First Time Ever Hearing YES Close To The Edge (Reaction!!)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- 🎯 Road to 300,000 Subscribers
Support the Channel Here ⤵️
🎬 NEW PATREON | / poloreacts
/ poloreacts
➡️ BUY ME COFFEE www.buymeacoff...
➡️ cash.app/$polo...
➡️ Cash App $PoloMars
If you want to send me books, memorabilia, LPs, or any other gifts you can do that at the address below. Thank you!
Polo Mars
PO Box 927
Perrysburg, OH 43552 🎯 Road to 300,000 Subscribers
Support the Channel Here ⤵️
🎬 NEW PATREON |
/ poloreacts
➡️ BUY ME COFFEE www.buymeacoff...
➡️ cash.app/$polo...
➡️ Cash App $PoloMars
If you want to send me books, memorabilia, LPs, or any other gifts you can do that at the address below. Thank you!
Polo Mars
PO Box 927
Perrysburg, OH 43552
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Just want to say thanks for watching my crazy reactions! If you enjoy what I do on this channel consider supporting me. 70% of my videos are not monetized. Between setting up the studio daily, filming, editing, thumbnails, and research which all take away from my family, you guys motivate me to put out content daily. Consider buying me a coffee here www.buymeacoffee.com/poloreacts or my Patreon www.patreon.com/poloreacts PEACE!!
For me every time I hear this song, I strap myself down for a ride down the Amazon River. At the beginning one is about to enter into the jungle, hearing the water and birds. Turn the bend and you hear the rapids approaching, then you are on the class 5 rapids. After the rapids, one turns the next bend and enters into different parts of the jungle. Around each bend a different world opens up, and near the end a beautiful meadow opens up with the sun rays beaming down on you as you lie down in your canoe staring at the clouds. And at the end, the river sums up the ride with the blending of the chaotic and the beautiful that you just experienced. You come full circle, and one exits the ride and there is Mickey Mouse to greet you and help you out of the ride. If Disney can build a ride like that, I would be there every year. I wonder if they got their inspiration from the it's a small world Disney ride?
1) darken the room, 2) lay down on the bed, 3) Put on the cans, 4) Play at good volume and STFU. Repeat. No Record company is ever going to give a band like this another chance. So enjoy.
Great that you liked Close to the Edge. I've been going to Yes concerts for years. You have to typically have some patience at first listening to Yes music. Then it hits you how incredibly complex it is and enjoyable it is.
Following this album, Yes released their first live album “ Yessongs”, and Close To The Edge is included (actually the whole album). When listening, please considere the limitations on amplifiers and sound engineering of 1972
There are other live version in other newer live albums but I recommend the ABWH live version from their live album “An Evening of Yes Music”
There are only two kinds of people on this earth.. Those who have heard Close to the edge, and those who haven’t. Welcome to the right side!
That is one of truest comments I have ever heard!!
There are those who have listened carefully to Tales of Topographic Oceans.
@@peterlennox4828 “...getting over over-hanging trees...”
@@DaBigRMV “clearly to be home”…
I'm glad to say the band 'Yes' belongs to my generation. Everytime I listen to 'Close to the Edge' it takes me back to my teenage years experiencing the season of Spring.
This band was formed in my mother's living room in London. Jon Anderson is my first cousin.
😮
Amazing! 😮
and I flew to the moon with three monkeys and invented ice cream whilst there.
I hope you invented a good flavor😂😂@@michaelbeerbados3291
Wow
I took my mother to this concert because my girlfriend at the time could not make it. I asked her what she thought afterward. She looked at me and said that the was most fantastic thing she had ever heard live! Love you heavenly Mom!!!!
Wow, good for her! I've taken several boyfriends to see Yes or tried to play CTTE for them with little success. They claim to like it but I catch them falling asleep and looking bored. I thought Awaken would be more approachable but get the same reaction. Alas.
That's beautiful
Beautiful ❤
If your mum wasn't familiar with the music, I'm sure you blew her mind taking her to see Yes live. Even if she knew Yes beforehand! It's 2024 And they are still touring. They're playing with fellow classic rockers Deep Purple (who still sound really good).
Anyways, I saw Yes live in the late 90's. Man, the "get up get down" part of Close To The Edge, I just turned back a bit... the faces on the people!!! Beats any amusement park ride. Cheers!
I took my mother to an evening with Rick wakeman. She had trained at royal college of music and went prepared to hate, but loved it.
Music from the 70s is one of the greatest achievements in history of mankind. It should be saved somewhere safe.
In analog. Not that digital crap, too vulnerable
Outer space is the only safe place. The Aliens will love it.
