Quran Talk - The Prophet Was Not Illiterate
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Discord: / discord
Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk
Video Notes:
qurantalkblog....
qurantalkblog....
qurantalkblog....
qurantalkblog....
qurantalkblog....
qurantalkblog....
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: / talkquran
Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog....
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudy...
Additional Resources: www.quraniclab...
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitb...
Refuting typical arguments against Quran alone: qurantalk.gitb...
Masha'Allaah. Wow! Ummy/Gentile Prophet. Never thought about that. When we abandon the Quran, we miss out on real jewels.
it is known that Allah guides the ones to want to be guided,
Allah is arabic for the creator, because the most high is the most high everything beneath is creation, i think you have no understanding and acceptance that there is an arabic language with a clear meaning of the creator.
That why in chapter 96 it starts with speaks in the name of your creator who created you from a form of blood.
He did not use speak in the name of allah, because many people thinks it is about languages and names,
It is not it is about the creator of everything.
Because the people who received books before where known about ilahe in the language what was known between the children of Adam nuh Ibrahim Ismaël ishak jacub jusuf Musa eesa and the tribes in that ground, ilahe means creator and Allah means the creator because the creator is one.
So the creator is known as al Ali the most high.
Al kahar the destructor , al hay the living
So you are stuck with one arabic word, and youre heart is hardened but there still water in it, people like hijab has some problems in there harts it is hardened with sunnism and salafism based on mankind books from people who made fun with the one Allah sended to the opposite of the people of the book, , Allah guides all creation not only descendens of the people of the book, but this people where not an easy people they invented missguidance, only they misguid thereselves and think they are not, Allah helps them in there war against him. Allah is the best helper, not the misguider, if someone wants to be misguided the most high will help him in his willing,.
Only Allah gives his creation time to repent before the hour comes, he is the most forgiving the most high, he is the creator.
The knower, ..
This is what i think to know so far, i am not free of faults, this far it makes sense to me,
I agree with you, it’s a lie and an insult to our prophet when people say he was an illiterate.
All prophets of god were literate, best public speaker of their time, reformers, great leaders etc
If the Prophet of Allah pbuh was not illiterate then why did he have trusted scribes write down the Qur’an for him. Why did he not write it down himself?
@@joshuacook402 My answer might surprise you, he didn’t write the moral laws and principals mentioned in the Quran. In fact, the first messenger who is mentioned in the Quran i.e., Noah also didn’t write any of those laws.
Those laws were developed, practiced, and further enhanced over thousands of years by hundreds of generations then written and rewritten to be passed down by the Noble scribers over centuries before prophets (all messengers were simply the deliverers, applicators, implementers, drivers, executors of those messages).
When Quran talks about the inspirations and revelations of prophets as “Wahi” these were the self-discovered or previously discovered universal moral laws by the earlier prophets or wise men/ women.
I will give you an example, the way Newton supposedly self-discovered the laws of gravity or probably got inspiration or influenced by previous of contemporary theories on the subject of gravity written or explained by other unknown noble physicists who helped Newton understand the subject little further. Nobody knows about the previous personalities who set started their journey of finding some clues or reasoning or understanding on the subject of gravity.
Similarly, all the current physical laws were revealed to the humanity by the works of hundreds of noble thinkers.
Exactly, in the same manner all the moral laws were discovered, practiced, written down and revealed to some noble writers, philosophers, prophets and messengers.
Nobody knows when and who transcribed those moral laws. There were several such noble writers who
Was he born littered
I would hope you won't run tell Allah that! Allah does what He wills and just like He made our beloved mother Maryam pregnant as a virgin, He also was able to give our beloved Prophet revelation of the Qur'an! This was his miracle for him. Period!!
@@SheIsNaimah you are a Witness did you use a time travel device.
Ore do you believe in stories told by story tellers, Allah knows if you understand the logic
Great video brother .. to my understanding, Illiterate in Quran and Ibrahimic locution means he had no knowledge of old scriptures . He did not know of Torah or Bible
Brother, can we have contact? I have some questions that are verry important to me. I like your videos and thank you for the effort.
Check the bio
Unschooled in the previous writ/scriptures is how Sam Gerrans explains the meaning of 'ummy' which is very close to what you have brought about through this video. Very well researched.
