Who's scarier: Game David or Show David?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 480

  • @emeraldvideos8d465
    @emeraldvideos8d465 Рік тому +8554

    Game david for sure, but show David is scary in a more um...real life way? Idk how else to put it lol it makes you uncomfortable or uneasy

    • @Drkloki-pb3ym
      @Drkloki-pb3ym Рік тому +206

      Think that goes to show how well the show is

    • @something_els3
      @something_els3 Рік тому

      Show David comes off very rapey and pedo like.

    • @termain655
      @termain655 Рік тому +142

      Yeah the show David is like creepy

    • @eggboy26
      @eggboy26 Рік тому

      he looks like a child predator, yes

    • @KapitanHazenhof
      @KapitanHazenhof Рік тому +28

      The show david is just like me he likes em underage😅

  • @Skankhunt21
    @Skankhunt21 5 місяців тому +2264

    Friendly reminder that David was a math teacher pre outbreak

  • @flipflop356
    @flipflop356 5 місяців тому +902

    The part when he suddenly goes from walking around and looking for you, to getting on his knees and crawling to hunt you was terrifying

  • @carbonas
    @carbonas Рік тому +3475

    Show david is creepier game david is scarier

    • @0xMrix0
      @0xMrix0 Рік тому +70

      That isn’t true AT ALL. game David got me shitting bricks while the show one just pissed me off

    • @conqueeruu
      @conqueeruu 11 місяців тому +67

      ​@@0xMrix0 there's probably a trillion reasons why you think that and why they think that so lets stop

    • @CraneOnaKrane
      @CraneOnaKrane 8 місяців тому +2

      Show David literally tried to malest her in a burning restaurant

    • @edbrown4800
      @edbrown4800 8 місяців тому +23

      @@conqueeruuthe game was just better in every way.

    • @conqueeruu
      @conqueeruu 8 місяців тому +15

      @@edbrown4800 not every, just a lot.

  • @illusion8457
    @illusion8457 Рік тому +4283

    show david was much more unsettling and memorable for me. Game david looked like a bad guy from the start.

    • @Dadordemiel
      @Dadordemiel Рік тому +77

      Like a real psycho that hides among the people.

    • @CraneOnaKrane
      @CraneOnaKrane 8 місяців тому +3

      Omg You guys just like the game versions a lot😂 he was better in the show

    • @TylerSchaper-rt2my
      @TylerSchaper-rt2my 8 місяців тому +24

      @@CraneOnaKrane Okay? So? Nobody said that but if they like game version better so what?

    • @obaso.
      @obaso. 8 місяців тому

      Other way around imo

    • @darkshadowgamingii
      @darkshadowgamingii 7 місяців тому +1

      Lol for me its the other way around

  • @RaiVer928
    @RaiVer928 7 місяців тому +124

    troy baker and ashley johnson cameo in the show was cool

  • @Heelfan21
    @Heelfan21 Рік тому +1531

    Show David bothered me more.
    He had a more comforting look to him, whereas game David looked like he could turn out to be crazy.
    Show David also spoke with a gentler tone imo

    • @josinboop6132
      @josinboop6132 Рік тому +47

      that's what makes him scarier imo

    • @Augustmama
      @Augustmama Рік тому +16

      Definitely. But both made me sick

    • @Editslovejazzy
      @Editslovejazzy 6 місяців тому +2

      He had me fooled 😂

    • @thearcanamodernau8130
      @thearcanamodernau8130 4 місяці тому +9

      That's the point. He's supposed to look like a decent guy to people who haven't played the game and then turn out to be a massive creep

    • @thought-full3445
      @thought-full3445 15 днів тому

      That's actually quite interesting, I thought the exact opposite. I felt off about both of them from the start, but show David just gave a bad vibe from the start, he just came across as a creepy person to me from the getgo, whereas game David for a sec or 2 at first actually made me doubt whether he could actually be an okay person

  • @benjahildebrandt2001
    @benjahildebrandt2001 11 місяців тому +362

    Gotta love the fact that they knew the story was great enough to not change anything at all

    • @Stitch-007
      @Stitch-007 9 місяців тому +19

      Very happy this didn’t ended up like Disney Star Wars etc

    • @jimmythedrum446
      @jimmythedrum446 9 місяців тому +16

      Bills town?