I wore the grooves out of that vinyl when it came out....I was 13 years old.
In 100 years, this will be Classical Music
I've said that for years, maybe not 100 years, but their genius will be in a class of it's own - CLASSICAL ALT MUSIC.
Yes, this will be listened to for hundreds of years. Yes will be in the same category as all the rest of the masters like Bach and Chopin
Classic rock baby!
Welcome to Progressive Rock, the best genre of music ever invented ❤
I know an amazing musician whose opinion of Prog is "meh, some of it's okay.." 😮 😢 Oh, he can't have heard the right stuff, I feel so bad for him, I just can't wrap my head around it!😂
@@TischTosh and Close to the Edge being the crowning achievement of that movement, IMO.
@@TischTosh I've heard some bad and boring music which calls itself "progressive rock". Like let's do some long songs with non-standard metrics and fast playing and we're good, while everything else is cliché, uninventive and repetitive. He must have heard some of those.
The entire album from start to finish is a masterpiece. Its so rich, and moving, and powerful. The musicianship is at the absolute highest level, but balanced with such a depth of emotion that somehow transcends their insane technical abilities. Its a must-own record, desert island top five, one of the singular gems.
Very True., We need to listen to this entire album with a great bourbon.
@@harlandcamley3996I don’t think alcohol is the substance that they envisioned listeners enjoying while taking this journey.
I agree with the OP here.
Thanks for sharing your reaction to this with us. It is like reliving what many of us experienced when we let the needle drop back in 1972 on this record.
Since this was 8 months ago, it is likely you have listened to it all again. And by now you probably know that if you start and stop it, it’s like a bunch of greatest hits strung together in a medley. And I realize that part of the reason you do that is to prevent copyright strikes.
But if you get to listen to the entire thing all the way through, you may pick up on that this is meant to be heard more like a long unbroken work of art. Like a symphony and that all the little pieces build to a whole that cannot be broken and should not be.
This was the height of Yes IMHO. Though I like their next album even more, TALES FROM TOPOGRAPHIC OCEANS, nevertheless, CLOSE TO THE EDGE, is where it all came together and that was the best version of the band ever. The drummer, Bill Buford left after this album, and although the next drummer, Alan White (who just recently passed away), was a great replacement, Bruford was my favorite. And went on to do a lot of other great progressive rock (aka “prog”) after this with King Crimson, UK, various versions of his own bands, guesting in some Genesis tours etc.
This is a great journey you’re on. Thanks for sharing it with us.
Love this side but side 2 is my all time favorite recording of all tiime.
I grew up listening music like this. YES, Pink Floyd, Genesis, Queen, Deep Purple, and I used to think that future musicians would only improve on it and would get so good some day that new music will be even more amazing than what those bands were putting out there. I was wrong. They were the gold standard, and I didn't know. I'm glad I was alive then.
Yup. After Prog faded out, music overall when down hill and then accelerated in the fall and now ...we have rap. From heaven to hell in less than 20 years.
Yes, me too. Listening to them and even seeing some live when I was a very young teen are memories I'll always remember.
There's still tons of great music being done, including great prog stuff, you just need to go find it.
I grew up with this and played it to death as a teenager. It's been a while since I've listened to it, but hearing it today brought tears to my eyes.
me too!!!! keep on trucking
You can’t imagine what it was like to grow up with this music. I was 13 when I saw them live in 1976. I really feel sorry for todays youth to not have this as a foundation in their life.
Yep, they were something to experience live back in the 70's.
Why do we all feel this way? Because Yes was truly great. I mean the kind of greatness that is rare and only appears on time scales measured in thousands of years.
The YesSongs double LP is a masterpiece also! Actually, every Yes LP is a masterpiece come to think if it ........
I think That's the tour I managed to get to. Was it Tales From Topographic Oceans with green lasers?
I was 16,born in 60
Thank you! I am 63 and I have listened to this song and this genre over the decades. It does my heart good to see a younger generation discover this piece and others like it. Good music, regardless of genre is about universality and speaks to the soul.
Agreed!
I had two older brothers, seven years between the oldest and myself..... In 1972 I was ten, my peers were getting the Osmands, Baycity Rollers and the like... I was getting this, Black Sabbath, Deep Purple and ELP.... I think I won 😎
I totally agree, the younger generation to hear some yes
Amen. I'm 56 and have loved YES since about 1980. You may not understand the lyrics, but the music and overall feel is just perfect. RIP Chris Squire and Alan White.
1976. 14 year old me, living a pretty good life in rural Kentucky. My brother was a student at Georgia Tech. He comes home on Christmas break and, as always, he had something new for me to listen to. I could not take my headphones off! Every listen gives something new to hear! He ended up leaving that copy with me because I couldn't find it anywhere in our shit-hole little town. Still the greatest rock song ever, and I will fight someone over this.
