Відео

Bro still gives a point to blender even if both renders looks good.

id say, death to the nurbs system, the thing made me almost quit 3D lol

No need to spend 14 minutes to say Blender is the best, fanboy. A video to annoy 3ds Max users.

With all respect I use both but some facts: Everyone who complains about Max just hasn’t mastered it. Look at why ILM, Pixomondo, Framestore, and Scanline use it for VFX, props, and their art departments… It’s clear all the info is related to your personal goals. Check out what the pros at the indust..use, and you’ll see the real deal. Blender isn’t intuitive. It needs addons and tons of shortcuts to work smoothly for the basics. Max has loads of scripts, profesional plugins like, ( forestpack, thinking particles, tyflow, etc…)and a professional community. There’s no way around it, not right now.

You were not fair on the arnold and cycles bro! Arnold works good on GPU and it has far better details and calculations than cycles!

Such comparisons in 2024 look embarrassing, because many have already understood what is what and have begun to study programs as needed and for specific purposes. I’m studying Houdini, I really like it, but I wouldn’t wish modeling there on my enemy. Shame on the author for the shameful topic, but I’ll give it a like because it’s still relevant and more or less objective.

To be honest, I hate the hypocrisy of so-called "free" things, and then saying that because it's free, the quality is acceptable. Firstly, Blender cannot compete with 3ds Max in architectural interior design. Secondly, Blender cannot compete with 3ds Max in game . In our region, they install 3ds Max to create animations for games more frequently. Rigging and animating a bird in Blender is much harder than in 3ds Max. Thirdly, regarding extensibility, while 3ds Max is a platform with clean and powerful code, Blender is very complicated. You can use C++, C#, Python, and MaxScript in 3ds Max, whereas in Blender you can only use Python. That’s why 3ds Max has V-Ray, Corona, TyFlow, iToo... all these plugins are written in C++ or C#.

3Ds Max is a joke nowadays hahahaha

Blender is free.. Just like that 💪

On the question of price, I'd say that the more expensive your software, the more you'll be paid. It's not very attractive, especially to a lay audience, to work with free software. The guy is going to say to himself why should I give him money, my little nephew uses the same software as him.

Blender dates back to 1994. After failing as proprietary software, it was released under a free license in 2002. Success has not been forthcoming outside the small free software community. 2 interface changes later, and the advent of social networking, Blender is finally meeting with some success with a younger generation looking for a generational software. The software has unquestionably become the champion of social networking. For the rest, it's much less obvious. Fun fact, did you know that you can legally sell copies of Blender? And all the GPL-licensed addons on the Blender Market. So you can easily understand why the excellent plugins you find on 3dsmax and other software haven't been released on Blender. Free software has a number of specific features that most users are unaware of.

Blender 🔥🔥🔥

Cinema 4D is very good and for $730/yr it's a bargain in comparison to anything Autodesk has to offer. You have access to Z Brush and other cool plugins. Cinema 4D is a good compromise middle ground for someone who want a skill for a recognized brand but doesn't want to pay thousands then Cinema 4D is a good option.

lol your talking about software like we're in year 2000 , everything is going down really soon because of AI , skill requirement will be zero ., learning curve my ass

blender look like a toy compared to 3ds max period.

I worked with blender and max. Blender have better cloth simulation. In max it sometimes stops simulating. In 3dsmax you need use tyflow for good cloth sim.Buth in deno version, you not have normal cache. So after every render I lose cloth cashe simulation. Also blender have beter hair simulation. But Blender hairs simulation have bugs, sometime hair not properly simulate. It spreading out and nonmsense doing. But it usualky then you use many hairs and many segments. 3dsmax navigation I also more like. Animation with biped in 3dsmax more simple. You can set how many steps walk person. In blender you must bysefl animate walk. But in some things blender have more custum bone ajustment than in biped. But in biped much simpler made twisted bones for upper arm and forearm. Cycles also beter than Arnold. Arnold sometimes have some issues.And it in CPU mode and GPU mode some material render wery different. In new arnold version it have good denoising.... But cycles much cooler onlymaybe in cycles glow efect not wery good work... I 3dsmax used for free like student. But I can not sell my work probarly... Max startup tme also is longer. And if you not properly unnistal.something wrong made with ccleaner and clean 3dsmax registry. Then you can have big problems if you do not known how this that isue. And can spend many days toproerly uninstall and install 3dsmax. I have that isue after removing with ccleanr some registry of 3dsmax...

