YF-23 Black Widow II Vs YF-22 Raptor | Advanced Tactical Fighter | Digital Combat Simulator | DCS |

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лют 2025
  • Check out the Store: growling-sidew...
    CHECK OUT THE MINI DOCS CHANNEL: ‪@Mini_Docs‬
    Join the channel if you wish to support
    / @growlingsidewinder
    Ka-52 Download: www.currenthil...
    If You'd like to Support the Channel on Patreon:
    / growlingsidewinder
    Join my Discord:
    / discord
    Social Media
    ________________________________________________________
    Instagram: / growling_sidewinder
    Twitter: / growlingaim9
    Facebook: / growlingaim9
    Amazon Links for the products I use if you're interested:
    _________________________________________________________
    Link for Thrustmaster 16000M: amzn.to/2PQGYf2
    Link for Trackir 5: amzn.to/2VSN4kt
    Link for Warthog throttle/stick: amzn.to/2Vbfhyp
    Contact me:
    GrowlingSidewinder@hotmail.com
    Disclaimer: Please Note that I use sound effects to enhance my videos for dramatic effect and hopefully give the viewer more immersion and also I use reshade for some better colors. (you can download reshade yourself and use it to make your DCS look like mine).
    Processors: AMD Ryzen 9 5950X 16-Core 3.4GHz (4.9GHz Max Boost)
    Motherboard: Gigabyte X570 AORUS Elite WiFi
    Memory: 128GB CORSAIR VENGEANCE RGB PRO 3200MHz (4x32GB)
    System Cooling: CORSAIR H100i PRO XT RGB
    Graphics Cards: NVIDIA 10GB GeForce RTX 3080
    Operating System: MS Windows 10 Professional
    Operating System Drive: 2TB Samsung 970 EVO Plus PCIe NVMe
    Hard Drive: 2TB Samsung 980 PRO
    Power Supply: CORSAIR AX1600i ATX Titanium
    Tobii Head and Eye Tracking: www.tobii.com/
    Virtual Reality: Pimax 8KX
    HeadTracker: Trackir5
    Thrustmaster F/A-18C Hornet stick and Warthog Throttle.
    Thrustmaster TRP pedals.
    On this channel we like to do a lot of dogfighting most videos are some sort of dogfight between 2 different aircraft as we explore their different capabilities. From time to time I like to dabble in Virtual Reality, I think VR is a great new technology and I love to show that stuff off for the channel from time to time.
    If you enjoy war thunder or Microsoft flight simulator 2020 or even dogfighting in Battlefield 2042, consider getting yourself into Digital Combat Simulator by Eagle Dynamics, the Combat side of Aviation with the BVR and Dogfights really provides a different and interesting perspective on aviation. You can fly all kinds of combat aircraft including the F-16, F-15, F-14, JF-17, Su-27, Mig-29, Mirage and the F-18 Hornet along with many other aircraft and helicopters like the Ka-50 and Mi-8.

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @GrowlingSidewinder
    @GrowlingSidewinder  Рік тому +52

    Check out the Merch Store: growling-sidewinder.creator-spring.com/
    Thank you guys for watching and if you have any ideas for future videos please put them in the comment section below and they might just end up in the pipeline, thanks again, much Love.

  • @studlydudly
    @studlydudly Рік тому +1225

    The YF23 still looks like something from the future, even today.

    • @rogerdatruntings
      @rogerdatruntings Рік тому +23

      Damn straight.

    • @VIDGamer
      @VIDGamer Рік тому +17

      Idk why but when i see it i think of a slightly more futuristic su-57 and I automatically think it's ugly lol

    • @BlyGuy
      @BlyGuy Рік тому +57

      It's a 6th gen design in a 5th gen comp

    • @tyronnezx
      @tyronnezx Рік тому +20

      @@VIDGamer Also....the SU57 is a bit of a descendant of the YF-23. They incorporate the same S-duct to hide the engine heat and radar cross section

    • @traviswalker8933
      @traviswalker8933 Рік тому +14

      Yeah, but the canopy bow ruins it. The F-22 provides a better situational awareness and great all around viability.

  • @finnwilson6265
    @finnwilson6265 Рік тому +949

    When your missiles have larger radar cross sections than your aircraft.

    • @maverickmissile801
      @maverickmissile801 Рік тому +20

      Yea lol

    • @sogerc1
      @sogerc1 Рік тому +79

      Yeah, probably that's why that AMRAAM went for the other AMRAAM.

