It's because that's the point. In vegninis showcase, there's also that statue where you can reset your stats. They also mention it during the game in letters
I mean, he offered some knowledge and advice along the journey but he just became increasingly sketchy, to me. And he never gave me a reason to truly trust him. So I refused him. Of course, I then realized I landed myself in yet another boss battle. But The Nameless Puppet felt way better than Simon as a last boss. Even though none of them is a Glock Saint lol.
holy shit, i never realized at first because before this moment gepetto always speaking in soft tone, the moment i heard his voice here....... I felt Geppeto's voice is sounds awfully familiar. especially the amount of resentment in his voice at "but you insist on breaking my heart" and "The naughty ones that must be punished like you". that voice wont forgive my action in lands between either..
Right when I heard him talk at the start I clocked that. He uses a lighter tone here most of the time, but has those same inflections and rumble in his voice
Ya the end is nice.. cause I can tell in the true ending he was probably gonna insult him, but when geppetto saw the tear, he finally realized.. his puppet became a real boy.. as was no longer some puppet, but his son... Carlo, his son.. was alive the entire time... and he was sorry that it took him so long to see that..
Same here but i didnt try or max anything I just played organically. I am sure it has to do with how you treat people or something because I did not do anything special. I just acted like a human lol
Bad ending on my initial game and the secret Dorothy one. I think errbody gets it no matter the three endings. I was doing well in ng+, on my way for the 100% until Laxasia... Dammit! Imagine with ng+ Simon and Nameless Puppet... ugh! So close...
The fact that the Nameless Puppet is Carlo’s real human body, now on that gruesome state, and that the only, twisted emotion that appears to possess is pure hatred is just… depressing. It makes you wonder if he will eventually kill Gepetto just because he feels like it and won’t even care about his own father…
Thats why the strings were necessary. A cool detail I noticed as well. When Carlo was alive Gepetto was very much an absent father who didn't pay attention to him. Then when we refuse to give him our heart, he belittles us by blaming it on 'mischievousness', not even bothering to consider our point of view. Gepetto never wanted a son. He wanted a puppet.
The whole story was sooo weell made into the game, the fact that it actually had scenematics helped a lot to tell some story, and the fact that the game also Lets you know when a characters has something new to say, its great, you dont miss a thing, or get to try and interpret things around some text found in a broken ring in the middle of the poisoned swamp (darksouls lore) i have completed DS 1,2,3 and elden ring, and still dont know most of the whole story or what the endings meant...
Ngl I laughed the first time I saw Geppettos last words in the good ending. It threw me off I really didn’t expect him to tear into poor P like that lol Also these endings hit me harder than any other souls games endings ever have. Sophia > Ranni 💙
I had enough. I fought hard to the end but I just don't feel like defeating nameless puppet🤣. Gave gepetto my heart and now I'm just gonna see the "better" endings on the good old internet... Amazing cliffhanger by the way
Any guide on how to get the rise of P ending? I've beaten the game 3 f times following guides online and I always get the "free from the puppet string" ending 😔
To get the bad ending, you must give Gepetto your heart. To get the "good" ending, you must tell the truth as often as you can, and NOT kill Sophia and refuse to give Gepetto your heart. To get the True (Rise of P) ending, you must lie often (be a good person, basically) as kill Sophia as a mercy, then refuse to give Gepetto your heart.
@pauserepeat2383 Actually for the Free From Strings ending, you still have to lie, atleast enough to get long hair. If you tell the truth the whole time, your puppetry mechanism wouldn't allow you to refuse Geppetto at the end.
@@pauserepeat2383 lying often is NOT being a good person... Verses from the KJV of the holy bible Romans 3:10 “As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:” Romans 6:23 “For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.” John 3:16 “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” John 5:24 “Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life.”
