground to explore an entirely different arc, due to these Seams' issues. ---- It can also be assumed that the Seams are a result of trying to over-correct these tears and changes in reality, which is why people across the multiverse are being independently being sucked into a concentrated point involving a Raider, whose presence demanded the creation of a time-machine in the first place. I know this is a bit of a convenient stretch, but considering time-travel is now one of the biggest behind-the-scenes factors that drives the creation of more Dragonball content, I'd certainly prefer to have something that 'branches off' from X1/X2 rather than going through all of those events for a third goddang time.
I like the unintended conclusion you draw that if Future Trunks had just stayed away from our timeline after the first time that everything in the main story basically would have been better off. Trunks went back again to ensure he’d made that timeline better, and instead ensured that everyone in it eventually got killed by Majin Buu. I mean, luckily, they all got wished back, but still.
Gonna stop at 8:27. You aren't one to talk about not making any sense. For starters, there isn't any rule stated about how multiple trips make a secure connection, that is just something you came up with. It can be logically concluded that in actuality, it is only when the Time Machine is first used. Nothing in the main Canon goes against that and only supports it. Future Trunks only moves between his own and the one he first goes back to. The Trunks we meet was never destined to be defeated by Cell either. This is due to the fact that Cell had already returned when Trunks first beat Frieza, changing the future of that Timeline.
Wasn’t it stated that the Trunks from the timeline Cell came from, stopped the androids by using the shutdown controller or whatever? He never went through all the training and fought them, he just turned them off or whatever. That’s why he wasn’t strong enough to stop Cell.
He also didn’t mention cells timeline had a future trunks in it that killed the frieza in that timeline meaning cells timeline can’t be the original at best it can be the 2nd oldest timeline or first divergence. If anything it’s that trunks who traveled to cells timeline who has the original timeline
This is all predicated on the assumption that the time machine creates a new timeline EVERY time it travels, when in reality it only does so when there is a significant change in circumstances for the timeline. Hence, we only have 3 timelines in Z and 3 additional in Super. The main story, Trunks', Cell's, Goku Black's originating line, OG Zamasu's before he got Hakai'd and the one Goku Black created from travelling to Trunks' which we see in Super and which is reset out of existence with his life in the end of the arc.
There are many errors here. First, after Trunks kills Freeza and warns Goku, he doesnt go back home to check things up. Because Bulma already knew she couldnt change her timeline. Trunks specifically says that he got back to find a way to defeat the androids. So after giving Goku the medicine, he travels 3 years into that timeline future, now, this would be lets say in timeline 2, timeline one, being where Goku and all the Z warriors die. In this time line, they defeat the androids by using the schematics they found on Dr Gero lab, then Trunks go back to his timeline, and defeats the androids there, so when Cell wakes up, there are no androids to complete his perfect body. This Trunks never trained with Vegeta, since they had no need to, so he isnt able to defeat Cell. Cell kils him steals his machine and goes back, thus creating timeline 3. Now here we have that since he travel to a point Trunks was in the past, he starts changing that Trunks story, so this is Trunks 2, the first one being the one who trains with Gohan, destroys the androids, then dies at Cell´s hands, this one who will train with Vegeta, withness Gohan kill Cell, goes back to his timeline, kills 17 & 18 and then kills Cell, this would be another Cell. And how do the Trunks go back to their timeline, after having make alterations in the past? To travel in time is to travel in space, this is a reality in our universe, and Im pretty sure in the DB universe too, as when Trunks activates the time machine at the end of the Warriors of the Future Special, you can see the time machine traveling through space. So there is no magic point created betwen the points of time travel, and Trunks didnt wait 3 years to go back, other wise we would have seen him getting bigger, as he did after a year with Vegeta, lets remember he is just 16, so years do matter a lot. The time machine, simply have a way to return home, to its one timeline, but when going back, it creates a divergent, thats why we can have two future Trunks, one that dies at Cell and one that kills him.
It's stated by Trunks in the manga that it takes time for the time machine to get enough fuel to travel. So Trunks likely did wait and not make a 4th timeline. The whole idea of time travel is confusing when you focus on all the details. But your theory of *TM1* Trunks going to *TM3* [the DB we know about] and thus making a link between those timelines seems to be legitimate. So lets go from there. If the *TM1* time machine created a link to *TM3,* then it wouldn't matter that *TM1* Trunks went back to his time and chose a later date. Because they are already linked. I can't speculate if the link is due to a program that Bulma may have created, or if it was a natural outcome of the initial time travel. But either way, it seems to be the case because Trunks waited until he had enough fuel to do it again. Perhaps he waited for 3 years. I believe that to be the case, because in the manga, before he left, Goku asked if they will meet again. Trunks says something to the effect of "not sure. It takes a lot of time to gather fuel for a round trip in the time machine. If I'm still alive, I'll help in 3 years." Imperfect Cell wouldn't be strong enough to kill Trunks after going into the room of spirit and time. The Trunks that was killed would have had to be one that didn't use that room. We know this because that Cell, in his stronger semi-perfect form, was beaten by a Trunks who only used the room once at that point in the series. I re-read the VIZ translation of the manga and watched the subbed episode where Cell is explaining to Piccolo how he got there. It seems Cell didn't travel back 4 years like many people think. He traveled back 3 years. And (thanks to plot) it only takes him 3 years to mature from his egg form to the form he took while fighting Piccolo. At the same time this is contradicted by Trunks because he says the old time machine arrived 1 whole year before he got there and it came from 3 years after he left to the past. Damn it, Toriyama! I'll admit that I'm not completely familiar with Super as I am with Z but are the different universes interchangeable to timelines? I think I missed that explanation in the series. From what I know of the Black saga, whatever timeline future Trunks is in, that timeline has 12 universes. And Black killed the 12 kais in those timeline locked universes. What smells like copper?
I agree with this theory more than the video. I believe Trunks does wait before going back and that the timelines are just linked somehow. And that’s what Toriyama intended so I’m happy to go with that. But as a Z stan I won’t even begin to conjecture about Super since nothing about that series has proper incentive to be canonically consistent after 20+ years. It’s fan service imo. Krillin took on an SSGSS Kamehameha. I’m not interested.
At first it seemed like a Grand Fathers paradox "each new action taken in the past produces a new alternate reality/time line" now it's what we can officially call a fuster cluck.
I was using that theory to try and figure this out, and I actually thought I solved it. But I forgot the minor detail of Goku having to fight Zamasu for Zamasu to become Goku Black, which wouldn't have happened if Trunks didn't already travel back in time to ask for help to beat Goku black who randomly appeared in his future. This shit makes no fucking sense...
Just one last thing This is the reason Why There over infinite timelines to the point of rick and morty different dimesions/timelines maybe less then this
To be honest, I was following up until the first Future Trunks bit where he creates timeline 4 in an attempt to get back to timeline 3, as I was under the assumption that he had waited three years and then returned ( -of course that brings to question how he survived three more years in his apocalyptic future with murder androids but yeah- )And even as you assumed he somehow got back to timeline 3, I thought that would count as a return trip, seeing as he already went there once before, therefore not causing a split. I thought that was the very thing you were assuming didn’t happen, and that’s what confuses me.
He caused a split because one timeline cell is in and one timeline he's not in .at least what I thought.but this means that a perfect cell is still probably alive fighting space aliens because 1 timeline he succeeded.
That's also not counting GT Trunks. It would be cool if all three versions of Trunks were to meet each other. Kid Trunks, Future Trunks and GT Trunks could meet and they could fuse into one person. This Trunks would have all of the memories of all three timelines.
Idk what to think. I really love your ideas and how you wanna explain this. But maybe you should get with quaman he is another dragontuber that did a timeline explanation. It would be nice to see that.