    • @KKtheKitten
      @KKtheKitten Рік тому +2

      true

    • @RazorsharpLT
      @RazorsharpLT Рік тому +25

      Damn, future aircraft warfare will be cool. Imagine people shooting missiles at each other, just for them to lock on to the other missile. Loads of explosions in the sky, and then... a return to pure WW2 dogfights with heat seekers, but even those will be problematic unless you have a tail lock due to all the heat resistant material and the plane's manouverability. In the end - guns will be all you have left
      Hope the US army doesn't make the same mistake it did in Vietnam with the "missiles make dogfights obsolete" if they ever go against the J-20. Though the F-22 will have it outmatched there due to it's maneuverability

    • @GeneralThunderbolt
      @GeneralThunderbolt Рік тому +9

      ​@@RazorsharpLTapparently the J-20 doesn't have a gun only missiles so it will lose regardless

  • @maverickmissile801
    @maverickmissile801 Рік тому +325

    Well, you know what that means...
    We need a YF23 vs Su57 video!

    • @Leo-e3j7o
      @Leo-e3j7o Рік тому +19

      I second that

    • @avi8aviate
      @avi8aviate Рік тому +28

      The Su-57's "stealth" would be curbstomped.

    • @CaptainSpacedOut
      @CaptainSpacedOut Рік тому +11

      That doesnt seem like a fair fight 🤣

    • @teemukustila
      @teemukustila Рік тому +15

      I don’t think the SU-57 would stand a chance, stealth wise.

    • @Leo-e3j7o
      @Leo-e3j7o Рік тому +7

      @@teemukustila True, but the hypersonic missiles and hyper maneuverability would challenge the Widow

  • @TheOtherSlideYT
    @TheOtherSlideYT Рік тому +332

    Pretty neat history lesson! I had no idea the YF-23 even existed. It's amazing how these older planes are still more advanced than most flagship jets today 😂

    • @andreabindolini7452
      @andreabindolini7452 Рік тому +62

      Well, you missed one of the coolest looking fighters ever made, and the one that was actually *better* than the original YF-22 in many respects, but it lost because it was a too big leap for the time - the YF-22 was seen as a more traditional and "reassuring" design, a sort of "stealth F-15". No surprise that the original YF-23 concept revived in some regards in the current 6th generation fighter projects.

    • @danpatterson8009
      @danpatterson8009 Рік тому +3

      You make me feel old. Thanks.

    • @42ZaphodB42
      @42ZaphodB42 Рік тому +26

      @@andreabindolini7452 That's not true. The YF-23 was simply different in a couple of aspects (stealthier and faster, but less maneuverable) and the YF-22 just better fit the needs of the airforce. You don't need to forcefully inject an "underrated" story into everything.

    • @derekaldrich330
      @derekaldrich330 Рік тому +27

      ​@birbdad1842 There was some political consideration in the decision as well. By that time the USAF has been burned by Northrop on delays and cost overruns with the B-2 program. Compounding that was the fact that Lockheed performed a live-weapons demonstration and high-AOA demonstration, whereas McD-Northrop did not. The F-22 was the safer choice, especially given that the program was already a decade old.

    • @TheOtherSlideYT
      @TheOtherSlideYT Рік тому

      Sorry! 😆@@danpatterson8009

  • @bbbeezy
    @bbbeezy Рік тому +179

    I always loved the look of the YF-23 and wanted it to win vs. the YF-22. It just looked so much more advanced and cool.

    • @edwardklein5770
      @edwardklein5770 Рік тому +36

      Yes, the YF-22 looked like an evolution of the F-15. The YF-23 looked like something we'd use to fight off an alien invasion. Such a incredibly futuristic looking plane.

    • @traviswalker8933
      @traviswalker8933 Рік тому +1

      Canopy bows aren't really cool.

  • @Vladimirthetiny
    @Vladimirthetiny Рік тому +125

    The YF-23 was like the F-20 one of those "best fighters never" aircraft

    • @BARelement
      @BARelement Рік тому +19

      Northrop be getting shafted as if they aren’t the GOATS OFTHIS

    • @profo4544
      @profo4544 Рік тому +10

      its still technically the first and only 6th gen airframe, its fully unique while the f-22 looks like they just tried to stealth out a f-15 or something. Its also the best interceptor still to this day pretty much if it flew.

    • @deltasierracharlie
      @deltasierracharlie Рік тому +20

      @@profo4544
      What??
      That's nonsense.
      The YF-23 airframe is definitely not 6th gen. Far from it.
      The proposed F-23, just like the F-22, was designed to fully meet the 5th gen requirements of the USAF's ATF program. And it does meet them. But nothing more than that.
      That's why both F-22 and F-23 had similar stealth, range and flight envelope and performance characteristics.
      No one on Earth in the late 80s had the technology and ability to design/develop a 6th gen jet. Hell, all of those companies taking part in the ATF program were only just inventing/creating the concept of 5th gen aircraft at the time.
      6th gen capabilities and technology was the last thing on the minds of the people responsible for designing and developing the ATFs.
      The USAF and US aerospace industry only really started thinking about and developing 6th gen fighter requirements, capabilities and tecnology in the early 2010s, no earlier than that.
      NGAD will be on whole different level in terms of stealth, range and avionics and sensors.

    • @RobertStrong124
      @RobertStrong124 Рік тому +5

      @@BARelement The DoD was concerned that the same issues that plagued the B-2 program would plague the F-23, which was a factor in the decision.

