In all fairness to Jennie, the repetition of a statement is the very definition of a mantra. Still, Rosé's success says a lot about her as an artist. And her album is a work of art from start to finish.
Rosé and Jennie are my only hopes..i wish Jisoo proves herself in her acting career if not singing career..Jennie has a lot of potential and talent and i want her to use all of it..Rosé ofc has proved that even after 12 years her ultimate goal is to make music and she is definitely slaying that..I wish Lisa releases more meaningful songs with a deep message that she wants to convey to the world..I really love Rosé as a solo artist because there is just something different about her..she wants to cut open her heart and pour out all the feelings and thoughts inside it in her songs..what i really liked about her is that unlike other artists who would make a savage and a badass song calling out haters, roasting them and how they don't care about the hate comments and stuff, Rosé didn't do that instead she shared her true feelings about the hate she got and turned it into a beautiful song that is number one girl, She wasn't afraid to show vulnerability and made sure to clarify the whole reason why she wrote this album which is her ex..Admitting that you have an ex in kpop industry especially when you are one of the most influential idols is a big deal but she didn't hesitate to tell her fans the true reason and meaning behind the album..I really respect her for that..This just shows how much blinks and music mean to her..
In my opinion Rosie is the biggest artist in BLACKPINK and I think she truly explores her passion for telling stories. I think Jenny right now she’s just having fun. I don’t think she’s lazy or trying to make a hit necessarily. I think she’s genuinely just enjoying herself and having fun with her music, I think Lisa is exploring and trying all these new things so that she can get to know herself better and I don’t know about Jisoo , but yeah.
It’s way too early to talk about Jennie and Jisoo when their albums aren’t even out yet. Mantra is like APT, a fun introduction to the album made to create excitement, not what the entire album will be like. At least give Jennie and Jisoo a chance to prove themselves before jumping to conclusions. Judge when their albums come out and they create more music.
I think after rosè I think jennie is most creative and I know her album will be good 👍 I know rosé and jennie are only artists can't wait for jennie album
Rosies APT was announced number 1 in the Netherlands. Finally beating Die with a smile, which was on number 1 for 15 consecuting weeks ❤ Congrats Rosie, so proud right now!!
fun fact: music isn't the only art in the world. Acting, dancing and performing are also a form of art. Also, rosie is the only member with an album out. In their time at yg, jennie rose and jisoo all had the same amount of writing credits. Give the others a chance atleast, Jesus christ.
that's false Rosé is the only member of Blackpink that had writing credits for their solo debut both On the Ground and Gone even reviews mentioned how she wrote on them all the other members had Teddy and the normal YG team hand them finshed songs Jennie continued this with You & Me and she does't even have writing credit on the remixes/live versions of those songs either. So no while under YG Rosé had 2 more writing credits than both Jisoo and Jennie she has long been the most credited writer in Blackpink and has never released a song she doesn't have a writing credit on. Under YG Lisa = 0, Jisoo = 2, Jennie = 2, Rosé = 4. Rosé has double the credit of Jennie and Jisoo so please stop lying to make them sound better give Rosé her respect because why do you have to lie to make the other members look better?
@@sonicyouth9992 "why do you have to lie to make the other members look better?" why do u have to make up assumptions and degrade other members to make rose look better? lmao
@ But it's fine to call Jennie the 'Ace' of Blackpink and Lisa bigger than Blackpink and kpop, Lisa can writer on her website that she 'trancends Blackpink' so to she says she surpassess Blackpink in music and fashion all that is okay but we call Rosé the true artist for being musician and the only member to take part in the writing of ALL of her music and we are the bad guys? Why is praise okay for any member of Blackpink but Rosé? Blinks voted for Lisa over Blackpink for an award but at Coachella a video went viral when a guy called Rosé the Beyoncé of the group they all got mad and said 'they are all Beyoncé' so LIsa and Jennie can both be praised about the group but not Rosé. Well don't go around read the mulitpe articles by The Grammy's that say just that. Grammy's wrote two article about how Ros set herself apart from both Blackpink and kpop as a whole. Jennie's the true Ace, Lisa is bigger than Blackpink, is okay but Rosé is the true artist is too far? well how about you stop using her voice to defend other members like when Lisa got caught in 4k lip syncing a born pink sound check who IP syncs a sound check? and what did blinks do to defend Lisa against Army and other stans? they used clips of Rosé's live vocals. she's fine when you want her for fans wars or to defend the group but if anyone actually praises her that's a problem.
