Differences between Tokyo Ghoul // Manga Vs Anime
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 сер 2024
- I HAD SO MUCH FUN MAKING THIS VIDEO! I really hope you enjoy it! This is a very graphic horror anime and comic so please be warned some of the topics discusses may be uncomfortable. I made the video to talk about the differences between the manga and the anime adaptation. I hope you enjoy. Please comment below with your thoughts! I would love to hear what you think ^.^
💕C O M E. S A Y. H I ! 💕
Mail:
P.O. Box 843
Maplewood NJ 07040
Instagram: / coffeeoverapples
Goodreads: / steffany-ojeda
twitter: / steffanyojeda
Amazon wish list: www.amazon.com...
Book Depository Wish List: www.bookdeposi...
Thrift Books Wish List: www.thriftbook...
Email: coffeecatchats@gmail.com
Music Credit:
Fresh by MBB / mbbofficial Creative Commons - Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported - CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons... Music promoted by Audio Library • Breeze / Fantastic / F...
#tokyoghoul #animereview #manga #coffeeoverapples #booktube #anime
One thing you missed out on, during Jason’s torture of Kaneki in the manga Kaneki’s hair shift was more gradual with him slowly having his hair turn gray the more he was tortured. Whereas the anime had it change instantly upon accepting his ghoul half
its not much of a problem tho, the message is the same
and the "I Am A Ghoul" scene was a much more dramatic scene.
@@konquerance6825 Yah, in the manga he looks completely and utterly deranged while in the anime he just looks depresed, kinda weak in comparison, then again almost all the scenes in the anime are the PG -13 version of the manga
I remember someone mentioning that kaneki's Achilles tendons were cut, which likely means Jason took him out of the chair and the big theory here is that he raped kaneki.
@@thepacific2933no it’s not. Anime makes it seem like the hair magically turns white as soon as Kaneki accepts his inner ghoul
The thing that makes me so mad about the anime is that Ken just randomly joined aogiri tree. In the manga he didn't do that (just lile you said) and it drives me crazy
Thank yooou! I agree!
Not defending it, like at all, I fucking hate the changes the 2nd season had over the manga version, but it could've been a good what-if if Kaneki joined Aogiri to get inside intel so that he could get to the doctor that planted in him Rize's organs and after that destroy or severely hinder Aogiri's plans. If they had the balls to do an scenario like this, it could've been at least excusable, but nah, Ken just joins Aogiri for the lols and he spends most of the anime just being a moopy brooding moron. Good job you hacks
Stupidest part of the anime. Terrible writing lol.
7:14 one issue, in manga it says humans do indeed have RC cells as well. But ghouls have higher RC cells than humans, about 3 times that of a human so the RC scanners go off if a precense with a high RC rate goes through the scanner
the RC cells is the whole reason Ghouls can only sustain themselves off human flesh anyway or by eating other ghouls (though ghoul flesh tastes really awful to ghouls)
Anime: Has No reason for replacing organs.
Manga: More reason for replacing organs.
THANK YOU!👏🏽
@@CoffeeOverApples Np and It also show's rize being held captive. By the doctor If I'm not mistaking.
@@drakenpage777 Yup, in the anime she just, actually dies by some random pipes, but in the manga she gets deliberately crushed by steel beams by Furata, which only knocks her out. From there she gets kidnapped by Kanou after she's out, and held captive and harvested for her regenerating Kakuhou.
@@suzuxiiiahdv Yea and Renji Yomo Keeps her locked up in 1 cell thing. (In the manga), and we learn (In the first manga) about how they are made/how they work.