    • @profo4544
      @profo4544 Рік тому +3

      @@deltasierracharlie Im talking airframe being unique but it kind of is, the yf-23 doesnt even have splitters, the f-22 is rocking splitters, the yf-23's rear tailplanes moved on a huge axis much like how the su 57s move, but the yf-23s tailplanes were the size of a f-35 wing, the raptor didnt even beat it high speed manueverability, only low speed. And the yf-23 was operating a what mach 2 ? with the same engines the f-22 was topping out at mach 1.6.. Whats making the difference? the Airframe. The yf-23s airframe took ques from nothing, its a fully unique diamond wing design, if a 6th gen body got built today ? it would be a fully unique computerized design, just like the yf-23 was. I mean dude, ur aware the yf-23 could manuever and operate at speeds the f-22 couldnt even reach ? Out of all the categories, the raptor beat it in one, low speed manueverability. This isnt even bringing into the IR masking the yf-23 used, the bigger weapons bay able to carry bombs, all the f-22 could carry is air to air. And the yf-23s stealth signature was actually smaller than the f-22's, and more likely to be confused with something else, while the f-22 was a solid but small dot, all while being a larger plane than the f-22. And isnt japan using the yf-23 as somesort of inspiration for there ngad project or whatever there coming up with.

  • @lindenbyrne7725
    @lindenbyrne7725 Рік тому +148

    Another big contender for why the F 22 was chosen was due to upgrade ability over the YF 23. Fun fact when interviewing a test pilot for the 23 he said it was the most stable platform he had ever flown on and even mentioned that he felt it was possible to let go of controls while preforming mid air refuelling, for a pilot to even suggest this is insane and shows what the test pilot though of the aircraft he was flying.

    • @Velodictorian
      @Velodictorian Рік тому +31

      As formidable as the F-22 is (and I’m a big fan), this point is rather moot considering the AF is phasing out the F-22 with the F-35. The Pentagon’s move to green light the F-22 in hindsight is a bit of a blunder as the YF-23 could’ve fulfilled the role of the F-35 and F-22 and still been superior than both of them. And it would’ve had a 10 year operability advantage over the F-35.

    • @lindenbyrne7725
      @lindenbyrne7725 Рік тому +16

      @@Velodictorian not very feasible considering that the airframe itself would (from what I herd) not last past 2005-2010 other then completely remodelling the internal systems and changing the cockpit. For what the program was asking for, the 22 preformed what it was for far longer then what the 23 would be capable of. The YF 23 is my favourite aircraft but I believe that the U.S. made a logical decision about what would offer them the longest term security. Which is more then I can say for some of their other “great” decision’s.

    • @Velodictorian
      @Velodictorian Рік тому +6

      @@lindenbyrne7725The same thing was said about F-15 and A-10 and they figured out how to upgrade them. That saying I have no idea the cost of maintaining an F-23 would’ve been and from my (poor) understanding is that’s one of the key factors for phasing out the F-22

    • @NationChosenByGod
      @NationChosenByGod Рік тому +6

      The YF-23 was stable, but the YF-22 was so unstable that it can barely fly straight. So what does that say about the aircraft?

    • @robinmickelsson-htta3413
      @robinmickelsson-htta3413 Рік тому

      "When inteviewing". Did you do that?

  • @paulcooper9011
    @paulcooper9011 Рік тому +208

    I was a fan of the 23 over the 22.
    Japan has currently formed a partnership with the UK and the Tempest program for their next (6th gen) fighter as it very closely matched their own program.

    • @bertram-raven
      @bertram-raven Рік тому +10

      Yes, one benefit of Brexit was the UK being permitted to do things they do best; cutting edge battlefield technology.
      I can see the US Navy buying a large chunk of EW and CEW technology from the UK in about nine years.

    • @Prophet-of-the-Unknown-Lord
      @Prophet-of-the-Unknown-Lord Рік тому +4

      Italy is also part of the program (GCAP - Global Combat Air Program). Sweden has also signed an agreement to cooperate with Japan, and Saudi Arabia is pushing to join.

    • @TheRealAdds
      @TheRealAdds Рік тому +11

      @@bertram-raven Lmao.
      > Omits that Italy and Sweden (both EU members) are also part of the Tempest program
      > Forgets that the British would've never built the Typhoon and Tornado without the Germans
      Being an EU member has nothing to do with such "strategic" decisions. Unless you believe Bozza and the Daily Mail that is. Tempest was conceived before Brexit too. Hell France built Rafale on their own. But then again, I don't expect much from Brexiteers in 2023.

    • @gups4963
      @gups4963 Рік тому +1

      @@TheRealAdds Pretty sure they just expected a loss of personal autonomy on your part. Keep importing a culture that is openly admitting to wanting to end yours while you talking shit to others

    • @Forevertrue
      @Forevertrue 5 місяців тому

      Why spend more millions when you can revamp the YF-23 tail and use the Japanese Mitsubishi engine and the most modern radar and you have the best fighter in the world.

