- 340
- 781 138
QuranTalk
United States
Приєднався 12 кві 2014
Hadith Plagiarized Christian Folklore: Cædmon & the Hadith of the First Revelation
Discord: discord.gg/submission
Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk
Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/12/16/caedmon-the-hadith-of-the-first-revelation/
linktr.ee/SubmissiontoGod
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: talkquran
Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-count/
Hadith Refutation: qurantalk.gitbook.io/hadith-refutation/
Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk
Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/12/16/caedmon-the-hadith-of-the-first-revelation/
linktr.ee/SubmissiontoGod
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: talkquran
Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-count/
Hadith Refutation: qurantalk.gitbook.io/hadith-refutation/
Переглядів: 1 539
Відео
Quran Talk - Monkey Adultery Hadith
Переглядів 2,6 тис.День тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/04/20/hadith-monkey-adultery/ linktr.ee/SubmissiontoGod Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.g...
God & Time
Переглядів 1,3 тис.2 місяці тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/10/18/god-and-time/ linktr.ee/SubmissiontoGod Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/...
Gospel Contradictions
Переглядів 1,6 тис.4 місяці тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/07/28/gospel-contradictions/ qurantalkblog.com/2024/07/19/37-basic-law-of-hermeneutics-for-studying-scripture/ linktr.ee/SubmissiontoGod Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.c...
Quran, Gospel (Injeel) & Torah
Переглядів 1,7 тис.5 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/07/18/quran-gospel-torah/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-count/...
Sunnis Polluted the Kaaba with Shirk (Idol Worship)
Переглядів 4,2 тис.6 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/05/26/sunnis-have-polluted-the-kaaba/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-in...
Something Similar to Quran?
Переглядів 2,9 тис.6 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/06/11/something-similar-to-it/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-c...
Contextual Hadith (Asbab al-Nuzul) is a Sham
Переглядів 3,5 тис.6 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/05/19/necessity-and-reliability-of-contextual-hadith-asbab-al-nuzul/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle...
Quran Talk - Bearers of Seed (2:223)
Переглядів 1,2 тис.6 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/04/20/bearers-of-seed-2223/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-coun...
Circular Logic of Hadith Biographies (Ilm al Rijal)
Переглядів 2,7 тис.7 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/05/20/reliability-of-hadith-biographies-ilm-al-rijal/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.git...
Quran Talk - Knowledge & Power
Переглядів 1,5 тис.7 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/05/02/knowledge-power/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-count/ Re...
QuranTalk - Intercession: Who is Permitted? What will be said?
Переглядів 2 тис.8 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/04/24/intercession-who-is-permitted-what-will-be-said/ qurantalkblog.com/2024/02/17/intercession-myth-and-reality/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Res...
Debate: Truth & Answers
Переглядів 1,8 тис.8 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/01/10/debate-questions-answers/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-initial-...
Abu Lahab vs Dhajjal (Quran vs. Hadith)
Переглядів 2,7 тис.8 місяців тому
Discord: discord.gg/submission Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/04/03/abu-lahab-vs-dhajjal-quran-vs-hadith/ Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE Twitter: talkquran Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/ Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/ Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/qu...
Quran Talk - Can the prophet hear us?
Переглядів 3,1 тис.8 місяців тому
Quran Talk - Can the prophet hear us?
