Richard Wagner - Siegfried Idyll

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 189

  • @therealrealludwigvanbeethoven
    @therealrealludwigvanbeethoven 2 роки тому +18

    That ending...
    It teems with drama, suspense, and gratification in such an inimitably delightful way!

  • @lyricsronen
    @lyricsronen 5 років тому +24

    Wow what an incredible piece! So much beauty and longing. You can see here the extent of Wagner's understanding of harmony and its effect on the listener. The phrase that always brings me to tears is starting from 1:00, finally resting at 1:18. What a gorgeous 9th!

  • @zaftra
    @zaftra 5 років тому +55

    Never ceases to amaze how simple this music looks on a score.

    • @JeanPaul-Hol65
      @JeanPaul-Hol65 4 роки тому +15

      And yet, how beautiful it is!

    • @loveviolinespana9736
      @loveviolinespana9736 7 місяців тому

      Simple! Try to play😂😂

    • @charliegold3227
      @charliegold3227 4 місяці тому

      @@loveviolinespana9736looks can be deceiving

    • @aratinga77
      @aratinga77 2 місяці тому

      My orchestra is playing this at the end of the year. We are also playing Tchaikovsky 5th Symphony. This looks a lot simpler! It's hard to play something simple, though, without making a mess.

    • @GuruGuru3
      @GuruGuru3 16 днів тому

      Beeethoven's school, even Bach's. Wagner was the most economic on opera material there was.
      Wagner was so simple after all. He had very big help and he did the most of it. Light

  • @eugelmusic
    @eugelmusic 8 років тому +94

    Incredible harmony work. I'm amazed... Moment at 17:42 - 17:47 is like a heart of the whole composition, it is a painful pleasure! I love Wagner and i love how he accents moments of the most beautiful chord and intellectual tension. This music makes me shiver.. it is so human, so close, i'm happy through tears and crying through joy.

    • @leodreamguitar7463
      @leodreamguitar7463 2 роки тому +2

      Its just pure transcendental miracle of beauty and joy

    • @empanadasfritas7142
      @empanadasfritas7142 Рік тому

      " I'm amazed..." FU.
      Just shut up and listen.
      What do you even know about Wagner or Sigfride?
      You are traying to be so intelectual and you are just stupid.
      Just for once, shut up listen till you are 50 years old at least.
      Then we talk.

    • @empanadasfritas7142
      @empanadasfritas7142 Рік тому

      "most beautiful chord and intellectual tension" Dude? For real?!
      Do you even know who Wagner or Sigfried was or were?
      My man was building Movie Teathers on 1860S

  • @davidproudfoot9985
    @davidproudfoot9985 7 років тому +62

    What a birthday gift to receive. Aparently the trumpeter done rehearsals in the middle of a lake in order to no give the secret away.Fantastic story for a remarkable piece.

    • @markhughes7927
      @markhughes7927 5 років тому +2

      Wasn’t the trumpeter wagner himself? I seem to remember something like that - he certainly learned something unusual.

    • @Dreadpiraterabbits
      @Dreadpiraterabbits 4 роки тому

      @@markhughes7927 i think i remember that the trumpeter was a houseguest with them in the leadup to christmas.

    • @JohanHerrenberg
      @JohanHerrenberg 4 роки тому +6

      I think it was the horn-player, and it was Hans Richter, iirc, who was to become a great Wagner conductor.

    • @MaestroTJS
      @MaestroTJS 4 роки тому

      @@markhughes7927 The trumpeter was conductor Hans Richter.

    • @robertocannillo7057
      @robertocannillo7057 5 місяців тому

      ​@@MaestroTJS I think it was also the violist

  • @nagihcimekal
    @nagihcimekal 4 роки тому +19

    My favorite piece forever; it wrings my heart.

  • @corvinmatei2181
    @corvinmatei2181 7 років тому +37

    Absolutely fantastic. I am short of words! The details, phrasing, tension and expressiveness are very difficult to achieve. He knew what and how to get from the strings unbelievably. Impossible to match this! What a Master.