Exactly, I totally agree great video! the Arabic word ummi is related to the word ummah which means community / nation, the word ummi indeed means gentiles and refers to a person from another nation or someone who has not read any scripture and it’s parralel to the Hebrew word “goyim” which English literally translates to Gentiles / Nations
Secondly it says in the Torah indeed:
1. Leviticus 19:33-34 (NIV):
“When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not mistreat them. The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the LORD your God.”
2. Exodus 22:21 (NIV):
“Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt.”
3. Deuteronomy 10:19 (NIV):
“And you are to love those who are foreigners, for you yourselves were foreigners in Egypt.”
The Torah clearly states to tread gentiles / people from another nation as your own and yet they toss the book right over their shoulders and neglect the scripture
The word gentile is incorrect in that definition you gave, see, for example, Merriam Webster:
gentile
1 of 2
noun
gen·tile ˈjen-ˌtī(-ə)l
pluralgentiles
Synonyms of gentile
1
often capitalized : a person of a non-Jewish nation or of non-Jewish faith
especially : a Christian as distinguished from a Jew
2
: HEATHEN entry 2 sense 1
3
often capitalized : a non-Mormon
gentile
2 of 2
adjective
1
often capitalized
a
: of or relating to the nations at large as distinguished from the Jews
also : of or relating to Christians as distinguished from the Jews
b
: of or relating to non-Mormons
2
: PAGAN
3
[borrowed from Latin gentīlis] : relating to a tribe or clan.
The word is applied to any group or person outside of bani Israel whereas a goy is any nation, including Israel. The verses you cite from Torah are not applicable to those enemies laying siege to or invading your borders.
Nice topic brother wantherfull delivery MahasaEllah
Very smart like usual 😊
Keep it up.
Interesting suggestions. My friend who is a Shia Moslem told me in the Shia school of thought suggest that the Prophet (Pbuh) was not ‘unlettered/Gentile’ (Ummi). Even any ‘lettered man/Gentile’ is not capable of creating the Quran - still a miracle in so many ways. The arguments made in this video are similar to those made by my friend. They look compelling on the surface.
The contents of this channel are problematic.
@spandonsaha5210 so Quran is problematic
Salamu Alaikum, Brother May Allah guide us to this journey the Quran alone May Allah Bless.Jazak Allah Karin.
Another circumstantial proof of the prophet's literacy is the fact he was a trader by profession and trading in Arabia of that time was conducted using abj'd, a gemtrical system that replaces letters with numbers (alef is 1, ba is 2 and so forth) . So it would have been highly improbable for him to have known numbers and sums, an absolute mainstay of trading, without having known letters.
but when angel started to choking him and told him 3 times to read he clearly said I CAN NOT READ
Praise God
I don't read Arabic, but some context would b appreciated. Sahih Muslim 1080n translates to 'We are an unlettered people who can neither write nor count. The month is thus, and thus. folding his thumb when he said it the third time.'. Here, the term 'unlettered' seems to mean someone who can't write or count. Is the 'unlettered' word here different to the one in the Quran?
For my tiny brain, The prophet PBUH cannot read or write an Arabic letters.
The problem is you don't believe it that he cannot read and write. Who put the limitation on certain people is Allah, you can learn read or write doesn't mean other people can do the same.
and strangely, People in the past had more memory for remember things but majority of them cannot read or write, go figure.
you can make "Illiterate" as dont have the knowledge. the verse at the end still applied to the whole world.
and with your suggestion here did you speak out before to other people before or just make it the video and make a post on yt?
I just realize your topic here is just want to make a connection somewhere else. xd
God bless you
Praise God!
Muhammad was a successful merchant. The “Muslim scholars” who fabricated the illiteracy lie forgot that there were no numbers during the Prophet’s time; the letters of the alphabet were used as numbers; similar to roman numerals. As a merchant dealing with numbers every day, the Prophet had to know the alphabet, from one to one-thousand.
Even the contemporary adversaries to the prophet acknowledged that he could read and write. This is stated in the following verse.
[25:5] They also said, “Tales from the past that he wrote down; they were dictated to him day and night.”
(٥) وَقَالُوا أَسَاطِيرُ الْأَوَّلِينَ اكْتَتَبَهَا فَهِيَ تُمْلَىٰ عَلَيْهِ بُكْرَةً وَأَصِيلًا
Subhanallah you are wright.