Quran Talk - The Prophet Was Not Illiterate
Переглядів 7 тис.10 місяців тому
Quran Talk - The Prophet Was Not Illiterate
Christian Claims Sanaa Manuscript Discovery Will Destroy Quran
Переглядів 3,1 тис.10 місяців тому
Christian Claims Sanaa Manuscript Discovery Will Destroy Quran
Sunnis getting high on their own supply
Переглядів 3 тис.11 місяців тому
Sunnis getting high on their own supply
Quran Talk - Three Requirements for Monotheism
Переглядів 1,6 тис.11 місяців тому
Quran Talk - Three Requirements for Monotheism
Hadith Fails The Authenticity Test
Переглядів 3,5 тис.11 місяців тому
Hadith Fails The Authenticity Test
Was Abraham a Liar? (Quran vs. Hadith)
Переглядів 1,8 тис.Рік тому
Was Abraham a Liar? (Quran vs. Hadith)
Quran English Translation - Sura 16: The Bee (Al-Nahl)
Переглядів 444Рік тому
Quran English Translation - Sura 16: The Bee (Al-Nahl)
Quran English Translation - Sura 15: Al-Hijr Valley (Al-Hijr)
Переглядів 268Рік тому
Quran English Translation - Sura 15: Al-Hijr Valley (Al-Hijr)
This is golden 😂
MashaAllah! I've learned a lot through you guys after God has Guided me to Quran alone (God alone) nearly wandering a decade looking for a true religion warranted by the creator. I do believe from the four direction devil threatened to dupe humans the likes of Baphomet is the front one at least we can see this evil clearly but, from the direction Satan threatened to dupe us the right direction (probably through righteousness) is very dangerous millions & millions of people believe they are on the right track & believe they are guided while they are tricked by devil in to rejecting God's revelation for some idle talk & fancy words 👇👇 God's last testament: [7:30] Some He guided, while others are committed to straying. They have taken the devils as their masters, instead of GOD, yet they believe that they are guided. ☝☝this is very dangerous believing guided while worshipping devil by rejecting God's commandment true "Hadith is Devil’s babble that tries to silence the Quran" the Muslim Oumma today are silenced by devils babble the free choice (freedom of belief) granted by God is taken & humans killed just because they have different opinion specially on Muslim majority nations, womens are beaten or killed for their clothing, people shamed when trying to follow Quran alone I think I can't finish the injustice & oppression imposed on humans by this innovation & devils work. I believe the submission movement should arise & spread the light & true guidance for the whole of mankind. In my nation nearly 130 million people are duped by devil in to believing they are guided I hope I can do something, some kind of contribution in trying to show the true religion of God.
Lol, dimwitted ignoramus Hadith rejectors. So, the Qur'an mentions FOUR sacred months, out of 12, which are sacred and in which fighting is forbidden. Which are the four sacred months and which verse names these months? If you cannot provide the verses listing the names of these months, you're a jahil when you claim that the Hadith don't have a role in Islam 😂😂😂😂
You mean to say, we should stay away from salah (namaz) and Charity because the Quran doesn't mention about five times of prayer and how many charity we have to pay, but mention do Salah and pay charity, where we get the exact number and time for praper if not in hadeeth ( are you Jew?)
With respect, "hymn" is pronounced "him" Salam
Hadiths are from Satan himself to mis guide you from the true message
Sunnist workshiper = believe something non exist in Quran... Something renovation and fairy tail related on Allah they love so much...
There are so many prophet sent by ALLAH not all are mentioned may be caedmon was a prophet before Muhammad similarities does not prove that Hadith is just copied although it's right that all Hadith is not correct
مصادر جيدة...
Try reading Salaat without looking at hadith. Good luck.
It won't look anything remotely like the known ways of reading salaat. So you will conclude that it is wrong. Because your way is right. This is a really bad argument to be honest.
@Monavah you have no idea what you're talking about. Salaat has largely been the same for 1400 years based on these hadith which layout exactly how to read it. Read a book.
this is begging the question
Please give reference of hadith showing how to pray salat from start to finish.
Try reading Salat looking at Hadith. Good luck. You know why, coz there's no single Hadith that details the ritual gymnastics that you guys do.
Praise God!!
Notice how bruh needed examples from the Torah to help make a point in the quran .. the quran can't stand on its own
Brilliant presentation. Your efforts will speak for you on the day of judgement God willing.
Well an Arab Oral transmision is much more realible than in the christian world, because these arabs known well for their memorization capability and tradition But yes its difficult to trust hadits shahih bukhari as in a par of Quran, because Bukhori might and must make a mistake Transfering and information without digital world is highly corrupted its happen in all God's books like zabur torah and even injil this is showing how poor and ugly for us human to able to transfer a knowledge accurately and honestly! But if you research hadith these deep why not try to make your own selective hadits that in your view and research for which one is real authentic one... Because if you cannot do that then its difficult to reject hadith without first have to be very weird or contradicted to Quran isn't...?
What nonsense I am seeing here. Blind leading the blind.
This is pure GEM!
Dude. Does it matter. There will be some Sunnis going to heaven and some to hell. So don’t worry about it
Hadith fails again and again
Do you even know the arabic to have the pretention to be a koranite?