@@jisoospatriotichusband This person is a long-time hater of the other members, especially Lisa. They use multiple user names/accounts to post nonsensical hate essays against every member (especially Lisa). I saw one of their other user names (the "v i r us") in another reply and guessed that "sonic" would also be here. Sure enough.... It's sad for Rosie what this person does in her name, which is basically constantly hurling insults at the other BP girls.
Agreed! Love all the girls but Rosé is able to show her individuality, depth and passion for this art through her vulnerable writing and vocal skills. Listening to Rosie was a rollercoaster of emotions I haven’t felt with the other solos.
To be honest, Jennie's mantra is about like empowerment, independence, self love and stuff, not just being pretty and rich. The song was released on international girls day, empowering the global girls, the lyrics stand out, and repetition might be obvious, her music was nice. It did pretty well, Also gained popularity in kpop and internationally Lisa's rockstar showcased like fame and stuff, and for new woman, it shows the women struggle and the hard life of a girl. It actually is a pretty good concept and gained alot of popularity due to the concept, lyrics and vocals. Rosé absolutely owned this year, APT was globally immensely popular capturing the ears and hearts of almost everyone, it got popular in almost every country. Toxic till the end was also very popular showcasing a story in rosé's life and it was loved by many, number one girl has to be the third most popular and it really was a nice song. The whole album was an A++
@@jennifferss yep, if that's what it's called. I'm not like you who blindly accept everything about Jennie, but I actually give honest reviews. But if you don't have brain cells, the difference is being biased about someone or not.
It's an interesting opinion. It's not a very persuasive argument, though. For one thing, the definition of "artist" you're using is not clear. Writing songs about personal torments and experiences is one category of art. It's definitely not the only category. Performing is also an art (that's why there's a whole category of art called the "performing arts"). Working with a team to create performances that combine music, dance and visual presentations is art. You also try to imply that because Jennie's and Lisa's releases did not reach the same level of global success as Rosie's "APT" that must mean that they're doing something wrong and not getting their "art" right. Nonsense. APT (which, not incidentally, features Bruno Mars, one of the most popular musical artists in the world) indeed has reached a global level of success rarely seen since Gangnam Style. That's wonderful for Rosie. She deserves it. But it doesn't really say anything about her merits as an artist versus Lisa and Jennie. It doesn't mean that Jennie's and Lisa's songs are now suddenly failures and fizzle-outs just because Rosie had a song that was more successful. It's great that you have an opinion and express it. It's just not a very well thought-out or logical opinion.
I would 100% agree with yoiu. Rose is the only true artist that her work will be listened to 10 years from now. Rockstar is nice, but nice is like saying it's okay. Lisa seems like a super nice person but her work will be forgotten I feel due to its lack of soul. I have zero clue who the other members are of black pink. Seriously you could replace them with anyone singing those songs and it would make no difference. But Rose songs have to be sung by her to have meaning.
To you people, artistry only count when it comes along with tears. Any one actually listening to the lyrics or mantra and new woman would actually hear a lot about lisa and jennies personal journey that is unique to them, but I guess that doesn't count as soul
You all are just ready to downgrad the other 3 members. Everyone have their own aura and style. Mantra, new woman and rosie album are all uniquely good. It just depends on your taste in music.
