Відео

50:17 It's interesting to hear the lyrics of Roll With It Described as "amazing" as I find it to be yet another example of the usual rhyming world salad and an exercise in how to say absolutely nothing in 4 mins. "kiss the girl she's NOT behind the door" is classic Noel in a certain sense where we have words all slightly muddled (maybe this is his dyslexia, although I'm not an expert) also, what is his fascination with what is behind doors? "Maybe you and I will not believe in, the things we find behind the door" It's a shame really because I actually love Roll With It inc the video and single artwork; it's also their best sounding record and his guitar solo doesn't sound like his usual stock pentatonic runs. But anyway, despite the lyrical deficiencies Roll With It is #1 for me lmao

Haha. Most of the biblical ones are plagiarised from 60’s and 70’s classics.

Cum on feel the noise? These numbers seem well off.

One fella really trying get this guitar sold for top whack😂 Its a famous one sure.....was the first tour Noel would swap guitars for different songs...but id say the sheratons.... ES355s.... J200s/150s..... Riveras.... their more famous than this one. Makes me think of magic pie live when i see it.

The Gibson florentine really was special. His 120 watt matchless amps were also really special also. People forget how big the be here now sound was

Apparently Underworld were the Oasis merch company, it's nothing to do with Underworld the band.

Originally , and for the last 15 years I’d have said this should have been kept off the album and used as a bside, because it’s not good enough However, having watched your mate James Hargreaves’ recent video, where he deep dived analysed the DOYS album, with his theories of hidden Easter eggs and conceptual content, this song makes all the more sense and belongs on that album. Making it a better album However, it’s still among the worst Oasis songs (the calibre js high, very high) and is a rip off of that soul song from the I think 60’s (perhaps a different one to that mentioned by you on this video) - another one which James Hargreaves has done a video on! Anyway, that’s all 👏

Would have been a brilliant addition to (the already superb) Don’t Believe The Truth album. Pop this on after The Meaning of Soul (and also take off Abel to use as bside) and we’ve got an even better album It’s Gem finding his inner The Who via Oasis and good to have a rockier Oasis bside in this later era. It rocks heavy!

Among the ones you didn't mention, Octopus is a band I listened to quite a bit back in the day. They were on Food, Blur's label and made one album. The Audience was second rate but fun, considering it's late Britpop featuring Sophie-Ellis Bextor before "Murder on the Dancefloor" and other dance pop tunes.

and stop crying?

Who is talking... what was the previous band?

A Bell Will Ring is probably, definitely, the best Oasis song Noel never wrote. Gem found his inner Noel Gallagher with this one. I love it, and it’s one of the best 3 songs on a brilliant DBTT album. I’d go as far to say it’s perhaps the most overlooked or underrated Oasis song. It’s right up there Eyeball Tickler is where Gem found his inner The Who Agree on See Me Now, that is sh*te. Pointless. As bad a ‘song’ as Oasis had released

Only got as far as the part where you discuss Probably All In The Mind - I regard this as among the ultimate most underrated Oasis songs. It’s brilliant, and got a colourful melody too It’s taken me 22 years and 3 months to realise what Andy Bell was saying between the tracks - thanks to you! I always heard that as ‘LTV’ not know what was actually said. You’ve got it nailed there. Makes much more sense haha Keep up the great work

it’s cut from this version but your guest james you showed on the spotify version of the podcast is my best friend in the world and recently life hasn't been to kind to him as he may have told you. to hear him talk about something i know he is passionate about on a platform he feels welcome means the world to me and jesus christ I've just been crying for 10 minutes after hearing that message you guys have made one of his dreams come true and that is truly special so thank you so so much you’ve earned a new fan

Personally I think it’s quite unfair to judge Gallagher squire as a Liam Gallagher album it’s practically just another seahorses album with a 60s vibe which for me is great and what I wanted as a seahorses fan

Really disagree with the Squire collaboration... but that's ok

Love the beady eye stuff, and most of Liams solo stuff.

I seem to be in a minority in loving the LGJS record.. and COYN.. I think he was getting more interesting.. I also feel WMWN is just OK and sounds dangerously like a 90s Robbie Williams album x

Beady Eye is a funny one, I actually quite liked their "vibe". They had a lot of potential, but everyone kinda just shat on them then. People wanted to see them fail, especially Liam, which was a bit shame. I realize they were missing that "something". And I'm not just talking about Noel, I'm talking about finish. The magic that elevates mediocre bands to the goodness, and good bands to thegreatness. They could've provided that without Noel if they pushed themselves just little further, but as we now know they couldn't. And to put it straight UK-music scene(or music scene overall) wasn't ready for a retro band at early 10s at all, it was completely wrong time. And B.D.I. was all about that, nodding to their predecessors, and they did it well.

Personally I would place every single one of them in Good. For me every album has one or two excellent/biblical songs, one or two rubbish songs and 8 or 9 OK/meh songs. I've put together an 18-track double album playlist of all of my favourites. (And I can say exactly the same about Noel's parallel solo career as well!)

I can't listen to the one with John Squire. The lyrics are beyond terrible. Lol

Wigwam and morning son are Abso class

The second version of I'm Outta Time (coloured) is splendid

LGJS is Liam’s best ever album

I agree with your ranking !!