  • @VallaMusic
    @VallaMusic 9 років тому +31

    one of the most perfectly magical and beautiful pieces of music ever 2 my ears

  • @mrtchaikovsky
    @mrtchaikovsky 4 роки тому +52

    It is interesting to see how Wagner incorporated a few leitmotifs from the "Ring":
    The music at 0:21 is taken from the love duet between Brünnhilde and Siegfried at the end of "Siegfried".
    The sleep-motif from the finale of "Die Walküre" can be heard in the flute at 2:37, followed by slight variations; it returns in the oboe at 14:46.
    The horn plays a love-motif from "Siegfried" at 13:38 and reprises it at 19:52.
    The figure in the strings at 14:13 is a motif of bliss from the third act of "Siegfried".
    The call of the forest bird from the second act of "Siegfried" is used at 15:30, followed by its prophetic warning at 15:35.
    In conclusion, Wagner used motifs related to love, peace and nature, as one would deem fitting for a birthday present.

    • @pepijnstreng4643
      @pepijnstreng4643 Рік тому +3

      You say "taken from Siegfried" - in fact, Wagner wrote this 6 years before "Siegfried". So those motifs in Siegfried are taken from this piece!

    • @mrtchaikovsky
      @mrtchaikovsky Рік тому +4

      @@pepijnstreng4643 To quote Wikipedia:
      The composition of Acts I and II [of Siegfried] was completed by August 1857. Wagner then left off work on Siegfried to write the operas Tristan und Isolde and Die Meistersinger. He did not resume work on Siegfried until 1869, when he composed the third act. The final revision of the score was undertaken in February 1871. Performance was withheld until the first complete production of the Ring cycle, at Bayreuth in August 1876.

    • @pepijnstreng4643
      @pepijnstreng4643 Рік тому +1

      @@mrtchaikovsky well I'll be damned!

  • @tylerhannsz317
    @tylerhannsz317 3 роки тому +11

    5:20 makes me very emotional and then 17:40 makes me even MORE emotional

  • @TheodoreServin
    @TheodoreServin 3 роки тому +7

    "Ludwig" (1973) brought me here. There is a beautiful scene in the movie dramatizing that special birthday-Christmas, where an orchestra is really playing on the staircase of the mansion the family was living, and Cosima and her children are awakened by the beautiful orchestral music. It really captures the event wonderfully.

  • @emilkp3352
    @emilkp3352 3 роки тому +11

    No todo en Wagner es épica y grandilocuencia. También hay lugar para obras intimistas. El lado más desconocido de un genio
    Not all is grandilocuence in Wagner, there is also room for intimist works. The most unknown size of a genius

  • @JohanHerrenberg
    @JohanHerrenberg 4 роки тому +6

    Great performance of a very personal and magical piece.

  • @philipthonemann2524
    @philipthonemann2524 7 років тому +7

    Dear Olla, Remarkably helpful for my study of composition! Many thanks, as always. Philip

  • @cocoelane
    @cocoelane 3 роки тому +4

    thank you for your effort to make this video! perfect preparation for tomorrow‘s gig ✨

  • @diegeigergarnele7975
    @diegeigergarnele7975 5 років тому +8

    Great last seat dragging at 22:20 😂
    I can imagine Celibidache's face as this happened

  • @italia8705
    @italia8705 4 роки тому +7

    Amazing lovely pastoral sounds from the Great Wagner

  • @henrypark4356
    @henrypark4356 4 роки тому +4

    I have to play this song in for orchestra this year, and the score looks really simple, yet the song is so beautiful :)

  • @leonardosonn1205
    @leonardosonn1205 2 роки тому +1

    Geniale interpretazione !!! La migliore che abbia sentito.

  • @timotheuspeter734
    @timotheuspeter734 4 роки тому +8

    Celibidache‘s tempo is perfect for that kind of „reprise“ section from 18:46 onwards - I have never heard that descending clarinet more poignantly beautiful.

  • @arvstephenson1107
    @arvstephenson1107 7 років тому +7

    Truly inspirational piece of music.

  • @nandonizama7310
    @nandonizama7310 8 років тому +5

    Llega a tener especial y profundo sentido cuando conoces la génesis de tan bella obra.

  • @diegeigergarnele7975
    @diegeigergarnele7975 5 років тому +24

    The ending of this idyll gave me the feeling of a peaceful death after Mahler 2nd symphony finale

    • @zvezdinki7998
      @zvezdinki7998 5 років тому +1

      Die Geigergarnele what is idyll ? What it means?