    • @Zack-bl2gg
      @Zack-bl2gg 8 місяців тому +35

      They changed quite a bit of the pacing, scenes, etc in the show that led to a different viewpoint at the end of the season, but the David thing they def kept super similar. It’s so creepy

    • @lickitysplit666
      @lickitysplit666 8 місяців тому +15

      sad that the casting is so bad

    • @sift954
      @sift954 7 місяців тому +24

      Bill and frank? Sam being deaf? Adding characters like the girl trying to kill Henry? Ellie's mom?

  • @ricksanchez485
    @ricksanchez485 Рік тому +833

    Guy in the show was creepy af

    • @hamzakucukugurlu
      @hamzakucukugurlu 11 місяців тому +11

      They literally changed the planned roles of David and James

    • @ziggymar
      @ziggymar 10 місяців тому +14

      Feel kinda bad that the actor can act like a creep so well😭

    • @Ronnieradkesteardroptattoo
      @Ronnieradkesteardroptattoo 9 місяців тому +4

      Fr

    • @toyo8460
      @toyo8460 9 місяців тому +2

      You lived in my house.

    • @Matt-wb8ni
      @Matt-wb8ni 9 місяців тому +8

      Agreed, the actor showed his range in just one role, one moment he genuinely seemed like a likable guy, then as time went on he just became scarier and scarier.

  • @JinWBO
    @JinWBO Рік тому +118

    Surprisingly, show David. Both are incredibly creepy and scary people, and game David looks way scarier, but show David is more deceptive with how less creepy his appearance is. We get more expansion to his character, not to mention we see how he is with his group, being very abusive towards his members. It also feels like he has more power over them, whereas the game, it feels like the group could more easily turn against David should they choose to.

  • @cwxgames468
    @cwxgames468 Рік тому +359

    show David has the "Unexpected" look/vibe to him. He looks like a guy trying to hold on to everything from the world before, Game David seems like he has come to terms with what he has had to do to keep people safe. but that is just me

  • @Maya_k
    @Maya_k Рік тому +665

    game david is creepier but both are scary enough lol

  • @aminer5649
    @aminer5649 6 місяців тому +28

    Game David had the implied vibes of SA but show David just tried to go for it on screen and was going to laugh while doing it

  • @samuraigames4125
    @samuraigames4125 6 місяців тому +15

    The voice acting in the game is so much better

  • @bibbo3167
    @bibbo3167 Рік тому +22

    Game David is openly unsettling
    While show David is unsettling, he’s hiding something, but it’s only a gut feeling, not his actions which make it more creepy and unsettling

  • @Killabear-en2xq
    @Killabear-en2xq Рік тому +47

    It's kinda crazy to see it in another form, on TV.

  • @MagicBullet574
    @MagicBullet574 4 місяці тому +16

    The Way Game David talks is much more unsettling

  • @1Gingerduckling
    @1Gingerduckling 5 місяців тому +19

    Game David chases you around and kills you in the game - players are already afraid of him by the time it reaches that last cut scene. They players find him scary because he attacks us. In the show, we needed to feel afraid of him but in a different way. the way he acts and the way Bella screams when he's attacking her just... Ugh 😭 he scares me

    • @user-mt4ks4su3m
      @user-mt4ks4su3m 5 місяців тому

      Being scared of pixels on a screen is CRAZY

    • @Max1mum0R1d3
      @Max1mum0R1d3 5 місяців тому +5

      @@user-mt4ks4su3mreally….? That’s your low grade troll attempt?

    • @user-mt4ks4su3m
      @user-mt4ks4su3m 5 місяців тому

      @Max1mum0R1d3 I'm not scared of a bunch of electronics behind a piece of glass, sue me

    • @1Gingerduckling
      @1Gingerduckling 5 місяців тому +4

      @@Max1mum0R1d3 eh, don't feed the troll. If he wants to go around commenting on clips from a horror survival video game and TV show like I'M NOT SCARED OF THIS let him

    • @lennaymaboyyy4848
      @lennaymaboyyy4848 14 днів тому

      @@user-mt4ks4su3m you can use that argument for anything. “nah I’m not disturbed by that photograph, it’s just ink on paper.”

