SirJayWalker
SirJayWalker
  • 172
  • 2 106 085
Is Sengoku Dynasty BETTER Than Medieval Dynasty?
Instead of doing a review on Sengoku Dynasty, I thought it would be interesting to compare both Medieval Dynasty and Sengoku Dynasty.
Is Sengoku Dynasty better than Medieval Dynasty?
To preface, I'm not making this video to hate on or bash either of these games, because realistically, I have really enjoyed both experiences, but this may be the first time Medieval Dynasty has another Dynasty game that could potentially compete with the top slot. After playing the 1.0 Full release of Sengoku Dynasty, I find myself wanting a lot of the systems in Medieval Dynasty and Vice versa, so we're going to go over many of the systems these games have to offer and see which game does it better in my opinion, in hopes that Render Cube and Superkami could use these ideas to and consider implementing them in both Medieval Dynasty and Sengoku Dynasty.
Music: ua-cam.com/video/s3nckWeT-m0/v-deo.html
Переглядів: 13 379

Відео

Taverns Basics in Medieval Dynasty: Everything you NEED to Know!
Переглядів 4,1 тис.2 місяці тому
Taverns Basics in Medieval Dynasty: Everything you NEED to Know!
How to Survive your First Winter | Ep. 4 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
Переглядів 2,8 тис.3 місяці тому
How to Survive your First Winter | Ep. 4 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
I Found the BEST WEAPON | Ep. 3 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
Переглядів 7 тис.3 місяці тому
I Found the BEST WEAPON | Ep. 3 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
First Villagers Recruited | Ep. 2 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
Переглядів 6 тис.4 місяці тому
First Villagers Recruited | Ep. 2 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
I Spent 60 Days in Bellwright
Переглядів 3,7 тис.4 місяці тому
I Spent 60 Days in Bellwright
Best Oxbow Start | Ep. 1 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
Переглядів 39 тис.4 місяці тому
Best Oxbow Start | Ep. 1 | Medieval Dynasty Survival Guide
I Spent 30 Days in Bellwright
Переглядів 2,8 тис.6 місяців тому
I Spent 30 Days in Bellwright
Manage Village & Workplaces EFFICIENTLY in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 38 тис.7 місяців тому
Manage Village & Workplaces EFFICIENTLY in Medieval Dynasty
I Played Bellwright for the First Time - EXCLUSIVE Beta Gameplay
Переглядів 8 тис.7 місяців тому
I Played Bellwright for the First Time - EXCLUSIVE Beta Gameplay
I Played Medieval Dynasty New Settlement for the First Time
Переглядів 3,6 тис.7 місяців тому
I Played Medieval Dynasty New Settlement for the First Time
10 ESSENTIAL Tips to Master Farm Animals in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 14 тис.8 місяців тому
10 ESSENTIAL Tips to Master Farm Animals in Medieval Dynasty
10 Tips to Master Villager Management in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 41 тис.8 місяців тому
10 Tips to Master Villager Management in Medieval Dynasty
7 Mistakes EVERYONE Makes in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 133 тис.8 місяців тому
7 Mistakes EVERYONE Makes in Medieval Dynasty
Beginner's Guide to Leveling ALL SKILLS in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 28 тис.9 місяців тому
Beginner's Guide to Leveling ALL SKILLS in Medieval Dynasty
Sneak Peak: Medieval Dynasty: New Settlement is coming
Переглядів 3,6 тис.9 місяців тому
Sneak Peak: Medieval Dynasty: New Settlement is coming
SECRET Treasure Locations You Should Know (Oxbow) - Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 52 тис.9 місяців тому
SECRET Treasure Locations You Should Know (Oxbow) - Medieval Dynasty
10 Best Oxbow Locations to Build - Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 79 тис.9 місяців тому
10 Best Oxbow Locations to Build - Medieval Dynasty
10 NEW Ways to Make Money FAST in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 105 тис.10 місяців тому
10 NEW Ways to Make Money FAST in Medieval Dynasty
ESSENTIAL Tips to Mining in Medieval Dynasty (+ ALL Cave Locations)
Переглядів 46 тис.10 місяців тому
ESSENTIAL Tips to Mining in Medieval Dynasty ( ALL Cave Locations)
Village Tour 2023 - Racimir Retires in Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 101 тис.11 місяців тому
Village Tour 2023 - Racimir Retires in Medieval Dynasty
Day 2: We Robbed Everyone in the Oxbow.. | Medieval Dynasty Co-Op Gameplay
Переглядів 2,7 тис.11 місяців тому
Day 2: We Robbed Everyone in the Oxbow.. | Medieval Dynasty Co-Op Gameplay
Oxbow & Co-Op Released: Whats New? - Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 46 тис.11 місяців тому
Oxbow & Co-Op Released: Whats New? - Medieval Dynasty
Day 1: Oxbow FIRST LOOK | Co-op Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Переглядів 22 тис.11 місяців тому
Day 1: Oxbow FIRST LOOK | Co-op Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Medieval Dynasty as Intended: The Complete Story
Переглядів 4,8 тис.11 місяців тому
Medieval Dynasty as Intended: The Complete Story
Don't Let This Happen to You | Ep. 3 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Переглядів 10 тис.11 місяців тому
Don't Let This Happen to You | Ep. 3 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
50 Facts You Maybe Missed In Medieval Dynasty
Переглядів 37 тис.Рік тому
50 Facts You Maybe Missed In Medieval Dynasty
First Villager Recruited | Ep. 2 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Переглядів 19 тис.Рік тому
First Villager Recruited | Ep. 2 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Best Spring Start | Ep. 1 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
Переглядів 65 тис.Рік тому
Best Spring Start | Ep. 1 | Medieval Dynasty Gameplay
10 ESSENTIAL Beginner Tips for Medieval Dynasty [Medieval Dynasty 101]
Переглядів 145 тис.Рік тому
10 ESSENTIAL Beginner Tips for Medieval Dynasty [Medieval Dynasty 101]

