Epiphone ES335 vs Sire Larry Carlton - Are Sire REALLY Making a Better Guitar?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @christopherjbutler
    @christopherjbutler Рік тому +10

    Love when there's an early morning video to enjoy from you, sir. Eastern time zone here. Had a rough day yesterday, this intro is good medicine, Dr Cordy.

  • @elliotgreen987
    @elliotgreen987 Рік тому +12

    Jesus, I'm so glad to have found this channel! Don't get me wrong, old blues licks are my main love but your contemporary and occasional jazzy playing is such a breath of fresh air

  • @davidcudlip6587
    @davidcudlip6587 29 днів тому +2

    I have one of the newer Inspired By Gibson Epi ES335 in a Cherry finish and a Sire H7V in Cherry sunburst. It's the Sire that I'm picking up and playing more and more. Those P90's running thru a tube amp on the edge of break-up can't be beat. Very articulate pickups and the note separation is clearer then the humbuckers on the Epi. The Sire is great for harder edge blues, clean jazz, 50's rock and roll, or classic rock. If i was given one guitar on a desert island, I'd want the Sire.

  • @andycasile
    @andycasile Рік тому +2

    The blue version of this Epi is a guitar I play all the time. The frets did require a lot of work. I can do that myself, so no problem - but I'd happily sacrifice a little bit of looks to get a guitar that plays like a more expensive instrument. That said, now I have a guitar that looks and plays like a champ, and I bought it, so I guess everybody wins

  • @fantomas9240
    @fantomas9240 Рік тому +4

    I tried two Sire, the H7 (Vintage burst) and the H7v (black). The frets on the H7 were awfully sharp on the edges, all of them ! And the body was slightly asymmetrical. The H7v had just some mark of tool on the biding and some black paint spot. The P90 pickup were not good. The Epiphone was a little better but, choose carefully with real pictures of the model you purchase. I've seen a lot with tuners not well screwed on the back of the headstock and often asymmetrical body. Check photos and look where the body join the neck. For this range of price I much prefer a Gretsch Streamliner. The construction are way better and best constituency.
    My 2 cents but I guess, because of the very great feedbacks on UA-cam when they reached out on the market, the Sire H7 are now so required the factory is constantly on hurry and shorter time to work on them.

    • @marcohermans3207
      @marcohermans3207 Місяць тому

      I've the H7 and H7V. The H7V I bought at big box retailer who set it up near perfect. The H7 I bought at a music store nearby and it was also setup near perfect for my taste. With near perfect I mean I filed the not slots a tiny bit for better intonation on the first few frets. For the rest these instruments are flawless, smooth fret ends, no paint at the binding or other laquer faults, tuners are sufficient and working smoothly. The shop owner and I compared the H7 to real custom shop Gibson ES335 at a pricetag at €6000... The Gibsons sound more lively and warmer acoustic but as soon as you plug-in the difference dissappears. The Sire performed on high and low volume on 95% on the same level of the Gibsons that had a sweeter top end. Then I used a boss GE-7 pedal to make them exactly the same. The owner, the customers who where there, and I couldn't hear a difference....Great great instruments. The Streamliners are also great instruments sure but they have that Gretsch sound and you like it or you don't but it's not the 335 sound if that's what someone wants. The latest new Sire models reveal a compagny who wants to grow, being consistent, and making a good instrument for a good price. Every compagny makes a bad instrument from time to time . I'm a Luthier who sees every major brand on my workbench every week with different problems. Sire is no exception but the problems with them are adressed easily. The Epiphone 335 is a great instrument too but the neck shape throw me off. The reason that the Sire instruments being on backorder all the time has a reason..... The working man Guitar player wants an instrument that delivers, don't cost a fortune, looks good, sounds good. Sire does that perfectly

  • @stephencasse3985
    @stephencasse3985 7 днів тому

    Hi everybody, thanks John Nathan for your videos. I wonder wich Epiphone is this ??? Cause the "Inspired by Gibson Series" doesn't have the block inlays, just the dot ones ... ? Am I missing something ?