@@drakenpage777 That happens later. During the raid of Kanou's lab, Kaneki learns Rize is alive and sees her in Kanous holding device. Only later in the raid does Yomo appear to take Rize, and from there he keeps her in a shipping container next to the one he lives in, feeding her just barely enough food to keep her alive.
one of the most crucial scenes in the entire manga has to be the scene in tokyo ghoul:re, where after a completely devastating loss, kaneki is left at the brink of death. he is humiliated, he is told to his face that he has lost it all, and he is left in an immobile state with no way to escape in the moment. the best part about this is that ishida uses this as an opportunity to bring kaneki's whole character full circle by having a meeting happen between all versions of kaneki. in an amazing panel, we see kaneki's current state, with all of his past personas standing over him, wondering where they went wrong to end up here. it is so surreal to see how every version has their own mindset and really demonstrates how much of a complicated human being kaneki is. does it happen in the anime? i dont know, i didnt watch past a few episodes of :re cuz of how horrible it was and i certainly dont want these amazing scenes ruined for me in a bad adaptation. point is, ishida is a genius and uses so many amazing opportunities to bring about interesting characters that feel alive and not just 2D edgy characters. i love this series and hate how the anime turned out, really hoping for a remake someday.
It actually did happen in the anime
literally that scene is in the anime, stop being a manga tard and just watch re:, it can't be that bad. yall act like nothing is salvageable from the anime
@@BEDCORN oh ive watched like half of :re, it was a circus show compared to the manga, if you actually cared about the quality of the story with the finer details intact, youd understand where im coming from. i never once said anyone was in the wrong for liking the anime, if that was enjoyable enough for you then thats whatever. but for me it was not, it was a half-assed adaptation
Watch re bro then come back to make a argument you sound uneducated and uninformed of what your even talking about
Finally an explanation. I just finished watching Tokyo Ghoul today
Oh yeah and what about the German boy that was a servant. Is a male or female because when Eto kidnapped him it showed he had boobs in the kinda naked scene in the anime
@@Bwa he is a male that was made female by his master. they don't explain it much in the anime but the manga shows how it happened. I'm glad you liked the video! will be putting out an explanation to Tokyo ghoul RE in the future *thumbs up*
I wish they rebooted it
@@drunkscotsman5338 finished the anime today should I read the manga. Only if they had a better studio
I don’t think it was the animators being lazy that cut down the show, instead I think the anime is so rushed because they were forced to stick to only 12 episodes per season. Really wish they weren’t limited.
Your probably right. Over all it was a great show 👏🏽👏🏽
The animators being lazy is why the RE anime looked like absolute shit though
The animators are far from lazy it's the crunch culture studios have that is the cause of low quality animations
Yeah the anime adaptation was a rush mess
Seriously! Wish they would have kept to the script.
The Arima fights you mentioned aren't actually changes of each other. They're two different events with one taking place at the end of the original manga(Kaneki loses) and the other in the middle of the sequel manga(Kaneki wins) also called Tokyo Ghoul:re.
yes! when I filmed this I had not read :re yet. will be making that distinction the second video comparing :re to the anime.
Kaneki never actually won against Arima. He was taken to the CCG after the battle.
@@fandomlover9762 he does in :Re
Where you were describing the ending of the Tokyo Ghoul manga, you left out and mixed up quite a lot of things. Kaneki fights Amon in both the anime and manga, though in the manga after being heavily injured and entering a Kakuja state, Kaneki wanders down into the underground tunnels he originally trained with Touka in. He finds Hide down there, where they have a heartfelt moment, before Hide asks Kaneki to eat him to survive. The scene cuts to black, as Kaneki describes the taste of blood in his mouth, before he encounters Arima in the tunnels surrounded by the corpses of ghouls that had tried to defend Anteiku before trying to escape though the tunnels. The tunnels were designated as an escape plan to the ghouls in case they need to escape, also Kaneki percieves the corpses as flowers for a brief moment before realizing they're his dead allies. After that, the scene cuts off, and we're left to assume that Kaneki was killed by Arima in the tunnels.
In the anime however, after being injured in his battle with Amon, Kaneki flees the raid leaving his friends to die, and in the aftermath he meets Hide in a coffee shop. Kaneki and Hide share a similarly heartfelt moment before Hide dies due to prior injuries he sustained during the raid. Kaneki then carries Hide's body to the CCG before being presumably killed by Arima as the screen goes blank. The battle in the anime you're referencing at the end of the video happens during Tokyo Ghoul: Re btw.
Thank you so much, I finally understand what went down for hide to have to wear the mask in re. My 2 hour search is over due to your comment sir, thank you.
I haven't read the manga yet just a couple of chps but have watched the anime. And yes, there are usually not everything explained in the anime well as compared to manga.