My honest thoughts: Rosé: Love her or hate her work, she is undeniably the only member in the group (perhaps of the few members along with Jennie) that actually respects music by giving the time and thought, of what she wants to express I respect her a lot and i think her album and her recent success has proven to many why she is an icon. You hear a Rosé song and you know it's her not only because of her voice, but simply her storytelling, her use of guitar and piano, she has so much passion that I am looking forward to see more of her solo projects. Jennie: Hated all her solo releases with a passion aside for Solo, but to be honest i feel like Jennie is still discovering what she's doing with her music, finding her colors,. I think her album will be kind of decisive on how I will see her from now on. I am both excited and a bit afraid to be disappointed, but even if i don't like, I genuinely respect Jennie. I disliked Mantra but I understood her vision, so I am waiting to see her full album. Also i feel like Jennie, just like Rosie, is the kind who listens to her fans so I am guessing that she has learned a lot since mantra, so i'm really looking forward. Ji-Soo: Disclaimer - I love Jisoo a lot, find her funny, charismatic and specially how amazingly cool she is. But in all fairness, Jisoo is your typical kpop idol. I feel like she isn't really cut or very interested in music. Sure she has a good voice, but i don't think she'll do anything groundbreaking in her next album. I see her like Nayeon from Twice, or Irene from Red Velvet - with a good company, a good team of producers and songwriters, and the perfect marketing she won't fail but I don't really hold many hopes otherwise. Lisa: She disappointed me time, and time again. It feels like she makes music just for the sake of chasing trends or for aesthetic purposes. It doesn't help that she has always been the worse singer of te group, and even though she took most of the rap parts in the songs, without Rosé, Jennie and Jisoo, her music feels empty and meaningless just as her lyrics. It doesn't help that her marketing team focused more in forceful gimmicks and heavy, almost aggressive publicity to have us listening to her releases so I admit my opinion of Lisa fell in this era. I like Lisa in Blackpink but I dislike Lisa solo career. I don't think I'll bother to waste my money on her.
Jennie already an artist... she puts her hand in everything that she doing from music to mv to fashion - arts are broader than just singing, art also can be collaborative (coming from a perspective of a designer) - singing is not the only thing, people should educate themself about art - performative arts are also stage arts
an artist is someone who can convey a deep meaning in their album, jennie just isn't doing that but maybe she will learn to in the future meanwhile rosé for example shows the different stages of a toxic relationship in the order of her album
i think it's too early to make videos like this it's not even fair really cause rose's the only one with an album we should prob wait before we make vids like this...i fear jennie will prove us wrong with her album she's been teasing for the longesttt and she's never disappointed when it comes to her solo's. I like some of your other takes though
I agree everything about Rosé.. I even like all her songs in her album. She did great in her solo. Lisa is experimental but as she saidshe just want to try different things and doesn’t care about awards..so maybe she is just trying to figuring things out and her fame I think is mostly because of her fans so I think she feels that whatever she release her fans will be in full support.
After I've watched all this, i conclude that the person who made this video thinks that an "artist" has to write about love to be concidered an artist, for me all 4 blackpink girls are artists in their own way and they thrive even more together, i enjoyed watching this video😊
see to be honest if we don't talk about her album. Rose had announced APT on the day itself without promotions like teasers and stuff which did not create an additional hype, she did not wear any 10-15 outfits [where people make literal videos about an artists no of clothes in mv] or anything, just a fun song for people to groove to, she did not hesitate to collab with male artist even tho she is one of the kpop most famous ggs, and the main part being getting Bruno Mars on her song was just iconic, she knew what her audience needed. tbh even is bruno wasn't in the song this song would have still blasted (no hate to Bruno Mars i love that guy). I thought initially that maybe rose will lack cause all her blackpink girls opened there own company, but she just signed contrated with yg's sister company and atlantic records but did that girl prove me wrong