Once you have read and understood the Quran, you will definitely be certain that the assertion by the Sunni/Shiite/Sectarian scholars about the _"illiterate prophet"_ is nothing but a man-invented lie against the prophet!
Come on... how is it possible for Allah to send a KITAB to a person who cannot read or write?
What is a KITAB?
A collection of pages inscribed!
A collection of written pages.
peace to the world... *there is only one book we must read before we die... The Quran.*
You also contradict The Torah. And Allah sent Gabriel, the same, God, sent the 10 Devarim to bani Israel, and many there were literate.
@@nickmansfield1 Let us be serious and let me ask you 3 questions:
What is _"10 Devarim?"_
And, how do you know that there were literates among the bani israel at the time? Were you there? Or, did any of the people you heard the story from were present at the time?
It is CRYSTAL CLEAR you are just regurgigating lies & tall stories so often that you think they are _"historical facts!"_
_peace on earth_
*there is only one book we must read before we die... The Quran.*
@@nickmansfield1 Tell me something... how could you be certain that _"many there were literate?"_
Were you or any of the people you gleaned this from, present to count the number of _"literate"_ heads?
Or, it is just a story made up and regurgitated by those with personal interest?
_peace to the world_
*there is only one book one must read before we die... The Quran.*
Firstly, there are NO MIRACLES mentioned in the Quran!
You have mistranslated & mis-interpreted 17:59 as: _"What stopped us from sending the _"miracles"_ is that the previous generations have "rejected" ( كَذَّبَ ) them. For example, We showed Thamud the camel, a profound (miracle,) but they transgressed against it. We sent "miracles" only to instill reverence.
There are many proofs in 17:59 to disprove your assertion of _"miracles"_ in that verse.
Firstly, the Arabic word ( كَذَّبَ ) actually means *FABRICATE/INVENT A LIE.*
So... how is it possible to *fabricate a lie* against a _"miracle?"_
Contrary to the popular Sunni/Shiite/Sectarian belief, an Arabic word CANNOT have multiple BUT opposite meanings!!!!
For example, an _"ayat"_ can be taken as a verse or a sign or a symbol BUT there is ABSOLUTELY no way that it could also be _"a miracle!"_
WHY?
Easy peasy... what are signs or symbols or verses?
Are they NOT something that is PHYSICAL/bashar/MORTAL?
Are they not something PROVABLE? Something which any decent sane thinking human can verify & testify with their intellect/heart/mind, hearing and sight across the ages, i.e. able to withstand the passing of time?
So... now use your AQAL... can a _"miracle"_ be testified & verified by any decent sane thinking who is NOT present at that *particular instant in time?*
If you *"believed in miracles"* then what you are saying is that _your invented God is limited in power and could only perform miracles only once and your God is prone to FAVORITISM!!!_
There are other tangible proofs in 17:59 to dispel, beyond any shadow of doubt, that THERE ARE NO MIRACLES in the QURAN!
... to be continued...
this! i alwys thought 29:47/48 makes no sense with the illiterate argument. why would God say youve never a read a Book or written one with your right hand, if Muhammad didn't actually write it? especially then referencing the right hand in the Context of adding sth to the Koran in another verse?
21:00 His relative was familiar with the earlier scriptures when Gabriel began teaching him.
Why did he not write The Qur'an, or most of it, himself, if he was fully literate from the beginning of his ministry? I have heard from a Shia scholar that he became literate over time.
27:50 Your premise there is utterly false, The Torah decrees one who does not read will be asked to recite in a challenging language. It is not found in Isa.42, these are attributed to The Davidic Messiah. You do not have to reinterpret the language of The Qur'an in this instance, simply accept the truth and the miracle in their fullness. Isa.49 - S17: 104, prophecy unfulfilled in the days of islam's messenger. Deut.33:2 is very clear about Islam and the fiery judgment on faith to the nations, not for bani Israel, fulfilled towards the end of the ministry of the messenger of Allah, and S61:6 depends upon this verse as well as ib. 18: 18.
