Di Wu plays Schoenberg Drei Klavierstücke, Op. 11

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 142

  • @truthpopup
    @truthpopup 8 років тому +33

    Atonal music played with such feeling is very interesting.

    • @OAmus
      @OAmus 5 років тому +6

      One of the great misconceptions of many interpreters of this music, including Pollini etc., is that it should be executed dryly and "percisely" without feeling. This is in direct opposition to Schoenberg's intentions, as is easily evident from his writings and correspondences, as it is from the notation itself.

    • @supermax5584
      @supermax5584 4 роки тому

      Just like OAmus says, it is supposed to be played this way. Because in the end, music is there to express something. And you cannot express something when "just pressing down the keys".

    • @simonkawasaki4229
      @simonkawasaki4229 4 роки тому +1

      Well, one is never just pressing keys, like a cat. Schoenberg wrote these notes down for a reason, a very satisfying one. I don’t understand why anyone wouldn’t play Schoenberg without feeling.

    • @machida5114
      @machida5114 4 роки тому

      @@OAmus "style and idea" by Schoenberg!!
      Gould is right!!

    • @norbertflorianschuck9300
      @norbertflorianschuck9300 3 роки тому +1

      This is not atonal music. It is music with fast shifting tonal centres and many free dissonances.

  • @dierotewand3297
    @dierotewand3297 6 років тому +3

    Now that is dedication. I am in awe of her, playing this absolute atrocity. All from memory!

    • @caiovictorfornemartins771
      @caiovictorfornemartins771 5 років тому +1

      Well, I wouldn't say it's an absolute atrocity. I like this kind of music! It sounds appealing, inspiring, and very emotional to my ears.
      I completely understand those who don't like it, and at the same time I cannot help but see that taste for art is something subjective.
      Peace!

    • @AEZaubermann
      @AEZaubermann 11 місяців тому

      Atrocious? Learn to play keys at a high level in accordance with the pre-atonal system of western music, and the learn to play this work of genius by Schoenberg

  • @futurists7076
    @futurists7076 11 місяців тому

    Wonderful sound and phrasing. And absolutely understanding of this music. Congrats to Mrs Di Wu!

  • @SAMMIEWU1106
    @SAMMIEWU1106 12 років тому +9

    Indeed. Di Wu "sings" very well! Beautiful notes!

  • @chillyperson23
    @chillyperson23 8 років тому +34

    Wonderful! I found this by searching for "atonal music" because I was tired of listening to everything else i knew about. This music is very expressive in a way that is misunderstood, even hated, by many people because it's not what they're used to. I find it funny that it still has that same effect today that it did when it was first written!

  • @7171Julian
    @7171Julian 2 роки тому +2

    Wonderful performance. Di Wu really makes this music live. It's far better than I had expected, I'd never heard these 3 pieces Op 11, before. They really are stupendous pieces when they are played as well as Di Wu plays them.

  • @rholbrook0587
    @rholbrook0587 7 років тому +4

    Wonderful technique & interpretive abilities too. It seemed that she is fully engaged with each note, the piece as a whole, and how each note, or group of notes, fit together. Great job!

  • @_H_2023
    @_H_2023 3 роки тому +3

    It has to be the best version out there. 10/10 Di Wu.

  • @kkyyee
    @kkyyee 6 років тому +7

    This really captures how I feel as someone with bipolar depression.

  • @antonderuwe3041
    @antonderuwe3041 Рік тому

    excellent performance of this work by Schönberg. One of his first works in the atonal style, the basic for further works by him and A. Berg and A. Webern. Di Wu understand very well this work, to perform it without a music score. Very expressive. Congratulations!

  • @-_NAN_-
    @-_NAN_- 8 років тому +12

    This is what atonal music is meant to be and there was a lot of thought put into this music. Well played too.

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 8 років тому +1

      " there was a lot of thought put into this music" How do you know?

    • @user-ef4de6ds6f
      @user-ef4de6ds6f 4 роки тому

      @@jaspernatchez he is saying schoenberg really took his time with this composition. The different harmony's and connecting elements he incorporates in this really shines out.

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 4 роки тому

      @@user-ef4de6ds6f puhleeze

    • @user-ef4de6ds6f
      @user-ef4de6ds6f 4 роки тому

      @@jaspernatchez please what?

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 4 роки тому

      @@user-ef4de6ds6f Honestly? Please stop attempting to speak about things you obviously have no clue about.

  • @baldrbraa
    @baldrbraa 3 роки тому +3

    I have a feeling that this is the point in history where Schönberg’s music is starting to make sense to a broader public. After 100 years, it was worth it.