    • @Operafreak9
      @Operafreak9 4 роки тому +3

      Oh yes Mahler's Second, a fitting companion to Wagner. Perhaps the only one.

    • @f.p.2010
      @f.p.2010 4 роки тому +1

      @@zvezdinki7998 something like a peaceful state (of mind)

    • @f.p.2010
      @f.p.2010 4 роки тому +1

      @@Operafreak9 nah, all Mahler symphonies apply

    • @zvezdinki7998
      @zvezdinki7998 4 роки тому

      Erinyien Phantasm if this is possible for Wagner

  • @plekkchand
    @plekkchand 7 років тому +2

    Thank you so much for uploading the score for this masterpiece. I am making a transcription.

  • @h.r.f.schotanus9654
    @h.r.f.schotanus9654 2 роки тому +2

    gespeeld in het Wagenings studentenorkest als concertmeester onder Dick Blokbergen in 1960-1961 mooie herinnering!

  • @williamfkoreniii9808
    @williamfkoreniii9808 2 роки тому +4

    From the soul of Wagner ... to the hands of Sergiu Celibidache ... we are brought into the arms of God!

  • @MaestroTJS
    @MaestroTJS 4 роки тому +3

    Regardless of what you may think of the piece itself, this has to rank as one of the greatest presents of all time, maybe THE greatest, especially when one considers the type of person Wagner was most of the time. Hopefully Cosima was appreciative!

  • @Dylonely_9274
    @Dylonely_9274 2 роки тому +1

    Gorgeous. Simply gorgeous.

  • @emanuel_soundtrack
    @emanuel_soundtrack 5 років тому +12

    measure 340 for ex. : the sound every composer tried to reach later

  • @philipkuttner7945
    @philipkuttner7945 2 роки тому +2

    Maestro, it's not slow ENOUGH--I'm still awake.

  • @nicholaslopez2185
    @nicholaslopez2185 7 років тому +2

    thanks for uploading

  • @emanuel_soundtrack
    @emanuel_soundtrack 5 років тому +10

    jumps of 9th on the strings, mediant modulation, we cannot employ it anymore like before...

  • @MrTheodicy
    @MrTheodicy 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for sharing

  • @hello-rq8kf
    @hello-rq8kf 2 роки тому +1

    Measures 330 through 350 have to be the single most beautiful 20 measures in all music

  • @andrewrichesson8627
    @andrewrichesson8627 3 роки тому +51

    If only Wagner wrote more orchestral works like this...

    • @christianwouters6764
      @christianwouters6764 2 роки тому +6

      Absolutely. I mostly regret when the singers become involved. It just doesn't sound right: shrieking and growling and one can't understand a word anyway. This piece shows that opera is better without the singers.

    • @leodreamguitar7463
      @leodreamguitar7463 2 роки тому +12

      @@christianwouters6764 lol

    • @mustysheep3977
      @mustysheep3977 2 роки тому +4

      @@christianwouters6764 it is still good when. in real life they sound a lot better. It is only the recordings where it fails and can sound screechy.

    • @chpnlzt
      @chpnlzt Рік тому +1

      @@christianwouters6764 - THIS IS A SPECIAL PIECE HE WROTE FOR HIS NEW WIFE FOR HER BIRTHDAY, AND HE WOKE HER UP TO AN ORCHESTRA PLAYING THIS AT THEIR HOUSE ONE CHRISTMAS MORNING, THIS WAS NEVER ANY PART OF AN OPERA, OR EVER HAD ANY SINGING - MYSELF I LIKE SOME OF THE GREAT OPERA ARIAS, BUT THE SINGING OF DIALOG IN AN OPERA I CAN DO WITHOUT, AND I KNOW WHAT YOU MEAN ABOUT THE SINGERS ....

    • @rominn2184
      @rominn2184 Рік тому

      @@chpnlzt ^ Why are you typing in all capitals?

  • @musik350
    @musik350 5 років тому +7

    19:50 Meistersinger

  • @innocenzobarrera1505
    @innocenzobarrera1505 5 років тому +3

    Bellissimo!

  • @ashleythorpe7933
    @ashleythorpe7933 2 роки тому +1

    20:20 Very similar to a passage in Mahler's Totenfeier

  • @originaltommy
    @originaltommy 4 роки тому +3

    It really is an extraordinary composition. I'm very fond of it and there are some moments that have me swooning. I think that was the intent? lol

  • @empanadasfritas7142
    @empanadasfritas7142 Рік тому +1

    Conduct minor string groups after 5 years in a conservatory and real love for Wagner this still my favorite. Wagner did this to Impress Nietche in some way. This is perfection even if you dont like it.