Thanks so much for sharing. My experience was very similar (except I was in the sticks in middle Tennessee) and I was ALSO 14, and a couple of years later than yours.
Lol,,when you believe that much in something, it must be true...I agree!
Same here. I am from rural Southeast Kentucky and my Big Brother introduced me to a lot of hard rock beginning with his eight-track tapes. I spent countless hours in his room when he wasn’t home with the headphones on and he didn’t mind a bit. The first album he bought me was Thick as a Brick and I became a lifelong Tull fan. My best friend in college (1976-80) introduced me to Yes and I grew to appreciate them as much as JT. Still listening to both after all these years.
I must have listened to this album and this song a thousand times or more, each and ever time I feel like there is something new to be heard weather it be the music or the lyrics.
I think you’re wrong.
This is the greatest 5 rock songs ever!
It's orchestral and cinematic. It's a short film for your ears. Epic.
Polo, YOU should have been born back then....IT WAS PERFECT!
"Close to the Edge" is arguably the greatest song I have ever heard. It is what prog is supposed to be.
Awaken is better, in my hopefully astute observation.
I can think that "The gates of delerium" and "The revealing science of god" are on the same level.
Not even my favouite band at all but this was progs Zenith
"Suppose to be"
@@mr.dirtydannnnn You are correct.
Yes became my favorite band after the Beatles split and still are....The late 60's and the 70's Yes created Progressive Rock, the most complete music ever created...definitely inspired from the entire Galaxy. Im so happy that you and many others are exploring and awakening to the heart and soul of Yes. It makes my heart soar ❤️, Scott
Although king Crimson created prog rock
It is genius. The creation, the virtuosity.
I saw Yes live in 1976. There are no words adequate to describe their music.
Yes Please Let's hear it live!!
Then Heart of the Sunrise please!!! and thank you too!!
Oh good one
That song is amazing too!
YES that and yours is no disgrace are the 2 I want him to listen to the most
The thing I love most about progressive, or "prog" rock, is that the people who created it showed that music could really take you somewhere. Nothing epitomizes that more than Close to the Edge. 50 years later it's still an absolutely amazing piece of music. I'm glad you think so too.
@Todd Frank Don't know what we did to deserve progressive rock, but am very thankful it was created. Got to grow up with it.
I just saw an interview with Jon Anderson. He’s a little older than me and since my face is almost unrecognizable to myself in the mirror I looked at him and went ‘oh,yeah’ we all turn out that way,ha ha! He still impresses me even to this day which makes me feel young at heart.
I read an interview with Bill Bruford, drummer, who left after “Close to the Edge.”
When asked why said something along the lines of “there was nothing left to do…”
Growing up with all these bands (im 66), never knew it was even called Prog Rock. Yes, ELP, Pink Floyd, Hawkwind were just a different type of rock than Zep, Deep Purple, Black Sabbath, etc. fantastic musicians making fantastic music
@@markmissildine8345 Everything has to have a name. I don't know when the name "prog rock" was dreamed up..and it's been applied to all kinds of different stuff that's seemingly unrelated. But agreed,,great music played by fantastic musicians.
"longass songs" were the trademark of the progressive era. A period of time in the 70s when the studios allowed the bands to simply go into the studio and be creative. Although prog rock still exists as a more underground movement, the studios imposed more and more controls and social engineering after the 70s. Close to the Edge was the QUINTESSENTIAL prog album. Unrivaled.
Rick Wakeman, the wizard on the keyboards, is so unmistakable on this recording. You really have to differentiate the periods of this band playing with him or without him. He makes a huge difference.
But all periods have highlights. Starship Trooper....The Gates Of Delirium... In The Presence Of. YES usually shines brightly. There were some weak releases as well. But most were pretty amazing.
I honestly felt that Magnification was their greatest release since Going For The One. The music industry tried to push that "The Ladder" as the best album since Close To The Edge. Which was total bull. Relayer, Going For The One and in my opinion Tales From Topographic Oceans were all masterpieces. Trevor Rabin period also included masterpieces. . Shoot High Aim Low. UNION had some beautiful gems as well. MAGNIFICATION was a masterpiece. Unfortunately released on a minor label that didn't have the money to promote it correctly. The live DVD from this period with the orchestra demonstrates the power of this era.
@@daviddrennon4089 I am also a fan of the other periods of Yes. No offense towards any other of their keyboardists (Tony, Patrick, Igor, Oliver, Jeoffrey). But Rick has his very own special signature.
