Phoebe Goh
Phoebe Goh
  • 16
  • 51 646
Can you make a quinoa seeded sourdough bread?
I am sharing my recipe on how to use quinoa and dark rye flour to create a beautiful loaf of delicious and nutritious sourdough bread. If you like seeded sourdough bread, you come to the right place. I am also using an ingredient called okara (soymilk pulp). If you make your own soybean milk and do not know what to do with the pulp, this is one good way to use it. Quinoa flour tastes a little bitter, and okara is sweet, they compromised each other really well in this combination. Please try it and let me know how you like it.
05:38 Ingredients
05:42 Oven temperature
05:45 Message from Phoebe
#quinoaseededsourdough #phoebessourdough #100percentwholegrain
Переглядів: 1 500

Відео

Vegan Oyster Mushroom Crostini Appetizer | Mushroom Feast 2/4
Переглядів 1574 роки тому
Delicious vegan oyster mushroom crostini appetizer recipe, all-time favorite, easy vegan recipe, a good lean meal plan or make it for a mushroom feast side dish or appetizer, you must try it. 06:08 Vegan oyster mushroom crostini appetizer ingredients. 06:21 Phoebe is tasting the vegan oyster mushroom crostini appetizer. 06:25 Link to watch vegan portobello mushroom soup - ua-cam.com/video/8XFk-...
Vegan Portobello Mushroom Soup | Mushroom Feast 1/4
Переглядів 3304 роки тому
Delicious vegan portobello mushroom soup recipe, all-time favorite, easy vegan recipe, cream-free mushroom soup, a good lean meal plan or make it for a mushroom feast dish or first course, you must try it. 08:50 Link to watch oyster mushroom crostini - ua-cam.com/video/fUIyaLGsN3U/v-deo.html 08:53 Vegan portobello mushroom soup ingredients. 08:58 Phoebe is tasting the vegan portobello mushroom ...
Bone in ribeye reverse sear
Переглядів 564 роки тому
Reverse sear is the easiest cooking method for any kind of thick-cut steak. The steak remains juicy, flavorful, and easy to cook into perfection for any steak doneness you prefer. Please see the internal temperature degree of steak doneness below. 3:25 - The general guideline for the internal temperature degree of steak doneness (English). 3:30 - The general guideline for the internal temperatu...
Artisanal 100% Rye Sourdough Bread from the beginning to the end.
Переглядів 46 тис.4 роки тому
Learn how to bake an artisanal 100% pure rye flour sourdough bread from the beginning to the end. No commercial yeast added, using only strong rye flour sourdough starter. It is delicious, rustic, and lasts for a long time. This rye sourdough bread freezes well in the freezer. Great taste and texture. It is a "must-have" rye sourdough bread at home. #artisanalryesourdoughbread #onlyryeflour
Testing New Sourdough Starter | By Phoebe’s Sourdough.
Переглядів 4094 роки тому
Testing the strength of my two-week old whole grain spelt sourdough starter and transforming it into a tasty loaf of semolina sourdough bread. This recipe is adapted from Swathi Iyer/ Zesty South Indian Kitchen, check it out. ua-cam.com/video/UisjHYFaJo4/v-deo.html You will find: Ingredients (English & Chinese): 00:00:18.089 - 00:00:22 Kneading the dough: 00:03:00 - 00:03:15 Shaping the dough: ...
Let’s Make Pasta Alla Bolognese!
Переглядів 714 роки тому
Let's Make Pasta Alla Bolognese! I learned the pasta sauce recipe from an Italian friend many years ago and mastered it. My friend's mum always says the longer you simmer the sauce the better it gets. Low and slow... the Bolognese sauce will smile at you! Sauce simmering time: 1 hour 30 mins. Prep time: 10 mins. Portion: 6 people Pasta: 1 packet of spaghetti Ingredients: 1 Leek - Thin slice, I ...
How To Make Your Own Natural Sourdough Starter From Scratch | By Phoebe's Sourdough.
Переглядів 1,3 тис.4 роки тому