  • @DJVideso
    @DJVideso Рік тому +46

    Game David, that freak runs up out of nowhere from behind you and stabs you right through the heart

    • @S4O.M
      @S4O.M 8 місяців тому

      You mean in the game?

  • @fancher00761
    @fancher00761 4 місяці тому +5

    Definitely David from the game literally he chases you down with the dang machete

  • @theforcer1762
    @theforcer1762 11 місяців тому +10

    No one can beat Nolan North

  • @Nameschino
    @Nameschino Рік тому +24

    Im so gutted the season ends this week😭😭😭😭😭😭

    • @justinmanning-vs5qg
      @justinmanning-vs5qg Рік тому +8

      Yeah but it’s already comfrimed they are doing a second season

  • @1stfire_shadow
    @1stfire_shadow 3 місяці тому +4

    Bella Ramsey girl did a wonderful job

  • @Blingblow_779
    @Blingblow_779 Рік тому +34

    Game David for sure.

  • @perfectpotatogaming4211
    @perfectpotatogaming4211 Рік тому +138

    Is that Troy?

  • @Qiuvox
    @Qiuvox 2 місяці тому

    Ashley Johnson is just perfect voice acting

  • @VivekYadav-ds8oz
    @VivekYadav-ds8oz 17 днів тому +1

    Game David eased you into trusting him through gameplay. We defeat an entire hoard including a Bloater with his assist. Then when he finally betrays it hits deeper. We don't spend a lot of time with Show David to trust him, but he looks more friendly so kinda achieves a similar effect anyways.

  • @BR4DS_D4W3
    @BR4DS_D4W3 Рік тому +6

    Love how troy is in this

  • @noodleolly3741
    @noodleolly3741 10 місяців тому +10

    Game over the show for everything lol

  • @alixtricity
    @alixtricity 18 днів тому

    “oh babygirl” 🥺🥺🥺🥺

  • @toniwinston5191
    @toniwinston5191 Місяць тому

    The game and the tv show made people emotional especially the people that played last of us 1 & 2 💯👍🏾

  • @joe0_0y
    @joe0_0y Рік тому +9

    Show david just had something unsettling about him

  • @yellowvoltage_
    @yellowvoltage_ 11 місяців тому +2

    Game David gave me trauma lmao. It took so many tries to get past his second phase.

  • @jillKirwan
    @jillKirwan 25 днів тому

    the fact that u made mike survive insane. it said online this was really hard to do

  • @juliansotelo6968
    @juliansotelo6968 8 місяців тому +3

    Troy baker playing the bad guys he slaughtered in the game

  • @TravisTalayumptewa
    @TravisTalayumptewa 7 місяців тому +1

    Game David. The show ain't the same in so many ways.

  • @ishownigas3980
    @ishownigas3980 2 місяці тому

    David was pretty chill

  • @raggyroo3184
    @raggyroo3184 16 днів тому

    game david bc that whole fight scene with the cabin on fire hunting ellie was terrifying especially his taunts and when he would disappear and surprise attack
    show david doesn’t even come close

  • @SakinaAhmad-k5h
    @SakinaAhmad-k5h 2 місяці тому +1

    Show David creeps me out

  • @theshadoweye3016
    @theshadoweye3016 Рік тому +4

    James looks like to be a David and David looks like to be a James

  • @Unkown-Army
    @Unkown-Army 8 місяців тому +2

    This prooves my point again, games like these look better than the real world

  • @octanehusky2634
    @octanehusky2634 7 місяців тому +1

    Game David easily, they tried to make show David a preacher or something? It didn't sit right with me because the was no reason to make him one in the first place.