I guess having one of the greatest living classical pianists in your band might make a noticeable difference. THIS is what separates the boys from the men when it comes to keys. There are rock keyboards, there are jazz keyboards, but at the end of the day, all roads lead to Rick on the piano.
YES.. IS THE BEST OF PROG ROCK, I'VE SEEN SO MANY, BUT NOTHING COMPARES TO.. YES...❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
In 1972 when I was 19 I saw Yes in concert from the 3rd row sitting right in front of Steve Howe. It was one of the best concerts I’ve ever seen. I’ve been a yes fan for more than 50 years. I find it so interesting to see someone discover music that I’ve enjoyed for what seems like forever.
Me too! So great to see people appreciate my music!
I was 4th row. 😂
My first concert...in 1974 at the Broome County (sp) arena in Binghampton NY.
Your music appreciation is immense. This is one of the greatest pieces in the history of rock music and your reaction is just on point.
I'm 64 years old. And dude, this is my favourite song on the greatest album of all time, as far as I'm concerned. If someone asks what I like in music, this one tops my list. I know that there are some great jazz tracks out there that can top this, but this track has all the elements easily to hand. And be sure to check out the other tracks on the album too!
Awesome reactions video! I've never heard of you previously, but I found this video very entertaining. I'll be sure to check out some of your other vids.
P.S. Be sure to check out their triple live album called Yessongs. They can play this shit live too!
You can't imagine being 17 years old and grooving to music like this all the time and then watching it all getting destroyed by disco .
I’d love to know how many hours I spent in the 70’s, stoned with headphones on, listening to this and Tales.
I’m so glad I grew up in the 70’s…..
This song is one of the most influential pieces to ever be created! If you think about how many time signatures, from song structure, lyrics and simply masterful musicianship, and the fact that you have multiple genres of music all wrapped in one song!? And released in 1972! This song changed not only the rock/progressive genre, but influenced countless musicians for decades to come! We will probably never have anything like this again, so thank you Yes for blessing us with this Masterpiece ❤️
Yes, it is an awesome journey to listen to. They don't sound like anything you have experienced before, and you can appreciate the artistry each member brings into it. Simply in a class of their own.
13 yrs old when this came out. STILL LOVE THEM.
Yes's masterpiece, imo. Maybe someone already commented, but the highest harmony voice is the bassist, Chris Squire. Such an amazing musician. He joined a church choir at the age of six and learned how to sing harmony. His bass lines are so inventive, and his grindy, clanky tone is just brutal. Goat.
Goat for sure
Oh, and as hard to believe as it is, they did indeed perform this live, very faithful to this epic studio version. I saw them live "in the round" during their '75-76 tour and this was their opener...still in my top three all time concerts.
Also saw the "in the round" tour. Also a top 5 for me.
I saw the "in the round" tour at the Forum in LA as well. One of my all time fav concerts as well.
I saw them in Oakland California I don't remember if it was 1976 or 1977 when the concert was over my three friends I was with were in a band and Yes was their Heroes we chased their limos all the way to the San Francisco Airport and they had to stop at a gate and that's when we jumped out and we all got their autographs.
In the round was 78-79.
74-75 was the Relayer tour.
Wow! What a show that must have been!!
I've been moved to tears by this song before, not ashamed to admit it. That final few minutes is so moving.
Now that's it's all over and done, now that you find, now that you're whole, seasons will pass you by
“Soon” is the one that brings me to tears, even at 65 years old.
Pure genius is an accurate description.
These guys were in their 20’s. Let that sink in.
Merry Christmas to you and yours!🙂
My favorite song ever by my favorite band ever. And now one of my favorite reactions ever to the song. It truly makes a lot of us old cats well up to see people discover the music we’ve loved so much for so long. It’s also very rare for people, especially younger folks, to hear music this complex and adventurous and LONG for the first time and just “get it” immediately. These kinds of reactions absolutely make my day, so thanks for posting if you happen to read comments!
My thougts too……exactly! Music has become so dumbed down that people now JUST DON’T EVEN REALISE that music can be like this. A journey, a trip, an adventure for the soul. The FEELS I get watching this are unreal. My sister passed away last year and she’s the one that got me obsessed with music generally, especially PROG. I remember her saying that she’d been listening to CLOSE TO THE EDGE for 50 years and it still made her feel like she felt listening to it the first time. This album has shaped my entire soul.
@@tronlady1 Very well said, and sounds like you had an amazing sister. I bet she’s listening along with you every time you are hearing those songs she introduced you to!
YES is my favorite band, and got me into prog rock!
I feel blessed to not just appreciate this music, but LOVE it.
It’s like the best of symphonic music and modern music.
Well said... me too. It takes times and focus to get it.