How to make your own natural sourdough starter from scratch in 4 easy steps, 2 ingredients, patience and big smiles! Please see the feeding schedule below. INGREDIENTS: 1. Organic whole grain spelt flour. 2. Filtered water at room temperature. NOTE: You can choose any flour to make the sourdough starter that includes gluten-free flour. As for water, I have used mineral water before. I found it ...
How to make FRIED RICE II | Easy Dinner Recipes Part 2
Переглядів 1094 роки тому
Got the munchies! Fried rice is one of the best! How to make amazing fried rice at home in 2020. All you need is 8 minutes of cooking time, fast and easy, step by step from preparing the ingredients to start cooking and finish cooking it. How to make FRIED RICE I | Easy Dinner Recipes Part 1 Link: ua-cam.com/video/pJS60DJirSs/v-deo.html Part 1 is showing how to prepare the ingredients and what ...
How to make FRIED RICE I | Easy Dinner Recipes Part 1
Переглядів 764 роки тому
How to make amazing fried rice at home in 2020. All you need is 8 minutes of cooking time, fast and easy, step by step from preparing the ingredients to start cooking and finish cooking it. How to make FRIED RICE I | Easy Dinner Recipes Part 1 Link: ua-cam.com/video/pJS60DJirSs/v-deo.html Part 1 is showing how to PREPARE THE INGREDIENTS and what ingredients are needed. Preparing the ingredients...
HOW TO WHISK MATCHA AT HOME | EASY AS 123
Переглядів 964 роки тому
How to prepare a traditional matcha tea at home. It is fast and healthy, I love the energy I got from it. I am making slightly thicker matcha today than usual. I want to get the oomph of it. If you would like to make thin matcha, you can do the same as the video above and then add hot water slowly from the side of the bowl. You will keep the matcha foam structure together by doing this way. The...
Fast and Easy Dinner Recipes | Pan Seared Scallops
Переглядів 1884 роки тому
How to pan sear scallops. I am making a quick dinner using fresh scallops, sweet potatoes, and asparagus. It is quick and easy. Here is the summary of each step of the video: 1. How to pan sear scallops - at video minutes 04:25 2. How to bake sweet potatoes in the oven - at video minutes 02:40 3. How long to bake sweet potato cubes - 25 mins 4. Can you eat the skin of sweet potatoes - yes 5. Wh...
YouTube QSFE meals | Chinese Cucumber Tofu Salad Recipes
Переглядів 2694 роки тому
How to make Chinese cucumber tofu salad QSFE (Quick, Simple, Fast and Easy) meals. Vlog Star app apps.apple.com/us/app/vlog-star-yt-studio-editor/id1286943307 Thank you for watching! Today I’m making a simple Chinese cucumber tofu salad. You will find all ingredients in the video. #StayHome #WithMe and make #Salad To watch this video in high resolution, please go to a video quality setting to c...
Vegan Matcha Latte | Healthy Refreshing Drinks
Переглядів 894 роки тому
How to make a vegan matcha latte. #StayHome #WithMe and drink #MatchaLatte I am using Organic Edensoy Unsweetened soy milk and Naoki Fine Kagoshima Matcha First Spring Blend Ceremonial Grade (organic) for making this vegan matcha latte. You can use any kind of whisk as long as you can separate the matcha powder nicely and creates those small bubbles. Temperature of the soybean milk: in order to...
印度马萨拉 (香料)奶茶 Masala chai
Переглядів 2265 років тому
印度马萨拉 (香料)奶茶 Masala chai

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @MC-tl5yq
    @MC-tl5yq 2 місяці тому

    Best video i have seen on the topic.

  • @ava9779
    @ava9779 2 місяці тому

    Great work but whenever I make rye bread it becomes too sour what could be the reason?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 місяці тому

      A couple of reason I can think of. - The rye starter was not on the peak of the rise when you use it. - You cut into the rye bread too soon. It is recommended to rest for at 12 hours before cutting into it. Try toasting it and see if the sourness will be reduced. I hope it helps!