38:20 S2: 78 is very clear about the usage and the meaning for illiterate, or possibly semi-literate. The subject is clearly, them, in the succeeding verse, not those unaware. Again S3: 20 is consistent with the usage elsewhere. Critically, 35:15, S7: 157-8 are consistent with 62: 2.
Of course I could be wrong and the pagan Arabs were actually big on education for the masses just like the rest of the world in that time, The Dark Ages.
❤ we bear witness that there is no other god besides God.❤
Why is this in my feed? I dont need this youtube.
Brother is it permitted to marry a sunni when you have no other option?
Good question 😞
huh ( ಠ ▵ ಠ)? what are you?
The wird is unlettered,not illitrate. He didn't know how to read or write doesn't mean he couldn't understand when it was read to him. Doesn't mean he waant intelligent.
The fact that he could read does not make him intelligent either
You really need to consult an English dictionary:
illiterate
adjective
il·lit·er·ate (ˌ)i(l)-ˈli-t(ə-)rət
Synonyms of illiterate
1
: having little or no education
especially : unable to read or write
an illiterate population
2
: showing or marked by a lack of acquaintance with the fundamentals of a particular field of knowledge
musically illiterate
3
a
: violating approved patterns of speaking or writing
b
: showing or marked by a lack of familiarity with language and literature
an illiterate magazine
salam brother, have been checking u and some other people, who are doing this life changing work, in fact it might change the minds of the emerging youth just only if they pay a little attention. what is your information about, jinns, ruqyah/exorcism ??? i would like u to produce a video on that, the actual genuine ruling and teachings of Quran on the matter, thanks for the work. ur work is a bomb on the flock of sheep, May Allah wake us all up
aameen
The word kitab كتاب doesnt just mean book, it is one of its meanings but in arabic it is a verbal noun which can also imply law or rulings however you wish to understand it. See one example here. The word below is كتب which is plural of كتاب.
Al-Bayyinah 98:3
فِيهَا كُتُبٌ قَيِّمَةٌ
Within which are correct writings [i.e., rulings and laws].
Can we get app developers to create an app to unite quran only muslims. Help us make our own congregation and mosques etc. Find the real belivers and stick with them.
God has opened our eyes to know that, hadith books were written by the enemies and hypocrites of Allah religion.
alhamdulillah..... but the miracle only can perform by prophet.... not normal human.... and the miracle is always happen when we hard work for that, that the only miracle we can do base on the hard work.... example human is killing each other, but when the correct islam is there, human can live together harmony similarly like a cell .... so for us that a miracle to happen... but for got that is not miracle, if we follow only his command... this is how logical path works...
Both are true, he was both the Ishmaelite prophet promised in the torah and injeel, and he was also illiterate. Many of the sahih hadiths show that the prophet could not read or write, and he had someone with him to read and write for him.
the torah says "the book will be given to the one who cannot read" talking about the Ishmaelite prophet
Stop deceiving yourself and stop lying.
The Bible never promised and prophet fro Ismael lineage.
@@Law-g5y so God will bless Ishmael by making him into a great nation of disbelievers?
@@r1ght3ousness-of-the-faith Ishmael is irrelevant to our God Jehovah.
Ishmael went out of Israel and never came back and was not part of the promise of God to the people of God
@@Law-g5y Yehovah is God of all. Ishmael was circumcised and, therefore, part of the Abrahamic Covenant, you will possess your enemies' gate, read, Battle of Khaybar! In Matthew 21:43 he is a nation bearing fruit, not Esav/Rome. Go back to Moses, Mohammad is the one like Moses, bringing a law, a fiery judgment on faith, ash-dat, to the nations, Deut.33:2, etc. The codes for the names are embedded in the gematria as an encryption against the heretics.
4:51 Hast thou not turned Thy vision to those who were given a portion of the Book? they believe in superstition and Lies, and say to the Unbelievers that they are better guided in the right way Than the believers
Is their a Quran with this perfect correction 🙏
Yes, The Quran A Complete Revelation translated by Sam Gerrans
I don’t believe the prophet Muhammad was illiterate… he was a successful and fairly well traveled merchant he probably had lots of knowledge.
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
I agree that the prophet was not illiterate but ما أنا بقارئ says ‘ I’m not a reader.’ The verb for recite is تلى - يتلو - talaa - yatlu
when jibreel alaihe esalam came to the prophet peace be upon him he probably had a tablet with him and he then taught him how to read it just by a command then the prophet pbuh didn't need to take the thing with him he memorized the verses in his heart
😂from imam bukhari?