  • @j.mcneil7270
    @j.mcneil7270 Рік тому +44

    Please reverse role fight. This was incredibly, evenly matched fight for sure. Multi round fights using all capabilities with an effort to see a merged dogfight battle to truly capture the abilities and weakness. I enjoyed the well developed and executed lesson on the YF 23/23 history, keep up the great work.

  • @v8makoshark
    @v8makoshark Рік тому +76

    Thanks! Great mini doc, and great dog fight, G/S. We need more of these info/docs please.

    • @GrowlingSidewinder
      @GrowlingSidewinder  Рік тому +22

      Thank you very much and yes plenty more to come in the future.

    • @aunmohammad241
      @aunmohammad241 Рік тому +1

      Bro give me 10$ plz

    • @v8makoshark
      @v8makoshark Рік тому

      If....you can amuse thousands of us by planning, structuring and stringing more than 2+2 together into an idea, coming up with a great video thats infomative and entertaining...maybe you might get a few bucks, dude ! 🤣😂😅@@aunmohammad241

  • @startourzdcs
    @startourzdcs Рік тому +250

    I have always loved the black widow, but the raptor remains my favorite looks wise.

    • @CakePrincessCelestia
      @CakePrincessCelestia Рік тому +25

      Other way round for me XD

    • @kuhnville3145
      @kuhnville3145 Рік тому +8

      @@CakePrincessCelestia I like the *idea* for the shape for the YF-23 but the engines, wing, fuselage, intake, and canopy shape all look pretty ugly combined to me

    • @Slu54
      @Slu54 Рік тому +14

      Yf23 looks so cool, more futuristic looking

    • @BlyGuy
      @BlyGuy Рік тому +11

      ​@@kuhnville3145the YF22 is also pretty ugly, but the finished product is outstanding. I imagine had Northrop won the competition, the final Black Widow II would have been a lot sleeker and looked amazing.

    • @BlyGuy
      @BlyGuy Рік тому +3

      ​@@Slu546th gen airframe in a 5th Gen comp

  • @spencersanderford7518
    @spencersanderford7518 Рік тому +50

    I would say one of the other things that favored the yf-22 during the development program was that it had 3 internal bays over 1, meaning if there was a bay door malfunction during a mission, even if it was the main one, it would still remain effective in combat vs the YF-23 whose single bay was larger, but if it malfunctioned it wouldn't be able to fire any missiles. That plus the B-2 suffered such massive cost overruns there was hesitancy to assign them another major contract.

    • @apparition13
      @apparition13 Рік тому +15

      Didn't that work out great. Part of that overrun was the USAF changing the requirements well into the program forcing a redesign of the entire airframe, but what it meant was that Northrop actually had a good idea what a new program would cost.
      Lockheed on the other hand did their standard over-promise and under-deliver sales pitch, and we wound up with good aircraft in the F-22 and F-35, that were way over budget and years late.

    • @Ghoster311
      @Ghoster311 Рік тому +11

      The production yf-23 was going to be stretched so it would have a separate weapons bay ahead of the primary bay which would hold the sidewinders. It also had an advantage since its weapons bay doors were masked by the inlets when opened. That reduced the radar spike when the were opened to fire.

  • @TwizzKranky
    @TwizzKranky Рік тому +13

    Ever since the bandit unknown video awhile back when he got blown away by this, I've been waiting for this fight. Amazing work

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ Рік тому +98

    I had no idea DCS had the Black Widow II! This has to one of the speculative battles possible as both planes are DEEPLY classified re their true capabilities. IIRC one of the "knocks" on the YF-23 was that it used an innovative but untested internal "carousel" missile mount system; officials were concerned that it was overly complicated and might introduce reliability issues. Of course, to create previously-unseen levels of stealth offered by the YF-23 some outside-the-box solutions were required. I hope Japan resurrects the Black Widow II as the base for a new aircraft. The design is simply too potent to leave in the dustbin of history and was superior to the Raptor in many way. Thanks for a great video!

    • @profo4544
      @profo4544 Рік тому +20

      probably the best interceptor and arguably the first and only 6th gen airframe, its fully unique while the f-22 looks more familiar, thats a small part of why it was chosen also. Another dude did 3v3 f22 vs yf23 another channel and the yf-23s won more than the raptors did, regardless of who was flying. The yf-23 seemed to be harder to get a missile lock on

    • @Pikilloification
      @Pikilloification Рік тому +9

      Who cares, it's a videogame

    • @matchesburn
      @matchesburn Рік тому

      @@Pikilloification
      It's a simulator.

  • @dadteaches
    @dadteaches Рік тому +17

    My grandfather's last project at Mac was the YF-23. I was so mad when the 23 lost ;) I don't even think I was in HS yet.