  • @DogRobot101
    @DogRobot101 Рік тому +14

    Show David for sure

    • @komix1873
      @komix1873 6 місяців тому +1

      Game>show😉

  • @OGNabs
    @OGNabs Рік тому +14

    They’re both scary

  • @Deinotube
    @Deinotube 28 днів тому +1

    Why does james look in the show look more like david in the game

  • @fadingsolo9457
    @fadingsolo9457 10 місяців тому +10

    Nothing will ever beat the game

    • @komix1873
      @komix1873 6 місяців тому

      True

    • @Caschiba
      @Caschiba Місяць тому

      @@fadingsolo9457 yea the Game was way better

  • @damnedifido1062
    @damnedifido1062 8 місяців тому

    The survival by any means also applies to the Cordyceps fungus

  • @fyre_zenith
    @fyre_zenith 4 місяці тому

    Show David was way more unsettling but like to me they both looked incredibly unsettling from the start. Show David looked more creepy because he looked so calm and serene at first, but game David was creepy because he just looked like a bad guy who would go crazy at any second.

  • @destroy8842
    @destroy8842 29 днів тому

    They did such a great f*uckin job with this show. Shot for shot remake of the game

  • @ameliaflynnhayes
    @ameliaflynnhayes Рік тому +3

    Theses scenes were both pretty scary

  • @RogueJyn
    @RogueJyn Місяць тому

    It was easier to pin game David as a creep. But God damn, TV show David seemed nice at first, and it's low key scary how realistic that is. Cause you never know when someone turns out to be evil.

  • @Ahmad_-_-_Tarnished
    @Ahmad_-_-_Tarnished 4 місяці тому +1

    The Game IS Better ❤

  • @jackplatter1163
    @jackplatter1163 Рік тому +2

    The game will always be in my heart. 2011
    Edit 2013

  • @sylvesteruchia5263
    @sylvesteruchia5263 8 місяців тому +1

    This is one of those cases where its a tie.

  • @spaghettibird5135
    @spaghettibird5135 19 днів тому

    Game David will always sound like a South Park character to me he sounds so much like Matt Stone does as a lot of characters

  • @lucifermagne7458
    @lucifermagne7458 20 днів тому

    Show David was less subtle and therefore not as frightening to me. It felt like it was the writers going "hey this dude's a pedo", while the only time it ever felt that was directly shown was when he grabbed Ellie's hand. He was much more subtle and sneaky about his intentions up until that point, therefore he felt more creepy and real (which is unfortunate that it felt more real)

  • @LTS209
    @LTS209 Рік тому +23

    why do show David and James look like they swapped looks from the game?

    • @aizukimaude
      @aizukimaude Рік тому +6

      the show james was indeed the game david

  • @R4Y2k
    @R4Y2k 20 днів тому

    Would have been so funny if Nolan North had reprised his role as David in the tv show.

  • @dt7197
    @dt7197 22 дні тому

    Voice actor for the game Ellie was just so much better

  • @Engineering541
    @Engineering541 Рік тому +6

    GAME ALWAYS

  • @zaccampa4055
    @zaccampa4055 Місяць тому

    Game David is scarier for sure. Both are scary though, the show was cast so well.

  • @hsd287
    @hsd287 Місяць тому

    Troy Baker as James ❤❤❤

  • @jojostoenail2162
    @jojostoenail2162 3 місяці тому +1

    Game is always scarier

  • @ECNLGK_
    @ECNLGK_ 8 місяців тому +1

    That was my favorite episode

  • @michael56521
    @michael56521 2 місяці тому

    Show David looked more creepier where the game version looked more scarier

  • @Goober04853
    @Goober04853 3 місяці тому

    Show David’s appearance just looks like a cannibalism

  • @rickytricky57
    @rickytricky57 3 місяці тому

    Troy is so damn BADASS, even as a side character

  • @Vishalswami
    @Vishalswami 11 місяців тому +3

    Game David 100%

  • @NoCluYT
    @NoCluYT 6 днів тому

    It's kind of funny how the TV show was more "in your face" about the whole thing rather than using subtlety like the video game. Video games are often criticized for lacking subtlety and complex storytelling, but this here shows the opposite

  • @kozhinwolf7447
    @kozhinwolf7447 11 місяців тому

    Shows David was one of the best characters in entertainment history

  • @YaboiJokestr
    @YaboiJokestr 4 години тому

    In my opinion, Troy should’ve been show David, the appearance fits a lot more

  • @huntermielke12
    @huntermielke12 4 місяці тому

    Still felt like Troy Baker looks the part of David from the game though

  • @Snow_Eclipse13th
    @Snow_Eclipse13th Місяць тому

    I'm playing this part now and it scares me so much

  • @adarshsaseendran2199
    @adarshsaseendran2199 9 місяців тому

    Show David gives off creepy vibe. But have David feels like a friendly guy, that makes him more dangerous.