becasue she's the only member of the group to have writing credit on all her solo songs, she was the only member that had writing credit for their solo debut under YG. Lisa, Jennie, and Jisoo did not writer for their debuts and instead had Teddy and the YG team hand them finished songs. Rosé even talked in Billboard and on Knowing Brothers how she had to fight for the songs she co-wrote YG didn't want to release them she was sitting at home crying when she got the call that YG would allow her to release her songs. Lisa told the story of how Teddy was playing her songs and she picked them saying the would be hers telling YG that's what she'd released and they agreed since they were Teddy written songs under YGs format. Even Billboard commented to Lisa that Rosé had a very different experience. Rosé fought for the songs she co-wrote while the other members just had songs handed to them. Jennie continued to have Teddy and team write for her having You and Me and both Solo Remix and You and Me Coachella versions both being written by Teddy and Team as well. Lisa has the least writing credits in Blackpink she's the only member do not write on any Blackpink songs. Rosé is the most credited writer in Blackpink even if Jennie and Lisa released 12 track albums where they have credit on all the songs (they won't because Lisa doesn't have any credit on Moonlit Floor so that's at least one song she didn't write on her album) so even if they both were to realse 12 track albums with credit Rosé would still be the most credited member in Blackpink pulse Rosé has 3 more songs coming in a delxue. I true artist writes their songs they don't have songs handed to them for them to perform. Rosé is the most credited writer in blackpink she even has composing credits and was excuitve producer for her entire album. She owns the masters and publishing rights. you'll notice on their credits Lisa and Jennie only have P rights so for the recording Rosé has both C & P she owns everything even the lyrics so that's why she is able to sell merch like number one girl shirts she gets the most royalties. So Jennie and Lisa started labels as a from of status while Rosé quietly opened her own publishing company so she could keep ALL the rights to her music Atlantic only distrubtes it they can't even sell merch without Rosé. So Lisa and Jennie opened their own labels to own less rights for their music. She sought out music producers and booked recording sessions independently on her own dollar and rented AirBBs, coming to terms with what she really wants to bring to the table, before finally signing with Atlantic Records. she did not utter a word of her hard work until everything was ready, shocking everyone with the announcement of a self-penned twelve-track album and the sudden drop of the mega-hit “APT.” She converted her emotional turmoil into creative expression, with all twelve songs exuding intimacy and vulnerability, while also demonstrating her ability to tackle diverse genres. ‘rosie’ is filled with catchy hits and emotional gut punches, but more importantly, with artistic grit and passion, Rosé managed to find a voice to blossom in an increasingly saturated industry.
@@thevirus8803are u slow. Lisa had written credit in one of her songs. Jennie is a member who has credits of songs like solo, you and me, solo remix, etc and jisoo too have writing credits. Let them at least release their own music before jumping into opinions
@@thevirus8803rosé stans are getting lame. Do u know the number of writers who helped to write each of the songs in the album? Or u just hate other 3?
I agree jennies mantra was repetitive, but i think the ideal meaning of it instead of just rich pretty girl would be independent and self focused woman, i also don't think her album will be a lack luster she's been really quiet lately and only giving us a few peeks of her album and even flew to mexico to film... no offense but i think she'll prove you wrong in the most positive way possible. Other than that great video and great research
Bro have you heard slomo by jennie ??and you can’t judge just by some songs you have to wait for the entire albums of them all to come out before judging
I will agree for now, but I also don't think it's fair to judge Jennie and Lisa before the actual album drop. Lisa's Album is very obviously her rebelling from a stagnant image, I mean the album is called Alterego implying she is showing lots of sides of herself which explains the genre jumping in her solo's thus far. While I can't see Lisa ever really be artistic driving force behind her music I do think in many ways it is her expressing the many sides of herself. Even if it's nt artistically solid I think for Lisa it's about doing new things and exploring new genres. Jennie though I am really not sure about, mainly becuase we have very limited details and only 1 solo, but everything she tends to release feel's like it is trying to push the badass image YG gave her all the way back in 2016, and honestly that image has never felt genuinely like Jennie, I'm not saying they are completely different, but Jennie has always felt like she was forced into this image when in reality she actually cares alot more about what other people think of her and that the comments really get to her. All I want from a Jennie album is for it to seem genuine and not forcing and image
Some YG BP MVs actually have good storylines, like Lovesick Girls and HYLT. In HYLT, each set connects to show being trapped in a “dark enchanted forest” or toxic relationship and trying to break free, aligning with the lyrics. However, the MVs and music feel repetitive, always following the same structure: verses, pre-chorus buildup, killer chorus, and a dance break. Jennie has the potential to make deeper songs like Rosé, while Lisa seems uninterested in emotional or relatable themes, which is fine. You can still be an artist without deep lyrics-Doja Cat and Megan Thee Stallion succeed through beats, not meaningful lyrics.