Séloco já bateu 1 mi de inscrito, parabéns, lembro quando em 2021 jogava pokémon mais meu amigo, e diveis em quando eu trapaseava olhando seu canal kkkk manda um salve
I had to come on here to see the good ending play out because that final boss fight (along with the three before it) were miserable and I refused to finish 😂
@@lofej You mean it was too hard for you? Damn, it was my first Souls-like game and I defeated Simon on my first try and Nameless Puppet on the second. Which was quite disappointing. The hardest boss for me was Fuoko btw😂
Anyone in the comments who ACTUALLY got the true ending, answer my comment. This is not clout or like baiting, just me having genuine problem with who actually did it because of so many people here saying "Got true ending first try"
Oh no, you just need to have a high enough level of "humanity" to get the good/true endings. The bad/neutral endings (giving your heart to gepetto/beating the nameless puppet with low humanity) are always available. Ways to raise your humanity include; >Lying at any given opportunity >Performing certain gestures in certain places (like praying at a church) >Listening to the *entirety* of any music records you find while at hotel krat (you can just let it play while you run around upgrading your gear, you don't have to stand still for the whole thing) >Usually you gain some at the end of a side quest there's likely other specific situations that grant some humanity, but I haven't played the game in a while. Note you don't need *absolutely every single point* of humanity in the world to get the good endings.
it looked like the corpses of all the people and puppets who were still alive in hotel krat, so eugenie, venigni, pulcinella... :( in the bad ending, carlos appears to have gone on a murderous rampage. after that ending in-game, i heard if you back go to the hotel, all of the people are replaced with puppets, confirming that carlos basically just killed everyone.
P's alive, you can go back to the hotel and talk to the NPC to hear their reactions of the aftermath. You can also find a letter of puppet's Sophia, as well as the secret letter of the true mastermind of the game near the golden fruit tree.
You actually can keep playing after the end. Their is unique dialogue where the characters in the hotel react to which one you chose. So no, you never "die" cannonically. No matter which ending you end up in.
Damn it isn't the goal of P to become a real boy? how is that a bad ending? and i missed out on an epic fight! damn it i'm not playing another 20h is there another way?
No it was to become human. Achieving it through “cheating” aka science or achieving it through understanding humanity “organically” are two paths. If you didn’t read any of the notes and treated people carelessly the option to become a real human is limited to Gepetto but his option comes with built in insanity and subservience to his command so not sure if it’s truly a real boy either. Either way you are never really able to become a human 100%. One is through the heart other is via the body but you have no heart.
The father wanted to bring his son back. His put Carlos’ soul into a puppet to hope to bring him back. But in order to do that he needed Ergo, that only comes from living people. So he started the puppet frenzy to kill people and technically not be guilty by saying they lost control. But it was all part of his plan. To use the ergo of the dead to revive is son. However, he didn’t have his memories. He saw it as a failure and thought he would have to try again. But as Carlo, the more human you become the more memories you get of your past. You are Carlo, but he doesn’t know it until he sees those memories on the beach. But the Father didn’t know that and still saw him as a puppet not his son. So he was going to use the ergo Simon accumulated at his fortress to bring Carlo back in another puppet. But obviously something happened to make Carlo kill everyone he befriended
whyyy the hell do they not give you the option to reload man?? I literally dont get why not, how the fk am i supposed to know which choice is the right one??? Same thing happened with bloodborne but im not gonna waste my time replaying this game, such BS
The final scene of the true ending where Sophia in a puppet form holding P is so spectacular, reminds me of La Pietà scuplture of Michelangelo.
It's because that's the point. In vegninis showcase, there's also that statue where you can reset your stats. They also mention it during the game in letters
Fvck, I just ended the game and I forgot that Gepetto is the one who causes Puppet Frenzy , and I chose to give him the heart 🤦🏻♂️
just did that myself, i actually got so mad
@@arnasr760 I had to play again the game again
@@Ezekjel 100%
I mean, he offered some knowledge and advice along the journey but he just became increasingly sketchy, to me. And he never gave me a reason to truly trust him. So I refused him. Of course, I then realized I landed myself in yet another boss battle. But The Nameless Puppet felt way better than Simon as a last boss. Even though none of them is a Glock Saint lol.
