I heard this symphony for the first time Friday, June 21, 2019, with the Milwaukee Symphony and now can't stop playing it. The trumpet solos are exquisite beyond words. I even had the honor of meeting John Adams when he came to Milwaukee a few years ago for the premiere of one of his pieces. I first discovered who he even was from the movie Shutter Island and now relish any opportunity to hear his music.
My wife and I were at this concert too! Crazy coincidence. We are listening to the Milwaukee Symphony do another one of his pieces right now - The Dharma at Big Sur
You read my mind! They didn't, but did you notice how Göransson's score evokes Adams' motifs constantly? I esp thought Trinity, Destroyer of Worlds, and Regret were undeniably taking nods from Adams. Also, if you see the movie, you'll notice some shots take after from the opera itself, including one of an agonizingly anxious Oppenheimer entering the tent with the test bomb, and the fact that Oppenheimer says to Groves, when asked to name the test, "Batter my heart, three-person'd God".
Otro de los genios que admiro profundamente. No puede ser que no se hagan sus obras en nuestro país. Una compañera de colegio que vive en Londres, hizo la puesta de Doctor Atomic, tanto en el Met como en Covent Garden. Antes filmó The Death of Klighoffer. Cuenta q'ens tan genio como lo es su música. Harmonielehre está entre las primeras obras que escuché, junto con Short Ride in a Fast Machine. Veo que esto es del 2007.... GRACIAS eternas x este espacio!!!❤
Gracias Roberto! Adams es un compositor que me gusta bastante, particularmente su magistral sinfonía "Harmonielehre" que es de mis piezas preferidas de todo el siglo XX.
Genial. También la tengo. A veces es cuestión de suerte con los bloqueos. Estoy subiendo ahora unos videos, programados para el 16 de Mayo, y todos los contemporáneos resultan bloqueados... incluso Franz Berwald (1796-1868), tampoco me dejaron... Espero tener mejor suerte la próxima. Esta publicación del 16 de Mayo quedará prácticamente nula de contemporáneos.
Terrific performance. A thrilling internal journey, lying somewhere between structure and aleatory, which offers a most rewarding and satisfying experience.
Not really the biggest fan of this piece to be totally honest, but it's nostalgic to listen to this piece having played it before some years ago, but i must say, from around 17:45 to the end is just incredible to me
As with the opera, the only part of this that moves me is “Batter My Heart, Three-Person’d God.” The rest is cacophony: random chaos, unrelated and disorganized dissonances, thrown together without a pattern or rhyme. Adams was better as a minimalist.
Listen more carefully. I played the opera when I was with the Metropolitan Opera. The music is well crafted and serves the story. I agree though, that “Batter my heart” is the highlight. Gerald Finley sang it magnificently.
Alert readers will notice that , after an entire year, neither @dogisgreat1 nor any other phony has answered my question. It is also worth noting that the successive compositions of John Adams have become worse and worse over the following years. I'd rather listen to the music of Jim Thirlwell than the Violin Concerto of John Adams.
I heard this symphony for the first time Friday, June 21, 2019, with the Milwaukee Symphony and now can't stop playing it. The trumpet solos are exquisite beyond words. I even had the honor of meeting John Adams when he came to Milwaukee a few years ago for the premiere of one of his pieces. I first discovered who he even was from the movie Shutter Island and now relish any opportunity to hear his music.
Great, I'm very happy to know this. Your enthusiasm is contagious !!!
Thank you very much for your message, Maria Kirylo!!!!
My wife and I were at this concert too! Crazy coincidence. We are listening to the Milwaukee Symphony do another one of his pieces right now - The Dharma at Big Sur
Hope this gets used for the trailer music for the Oppenheimer trailer (when it comes out that is). Has a very cinematic quality.
You read my mind! They didn't, but did you notice how Göransson's score evokes Adams' motifs constantly? I esp thought Trinity, Destroyer of Worlds, and Regret were undeniably taking nods from Adams. Also, if you see the movie, you'll notice some shots take after from the opera itself, including one of an agonizingly anxious Oppenheimer entering the tent with the test bomb, and the fact that Oppenheimer says to Groves, when asked to name the test, "Batter my heart, three-person'd God".
Otro de los genios que admiro profundamente. No puede ser que no se hagan sus obras en nuestro país. Una compañera de colegio que vive en Londres, hizo la puesta de Doctor Atomic, tanto en el Met como en Covent Garden. Antes filmó The Death of Klighoffer. Cuenta q'ens tan genio como lo es su música. Harmonielehre está entre las primeras obras que escuché, junto con Short Ride in a Fast Machine. Veo que esto es del 2007.... GRACIAS eternas x este espacio!!!❤
Qué afortunada tu amiga, Danse De Puck!!! Tengo también esas obras de Adams que mencionás.
Gracias por apreciar mi tentativa cultural.
Gracias Roberto!
Adams es un compositor que me gusta bastante, particularmente su magistral sinfonía "Harmonielehre" que es de mis piezas preferidas de todo el siglo XX.
Genial. También la tengo. A veces es cuestión de suerte con los bloqueos. Estoy subiendo ahora unos videos, programados para el 16 de Mayo, y todos los contemporáneos resultan bloqueados... incluso Franz Berwald (1796-1868), tampoco me dejaron... Espero tener mejor suerte la próxima. Esta publicación del 16 de Mayo quedará prácticamente nula de contemporáneos.
Terrific performance. A thrilling internal journey, lying somewhere between structure and aleatory, which offers a most rewarding and satisfying experience.
Thanks for your comment, Walshamite!!!
Agree 100%. I only wish the actual opera had been as dramatic [heavy sigh]. The libretto was a ball and chain around Maestro Adams' music.
@@sidneybarrett8941 :
I appreciate your comment, Sidney!!!!
The Laboratory 0:00
Panic 2:02
Trinity 16:36
Thank you very much for this addition, Mateusz Czarnowski. When I published this video I still did not indicate when each section begins.
Thank you for uploading
Moving and touching !!!!!!
Fantastic !
Struggente composizione.Trumpet solo part 3 sublime.Fantastico john adams .Maestro!!!
I'm glad you enjoyed this work !!!!
Thank you very much for your comment, Angelo Ravera!!!
oh yes, that trumpet solo!!!!!!!!!!! yes, shatter my heart.
OMG Shatter my heart indeed.
Thank you very much for your comment, Sam Lander
!!!
Or Batter, even!
Not really the biggest fan of this piece to be totally honest, but it's nostalgic to listen to this piece having played it before some years ago, but i must say, from around 17:45 to the end is just incredible to me
This is inspired by inasnity, and vice-versa.
I'm trying to understand modern classical, but this doesn't speak to me. It sounds too much like incidental music from a movie soundtrack.
As with the opera, the only part of this that moves me is “Batter My Heart, Three-Person’d God.”
The rest is cacophony: random chaos, unrelated and disorganized dissonances, thrown together without a pattern or rhyme.
Adams was better as a minimalist.
ok, boomer
@@dogisgreat1 If it’s “highly organized and packed with rhythmic interest,” what meter is the first minute in?
Listen more carefully. I played the opera when I was with the Metropolitan Opera. The music is well crafted and serves the story. I agree though, that “Batter my heart” is the highlight. Gerald Finley sang it magnificently.
Alert readers will notice that , after an entire year, neither @dogisgreat1 nor any other phony has answered my question. It is also worth noting that the successive compositions of John Adams have become worse and worse over the following years. I'd rather listen to the music of Jim Thirlwell than the Violin Concerto of John Adams.
@@KeithOtisEdwards Try listening to the timpani. What "meter" is the first minute of "The Rite of Spring" in?