  • @Leibo07
    @Leibo07 7 років тому +1

    Thank you, Di Wu, for playing this music as well, and the awesome way you do it. I hope you will stick to it.

  • @jbw53191
    @jbw53191 Рік тому

    Incredible voicing! I wish I had played it this way back in college.

  • @andrewnegustorov6371
    @andrewnegustorov6371 5 років тому

    Stunning music - stunning performance! Love it so much!

  • @gavmusic
    @gavmusic 2 роки тому +3

    Beautiful interpretation and performance. Schoenberg was always a romantic composer, regardless of whether it's his early, obviously romantic works, the atonal works or the 12-note serialism compositions.

  • @patrickbarrus8315
    @patrickbarrus8315 5 років тому +5

    the theme at 6:10 is one of the loneliest sounds in the world

  • @jacquesderegnaucourt1725
    @jacquesderegnaucourt1725 Рік тому

    ADMIRABLE!!! Magnifique! 1000 mercis!!!

  • @lourak613
    @lourak613 5 років тому +2

    The influence of Scriabin is so strongly felt in this work. Note particularly, the texture and rhythmic flow.

  • @DerekWilliamsMusic
    @DerekWilliamsMusic 2 роки тому

    Fascinating through the looking glass of history. Superbly played.

  • @amielgonzaga5239
    @amielgonzaga5239 9 років тому +5

    Genial! Opus. Muy buena interpretación

  • @caiovictorfornemartins771
    @caiovictorfornemartins771 5 років тому

    Strong piece and awesome performance!

  • @paulcummins6780
    @paulcummins6780 5 років тому

    Very expressive! Beautiful job!

  • @galibgasancom
    @galibgasancom 11 років тому +3

    DI Wu - FANTASTIC!!!

  • @My-Dear
    @My-Dear 3 роки тому +5

    쇤베르크 세 개의 피아노곡 1악장 ~3:15
    조표 없이 필요할때마다 임시표를 붙여 정확한 음을 표현하여, 조성을 암시하는 움직임 찾을수 없음. 과거의 협화음-불협화음 구분에서 해방됨.

  • @lotharlamurtra7924
    @lotharlamurtra7924 6 років тому

    Magistral interpretación. Nunca antes una interpretación de música para piano de Schoenberg me había llamado tan poderosamente la atención. Solo acabar lo he vuelto a oir. Increíble que pueda no gustar a todo oyente atento y curioso. Viva la música y gracias Di Wu!

  • @Bashkii
    @Bashkii 11 років тому +8

    IT´S soooooooooooooooooooo wonderful!!!

  • @MadMusicologist
    @MadMusicologist 12 років тому +6

    Phantastic. Incredible. Expression and precision. How would Alban Bergs Sonata sound when she plays it?

  • @stueystuey1962
    @stueystuey1962 5 років тому

    absolutely phenomenal.

  • @machida5114
    @machida5114 4 роки тому

    This performance great!!
    Expressive atonal music great!!

  • @irokosalei5133
    @irokosalei5133 Рік тому +1

    Arnold Schönberg is the Thelonious Monk of XXth classical.

  • @bobbylovejoy
    @bobbylovejoy 6 років тому +1

    Tremendous!

  • @EmanuelaZucchi
    @EmanuelaZucchi 12 років тому +4

    Brava!

  • @raindual
    @raindual 4 роки тому +3

    Atonic music such as this make me dream about surrealistic creatures

    • @b.walter6646
      @b.walter6646 4 роки тому

      Captain Beefheart was a surrealistic creature.

    • @irokosalei5133
      @irokosalei5133 Рік тому

      And demons travelling on different planes of existence.

  • @CameronGuarino
    @CameronGuarino 6 років тому +28

    i love watching people get mad at schönberg because their ears are trapped in the baroque era

    • @ryangiraldi5722
      @ryangiraldi5722 5 років тому +6

      Cameron Guarino I personally love music from the baroque era, and I absolutely ADORE atonal music. So there, now they have no excuse.

    • @BuddyStewart94
      @BuddyStewart94 5 років тому +7

      I think you mean in the Wiener Klassik/Romantik era?! I don't think that average people usually listen to Bach's fugues. (I do, but people normally don't)

    • @supermax5584
      @supermax5584 4 роки тому +1

      It doesn't matter what music you usually like, eg Gregorian chant, techno or even (dipshit like) Einaudi. If you like something, then you do. And there's nothing to change about it

    • @machida5114
      @machida5114 4 роки тому +4

      The tonality of the musical work is the sweetness of the drink. Sometimes I want a sugar-free drink.