Watched u til the end. Beautiful. Thank u
You have just reacted to my favorite song of all time! I first heard this song in 1982 when my Brother-in-Law introduced me to it. It was NOTHING like anything I had ever heard before, or since. I absolutely LOVE watching people listen to this song for the first time, and you DID NOT disappoint! One thing I can tell you: You can listen to this song over and over again, year after year, and somehow notice things you never heard before! There is so much greatness occurring in this song, that you’ll be focusing on a sound, and miss all the other things going on around it! GREAT REACTION, and I LOVE this channel! Peace!
I remember as a kid going through my brother's record & tape collection when he was out to find the "Starsky & Hutch" mad song he played. It was Yes, "Heart Of The Sunrise". Thank god for older siblings.
Douglas, I just can't add anything to your excellent comment. Except I discovered YES and this album in high school in 1975. It is as spiritual and special to me now as it was back then.
Me too. As soon as he reacted the way that this song warrants, that moment I SUBSCRIBED.
So true. I’ve been listening to this song for 50 years and it’s always fresh, always amazing.
Amen to that!
You asked what is this song? It's the greatest song ever written! In my ever so YES loving humble opinion.🤩Make sure you listen to the other two masterpieces on the album.
Listen close to the lyrics, The name of the Group has been shortened from what it is. When you realize who the master is. This song in ways describes a NDE. This place we reside today is not all there is. Ponder your earthly clothes and your soul.
@@robertforsythe3280 please elaborate? I’m keen to hear more!!!,
@@robertforsythe3280 please elaborate? I’m keen to hear more!!!
@@tronlady1 Jon Anderson is very spiritual. Yes is short for Yeshua. The name the Disciples of Christ called him. Many of the songs by this band have meanings few understand. Close to the Edge is a parable for a NDE. When one has had a NDE you are no longer afraid of death of your human house or as today Avatar body. You are connected to spirit and may have gifts to connect you in a way to the above.
If you loved this song listen to Awaken from the Going for the One Album
Over the top guitar and keyboards
Speaking as someone who used to be in a garage band, even more incredible than the creation of this song is the fact that they could pull it off when playing LIVE and make it sound just as awe-inspiring as the studio version. Their musicianship was off the scale. I loved the analogy of a Greatest Hits montage, that feels perfect. Most successful bands would need an entire career to come up with the musical moments that YES put into this single song. Peace!
Night after night!
I have seen YES, 2 times, once in the ROUND! The stage rotates around the whole concert! Great show!
I caught them once in 91 and feel very lucky that Anderson, Bruford, Wakeman, Howe and Squire were all there. I was blown away how accurately they could play music that is so complex.
Saw them 3 times in the round starting in 78. Hampton VA each time. Cherished memories.
This song changed my life at 14 when I first discovered it. Since we’re still listening 50 years later and still blown away by it, I guess it wasn’t just a fad like bell bottoms 😊
Bell bottoms are not a fad.
I'm a musician. I am one of those nerdy prog rockers. The beauty is they didn't give two shits about money. Deepest respect.❤️
@Satanic Panic Fun and Games That is why music like this is underground.
They knew what they were creating. That it was something amazing that they were doing, and could show the world. They were performing at their highest levels.
Chris Squire's bass at the 13:45 mark just cannot be rivaled. Send shivers down my spine even decades later.
Insane those syncopations/displacements... Never get tired of it
Went to see Yes live in my late teens. Chris Squire was also something to watch. Watching his speed, unusual in a bass player, verified his virtuosity. Whole band was tight and fast.
I'm so happy that you had the wisdom and intuition to take on this magnificently mind blowing song! It was a joy to be with you on this leg of your musical journey. At 68 years of age, I just had my older Brother, a life long Recording Studio Engineer who is now 70, just sent me an e-mail about me taking him to Tampa Stadium to experience YES on their Close to the Edge Tour. It was a cold and rainy February night that neither of us will ever forget! Thanks again for allowing me the opportunity to witness your mind trying to wrap itself around hearing Close to the Edge for the very first time. It was an honor! Thank you so very much! I'm about to share this video with him.
In 100, 200, 500 or even 1000 years this will be regarded as One of the best musical compositions produced by consummate human beings and musicians as well as recording engineers. This piece of work stands equal to and comparison with the great classical composers; put simply its an absolute masterpiece. I think Ive listened to this over a 100 times or more and each time it deeply impresses me and often still reduces me to tears. I am so glad you get it, its life affirming stuff.
About time you did Yes. Without doubt the best ever group
Yup
Agree
Certainly the greatest prog album.