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @jazzherosg5934
    @jazzherosg5934 2 години тому

    They should add swing' set slide, sandbox for the kids.

  • @Jlibby63
    @Jlibby63 3 години тому

    Love this game and your tutorials are very helpful, hi from the Netherlands

  • @SirJohannRoyale
    @SirJohannRoyale 3 години тому

    devs need to add some type of companions like a villager warrior or something so you can feel more like a leader or something. 😢

  • @Hinkel84
    @Hinkel84 4 години тому

    So basicly there are very cool outfits and armor, but I can't equip my citizens with it and they won't follow me in combat? Why do I need armor and weapons then?!

    • @lisekiilstofte5619
      @lisekiilstofte5619 3 години тому

      If that's true that's a shame.

    • @MaxMustermann-vn8du
      @MaxMustermann-vn8du 5 хвилин тому

      the game is not supposed to be a mil sim of some kind, there will never be some huge fights, raids on your town or anything like this, if u want such a game, your wrong here, the armor is therefore mostly to make fights with bandits a bit harder, give the player more endgame content and more content for the kings quests.

  • @thanhlongvo7092
    @thanhlongvo7092 4 години тому

    how did you get the hand lantern?

  • @malepagamer7281
    @malepagamer7281 4 години тому

    hi Jay , is there a way you can eval. MD, Bellwright, Mano Loards , M. B. or any other you know ... ty..👍👍 you killed the egg cooks no more eggs for you ....🤣

  • @KingofDiamonds117
    @KingofDiamonds117 5 годин тому

    Why no gambeson? Why?