  • @ExtremeUnction1988
    @ExtremeUnction1988 Рік тому +10

    As long as I've watched this channel, this is the video I've been hoping would be made. I've always loved the YF-23. I'm glad to see DCS has gotten to the point that we can have awesome match ups like this.

  • @danpatterson8009
    @danpatterson8009 Рік тому +42

    At the time of the competition I thought the YF-23 would win, mostly because it had "the look"-clearly a radical departure from previous designs. I recall the YF-23 team complaining that they had done a better job of adhering to the specification and that the YF-22 got the win because the Air Force changed their priorities. Who knows? The two YF-23 prototypes are in museums today- one in Dayton, and the other at the Western Museum of Flight in Torrance, California. I saw it there a few years back, sitting out in the sun in the museum's back yard. Hopefully they've moved it inside by now.

    • @Thatswildpimp
      @Thatswildpimp Рік тому +1

      who cares

    • @airforcedog54
      @airforcedog54 Рік тому +30

      ​@UDontCare0 the people that clicked this video. Clearly, you are watching something that you don't find interesting including the information after the fact of this amazing aircraft.

  • @Eliminator6363
    @Eliminator6363 Рік тому +24

    It's pretty crazy that the YF-23 has such similar characteristics to the NGAD concepts, minus the vertical stabs. Similar design philosophy too, favoring stealth over maneuverability.

  • @JasonSmith-je6dc
    @JasonSmith-je6dc Рік тому +11

    Thank you for this! I’ve been wanting some Black Widow II action!!!!

  • @acehole727
    @acehole727 Рік тому +8

    The YF 23 is still my favorite aircraft design ever I remember following the ATF program in the 90's and drooling over the YF 23 design hoping it would win the contract.

  • @rowdyace5719
    @rowdyace5719 Рік тому +1493

    Day 34 of asking for Cessna 172 vs F-22 Raptor

    • @derroneverest4511
      @derroneverest4511 Рік тому +62

      The Cessna doesn’t even have weapons

    • @dayoftherope1690
      @dayoftherope1690 Рік тому +150

      Ramming speed ahead

    • @phillipwells1557
      @phillipwells1557 Рік тому +73

      Bird dog with rocket launchers on the struts

    • @Acrophobia2
      @Acrophobia2 Рік тому +37

      There is not Cessna in dcs😑

    • @sparky4878
      @sparky4878 Рік тому +9

      Apologies if a double post from me here. Mine seem to disappear!
      Or perhaps neither posted. Was making a reference make to the P51 video with the Mustang taking the F22 down by hitting it.

  • @NickArcieri
    @NickArcieri Рік тому +33

    Day 1 of asking for F-15 vs. Goodyear Blimp

  • @CapitanADD
    @CapitanADD Рік тому +9

    Every time i watch a missile go by the f22 not locked onto anything i think of the droid from portal 2 “are you still there?”

  • @End_of_Lvl_Guardian
    @End_of_Lvl_Guardian Рік тому +15

    YF-23 is quite possibly my favourite fighter ever designed.

  • @WordToMomsYo
    @WordToMomsYo Рік тому +3

    Really appreciated that introductory history on the two planes... You should do more of this in the future.

  • @jsstt
    @jsstt Рік тому +7

    This channel is so crazy with the quality I can't get enough

  • @straitouttahell
    @straitouttahell Рік тому +3

    Thank you, been waiting to see the YF-23 on this channel for a long time.

  • @drippyrooster286
    @drippyrooster286 Рік тому +1

    Saw both of these fighters at the National Museum of the USAF in Dayton OH. They were just static displays but looked amazing! That museum is definitely worth the trip.

  • @RickardLejonhjarta
    @RickardLejonhjarta Рік тому +8

    i dont know how you turned Combat into ASMR but here we are

  • @torokun
    @torokun Рік тому +5

    I wanna live in a multiverse that chose YF-23 over YF-22.

  • @vincebyobscuba
    @vincebyobscuba Рік тому +3

    Really love the brief history/education aspect of this video! Keep up the great content!

  • @saquist
    @saquist Рік тому +2

    Ive trued to tell the F35 pixie dusters, "when everyone is stealthy the BVR advantage evaporates...so you better have better moves than sub 1 thrust to weight and the wing loading of a flying brick"

  • @khoatran-sv7je
    @khoatran-sv7je Рік тому +12

    Very grateful GS finally managed to do a video on the YF23, the history behind both fighters and the ATF program really highlights America's lead in technology. YF23 will always have a sweet spot in my heart. What if the US chose the YF23 over the F22? How would it change warefare today? What if the US experimented the the F120's variable-cycle engine? I guess we will never know for sure. Great video GS! Also, would it be possible if you can do a video where you're the one flying the J20 or even the YF23 itself?

    • @bertram-raven
      @bertram-raven Рік тому

      Get ready - the shackles are now off the UK.