  • @stutti42
    @stutti42 9 років тому +4

    I wonder, and it is appreciated.

  • @АлександрЯрков-ш2з
    @АлександрЯрков-ш2з 6 років тому +3

    Браво гениально написано и сыграно

  • @clavichord
    @clavichord 5 років тому +5

    Wagner's Siegfrield Idyll and Celibidache conducting are a sublime combination. Celibidache may be unorthodox in some of his slower conducting at times... but you know.. I appreciated it... Celibidache is Celibidache. He forces you to concentrate on the details.

  • @thierryranger2230
    @thierryranger2230 6 місяців тому

    Wagner was the greatest , what a piece. 21:41 to the end... Perfection.

  • @moins_vif
    @moins_vif Рік тому +2

    Thanks, Larry David

  • @Tamadehenzhan
    @Tamadehenzhan 6 років тому

    nette Sendung, danke!

  • @papagen00
    @papagen00 Рік тому +1

    Happy Birthday Richard 🎉 🎂

  • @lawmain2864
    @lawmain2864 4 роки тому +1

    Oh my god, it's Sergiu Celibidache

  • @jamesnixon2243
    @jamesnixon2243 6 років тому +1

    Wilhelm Richard Wagner (Saturday 22 May 1813 - Tuesday 13 February 1883).

  • @amrahShsakaA
    @amrahShsakaA 4 роки тому +4

    Thank you Larry David

  • @sissiwang907
    @sissiwang907 4 роки тому +1

    The clarinet makes a few wrong notes at 8:12, maybe he/she forgot to transpose the score.

  • @gyuro7988
    @gyuro7988 4 роки тому +24

    I decided to choose this piece for a BRIEF analysis in my music class. I couldn't help but write a 1000 word analysis just for the piece. The entire piece of word (including Wagner's biography) was 2000 words. His music is surreal, especially this piece that contrasts with his other works. His life is the one thing that bothers me... what a horrible man to write such amazing music!

    • @truthfearsnoinvestigation
      @truthfearsnoinvestigation 3 роки тому +1

      A horrible man 🤔…
      Why because he knew and spoke the truth about a certain t r i b e?
      It’s the 21st century, there is way too much information that exists to remain in the dark!

    • @andrewnix6480
      @andrewnix6480 3 роки тому +5

      @@truthfearsnoinvestigation eat slugs

    • @arisowizard7178
      @arisowizard7178 3 роки тому +1

      @@truthfearsnoinvestigation like literally, phrases like these don't belong in this world at all!

    • @truthfearsnoinvestigation
      @truthfearsnoinvestigation 3 роки тому +1

      @@arisowizard7178 what the truth?
      The truth is only hate to those who hate the truth.

    • @segmentsAndCurves
      @segmentsAndCurves 3 роки тому +1

      Believe me, a good composer could be as a butthole as imaginable. That certainly doesn't change the fact that they are a good composer.

  • @GYMCENTRAL1
    @GYMCENTRAL1 5 років тому

    Wells Cathedral School Showcase Concert on Saturday 4 May 2019
    Chamber
    Music
    Thomas Nettle (conductor)
    Springtime highlights from the School’s specialist musicians’ performance programme, including a rare chance to hear Wagner’s ultra-romantic Siegfried Idyll @t​

  • @davidrehak3539
    @davidrehak3539 6 років тому

    Richard Wagner:Siegfried-Idill WWV 103
    Müncheni Filharmonikus Zenekar
    Vezényel:Sergiu Celibidache

  • @Lerkovac
    @Lerkovac 9 років тому +3

    Blijft mooi.

    • @clavichord
      @clavichord 5 років тому +1

      Wordt wakker met Wagners Siegfried Idyll en je dag kan niet meer stuk....

  • @LucasHagemans
    @LucasHagemans 4 місяці тому

    2:30 Sanctuary or Sleeping Brunnhilde

  • @bpogueg2
    @bpogueg2 5 років тому +48

    Larry David brought me here.