If blender had Corona Render, i wouldn't use 3ds max right now

To be honest, I don't like the community atmosphere of Blender. They tend to criticize other DCC software. Over these three years of learning, Blender's version updates always seem to break something, and I've gradually grown to dislike Blender.

men, blender is not easier to learn, it's not intuitive after other programs. both programs the same old, there are tone information for learning and only blender was change ui and hotkeys so don't tell what it's easier, you are lying. the same for community. if you are telling what is most using that's because the only pros it's free. go and check how many users in game what are free comparing with others paid. You should be objective. I am not protecting 3ds max the both programs have own bad side, and there are many other good combines like cinima4d, lightwave, maya, Houdini, modo, etc. there is no the best software in the world. so why are you lying to people? About plugin you are also do not understand why 3ds max is winning, it's leads from second category of you video, because it's huge comunity and user base, they are can make good plugins, and blender is loosing because it requires open code for implementation, that's why there are no vray, corona and other cool things. And don't tell me what you didn't know how selling blender clones with only different name and ui. video is bullshit. good luck

Maya and blender, which is good for rigging?

I have worked with both Maya and Blender. Maya is far better in terms of its standard interface and options. However, I wish Maya had some features that are available in Blender

Haven't watched the video yet but must say: I'm positively surprised that comment section isn't just all Pro-Blender circlejerk. And this is coming from artist who only uses Blender atm. I honestly think worst part of Blender is its community. So many get triggered if you even mention why you use 3ds max instead of Blender. Also I absolutely hate where the Blender UA-camrs are going with their content too. Everything is just full of attention grabbing fast intro edits etc.

Great Comparison. I chose Bforartists as my primary 3D app for my small studio. It is a fork of Blender that focuses on the icon driven UI to access all the awesome tools of Blender. It also has many features Blender doesn't have. I chose it over C4D.

Autodesk 3DsMax👍👍👍👍👍

I think they are both tools, it all boils down to the user skills and experience.

I've been working with 3DSMax for nearly 20 years (I started back in the Discreet days) and I've been learning Blender for a few months. The latter is orders of magnitude harder for me to learn, there are a lot of "hidden" features that are very hard to get to know, whereas in Max almost everything is right under your nose or quickly available. Blender is very difficult to understand when you switch from Max, it's completely different and some features often seem annoying and stupid. But once you get past all that, somehow Blender starts to feel more convincing, more modern, more thoughtful. I use it for modeling/texturing and animation and I really like the sculpting. If you want to be an employed graphics designer, Max is the way to go, but if you're a freelancer like me and not particularly working on giant projects, I think Blender is the better choice today. There are an awful lot of cheap/free add-ons for the latter.

Man, a HUGE advantage of Blender in modeling is now Geometry Nodes as well man. You miss that you miss everything. That by itself would win over 3Ds Max modeling range nowadays. Procedural modeling with your custom modifier parameter man. That couldn't be ignored.

I apologize for disappointing you, but since TyFlow 1.111 was released, Blender can no longer compare to 3ds Max

Dude, you are comparing Autodesk's 3ds Max and Maya with Blender. Max and Maya are professional solutions with almost real-time support. Blender is probably okay, but comparing it with 3ds Max and making comments on both of them is nonsense.

Blender fanboy 😒

One important aspect of 3ds max over blender is polygon handling, max can handle tons while blender stays far behind. On the plus side of blender, i really like the interface, but at the end i choose 3ds max

There literally is no comparison, 3Ds Max tops now and always

whom ever say that modeling is better in max, clearly did not use blender.

you cant compare blender and 3ds max. blender is an all around full functioning application. 3ds max is way behind. i don't know why people make these comparison videos and end in no decision. blender is the future and constantly evolving.

TyFlow for 3ds max will not cost you thousands, VERY YOUNG padawan. It's free and you are a joke.