As far as the hadith and sirah (biography of the Prophet) is concerned, it is unthinkable to me that none of the multitude of companions of the Prophet knew that he can read & write.
Yes. I Think the ability to read/write was quite a rare things for arabian people at that time. The time where paganism were rampant, wars between tribes & clans, etc and its even called jahilliya/ignorance era. Ability to read/write was there, but only to handful of privileged ones amongst the arab, to poets, or maybe its more common for jews & christians. Hence "illiterate nation" is a valid term. And if the prophet recited the Book while claiming he hasnt read/ write before, people wouldn't see it as a miracle anyway for the facts that hes from quraish tribe and that they think the quran is just some sort of plagiarized work of bible & torah from jews/christians living there.
I believe tho that only at later years that the prophet pbuh could read/write. Just as the quran was revealed at stages, he has 20+ years to gradually learning how to read/write from his companions.
The Prophet, PBUH, was a merchant for about 20 years before becoming a prophet. I would imagine that being able to read/write, especially numbers would've benefited him and the business he conducted in the name of his Wife over that time, even if he didn't really do it that much until he was a prophet.
The Prophet's SAW miracle was the Quran, there is no need to try and make his story grandeur by making him illiterate too.
it's mentioned many times in the quran that prophet couldn't read or write, not just the word "ummi"
please don't be misinformed by these false pretenses trying to "protect" our prophet
Please provide the evidence, i.e. surah & verse, for your Sunni/Shiite/Sectarian lie about the prophet who you assumed could neither read nor write!
But, we all know that you, Sunnis/Shiites/Sectarians are just LIARS, don't we?
peace on earth... *there is only one book we must read before we die... The Quran.*
verse?
@@arkkromas1307 alankabut:48
@@zaidkiwan5168 Good proof.
[17:50] He debunks your understanding of Surah 29:48
וַיִּקְרָ֖א אֶל־משֶׁ֑ה
How can iqra mean just recite when in Arabic it’s used to mean read? People try to deny the truth of the Quran.
Because so many scholars of Qur'anic Arabic tell how it's a wrong translation. I had a video explaining this before too, but essentially Iqra means read, but not read as in read off of smth, but as in recite. And when the Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) said I cannot read when told to read, a more accurate translation when you look at the Arabic word and how it was used, it is actually more accurately translated to I will not read.
Your fabricated had prove he could read and write
.on his death bed he said give me a pen and paper ii write something
In making an agreement to avert war the agreement was written signed by prophet.
It was rejected by other party and he cancelled tiltle and wrote his named
More evidence
There are two scenarios of the sngel
1 said read
2 said recite
He answered i cant recite
Its falsly translated as read but iqra is best translated recite
S7:157 cannot be disputed.
9:55 Other information I have heard from Shia sources asserts that, in terms of letters to the kings, the messenger dictated them.
@@huntertyler355 The extant Torah and the code of Achmad, Mohammad, and the rest of the proofs which are more plain. And:
Isaiah 29:11-12:
And to you it becomes a vision of the-all; as words of The-Scroll, the sealed-one, which they give to one who knows reading (var.) to say, “Do, read (recite) this.”
And he said, “I am not empowered, for it is sealed.”
And The-Scroll was given to one-who did not know reading to say, “Do, read (recite) this.”
And he said, “I did not know reading.”
The word used in that verse is ‘ummiyyun’ meaning unschooled. = The Prophet was not a gentile and did not know the scriptures.
@@peacemakermind Yes, unschooled and illiterate, these are synonyms.
Not a gentile, what do you mean by this?
I truly believe that it was absurd to think of a super-intelligent person, who graded internationally for his wife Khadija was illiterate. BUT, I am sorry, I could not find MANY of the verses you quote in the Qur'an.
You make s mistake to say a gentile prophet is mentioned in the isaiah 42 texts.this even contradicts with your muslim claims that mohamed and arabs are descendants of ishmael.which is false
Today we know its lies mohamed is from yemen.