  • @emanuel_soundtrack
    @emanuel_soundtrack 5 років тому +3

    its silly how he makes me fell i lost the relation to the infinite

  • @JanCarlComposer
    @JanCarlComposer 3 роки тому +6

    Wagners style of music has often been copied but it is just impossible to live up to the original ...

  • @javierburgre2__147
    @javierburgre2__147 3 роки тому +3

    Im sorry were you whistling Wagner?

  • @s1cksadworld
    @s1cksadworld 5 років тому +1

    Where could I buy this? Sorry struggling to find :(

  • @rafa0086
    @rafa0086 4 роки тому

    Which is the chord played in 5:35?

    • @pedrofuster9161
      @pedrofuster9161 4 роки тому +2

      Looks like a c-sharp minor (the sixth degree in E major) with E on the bass(first inversion) and a suspension of a fourth on the melody (the F sharp)

    • @kallehed6330
      @kallehed6330 3 роки тому +2

      Yeah, it's a deceptive cadence, C# minor to F# 7 to G# minor(where B major was expected)

  • @shnimmuc
    @shnimmuc 6 років тому +24

    A wondrous work, perfect. I am ashamed that this man is generally avoided by the Mozart Bach people.

    • @clavichord
      @clavichord 5 років тому +7

      Is Richard Wagner avoided by Mozart Bach people? Or do you mean the conductor Sergiu Celibidache?

    • @andrewrichesson8627
      @andrewrichesson8627 3 роки тому +2

      Bach and Wagner are my #1 and #2

    • @moltovivace
      @moltovivace Рік тому +1

      ​@@andrewrichesson8627Same. St. Matthew Passion and Parsifal are the only works worthy to express God.

  • @jeffreymccray2856
    @jeffreymccray2856 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for posting this. I like the videos that help you to follow the score, but this performance is much too slow and overly indulgent.

  • @carl44acq
    @carl44acq 2 роки тому

    I've always wondered if Cosima stayed in bed for the whole thing.

  • @harryandruschak2843
    @harryandruschak2843 9 років тому +17

    Another of those musical history "what if". What if Wagner could have written more chamber music like this? (The original performance was with solo strings.) I for one would have been happy if he had written those instead of Parsifal.

    • @raticida123456
      @raticida123456 8 років тому +12

      Wagner has a very big spirit, chamber music can't handle it enough, this piece is very intimate, chamber music is enough for this piece and was a "special edition " for Cosima.. a lot of parts in the dramas of Wagner have chamber parts, solo parts, etc... he is very dynamic, he goes from the easy thing to the maximum. Parsifal was necessary to do contrast with his other works, you see die meistersinger and it's very popular, you see tristan and it's very romantic, you see the nibelungen and you see fantasy and mythology, now needs the epic medieval theme so you get parsifal.. for me is the best drama

    • @clavichord
      @clavichord 5 років тому +3

      In my opinion, Wagners greatest but not only creativity and influence, lies in his innovation and unique handling of ORCHESTRAL music.... perhaps this is taken for granted by the modern listener, but if you place yourself in Wagners time, many of the sound innovations he made had never been heard before..... so... yes he could have written excellent chamber music, but Wagner's greatness lay elsewhere and he knew it.... There are also those who claim Wagner should have written more symphonic work instead of Opera, but again, his Operas allowed him the discriptive vehicle to become as creative in music as he did.... so the "what ifs" come to a dead end and as a composer Wagner made the right decisions at the right time under the right circumstances.

    • @metacarple
      @metacarple 5 років тому +3

      Harry Andruschak If you listen to Wagner’s mature worka in detail you will find that long passages are indeed the chamber music for which you yearn. For example, listen to the Siegmund\Sieglinde scene near the beginning of ‘Die Walkure’ -after the storm opening, Wagner uses a clarinet, a viola, a cello and a horn for much of the accompaniment. Passages like this are scattered throughout The Ring, Tristan und Isolde, Die Meistersinger and Parsifal. The big, powerful sections are the ones most often segmented in concert but there is much which is smaller in scale, more chamber-like and more intimate. Dive in and enjoy!

    • @Operafreak9
      @Operafreak9 4 роки тому +4

      @@raticida123456 Parsifal was abolutely necessary for Wagner to complete what he had been saying throughout his career. It is a profound spiritual drama and Wagner was profoundly spiritual. He had to leave us the complete testament of his life's journey in music. Parsifal first occurred to him aas a drama in 1845. It was in 1882 he completed it and staged it. He knew, when he started he had alot to say before he could top of his lifework with Parsifal.