Btw I loved your thumbnail!!😍😍
Thanks!😻 let me knoe ehat you think of the manga if you decide to finish it
Thank you for such a clear explanation! Probably will buy a chapter with flashbacks of Amon and Kureo Mado.
Your very welcome! Yes their mentor/trainee relation ship was a good segment of the series 💯
Tokyo ghoul was my first manga series
I'm getting Tokyo ghoul re soon :)
hope you enjoy it!
Thank you (^^)
Why if u can easily read it for free online.
Me too man
@@VideoEssayWatcher5484 no where near as good as a paperback
I watched the anime first but saw a lot of review that the manga was better, and i pursued to finish it and i binge read it for like 5 times manga was masterpiece
It was! My book club is going to be discussing it tomorrow volumes 1-3 you should join us its a 1pm est. Info is in the video titled manga book club announcement
I read the manga and finished the anime, I found them both really good, and I think my favorite anime is Tokyo ghoul
season 1 was the only good thing from the anime while the manga is just godly
Hey i just watched S1 for it's opening and animation so can u start manga at ch 66 where S1 ended or read from start
this is mind blowing how diffrent it is from the anime now i regret collecting most of RE and not starting with the first part i didnt realize it was so diffrent haha no wonder a few terms and things that come up in re dont make a lot of sense or i hadnt heard of before
haha right!? did you get a chance to read it yet? I hope you end up enjoying it!
but im ngl they need to remake the tokyo ghoul anime
Never have I been so addicted of a manga than Tokyo ghoul .And this is the best explanation video for all you anime watchers out there confused by the anime.
thank you so much
Really liked the video, but I just have to point out something, One of the heads of Agori are called Tattera not Arata, Arata is (spoiler alert:) the name of Ayato and Touka's father.
Thanks for the clarification. Probably just got mixed up 😂
@@CoffeeOverApples
No problem
Please do a re: comparison anime and manga differences
promise I am working on it!
Sucks that it most likely wont get the brotherhood treatment. I liked season 1 and 2, but reading the manga right now and it's a much better story. Don't understand why they needed to cut and change so much.
If I have to guess, it's because TG is a full-on seinen with lots of dark scenes and themes, and the studio execs didn't have the balls to animate it without softening both the story and the art direction, cus at least from Naruto till the present they're a shonen studio
I couldn't get into season 1 after I read the manga. Everyone says it's decent but anime watchers don't realize what they are missing in the manga. The world is muchore clearer and better character arcs. They even glossed over important parts to in season 1.
The flowers are Red Spider Lilies. In Japan, they represent Death and Reincarnation.
He sees a field of flower either because there's death all around him, or because he's about to experience death.
It's up to interpretation.
Edit: I assume they are red spider lilies, there's no color in the manga so I wouldn't really know.
thanks for the clarification!
Me personally I really liked the anime even though it doesn’t match the manga in some regards. I like that it still tells some of kaneki’s struggles
I know I'm late and you might have read Tokyo Ghoul Re by now but the Arima fight you were talking about in the anime is actually the 2nd fight Kaneki has with Arima, the first fight was completely cut out of the anime.
yea I did read it and preferred the first season of the anime and first half of the magna so don't think I will be reviewing it. Thanks for watching!
At about 19:48 your taking about kaneki and arimas fight in Tokyo ghoul re: in re: arima kills himself so kaneki can become the new arima. their fight at the end of the first manga is the same as the fight at the end of Route a only in the manga it’s more detailed. It ends with arima telling kaneki he’s gonna use him as his be quinque
The flowers bit is explained in re. I could spoil it for you cuz I don’t think the anime gets into it but if your gonna read the manga i don’t need to 😂
Im reading RE now for the next video 🙈 dont tell me! Cant wait to find out the details
Somone might have said this already but the flowers kaneki keeps seeing are red spider lillys and they represent death in Japanese culture.
"Because Vegeta is a bae". I think Kuki Urie is much more close to Vegeta.
😂 good point
The manga is way better. Season 2 is different from the manga and season 3 removed all the information needed to understand the story.
If you want to know the full story and understand it, read the manga.
In my opinion the anime is still alright, albeit a lot more confusing since they removed a lot of details and character development. Therefore I really recommend you read the manga if you were a fan of the anime.