I’m just gonna share my opinion on this. There is technically five canon timelines in Dragon Ball The first timeline is where “First Future Trunks” is killed by Imperfect Cell. That trunks goes to the Second Timeline called the “Unseen timeline” because we never see it, however DBM covered this. In this timeline, Kami refuses to let the Z-fighters into the hyperbolic Time chamber because the androids haven’t done anything wrong. Bulma creates a remote to shut down the androids permanently. This is given to Trunks, which he takes back to the first timeline I referenced. The third timeline is where we the viewers follow future trunks we all know and love. His future is the same as the timeline 1. The fourth timeline is where we follow the Z-Fighters, and main story takes place. After, killing timeline 1 Trunks, Cell arrives in this timeline. The fifth timeline is where Zamasu killed The universe seven supreme Kai, and therefor, creating another timeline.
@SlappyTheClappy Sorry, to clarify, I mean travel like Trunks' second trip to the timeline. For example, the link want fully established between his timeline and the new one, so he was able to kinda use that same bridge but change the date he came out of by a couple years since the dates were relatively close and the rip in the space time continuum is also relatively new.
@@Kyleand3rror Then the story could not have happened the way it did as you would need to somehow have 2 trunks in the same timeline, one to die to Cell and one to travel forward in time to fight Cell.
@3:13 there's also Towa and the Supreme Kai of Time [cronoa] [both of which use magic to travel via timelines, scrolls for kai, dark/deamon magjc for towa and mira]
Zeni, the dude that created all universes and can watch all timeliness, has stated an ability to intervene if something happens to alter his story significantly enough. he refers to this timeline as timeline one, regardless of whether it's timeline 7 or not. so my theory is that he wiped out all of the timelines that splintered off of timeline one, splicing events from the different timelines on to timeline one to make an interesting story, and that only five green Rings exist because those are the only timelines that did not alter the story significantly enough to need intervention.
I thought that there was five timelines because of the regular timeline, future, Cells timeline where he kill trunks first, Zamasu Timeline, and then the timeline where Freitas blows up earth in RoF
I always took it that changing the date you want to time-travel to only creates a new timeline when the date is earlier than that you have prievously travelled to. Therefore, Future Trunks showing up three years later after killing Freeza and King Cold would not create a new Timeline, but Cell stealing his Time Machine and arriving earlier would. I also noticed a small hole in your explanation, you said that Trunks would go into the Room of Spirit and Time and grow strong enough to defeat 17 and 18, but he was still weak enough to be killed by Imperfect Cell, plus, his appearance does not have its post-ROSAT look.
Yeah, the moment he mentioned that date change is what causes timelines to split, I knew his 25 timeline theory seemed ridiculous. From what we have seen, only traveling to the past of a timeline is what causes a timeline to split. We have never seen traveling to the future of one causing a split since time technically flowed normally without any changes to the past. The idea that 12 timelines are created by killing each Supereme Kai of Time is pretty ridiculous as well, since by his logic, the moment Future Trunks' Supreme Kai was killed, a new timeline would be created for no reason.
The video fails at that point,cell never changed the date and trunks did not train to beat his androids, he used the remote controller, and after get ambushed by cell
I actually came back to this video(apparently after two years) and I really just wanted to say that there's actually ANOTHER timeline! In the Manga, Cell states he gets Frieza and King Cold's cells and there's a flashback panel of them dying by ANOTHER Future Trunks. In the anime he talks about it and specifically says a Future Trunks kills Frieza and King Cold. Meaning THAT FUTURE TRUNKS traveled INTO CELL'S timeline and then went BACK to his own! So theoretically, in the "original timeline", Goku killed Frieza and King Cold, Androids wipe out the Z Fighters, Trunks goes to CELL'S TIMELINE, comes back with the bomb blueprints to blow up Android 17 and 18, and possibly dies from the Cell of HIS TIMELINE! The thing is, HIS CELL wouldn't travel through time, because if he did he'd be in FUTURE CELL'S timeline and become perfect, co-existing with another unborn Cell and ruling that timeline!
Actually, time travel in Dr. Slump DOES count, since both Gatchans appeared in both the Red Ribbon Army Saga and Episode 69 of DBS. So consider all these timelines doubled AT LEAST
Lets say timeline 3 is the timeline with the movies while timeline four is GT’s timeline. It makes as much sense as the infinite loops
Well, the Movies and GT are the same timeline.
Go watch the Super 17 Arc. When the news on the TV shows villains attacking the city from Hell, you see Cooler in the crowd, thus canonizing the movies.
@@Kaptain_Wario that's exactly what I was saying.
@@Kaptain_Wario ok I will admit you are right. At least the Cooler movies. And going a bit farther into that Vegeta knowing the Fusion Dance could link up Fusion Reborn. And Wrath of the Dragon could link up to GT as well considering in GT Trunks has the same sword he got at the end of the movie. The other movies though I’m not sure.
One of the movie timelines stops after Lord Slug anyways since the Cooler movies basically demand the events on Namek play out as they did in the show whereas the timeline up until Lord Slug demands it must have played out differently, mainly with Piccolo surviving the saiyan invasion arc.
@@MrZer093 And Goku not hospitalized
11:32 There is a huge correction here. In this timeline the show and manga state Cell states that Trunks had turned off the androids using the remote. This means that it isn't necessarily a Trunks that went through the Time Chamber Training, especially if it was then there is no way Cell could have sneaked up on him. Cell even said that the Trunks he took out was weaker.
I really feel bad for Bulma in that timeline
Also the video uploaded said cell changed the date. However, in the show, cell tells piccolo he didn’t change the date. It was preset by trunks
The thing I never got was why did bulma not leave that timeline,if so bad
@@MrShaiya96while this is true, this also opens the following question:
So Cell didnt change the date of the time machine, yet he still arrives before the Androids are awakened. Why would Trunks go there? He already warned the Z fighters about the androids
@@MT-oo5zc a bit late but maybe he thought "Oh, wait, wouldn't be better if I time travelled before earlier ?"
but this is just a crappy theory
The trunks killed by cell was actually the 3rd trip into the past. Trunks was going back to tell him the z fighters how to beat the androids so that implies multiple timelines can connect to multiple different timelines.
This is even worse ig, cause you can have infinite plots
It's not supposed to 😂thou it's supposed to split
@@doppiovinegaro3525 it had already been confirmed that the future trunks that we first see is not the same trunks that meets the Z fighters 3 years later.
@@kanewilson8624confirm this with a source?
I seem to recall in DragonBall xenoverse there was mentioned that the time-line split actually happened because of a flaw in the time machine method/design. This was "fixed" so timeliness could no longer split when the time machines were used to handle time fragments (parralel quests) that spawned from fixing the time-line in the scrolls of eternity. Even tough it is not cannonical to the anime/manga ot is something interesting to take note of.
When was this I've dedicated myself to completing the entire story and all side story's and events but haven't seen this mentioned I want to know if I missed something or forget?
@@IAmBored654 I vaguely remember this too I dont remember when it was maybe the goku black dlc story idk
This gets even more complicated because Kakarot is stated to be canon and since Towa/Mira show up this could imply that Xenoverse is canon and...
That makes no sense. The time machine was creating an entirely other universe and then traveling there but further back in time? That's pretty nonsensical.
@@seansquiers6506 I remember someone asking akira if xenoverse was canon, and the guy said it was, just happens at the very end of the timeline
I just spent a whole hour bingeing your work back-to-back and it was a real treat to see someone so dedicated to the franchise, while implementing some really good editing! All the best to you and and I hope that you continue to make quality content like this for even more people to discover.
Hey, thank you! This comment made a hard day a little easier. I'm working on some more stuff for the channel and hope to have it up soon!
ThePark 627 did they do something specific that I missed or do you just mean the endless clickbait of little substance that plagues Dragon Ball UA-cam?
Either way, thank you so much! I’ve got some cool DB videos in the pipeline that I hope you’ll like!