    • @machida5114
      @machida5114 4 роки тому +1

      @@Theosis78 Yes, we inevitably hear harmony.
      Strong sweetness kills other tastes.

  • @0reason2exist
    @0reason2exist 11 місяців тому

    technically and musically wonderful performance

  • @petermyers7562
    @petermyers7562 2 роки тому

    From 07:17 to 08:20 is achingly beautiful and numbingly moving.

  • @opticalmixing23
    @opticalmixing23 2 роки тому

    Schoenberg getting mass recognition here

  • @baldrbraa
    @baldrbraa 3 роки тому

    There is no other way to judge music than whether it grips you in some way. Sometimes all you can say about it is that «I really felt it at that point in the middle where it went ‘ooomph’». Then, after repeated listening, the thrill may either transmute into a deeper appreciation that the whole piece confirms that bit of meaning, or, you may come to realise that it was just a fluke and the composition doesn’t follow through on its promise. Either way, you don’t owe your experience to anyone, it’s yours and you grow on it in your own way.

  • @davidfuzefiuczynski
    @davidfuzefiuczynski 7 місяців тому

    do i hear some phrases from Alban Berg's piano sonata?

  • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
    @Fritz_Maisenbacher 11 років тому +2

    Herrlich .

  • @mohamadkebbewar6827
    @mohamadkebbewar6827 9 років тому +12

    Fantastic piece, great performance. Thank you :)

  • @boochama
    @boochama Місяць тому

    9:45 BRAVA🎉

  • @amandadavis5311
    @amandadavis5311 9 років тому +15

    Gorgeous performance

  • @einerlei9135
    @einerlei9135 9 років тому +3

    von nicht zu überbietender Intelligenz und Eindringlichkeit - diese herrliche Frau, aus der Tiefe Asiens

  • @DiscoInTheNunnery
    @DiscoInTheNunnery 10 років тому +9

    It's interesting, although this piece was Schoenberg first venture into what eventually became his 12 tone system of tonality, there's still a relatively decent amount of traditional tonality in them. Like Bernstein said, even atonal pieces are written using the same 12 tones that make up the tonal system.

    • @fcox8563
      @fcox8563 7 років тому +2

      His free atonal style is quite different from his 12-tone style, which didn't start until the 1920s, when Neoclassicism was all over the place. His free atonal works are much more expressionist/late romantic, and the works in the 1920s are often neoclasssical in nature: suites of Baroque-influence dances, etc.

  • @마리모-n2w
    @마리모-n2w Рік тому

    쇤베르크 세개의 피아노곡, 작품번호 11번 1악장 ~3:15

  • @nizhang8287
    @nizhang8287 11 років тому +6

    schoenberg

  • @version191
    @version191 10 років тому +5

    great performance

  • @user-zv7fp9hg3g
    @user-zv7fp9hg3g 2 роки тому

    0:01~3:15

  • @ZolaNtondo
    @ZolaNtondo 4 роки тому

    D’un goût charmant

  • @galibgasancom
    @galibgasancom 11 років тому +3

    best interpretation!Thanks

  • @stephenn77
    @stephenn77 3 роки тому

    How does one memorize something like this??? Funny, Schoenberg ends on a major chord!

    • @_H_2023
      @_H_2023 3 роки тому

      He doesn't end this piece on a Major chord ! from top to bottom D, Eb, B, C♯ in the bass, closest would be enharmonic B - D(♯) instead of Eb which would make it B9 but it clearly isn't.

  • @franckmousset4022
    @franckmousset4022 5 років тому

    Le tempo de la première pièce est trop rapide.

  • @andersonbg3759
    @andersonbg3759 8 років тому

    Complejo tios!!! Me quedo con mi mozart jeje

  • @lagosfernando
    @lagosfernando 3 роки тому

    El director de cámaras a los leones.

  • @alanbash2921
    @alanbash2921 5 років тому

    Showing emotion in Schoenberg ?........ It's time for ROOM 101

    • @untilted9126
      @untilted9126 5 років тому

      at least 0:23-0:30 sounds beautiful lol

  • @zweiosterei
    @zweiosterei 7 років тому +2

    Schoenberg >>>>>>>> Chopin

  • @ComtedeMonteC
    @ComtedeMonteC 10 років тому +8

    This is certainly a very good performance but I find it better to listen to it without the video as this girl's mannerisms I find annoying. Nonetheless, a very good performance.

    • @baldrbraa
      @baldrbraa 3 роки тому

      I worry about her back though, if she keeps arching it like that for years to come.