So basically “I didn’t like Lisa’s and Jennie’s songs, thats why they’re not artists”, I don’t know how people cannot realise how stupid this statement is. “Lisa’s forced releases” as if she wasn’t preparing them the whole year closely participating in writing and making the whole thing, “I like New Woman but it’s really just Max Martin, so let’s just discredit the fact that Lisa is one of the main writers of the song as well”, “Jennie has no actual depth in lyrics, she’s just pretty face” Listen to slow Motion, she literally wrote her part and the chorus of the song, that’s one of the most deep blackpink solo releases. Music don’t how to be in one way to be good, sad music can be good, catchy song can be good, deep lyrics are touching, fun lyrics are for fun. Rosie did amazing, same as all the girls, they all showed their passion for music, they want to write, they want to make music themselves, they’ve all been saying “this time is different cuz I’m doing more myself” and that what musicians are, creating your art.
True. Most of western artists songs about crying about ex or s6x ,that it. They act like everyone is singing meaning full in the world. Jennie mantra is good, maybe not great. But its too good for first comeback after she left yg. This video is just to make praise rose. Lisa new women is good but only problem with lisa is her live vocal. And lisa is not main writer for songs
@@Asdfghjjjk I think about how good Mantra is can be really subjective, that’s the song, some might be obsessed with it, someone can’t stand it, but one thing for sure, in terms of recording quality is objectively good, cuz it’s been recorded with Columbia team. About Lisa’s writing credits, it what ASCAP says, but I guess it might be different in other sites, but she participated in writing for sure.
The fact that you said that Jennie can't write a song about love is so funny, you're probably one of those korean men who got jealous Jennie wrote a song about women empowerment that didn't include them, that's not an unwanted opinion of yours but you're staright up missing the point of mantra
True. Jennie can write. But Mantra is not even about women empowerment. Its not that deep. Talking about girl is not always empowerment. Which korean male hate that songs😂😂. It was blink theories, when kbs banned her song for using brands names.
@@jennifferss no?? That korean men jealous about jennie empowerment songs is mantra. Blinks make that theory for mantra ,not for her new songs. Last line she said she missed the point of mantra
Rosé as a solo artist is becoming a global sensation. Rosie is a contemporary pop album written and recorded in L.A. so I don't understand the Kpop tag. It's an admirable statement from an artist just beginning to spread her wings.
I'm not sure yet what to think of most of the others' releases but tbh I'm more of a casual listener of blackpink anyway and have always admired rosé, her voice and love for music. I literally fell for her the moment I heard her 1st part in kill this love (my first bp song) and since then she's been one of my all-time favourite singers and musicians. So I definitely agree on her being the most musically-talented bp member. As quite a few other people have said before: She lives and breathes music and it makes me incredibly happy to see her achieve her dreams. 💗 Still, I'm always curious to get to know the other members better as well and see what songs they release! Personally, I was almost surprised on how much I like almost all of jennie's solos and 'new woman' by lisa (in contrary to many others I've always liked the vocal parts in bp songs more than the rap parts). Excited for all their new releases!
That’s why I could only agree on Rose to be announced as the real K-pop Queen. Sorry but Lisa has nothing to do with the title her fans gave her. Rosé is all rounded and the LESS harmful member of Blackpink equally with Jisoo who is as innocent as Rose. Rose’s stage presence is true and voice quality is better than the recorded one. She shows off her feelings and that’s why I can truly agree that she’s worth the title of K-pop Queen. Cause in my opinion the queen or king is chosen out of their talent and not the biggest and most toxic solo fanbase. Blackpink might be called the queens of K-pop but if we look inside it, Lisa is the last member to show the worth to be a queen.
This highly critical commentary is unpleasant due to its comparative nature and represents a solitary viewpoint. It is destructive by nature, rude and incorrect for over 100000000 listeners (Blackpink UA-cam @ 95mil is ranked 14 as the most subscribed to channel). It is dialogue at its worst and can be best described as hate speech, not constructive analysis. This type of dialogue can lead to ruination, depression, suicide, war, minx bitching etc etc and can ultimately result in lawsuit. It is the antithesis of what these Artists have contributed and will continue to contribute to the Arts.❤
Its weird to agree and say that because none of the blackpink members have released an OFFICIAL FULL LENGTH STUDIO ALBUM only rosè did that how about lets wait a month and say what you want?