  • @daunavonhart1012
    @daunavonhart1012 5 годин тому

    mount & blade needs to take notes

    • @raginasiangaming910
      @raginasiangaming910 6 хвилин тому

      What are you talking about lol? The games are very different. Medieval Dynasty is very micro and Bannerlord is macro. Bannerlord offers a lot of features that MD doesnt...like the very basic ability to have followers A closer comparison is Bellwright. And Bellwright offers a lot more...such as bigger battles and the ability to army and equip followers, set them into groups, execute very basic battlefield tactics, etc. Also, Bellwright villagers actually work (ie, they're not just a behind the scenes math equation). On the other hand, Medieval Dynasty feels less ambitious but more complete...especially the whole family mechanics.

  • @catiecatseye
    @catiecatseye 7 годин тому

    I really love this game, but if it weren't for you I probably would have gotten frustrated and not play to it's full potential - and now I'm obsessed 😅 Thank you! I've been gaming, a long time and this one was hard to get into without more guidance. Glad I didn't put it down 🤘

  • @deviousbutton9211
    @deviousbutton9211 8 годин тому

    ....cute BUT.. when can we get the ability to do the simple task of.. PLANTING TREES AND BUSHS.. it's something so simple that would make a much larger impact on town design than any of the updates so far..

  • @sera6680
    @sera6680 8 годин тому

    hi

  • @artur39111
    @artur39111 9 годин тому

    What you mean "two devs"? I thought it's the same dev? So basically it's coming to sengoku dynasty have more of everything. Thus some problems. Though, I hope they'll be fixed. My few points is - dialogues. In SD You can talk to any npc on the map, everyone have some story. In MD it looks like you playing zombie game. Npc have 0 emotions, 0 anything. They just walking like zombies. But, environment is prettier, yes. MD doesn't feel alive at all. And that is my main complain. Together with absence of any actions on the map. It's perfect game if you have insomnia. Nothing ever happen there. In SD my best hope it's raiding system. They promised it, and I really hope it'll be implemented.

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker Годину тому

      Render Cube makes Medieval Dynasty and Superkami makes Sengoku Dynasty. They're both under Toplitz productions tho

  • @adriennesummers2498
    @adriennesummers2498 10 годин тому

    Is the update coming to console on 11/27? Or just PC/Steam?

    • @mattalford9427
      @mattalford9427 6 годин тому

      It will be released on all new gen consoles. Xbox series S/X and PS5 🎉

  • @Dahbrogadgee
    @Dahbrogadgee 10 годин тому

    Just started last week on ps4 lol got ps5 now hoping update works for the valley map enjoy your vids love from NZ

  • @recksters54
    @recksters54 10 годин тому

    I know the game a fair bunch. Doing a new playthru in Oxbow, year 8 on Hard, still fairly easy I like Oxbow so far even in Single player. I wonder with the update if I should restart in the Valley or continue my new Oxbow one?

    • @PinoyZo1
      @PinoyZo1 9 годин тому

      @@recksters54 valley is more for storyline, oxbow is more for quest boards

  • @redbaron030
    @redbaron030 10 годин тому

    Playing Sengoku Dynasty with specs that are recommended for Medival Dynasty and I can't even reach smooth 30 fps, don't to mention loading times... And I'm playing since early access day 1.

  • @redbaron030
    @redbaron030 10 годин тому

    I just started playing Valley, I'm planning to continue in the next 2 days. Is a fresh start must after this update? Does the new features like bandit camps, swords etc also apply for Valley start?

    • @Dahbrogadgee
      @Dahbrogadgee 10 годин тому

      I need to know this aswel just upgraded from ps4 to ps5 started last week but I like the valley map

    • @hereforthecomments9676
      @hereforthecomments9676 9 годин тому

      ​@Dahbrogadgee I'm 4 gens into my game. I need to know this too. I know want to loose all the heritage I've built 😂.

    • @intothedarkabyss8128
      @intothedarkabyss8128 3 години тому

      i want to know as well. i commented under the update video and they responded with "yes" sooo perhaps?

  • @PinoyZo1
    @PinoyZo1 10 годин тому

    Can you make a shorten video on what the updates is going to have?