    • @kaljamaistuuperjantaisin
      @kaljamaistuuperjantaisin Рік тому +1

      ​@@bertram-ravenno they aren't

    • @Joseph116PZ
      @Joseph116PZ Рік тому

      Dunno, Sidewinders kinda becoming a one trick pony with the F-22, I never see him flying the challenger aircraft.

    • @Prophet-of-the-Unknown-Lord
      @Prophet-of-the-Unknown-Lord Рік тому

      @@Joseph116PZAs far as I know that's because they don't have a proper cockpit.

  • @MrSauva
    @MrSauva Рік тому +11

    Love the combo history lesson + entertainment! I'm here for more of that :)
    Who was flying the YF-23?

  • @fullmetal_vet
    @fullmetal_vet Рік тому

    In 1990 I was in the 5th grade and had a friend whos dad worked on the YF-23. He brought me pictures, it was so cool.

  • @ThePretender1
    @ThePretender1 Рік тому +1

    I loved the Yf23, i remember sim flying it a long time ago

  • @sana-cm7oc
    @sana-cm7oc Рік тому

    Very cool seeing the YF-23 flying. That was the best summary of the YF-23 I've seen - anywhere.

  • @treeWasNice
    @treeWasNice Рік тому +17

    You should do YF-23 vs Su-57 or Su-75.

  • @zomfgroflmao1337
    @zomfgroflmao1337 Рік тому +4

    I mean even in this the agility still is amazing, imagine the missile trying to calculate where it needs to be while the F22 flies some ridiculous maneuvers that are impossible for any other aircraft...

  • @patrickdavis8271
    @patrickdavis8271 Рік тому +1

    Need to see a best of 3 BVR video of these two aircraft fighting. Love to see you fly the YF-23 against other fighters. Another fantastic video GS! 😉👍

  • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
    @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 Рік тому +4

    The YF-23 certainly wins on looks, beautiful aircraft!

  • @thepaisleyproject
    @thepaisleyproject Рік тому +1

    It's important to know that with planes this evenly matched. It really comes down to luck and pilot's skill. Neither airplane is particularly better than the other

  • @pliniobass
    @pliniobass Рік тому +1

    I guess in a world of stealth fighters, agility is king. And that's why the F-22 was chosen. A merger in the fight between stealth fighters is perhaps inevitable, the one with greater maneuverability will win.

  • @guyray1504
    @guyray1504 Рік тому

    So good to see these aircraft after spending 6 1/2 years with the F-117 Nighthawk that couldn't fight it way out of a paper bag but sure raised hell on downtown Bagdad. Loved all the information at the start.

  • @13bullits-yg7co
    @13bullits-yg7co Рік тому

    So glad you have done this, every time I see the YF-23 my hart beats faster, this plane is so beautiful and beyond his time!

  • @threadfall100
    @threadfall100 Рік тому +1

    God I wish we could've seen the finished thing. Even after refining the YF-22 into the F-22 we all know and love, it still doesn't seem as futuristic as the prototype Black Widows! The story around the name has some fun moments, at one point a triangular... panel? instrument? feature of some kind inspired the team to give it the red hourglass on the belly like its arachnid namesake. At least until they were forced to paint over it again to not compromise on stealth after higher ups quizzed them on it.

  • @darvinclement8404
    @darvinclement8404 Рік тому

    Went out to Edwards AFB to watch a shuttle landing and drove by the two of them sitting side by side not far from the road we were on. That was the highlight of my day. Wind was blowing too hard for the shuttle to land. It had to land at White Sands 2 or 3 days later.

  • @Alexandros85
    @Alexandros85 Рік тому +3

    YF 23 beautiful aircraft! I hope to see more scenarios with this bird.

  • @mattfgln
    @mattfgln Рік тому +3

    Finally the yf-23 . It was past time it got featured

  • @ArmaSti
    @ArmaSti Рік тому

    Your flying high, I'm flying high... that intro was amazing. 10 thumbs up.

  • @triplemoyagames4195
    @triplemoyagames4195 Рік тому +12

    I will forever be upset at getting robbed of the YF-23.

  • @andrewburkholder3842
    @andrewburkholder3842 Рік тому +4

    I absolutely love the 23 but it makes sense given the relative parity in stealth to want more maneuverability if you were facing another similarly stealthy adversary. I think this battle illustrates it perfectly - if you are both stealth expect to need to go within visual range.

    • @ohctascooby2
      @ohctascooby2 Рік тому

      But GW didn’t win due to maneuverability.

    • @matchesburn
      @matchesburn Рік тому

      "relatively parity in stealth"
      ...That still doesn't exist today in 2024? What crystal ball was the DoD using to measure this and see this non-existent advisory you're referring to?

  • @libertylivesin1776
    @libertylivesin1776 Рік тому +4

    Nothing will match the raptor until the NGAD. On paper and reality. The raptor is the finest product the military industrial complex has ever produced in the air.

    • @rodnemeth6766
      @rodnemeth6766 Місяць тому

      Except in stealth the yf23 was better and had better thermals.