    • @ValzainLumivix
      @ValzainLumivix 2 роки тому +1

      Thank God he wrote Parsifal instead.

  • @Quotenwagnerianer
    @Quotenwagnerianer 5 років тому +6

    "Wagner had never intended to publish this work, but financial problems forced him to make it public in 1877."
    The man could never hold his money together. He should have gone and take an apprenticeship in accounting and finances with Verdi.

    • @tommot7755
      @tommot7755 4 роки тому +1

      He has built his own theatre you moron!

    • @williamstephens9945
      @williamstephens9945 2 роки тому

      @@tommot7755 He had to rely on his friendship with the king of Bavaria to fund it.

  • @park6877
    @park6877 3 роки тому +1

    2:30 4:10 6:22 9:53 11:43 12:56 14:34

  • @josemanuelmallo
    @josemanuelmallo 8 років тому +8

    Wagner in human form

  • @theFishy70
    @theFishy70 5 років тому +1

    13:35

  • @josiahrogers1728
    @josiahrogers1728 Рік тому

    13:37 oh my god

  • @originaltommy
    @originaltommy 4 роки тому +2

    He ain't no Mahler or Strauss but he'll do. Just kidding.
    Odious creature that he was, he wrote well, there is no denying that. Prelude to Tristan und Isolde is the height of Romanticism and utterly ravishing.

  • @camilohiche4475
    @camilohiche4475 3 роки тому +4

    Please watch this at the lowest quality only (144p) since it's just for the music, which is much more ecologically responsible than at a higher rate. Watching this at 240p (which is unnecessary for listening purposes), will increase the bandwith by double to almost tenfold! At 1080 the bandwith is augmented by a factor of 100!
    The use of digital technology accounts for 4% of the world's greenhouse gas emissions, as much as the emissions from the world's truck fleet. Of that, a BIG part comes from livestreaming videos, mainly 3 sources : UA-cam, Netflix and porn.
    Let's enjoy this beautiful music by being aware and responsible, doing our little part in decreasing our carbon footprint and protecting this wonderful planet for the generations to come.

    • @Kyle-ur4mr
      @Kyle-ur4mr 3 роки тому +3

      Take a bath I’m watching this in 720p

    • @camilohiche4475
      @camilohiche4475 3 роки тому +2

      @@Kyle-ur4mr So badass man.

    • @chadkrause6574
      @chadkrause6574 3 роки тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/lITBGjNEp08/v-deo.html

    • @kallehed6330
      @kallehed6330 3 роки тому +3

      Well, do you really think us, the youtube watchers, numbered in the billions should be responsible for the emissions of youtube? Shouldn't it be youtube's responsibility to use clean energy?

    • @camilohiche4475
      @camilohiche4475 3 роки тому +1

      ​@@kallehed6330 Who is at fault? The prostitute or the client? The drug dealer or the consumer? The guns dealer or the warlord? Well, actually, everyone involved is responsible of their own choices. You are not the one who decides youtube's energy supply strategy, but you CAN choose to watch a video at a lower resolution. There's no such thing as "clean" energy, what you need to understand is that the more the demand of energy is, the higher the stress on the environment will be in order to meet that high demand. Fossil fuels are used because they are extremely energy-intensive (much more so than any other energy source, even nuclear), so they provide enough energy for our high demanding energy needs. It is only by SEVERELY reducing our energy needs that these needs can be able to be met using only carbon-free energy sources.

  • @charlieprice3881
    @charlieprice3881 2 роки тому +2

    I bet Mahler secretly wished he'd written this. The Adagietto from the 5th to me is Mahler's Siegfried Idyll

  • @Danlovar
    @Danlovar 2 роки тому

    Sounds like "home".

  • @nicholaslopez2185
    @nicholaslopez2185 7 років тому

    can someone please tell me how i pronounce this phonetically?

    • @nicholaslopez2185
      @nicholaslopez2185 7 років тому +2

      the piece's name. thanks

    • @philipcai9499
      @philipcai9499 6 років тому +1

      seeg-freed i-dill

    • @Tokoloko
      @Tokoloko 6 років тому +2

      Wagner did nothing wrong seeg-freed ee-dill

    • @FleuveAlphee
      @FleuveAlphee 6 років тому +4

      Actually not seeg- but zeeg- ...