  • @shawnlutz7008
    @shawnlutz7008 Рік тому +3

    Cool playing and both sound really nice. I like them both but went with the Sire H7 in white/gold. I have seen some pretty nice laminated tops on the H7's so if that is one's thing you could find them. For mine I have no complaints with fit and finish as I expected to see some tooling and minor inperfections. My FB was dry AF and not sure if the cause was the strings it comes with or the frethboard but it turned my fingers black. After a string change, cleanup, fret polish, board lubed and set up to my preferences it plays and sounds really nice. The quality at the price point is fairly hight really, from many other brands as well. The neck on the Sire and overall playability is great, it just feels comfortable in the hands. For the comparison record I primarily play USA made guitars and have some custom shops from others builders, Fender/Gibson/GMW/Jackson etc and the Sire is fun and not unworthy in the slightest. I've been playing the crap out of it as a nightly wind guitar where I shut off all electronics and just play unplugged for an hour or 3 by candle light before going to bed. The 335 type semi hollow helps hearing over an old school metronome when running scales/sequences. I've had it a couple months and already the gold finish is wearing off the bridge/TP. I didn't expect to like it this much but I do LOL

  • @Takianagi
    @Takianagi Рік тому +2

    John I get to meet Larry Carlton later tonight and I'm going to ask him to make you a signature guitar 🎸😁🎸🔥 Much love and have a good weekend!

  • @mike1967sam
    @mike1967sam 8 місяців тому

    I bought the Sire H7V (P90) in CS and in all honesty it is as perfect as possible, maybe I got lucky because I ordered it from Thomann. The fret work is as good as my Gibson and my Ibanez Japan models. I was thinking of buying an Epiphone ES 335 with humbuckers but I feel I'm beginning to suffer from too many purchases which tends to have you leave 4 or 5 guitars behind that you don't play for months on end but let me say your video comparisons and playing are excellent, this is the third video of yours I've watched and it's really well done, kudos John.

  • @ProducerDudes
    @ProducerDudes Рік тому +4

    I got an Epiphone Jim James 335 and its honestly one of the best guitars I've ever owned. I've gone through maybe 25+ Gibson Les Pauls and 10+ Fender Professional guitars and several from every other brand and its one of the guitars that is in my main rotation. Haven't used an epiphone since maybe 2009? I've actually disliked them on several occasions, but this guitar in particular I'd take over all but 1 of the Gibson's I've ever owned and just reminds me that the name on the headstock is just a word. Appreciate the content!

    • @bellinghammond
      @bellinghammond Рік тому

      "but this guitar in particular I'd take over all but 1 of the Gibson's I've ever owned"....Which guitar? The Sire? The Epi ES335? or your Jim James?

    • @ProducerDudes
      @ProducerDudes Рік тому +1

      @@bellinghammond my Jim James Epiphone

  • @ovivan79
    @ovivan79 Рік тому +6

    Honestly, I'm starting to get the feeling that Sire put more attention into their QC when they launched their PR campaign with the release of the Larry Carlton's and maybe it's easing down a little now whereas Epiphone is doing the opposite, seeing the competition and popularity of their models.

  • @blueeyephil
    @blueeyephil Рік тому +14

    Love how you threw, get a Tokai instead at the end. 😂

    • @ovivan79
      @ovivan79 Рік тому +1

      But where do you even buy them? Ebay?

    • @gregjohnson6329
      @gregjohnson6329 Рік тому

      I assume the Tokai ES 130 video done here. For that price you’re close to an Eastman T486 that is killer n

  • @MarkLysaght
    @MarkLysaght Рік тому +1

    The Sire has an ebony fingerboard? I have a black H7V and it's very playable, the P90s amazingly good at the price point. I chose the black version as, like you, the burst looked a bit tacky but the black version with gold hardware looks really classy.

  • @mikejones-hs7od
    @mikejones-hs7od Рік тому +2

    On my H7V the burst, fit and finish is all really nice. That one you have there the burst is def weird. Frets were good on mine but very scratchy, needed a full level and crown as the tooling marks were too deep. But the edges are very comfy and after the frets were fixed the guitar is pretty much perfect.

  • @darwindesilos9484
    @darwindesilos9484 Рік тому +2

    What do you think of Tokai ES-78? They are the most accessible Tokai semi-hollow I think although they are probably made in China which is nothing wrong of course; it’s just that made in Japan and Korea are considered higher quality.