Only Arabs ie desert dwellers from northern araia ...petra are of abraham
God makes a covenant with Abraham that in him All families of the earth would be blessed .this clearly is abraham isaac and jacob not hagar or ketruah line
Lastly can you produce a verse in quran which says allah said a gentile prophet is mentioned in the tanakh particularly in the books of the prophets?
Here you are wrong.
In NT this is quoted as regering to christ
Quran says mentioned in torah and injil.
Isaiah is in the prophets not mentioned in quran its not in torah.
So that text had nothing to do with quthum bin abudallah
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
Hadith of pen and paper too
No prophet had supernatural miracles.
Keep deceiving yourself
@@Law-g5y not
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
@@bashirahmadnoori6750 there’s no explanation.
@@Law-g5y only u r.
Isaiah is about Jesus, not Muhammad.
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
7:03 This was to be understood as a fulfillment of Isaiah 29:12, if i'm not mistaken. (But why can't the person not read? Perhaps because he doesn't know the language the text is in, not necessarily not knowing how to read per se in arabic)
Allahu 3alam to be honest.
I know the Quran is from God without needing anything else, but i do believe it fullfills prophecy as the Quran seems to reference that, and it makes sense.
By shias, we believe he could read and write. And not only that, but he knew all the languages of the world
Of the universe😂?
Brother there was no miracle in the past and there has been no miracle shown by Allah nor any previous prophets. Ayath is not a miracle and miracle is not an ayath.
@InnocentBigWaterfall-uq7cx I didn’t read anything like that in the text of the Quran. Translations will say whatever they want but can they prove it using Arabic text of the Quran? I don’t think so.
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
Weak arguments
Prophet Muhammad saww was given many miracles by Allah. The Quran itself records some of these miracles which are verified in hadith also.
For example.. the Quran says in the Battle of Badr Allah sent angels to help the small muslim army against the huge army of disbelievers. The hadith verifies this as many people saw those angels fighting alongside them.
Cannot believe you have made this video to diminish the miracles Allah sent to Prophet Muhammad saww.
Shame on you.
Your knowledge/understanding of quran and sirah seems poor.
Kindly remove this video.
If the Prophet Muhammad saww could read and write himself, he would have recorded the Quran himself during his life in the form of 1 book. However he did not. Instead he had different scribes who he would call to have the ayats written down. The Quran was compiled after the Prophet saww passed away.
I hope this is not a US funded video/ channel to spread false ideas about Islam.
The Qur'an is a fabrication.....all talk but no proof of anything
You mean, the no longer functioning, formerly democratic Constitution led federation of the USA, now governed by their military-industrial complex, since possibly 7 months before their 20 (2x) elections?
Most other nations are also led by despicable, democidal tyrants.
Hadith can't verify Quran is not produced by Allah or the prophet is the other way round the Quran is what can verify a hadith
0:57 Brother, you cannot even pronounce Arabic words properly.
He has got rewarded for making mistakes
Most Muslims are not Arabs, nor is Arabic the main language for most Muslims, not having the correct accent/pronunciation is not indicative of the information shown in this video.
Unless you are advocating for Arabian dominance in a religion meant for all people of the world, where Arabs are also a small minority of the worlds population, you have not made argument for the information in this video.
Simple facts
Mohamed was literate
Ummi has meaning of those who dont know the scriptures
No gentile prophet in the Abeahamic covenant
In quran it says mentioned in torah and injil but isaiah is mot in sny of those
Hence islams thrives on
1.lies
2fsbricationd
3.teisting verses
4.wrong translations to make a point ie angel gabriel is holy spirit or private patrts is sleeve or ummi means cant read or write
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
Show faces of your scholars and speakers who are giving you these false ideas about Islam.
Mainly all the hanbali ibn teymiyite wahabite and madkhalite and all thiers ramifications
Exactly!!! Whoever this is putting this misinformation out needa to go back and study with some scholars or are they simply enemies of Islam? 🤔 Subhan'Allah. 😊
But the hadith is sahih, if he couldn't write wouldn't they of known it?