@cardndmch😅😅so According to u emeritus : God needs help from bukhareye and abuhoor???? Etc…etc…???
@@cardndmch yes I know Arabic now what? Your scholars know Arabic, yet they don’t know Quran 😂😂👍
@@Alain-bb8sf you have a broken logic, hadiths are extensions. Btw, all ayats from the Quran are found in the hadiths. And there is knowledge in hadiths that I consider being as top tier in metrics of usefulness. So if you don't know about them, then I am sorry for you, it will be hard to find it in the Quran.
Does the Quraan teach you how to pray?
This is interesting
Isaiah (c. 745-742 BCE), 29:10-14: For Yehovah has made a sacrificial-libation upon thee; a spirit of-trance - and closes your eyes; the prophets, and your head seers, were obscured. And to you it becomes a vision of the-all; as words of The-Scroll, the sealed-one, which they give to one who knows reading (var.) to say, “Do, read (recite) this.” And he said, “I am not empowered, for it is sealed.” And The-Scroll was given to one-who did not know reading to say, “Do, read (recite) this.” And he said, “I did not know reading.” And my Adon is saying, “Insomuch that this people approach in their mouth and their lip they honour Me, and [yet] their heart is-removed from Me, and their fear of Me is a disciplic precept of lesser-men. Therefore behold Me (adding) יוסף (Joseph) to a distinguishing-work of this people; a distinguishing-work and a marvel. And their sages' sagacity perished, and discernment of-their intelligentsia remains-safely-tucked-away.”
Note that due to Roman calendar changes we could read the era of Isaiah's ministry commencing to 2 years earlier, being 747 BCE. We are uncertain as to when precisely the earliest book which details Nabi Mohammad's life, and survives in any significant form, was written. Ibn Isḥāq (born c. 704, Medina, Arabia-died 767, Baghdad) was an Arab biographer of the Prophet Muḥammad whose book, in a recension by Ibn Hishām, is one of the most important sources on the Prophet’s life. - Britannica online. 767 CE validity as the date of Ibn Kathir's death is critical to the Biblical code mentioned in The Quran, S61:6.
انا اختك في الله والله ما كتبت هذا الكلام الا من الضيق وقسوت الضروف اني وامي واخوني نشأت من التعب اني طالبه من الله ثم منك لاتردني خايبه حسبنا الله ونعم الوكيل في من اوصلنا الا هاذا الحال يِآ نآس يِآآمٌـٍة مٌحًمٌد صِآرتٍ قلّوبگٍمٌ بلّآ رحًمٌهً ولآشفُقهً ولآ. أنسآنييهً گٍمٌ شگٍيِتٍ وگٍمٌ بگٍيِتٍ گٍمٌ نآديِتٍ وگٍمٌ نآشدتٌ ولگٍن لآ حًيِآٍة لّمٌن تٍنآديِ هًلّ يِرضيِگٍمٌ آن خواتي يِبگٍون ويِمٌوتٍون مٌن آلّجُوع. وآنتٍمٌ مٌوجُودون يِعلّمٌ آلّلّه آلّعلّيِ آلّعظيِمٌ آننآ لآ نمٌلگٍ حًتٍى قييمٌـٍة گٍيِلّو دقيِق آبيِ مٌتٍوفُيِ اخي اول كلامي انا اقسم بالله على كتاب الله اني لاكذب عليك ولا انصب ولا احتال اني بنت يمنيه من اليمن نازحين من انا واسرتي بيننا ايت الشهرب. 15 الف يمني والان علينا 45الف حق 3 شهر وصاحب البيت من الناس الي ماترحم والله يا اخي انه يجي كل يوم يبهدلنا ويتكلم علينا ويريد من البيت للشارع لانناماقدرنا ندفعه الأجار شافونا الجيران نبكي ورجعو تكلمو الجيران ومهلنالاخره الأسبوع مدفعنا له حلف يمين بالله هذا بيخرجنا إلى الشارع رحمه واحنا. بلادنا بسبب هذا الحرب ولاجد قوت يومنا وعاشيشين اناوامي واخوتي سفاره والدنا متوفي الله يرحمه ومامعنا أحد في هذه الدنيا جاانبنا في هذه الظروف القاسيه خواتي صغار يخرجو للشارع وشافو الجيران ياكلو ووقفو بابهم لجل يعطوهم عند كسره خبز والله الذي له ملك السموات والارض فقط ويطلق الباب وطردوهم ورجع يبكو ايموتو من ما احدهم وعطلة ردها لقمت عیش والان لوما احد ساعدنا في إيكيلو طاقة دقيق اقسم بالله انموت من الجوع فيا اخيرا انا دخيله على الله ثم عليك وريد من مساعده لوجه الله انشدك بالله تحب الخير واتساعدني بقدر ماتسطيع توصل مع تراسلي واتساب على هذا الرقم 00967717591071 وتطلب اسم بتي وترسلي ولاتتاخر وايعوضك الله خير بكل اخواني سغار شوف كيف حالتهم وساعدنا وأنقذنا قبل أن يطردونا في الشارع تتبهدل أو نشأت من المعاناة وانا واسرتي نسالك بالله لولك مقدره على مساعد لاتاخر علينا وجزاك الله خيرا. ~π~π~√π÷~π~π~√~π؟!؟!!!؟!!!-•-♡♡♡♡♡♡؟!؟!! 💔😅🥲😢😭~~♡♡!..