@@SpellCommander91 hey brother, where did all of your Yu-Gi-Oh! Fan theories go? I was trying to show them to a buddy tonight and couldn't find them anymore. Did they get deleted or something else?
@@robinkern926 my channel came under attack for Copyright by Nihan Ad Systems, a company that represents the studio that produced Duel Monsters through VRAINS. I'm in the process of getting them sorted. Hopefully they'll be back soon.
@@SpellCommander91 oh snap. That's not cool. I'm guessing this is probably along with the same wave like the people getting strikes due to DBZ stuff or the likes.
You got this bro. Keep up the amazing work. Your theories really made me think and I can't wait to hear them again and more. You'll overcome this one dude!!! You got this.
"How many trunks does it take to screw a Goku black"
This should be a meme
That was Whis’ plan the entire time
Me: Oh hey a DB Timeline Video Neat.
*Also Me* : THERE'S *25* ???
It u played UT there's more.
@@ohmyoof3pizzaman205 What does Undertale have to do with Dragonball?
@@DragoSonicMile MULTIVERSE!
The thing is timeline 4 didn’t happen, because trunks DID wait 3 years to go back, that’s why the Z fighters Recognize him! And even though this is technically the original and unseen timeline and not the Main and HOT (history of trunks) timeline we can assume that the original and HOT trunks would behave the same way
And because of that trunks curious on how the timeline era's will play and that is the born of the time patrol in the game
Actually he didn't, he simply uses his time machine to go 3 years later but for him it was like a week later, or else we would've seen trunks be 20 when he returned and yet he was still 17 and turns 18 when he trains with vegeta in the time chamber
Evidence to back up your claim?
“Hot Trunks” 💀
Actually, no.
If memory serves me, Trunks explains to Goku on his original trip to the past that it will take him six months to get the machine fueled for another round trip. He then proceeds to say that he'll join them again on the day the Androids show up "if I'm still alive."
So, no. Trunks did NOT wait three years to make a return trip. He did however have to wait six months just to be able to do it.
Take a year for fuel.so he must of left after a year to another date
Sorry for not mentioning but this is a super informative and researched video. Thank you for your hard work
Hopefully in the future chapters, the Supreme Kais realize, "Whoops, we forgot another box with 20 more rings."
I have a few theories on how the time rings can be correct, though they are a bit shaky and require some fan-justification
Theory 1: Changing the date only severs the link if you change it to be earlier than what you already have it set to, this allows timeline 4 and 7 to not be neccesary 7 - 2 = 5, which matches the number of time rings, this would track considering the time rings don't split reality as they only allow you to go forward in time.
Theory 2: The whole gods killing eachother thing doesn't break time, what happened is the timeline already split when Goku, Vegeta, and Trunks learned about their timeline's future, splitting it into a reality where Zamasu enacted his plan, and one where Zamasu got hakai'd by beerus, under this assumption, Beerus was not responsible in any capacity for the creation of another timeline, and it had already happened by the time beerus went to destroy Zamasu.
So what we have with this logic is
Theory 3: The time ring prevented Zamasu's future from being aborted, this is the direct cause of the timeline split that created timeline 6.
Timeline 1: Cell's Origin Timeline (Timeline 1)
Timeline 2: Future Trunks Timeline (Timeline 2) (Theory 2 Dictates that this timeline doesn't get split 12 times)
Timeline 3: Original Present Timeline (Timeline 4) (Theory 1 Prevents another split here)
Timeline 4: Cell's Perfect Timeline (Timeline 5) (Theory 1 would not prevent any split here as Cell & Trunks are seperate time travellers in seperate time machines)
Timeline 5: Dragon Ball Z/Black Timeline ("Aborted" Timeline 8) (Theory 1 Prevents another split here, Theory 3 prevents this timeline getting aborted)
Timeline 6: Dragon Ball Super timeline (Timeline 8) (Theory 2 Dictates that this timeline doesn't get aborted)
EDIT: I'm assuming Trunks coming back during the Goku black arc is a return trip to an already linked timeline.
exactly what i was thinking
I see dragon ball super and dragon ball gt as two timelines that were the result of universe 12s time travel thus creating the first timeline split ( the rest of the events are exactly the same upto the defeat of Majin buu) then we have bulmas time machine and trunks time traveling creating more splits within these split time lines
I would like to add 2 more actually
Gt timeline : where either shin died and beerus never woke up { but this also a buyback theory Where Goku never got revived by old Kai so this theory denies it)
Second beerus never woke up or he slept just enough time so that he wakes up after Goku goes with shenron (and Vegeta kinda retires idk like I haven't seen gt and other sagas except last one really don't matter )
Time line 10:::: the DBZ movies saga
Where Basically some random trunks from a universe where it really stayed same (excluding dbs broly and super hero happens they don't )
It could also be another way of gt timeline but idk
basically, they just invent timelines to keep the franchise going...
This was advertisement I clicked 🤷♂️
auslatino89 same
“Wasn’t it cool that one time trunks made a lightsaber out of human souls?”
*WHEN YOU PUT IT LIKE THAT-*
I applaud the effort that went into this video, it took me watching this 7-8 times to get what u were saying, my brain is now jelly. Good job dude
So odds are, what Whis did was take a more nuaced approach involving the God-on-God violence to take things in a direction to prevent the infinite loops. Beerus likely just did it wrong, or the infinite loop thing/timeline thing is just to ward off God-on-God violence, because that actually sounds like a viable defensive measure.
waiiiiit, if timeline 7 is the real timeline and goku is in Universe 7, that means toriyama did know what he was doing.
This confirm the fact that toiyama has an IQ of 9000.
Edit: I made this joke half way through the video and now after finishing this video I know now this shits confusing.
No, Toriyama has an iq of 9001
i feel that some one has been wooshed
@@novadestroyerthesundestroy890 I feel like someone has been wooshed*
1st rule of Mr popos training do not talk about Mr popos training
Smile
blame toriyama for fucked up story( confusin people)
I know it his fucked up story.
actually future kakarot has died with heart virus remember.
The history of trunks.
Super?? Doesn't make sense.
Father of kakarot is Canon too.
New movie doesn't make sense.
Baby kakarot was sent to earth never mention about armor??
Explain dis
When it comes to zamasu and goku black, I think they went on a cathartic rampage and that's why they destroyed the mortal population themselves instead of using the dragon to do it.
Given that planet-busting can be done with a flick of a finger in this series, them giving Earth special attention due to it being Goku's homeworld and the source of time travel makes sense. There is absolutely *no* reason for them to be taking so much time with it other than "Because they want to". Trunks was in no position to stop them at the start so it wasn't like they *needed* him dead to pop the Earth like a balloon.
@@manwithaplan5503 "Earth invented time travel beforehand" also explains the entire weird-planet thing Earth has going on. We have no evidence that anyone ever used the Dragon Balls to resurrect dinosaurs or make dogs rule the world, but that sounds exactly like what humans inventing time travel world do.
my head canon is that they had already taken out the rest of the universes and left universe 7 for last, as a sort of dessert
Brilliant video. Bottom line is it becomes incredibly difficult not to explain it away into infinite universes. Even future trunks says (in super) that a different amount of time has passed in his timeline- likely indicating to us that this is a different future trunks and that we deal with a different future trunks every single time he uses the machine.
Well yeah, his hair changed color. Blue Trunks is obviously not the same guy as Purple Trunks.
@@PosthumanHeresy what makes you think it isn’t a hair dye?
@@fuckinhateryan are you being serious or are you joking I can’t tell
I think your correct because because the trunks in super was the same trunks but different at same time. It could easily be trunks from android 13 or Bojack saga even thou it not cannon it's showing a different timelines trunks .from Brolly,Bojack,trunks.movies means some event did not happen
Universe 12 creates a time loop, thus causing Dragon Ball Multiverse
It doesn't, the kaioshin of u12 confiscated the time machine thus negating the risk of creating a time loop
No thanks.