  • @philipmarsh3522
    @philipmarsh3522 Рік тому +3

    I suppose it’s probably a bit easier to have the frets tidied up than having a new paint job. Sire might want to work on that.

    • @jessejordache1869
      @jessejordache1869 2 місяці тому

      A set-up will fix the fret problem. Never heard of a luthier who gives a new paint job.

  • @stevewilliams846
    @stevewilliams846 Рік тому +3

    I've worked on both Sires and Epis. The overall fretwork is better, from what I've seen. Either might need some spot leveling.
    I generally would rather have the Sire comparing humbucker to humbucker on both.

    • @davidcudlip6587
      @davidcudlip6587 29 днів тому

      That model Sire doesn't have humbuckers. It has single coil P90's.

  • @gioelevio1626
    @gioelevio1626 Рік тому +2

    I have a Sire L7 in black/gold and it’s a very fun guitar, I use it when I teach lessons and as a spare guitar. Do you think it would benefit a lot from a pickup upgrade? My Gibson Les paul (it’s a really good custom shop one, with Custom buckers) sounds brighter and with more output, and the Sire is a bit more mid focused, it’s nice but it doesn’t have the same weight sonically. I don’t know, just wondering… If upgrading the Sire makes any sense…

  • @davidpatrick1813
    @davidpatrick1813 10 місяців тому +1

    Would like to have the same comparisons with the Carlton as with the Eppiphone. I see only the lead sounds were compared.

  • @Takianagi
    @Takianagi Рік тому +2

    I got Larry to Sign my Sire S7 last night during his workshop and told him that you should be sires next guitar guy and to make you a signature guitar! Much love! ❤️☺️🎸

  • @clydebermingham121
    @clydebermingham121 6 місяців тому

    The most important things to me about any guitar or instrument is playability, sound & sturdiness (durability ) .
    Give me a Willie Nelson’s “TRIGGER” looking guitar even … if it plays so indispensably well … and sounds so well .::
    And how will a guitar &/or instrument endure through out the ‘ages ‘ ?

  • @damienalvarez2957
    @damienalvarez2957 Рік тому +3

    I was stuck between getting an Epi 335 in raspberry burst or the similarly-priced cherry red Sire semi-hollow. I came so close to getting the Sire but given that both had a similar feel to me, I got the raspberry Epi. Just could not resist that finish. That said, the Sire looked super clean with all of its cosmetic appointments. I even liked the metal headstock “binding”. Gave it an extra bit of elegance.

  • @MrJazzedBlues
    @MrJazzedBlues 4 місяці тому

    Why compare 335 style guitars with different pickup configuration? Humbucker on the Epi 335 and the Sire with P90 style pups?

  • @vincemincevince
    @vincemincevince Рік тому

    i have es335 it’s so amazing one of the best guitars i’ve owned

  • @youKnowWho3311
    @youKnowWho3311 Рік тому

    Sire headstock ftw. Both sound great under your hands sir!

  • @kingstumble
    @kingstumble 8 місяців тому

    I used to have an Epi 335 and an Epi 339. I sold them both because I couldn't stand the Alnico Pro pickups. I also had an Epi Les Paul with Probuckers which I really liked. So if only they had put Probuckers in the 335 and 339 I would have kept both.

  • @picksalot1
    @picksalot1 Рік тому +1

    Just some random observations, the "break angle" of the strings behind the bridge on the Epi is good, but too shallow on the Sire. You'll probably get a better sound out of the Sire if you can lower the Tailpiece. The Epi sounded really good, and it seemed you had an easier time playing it. 🤷

  • @vip01
    @vip01 9 місяців тому

    I have an Epiphone es-339, and a Sire H7, I had an Epiphone Es-335. I like the pickups better in the Epiphone.

  • @DavidEidelberg
    @DavidEidelberg Рік тому +2

    The Epiphone by Gibson line seems to have better quality control to me.

  • @huka83
    @huka83 Рік тому +1

    Plz make a video on sterling cutlass ct50 plus!

  • @MixableRat90
    @MixableRat90 Рік тому

    Cold you do a shootout which the Yamaha pacifica 6xx vs sire s7, They are around the same price range and I was considering buy-ing one of them.

  • @ErebosGR
    @ErebosGR Рік тому +1

    I'd get an Ibanez AS93FM instead. Or an AS73 and upgrade the pickups.