WMWN is peak Oasis level in my book. Top 3 all time Gallagher albums.

Juicy 360p

Great list. But I'd have put squire album last. It's awful in my opinion.

Got a soft spot for different gear, it's pretty unique

"Why me Why not" is his best as a solo artist. "As you were" is good. "C'mon You Know" sounds pretty baffling to me, idk, the production reminds me to some crappy Foo Fighters album. Recently I've been listening the Beady Eye albums, and the second one is better than what I thought then. Great list!

beady eye's first album is better than LGJQ - thats a fact

I think you’re largely on the money here JC, although I might be tempted for As You Were into excellent.

If you include The Masterplan, you’d also have to include Time Flies, Stop The Clocks and Back The Way We Came. It’s a compilation album Good list, although I’d go with; Biblical: WTSMG Definitely Maybe Be Here Now Amazing: Don’t Believe The Truth Chasing Yesterday NGHFB SOTSOG Good: Council Skies Who Built The Moon? Heathen Chemistry Liam Gallagher John Squire Alright, Good Enough: Dig Out Your Soul As You Were Why Me, Why Not Average to Poor, Should Be Better: Come On You Know Different Gear Still Speeding Absolutely Rubbish: B.E

Live Forever is one of the best songs ever recorded and these cunts are talking about b sides

I see a lot of people acting surprised by Liam’s approach to singing. It makes me wonder how many of these people have actually been following the Gallaghers for the last few years because the other night wasn’t anything that different from the usual for him.

who was the Noel 'wannabe' on guitar??...

The cruel irony is that from a sound production perspective on tv at least it was the best I’ve heard the rest of the band 😅.

All they have to do is drop the original keys of the songs a semi tone or even a tone down, and it would drop the shouting and relax his vocals. He’s 52, not 22. Can’t believe they keep persisting on keeping the same keys as they were in 1994. He just can’t sing them like that anymore. Liam needs to take criticism, something he’s not very good at.

This was an amazingly insightful interview, it's great to hear someone share their decades of experiences straddling the boundaries between the rock/pop music world and classical world, and how difficult it must be to cater for such conflicting artistic temperaments and navigate the complex world of credits and publishing etc. He sounded like a very humble and self-effacing gentleman to listen to and he clearly understands the cyclical nature of inevitable changes in the industry, he's not constantly berating modern practices or trying to bring things back to "how they used to be", which is very refreshing.

A lot of excuses being made for Liam/ a terrible performance.

He had a singing straw, a stainless steel straw phonation tool that helps singers and speakers develop stronger, healthier, and more balanced voices...or so the theory goes. I've seen him with it quite a lot.

Awful

his band is pure shite, that s the main problem

His voice is just fried

This is few potential technical reasons for Liam’s performance at Wembley: When a singer doesn't have a good monitor mix, especially if the mix is not balanced or clear, it can cause a phenomenon called "pitch perception shift." This issue can make the singer perceive the pitch of the song as being lower (a half step down) than it actually is. Here’s a technical explanation: 1. Delayed Audio Feedback: If the singer hears a delayed version of their own voice or the instruments through the monitors, it can cause confusion and lead them to sing off-pitch. The brain tries to correct what it perceives as a mismatch between what is being heard and what is being sung. 2. Phase Cancellation: Poor monitor mixes can result in phase cancellation, where certain frequencies are reduced or cancelled out. This can distort the harmonic content of the sound, making the singer perceive the pitch inaccurately. The singer might adjust their pitch to compensate, leading to singing off-tune. 3. Insufficient Volume or Clarity: If the monitor mix is too quiet or lacks clarity, the singer might struggle to hear themselves or the backing track properly. This can cause them to rely more on muscle memory and internal pitch perception, which might not align with the actual pitch being played. 4. Psychoacoustic Effect: In some cases, the combination of the above factors can lead to a psychoacoustic effect where the singer perceives the pitch to be lower than it actually is. The brain, trying to correct for this, causes the singer to unintentionally sing in a different key, typically a half-step down. In live settings, having a well-balanced and clear monitor mix is crucial to ensure that the singer can accurately hear the music and their own voice, maintaining proper pitch and timing. That’s why Liam, in some parts of the songs appears to sing wrong. If you listen the audios and videos, sometimes he seems to sing on a lower tune.

Sounded tired, burnt out, pissed off, shouldn't have done it, probably not worth the paycheck with the negative press.

Wasn’t his best but he’s just come off a huge tour. Go listen to his voice from Knebworth 2022 or even at the beginning of this tour and he’s much better! Those songs take their toll when you sing them like he does night after night! Oh and it was his b day so he probably had a few too many 😂

I love liam but that was an awful performance...I have seen liam plenty of times and people who are saying that this is just what he sings like and what he has always sounded like are just wrong...since the reunion liam has turned a lot of people off...he has put on his rock star persona to an embarrassing extent...there are 2 types of oasis fans...ones who love the music and are real music fans and then there are liam fans who don't know shit .. liams band are also fucking horrendous

I listened twice. First to the live radio broadcast, later to the filmed version. Sound quality was much better on TV… the radio one was mixed v badly & made LG sound ropey. The filmed one sounded as good as his Definitely Maybe shows.

The sudden drop in energy is hilarious 😂