I mean it’s supposed to be played through again to get the other ending & all items etc to get platinum badge it’s a must
holy shit, i never realized at first because before this moment gepetto always speaking in soft tone, the moment i heard his voice here....... I felt Geppeto's voice is sounds awfully familiar. especially the amount of resentment in his voice at "but you insist on breaking my heart" and "The naughty ones that must be punished like you".
that voice wont forgive my action in lands between either..
What voice are you talking about?
@@789syrus789Gepetto’s voice actor is the same as Margit from Elden Ring
IFKR I then relived the 'put these foolish ambitions to rest" ptsd
Right when I heard him talk at the start I clocked that. He uses a lighter tone here most of the time, but has those same inflections and rumble in his voice
Also the voice of johnathan reed main character of vampyr, great voice actor
Finished the game yesterday with the Rise of P ending. Can't wait for the new one when it comes out!!!
I got 1st try on the true ending. Totally worth playing the game. The story is really well made.
Blueberry wife comes back alive yipee
Beagles love blueberries •
When I saw P tears drop, I was crying inside. Such a beautiful moment
i was crying outside
Ya the end is nice.. cause I can tell in the true ending he was probably gonna insult him, but when geppetto saw the tear, he finally realized.. his puppet became a real boy.. as was no longer some puppet, but his son... Carlo, his son.. was alive the entire time... and he was sorry that it took him so long to see that..
@@vsvs7802 very well said my friend
I was not expecting the real boy ending to go the way it did. That shit was dark as hell.
I got the secret ending in the 1st run. Damn ..
yeah same. Got actually really surprised by that.
Same bro
I got it first run as well, you just have to have max humanity right? That was the one thing i made sure of
I also got the secret ending, I was gonna do another run if it just ended with the waif dying but we good👍
Same here but i didnt try or max anything I just played organically. I am sure it has to do with how you treat people or something because I did not do anything special. I just acted like a human lol
Just finished the game
Didn't knew wich ending i got till now. Got the secret one (True + secret scene)
I got super mad fighting the namelass puppet up to the point i said im gonna f*cking kill geppetto right after this. Turns out he died by himself🤣
He had a whole second heart. Geppeto. Brother, please. If you can make more than one heart. Give it the other one
that's not how it works.
This is awesome, I got the true ending + secret ending in the first run, alright I won't need to play more.
Bad ending on my initial game and the secret Dorothy one. I think errbody gets it no matter the three endings.
I was doing well in ng+, on my way for the 100% until Laxasia... Dammit! Imagine with ng+ Simon and Nameless Puppet... ugh! So close...
Same but I'm playing ng+ to get everything. Going for bad ending this time, so nameless can f off 😂.
@dri748 hahaha I can understand that
shame i have to come to youtube to see the ending i got without textures constantly going low-res
Got the true ending on my first run, really loved every moment of this game
First run and got the secret ending, damn, feels awesome! I thought I had definitely screwed some quests up in the game.
The fact that the Nameless Puppet is Carlo’s real human body, now on that gruesome state, and that the only, twisted emotion that appears to possess is pure hatred is just… depressing. It makes you wonder if he will eventually kill Gepetto just because he feels like it and won’t even care about his own father…
Thats why the strings were necessary.
A cool detail I noticed as well. When Carlo was alive Gepetto was very much an absent father who didn't pay attention to him. Then when we refuse to give him our heart, he belittles us by blaming it on 'mischievousness', not even bothering to consider our point of view.
Gepetto never wanted a son. He wanted a puppet.
The whole story was sooo weell made into the game, the fact that it actually had scenematics helped a lot to tell some story, and the fact that the game also Lets you know when a characters has something new to say, its great, you dont miss a thing, or get to try and interpret things around some text found in a broken ring in the middle of the poisoned swamp (darksouls lore) i have completed DS 1,2,3 and elden ring, and still dont know most of the whole story or what the endings meant...
Was lucky enough to get the rise of p first playthrough. Time for another 5 runs.