If you say "Musician" (and even tho not so much good as she could be) I could, maybe, agree (Let's see/hear what Jennie will release in this year). But the only "ARTIST". I COMPLETELY AND STRONGLY DISAGREE! It's clearly a UNFAIR saying... If you want to say they are not good artists saying this, it's a thing. It's your opinion that I disagree but respect. But an artist is an artist being good or bad one. Lisa is better dancer which is a art. Jisoo is a better actress which is other type of artistic practice. Jennie I think is a little of each thing (and has been hidden her "treasure"). I think she would be better being a rocker (so I'm very exciting & curious to hear her album solo. I pretty sure would be very good ~ and shocking like she said it could be! )
agree with u……… i feel the soul and clear theme inside Rosè Album…… we see she is just simply enjoy her music which inspires the listener ….. hope our other Blackpink members can have clear goal . I have more expectations on Jennie coz she has multiple talents…. Can’t wait to hear there album very soon.
You saying that Jennie only tried when it came to the US performances is problematic. And she revealed in the documentary that she easily gets sick and she was not good at performing in heels. Let’s see how you dance in heels while also singing exactly like the studio version.😒 L opinion
As a Chaesoo bias, I'm not going to pretend say she's better than her. Each of the girls have what it takes to being an artists seeings everyone is into different things. There is no one way to be an artist. Now I would be open to seeing a video when the other three actually release an album or a body of work outside of being blackpink. Until its premature to say only Rosé will be an artist.
If Lisa doesn't embrace rapping she will not have much of a future outside of her current fanbase. Jennie is much more suited to be a pop star but she too should stay rapping is what they are best at. Rosé is the type of artist that can really stick around 10 20 years from now.
shes the only one who can sing but shes also the only with the MOST help considering all the labels shes now tied to then straight out the gate a ft from BRUNO MARS
uh oh definitely NOT! Lisa definitely has the most help considering her being linked with Frederick Arnault and her getting promotions with big western magazines, shows and artists nonstop without being a prominent figure yet in the western industry.
Lisa has Freddy buing her stages and spots on French Shows for singers. How is Lisa who has been slammed on nearly all her stages for lip sync going to go and tell people on a French show about singing? her rich French boyfriend got the job for her just like everything else. Also Rosé was smart instead of opening a label for staus she opened a publishing company so she could retain all the rights to her music. she has both P & C credits while Jennie and Lisa have only P. So Jennie and Lisa opened their own labels to own less rights to their music. As well Jennie is signed with Colombia and Lisa wit RCA both huge labels Rosé of course we all know rejected Colombia as that went viral her sitting down with the president for lunch Colombia tried to get Rosé but she wanted Atlantic instead. Warner/Chappell music signed her because she's a songwriter not a performer.
Good review. But you need to update your evaluation of Jennie's artistry after watching her new "Zen" music video, which IMO is the most artistic, most Avante guard mv I have ever seen in Kpop.
I thought Lisa was the most talented member in bp just by looking at her followers but now I know the most unpopular member Rosé is the most talented. Jennie second. I've lost all my hopes or interest on Jisoo and Lisa
APT was famous js bcz of bruno ik rose also worked hard for that but the credit goes to bruno and rose's stans also know that but they js wanna deny it and talking about the lyrics of APT i think mantra made more sense than APT and jennie too wrote the lyrics of mantra and her full length album have 15 songs which i think are absolutely gonna be a hit and what made it more special was that jennie wrote all her songs and u were wrong when u said rose have the most monthly listeners on spotify beating BTS but no this record was held by jennie before and not BTS. and same with jisoo i think that her album will be a hit too and u didn't mention jennies performances of mantra like she literally slayed those performances and sang the whole song live and danced energetically.
It's really premature to say that Rosè is the only artist while all of them have just started their solo careers . Jennie has the insane creativity and styles in mv, too . Despite APT, I liked No. One girls more .
When you said rosé perfected her mv and song on the first try unlike lisa, it sounded like a bad thing even tho it isn't, it's important to make mistakes and learn from them
She is not giving hate, she is only telling the truth. Eversince Lisa went solo, her name has been embroiled in many controversy. Stop labelling truth as hate.