@@ShadowMarcus77 that’s stopped in one timeline but who’s to stop the other timeline version from trying again
But that’s only in the manga. Which isn’t the canon events
Uhh, no. The DBS manga is the one Toriyama considered as the OFFICIAL continuation of his original story. Even Broly and Super Hero movies are more in line with the manga than they are with the anime. @@captainswagger2838
My personal headcanon as to why there are only 5 Time rings present (6 after Zamasu's death) is actually Xenoverse/Super Dragon Ball heroes/The Time Patrol.
The Time Patrol and the Supreme Kai of Time's job are to "Weed" alternate timelines down and adjust them to a point where they can be self-consistent with relation to each other.
This likely has something to do with the Time Scrolls and Toki Toki in how it is regulated, but the result is that whenever a timeline that is extraneous is born, Chronoa or the Time Patrol arrive and "reset" the timeline TVA-Style and maybe pick up allies from the timeline to join the Time Patrol, thus why we have Xeno Trunks and the Xeno GT versions of characters.
So with this assumption the 6 time rings at the end of the Goku Black arc are the result of Chronoa and the Time Patrol doing timeline spring cleaning of the Goku Black arc in order to keep things in line.
These 6 timelines likely are.
Timeline 1 (The Main Timeline)
Timeline 2 (The History of Trunks Timeline, erased then recreated with a timeline that takes its place with an extra Trunks and Mai in tow)
Timeline 3 (Cell's Timeline)
Timeline 4 (The Unseen Timeline, aka a timeline where Trunks arrives and helps Goku and pals out with no intervention from Cell)
Timeline 5 ( Universe 12 Time Machine Timeline, this timeline and Timeline 2 are conjoined as they are the two timelines with the U12 TIme machine as Infinite Zamasu in the manga stated that he found the U12 Time machine within Timeline 2, so Timeline 2 was split off of this incident)
Timeline 6 (Goku Black's *revised* Birth, with the Time Patrol and Chronoa making sure that the offshoot Goku Black from this timeline heads to Timeline 2 and properly becomes the genesis point of Goku Black in future occurrences of the loop as any potential timeline that would be offshoot in repeat loops are self-contained and erased, leaving space for a new timeline 6 to appear)
Excess timelines born from improperly done return trips or first entering of timelines are erased by the Time Patrol, with the order of events being
-Timeline 5 splits off timeline 2
-Timeline 3 continues from timeline 5 until Trunks travels back in time to make TImeline 4
-The link between Timeline 3 and 4 is locked in place by the time Patrol so Trunks does hop between the two timelines.
-Trunks is killed by Cell and cell takes his time machine to go to make Timeline 1
-Timeline 2's version of Trunks is guided to Timeline 1 either via how many timeline wounds there are throwing his time machine off course, or by the intervention of the Time Patrol.
-Timeline 1 and 2 are linked now and stay linked.
-Zamasu steals Goku's body after an unknown period of time in Timeline 1, becoming Goku Black heading over to Timeline 2 to recruit his counterpart there
-Trunks heads back to timeline 1 either via the lock-on tech Pilaf suggested or aid of the Time Patrol, this doesn't split the timeline likely due to the Time Patrol.
-The events of the Goku Black arc play out normally as Goku Black is self-consistent still due to his time ring.
-Beerus kills Zamasu, due to Timeline 1's future counterpart as Goku Black having his time ring on, it splits the timeline, birthing timeline 6 and erasing the future that would result in Timeline 1's Goku Black. (Calling the erased Future Timeline 1B)
-Timeline 6 Zamasu proceeds to reenact the events of Timeline 1B Zamasu, taking Goku's body and heading to Timeline 2
-Goku Black from Timeline 1/1B is actually erased as Beerus stated, but is replaced by the unintended Timeline 6 counterpart, thus solving that apparent paradox.
-Timeline 2 is erased by Zeno, destroying the time ring of that universe, only to be recreated by Whis time-traveling one more time, offshoot timelines born from this incident are handled and surpassed by the Time Patrol.
this one
You're forgetting timeline 7, the Z movies and GT timeline, and timeline 8, the Super Dragon ball heroes/xenoverse timeline
God I hate time travel.
mybe ou update tis as there mroe timelien out there goku black come back in hereos fireza ins emcha and alvie ina nther timeline so the androdi 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 in anther alos the fis kai of time prof this with her tourmn she siad there to many tiemlein and goku black sia dhe kileld 99 gokus o 99 timesline he want to
@@sebastienholmes548 DBZA explains it the best. Multiverse theory's a bitch 😂
That whole thing with all the trunks and mais is basically the rick and morty time traveling snake episode
Strangely this makes me wanna play Xenoverse again.
And they still making DLC for the sequel at least
@@halrun209plays5 bro I NOTICED! I was surprised there were so many updates when I got on 😆
Yeah but no hair changes, no new transformations, no different fighting styles nothing😢
@@dennisquiah7 yeah, it's time for a new game 😅
@@dennisquiah7 because that takes effort
This is purely incredible, I had myself asking where Trunk's timeline sits at a stupid time in the morning, I wrote it down and went back to sleep. Upon finding your video my mind has been obliterated with the amount of work that went into this. I am thankful but still none the wiser but knowing now of how many "possible" timelines has only left me with more questions.
Thank you for breaking this down more than DB ever did.
So I thought it was pretty well explained that once there's a link between the two timelines that's it. They can go between the two without creating a new timeline. Here's how I've always seen it. Timeline 1 is where Cell comes from. Timeline 2 follows the main timeline we see except Cell doesn't show up, so Trunks and Vegeta probably kill the androids after getting out of the time chamber, leaving Trunks to go back to timeline 1 where he gets killed. Timeline 3 is where Cell shows up, and is defeated by Gohan. Now Trunks goes off back to what would be timeline 1 but because of knowledge he didn't have before Cell created timeline 3, Trunks prevents his own death creating timeline 4, where Buu isn't released, he learns super saiyan 2 after seeing the supreme Kai die, and eventually Goku Black shows up because in timeline 5, an alternate to timeline 3, the guy that's trained by Gowasu uses the super dragon balls to become Black, kill Goku's family, and decides to hop between timelines and terrorizes Future Trunks world. I don't think Whis restoring Trunks world created or eliminated everything so we're at 5 timelines for the main heroes. And if you follow the games and the time patrol stuff then we're around 6 if you just want to shove all of GT and the movies into one section.
I'm pretty sure the timeline stuff was explained pretty succinctly with Dragon Ball Super, with time travel creating branching timelines. Each one has its own Time Ring, to help show just how many timelines there are. And, normally, the Kais and the Gods of Destruction can make alterations without creating a new branch... but that was NOT the case with Black since, at the time, he was wearing the Time Ring, meaning that he was basically immune to changes in the timeline, meaning that his existence simply became another branching path instead of him being retconned out of possibility. This fits with Whis' actions in order to make sure Future Trunks could go back home to his 'timeline', even if things would be vastly different.
How would Trunks getting out of the Chamber lose to Imperfect Cell ?🗿
@@LordTyph I thought I remember seeing that Goku Black only survived because he wore the time ring and because of Beerus’s intervention that timeline where he killed Chichi and Goten was “aborted”. Goku Black basically exists outside of “time and space”, a paradox of some sort. I wonder what would’ve happened if somehow his ring got removed, would he just blip out of existence? The anime did seem to imply heavily that the ring was the reason he still existed like you mentioned. Unfortunately that also brings into question of their ethereal form they took when Future Trunks used his spirit sword. You could say that the mortal Goku Black was finally killed with the spirit sword and the ethereal form was just the immortal Zamasu.