  • @tims6824
    @tims6824 Рік тому

    John it's sounding so great

  • @jacobcheng8299
    @jacobcheng8299 Рік тому +1

    love your work!

  • @toneseeker87
    @toneseeker87 Рік тому

    The playing will certainly bring out the best in the instrument. ❤

  • @ferdauzabdulkadir8553
    @ferdauzabdulkadir8553 Рік тому

    It’ll be exciting to see a similar comparison with the PRS SE hollowbody 2 piezo.

  • @neilyoung5029
    @neilyoung5029 9 місяців тому

    I would say that everything that the Sire excels at can be sorted on the Epiphone by a setup….and I’m a rhythm player so massive frets don’t worry me….you can’t fix the cosmetic issues.

  • @vladaspetrauskas2800
    @vladaspetrauskas2800 Рік тому

    You are the best Jonh!!! You worthy!

  • @sober-southoftheborderever3591

    I have the Sire "335" in Sunburst and I love it. Everything is perfect. I also have the new EPI 335 which I like too. Both guitars are amazing!

  • @clydebermingham121
    @clydebermingham121 6 місяців тому

    NICE PLAYING ✌🏽🙏🏽👍🏽

  • @infinity-1834
    @infinity-1834 Рік тому

    Beautiful playing mate! Personally the Epiphone gets it. This is based 100% on tone, so the playability I can't comment on. Tried an Epi Les Paul some time ago and wasn't that fussed about rushing for my wallet. I don't really want to gig my old Gibbo, so I think I'll try the Epi myself. Great vid as ever!👍

  • @ksharpe10
    @ksharpe10 Рік тому +1

    The sire is painted more or less like a Gibson 335, the epiphone is painted like the epiphone style, the patterning that is. Fret work is hit or miss with all companies. Once got a Fender american standard off Ebay, when I got it, even though it had been modded, diff. pickguard and wagner SR pickups. But my gosh the minute I went to play it, i said in no way was anyone ever playing this, the frets were sharp to the left hand, well I used just one of those Hobbiest nail files you can get at any hobby store, and tidied up the fret ends, took about 2 hours tops, then it felt like a played in guitar, any one can do this it is not ROCKET SCIENCE. Now if I spent 5000 on a Gibson even 3000, and it came that way I would be in SHOCK to say the least. Well just my 2 cents both guitars sound great, but that is the ARTISTS fingers and HIS Masterful abilities dialing in GOOD SOUNDS. If I lived near John Cordy I would gladly teach him how to do his OWN finishing work and SOLDERING work. It would be my Pleasure to do so.

  • @Patriot1777
    @Patriot1777 8 місяців тому

    I own the s7 and love it 😊

  • @thelantern9075
    @thelantern9075 3 місяці тому

    Nice opening track. 👍

  • @WilliamJOHNSONJR
    @WilliamJOHNSONJR Рік тому

    JNC, Thanks for this ! Somewhat superficial (no deep dive where they actually get taken apart) ... But these are Semi Hollows , so Nobody does that ! Epiphone is the old established name. Sire, new kid on the block.
    I do like the finish choice (color) on the Epi ...and maybe even the flamey-stripey... But even as a Tyro Hobbyist Beginner ... I absolutely hate jaggy fret ends , and what's more , fretboards that shrink ! (I live in an extreme environment, where now Heat & Humidity makes fretboards fat & chubby) ... But in the dry, nasty Midwestern US winter ... FRETSPOUT bad as COVID when the dry cold kicks in !!!
    I see the Sire, as my "High End P90 Platform", and will probably stick with it as my choice.
    Both guitars , are more guitar that I can exploit at this point, but as Epi is trying to make a QC comeback, and Sire trying to maintain ... I'll stick with the new kid (as I'm still diggin on P90's)

  • @1madaxeman
    @1madaxeman Рік тому

    I wonder if he got a replacement or a refund ??

  • @renodavid
    @renodavid Рік тому

    I definitely wouldn’t buy a Sire with a sunburst finish sight unseen. There’s just too much of an art to getting the spray just right, and I can’t stand it when the job is botched (like the one here). I’m actually thinking of getting a Danner version of a 335. They quality looks decent and Danner sells some used ones on their eBay site for $200.😳 Unfortunately, that’s all I can afford at present, but I’ve always loved 335s. B.B.!

