im not a dancer or a dance teacher, yet i understood this was a fusion dance not strictly bharatanatyam. she wasn't at her best but the concept was conveyed like an open book. she's a legend and i admire her capacity to make dance simple for everyone to understand. she's remarkable.
Yeah dats true.. she connected wd d filmy audience... just like a story teller.. and ppl are criticising her for not gvng a classic bharatanatyam... nd anchor itslef told " she s cmng wd a perfrmnce"... not "bharatanatyam"
@@visalskumar This is called Naatiya Nadagam in Tamil classic dances. A kind of branch in Bharathanatiyam itself. In which a story will be there, usually from the Epics.
Only south india has women remaining today who understand and perform classical dances. Awesome blend of innovation and tradition. As a north indian i feel Shobhana ji is the epitome of Hindu women’s grace.
That's because much of South India were until recently Hindu kingdoms unlike North Indian areas subjected to centuries of life as dhimmis. Yet, million applauses to the North people for being rooted in Dharma.
Ithaye vera yarachu adi iruntha avangala criticize panni troll pani irupanga. Ivanga panathala joint pain, health issues nu soldranga then wht about the group dancers. The performance was throughout clumsy.. I know she is the best dancer, this is the fusion of bharanatyam and mohiniattam but very difficult to predict the ratio. It doesn't mean that grt dancers can make mistakes. Performing in front of Amma, vyjanthimala, venniradai nirmala is not an easy game🤘home work is more important
Bharatham is an age old golden dance...it is a legendary art in India never disgrace it...some of them misuse dance with shoes ...please avoid this with modern music...this a Diamond one presented by our ancestors ..please protect it....
I felt a problem like sprain or joint pains wid Shobhana Ma'am. I am quite sure from her signing off that she herself was not satisfied with the performance
This is a great performance by shobana as she is embodying the deity Durga and has to change in to the warrior goddess she is known to b e. Beautiful dance and choreography was excellent if not pure bharatanatyam
Shobhana mam is the back bone of classical dance..as a male classical dancer proud abt her...bt this performance is not satisfing,it may be bcs of the song.....
Imagine her Aunties Padmini or Ragini or Lalita or even Vyjayanthimala or Kumari Kamala or L Vijayalakshmi for that matter even Meenakshi Seshadri would have burnt the dance floor with our hearts on fire for more...that was them and this is now, no doubt Shobana is an accomplished dancer herself this was just average..
Where is Meenakshi Seshadri dancing now? When was the last time she came on stage like this? Why are you all after Shobana's work if you can't appreciate it atleast dont criticize it.
@@lizzystar1907 ua-cam.com/video/8dPt2WPtlNg/v-deo.html yes you are right about her performing of late but i remember seeing her in Damini and i found her dancing just like Padmini, Vyjayanthi and kamala . What i meant was Shobana is a terrific dancer but her moves in this was average..she reminded me of Hema Malini
All the actors look bored or slightly annoyed.... shobhana is very talented but this was not a good performance and had nothing to do with the aigiri nandini lyrics- this is my opinion as a classical dancer and teacher
For heavens sake this is not pure Bharatham. Aramandi and angashudhi have changed today. Even in past changes were made according to the times. And this is a composite art not pure Bharatjam. We don't have proof for pure dance in India. Please show where there is books 5000 years ago? Hence this beautiful art form is awesome art S art no comparison it is aesthetic to watch Thank you Dhobana.
Thank you! In this age of puritanism and nationalism surfacing everywhere everyone including artists are suddenly being criticized horribly by people who just sit back and rant without having no knowledge.
If the same performance will any other group dancers Will done defnatly people will never accept for this Great Stage and front of wonderful Indian artist so sad.