In the end I don’t understand why the arc ended how it did with a Future Mai and Future Trunks that exist as survivors of a completely annihilated timeline/ multiverse. Perhaps it may have been better to basically have Zeno intervene and destroy Goku Black since the very beginning before he killed Gowasu. Basically the story never happened at all but we as the viewers know it happened, heck Goku and friends could’ve been allowed to know what happened. But I guess either the editors or Toriyama wanted to make a leeway to make Time Patrol Trunks happen should they ever want to do so.
this comment was so good, i not even watching the rest of the video
@@_.El._ 1. He was caught off guard.
2. I've heard theories that Trunks used the shutdown remote on 17 and 18 instead of training to defeat them, which would explain why he was so weak.
I would like to assume that because of Cell’s creation of Timeline 5, Timelines 2 and 3 are erased completely and their Green Time Rings no longer exist, basically resetting the timelines to 5, allowing for the four Green Time Rings in Dragonball Super.
Thoughts??
How and why were they erased?
Where was dragon ball Gt hmmmmmm
@@suiyeethepinkunicorn7780 well, GT is after Goku retires so, after Super.
if you want to count it as canon since it was entirely an anime, not written by Toriyama, but entirely different people
so at that point either A. GT is in a timeline all on its own where the events of Super did not happen
or B. GT piggybacks off of the end of Super where things realign. Pan is a teenager now, Uub is under Goku's wings (we know Uub is canon to Super btw).
also, i believe GT Trunks is Kid Trunks, meaning that Future Trunks is just chilling with his double
Super is not Canon to gt because they are quite different in time lines
@@suiyeethepinkunicorn7780 haven’t you been paying attention? GT is just another timeline in the multiverse!!
Damn so this is why the time patrol was made
I say there’s 7 Timelines
1.5th Timeline: Universe 12s split timeline where the 1st Time Machine is made and destroyed (also the Universe 12 Time Machine is also destroyed)
1st Timeline: Universe 12s original timeline which has The timeline where Cell kills 1st Future Trunks and goes back in time
2nd Timeline: The timeline where 1st Future Trunks gives Goku the Heart Virus Medicine
3rd Timeline: Our Future Trunks’s timeline
4th Timeline: The (So-called) Main timeline where the Cell Saga and everything until the GB Saga and then Future Present Zamasu goes 1 year ahead with the Time Ring and steals Goku’s Body then goes back to the Future Present and then hops to the 3rd Timeline
5th Timeline: after Future Trunks goes back in time in the Main Timeline by mistake in an attempt to get help from the past to stop Goku Black and Beerus erases Zamasu stopping the second Goku Black creation
6th Timeline: Future Trunks and Mai’s new timeline where they live with themselves
Edit: 7th Timeline DBGT lol
Late reply I know but How could 1st future trunks give goku the heart medicine if he was killed by cell, wouldn’t that create a paradox creating a new timeline?
@@holdthefridge The Trunks That Cell Killed Already Traveled Back In Time, When He Got Caught Off Guard By Cell He Was Planning To Tell The Z Warriors How He Defeated The Androids, That Is The Whole Reason Cell Even Wanted To Time Travel, Because Future Trunks(Cell) Already Destroyed Them
@@ezequielinsaurralde5058 yeah I realized a few hours after I commented, I had a dumb moment and could find the comment again lmao thanks tho
11:50 But there are no fighters left with enough energy to revive Buu.
I recently discovered your channel. I love it man!!!
Your logic.
These alternate timelines are exactly what all the stories in the millions of games SHOULD be, but no, instead we get to fight Raditz for the millionth fucking time.
One alteration I'd make to your video: The Trunks from Timeline 1 that wound up in timeline 4 likely never went into the Hyperbolic Time Chamber to train. What had been theorized to have happened is that he found the Android blueprints in Gero's lab and Bulma created the device to shut them down, which he used in his timeline. I say this because had he gone into the HTC he would have been more than powerful enough to kill Cell like we saw in the anime.
I agree with this as well
So fun fact: there WAS a time travel event when Zamasu killed his master. That was Whis' do-over ability. Even though it was just the 5 seconds, they traveled back and made a change in those 5 seconds. So now we have to add on a timeline break for every time Whis has used this ability in the cannon! That's an extra 2 at a minimum, as he alludes to using it from before the Golden Freeza arc and ALSO uses it DURING the Golden Freeza arc! So it's not that gods killing gods creates new timelines, it's that Whis is just using Beerus as a scapegoat for his own misdeeds
You have it all wrong lol. Temporal do over does not go back in the past, it literally REWINDS time, meaning Whis’s ability fully rewinds time as if it never happened. I’m sure grand minister it took extra precaution to give angels this ability, I’m sure he was smart enough to prevent more timelines appearing lol
There was a 3rd rewind as well literally when Beerus sneezed and blew up a planet prior to Goku and Vegeta returning to earth during ressurection of F
@@moeej6809 This is never specified as being the case. I'm inclined to think you are correct. It would make sense that given time branches are considered aberrations, the ability to lop off undesirable chronological outcomes would be totally consistent with the role of an angel.
@@moeej6809 yes it dos whis told beerus by eraisng zmashu you made time ring of your whis todl you this
@@moeej6809 i swear beerus tells whis afterward that he inadvertently created a new timeline/ring when he did to do over
i've rewatched this video so many times, for some reason i never get enough of it
A few problems with this:
1. Someone in the comments below stated that Trunks legitimately waited 3 Years before Going Back to Timeline 3. This makes the Total Amount of Timelines to 7 as this happens twice.
2. When Beerus erases Zamasu out of existence it causes a new timeline due to the fact that he had obtained new information through a time traveling Goku and Vegeta, which wouldn't have been known otherwise. In the Timeline Zamasu Doesn't Get Erased but Goku and Vegeta does time travel in he is more than likely the Goku Black who somehow survived the time paradox, thus allowing the continuation of his existence, as Beerus was 100% sure that he got rid of Zamasu, not expecting that another timeline Goku Black could exist and repeat everything and not get erased.
1: trunks didn't wait 3 years, that would've made him 20 when he came back, which doesn't work (he ages in the time chamber and comes out taller, and people don't keep growing into their 20s, including saiyans).
2 edit: originally i said Beerus didn't create a new timeline when he erased Zamasu, but the manga and anime explicitly say he did. oopsies. bad writing :(
Corn boi
Whis directly states Beerus created a new timeline too when he destroyed Zamasu. Of course he did, the original timeline from that part of the story would have ended up with Zamasu stealing Goku’s body, killing him and going to Trunks’ timeline, continuing the time loop.
How Beerus was able to break the timeloop in our timeline is a plothole, because everything that happened in our timeline should have happened originally as well; in Black’s timeline it seems like Goku and Beerus just stopped investigating Black’s mystery for whatever reason, and Trunks just went home or something, which is why Zamasu had a chance to steal Goku’s body and Goku was just farming again when the body swap happened. That doesn’t make sense though obviously because there was no changing factor in our timeline as to why Beerus killed Zamasu in our timeline but not in Black’s. They screwed up
@@grydon6422 yeaa i hadn't gotten to that part of the vid yet, oops. crazy how that one line creates such a random plot hole
He didn't wait just changed date
Yea There is no way Trunks had enough fuel to go back and forth constantly
That into 😳💥
meanwhile all these time travel violation happening and Chronoa is taking a nap in Time Nest....
she's more incompetent than beerus.
Kinda? She arrested Trucks for his time machine shenanigans and made him work for her.
Chronica like a damn fly compared to even krillin. Flick her away
SpellCommander91: "You want to see me do the same break down for Avengers: End Game..."
Me: Well, since you offered...
YES!!!!
So would trunks only need 6 versions of himself to theoretically turn himself into a Super Saiyan God? 🤔
i mean he is one........
have you not seen the dragon ball heroes trailer?