Praise God.
More evidence of the first hadith narraration being a lie according to the Qur'an. When Jibreel came down and the Prophet saw him in the horizon descending: 53:9 - And was at a distance of two bow lengths or nearer. This implies Jibreel never squeezed and frightened the Prophet. He was simply in front of him speaking/delivering inspiration.
That surah has nothing to do with the first revelation, it was at miraaj. You literally proved why we need hadith to understand the tafsir of the Quran
@WaqasAli-ct7ly you obviously don't read the Qur'an. Read the first 15-20 ayat of Surah Najm. It says he also saw Jibreel another time in the heavens. If anything that would be Miraaj. The 2nd time.
First of all it's not Alla , it's Allah .Ah at the end please I am sure you can work on it if you are not AI generated. There were no Hadiths for at least first 150 years following the death of the prophet (pbuh). 'We have made the Quran easy for you to understand'.
But the question is Why did it take over one hundred thirty years to have the biography of a powerful man to be written They had political power,money,learned men and all the good will.shy didn't the swahabas care to get it written.tbe ummayads .some thing wrong. Then the likely story appears fishy You are honest man. Muslims keep telling us of isnad but who created it? We have a problem. I have asked any Muslim to show me a verse which says an angel appeared to Mohamed by then Quthum bin Abdullah and told him to recite. Non.
He said Allah
Thats not true either, Abu Hurayrah and Abdullah ibn Amr and Ali ibn Ali Talib wrote the hadiths down while the Prophet SAW was alive, and the students of the companions also wrote it down
@ Let me rephrase it. Verbal statements attributed to the prophet ( pbuh) were compiled 150 years later in the court of the ruling leader for their own political agenda. Yes Bokhari and others were on the payroll of these rulers. Of course more or less 70% Hadiths were written by Abu Huraira . Only Allah knows what he heard and others who quoted him later on. I don’t know much about Ali (ra) Hadith collection but I do know Abu Bakr wrote 33 or so and then he stopped it . I guess he was the wisest of them all. Bottom line is as along as the Hadith is in the light of the Quran it will be scrutinized. Unless you are telling me that Allah revealed something to the Prophet (pbuh) outside of the Quran. Allah knows best.
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly We don’t have a problem with you choosing to obey Abu Hurayrah or Abdullah Ibn Amir along with Allah, that’s between you and Allah. But we have a problem with you not being honest with yourself and trying to say things about Allah that aren’t true. We were created by the same Creator, if you fail to recognize the Creator someone else will not, that’s the beauty of diversity.
brother always put sources in the descriptions thats more professional God bless you
Peace - the link to the article with the sources is always in the description
@@QuranTalk Thank you for your videos. Although Im not a quranist, Your videos have changed so much of my life for the better. May God bless you accordingly.
Please make a video about naafi the mawla of ibn umar and ikrama and aamish.. just read their bio and their age of birth and death do not overlap with following narrators....
Hadiths are plagiarized from the Judaism-Christianity-Zoroastrianism-Animism-Old wifes tales-Insults- Nonsense and Fabricated Lies to replace the Qur'an with the fabricated hadiths lies and invent the manmade religions of Sunnism and Shiism and to deceive the people .