I agree I read the manga and it was way better
@@CoffeeOverApples Do you think TG will ever get a Reboot that follows the manga and why?
I feel void after I finished the manga still Kaneki was one of the best characters represented in my experience. he had a long path to redeem and accept himself after all the conflict and despair, finally a resolution for his tragic days.
It was amazing 🥺💯
I still cry at the last chapters of :re
i loved the anime at first because it had me intrigued but then it got so confusing especially during and after season 2 , i really don’t want to watch season 3 due to the differences imma suck it up and probably read the manga (which will take me an eternity with my slow reading skills)
Best decision!
Not going to watch all of this video yet because still reading TG, but one difference I think is apparent is that, kaneki learns that cannibalization of other ghouls as a ghoul strengthens yourself. I felt this was not in the anime which is a crucial detail and I think they did not even have the scene of kaneki eating jasons powers.
It's my no.1 Manga/Anime ..
No anime or manga can replace my love for tokyoghoul 😍😍
Never read the manga, so this video definitely helped put things into perspective for me. Loved the anime 👌
Glad I could help!
The manga is a literal masterpiece. It upsets me that people see it as mediocre because of the shit anime.
@@bubbles9844 lucky it seems like more people online are giving the manga a chance 👍🏼
@@bubbles9844 there are people who only prefer anime as it's shorter and wrapped up i guess while reading a manga you have to be more invested in it.. Consider it just like some people prefer movies while some prefer books
This answer so many questions badazz UTa is the 🐐
Tokyo ghoul had so much potential in being an anime, it sucks that they left a lot of main things out. Hopefully someday it gets a remake
i would LOVE a remake!
In season one they changed the order of arc of hinami and Shu
they did! let me know if there is anything you think I should mention in the next video!
@@CoffeeOverApples when kaneki got trapped inside the restaurant by shu in the manga there were 3 people him a 2 humans in the anime i think it was an auction room and he was alone; in the anime there were added a scene were gecko i think its his name (idk it in english) visits hinamis father and also were he gets killed
also the live action tokyo ghoul film that was released in 2017 based alot of stuff from the manga so its one of my fave movies, they made a sequel in 2019 where it involves tsukiyama and the chruch fight and im waiting for them to announce the third film where they introduce aogiri
There's a live action!? *drops everything*
@@CoffeeOverApples yeah :) im not sure where to watch it tho cuz these movie sites are unreliable but its on netflix ! :) its really good tbh, its one of my fave japanese films and i love the actors and plot, they changed the touka actress for the sequel tho cuz she was underpaid and went to attend something called happy science
I hope the anime is remade some day
Me too honestly
kaneki fought a real battle with arima twice. first he lost and in tokyo ghoul re he won
0:25 …but I thought it was a psychological dark fantasy manga…
Yup
Wow thank you so much. I just finished season 1 and 2. I’m pretty disappointed that it’s completely different from the manga,but excited to read the manga!! Do you know a website I can order the whole manga set?! For Tokyo Ghoul!
im so glad this was helpful!! if you want to purchase the manga, barnes and nobles sells omnibus editions of the manga (bind ups of multiple volumes) you should be able to order it online. I have also bought some second hand on thriftbooks.com and book depository. the conditions were fairly decent. hope this helps!
@@CoffeeOverApples wow thank you so much!!! ♥️♥️
The Arima vs Kaneki fight happened like this.
So in the anime when Kaneki fights Amon it was way different than the manga fight. In the manga Amon gets the “Arata”( or sth like that which is a body armor, the same was used to fight Kuzan). Kaneki still beats him but turns into his centipede form. He also rips an arm out of Amons body. The bigger difference from the anime is that he doesn’t fight Arima right away. So in the anime right after he beats Amon, Arima arrives, however in the manga version Arima has been deployed in the underground tunnels or to be precise at the v14 tunnel(?). Kaneki escapes the rest of the doves meets Hide in the tunnels, eats a part of his face and neck( this is shown later in :re when we see Hide’s scars. In the manga we only see Hide trying to calm Kaneki down and then we cut off to Kaneki being alone). After that Kaneki goes to v14 that being the part where tunnels from the 20th ward intercept. There he sees the flowers and that kind of stuff, but that turns out to be only his imagination. What lays before him is all the ghouls who tried to escape. There he has his first battle with Arima and loses badly.