  • @jeffweiss2131
    @jeffweiss2131 4 місяці тому

    Outstanding video! I can hardly wait to try this recipe. Excellent descriptions and details. I think I can do this!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 місяці тому

      Did you try it?

  • @johnreynolds562
    @johnreynolds562 5 місяців тому

    Is there a recipe with amounts etc? Thank you for a great instruction video!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 4 місяці тому

      It is in the video. Watch the video until 0:21, you will see the ingredients there.

  • @christophermoyer6103
    @christophermoyer6103 6 місяців тому

    Nice video. I'm going to try this.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 6 місяців тому

      Thank you!! Did you try it?

    • @christophermoyer6103
      @christophermoyer6103 6 місяців тому

      @@PhoebeGoh not yet. traveling but will get to work on baking when I get home

  • @eleanorbardsley1953
    @eleanorbardsley1953 7 місяців тому

    Made it for the first time and it came out great much better than my previous attempt with another online recipe. I just need to practice a bit more so it turns out as well as Fiona’s. Very happy thanks.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 6 місяців тому

      Great to hear! I hope you enjoyed it!

  • @teresatam4247
    @teresatam4247 8 місяців тому

    Can you give me a recipe for sourdough starter

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 8 місяців тому

      Here you go: How To Make Your Own Natural Sourdough Starter From Scratch | By Phoebe's Sourdough. ua-cam.com/video/_t6jf6OZ_9A/v-deo.html

  • @teresatam4247
    @teresatam4247 8 місяців тому

    Do have receipts for sourdough

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 4 місяці тому

      The ingredients for this 100% Rye Sourdough is in the video. Watch 0:21.

  • @helland11
    @helland11 11 місяців тому

    Hey i tried to do it this way. All worked well and the bread looks nice and dark. However it fell a bit inside, so there is a small hole just below the bread top 😢. Is there anything you could advice or anything i should take into account to avoid it?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 8 місяців тому

      Hello Oleg, sorry for the delayed response. That small hole could happened if the air on the surface did not escape completely when you shaped the dough for the second proofing. The other possibility could be, you folded some flour into the dough while you were shaping it for second proofing.

  • @ShazWag
    @ShazWag 11 місяців тому

    Ooh thank you. I'm excited to try your method this weekend 😊

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 11 місяців тому

      Let me know how that turns out for you!

  • @DrVektor
    @DrVektor Рік тому

    your technique near to mine. I like the way it works. You don't waste even the tiniest bit of dough. I love you. Have a good day. The bread turned out great.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Thank you for the message. Have a great day there too! Enjoy baking!

  • @pw309
    @pw309 Рік тому

    Thank you so much! I have been searching in vain for a recipe for Finnish rye bread (Ruisleippä) and this appears to be the closest thing I have been able to find in English. I cannot wait to try this recipe!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      I’m happy that this video appeared at your feed! I hope you try it and let me know how you like it.

  • @rainerrain9689
    @rainerrain9689 Рік тому

    Hi, you haven't made a video in 2 years, I hope all is well with you.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Thank you for asking Rainer! I need to find time to do this. My work has gotten really busy.

  • @rosasottile8410
    @rosasottile8410 Рік тому

    beautiful rye bread, do you use room temperature water?

  • @denebgarza
    @denebgarza Рік тому

    Other videos on 100% rye sourdough say to let it rest 12-24 hours after baking. Do you do the same?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Yes. I cut into it after about 12 hours. If you think it is still too sour for you, you can wait for longer time to cut into it.

  • @monica4200
    @monica4200 Рік тому

    Great video - love your technique!

  • @dawnlau3507
    @dawnlau3507 Рік тому

    hi Thanks for sharing this! Are you in Singapore / Malaysia? Trying to gauge weathers and ambient conditions / temperature.