  • @Bro_wat
    @Bro_wat 5 місяців тому

    Game David felt more sadistic to me

  • @paulchiagoziem588
    @paulchiagoziem588 Місяць тому +1

    The is far better ❤

    • @Jkhorve
      @Jkhorve Місяць тому

      Agreed 💯 nothing better than the

  • @End0_YT_CHANNEL
    @End0_YT_CHANNEL 6 місяців тому +1

    The real life david looks like a really nice guy but the game…..SHEEEEESH

  • @THAT_girl-p6g
    @THAT_girl-p6g Рік тому +2

    Poor horse bro no one is even caring about that horse…..

  • @Pizzaface9331
    @Pizzaface9331 4 місяці тому

    David from the show is the creepiest David from the game is scariest

  • @joelhelms1455
    @joelhelms1455 Рік тому +24

    The game is so much better!

  • @Oliredwd9cm
    @Oliredwd9cm 10 місяців тому

    David in the game was scary but show was absolutely creepy

  • @annakronawetter5869
    @annakronawetter5869 4 місяці тому +2

    Definetly videogame elli🎉

  • @1012Games
    @1012Games 11 місяців тому +2

    The fact that they managed to make him even creepier

  • @blackwolfphantom6464
    @blackwolfphantom6464 9 місяців тому

    Im glad they went with the games scirpt

  • @SndjjwwejWdbbwene
    @SndjjwwejWdbbwene 4 місяці тому

    Show David is creepy while game David is sinister

  • @LeonXavier28
    @LeonXavier28 13 днів тому

    They need to recast ellie

  • @sceyth
    @sceyth 8 місяців тому +1

    Equally creepy. They got David right

  • @bell4889
    @bell4889 9 місяців тому

    Game David was worse for sure! Show David was just kinda creepy, game David was fear invoking.

  • @UnfazedPhoenix
    @UnfazedPhoenix Місяць тому

    Show David is creepier in a perv way. He gives off really strong perv vibes. Kudos to the actor lol. But game David is actually scarier

  • @aleenhamdan7866
    @aleenhamdan7866 7 місяців тому

    Both they really freak me out

  • @lakemasterex7582
    @lakemasterex7582 Рік тому +20

    Show david

    • @acanadian9776
      @acanadian9776 Рік тому +3

      Clueless.

    • @TheLokap360
      @TheLokap360 Рік тому +18

      @@acanadian9776Do different opinions upset you? Will you lose sleep tonight over this you think?

  • @KozmikyodaKozmikyoda
    @KozmikyodaKozmikyoda 5 місяців тому +2

    Why does elly look like an alien with a huge space between her eyes

  • @The509sfinest
    @The509sfinest 11 днів тому

    They casted the wrong Ellie

  • @tryeveryfandom1718
    @tryeveryfandom1718 7 місяців тому

    Fans: Are you gonna give david more background or are u gonna make him creepier somehow
    Show-writers: *Y E S*

  • @SAQSTX
    @SAQSTX 14 днів тому

    Ellie[Game]: perfect
    Ellie[HBO]: Big ass forehead

  • @randallchiasson3407
    @randallchiasson3407 9 місяців тому

    Show James looks like game david

  • @chrismayfield9240
    @chrismayfield9240 14 днів тому

    Game David, but show David did a good job

  • @evilkermit8104
    @evilkermit8104 Рік тому +1

    Show David, it’s implied in the game he’s a pedophile but I’m the show he basically says it.

  • @gianeirationgco5163
    @gianeirationgco5163 10 місяців тому

    Show David was way more scary and creepy than the Game David

  • @ImGMan17
    @ImGMan17 6 місяців тому

    Game David for me. He looks creepy and his voice is even creepier!!! Show David does not bring that same insanity.