Someone having more than 20 years of experience in 3D: SO: 1. Learning Curve... (Perfectly Relative... Not comparable) | Draw 2. Community is a different thing. In this case Blender has a much bigger community than any other 3D software. (Free) | Blender +1 3. Max has an SDK. (which can be extended with, c++, c#, python, maxscript) and compatible with Qt, WPF, .NET, GDI). Blender has an API which cannot be used for as many things. A guy asked me to write UVReactor Blender. It cannot be written for Blender, since no SDK. | 3dsmax +1 4. Modeling... It's only depends on how you model. Both have shit loads of free scripts. | Draw 5. Both has the same animation tools. Both have a lot of free scripts for animation. Btw. Many companies are using max for animation. | Draw 6. Comparing render engines are also doesn't make sense. All of them has their own area. | Draw 7. Both crashes. I have crashed Blender by changing a simple hotkey. This one is also not a comparable opinion. If you know the complexity of these two software, you know all software has their own problematic parts. | Draw 8. Price... Blender is free. Clearly a winner in this aspect. BUT... 3 year of learning license and Indie license for 3ds max and free ADN license, plus you can participate in the Beta. | Blender +1 8+1. Industry Standard... Good luck finding a job with Blender | 3dsmax +1. . . . It's funny that you left this part out of this comparison as a total separated point. Overall these two are not comparable in merit. Both software are good if you know how to use them.

I work in both, and 3ds Max is more prone to sudden crashes than Blender-there's no argument there. 3ds Max literally crashes when you rotate geometry in the viewport, which never happens with Blender. Blender is extremely optimized but has its own limitations when it comes to large scenes. 3ds Max is better at handling lots of geometry, but in everyday work, 3ds Max crashes a thousand times more often than Blender. Blender creates an auto-recovery file in the Windows temp folder at the time of a crash, whereas Max's recovery files are often corrupted and unusable anyway.

That student problem with Maya is the same problem I have. For some reason I can't install Maya, always crashing after the install, Autodesk doesn't seem to care, they don't offer any help or solution. Meanwhile, I have used Max for a decade, it's my go to software and I prefer it to Maya in all situations. I started to use Blender 5y ago and I like it a lot. But what I hate about Blender is how they keep changing the interface and some functionalities. Stability is very important and that should include how the development of a software is going. Max changed the interface in 2017 and it took some time to get used to which slowed our productivity. But Blender radically changed theirs multiple time which is infuriating at times. I use Blender for 3D printing and some animations but Max for everything else. TyFlow is also very hard to ignore especially since now they added Stable Diffusion in TyFlow. I had to install Maya for a partnership with a client and we ultimately decided to use Blender instead and use TyFlow and Ornatrix from 3DS Max for the special effects. I hope Maya crashes and burn!

Max is dead easy, I used it many years for architectural design and previz, Blender is a hassle, way too many funky workflows, shortcuts, and limitations, I got really frustrated with it and switched to Houdini, I never looked back!

If you can afford it, Max is better, and easier to learn. Blender only dumped its ridiculous interface with the release of 2.80

se

some added points: 1. Cycles is not comparable to Arnold in term of fidelity (biased vs unbiased). and although is appears faster in simple scenes, it is actually slower if photorealism is your goal. 2. working is CAD, SOLID meshes is not viable in blender. 3. Render engines: Vray, Corona, Fstrom... are a big plus in 3dsmax. 4. Sculpting and texturing - Blender all the way. 5. Particles System in max - Tyflow, is a strong plus. 6. I find Blender subdi modeling to be way more organic and creative.

Why many Graphic designer editor animator and 3d artist on youtube has muscle, aren't they sitting all day in front of computer? I sit all day for a month and cant even make a decent donut with this confusing Blender

so basicly 3Ds Max just only for modelling.. You need Substance painter to Texturing, You need Zbrush to Sculpting, Maya for Animation, Arnold renderer for rendering so that 1,875 /year just for modelling, you have to add Substance, Zbrush, Maya and Arnold for the rest of the works When my blender crash on windows, go to %temp% folder and youll find blender make backup every couple of minutes, depend on your setting,

To summarize, Blender is perfect for individuals or small scale operations. But for massive enterprise level projects, Autodesk is the way to go. They may not have as great of a community as Blender, but their customer support for enterprises is top notch.

bro just ranted about why blender is better

Stability: "Blender crashes a lot more, but I found this one guy on the internet that said he had a problem uninstalling and installing Maya, so between 3DS Max and Blender, it's a draw." ???

I use both programs now - both have their merits. I prefer Blender but use Max for work. The only point I would add to the video would be texturing - texturing in Blender is a breeze but Max is a pain in the arse which is why we use Lumion (a great program btw) at the job. He’s right about all his points - pay attention to what he says my friends.

I was a 3dsMAX user from my college days in 1997-98. I shifted to Blender in 2023. I have never looked back. Blender is the future. Autodesk is soon going to be the past.

Garbage garbage...