The 1st and the 2nd ending feels like Bloodborne’s ending. Either you die or fight to stay alive.
and the secret ending has you ascend above humanity
Ngl I laughed the first time I saw Geppettos last words in the good ending. It threw me off I really didn’t expect him to tear into poor P like that lol
Also these endings hit me harder than any other souls games endings ever have.
Sophia > Ranni 💙
Yep, a soul game indeed, even when you get the best ending, you're still screwed.
Its tragic. Only at the end (True ending when Geppeto saw P cry) Geppeto realize the boy he wanted to bring back was right in front of him
Só joguei o jogo uma vez, sem detonados e consegui pegar o final verdadeiro.
Caracaaa, aí simmm hein man
I had enough. I fought hard to the end but I just don't feel like defeating nameless puppet🤣. Gave gepetto my heart and now I'm just gonna see the "better" endings on the good old internet... Amazing cliffhanger by the way
Me too!!! Im so angry man, i want to fight the nameless puppet
Any guide on how to get the rise of P ending? I've beaten the game 3 f times following guides online and I always get the "free from the puppet string" ending 😔
To get the bad ending, you must give Gepetto your heart. To get the "good" ending, you must tell the truth as often as you can, and NOT kill Sophia and refuse to give Gepetto your heart. To get the True (Rise of P) ending, you must lie often (be a good person, basically) as kill Sophia as a mercy, then refuse to give Gepetto your heart.
@@pauserepeat2383 that's literally what I did (rise of P ending) and still good the "good ending"
@pauserepeat2383 Actually for the Free From Strings ending, you still have to lie, atleast enough to get long hair. If you tell the truth the whole time, your puppetry mechanism wouldn't allow you to refuse Geppetto at the end.
@@pauserepeat2383 lying often is NOT being a good person... Verses from the KJV of the holy bible
Romans 3:10
“As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:”
Romans 6:23
“For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.”
John 3:16
“For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.”
John 5:24
“Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life.”
@@juana.6549i think u gotta get the white hair
I got the true ending - so glad, I really enjoyed it and was invested in the story telling. Brilliant game.
Séloco já bateu 1 mi de inscrito, parabéns, lembro quando em 2021 jogava pokémon mais meu amigo, e diveis em quando eu trapaseava olhando seu canal kkkk manda um salve
I had to come on here to see the good ending play out because that final boss fight (along with the three before it) were miserable and I refused to finish 😂
same, i just fuckin gave the heart, the fuckin second phase of the nameless puppet made me quit...
@@lofej git gud m8
I had to do the same I was extremely to stressed out to do it again 🤣
@@deviantan021are people still saying that 😂
@@lofej You mean it was too hard for you? Damn, it was my first Souls-like game and I defeated Simon on my first try and Nameless Puppet on the second. Which was quite disappointing. The hardest boss for me was Fuoko btw😂
Mee to, it was hell of a game really, a soul like with a really good story
Anyone in the comments who ACTUALLY got the true ending, answer my comment.
This is not clout or like baiting, just me having genuine problem with who actually did it because of so many people here saying "Got true ending first try"
Not really a secret since it activates once you finish the game
Did i need to beat every boss without espectre to get one of those finals?
Oh no, you just need to have a high enough level of "humanity" to get the good/true endings. The bad/neutral endings (giving your heart to gepetto/beating the nameless puppet with low humanity) are always available.
Ways to raise your humanity include;
>Lying at any given opportunity
>Performing certain gestures in certain places (like praying at a church)
>Listening to the *entirety* of any music records you find while at hotel krat (you can just let it play while you run around upgrading your gear, you don't have to stand still for the whole thing)
>Usually you gain some at the end of a side quest
there's likely other specific situations that grant some humanity, but I haven't played the game in a while.
Note you don't need *absolutely every single point* of humanity in the world to get the good endings.
@@flipperjr.3822 thanks man, This helped me a lot!!!