Correction, Hide said to Kaneki to eat him so that he could fight his way out, and cus his ghoul instincts were messing with his conscience he wasn't sure whether he just took a few bites or just straight up ate him whole.
I could be wrong but I think the field of flowers at the end indicates that he lost the metal battle in his head deciding whether he was a ghoul or a human.
I'm confused .season 2 of anime is completely separate from manga? Does that mean season 1 covered the entire manga?
Most of it but different changes
pretty much
I’ve watched season 1 should I keep watching or start the manga. If I start the manga do I start after season 1 or the beginning?
Start the manga from book 1, it might clear up some confusion for you and there is a couple of changes that would help you stay on track with the second half of Tokyo Ghoul
@@anthonyj0112 thanks
@@rippmario your welcome
also that book shelf behind, catch coming to collect every book and manga you have thats horror so i can read em in my room all day lmao
Aaaye! *high five* have you read neon genesis Evangelion? That was my fave horror/sci-fi of last year hands down
@@CoffeeOverApples i was planning on reading it but i dont have money or anywhere nearby to purchase books or manga i like :( but i read manga online as an alternative
@@leviathan9865 it should be available online. I use manganelo
@@CoffeeOverApples is it a free manga site?
@@leviathan9865 yup! Its fan scans so ya know its not legit but they have a ton of manga I do most of my reading there
love the vio, its funny how she answer all my questions that i kept asking when i read the anime haha lol
So glad to help!
Not this dropping on my birthday
Happy birthday!
Do you recommend this as first time reading a manga ? 🖤
Hi! I would say the answer depends on what kind of anime you watch. If you liked the anime or if you prefer horror in general this is a fun way to go. This manga is a bit hardcore on the gore and is the kind that leaves you with more questions than answers so you need some patience to get through the series. For your first manga I would always suggest a oneshot (standalone) or short series so you don't have to get too invested to start. My favorite short series is Planetes by makoto yukimora. If thats too scifi and you want something sweet instead Wish by Clamp is 4 volumes. 👍🏼
The battle at Kanos house was the battle of Cochlea. Then later in re there is the real battle of Cochlea which is for Kaneki to save hinami and a lot of ather stuff
Really Really Really good video!
thank you so much!
She made me want to watch and read them both
aaaw thanks ^.^ hope you enjoy it!
There are two fights of Arima vs Kaneki one at the end of Tokyo Ghoul and one in the middle of Tokyo Ghoul :Re the anime just cut out the whole first fight
You’re confusing me more then you are helping me. You said you haven’t read season 2 manga which is season 3 anime…but you are also jumping between season 2 anime and season 3 anime content while referencing what you already said you haven’t read yet…I’m so lost. I thought we’d be talking about season 2 since they didn’t follow the manga so season 3 would make sense but we’re jumping from 2 to 3 to 2 to 3 to 3 to 2 to 3 and it’s making no sense at all…
My brain can’t process or understand this >_< I tired but manga and anime doesn’t make sense to me >_
right i was confused too. basically there were moments from the anime season 3 that were actually in manga season 1. I watched the full anime so that how I knew what plot points were not from manga season 1 which I did read. Sorry it was confusing ^.^
I watched the anime first and liked it, so these should be amazing 😊
hope you enjoy it!
@@CoffeeOverApples also is there a certain store or website you get your manga from that you would recommend
How many mangas are there?
There are two books Tokyo Ghoul and Tokyo Ghoul re if I'm correct
Yes there are two seasons to the manga and bot have 14 volumes so 28 manga in total
@@CoffeeOverApples the base series has 14 volumes. RE has 16 volumes
@@operaghostkay gasp* i'm missing two lol
@@CoffeeOverApples the last two are verrry important
Whats better tokyo ghoul or the “ re “ version
Tokyo ghoul is better in my opinion.
Juuzo is best character
in the manga hide dosn't die
Did Tokyo Ghoul: re 3rd and 4th season of the anime followed the manga really well or not?
a bit, with some ommisions
@@CoffeeOverApples Good to know!