  • @ellenfrance7004
    @ellenfrance7004 Рік тому

    Hi! Thanks for a recipe! I am familiar with regular sourdough that uses white flour and some rye but this will be my first whole rye bread. I have a question about baking-do you close the lid of the preheat clay pot first then removing the lid midway or you just bake it in the pot without the lid all the way?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Closed the lid baked for about 40 mins and then remove the lid baked for about 10 to 15 mins.

  • @faithtomorrow
    @faithtomorrow Рік тому

    Thank you so much for this! WOW. I’m in awe and this video was also very pleasing/peaceful to watch. ☺️ Can’t wait to make my own.

  • @floofnooterson6180
    @floofnooterson6180 Рік тому

    amazing video! i will try to bake this bread soon. it is my first loaf

  • @user-ot2qm5jc3z
    @user-ot2qm5jc3z Рік тому

    !!!!!!!

  • @goldfishoptics
    @goldfishoptics Рік тому

    Glad I watched this - seems a little different to other 100% rye sourdough videos I've watched. The adding water slowly tip is intriguing... Thanks

  • @mirib5007
    @mirib5007 Рік тому

    My starter is a mix of every kind of flour over the months. I fed it, and it more than doubled on the counter. I stirred it down before adding the water and to the flour, 2 cups dark rye + 1 cup unbleached wheat, + 1 T molasses, but I added my salt to the starter water, do you think it effects the rise? I mixed & left for 18 hours, then got into a ball with a little flour. I put it on parchment paper & let rise 2 hrs in a beep round bowl, not a banaton, then put directly in a preheated 475F oven 4 qt Dutch, baked for 30 min with lid, +15 min without lid. It looks pretty good! But I added caraway seeds, they taste bitter, although stored in the fridge. My crumb has no holes.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Salt will affect the rise for sure. You can add the salt to the flour instead of the starter directly. You don’t want to kill the yeast in the starter.

  • @annaschull
    @annaschull Рік тому

    Thank you for making this video. It’s very easy to follow and I like the sound of your voice. I’ll try it for sure!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      Thank you! I hope you will like it!

  • @constantin1959
    @constantin1959 Рік тому

    very very nice; thank you!!

  • @amyyap79
    @amyyap79 Рік тому

    Hi. Why it is so sticky as I pour all the water into the pot at the beginning, then pour salt n 504g rye flour?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh Рік тому

      If you follow the video, you don’t pour the water all at once. You reserve some water to add little by little while you are trying to get the right consistency. Rye is sticky at first but it won’t be sticky if you get the right consistency.

  • @juliaa7908
    @juliaa7908 Рік тому

    Great video! Thank you!!

  • @itzakpoelzig330
    @itzakpoelzig330 2 роки тому

    Wonderful video! I've been watching many sourdough rye bread videos as part of my goal to eat more of the food of my ancestors on a regular basis, and this video gives me confidence to try making this at home. Thank you, Phoebe!

  • @OAPerez40
    @OAPerez40 2 роки тому

    Thank you, Phoebe Goh! That was such a simple, straight-forward video for making 100% Rye Sourdough Bread, which is my favorite bread in the world! I'm tired of paying higher and higher prices for it--when I can even find it--that is. It's time for me to start making it myself. Thank you, again! Well done!

  • @thehaipath
    @thehaipath 2 роки тому

    This is a great video, what a different method to knead and adding water little by little. I’ll have to try this recipe to perfect my 100% rye! Thank you for sharing

  • @lyndereggi4156
    @lyndereggi4156 2 роки тому

    Beautiful bread. I’m having trouble getting my dough to double in size and also it get brown on the bottom and tough to cut. Any suggestions please on how to solve these problems.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      You mentioned it gets brown on the bottom, how did you bake it?

    • @lyndereggi4156
      @lyndereggi4156 2 роки тому

      @@PhoebeGoh I bake it in a cast iron Dutch oven.

  • @dfertefwergwergrfgwr
    @dfertefwergwergrfgwr 2 роки тому

    Very good job!