Very good video brother...I notice that the Tafseer that speaks about the creation and the whale nun is also from an ancient Egyptian fable which they used to tell their religious followers. Then to see it included in Christianity and then Sunni Islam is definitely NOT. A coincidence. Paganism is always working behind the scenes to mislead mankind just as Shaytaan promises in the Qur'an.
Bible doesn't have that story of whales
(Personally) I'd rather converse with a Mulhid/Atheist, as opposed to converse with a Qur'ānist, about anything relating to al-Islām.
Mshaallah I totally agree. Ummi means gentile prophet.
Praise God
How about birds' salat? Allah's and angels' salat to the prophet? Allah's salat to mumins? Mumins' salat to the prophets? These are also said in Qoran. Are they too prayers coming from the prophet Abraham?
🙊🙉🙈... 😂😂😂
so true, all true and it is all the work of Satan.☝
nah you are just connecting dots randomly. I think the verse refers to "Qiyamaat" the Apocalypse
Get ready guys don't tell me i didn't warn you guys when the religion forces everyone to stops you from having sex with your lover don't say i didn't warned you guys i swear thier are to many dictating people in religion's like this that they think they can get away with being dictating person because they have the power to have control on what you do and if you do something they don't agree upon then they shift the blame on to you and they wonder why people are leaving the relgion because its to forced thats why
Great video! Its not only the monkey adultery to make it obvious, for me what made it OBVIOUS obvious, Was when i was some disgusting hadiths about muhammed ﷺ In his private times with his wives.. 😭 We have all the rules about what makes someone a good narrator, but none of the rules are "gossiping about your mom and dad Sex life???" like what-- (because muhammed ﷺ and his wives are like father and mothers for us) I wonder what are those people thinking sometimes, but its important to shed light on this because Kafirs can look at those verses and stay away from our beautiful religion 😢 In the side note, i think we need more strict regulations for sahi, especially since some people are really influenced by it. I expected to see at least 2 totally independent chains of narrations. Cuz that makes it really hard 2 people conspired to make a fake hadith
If reject all hadith,then from where to know how to pray,what to pray....
This video made my night. Love the content and glad to see it after the hiatus. God bless you.
You'll never find faults in quran and sunnah. Your forefathers couldn't, you think you can do it😂😂😂 joke on you. N btw this hadith you are talking about wasn't narrated from the nabi SAW and the companions, it was a view of that tabii. Keep on hating as will destroy your peace ✌️ 😅😅
actually basic knowledge of Hadees there is story fairy tale and another actually told by prophet A.S in that the story teller must knows the chain and he must be never lie never cheat he must be truthful and trustworthy and mentally stable ! but in this no chain
I knew you would address this serious matter. Praise God for exposing the insanity of Hadiths. Praise God!
What was Bukhari thinking while copy pasting? 😂
I think it is not even bukhari who wrote in it.
The so-called "Monkey Adultery Hadith" is not actually a hadith from the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. It's based on a story told by Amr ibn Maymun, who described something he claimed to have seen before becoming Muslim. He said he saw a group of monkeys stoning a female monkey for "adultery." What You Should Know: Not a Hadith: This story doesn’t come from the Prophet ﷺ. It’s just something Amr ibn Maymun said he witnessed, and it has no religious or legal significance in Islam. Likely Folklore: Scholars generally see this as either folklore or a misinterpretation of animal behaviour. Islam doesn’t apply human moral rules, like those about adultery, to animals. Why It’s in Al-Bukhari: Imam Al-Bukhari included this story in his book as part of historical accounts, not as a religious teaching. Early scholars often recorded various narrations, even if they weren’t verified, to preserve them. The Bottom Line: This "monkey adultery" story is not an Islamic teaching. It’s just a story from history, and it has no real importance in Islam.
Fabricated hadiths with clear issues are discarded, but what about the fabricated ones that don't have clear issues? What if someone competent came up with them, to the point that you can't distinguish it from authentic ones?
what kind of thinking results in someone choosing to insert this into a book of hadith ?