  • @SandwichDemon66
    @SandwichDemon66 11 годин тому

    I'm unreasonably hype for this

  • @christianh.3302
    @christianh.3302 14 годин тому

    Hi, the video really helped me. Can you make another one where you perhaps go into more detail, e.g. in which phase of village building how much of which material should be produced, from when you need several production buildings of one type and what the settings of the production buildings should be (e.g. with the woodcutter how much percentage should be placed on collecting logs, sticks, making firewood and boards) etc. ?

  • @gwouru
    @gwouru 14 годин тому

    They really need to fix the lag issue in Sengoku Dynasty. Might actually be more fun then.

  • @Runehunter7
    @Runehunter7 17 годин тому

    I prefer medieval dynasty because it's the only one on xbox 😅

  • @chynnapierce2190
    @chynnapierce2190 17 годин тому

    What if you are playing as a female? How does that work lol

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker Годину тому

      When I made this, you couldn't play as a female 🥲 ill try and make an updated video including both male and female once I get done with moving

  • @igospode9147
    @igospode9147 17 годин тому

    I like the bronze scissors for making wool the best item to sell, as it gets double the amount of items and has a lower price, getting the most money from the vendors

  • @youngoutlaw5150
    @youngoutlaw5150 19 годин тому

    Europe historically can’t compare to Asia and or the Middle East so why should gameplay get expired by those historical events

  • @gloriasdaughter940
    @gloriasdaughter940 20 годин тому

    I like this assessment. I have both games and have really enjoed the designing and customization in Medieval dynasty. ( I drop a lot of items to place everywhere) but even though I can't do that as easily in Sengoku I am a fan of the indoor customization more in that game. Really hoping MD catches up on that front

  • @clevelandrobinsoniv5960
    @clevelandrobinsoniv5960 22 години тому

    I missed the Live!!!! Nooooo!!!!

  • @raginasiangaming910
    @raginasiangaming910 День тому

    First comment. Great videos and your tutorials are invaluable. I wish you could get your people to follow you like in Bellwright. That's really the big reason I prefer Bellwright...having a squad following you. And I'd recommend Fallout 4 for Bethesda games. Base building is decent, plus you can be the roving sheriff between your settlements.

  • @saphloop
    @saphloop День тому

    idk if they changed it since this stream but u can definitely change the build limit on console

  • @8.E.N
    @8.E.N День тому

    imagine if toplitz is planning on crossgame like the bandits of sengoku being the player from the oxbow and bandits in the oxbow being the player from sengoku

  • @FreedomOfSpeech006
    @FreedomOfSpeech006 День тому

    You are all over the place, jumping from one thing to another without completing things or reading throughout.

  • @aesirgaming1014
    @aesirgaming1014 День тому

    I think both games are fun in their current state, but both would also benefit from major improvements. I love these types of games and one day it'd be really nice to see all of these small devs bands together and make one large, complete game. Too much to hope for, I know, but a guy can dream.

  • @drexpak5489
    @drexpak5489 2 дні тому

    Right now, i would say Sengoku Dynasty is better then Medieval Dynasty, but whit an update for Medieval Dynasty rjght around the corner, i think we have to wait to further comparision. But as always, good video SirJay Props from Portugal 🇵🇹🍻 PS: for some reason, i only saw your video now, UA-cam algorithm at is finest...

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker День тому

      If UI and Performance were improved, character models were more appealing, and the Dynasty System was complete, I would say Sengoku is a better game. Its probably going to take some time though 😅

  • @MrHestolemyname
    @MrHestolemyname 2 дні тому

    I'm holding back on buying Sengoku Dynasty until the performance and character models improve. Hope it will be soon since I'm really itching to play it!