  • @flowerrin6835
    @flowerrin6835 2 роки тому

    太好啦!!!!

  • @mariellekelly9183
    @mariellekelly9183 2 роки тому

    What would be the difference if I use a starter with just plain flour?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      It is just not 100% pure rye bread. It is the purity that count. With that said, you can use any starter you want and mix with any flour you like to make a sourdough. It gives difference taste profile.

  • @toddmacintyre1376
    @toddmacintyre1376 2 роки тому

    Great looking bread; can't wait to try. Wondering if you or someone can clarify the water. Did you start off with 378g of water with starter and added additional water as required or is the initial water mixed with the starter, a bit less than 378g and you added in stages up to 378g water total?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Hi Todd! The total amount of water I used was 378g. I will recommend not to use 378g of water at once because the moisture of the rye flour you use could be different from mine. Also depends on the humidity in the room, and what season it is. Sometimes you may need more than 378g of water. Start with half of 378g, then add the water little by little to get to the consistency that is not too hard and also not too soft that you can’t form a loaf. So far, others seem to like the recipes and no problem with it.

    • @toddmacintyre1376
      @toddmacintyre1376 2 роки тому

      Terrific thank you, looking forward to trying it.

  • @vitalytarasov1658
    @vitalytarasov1658 2 роки тому

    The most authentic whole rye bread I have seen here. I am preparing my starter and will make your recipe tomorrow. Thank you for an informative video.

  • @dorukkiratli1624
    @dorukkiratli1624 2 роки тому

    After watching so many videos this is the one I'm trying. It's surprising how other youtubers don't mention adding the water slowly and most of them complain about rye being messy. Maybe they should watch your video!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Rye is actually very easy to deal with. Adding the water a little bit by bit will help you in control or maneuver of the dough.

    • @itaigutman
      @itaigutman 2 роки тому

      @@PhoebeGoh thanks for the recipe! doesn't the consistency (i.e. % of hydration) affecting the rate of fermentation and rise of the bread? In which way is the results are different than other recipes with a more "runny" consistency?

  • @leehotspur9679
    @leehotspur9679 2 роки тому

    Thank you for sharing I intend to use you recipe You are very articulate in your preparation a pleasure to watch

  • @juneduvanney5751
    @juneduvanney5751 2 роки тому

    Thanks so much for your great recipe.

  • @sima7731
    @sima7731 2 роки тому

    Hi, I have never made a starter. Could you please list the ingredients in making a strong rye starter? Thank you.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Hi, it is just rye flour and water to make the starter. The more you feed your starter, the stronger it gets. Time.. is the important element for making stronger starter. The older the starter is the stronger it is. Here is the link how to create a starter. You can use any flour. If you want your bread to be 100% the same flour as the flour you are going to use to bake a bread, for example 100% stone ground rye sourdough, is made from 100% stone ground rye starter and stone ground rye flour. Please refer to this link how to start your own starter. How To Make Your Own Natural Sourdough Starter From Scratch | By Phoebe's Sourdough. ua-cam.com/video/_t6jf6OZ_9A/v-deo.html

    • @sarinawanitakun7837
      @sarinawanitakun7837 Рік тому

      Thank you for your kindness information. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @phuoctinh4517
    @phuoctinh4517 2 роки тому

    Hi , Phoebe Goh ..In your vide "Artisanal 100% Rye sourdough bread " you used strong rye starter .(70gr )..I can make sourdough starter by rye flour as this video .Please tell me .....Thanks And from day 3 , we have to feed two times /day ?

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Yes, absolutely! You can use rye flour to make the starter. You can start feeding twice a day from day 3. You will notice the starter will get hungry very quickly after day 2. Once you have fed the starter for 6 days or a week, the starter should be string enough to use for baking sourdough bread. If your environment is warm or hot, please shorter the feeding time. Your starter would not taste too sour when you make it to sourdough bread.