Were can i buy that manga book?
I feel like this could have been better organized. I can’t tell what order these different events happen and I was really trying to avoid having to read the manga.
Is your channel name a death note and Tokyo ghoul reference? I’m new
🤫😉
Just finished the anime although I'm confused on s2 ? cuss i think the 1st and 2nd episode is the same as s1. i think its the app? idk
Beautiful look.
Thank you so much!
I read the first volume and it was explained better
Right?!
kaneki vs arima was pretty shortend but its it exactly same as the re manga arima kills himself
Yeah the field of flowers were really just a bunch of bodies from Irimi’s gang the Black Dobers that were killed by Arima, there may have been a couple of deceased CCG investigators but Kaneki does state that he smelled “Over-matured and decaying flowers” which would mean it smelt awful to him (i think) possibly because of the ghoul bodies but I’m still not 100% on this sooo :/
that makes sense thanks for the explanation!
@@CoffeeOverApples no problem, I tried my best to not confuse you but then ended up confusing myself a couple of times 😅 it took about an hour to think
I was always confused on why people hated Tokyo Ghoul after s1, now I understand why
I'm so glad this was helpful 😊
I’ve started to read the manga, and god damn, I absolutely love it
glad you are enjoying it!
Ahhh the deception of shounen anime
lol indeed
Plz reply if you have a suggestion where I can order the whole manga set!! English version of course! 😁😊
do let me know how your like the manga!
i stop watching after she said Tokyo Ghoul is a horror anime
Thank you for saying so. Why is that?
20:40 I thought that the field of flowers were all of the dead humans/ ghouls they were standing on. I believe it does say that they were standing on all the bodies somewhere in the manga :)
hahahaha good to know I'm not crazy. thanks! hoping to put up review of :re soon =D
Coffee Over Apples can’t wait to hear it, I’m still reading the re manga
@@SenkoiNaki hope you enjoy it!
I haven’t read all of Re: yet, but if I thought the flowers actually had a purpose, like something about them can suppress rc cells, so they vent them in the cells to help keep the ghouls in check & that’s why there’s a room full of them under the prison, or something like that, at least I’ve heard shit along those lines l before, but like I said I haven’t finished Re: yet so idk if it’s true, pretty curious about them now tho lol
Yup, in the last volume kaneki mentions that he was so captivated by Arima’s beauty that he didn’t realise that “what lay beneath my feet was not flowers but an exorbitant amount of death”
Gigguk was right it makes sense in the manga
When you're referring to season 3 of the anime, are you referring to :re? That was the only confusing part
Yes I am 🥰
Arima does fight and kinda kill himself in re they tottally skipped the Kaneki Murder fight at the end of volume 14
I have never read a manga but after watching finishing Tokyo Ghoul i feel like it’s missing a lot of plot. Should i invest my time and read the manga?
Yes! The manga is much better plot wise than the anime adaptation.
Coffee Over Apples okay thank you, but should i read the original or TG:re??
@@jonnnyz9519 :re is the second season of the manga. Read tokyo ghoul first then tokyo ghoul :re second.
I like the anime, but the manga was better written.
Yes!!! I AGREE👏🏽👏🏽
Juzo got no balls
Would have been better with a few more images. Overall great vid.
I don’t mind the story in season 2 but Jesus fuck the animation change, and just fuck re
Its totally different from the show?? I never heard of something like that before thats crazy but interesting
yea very different but still enjoyable
Anime was very good if you havent read the manga😁
haha very true
I never read the manga just watched the anime. I honestly thought season 1&2 were amazing.
they were great! It just didn't match the manga
First season 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 second season 🤔🤔🤔😵😵😵 and I stop
Just skip season 2 and go straight to RE 🤣
The Manga is just much much vetter
agreed!
PLS TELL ME THE WHOLE ORDER TO WATCH/READ THE TG?!
First read Tokyo Ghoul (144 chapters) then Tokyo Ghoul:re (183 chapters). Thats it
@@dino.antares this^
just skip the anime, it's not worth your time to be completely honest.
the anime missed out a lot of infos from the manga tbh
It did!!! Manga was way better
@@CoffeeOverApples indeed!!