See actually it is not only a tamil but a South Indian, which was conducted in Chennai, comprising all the 4 languages. So the comments must be in tamil telugu malayalam kannada
@@senseprevails24 you obviously don’t understand the nature of this dance and it’s tradition unchanged for millennia …. generation does not come in to it
This is callled Naatiya Nadagam, in classic Tamil culture. In other words, unlike usual Bharathanatiyam which involves mostly dance, a Naatiya Naadagam will also have a story or drama will be there along with Bharathanatiyam.
Shobhana badly needs to go back to dance school and retrain. Obviously she has lost touch . Her adavus are not precise and she seems to move in a carefree way. Bharathanatyam requires strength and precision, Shobhana seems to be making an halfhearted attempt at dancing. She did dance well in some of her movies decades ago. Last ten years or so many of us have watched her talents wane away. I cant believe she thinks she can still perform and organizers keep inviting her to perform at such events. This is embarrassing.
Exactly observed, this is because of something called over experimenting and fusion work, in order to create a separate image in the name of that particular bred style, of course Shobana ji has deviated, just like her Hema Malini ji also deviated, she performs Kuchipudi in Bhatanatyam attire and mixes both the forms along with yet another dance style Odissi by her daughters. It has become trendy now a days. Its good thing to experiment new stuff but without having been delineated from the roots.
I saw all the comments out here,All the good ones and the bad ones. I mean come on guys you guys need to be sensible.She is not the only one working in this dance, it's a team effort, sometimes some situation goes out of hands and she can't do anything about that.Everyone cannot do everything everytime with utter perfection.Wanting perfection in everything we see is somewhat selfishness, isn't it guys! Well Shobana mam is great dancer no doubt .If you guys want to see her bests then check out the ramayan...It's on UA-cam. Ithreyum nalla oru dancerum nadiyeyum kaanan kittiyath aanu namade okke oru bhagyam.Avare orikkilum nammal pucchikkan paadilla...Avaru devam onnum alla ath enikkum ariyam pakshe even she is a human being and we should consider that.......This is for #the Shobana mam
im not a dancer or a dance teacher, yet i understood this was a fusion dance not strictly bharatanatyam. she wasn't at her best but the concept was conveyed like an open book. she's a legend and i admire her capacity to make dance simple for everyone to understand. she's remarkable.
Yeah dats true.. she connected wd d filmy audience... just like a story teller.. and ppl are criticising her for not gvng a classic bharatanatyam... nd anchor itslef told " she s cmng wd a perfrmnce"... not "bharatanatyam"
@@visalskumar This is called Naatiya Nadagam in Tamil classic dances. A kind of branch in Bharathanatiyam itself. In which a story will be there, usually from the Epics.
4:18 in front of India's 1st Greatest South to north Bharatha natiyam Dancer/Legendary actress vyjayanthimala mam..So proud Blessing Shobhana mam
நடிகை பத்மினியின் சகோதரரின் மகள் ஷோபனாவை பார்க்கும் பொழுது பத்மினி நினைவுக்கு வருகிறார்
All are watching very eagerly. Very graceful performance.
Result is reflected on vyjanthimala mam's face
Very correct I also I served and thought of it
Really superb mesmerizing performance Shobha ji .....U r really a epitome of Dance
shobena mam is a beautiful dancer, got a luck to watch her concert conducted at palghat , during last very awesome , very humble person
P.v.vgpal Pvyr
సూపర్ శోభన గారు.. ఎక్సలెంట్
Exelent performance ! 🙏👏👏👏
Only south india has women remaining today who understand and perform classical dances. Awesome blend of innovation and tradition. As a north indian i feel Shobhana ji is the epitome of Hindu women’s grace.
That's because much of South India were until recently Hindu kingdoms unlike North Indian areas subjected to centuries of life as dhimmis. Yet, million applauses to the North people for being rooted in Dharma.
The South Indian film industry is so rooted to their culture. You can not expect such a classical performance at a Bollywood award show.
Beautiful raga and choreography was outstanding
Greatest performance mam.i am also a classical dancer. Superb.......
Very good performance in ms.shobana in100 years of cinema celebration.