XDDDDDDDDDDDD
A plausible plug for that green ring pot hole is; a ring exists for every timeline that directly connects to the timeline in which the rings exist.
Thus, as there is 5 rings, that means that 5 other timelines have interacted with the one in which we see the 'main timeline' take place.
It is entirely possible that in the future trunks timeline there are more green rings that exist, due to more timelines interacting with that one.
This allows for the theoretical infinite timelines concept.
This.
My theory is that one of those timelines eventually led up to trunks being recruited as a time patroller by chronoa and since then they have been working to fix all the timeline mess created by the time machine in different points of time, with the green time rings being just the more recent ones they haven't tackled yet, or the ones created by god's mistakes like what Beerus did, which she's probably not allowed to mess with
Maybe there was more boxes of green time rings that we have not seen yet
Also I would love an analysis of time travel in Avengers: Endgame
I always just figured that if you time travel to a date after the most recent time travel that happened in your timeline, you would end up in the same timeline without causing a new split, while if you go to a date before the most recent time travel, you still would go back to the same timeline, but you'd cause a new split (and depending on certain circumstances, a split in your own timeline as well), and the new timeline that you appeared in would now be the one you travel to, with any time travelers that appeared in that timeline after you coming from any timeline that split off from your own. It made sense to me, anyway.
As for the aborted futures... yeah, I got no fricking clue. However, I will say, I think the reason why Beerus killing Zamasu created a new timeline was simply because it was simply a change in history, even if Trunks didn't directly cause it.
I know it’s a year late but yeah that’s it, a new timeline isn’t created just by travelling back in time it’s only created when a change in history is made it creates a paradox example, future trunks coming to timeline 1 during the goku black arc doesn’t do anything it’s only when beerus hakai’s zamasu that’s it creates a paradox and so a new timeline is created timeline 6 which is where zamasu is alive and successfully becomes goku black
Trunks never travels through time -
What he does and did is a dimensional jump .
Thinks sideways rather than front- back .
He states this when Berus and who’s take goku to universe kami from goku black universe.
When he goes back to defeat the androids he is still alone .
He also says he already defeated boo he says in black storyline
My headcannon to explain this is that if you break a timeline you destroy a timeline. Which means the universe 10 destroyer erased a hell of a bunch of timelines for an entire month and was left with 4 and was just like... "well they don't seem to be duplicating anymore... guess the problem is solved!" Like I bet he did it to hide the other timelines out of shame but it just caused them all to stop existing.
You also forgot Buu's killing of the Compass Kais, that's some more timelines going by your logic.
The first main problem you mention is that Trunks going back in time, then FORWARD in time again, creating another alternate reality.
Based off of how the rings vs time machines work, isn't there the implication that traveling BACK in time creates a branched reality, but traveling FORWARD in time doesn't?
For instance, if I travel travel 10 minutes into the future, there is still only one timeline: one where I disappear and reappear 10 minutes later. There is no alternate timeline where I never got into the machine, and did not reappear in 10 minutes.
To create THAT branched reality, I'd have to go back in time AFTERWARDS to go and stop myself from getting into the time machine.
No Going in to the Future in a Multiverse Theory timeline just makes a new Timeline as well since time can’t be rewritten it would just make a new Timeline where you were not around
“The difference between writing fiction and non-fiction is, non-fiction has to make sense”
-Something I read once 🤗
Nice tackle
I'm a very big time-travel nerd and have been analyzing so many my whole life. New mindsets ahdm perspectives have lead to various disgrams for several franchises.
Writers for time travel very rarely get all their ducks in a row.
The multi-timelines and doorway mechanic is one of most solid out there. It counters most paradoxes. There are some specific mechanics that need decided and certainly some for the base story narrative.
Info-dumps of super complex concepts are hard to fight in. Especially when your base story and audience is all about "punchy-fighty beat em up" arcs.
The "infinite spaghetti", as I call it, is a tricky one to fix or gloss over and ignore. There certainly were more timelines rendered by all the old Z setting. Fitting them in narratively def is a passing issue even if they were thought of.
A mechanic I considered Trunks to have is a "history / destination" log in the time machine. Allowing for a revisiting of a past location. Basically reopening of the doorway.
But as for my normal models, any revisit to a past does spawn a new branch.
I personally have thought about a whole channel discussing all this and for each franchise.
I'm def open to compare models. :)
This becomes even worse when you think about the time Goku time traveled to meet young master roshi and THE OTHER TIME where him and trunks time traveled to meet a younger version of Goku.
11:30 is never mention that Cell changed the time machine date. When Picoolo asked him why did he selected this timeline he simple answered that he did not know, the machine was already set up to appear on his era.
True and its one of the plot holes of that arc bc why would trunks have it set for that time.
@@QuickPlaysHD Yeah, and despite who Cell is, I wouldn't say it is in his nature to lie about such a thing...
So it really doesn't make sense...
Could be that because there was already a time machine in that exact time already and Trunks didn't realize he should change the time. Maybe the machine automatically goes back a bit of time to as a glitchy fix...
I guess?
First... jk ima stop... But seriously this channel is so underrated
Shark Assassin ikr
Brain... hurty.
You can change the date without severing the link so long as it is any time after your original visit. Trunks creates one new timeline when he kills Frieza and Cold and then returns to it. Cell then makes a new one when he goes farther back then Trunks did. Because of this everything with your timeline 3 model is off. I'm glad that people still try to figure stuff like this out though!
It sad when I think about the dbz/dbs timeline I got to turn off my brain for it to make sense
Same that’s why I hate the goku black arc no arc should make the viewers head hurt from just thinking about how it works lol.
@@damarkomoore5236 true lol
But beerus said when gods destroy someone they completely destroy them in drangon ball super so if the man who original created time travel device was killed by a god of destruction of some one like that wouldn't it mean he was completely destroyed including the alternate timeline versions of him
No as beerus destroyed zamasu but the alternate version was still alive
@@joster6268but in that alternate time line zamasu had surpassed beerus power and the only one who could bring him down was the omni king. he also killed the supreme kai of his universe and replaced him making himself a supreme kai (god of creation). And because he's a supreme kai his life is tied to the new god of destruction who would probably not let him die. So i don't think zamasu' situation is comparable.
Ethan Kellerman thanks forgot about that
@Ethan Kellerman no they don’t Goku Black was just lacking the knowledge of the Time Rings Beerus just wanted Trunks to F Off from his timeline and everyone else was just Gullible enough to believe him
@DatrixTSW2012 Whis is wrong Future Trunks made that Timeline when he traveled back in time since he accidentally went back almost a year to before Zamasu started his 0 Mortal Plan
idk anymore it just doesn't make sense cause the trunks from history of trunks came back to where Android 19's head was blown up by Vegeta's big bang attack instead of that one timeline you talked about where Goku is already dead from the virus
the thing is.. 17 and 18 arrived so late in the present/main timeline where it matches Trunk's 3 year return and Goku's late heart virus so everything in the present comes late because trunks created a new timeline
Awesome video bro. I just came across you channel and I love the content. To see you that dedicated and break down every possible scenario is amazing and you definitely deserve a lot of credit for the time taking to make this video.
13:30 here's the part where I think you got some stuff wrong.
When Imperfect Cell went back in time in Timeline 5 he probably had to have gotten killed by the Androids. The Androids had already killed so many people meaning Cell couldn't absorb enough power so when he attempted to absorb the Androids he probably ended up getting Clapped by Android 16.
The Androids still ruin the timeline so the Trunks from Timeline 5 goes to Timeline 6 and the same Trunks goes 3 extra years into the future to create Timeline 7. Because Imperfect Cell from Timeline 1 had gone to Timeline 5 and the Future Trunks from Timeline 5 created Timelines 6 and 7; then that means there would be a new version of Imperfect Cell in Timelines 6 and 7, almost as if he was cloned due to time travel.