Itjihad lead me to Allah
"حَدَّثَنَا يَحْيَى بْنُ سُلَيْمَانَ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنِي ابْنُ وَهْبٍ، قَالَ أَخْبَرَنِي يُونُسُ، عَنِ ابْنِ شِهَابٍ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، قَالَ لَمَّا اشْتَدَّ بِالنَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَجَعُهُ قَالَ " ائْتُونِي بِكِتَابٍ أَكْتُبُ لَكُمْ كِتَابًا لاَ تَضِلُّوا بَعْدَهُ ". قَالَ عُمَرُ إِنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم غَلَبَهُ الْوَجَعُ وَعِنْدَنَا كِتَابُ اللَّهِ حَسْبُنَا فَاخْتَلَفُوا وَكَثُرَ اللَّغَطُ. قَالَ " قُومُوا عَنِّي، وَلاَ يَنْبَغِي عِنْدِي التَّنَازُعُ ". فَخَرَجَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ يَقُولُ إِنَّ الرَّزِيَّةَ كُلَّ الرَّزِيَّةِ مَا حَالَ بَيْنَ رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَبَيْنَ كِتَابِهِ."
Narrated 'Ubaidullah bin `Abdullah:
Ibn `Abbas said, "When the ailment of the Prophet (ﷺ) became worse, he said, 'Bring for me (writing) paper and I will write for you a statement after which you will not go astray.' But `Umar said, 'The Prophet (ﷺ) is seriously ill, and we have got Allah's Book with us and that is sufficient for us.' But the companions of the Prophet (ﷺ) differed about this and there was a hue and cry. On that the Prophet (ﷺ) said to them, 'Go away (and leave me alone). It is not right that you should quarrel in front of me." Ibn `Abbas came out saying, "It was most unfortunate (a great disaster) that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was prevented from writing that statement for them because of their disagreement and noise.
@@steveryder1174 Assala aleikum. Please, Can you tell me what the number this hadiz is?
why don't u bring your evidence 😂 oops u don't have
The so-called "prophet" was not a prophet.
You don’t believe in God I see
@@BM8C7
I believe in God, not in false gods as al-Lah.
@@BM8C7
I don't believe in muhamad. And you say to me : "you don't believe in God" for muhamad is your god. Even al-Lah does salât for muhamad (sura 33, verse 56).
@@vousetesleseldelaterreyou don't know what salat means, it does not mean prayer, we seek salat and Allah does salat upon us.
@@hello_worLd6104
so is salât a divine action ?
In surah Al Alaq we can see that Gabriel/jebreel. Taught Muhammad to read.
"Read, ˹O Prophet,˺ in the Name of your Lord Who created"
96 : 1
Then later gabriel orders Muhammad to read for the second time in the same surah
"Read! And your Lord is the Most Generous,"
96 : 3
If we just use Qur'an without any context mentioned by hadist we can't know what happened in this revelation of Muhammad (Saw) AND, those two verses was supporting what the hadist said about Muhammad(Saw) being illiterate. But if you insist on taking just the Qur'an you will question yourself about why Gabriel commands our prophet To read twice, and so other verses in Qur'an that needs to be understood in context.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is proof that the word " Ummy " always referred to as Gentiles and not " illiterate " . If we believe that Muhammad leads trade missions for Khadijah before prophethood , he must have known how to read/write trade accounts. At the time the arabs use the letters to represent numbers similar to the romans.
In English:
illiterate
adjective
il·lit·er·ate (ˌ)i(l)-ˈli-t(ə-)rət
Synonyms of illiterate
1
: having little or no education
especially : unable to read or write
an illiterate population
2
: showing or marked by a lack of acquaintance with the fundamentals of a particular field of knowledge
musically illiterate
3
a
: violating approved patterns of speaking or writing
b
: showing or marked by a lack of familiarity with language and literature
an illiterate magazine.
Your definitions need to take conventional language into account.
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90
@@bashirahmadnoori6750 I can do it in one proper noun: Satan.
We ar living in the end time because every day we see coming with ridiculous things.now ur are telling us the prophet was not ilitrate.how can we believe someone like u and ignore the ulemaa before u
Talk to Christian PRINCE ,sam shamun, godlogic. Learn the facts. Rest is all imaginations. Joke
They will cook him.
@vousetesleseldelaterre ...they will agree with him on this topic actually.
This topic is in alignment with Christian Prince
The Trinity Explained : -
ua-cam.com/play/PL5cck_lh9aZdNEoTNzc8u_SHunGvLKIMD.html&si=GtJIa9qFUtTwqy90