Most beautiful n graceful lady...But in this perfomance ,her real beauty ,n grace ,perfection didn't come
Arun c.v 9x99z999y
It's ok she is amazing ❤️🔥🔥🔥
Dance queen 👑 Shobana madem
Mind blowing performance madam from AP
Amazing performance ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Who is the singer of this song. Where can I download this version from
Superb Mam, am a great fan of Yours...
Super Shobana Garu 💐💐💐💐💐
Ithaye vera yarachu adi iruntha avangala criticize panni troll pani irupanga. Ivanga panathala joint pain, health issues nu soldranga then wht about the group dancers. The performance was throughout clumsy.. I know she is the best dancer, this is the fusion of bharanatyam and mohiniattam but very difficult to predict the ratio. It doesn't mean that grt dancers can make mistakes. Performing in front of Amma, vyjanthimala, venniradai nirmala is not an easy game🤘home work is more important
Your correct, your clearly explained what I'm think 😊
You should not conclude by watching on YT. Cheers. It may have been a last minute plan. All Bharatanatyam exponents on social media 🙏
Shobaba mam is superb looks ditto like Padminiamma..God Bless Her and Bharatham....
She is simply amazing ♥️♥️♥️
🙏🙏👌👌👌😍 wonderful performance
❤❤❤❤❤sobhana
Amma we miss u excellent dance by shonana
whenever I c this performance I feel like seeing the real goddess durga. Hatts off to shobana mam. splendid performance
❤
👌👍I like Shopana madam so much.
Shobhana.. mam 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻. Ente ettavum valiya agragham , shobhana mam ne kananam ennullathanu... ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Fascinating performance. Wonderful choreography. Very good fusion.....
If anyone else had performed the same, people would have mocked and criticized! Are the dancers even dancing anything?
have u noted, vaijayanthi amma didn't even bothered to watch this crap
Yes, the choreography wasn’t good , the movements were very random and lacks elegance. Even Vijayanthi mala looked frustrated with it .
Amazing!
Not an expert but seeing other performance of her,this is highly disappointing in front of the huge crowd and a legend siting there.
Yes it,s true. She is not fully involve in her performance.
Yes
Super
Shiva dances way better. How nice to see Vijayantimala and her skillfull looks! Even she didn't like.
Last scene superbb
Shobhanaji Great Performance and concept...
4:18 .... doyen-vaijayanthimala mind voice ( enna ellavudaa ithu...karmam intha kodumaiyellaam paarkannamunu thalai yeluthu)
Celebrity dance !! Total mess.
correct
Great concept...
Great concept
Shobhana mam supper
Good nice perfomance👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻sobhana mam
Excellent
Excellant performance.
Bharatham is an age old golden dance...it is a legendary art in India never disgrace it...some of them misuse dance with shoes ...please avoid this with modern music...this a Diamond one presented by our ancestors ..please protect it....
Super excited
Very nice
Fusion barathanatyam, mohiniyattam
She is very simple in real.....♥️👌
Sadanai pen nadanathai sadanai pengal JJ madam, Vaijayanthi madam ellam pakkaradu excellent aa irukku
excellent performance
I felt a problem like sprain or joint pains wid Shobhana Ma'am. I am quite sure from her signing off that she herself was not satisfied with the performance
Stupid fellow
Superb
Wow😲
great performance and concept but please keep your performance quality..............
Very nice madam
MAGNIFIQUE!!!
Sobhana is a a great dancer.but this performance was not really the great from her.
K
ZTf TV edffgggdlxffrxswqr@
Ldsmdm_'&:/3fg+bhhm _&bj•||``+(few
This is a great performance by shobana as she is embodying the deity Durga and has to change in to the warrior goddess she is known to b e. Beautiful dance and choreography was excellent if not pure bharatanatyam
Shut up!!! This is such a great performance by her...See her age nobody can dance so well at this age!!
@@ryanmathew1851 you can shut up.mr Ryan.i have the right to express my view.