The use of the Moog synthesizer changed music forever, Rick Wakeman was at the forefront of that revolution. Yes is iconic.
yes Rick Wakeman with yes and Kieth Emerson with Emerson Lake and Palmer
It wasn't just rick what about Keith Emerson 😊
@colindelaney4013 yeah, you're right!
My favorite song! Classical composers and musicians are blown away when they first hear this.
One of the greatest pieces of music ever recorded
IMO, this is the greatest single piece of music ever recorded.
The genius of Steve Howe (Guitar) is that he plays a mind melting patch of speed notes, then slows down just enough that you can catch up with what just happened, then he does it again. And again.
This is my desert island album. One album only. This is it. Listen to the rest of it.
I couldn’t agree more! (My second choice (if I could have one) would be Dark Side of the Moon.)
I’m very torn between this and Skylarking by XTC for my “one album” list, but I think this is always ahead by a nose.
You have hit upon one of the greatest bands and greatest songs ever experienced in the history of humankind. Yes, there is nothing like it. Pure, unadulterated prog rock. If you want to find more like this, I'd suggest Tarkus by ELP and Firth of Fifth by Genesis. ELP and Genesis are two bands I'd suggest you examine, along with another mind-blowing band Pink Floyd (After you listen to Dark Side of the Moon, you will never be able to return to life as you knew it). BTW, I call these three songs the epitome and trinity of prog rock. Yes has three foundational albums, of which Close to the Edge is one, along with Fragile and The Yes Album. Rick Wakeman on keys, Bill Bruford drums, Steve Howe guitars, Chris Squire bass, and Jon Anderson on lead vocals are individually and collectively some of the best musicians this planet has ever experienced, all virtuoso players and stellar song crafters, as well. Welcome to the Valhalla of rock. To receive your full anointment and membership in the club, you must complete the journey by listening to Tarkus and Firth of Fifth. Good luck.
The late 60's and 70's musically was a great time to be alive.
Try Mystery if you harken back to the old days: ua-cam.com/video/RYHrto5U5MY/v-deo.html
@@michaelkeudel8770 Thanks I'll give it a listen
@@michaelgnit8476 That album was released 1998. This what they sound like today, newest song released 1 month ago, new album early 2023: ua-cam.com/video/f2nBw63L8TA/v-deo.html
i am in total agreament regarding the journey
It's a river born in the mountains rushing down through gorges and plains, over waterfalls into deep calm pools and through jungles , finally at the estuary and the the heavenly surrender to the ocean.
I am 68 and saw this live in 1972 at Belle Vue Manchester,all I can say is from that moment on my life changed in a way that is undescribable and absolutely no sound on earth has EVER been able to come anywhere close.
This and "Yours is no disgrace" will be played at my funeral and both tracks have been always been and always will be my "Go to" sounds whenever I need direction in life
I am serious when I say I couldn't live without them .
This is the greatest hit ever-musically speaking- Yes 💪👍 Thx.
So glad you reacted to this! My favorite band, album and musical piece. I first heard it in 1976 at age 15 and saw Yes perform it live several times. The "flip side" is just as amazing! And You and I, and Siberian Khatru.
I'm convinced Yes CttE will be revered for centuries. Like Mozart and Bach!
The same for me wss in Great Britain at 12 y/o when it came out yes has always been in my top 2 bands
Engineer Eddie Offord had a huge part in editing, arranging and mixing this masterpiece. Spiritually, this work reaches heights unmatched by any other prog song. Sublime.
Good call....Offord also engineered some of the Emerson Lake & Palmer LP's....They paid omage to him on the Trilogy LP with the song "Are You Ready Eddie"
Thanks! Finally someone who also credits the extra-member of the band. Without Eddie, no Close To The Edge!
Musical sublimity indeed !
I saw yes at the Boston garden in 1973 it was my first concert (relayer tour) it was on a school night and promised my mom that I would be on time and focused I’m almost 62 and can’t remember what I had for breakfast but I remember everything about that night, YES forever!
Im so blessed that i got to see Yes 18times. The most amazing band ever. So far ahead of everyone. Their songs take you on a spiritual journey. 50 years later i still get chills listening to it. Check out their song "Awakening " and "Gates of delirium ". Will make you cry with joy.
The level of creativity and imagination coupled with top tier musicianship was the mark of the progressive rock genre in the 70s. It was ethereal, complex, provocative, and touched a deeper part of that essence where that musically intuitive part of the human psyche resides and no genre has achieved since.
Very well said
This. Exactly. Just wish kids had something this good now. Fleet Foxes are as good, in their way, as the 70's era musc. Reminiscent of Crosby, Stills and Nash.