@@compilations5515 She hasn't been "embroiled" in any legitimate "controversy". Because she's generally been the highest profile, most-followed member for years (and of course all the members are also super popular), she's always also gotten the most hate from people who hate seeing her at the top of anything. The "controversy" is mainly just haters saying stuff to make up controversies. You also can't say that this video maker's opinions are "the truth". They're just opinions. Rosie got Gangnam Style levels of success with APT (and only with APT). People who hate the other members are using that as an excuse to label Jennie's and Lisa's songs as "failures" or "attempts" (as this video does). That's of course nonsense. By any reasonable measurement, both Jennie's and Lisa's songs released so far have been quite successful...and as successful of any of Rosie's songs other than APT. If you don't like Lisa's songs or Jennie's songs, that's fine. Just don't pretend that saying that they aren't "artists" is "THE TRUTH" that everyone else has to accept.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N Stop being in denial. Lisa definitely needs to improve her live singing abilities because she wasnt only lipsyncing once, but all of her performances since she went solo were never praised. If you are a trur fan, you would want her to improve. Especially that her fans label her as the queen of kpop, yet she is always associated as a singer who always lipsyncs.
@@compilations5515 Your penchant for hyperbole is getting the best of you. She is not "always associated as a singer who always lip-syncs". That's mainly a bandwagon that haters have, with mixed results, worked overtime trying to pin on her. She has indeed used a backing track in her live performances (as do a majority of the performers who have performed at similar venues). She has combined live singing with the backing track and typically makes no attempt to lip-sync when she's not singing. The "gotcha" moments that the haters typically point to are the moments when the backing track plays and she is clearly not singing along. You'd be hard pressed to find moments where she is not singing live at all, but only lip-syncing. You also claim that "all of her performances since she went solo were never praised". Utter nonsense. It appears that you think that you represent everyone on earth when you make such claims. You can find people praising her performance in less than 5 seconds of honest searching. You can find examples of her singing live also. Of course YOU will say that anyone who ever praised her is delusional and in denial and anytime that she is obviously singing live she really isn't. Of course she could improve. Saying that doesn't mean your delusional hate campaign has any merit.
i believe that Rosé could truly become the biggest act buT mevv was nom for best artist at mama and atlantic was just called out for their inflation of accomplishments by buying them so her accomplishments are really still questionable until she steps out on her own truly.
Lisa has already 3 songs and 2 of them are literally meaningless, the third one is just a remake of other song, she can't sing, and she doesn't write, she's just a face and a body, cuz she dance. On the other side, Jennie can rap, she can't sing very well, but she has a style, maybe her album will be more authentic, but Rosé is the most authentic and original member of Blackpink.
Rosé’s debut effort was authentic and you can’t take that away from it. While all the other solo songs so far sound like blackpink rejects, Rosé came out the gate with something fresh and exciting like apt
@@Mushroom_foru im not a fan, but you can say easily that lisa is just a product, the girl is always lipsinging, she cant do anything else than look good and dance, her songs are just a joke.
@@Mushroom_foru Rosé is really the golden vocalist of kpop. Her voice and vocals are unique and such a great vibe. I hope 2025 is also Rosé's year. Jennie can shine too according to me. Lisa should make rap songs instead of these songs which she isn't able to sing live. On recent thai performance, Lisa wasn't lip syncing but backtrack was very loud. At least she didn't lip sync this time. I'm looking forward to Jisoo's. I really liked her flower and all eyes on me. Jisoo's second solo is on 14th feb on valentine's Day 🤭. Don't forget to give it a chance.
And look at Taylor, so successful. Laugh at your fave's live vocals first, because no matter how many albums she release, if she cant sing, she will always be remembered as worst lipsyncer. 😂
Well her APT song was only popular because of Bruno mars!..no hate to Rosie stating a fact plus the sound of that song is another interpolation of other songs!be original rosie!
@@compilations5515 You clearly are one of those weird solo stans who thinks that it's all a zero-sum game and you have to disrespect and hate on the other members in order for Rosie to be the "best" . You're not taking principled positions. Of course Rosie and Bruno share credit for the success of APT. You can't pretend that Bruno was irrelevant. But Rosie was of course also essential to the success of the song. Lisa doesn't sing live as fully or extensively as Rosie does. I don't think anyone would expect otherwise. (You keep claiming that she doesn't sing live at all, which is manifestly not true.) By contrast, Rosie doesn't put on much of a show at all, with regard to choreography, stage movement etc. That's fine with me. They each have their strengths. People expect Lisa to put on a whole performance that uses an entire stage, if not multiple stages. People expect Rosie's focus to be mainly on her singing. You don't have to disrespect one in order for the other to be the "winner".