@@sobhanapanicker1022 hmm..take all your rights
Dear chechi super super
🤩
ma'am u r my role model, I am also a bharathanatyam dancer. I like u ma'am
Sasirekha Chinnathambi
this is not bn u dumb ...a crap
My god! What a performance. My idol!
M
😂 iam a tamilan but not understand Indian independence is over is 75 years but 100 years of Tamil cinema 😂 who agree
Tamil cinema started before independence
Its a 100 year of indian cinema not tamil cinema😂😂😂
@@ramanikrishnan4087 but i think bombay industry stars first in India 🤔
Actors Dance performance fully Upload pannunga
Shobhana mam is the back bone of classical dance..as a male classical dancer proud abt her...bt this performance is not satisfing,it may be bcs of the song.....
Imagine her Aunties Padmini or Ragini or Lalita or even Vyjayanthimala or Kumari Kamala or L Vijayalakshmi for that matter even Meenakshi Seshadri would have burnt the dance floor with our hearts on fire for more...that was them and this is now, no doubt Shobana is an accomplished dancer herself this was just average..
Yeah , no doubt she is immensely talented but this performance just below average...
Where is Meenakshi Seshadri dancing now? When was the last time she came on stage like this?
Why are you all after Shobana's work if you can't appreciate it atleast dont criticize it.
@@lizzystar1907 ua-cam.com/video/8dPt2WPtlNg/v-deo.html yes you are right about her performing of late but i remember seeing her in Damini and i found her dancing just like Padmini, Vyjayanthi and kamala . What i meant was Shobana is a terrific dancer but her moves in this was average..she reminded me of Hema Malini
❤❤
All the actors look bored or slightly annoyed.... shobhana is very talented but this was not a good performance and had nothing to do with the aigiri nandini lyrics- this is my opinion as a classical dancer and teacher
we enjoyed it. you being the classical dance teacher doesnt give you the ultimate power to dismiss other people's work.
@@planet_Jupiter same to you. ur foot
Exactly
.
Megha I’m fan of her dancing n acting,but this doesn’t seem attractive
Vyjanthimala : wat the hell!!!!
I am utter disappointment.i sat
At 10-30 to watch shobana's
Dance.
Vera Nice
shobana madam Ella dance chennagiruthe.⭐⭐
sujatha.k.b sujatha.k.b atre avra perfectness glow salpa dull agittu ansutte..she is a gem i know..but eno missing ittu
പാട്ടും ഡാൻസും ആയിട്ട് ബന്ധമില്ലാത്ത പോലെ feel ചെയ്യുന്നു. ചേച്ചിയുടെ ഡാൻസ് എന്ന് പറഞ്ഞപ്പോ ഒരുപാട് പ്രതീക്ഷിച്ചു.
I love bharatham
A good performance but mam not involved in this dance becoz of some physical issues I have a great respect with her
Can I know what that physical issues ??
Where is aramandi😕
How can she give such medicre performance and that too infront of Vyjayantimala and Venniradai nirmala
Even jj also know bharatham
this is not aramandi dance itshould be graceful only
SHOBANA Ji's dance and expression were perfect ...background song was not in sync..
usha her dance is off rhythm it is so hard to do that only the most experienced dancer can do that kind of rhythm that why this dance is so difficult
I love sobhana..but this is was perfomance
shoba madam dance yaavude aagirsli thumbs chennaagiruthe ⭐⭐
My faaavvvvvvvvvvvvv she is ma +ve energy... I love....... Uff
For heavens sake this is not pure Bharatham. Aramandi and angashudhi have changed today. Even in past changes were made according to the times. And this is a composite art not pure Bharatjam. We don't have proof for pure dance in India. Please show where there is books 5000 years ago?
Hence this beautiful art form is awesome art S art no comparison it is aesthetic to watch Thank you Dhobana.
Thank you!
In this age of puritanism and nationalism surfacing everywhere everyone including artists are suddenly being criticized horribly by people who just sit back and rant without having no knowledge.