  • @MagierMondMax
    @MagierMondMax 9 років тому +4

    Very interesting and for this type of music very nice composed. But I really do think, that this is nothing against romantic geniuses like Liszt or Chopin. Even with new kinds of cadence, articulation and the players expression Schoenbergs compositions won't achieve that level.
    It's just "interesting", nothing more.

    • @MagierMondMax
      @MagierMondMax 9 років тому

      *****
      Yes, I know. But, as I said, it's just "interesting" and a musical experiment. You can't revolutionize music with maths. There have to be harmonies and repetitions. And Di Wus extreme agitations do not avoid this unasthetic music. But please don't understand me wrong. Im a great fan of musical expreiments and the idea of expressionism. But in my opinion expressionism has failed.

    • @williamgriebenow3426
      @williamgriebenow3426 9 років тому +1

      Without a doubt, I do see your point, some of the Modernist (even Impressionist) piano pieces were too much of a concept or just an idea instead of a product.
      Unlike composers ("composers") like Brian Ferneuhough though, we know that Schönberg was a genius, just listen to his Gurre-Lieder!

    • @PiEndsWith0
      @PiEndsWith0 9 років тому +2

      +Gum Monster Drei Klavierstücke were neither 12-tone nor serial ;)

    • @PiEndsWith0
      @PiEndsWith0 9 років тому +5

      +MagierMondMax I never understood this type of criticism of Schönberg. Sometimes the emotions can become too powerful and threaten to just go berserk... I'd understand that. But claiming it's just "interesting", as in non-emotional, just rational, purely mathematical... I don't understand. It's like criticising Mozart for heavy-handedness, Bach for over-simplifying his harmonic procedures or Mahler for making his themes superfluously over-complicated.

    • @zweiosterei
      @zweiosterei 7 років тому

      Music isn’t a competition. Every piece and composer has its own charm.

  • @Melpheos1er
    @Melpheos1er 8 років тому +16

    Come'on this is ridiculous. Schoenberg was a con artist. There is nothing musical in that kind of shit. This is just a bunch of note put in random order.
    You can replace any note by another one without knowing if it's "correct" or not.
    Actualy, she could have played the whole tune with a false note (according to the partition) every two or three notes and noone would realize

    • @chillyperson23
      @chillyperson23 8 років тому +12

      Listen to someone else play this piece and you'll see that it's not just random notes. It was carefully written and played. Of course there will be slight differences every time it's played. Timing, note lengths, pauses, etc, and maybe a few notes different here or there just cuz it's complex. Look at the sheet music for this. Atonal music ftw!

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 8 років тому +1

      "ou can replace any note by another one without knowing if it's "correct" or not." Exactly right.

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 8 років тому +2

      If you think this is great, you have no ear for music. Sorry, but that's the truth.

    • @jaspernatchez
      @jaspernatchez 7 років тому

      Thanks, Urb, but I'm beginning to think Francois is right. I can't change the world on YT comments. I think I'm done with them.

    • @Melpheos1er
      @Melpheos1er 7 років тому +2

      Maybe depressed or suicidal people find it beautifull, otherwise ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

  • @WilfredIvanhoe
    @WilfredIvanhoe 7 років тому

    I'm not sure what do people see (or hear) in the complete mess of tunes that's called atonal "music", or in even worse crap that passes as "art" these days.
    "Emperor's new clothes" syndrome, most likely; the need to feel like a special snowflake intellectual is so strong that one supports even an obvious fraud if it gives a chance to snort at the plebs who "don't understand", even though there is, in reality, nothing to understand at all.
    Either that, or underlying schitzophrenia; a messed up mind responding to messed up tunes.
    I'm sure the pianist has put a lot of effort into learning this. But what's the point when I could just sit a 3-year old, or even an orangutang next to a piano, record the playing, transfer it into notation and call it Schönberg's lost masterpiece, played by a talented young artist wishing to remain unknown for now? Not a single one of you who are praising this stuff would be able to tell the difference. A musical "Socal affair" would be incredibly easy to pull off.

    • @patrickbarrus8315
      @patrickbarrus8315 5 років тому +1

      Schoenberg would probably love this comment

    • @user-ef4de6ds6f
      @user-ef4de6ds6f 4 роки тому

      of course we would be able to tell the different because when you look at schoenberg's elements he incorporates in his pieces, you can start to see patterns and repetition. Compared to randomly putting notes on a page, you cannot see any patterns because the notes do not follow any path. Please get out of your tonal mindset

    • @yat_ii
      @yat_ii Місяць тому

      it is not true at alll... schoenberg's music is very expressive, and it is much easier to understand than people make it out to be...