  • @DH-CA
    @DH-CA 27 днів тому

    To my ears the Epiphone sounds better. It rings out and cleaner sound…. The H7 is smoother - so it’s all up to your preferences. But I don’t necessarily say the H7 sounds better…

  • @JohnQuincy1776
    @JohnQuincy1776 5 місяців тому

    the finish on the Epi is so much better it is probably worth a fret job.

  • @hagicocompany
    @hagicocompany Рік тому

    I will get a Yamaha standard for the price and the sound

  • @samseitz9937
    @samseitz9937 Рік тому +1

    How much does having a tag on the headstock impact tone?

  • @juandoming6688
    @juandoming6688 Рік тому +1

    Its crazy how quilter labs gets no love on youtube. Total blackout. 😊

  • @markhill9275
    @markhill9275 Рік тому

    Id rather save my penniea and get the Eastman 486. Or get hold of an Agile 1000, and upgrade.

  • @paco68it
    @paco68it 4 місяці тому

    I’ll stick with my Epy thanks!❤

  • @True96red
    @True96red Рік тому

    So I got quite a few Sire Larry Carlton guitars when they first came out, it seems that the quality on them was much higher then than it is now. The burst on mine is high quality, and the fretwork is excellent. Maybe the quality dropped as production ramped up

    • @True96red
      @True96red Рік тому

      I have 3 electric sires, 1 acoustic, and 1 bass

  • @yoheff988
    @yoheff988 Рік тому +3

    For the life of me I could never understand why people like those plywood guitars, other that the fact that they large and bulky I don't see any amazing sound qualities, after all they have a center solid wood block in the center which really makes them solid body guitars. The diference in sound between those and solid body guitars is zero, and all the people that think they hear a diference it's all in your head LOL. On top of it's uncomfortable to play high on the 22nd fret. SO WHAT'S ALL THE NOISE ABOUT?

  • @joeschmoe1301
    @joeschmoe1301 11 місяців тому

    Yes, he is comparing guitars with different pickups but, he plays fast so he is forgiven.

    • @johnnathancordy
      @johnnathancordy  11 місяців тому

      How often have you seen a comparison of guitars with identical pickups?! Is that a thing...Also good luck changing pickups on an ES type guitar ha...I couldn't do it

  • @randyallen4959
    @randyallen4959 Рік тому

    Seriously, why compare p90s with hb equipped guitars other than contrast pickups. It's not legit review other than QC, finish, and neck

  • @gffg387
    @gffg387 Рік тому +21

    Jonathan, one guitar has P90, the other humbuckers. You can't compare them.

    • @john.parker65
      @john.parker65 Рік тому +15

      He can if the wants 😂

    • @christopherjbutler
      @christopherjbutler Рік тому +1

      ​@@john.parker65😂

    • @gffg387
      @gffg387 Рік тому +9

      @@john.parker65 But what if the comparison police finds out?

    • @chinchillax1483
      @chinchillax1483 Рік тому +11

      I think he’s mostly focusing on playability and quality, not so much the sound, since, let’s be honest, they’re both going to sound fine. In my opinion, it’s hard to find a guitar that truly sounds bad once you get to a certain price point

    • @_caseyjames
      @_caseyjames Рік тому +1

      Yeah that's fair

  • @Patriot1777
    @Patriot1777 11 місяців тому

    Sire😊

  • @tbluesboye
    @tbluesboye Рік тому

    I got a Tokai instead! 😎

  • @Borgz34
    @Borgz34 Рік тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @twoys440
    @twoys440 Рік тому

    not made in japan and no yellow color, pass.

  • @markv.5962
    @markv.5962 2 місяці тому

    too many effects for a demo

  • @maciejpe779
    @maciejpe779 10 місяців тому

    This is the worst presentation ever... So much Overdrive and effects, no clean sound straight from the amp, i think the straight woodstick will be sounds similar....😢

    • @johnnathancordy
      @johnnathancordy  10 місяців тому

      I can think of some speeches in Germany that maybe were worse presentations?

    • @maciejpe779
      @maciejpe779 10 місяців тому +1

      @@johnnathancordy Germany😆🤔