  • @christopherwang4392
    @christopherwang4392 Рік тому +5

    I believe some people have argued that while the F-22 Raptor was better as an air superiority fighter, the F-23 Black Widow II would have been useful as a stealth fighter-bomber / strike fighter replacement for the F-15E Strike Eagle.

  • @jeravincer
    @jeravincer Рік тому +1

    Excellent! The YF-22 has always been one of those "could have been" jets that was lost to history.

    • @HyHwua
      @HyHwua Рік тому

      You said YF-22!😂

  • @leonardolanzara4486
    @leonardolanzara4486 Рік тому

    I'm old enough to remember the ATF competition. great video!

  • @sonar357
    @sonar357 Рік тому +2

    Interesting fight. Now we need to see a rematch using Sidewinders and guns.

  • @SacredCowStockyards
    @SacredCowStockyards Рік тому +1

    1:00 so I guess that makes the F-22 a worthy opponent to a Chinese blimp

  • @jasonvick55
    @jasonvick55 Рік тому +2

    It’s amazing how similar the YF-23 is to the new Air Force’ NGAD. Of course, there are no vertical tail surfaces on the 6th gen fighter and some other differences, but they clearly utilized the YF-23 platform in its overall design.

  • @noah._.powell
    @noah._.powell Рік тому +3

    I wish they had BOTH won. Imagine the YF-23 in an interceptor role working in tandem with the F-22

    • @FlintIronstag23
      @FlintIronstag23 Рік тому +2

      Impossible due to the cost. High technology equals high cost.

    • @noah._.powell
      @noah._.powell Рік тому

      @@FlintIronstag23 yes I know

    • @noah._.powell
      @noah._.powell Рік тому

      @@FlintIronstag23 hence the Raptor program being canceled

  • @TsunauticusIV
    @TsunauticusIV Рік тому +2

    Bro. This was an AMAZING video!

  • @KINGSolomonReturns
    @KINGSolomonReturns Рік тому

    This is cool, man. I like how you started adding the history before.

  • @B14ckic3
    @B14ckic3 Рік тому +2

    Anybody else finds the YF-23 kinda scary? Man this jet gives me the creeps, looks like something alien.Still love it.

  • @ohctascooby2
    @ohctascooby2 Рік тому +3

    Definitely like to see more of the yf23 and with you as the pilot. It seemed to turn pretty tight at one point (6:15). If it wasn’t for the pilot rolling up on his side seemingly oblivious to your missile being there i think he would have survived. You staved off each other quite a while and never actually got to use the maneuverability strength of the 22. At 5:15 he seems to be hauling ass. I would bet his hidden exhaust could help him stave off missiles possibly better at close distance than the 22 could.

  • @beatboxbuggi6884
    @beatboxbuggi6884 Рік тому +1

    You know you have a small RCS when the enemy missile goes after your missile instead of you

  • @ArcaneActual
    @ArcaneActual Рік тому

    Love the documentary type intro! Great fight, bringing it into 4 miles

  • @Ifoughtpiranhas
    @Ifoughtpiranhas Рік тому +12

    Even though it's 35 years old, I'd still pick the YF-23 Black Widow II over the Su-57 Felon any day of the week. The technology for the aircraft was miles ahead of its time.

  • @97BuckeyeGuy
    @97BuckeyeGuy Рік тому

    I liked the little bit of history lesson to open the video. Poor dude ejected face first into the ground. 😂

  • @JasonAquinoRacing
    @JasonAquinoRacing Рік тому +1

    The opening made me think I was on your Mini Doc UA-cam page 😅 Great video as always

  • @7pastorb
    @7pastorb Рік тому +3

    Full dogfight.... both with and without Fox 2s.
    And another BVR engagement with some ground features and ground support.

  • @WirableCrown1
    @WirableCrown1 Рік тому +1

    Imagine being so stealthy that your missile goes after the other guys missile instead because it has the greater signature....crazy

  • @kyokushinkuma
    @kyokushinkuma Рік тому

    Saw “Gray Ghost” back in May at the USAF museum in Dayton Ohio, it’s a beautiful plane.

  • @-Ripcord-
    @-Ripcord- Рік тому

    Loving the scenario based and history based fights much more than the dogfights over and over

  • @robinmickelsson-htta3413
    @robinmickelsson-htta3413 Рік тому +3

    The fight we all had been waiting for buddy. Now we all look forward to the dogfight first to 5.
    Also, week by week, month by month. I am so glad to see your channel grow; you are becoming more comfortable and you trying your best in regard to technology and presentation to help your audience. Keep doing exactly what you are doing my man.

  • @spackle9999
    @spackle9999 Рік тому +1

    I can't wait for the merge gunfight.