Future Trunks wasn't the one without a home timeline. It was these 2 different versions of Timeline 1 Cell. This version of Cell believes he's from Timeline 1 but actually doesn't have a home timeline.
Hopefully this makes sense.
Goku blAck shit is unsolvable
And that still leaves us with 7 timelines
@@alexisislas-gonzalez5991 Not trying to fix the "7 Timelines" stuff. Just tryna make the whole Cell Time Travel thing in the Original Anime/Manga actually make sense.
I’m not even halfway through the video and I’m all sorts of confused. How does Time Travel work?
It does but doesn't. That's all you need to know.
Not finished yet, but I’ve gotta say: your idea of timeline 7 being the origins of Goku Black makes SO much more sense than the canon explanation. It’s still kinda convoluted, but it works so much better than “time ring makes me immune to having my past changed.”
Now I know what I'm missing for Xenoverse 3 (and why we may never get it):
- Instead of revisiting the events of X1 like X2 did for the most part, you're staged to address the Temporal Seams that the Breaker Civilians are currently handling and being trapped in.
-- The alternate branching timelines that have blossomed due to time-travel will be the explored scenarios that have more story fleshed out, rather than being reduced to mere Quests you get graded for.
--- We potentially have the ground to explore an entirely different arc, due to these Seams' issues.
---- It can also be assumed that the Seams are a result of trying to over-correct these tears and changes in reality, which is why people across the multiverse are being independently being sucked into a concentrated point involving a Raider, whose presence demanded the creation of a time-machine in the first place.
I know this is a bit of a convenient stretch, but considering time-travel is now one of the biggest behind-the-scenes factors that drives the creation of more Dragonball content, I'd certainly prefer to have something that 'branches off' from X1/X2 rather than going through all of those events for a third goddang time.
I like the unintended conclusion you draw that if Future Trunks had just stayed away from our timeline after the first time that everything in the main story basically would have been better off. Trunks went back again to ensure he’d made that timeline better, and instead ensured that everyone in it eventually got killed by Majin Buu. I mean, luckily, they all got wished back, but still.
So in other words… Zamasu was right.
Gonna stop at 8:27. You aren't one to talk about not making any sense. For starters, there isn't any rule stated about how multiple trips make a secure connection, that is just something you came up with.
It can be logically concluded that in actuality, it is only when the Time Machine is first used. Nothing in the main Canon goes against that and only supports it. Future Trunks only moves between his own and the one he first goes back to. The Trunks we meet was never destined to be defeated by Cell either. This is due to the fact that Cell had already returned when Trunks first beat Frieza, changing the future of that Timeline.
Ditto, it's crazy after all these years, Qaaman's video on the Timelines still holds up the best imo, he just needs to update it for super.
This is why the gods know ,don't fuck with time travel. You end up with narrative catastrophes like this
This type of video is the speculation I love to find on UA-cam this video is an amazing and I hope you do more
No wonder the Spirit Sword technique was so powerful: there were an infinite amount of Trunks' hidden behind a bush all giving him their energy.
Every time a new timeline is created, a new Zeno is created. That's why it's so taboo I believe
Zeno*
True
Wasn’t it stated that the Trunks from the timeline Cell came from, stopped the androids by using the shutdown controller or whatever? He never went through all the training and fought them, he just turned them off or whatever. That’s why he wasn’t strong enough to stop Cell.
He also didn’t mention cells timeline had a future trunks in it that killed the frieza in that timeline meaning cells timeline can’t be the original at best it can be the 2nd oldest timeline or first divergence. If anything it’s that trunks who traveled to cells timeline who has the original timeline
I just guessed cell supressed himself and absorbed trunks
@@johannessguten2527 Came back to this after two years, and I'm glad to see someone else mention it! I've already made a comment about it! 😹
There are 5 time rings because those are the ones that are accesible from that timeline
Wow, great research/theories. This must have taken some time to write up!
This is all predicated on the assumption that the time machine creates a new timeline EVERY time it travels, when in reality it only does so when there is a significant change in circumstances for the timeline.
Hence, we only have 3 timelines in Z and 3 additional in Super. The main story, Trunks', Cell's, Goku Black's originating line, OG Zamasu's before he got Hakai'd and the one Goku Black created from travelling to Trunks' which we see in Super and which is reset out of existence with his life in the end of the arc.
yeah im not gonna lie, this video seems extremely iffy and im not sure if i agree with it at all.
Idk if all this is possible since I don't know enough about the hypothetical physics of time travel but this gives some thought.
How to get people to rewatch your video and boost it in the algorithm 101: make it about headache-inducing time travel explanation
There are many errors here. First, after Trunks kills Freeza and warns Goku, he doesnt go back home to check things up. Because Bulma already knew she couldnt change her timeline. Trunks specifically says that he got back to find a way to defeat the androids. So after giving Goku the medicine, he travels 3 years into that timeline future, now, this would be lets say in timeline 2, timeline one, being where Goku and all the Z warriors die.
In this time line, they defeat the androids by using the schematics they found on Dr Gero lab, then Trunks go back to his timeline, and defeats the androids there, so when Cell wakes up, there are no androids to complete his perfect body.
This Trunks never trained with Vegeta, since they had no need to, so he isnt able to defeat Cell. Cell kils him steals his machine and goes back, thus creating timeline 3. Now here we have that since he travel to a point Trunks was in the past, he starts changing that Trunks story, so this is Trunks 2, the first one being the one who trains with Gohan, destroys the androids, then dies at Cell´s hands, this one who will train with Vegeta, withness Gohan kill Cell, goes back to his timeline, kills 17 & 18 and then kills Cell, this would be another Cell.
And how do the Trunks go back to their timeline, after having make alterations in the past?
To travel in time is to travel in space, this is a reality in our universe, and Im pretty sure in the DB universe too, as when Trunks activates the time machine at the end of the Warriors of the Future Special, you can see the time machine traveling through space.
So there is no magic point created betwen the points of time travel, and Trunks didnt wait 3 years to go back, other wise we would have seen him getting bigger, as he did after a year with Vegeta, lets remember he is just 16, so years do matter a lot.
The time machine, simply have a way to return home, to its one timeline, but when going back, it creates a divergent, thats why we can have two future Trunks, one that dies at Cell and one that kills him.
It's stated by Trunks in the manga that it takes time for the time machine to get enough fuel to travel. So Trunks likely did wait and not make a 4th timeline.
The whole idea of time travel is confusing when you focus on all the details. But your theory of *TM1* Trunks going to *TM3* [the DB we know about] and thus making a link between those timelines seems to be legitimate. So lets go from there. If the *TM1* time machine created a link to *TM3,* then it wouldn't matter that *TM1* Trunks went back to his time and chose a later date. Because they are already linked. I can't speculate if the link is due to a program that Bulma may have created, or if it was a natural outcome of the initial time travel. But either way, it seems to be the case because Trunks waited until he had enough fuel to do it again. Perhaps he waited for 3 years. I believe that to be the case, because in the manga, before he left, Goku asked if they will meet again. Trunks says something to the effect of "not sure. It takes a lot of time to gather fuel for a round trip in the time machine. If I'm still alive, I'll help in 3 years."
Imperfect Cell wouldn't be strong enough to kill Trunks after going into the room of spirit and time. The Trunks that was killed would have had to be one that didn't use that room. We know this because that Cell, in his stronger semi-perfect form, was beaten by a Trunks who only used the room once at that point in the series.
I re-read the VIZ translation of the manga and watched the subbed episode where Cell is explaining to Piccolo how he got there. It seems Cell didn't travel back 4 years like many people think. He traveled back 3 years. And (thanks to plot) it only takes him 3 years to mature from his egg form to the form he took while fighting Piccolo. At the same time this is contradicted by Trunks because he says the old time machine arrived 1 whole year before he got there and it came from 3 years after he left to the past. Damn it, Toriyama!