If the same performance will any other group dancers Will done defnatly people will never accept for this Great Stage and front of wonderful Indian artist so sad.
very excellent performance
Great performance
Super dancer
ഇവരുടെ ഏത് ഡാൻസ് നോക്കിയാലും ഒരേ കോപ്രായങ്ങൾ പോയി ഭാനുപ്രിയ ഡാൻസ് ചെയ്യുന്നത് കണ്ട് പഠിക്ക് ചേച്ചി
Sure
പറയുന്ന നിങ്ങൾ ഡാൻസ് അങ്ങേയറ്റം പേടിച്ചു വന്നതാണെന്നു തോന്നുന്നുണ്ടല്ലോ
@@gdgggggg അവർ ഡാൻസ് പഠിച്ചിട്ടില്ലെങ്കിലും പറഞ്ഞ വസ്തുത ശരിയാണ്
ശെരിയാ.. ഇതിൽ ഇവർ ന്തോ കിടന്ന് കാണിക്കുവാ ശെരിക്കുന്ന പ്രാക്ടീസ് ചെയ്തില്ലാന്ന് തോന്നുന്നു. Full doubt അടിച്ചു കളിക്കുന്നത് പോലെ തോന്നുന്നു 😁
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
132 விமர்சனக்களும் ஆங்கிலத்தில் இருக்கு
அதுதான் இன்றய தமிழன் நிலை
See actually it is not only a tamil but a South Indian, which was conducted in Chennai, comprising all the 4 languages.
So the comments must be in tamil telugu malayalam kannada
👍🙏
U luk vry gorgeous mam..
Shivas costume is looking funny OK total cenima people
The best classic dancer in Indian cinema
Vijanthimala is the best
@@suepalam different generation pa
@@senseprevails24 you obviously don’t understand the nature of this dance and it’s tradition unchanged for millennia …. generation does not come in to it
joy maa
This is callled Naatiya Nadagam, in classic Tamil culture. In other words, unlike usual Bharathanatiyam which involves mostly dance, a Naatiya Naadagam will also have a story or drama will be there along with Bharathanatiyam.
What kind of performance...
Nothing matches..
Not at all balancing..
Sorry to say that this one is not up to the level
I don't get words!!!!!!!
lakhs of likes to this performance
Shobhana badly needs to go back to dance school and retrain. Obviously she has lost touch . Her adavus are not precise and she seems to move in a carefree way. Bharathanatyam requires strength and precision, Shobhana seems to be making an halfhearted attempt at dancing. She did dance well in some of her movies decades ago. Last ten years or so many of us have watched her talents wane away. I cant believe she thinks she can still perform and organizers keep inviting her to perform at such events. This is embarrassing.
Exactly observed, this is because of something called over experimenting and fusion work, in order to create a separate image in the name of that particular bred style, of course Shobana ji has deviated, just like her Hema Malini ji also deviated, she performs Kuchipudi in Bhatanatyam attire and mixes both the forms along with yet another dance style Odissi by her daughters. It has become trendy now a days. Its good thing to experiment new stuff but without having been delineated from the roots.
Shobhana pillai ,she is beautiful Nair lady
I saw all the comments out here,All the good ones and the bad ones. I mean come on guys you guys need to be sensible.She is not the only one working in this dance, it's a team effort, sometimes some situation goes out of hands and she can't do anything about that.Everyone cannot do everything everytime with utter perfection.Wanting perfection in everything we see is somewhat selfishness, isn't it guys! Well Shobana mam is great dancer no doubt .If you guys want to see her bests then check out the ramayan...It's on UA-cam. Ithreyum nalla oru dancerum nadiyeyum kaanan kittiyath aanu namade okke oru bhagyam.Avare orikkilum nammal pucchikkan paadilla...Avaru devam onnum alla ath enikkum ariyam pakshe even she is a human being and we should consider that.......This is for #the Shobana mam