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker День тому

      I hope so too! Game is very good in many ways, but far from perfect

  • @madjik1979
    @madjik1979 2 дні тому

    Sengoku is much newer. Medieval has a three year head start on Sengoku, and wasn't feature complete or fully polished on launch either. Sengoku isn't fully feature complete yet either, it's missing the "Dynasty" bit (have a kid, and take over the Dynasty through him) though it is planned to be in the game. Medieval is better, but that's largely because it's had more time to cook. I suspect Sengoku will make some progress on your frustrations over the next few years and that this comparison will be much closer in that time. EDIT:: HA, you made this point at the end of your video. Kudos.

  • @SaxonSpooner
    @SaxonSpooner 2 дні тому

    Wild West Dynasty is obviously the superior game. That is sarcasm by the way.

  • @jacobhuffman5002
    @jacobhuffman5002 2 дні тому

    16:48 is that the song “your love” by the outfield?!? Do you use a mod for these songs to play?

  • @jacobhuffman5002
    @jacobhuffman5002 2 дні тому

    11:45 is it just me or does this sound like “running up that hill” by Kate bush

  • @saphloop
    @saphloop 2 дні тому

    im currently addicted to this game i finished the valley story and now im playing oxbow but i find myself restarting alot 😭

  • @Grace-gm5id
    @Grace-gm5id 2 дні тому

    the thing about the combat in medieval dynasty that i like is that 1 hit can kill you, i dont like those tanky games where if you mess up its just like -10 health

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker День тому

      That's the part I don't like LOL. It will probably be improved upon this coming update

  • @PedroCaine
    @PedroCaine 2 дні тому

    All I could hear was the song “I got 5 on it “with the music lol

  • @MedleyOfGames
    @MedleyOfGames 2 дні тому

    Great video, full watch from me! I have both games and just started covering Sengoku myself on my channel again after the full release. I appreciate your comparisons between the two and agree on most accounts. The only thing I disagree on is I think the environment in Sengoku just looks beautiful, where as Medieval has more of a bland look. Just my opinion though!

  • @TruthSayer2007
    @TruthSayer2007 2 дні тому

    Sengoku dynasty has a ton of glitches at the moment, so I'm def like MD much more right now. SD has this glitch that loses my items when transferring to storage.

  • @gitfunkt3815
    @gitfunkt3815 3 дні тому

    Genuinely pissed my friend off because i had my wife making flatbread during the day and then at night time id refuse to sleep because id be making flatbread all night. He was happy when he had an extra 1000$

  • @firstlast5350
    @firstlast5350 3 дні тому

    It's a pity Sengoku runs on unreal 5 and has higher hardware needs. I won't be buying new video card to play it.

  • @raginasiangaming910
    @raginasiangaming910 3 дні тому

    I can't stand souls like combat...too arcade. Bannerlord has the best melee combat system...any medieval game should be directional combat.

    • @SirJayWalker
      @SirJayWalker 3 дні тому

      I respect it. I need to play Bannerlord more, but it hasn't hooked me yet.. maybe one day 😅

    • @raginasiangaming910
      @raginasiangaming910 3 дні тому

      ​@SirJayWalker thing I always tell people with any Mount and Blade game is to play the mods. The base game is ok, but the modding community makes it shine. Bellwright has a similar combat system...I am hoping that game keeps getting worked on because I think it could be better than Medieval Dynasty...depending on Medieval Dynasty expands it's combat. Right now, I'd say Medieval Dynasty is a better game, but it needs more combat challenge.

    • @raginasiangaming910
      @raginasiangaming910 3 дні тому

      And also Bellwrights combat needs tweaks, such as enemy should be able to destroy fences. I solo defended every raid by building a fence triangle and shooting said raid to death. I hope all these games do well because I love this genre.

  • @d-fineza0449
    @d-fineza0449 3 дні тому

    Thanks, mate. Helps alot that info.❤

  • @NotHappening-b8t
    @NotHappening-b8t 3 дні тому

    i do wish vilagers lvled quicker. that said its cool how fun this game can be just managing stuff

  • @jameskeller3425
    @jameskeller3425 4 дні тому

    we need a mix between Medieval Dynasty and Kingdom Come Deliverance