  • @WeirdTippy
    @WeirdTippy Рік тому +1

    I would love to see a best of 3 fight between more capable aircraft which are closer in specs and techs to each other. That YF-23 is formidable prey to a Raptor and could definitely win a few fights I reckon. Loved the history lesson at the start btw

  • @cambellschunky704
    @cambellschunky704 Рік тому

    GS/Mini-Docs amalgam. My favorite format. I wish GS would provide some simultaneos and related releases between his channels. The devopment history between these 2 aircraft is quite interesting.

  • @bluecollarbuddha948
    @bluecollarbuddha948 Рік тому +2

    Umm...I can't be the only one thinking of an F-15 vs Good Year Blimp video now, am I?

  • @Eyerleth
    @Eyerleth Рік тому +7

    F-22 is an amazing plane, but I still think they should have picked the YF-23.

  • @fierypickles4450
    @fierypickles4450 Рік тому +1

    That was quite the duel.

  • @r.b.ratieta6111
    @r.b.ratieta6111 Рік тому +1

    It's funny and interesting to think that when stealth cancels both fighters out, it falls back to "classic dogfighting" within visual range.
    Perhaps that may have been a factor as to why the DOD chose agility over stealth. Although I have heard that the world of classified aircraft has a LOT of drama behind the scenes, including bribery scandals, security leaks, and the occasional project leader who randomly ends up dead or missing.
    In Ben Rich's "Skunkworks" book where he talks about taking over the program after Kelly Johnson, he mentioned Lockheed was in very hot water with the Department of Justice and DOD because a number of bribes with U.S. allies like Italy, France and Germany to expedite lead times and contractor licenses had given them leverage over national security interests.
    So who knows? It could have been fair and square, or it could have involved the usual "politics" and bureaucracy of defense contracting.

  • @XxAverageJoexX
    @XxAverageJoexX Рік тому

    “Kinda hurts to say that though” no sir it would be upsetting had it lost. Since it is in our arsenal. Great video.

  • @covahredro8370
    @covahredro8370 Рік тому

    The missiles targeting each other was hilarious, image using that as an actual defensive maneuver.

  • @AlexandruVoda
    @AlexandruVoda Рік тому

    Aweeeesome. I really want to see more prototypes and experimental aircraft flown by GS in DCS. Maybe a Su-47, a Grumman X-29, a Sr-71 Blackbird.

  • @masterskilhollow
    @masterskilhollow Рік тому +2

    Ow, it hurt to watch that ejection and see the pilot crater before there was even time to deploy the chute.

  • @CordovanSplotchVT
    @CordovanSplotchVT Рік тому

    After playing Agile Warrior F-111X as a kid, the YF23 has been my second favourite jet after the F14 Tomcat.

  • @jzcski
    @jzcski Рік тому

    Super cool video!! Thanks for posting! Two fantastic looking jets duking it out made for great content!

  • @_Raven_
    @_Raven_ Рік тому

    That was a really good intro. I forgot I was watching a DCS video

  • @wipplewopple1876
    @wipplewopple1876 Рік тому +3

    I still think the YF23 should have won the contract. Also, I personally think it looks better, and the engine intake and exhaust designs were really fascinating. If you ever want to see what the F-23 would have looked like if it went into production, Hanger B Productions used some references to infer some design cues.

  • @yhird
    @yhird Рік тому +2

    The YF-23 looks like it was designed by an alien intelligence. Beautiful aircraft.

  • @lexwaldez
    @lexwaldez Рік тому

    The AMRAAM's just look so happy jumping off the rail like, "YAY!!!" and then...

  • @rampageExtremeGamer
    @rampageExtremeGamer Рік тому +3

    YF-23 is just plain awesome.

  • @TheFlyingJ
    @TheFlyingJ Рік тому

    The short history of the two aircraft before the fight was cool.

  • @wolfaja755
    @wolfaja755 Рік тому +1

    I think the future of aircraft will be a stealth aircraft capable of dogfighting. If everyone is going to have stealth fighters then it’ll always come to these close dog fights and the upper hand will always be with the one more capable at dog fighting. Itll probably progress to stealth bombers only since dogfights would be nearly impossible due to the inability to track enemy aircraft.

  • @kodywootton7472
    @kodywootton7472 Рік тому

    Yo wtf i wasn't expecting a history lesson like sandbox or taskandpurpose. Great content

  • @jackschumacher8472
    @jackschumacher8472 Рік тому

    Thanks for the history lesson. I remember when the public learned about the 2 aircraft and what they where. They are both use pure America. I think we should update and start building both. Better to have and not need!.

  • @FasterThanRaito
    @FasterThanRaito Рік тому +1

    When both sides have stealth it's like time travelling back to the 60's era of pre-BRV... only with supermaneuvrability and actually accurate missiles. Recipe for high-stakes danger zone

  • @h3llrayzor59
    @h3llrayzor59 Рік тому

    Love the flash opening of the payload Doors at the end of the Video

  • @atsimas
    @atsimas 7 місяців тому

    Your strategy is what makes the difference. A suggestion. One round you pilot the F22 one round the f23. Continue this format and let us see the real difference in the aircraft's capabilities.