@@danieldenona3806You asked "what kind of thinking" that would insert this story of monkey-adultery? The Sunni, Shiite & Sectarian kinds! It is obvious to Muslims that the Sunnis, Shiites & Sectarians have invented their religion through books attributed to Bukhari et al. _peace_
So because of this there is no god but god, praying does not make sense, fasting is not healthy, paying alms only for stupid and going on a pilgrimage a waste of money ? 😅 Funny how someone who does not have proper arguments simply tries to deviate and/or make fun of things he does not understand or like...by far one of the weakest apporaches possible A lack of quality paired with a lack of intellectualism leads to such contents... In the end those who laugh about otheres will laughed about 🤷♂️
Most comprehensive video on this topic…eye-opener
guys can someone tell what channel this is, i wanna know what this channel is islamophobic or the opposite cuz there is no channel description. plz tell im a bit dumb
It seems like a Qurani sect channel. They try tooth and nail to refute hadith, try to find contradictions and other reasons to refuse them(spoiler there is none), and they are not considered Muslims by the consensus of all Muslims wether be salafis esharis maturities etc etc,
Good question, I'm confused myself. I'm staying away from this channel just to be on safe side, v shouldn't play with fire.
The so-called "Monkey Adultery Hadith" is not actually a hadith from the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. It's based on a story told by a man named Amr ibn Maymun, who described something he claimed to have seen before he became Muslim. He said he saw a group of monkeys stoning a female monkey for "adultery." What You Should Know: Not a Hadith: This story doesn’t come from the Prophet ﷺ. It’s just something Amr ibn Maymun said he witnessed, and it has no religious or legal significance in Islam. Likely Folklore: Scholars generally see this as either folklore or a misinterpretation of animal behavior. Islam doesn’t apply human moral rules, like those about adultery, to animals. Why It’s in Al-Bukhari: Imam Al-Bukhari included this story in his book as part of historical accounts, not as a religious teaching. Early scholars often recorded various narrations, even if they weren’t verified, just to preserve them. The Bottom Line: This "monkey adultery" story is not an Islamic teaching. It’s just a story from history, and it has no real importance in Islam.
@@ZhyarBakerSo why is it written in Sahih Bukhari? People should have created a separate section for historical gossip. Now, it has a place in Islam because some people try to make sense of it and attempt to extrapolate Shariah hukm (Islamic rulings) or derive wisdom from its wording..
This'll blow up... Loved the explanation😂😂
That’s not a Hadith. Read what definition of Hadith is
Even so, why did bukhari include this ridiculous story
@ it’s an analogy by ‘Amr. Why would I know why bukhari added it to his collection? Sometimes athar are collected to get a fuller idea of people who appear in chains of narration elsewhere to build a character profile. If you check what is recorded by Amr bin Maimun it’s normally about the sahaba and not direct quotes from the prophet(saw). The sahih was used by scholars and not laymen while the Quran is accessible to all.
@@BeNGALi4LFE the so-called "Monkey Adultery Hadith" is not actually a hadith from the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. It's based on a story told by a man named Amr ibn Maymun, who described something he claimed to have seen before he became Muslim. He said he saw a group of monkeys stoning a female monkey for "adultery." What You Should Know: Not a Hadith: This story doesn’t come from the Prophet ﷺ. It’s just something Amr ibn Maymun said he witnessed, and it has no religious or legal significance in Islam. Likely Folklore: Scholars generally see this as either folklore or a misinterpretation of animal behavior. Islam doesn’t apply human moral rules, like those about adultery, to animals. Why It’s in Al-Bukhari: Imam Al-Bukhari included this story in his book as part of historical accounts, not as a religious teaching. Early scholars often recorded various narrations, even if they weren’t verified, just to preserve them. The Bottom Line: This "monkey adultery" story is not an Islamic teaching. It’s just a story from history, and it has no real importance in Islam.
Whenever you try to do taweel (interpretation) on this ridiculous hadith, ask yourself why this wasn’t addressed by the original commentators. Even the person who wrote the sharh (explanation) was born 50-100 years after the original narrator had passed away.
@@Hadeed20it's qouting from sahabi so it's not a hadith..just write this on footnote of hadith so we'll not get confused..we have read 10 different books to understand this hadith..
Hey, stop monkeying around!
Look at all these kuffaar zanadiqah in the comments. May Allah guide them to Islam