It’s amazing that you can hear this for the very first time, and just totally “get” it in every way. Many people need time to develop an ear for this… but you hone in on all the right elements, and you really feel it.
If I may - here is where you should go next with this band: simply “flip the record over” and check out side 2. There are 2 tracks there. Each of the three songs on this album are completely different from one another - and yet, all are equally great in their own way. Hard to imagine, I know.
I recently, early Nov 22, saw the 50th anniversary of Close to the Edge. YES still gets it done. Steve Howe is still top notch. There have been lineup changes as we all know but the band is still kickin. And kickin hard.
A masterpiece of musical artistry forever engrained in my being..On the same level as Bach and Beethoven..
There really is a harpsichord feel to Wakeman's organ and Howe's mandolin.
Polo I saw this band six times in my lifetime. All in the seventies when I was in the military overseas in England. They're still my favorite band. This is also one of the best toke em bands that you'll ever see. I have all their albums 20+. Every atom has a different theme and dounds differnt. You got a lot of listening to do. Lol but thanks for reation.
To me CTTE is the finest music ever created, perfect in every way. It is God's music 💓
I literally said “Holy Sh*t” when I saw the thumbnail- my favorite YES song/ album side AND my new favorite reactor. 🙏🏼 Thank you Polo and many thanks to your donation patreon! 🤘🏼🎧🤟🏼
You've really going down a rabbit hole with this band! 😉
They have live videos of this on UA-cam. And it's as outstanding as the studio version. They don't miss a single note!
Close To The Edge is a JOURNEY man, a luscious soundscape that really takes you in and doesn't let go until the very end, and yeah I agree, I still think this is one of the greatest songs ever composed ;?)
You CAN see them "perform this live." The concert movie is YESSONGS. It's here on UA-cam.
"Close to the Edge" starts at 23:00 minutes in.
You'll be happy.
Truth told, I heard the Yessongs concert album before I heard the studio version and I've always preferred the live take (the levels seem actually better engineered -- my taste)
Eddie Offord was a fucking genius of a sound man. So was Glyn Johns. :-)
Queenspark vid is pretty good.
Totally agree with you on the Yessongs version. It’s obvious they’d had time to “play it in”
The Yessongs performance was great, but the whole recording lacked bass power IMO
The same to me: I had the Yessongs album before the studio versions of CTTE and Fragile, and do like the live versions better. They are Live and energetic
I remember when Close to the edge was released. Imagine hearing it in '72 when nobody else was doing anything like this. Even today it's unique. Keep in mind there was no digital anything. Synthesizers could only play one note at a time, Synthesizers had no presets, you had to dial in every sound. There was no tap tempo for the effects, etc...
Yeah incredible...sounds like something no one could even produce in 2022 and they did THIS in 1972. Incredible.
And then they'd Play It all, Live, night after night!? Astounding Musicians.
I've been listening to this song for close to 50 years and it never gets old.
The greatest song ever recorded. I could listen to this forever. I can’t recall a more perfectly written and composed song ever. My opinion
One of the reason the sound scape changes often, is, when they were recording it, they would have to pack all their gear up, go off and do some gigs, then come back to the studio and then rebuild their gear, and start recording again. So obviously the sound kept changing in the studio. Yes are unique on all fronts. I hope you have watched some of the recording them live from this period of their musical career. That is where they really shine - LIVE!
YES and the prog rock catalog is huge with lots more to hear. Good luck with your journey!
Greatest song ever written
Awesome reaction, most people hearing this for the first time would just hear noise, but you got it right away, I have been listening to this song for 40 years now and I still hear things I never noticed before. Sometimes I will listen just trying to concentrate on one instrument like the drums and it blows me away how Bill knows what to play with so many changes going on, Then I will play it through just listening to the bass, and I think wtf is he doing? why on earth would he have thought of playing that part like that? this is pure genius and the same goes for the keyboards and vocals, YES are and awesome band and you you showed a lot of respect for their art so I am now subscribed and will check out your other videos.
Imagine some kids came here from another galaxy and they have complete mastery of every earthly instrument we possess, but then they say “enough of this tame sound by the rules y’all… let’s just bang around and have some fun!!”
❤ Yes!! 👍🏼
The best lp by the best band ever! Epic!! Tool and Rush both influenced by Yes.
This ☝️. So many bands influenced by Yes. Don't forget Dream Theater 🫡
Jon Anderson-vocals, Steve Howe-guitar, Bill Bruford-drums, Madman Rick Wakeman-keyboards, and the best bassist in the history of rock, the late, great Chris Squire. Geniuses on every instrument. Almost 55 years ago and nobody has come close to touching the level of these masterpieces. I would bet that people will be listening to and analyzing these songs a hundred years from now. Probably more.