Bad ending is the good ending from gepettos perspective. I gave him his son back
Nice, I got the true ending :D
Can someone explain why i can't refuse like the game won't let me
Is it because im on ng+3
you dont have enough humanity, cuz if its to low you dont get to chouse
Wait, who are the corpses in the bad ending?
it looked like the corpses of all the people and puppets who were still alive in hotel krat, so eugenie, venigni, pulcinella... :( in the bad ending, carlos appears to have gone on a murderous rampage. after that ending in-game, i heard if you back go to the hotel, all of the people are replaced with puppets, confirming that carlos basically just killed everyone.
Even in the bad ending if you go back to the hotel krat Geppeto has replaced all the staff with puppets !
ohh first game and got the true ending xd lucky me
Speake tell... Lady Dimitrisku? :))
wait so in true ending are you still alive or did you die to bring sophia back to life?
According to me p dies as he gives his ergo to sophia
@@sanskaarchauhan2652 thats a fked up true ending if what you say is true
No P is still alive, you can tell cause when Sophia touched his face, he twitched a little. He just collapsed cause he was exhausted
P is human and doesn't need the Ergo. He just fainted. He revived Sophia as a puppet with the remaining Ergo, just like she did to him.
P's alive, you can go back to the hotel and talk to the NPC to hear their reactions of the aftermath. You can also find a letter of puppet's Sophia, as well as the secret letter of the true mastermind of the game near the golden fruit tree.
Is it so bad if Pinocchio becomes a real boy and live happily with his dad tho? 😅 for real...
So Pinocchio died in the end??
In the true ending you can see he's still alive because he twitches a little bit, he just collapses because he's exhausted
No he sacrifices himself to give his life butterfly to the new sophia puppet. Then it’s hinted at that she brought him back to life
You actually can keep playing after the end. Their is unique dialogue where the characters in the hotel react to which one you chose.
So no, you never "die" cannonically. No matter which ending you end up in.
no. he became a human. he passed his ergo to sophia to bring her back to life as he no longer needed it as a human.
Damn it isn't the goal of P to become a real boy?
how is that a bad ending?
and i missed out on an epic fight!
damn it i'm not playing another 20h is there another way?
No it was to become human. Achieving it through “cheating” aka science or achieving it through understanding humanity “organically” are two paths. If you didn’t read any of the notes and treated people carelessly the option to become a real human is limited to Gepetto but his option comes with built in insanity and subservience to his command so not sure if it’s truly a real boy either. Either way you are never really able to become a human 100%. One is through the heart other is via the body but you have no heart.
The father wanted to bring his son back. His put Carlos’ soul into a puppet to hope to bring him back. But in order to do that he needed Ergo, that only comes from living people. So he started the puppet frenzy to kill people and technically not be guilty by saying they lost control. But it was all part of his plan. To use the ergo of the dead to revive is son. However, he didn’t have his memories. He saw it as a failure and thought he would have to try again. But as Carlo, the more human you become the more memories you get of your past. You are Carlo, but he doesn’t know it until he sees those memories on the beach. But the Father didn’t know that and still saw him as a puppet not his son. So he was going to use the ergo Simon accumulated at his fortress to bring Carlo back in another puppet. But obviously something happened to make Carlo kill everyone he befriended
why mine was secret ending?
wtf so i got the secret ending right away lol
i got the bad ending, because that nameless puppet is a cheater!!!
I got true ending by accident lol
i got the true ending
whyyy the hell do they not give you the option to reload man?? I literally dont get why not, how the fk am i supposed to know which choice is the right one??? Same thing happened with bloodborne but im not gonna waste my time replaying this game, such BS
I mean technically speaking that's how a proper game should be. Plus there's new game plus. I'm annoyed too but still.
hey NG+ is worth playing, you get more P organs, the bosses are harder but you are stronger so they are easier and you get more ergo and level faster
ever heard of save files? 😂
@@jmedina6625 stfu im console player
Wizard of oz? What?
Yes
Got the true ending on my first try. Btw great game!
I got the bad ending on my first try and it traumatized me