I'll admit that I'm not completely familiar with Super as I am with Z but are the different universes interchangeable to timelines? I think I missed that explanation in the series. From what I know of the Black saga, whatever timeline future Trunks is in, that timeline has 12 universes. And Black killed the 12 kais in those timeline locked universes. What smells like copper?
It is somewhat like loop
I agree with this theory more than the video. I believe Trunks does wait before going back and that the timelines are just linked somehow. And that’s what Toriyama intended so I’m happy to go with that. But as a Z stan I won’t even begin to conjecture about Super since nothing about that series has proper incentive to be canonically consistent after 20+ years. It’s fan service imo. Krillin took on an SSGSS Kamehameha. I’m not interested.
At first it seemed like a Grand Fathers paradox "each new action taken in the past produces a new alternate reality/time line" now it's what we can officially call a fuster cluck.
I was using that theory to try and figure this out, and I actually thought I solved it. But I forgot the minor detail of Goku having to fight Zamasu for Zamasu to become Goku Black, which wouldn't have happened if Trunks didn't already travel back in time to ask for help to beat Goku black who randomly appeared in his future. This shit makes no fucking sense...
Just one last thing This is the reason Why There over infinite timelines to the point of rick and morty different dimesions/timelines maybe less then this
To be honest, I was following up until the first Future Trunks bit where he creates timeline 4 in an attempt to get back to timeline 3, as I was under the assumption that he had waited three years and then returned ( -of course that brings to question how he survived three more years in his apocalyptic future with murder androids but yeah- )And even as you assumed he somehow got back to timeline 3, I thought that would count as a return trip, seeing as he already went there once before, therefore not causing a split. I thought that was the very thing you were assuming didn’t happen, and that’s what confuses me.
That's because he does wait and defends the remaining humans until he travels back.
He caused a split because one timeline cell is in and one timeline he's not in .at least what I thought.but this means that a perfect cell is still probably alive fighting space aliens because 1 timeline he succeeded.
One thing I learned
There 25 Timeline And It all confusing
Infinite Loops of timeline are gonna continue As Of The show keep going on
That's also not counting GT Trunks. It would be cool if all three versions of Trunks were to meet each other. Kid Trunks, Future Trunks and GT Trunks could meet and they could fuse into one person. This Trunks would have all of the memories of all three timelines.
GT Trunks is kid Trunks, but older.
@@AdmiraHax Lmao
@@AdmiraHax technically he is one timeline's kid trunks.
What happened to the Yugioh GX rewrites?
what program did you use to make this video? i like what you did and it looks very useful to know, so how did you do it?
Idk what to think. I really love your ideas and how you wanna explain this. But maybe you should get with quaman he is another dragontuber that did a timeline explanation. It would be nice to see that.
Maybe Zamasu instead of wishing mortals away wanted to kill them all slow and painfully and take his time, still dark though Jesus...
I’m just gonna share my opinion on this.
There is technically five canon timelines in Dragon Ball
The first timeline is where “First Future Trunks” is killed by Imperfect Cell.
That trunks goes to the Second Timeline called the “Unseen timeline” because we never see it, however DBM covered this. In this timeline, Kami refuses to let the Z-fighters into the hyperbolic Time chamber because the androids haven’t done anything wrong. Bulma creates a remote to shut down the androids permanently. This is given to Trunks, which he takes back to the first timeline I referenced.
The third timeline is where we the viewers follow future trunks we all know and love. His future is the same as the timeline 1.
The fourth timeline is where we follow the Z-Fighters, and main story takes place. After, killing timeline 1 Trunks, Cell arrives in this timeline.
The fifth timeline is where Zamasu killed The universe seven supreme Kai, and therefor, creating another timeline.
If Toriyama went back to check on how many timelines there were to make Super, the Kais would have an entire vault of those rings
Amazing editing, this is a great channel . Keep the good work
What if travel doesn't split timelines?
@SlappyTheClappy Sorry, to clarify, I mean travel like Trunks' second trip to the timeline. For example, the link want fully established between his timeline and the new one, so he was able to kinda use that same bridge but change the date he came out of by a couple years since the dates were relatively close and the rip in the space time continuum is also relatively new.
@@Kyleand3rror thats literally The most accepted theory. Or than it would all be a mess.
@@Kyleand3rror Then the story could not have happened the way it did as you would need to somehow have 2 trunks in the same timeline, one to die to Cell and one to travel forward in time to fight Cell.
@3:13 there's also Towa and the Supreme Kai of Time [cronoa]
[both of which use magic to travel via timelines, scrolls for kai, dark/deamon magjc for towa and mira]
never mind apparently it doesn't count.
Zeni, the dude that created all universes and can watch all timeliness, has stated an ability to intervene if something happens to alter his story significantly enough. he refers to this timeline as timeline one, regardless of whether it's timeline 7 or not. so my theory is that he wiped out all of the timelines that splintered off of timeline one, splicing events from the different timelines on to timeline one to make an interesting story, and that only five green Rings exist because those are the only timelines that did not alter the story significantly enough to need intervention.
I thought that there was five timelines because of the regular timeline, future, Cells timeline where he kill trunks first, Zamasu Timeline, and then the timeline where Freitas blows up earth in RoF
Time reversal does not create a nee timeline.
I always took it that changing the date you want to time-travel to only creates a new timeline when the date is earlier than that you have prievously travelled to. Therefore, Future Trunks showing up three years later after killing Freeza and King Cold would not create a new Timeline, but Cell stealing his Time Machine and arriving earlier would.
I also noticed a small hole in your explanation, you said that Trunks would go into the Room of Spirit and Time and grow strong enough to defeat 17 and 18, but he was still weak enough to be killed by Imperfect Cell, plus, his appearance does not have its post-ROSAT look.
Yeah, the moment he mentioned that date change is what causes timelines to split, I knew his 25 timeline theory seemed ridiculous. From what we have seen, only traveling to the past of a timeline is what causes a timeline to split. We have never seen traveling to the future of one causing a split since time technically flowed normally without any changes to the past. The idea that 12 timelines are created by killing each Supereme Kai of Time is pretty ridiculous as well, since by his logic, the moment Future Trunks' Supreme Kai was killed, a new timeline would be created for no reason.
The video fails at that point,cell never changed the date and trunks did not train to beat his androids, he used the remote controller, and after get ambushed by cell
I was watching this while doing homework and by the time i looked back i was utterly lost
Mentions XenoVerse "what the hell this is supposed to be"
It's confirmed in the DBS Manga that Temporal Do-over does not create more timelines.
thank you, i KNEW it was said somewhere, although i also swear it was in the anime too
These timelines are so confusing...
I actually came back to this video(apparently after two years) and I really just wanted to say that there's actually ANOTHER timeline! In the Manga, Cell states he gets Frieza and King Cold's cells and there's a flashback panel of them dying by ANOTHER Future Trunks. In the anime he talks about it and specifically says a Future Trunks kills Frieza and King Cold. Meaning THAT FUTURE TRUNKS traveled INTO CELL'S timeline and then went BACK to his own! So theoretically, in the "original timeline", Goku killed Frieza and King Cold, Androids wipe out the Z Fighters, Trunks goes to CELL'S TIMELINE, comes back with the bomb blueprints to blow up Android 17 and 18, and possibly dies from the Cell of HIS TIMELINE! The thing is, HIS CELL wouldn't travel through time, because if he did he'd be in FUTURE CELL'S timeline and become perfect, co-existing with another unborn Cell and ruling that timeline!
Actually, time travel in Dr. Slump DOES count, since both Gatchans appeared in both the Red Ribbon Army Saga and Episode 69 of DBS. So consider all these timelines doubled AT LEAST