@Nancy, this is James Shatley. I am not surprised I find you here! Yes is forever in our musical hearts & the lads captured lightning on vinyl. I LOVE this album!
James! How in the heck are you??
I saw this tour in 72 when it first came out. Amazing concert and enjoy yourself.
@Satanic Panic Fun and Games no but a second hand smoke hi was inevitable as we were sitting in the balcony
Piece i have ever heard. And I discovered it when I was 19. It changed my life because I think about the fact of the idea of composting something like that. That's why I love YES over every other options of music with ant kind of doubt. Nobody can do it. Not even conceive it..!!
Yes is pure genius! I’ve seen them at least half a dozen times live, even more incredible! Def watch this live!!!❤️
The opening section sounds insane at first. Then on later listenings, you realize it was filled with musical foreshadowing of parts to come later. You even mentioned that you thought you had heard the melody before. You had. In the intro. I don’t feel bad. I’m a musician and I still find new stuff in there all the time. I’ve played this song regularly for decades. Every couple weeks or months… It’s always a great ride.
After hearing, and loving, this song for years, I saw them play it live.
Literally, the words that passed through my head as it ended, were, “I could die right now, and it would be OK.”
Yes was like the beginning of progressive rock. Experimenting with sounds, instruments, timing and everything. I went to this concert with my sister when the album first came out. I don’t think we barely breathed from the start of this song til the end. We had Never heard anything like this! It was so incredible. Those guys never stopped. There was really no words to describe how it made us feel. ❤❤❤❤
You said you would listen to the song again but you won't you will listen to it again and again and again xcetera😊😊😊😊😊
The final few minutes are some of the greatest minutes ever in music
You will totally dig “Roundabout” by Yes
Yes has been with me since I was 14 smoking weed for the first time and listening to Roundabout. My mind was forever blown and my heart opened to this magical band of extremely talented musicians and composers. Saw the in ‘79 in the round performing this and so many other great tracks. This is music that demands your full attention and is overlooked by some who don’t have the patience or appreciation; however those who do get it are transformed and uplifted.
Yep. This song changed my life. Another one you should check out and is rather unknown is, Music of the Spheres by Argent. There's an excellent audio video on UA-cam. The one with the most views.
Also, Ikon, by Tod Rundgrens Utopia. Three songs that blew my mind as a young musician in the 1970's. ✌
I remember seeing this when the band played at The Cow Palace in the Bay Area. When the song slows in the middle, a stunningly beautiful woman in a dress of pure white began dancing off the side of the stage but still in the backstage area. Jon made numerous attempts to get the spotlight on this ethereal dancer but to no avail. I was fortunate enough to have a clear view of her as she danced with a magic that was as beautiful as it was enchanting. This was one of those rare moments when a small few are blessed with a truly unique experience. I will probably never know who that enchantress was, but I will NEVER forget that moment.
It's on the live album called Yessongs. Great live album recording for the day!!
Saw YES at the Nassau Coliseum, NY. 70s. And lost a bet. I said they couldn’t possibly do their songs LIVE. I lost that bet, and experienced an unforgettable concert.
I was there too. One of my all time favorite shows.
Thank you for posting this, Yes is the best progressive rock band of all time.🤟
Glad you posted your first-time reaction. I have always said their music represents what joy feels like. I've been listening to YES for 49 years.
In my mind, this was one of their best. I still remember when I first saw this performed live. I felt like I had witnessed the pinnacle of Yes only to encounter pinnacle after pinnacle during their live performances. I do not believe that there is a more talented group of musicians than those who graced this band.
My friend from high school showed me this gem in high school, about 12 years ago.. This song changed my life and look on music. At the time I never knew music could sound this way. This song is hands down one of my favorites.
Yes, there's nothing like Close to the Edge. It makes me feel wonderful.
As a musician, the way I define music, what music is, is it's a means that enables the composer / musician(s) to directly manipulate your nervous system in order to make you feel something. Emotions, happiness, sadness, excitement, fear, etc. can be produced in the listener directly without any thinking involved. Close to the Edge does that and takes you to all kinds of emotional places. I've loved it from the first time I heard it.
A masterpiece
God bless you for taking the time, opening your mind and your ears. This was my journey nearly 50 years ago. And it changed my life. The breadth of imagination that is not bound by musical skill... Because these 5 musicians can achieve anything.
It was my pleasure to witness you on this journey. The same Journey that changed my life. God bless you.
I feel this song reflects ones life , discordant but energetic at first , then thru different stages as " seasons will pass you by" , all while experiencing the highs and lows of life as you " get up , get down". It actually gets more meaningful as you age. A masterpiece