    • @Tokoloko
      @Tokoloko 6 років тому +1

      Oh yes, you are right... zeeg....

  • @음악감상용-r5w
    @음악감상용-r5w 2 роки тому

    ❤❤

  • @karipalacios7
    @karipalacios7 3 роки тому

    ❤💐🎧🌱

  • @BernardSAUSSAIE
    @BernardSAUSSAIE Рік тому +2

    *Nothing is worth the entire opera. I am always terrified at seeing people who are satisfied with Wagner extracts.*

  • @isaacmurilez6762
    @isaacmurilez6762 10 місяців тому

    9:28
    14:10

  • @kallehed6330
    @kallehed6330 3 роки тому +4

    I don't want to be mean, but Wagner, this piece is just... it doesn't go anywhere, it's just the same theme played over and over again, without any clear development. Like, I like everything that you wrote, it's beautiful, the hamony is longing and epic, the melodies are exceptional, but that's just one part of a composition. You have to do something with it you know, you have to have drama, the music should convey a story, it should be more than just beauty. This composition almost feels like a parody of your own music, like, how terrible can I make the music, while still making people like it, just because "oooh beatiful melodyy". Or maybe I'm just tired of hearing this overly romantic harmony, but idk, this music feels kind of shallow, it doesn't feel "real", it feels fake.

    • @j.masonbrown6216
      @j.masonbrown6216 2 роки тому +3

      Interesting take... What do you think of Strauss's "Metamorphosen"?

    • @kallehed6330
      @kallehed6330 2 роки тому +1

      @@j.masonbrown6216 Just listened to it for the first time, I liked it. It's kind of overwhelming, wish there was more silence, still has really great moments. Definitely has an effect on you like a good movie has with it's soundtrack, it definitely feels like a story, something bigger. Interesting Beethoven quote at the end.
      It moves you, though it kind of gives me a headache as well. I think Strauss should work on the balance, needs more soft parts and less forte definitely. Good piece though

    • @therealrealludwigvanbeethoven
      @therealrealludwigvanbeethoven 2 роки тому +6

      There's plenty of development in Wagner; not all music has to tell a story IMO.

  • @robertosolito1276
    @robertosolito1276 4 роки тому

    come può un anarchico scrivere certe cose

  • @xiao-dongwang3651
    @xiao-dongwang3651 6 років тому

    Too Slow, drags on forever.

    • @TheOneAndOnlyZeno
      @TheOneAndOnlyZeno 5 років тому +9

      Go listen to modern trash then.

    • @TheOneAndOnlyZeno
      @TheOneAndOnlyZeno 5 років тому +6

      @Asriel Meemurr Just telling the truth, sorry it hurts

    • @TheOneAndOnlyZeno
      @TheOneAndOnlyZeno 5 років тому +7

      @Asriel Meemurr Art is art, and modern trash should be in the bin where it belongs.

    • @95julius02
      @95julius02 5 років тому

      ​@@TheOneAndOnlyZeno proud of your own short sightedness

    • @TheOneAndOnlyZeno
      @TheOneAndOnlyZeno 5 років тому +4

      @@95julius02 Proud that I have standards and recognize Diamonds from a fake glass forgery.

  • @egee.sheeva6672
    @egee.sheeva6672 Рік тому +1

    If you had run into Liszt and Wagner when they had association and they invited you to join them for a walk or a dinner or a tree-full chat in the shade or by a winter fire hearth, then you would have had all the art genuine injected into you in those minutes that any (and I mean most who desired to be artists and realistically flatly failed to amount to anything with a subject 'muse) living romantic artist wanted-to-be could capture in all your life of struggle and failure...you would have had their forgotten moment. And would have traded all. ALL, for that moment.

  • @shaneheiden5448
    @shaneheiden5448 2 роки тому +2

    Larry David brought me here

  • @예신-n2s
    @예신-n2s Рік тому +1

    17:24

  • @unomagi
    @unomagi Місяць тому

    19:15

  • @connorjakob3482
    @connorjakob3482 3 місяці тому

    14:30

  • @NobuhikuObayashi
    @NobuhikuObayashi Рік тому

    18:37