    • @phuoctinh4517
      @phuoctinh4517 2 роки тому

      Thanks for your kind …. Next week I will try for two kind of flour ….

  • @Hedge_Haven
    @Hedge_Haven 2 роки тому

    Can you make this recipe with whole grain rye flour? Does it work just the same? Why have you chosen spelt flour? Thank you for your wonderful videos!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Yes absolutely! I have many starters and whole grain rye is the best starter I use for any kind of bread. It will work the same. It actually will kick off the fermentation process faster than using whole grain spelt.

  • @cindysebryk5093
    @cindysebryk5093 2 роки тому

    Love the shower cap idea. Thank you for the video.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      You are so welcome!

  • @yaelarbelymizrachi2319
    @yaelarbelymizrachi2319 2 роки тому

    Hello and thank you very much for the recipe. I have a question. After forty minutes in the bread pot it seemed to me made so I took it out for a temperature check. The temperature was 97 degrees Celsius. I decided to stop baking I took it out of the pot I turned off the oven and left for five minutes and then I took it out. I'm waiting in anticipation for tomorrow to cut it and I'm curious to know if I did the right thing by taking it out and not leaving it for another twenty minutes without a lid. I will only know tomorrow. But until tomorrow I am curious to know what you think? Thanks again Yael

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Sorry for late reply! How did it turn out? There are no rules as in when you should take the bread out. Every oven at home is different, as long as you like how the bread looks or the texture of the bread.

  • @albertromeu308
    @albertromeu308 2 роки тому

    Wow !! Such a beautiful loaf with so little sourdough. This is an interesting discovery. Thank you. It's a must-try recipe. I've got a millstone grinder and a 5-kilo sack of rye. You've baked my day.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 2 роки тому

      Wow! Millstone grinder...I dream to have one.

  • @aheartbeatific
    @aheartbeatific 3 роки тому

    This rules Phoebe. Your channel is a delight. Thank you for these resources.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      Thank you for the support 😍😍😍💕💕 ! I need to find more time to make the video and upload to the channel. I have so much more to share.

  • @touu999
    @touu999 3 роки тому

    Thanks for your video. I have a question, is it normal for the bread inside to be a bit squishy after bake? (I tried many times, not sure if that is normal or still raw ...haha)

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      Hi Lim, what flour did you use? Do you have a picture? If you can show me, that will be easier to understand. You can email me at phoebe_goh@hotmail.com

    • @touu999
      @touu999 3 роки тому

      @@PhoebeGoh Thank you, you are so kind. I use 100% rye flour. I will send e-mail to you!

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      @@touu999 I just sent you a reply.

  • @pekkimtee463
    @pekkimtee463 3 роки тому

    Can I use instant yeast instead

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      You can. The purpose here is to create a healthy bread that everyone can eat. If using instant yeast, you won’t get the health benefit from the sourdough fermentation. If you use instant yeast, you can bake the bread within an hour or two.

  • @janiceang8798
    @janiceang8798 3 роки тому

    Hi Phoebe, tq for your video. I noticed uou use a clay pot to bake the bread. Can any smooth-lookin clay pot be used for baking bread? I find getting a dutch oven is too expensive to invest in especially for beginner like me. Aporeciate your advice. Tq

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      The concept here is creating a small oven within in an oven. As long as the smooth claypot is able to be heated high enough temperature and won’t crack, you are good to go. Dutch oven is definitely expensive to invest. Claypot is pretty good for result as well.

  • @bybbah
    @bybbah 3 роки тому

    Hi I love PORTOBELLO MUSHROOMS. BUT LIKE YOU SAID I CANNOT WAIT TO MAKE MINE I LIVE IN NY,USA.LET US MAKE SOME SOUP.BUT IM MAKING TONIGHT PIZZA WITH MY PORTBELLO LEFT OVER.

    • @PhoebeGoh
      @PhoebeGoh 3 роки тому

      I didn’t see this comment until now. Sorry for late reply.