@nafisanaheed6984 They try so hard to discredit Rosé and her songwriting skills. They are just mad coz their fave cant sing, and cant also write a song. 😂
In all fairness to Jennie, the repetition of a statement is the very definition of a mantra. Still, Rosé's success says a lot about her as an artist. And her album is a work of art from start to finish.
yeah true. the only part i disagreed to was jennie's. i think she is still exploring and can also become an artist.
Rosé and Jennie are my only hopes..i wish Jisoo proves herself in her acting career if not singing career..Jennie has a lot of potential and talent and i want her to use all of it..Rosé ofc has proved that even after 12 years her ultimate goal is to make music and she is definitely slaying that..I wish Lisa releases more meaningful songs with a deep message that she wants to convey to the world..I really love Rosé as a solo artist because there is just something different about her..she wants to cut open her heart and pour out all the feelings and thoughts inside it in her songs..what i really liked about her is that unlike other artists who would make a savage and a badass song calling out haters, roasting them and how they don't care about the hate comments and stuff, Rosé didn't do that instead she shared her true feelings about the hate she got and turned it into a beautiful song that is number one girl, She wasn't afraid to show vulnerability and made sure to clarify the whole reason why she wrote this album which is her ex..Admitting that you have an ex in kpop industry especially when you are one of the most influential idols is a big deal but she didn't hesitate to tell her fans the true reason and meaning behind the album..I really respect her for that..This just shows how much blinks and music mean to her..
New woman is a meaningful song
@YalidsDiary yeah..that's why it's the best one out of all three
@@roseateavocadoandbecameros7875 moonlit floor is not meaningless too it's an amazing love song
Why does everyone have to release meaningful songs??
@@Give_me_a_hammer I don't know you have to ask them
To be fair, Jennie's song called "Mantra" obviously it will be repetitive. It's waaaay too early to judge her musical ability.
yeah, especially listening to slow motion, i think there is great potential
@@aarushikishore1417 Yeah she recently said in a interview~
“She forgot being an artist while becoming a performer” or smtg like that
In my opinion Rosie is the biggest artist in BLACKPINK and I think she truly explores her passion for telling stories. I think Jenny right now she’s just having fun. I don’t think she’s lazy or trying to make a hit necessarily. I think she’s genuinely just enjoying herself and having fun with her music, I think Lisa is exploring and trying all these new things so that she can get to know herself better and I don’t know about Jisoo , but yeah.
It’s way too early to talk about Jennie and Jisoo when their albums aren’t even out yet. Mantra is like APT, a fun introduction to the album made to create excitement, not what the entire album will be like. At least give Jennie and Jisoo a chance to prove themselves before jumping to conclusions. Judge when their albums come out and they create more music.
JISOO'S ALBUM DROPS ON FEBRUARY!!!!! It could also just be a single but I'm hoping it's an album
stop..do not compare a fun lively song with a song where theres twerking. I love the song but I don't think it can be compared with APT.
@@starxaurelia APT is about a drinking game 💀 Don’t even start
I think after rosè I think jennie is most creative and I know her album will be good 👍 I know rosé and jennie are only artists can't wait for jennie album
Rosies APT was announced number 1 in the Netherlands. Finally beating Die with a smile, which was on number 1 for 15 consecuting weeks ❤ Congrats Rosie, so proud right now!!
fun fact: music isn't the only art in the world. Acting, dancing and performing are also a form of art. Also, rosie is the only member with an album out. In their time at yg, jennie rose and jisoo all had the same amount of writing credits. Give the others a chance atleast, Jesus christ.
Agree with you💯🤌🏻
that's false Rosé is the only member of Blackpink that had writing credits for their solo debut both On the Ground and Gone even reviews mentioned how she wrote on them all the other members had Teddy and the normal YG team hand them finshed songs Jennie continued this with You & Me and she does't even have writing credit on the remixes/live versions of those songs either. So no while under YG Rosé had 2 more writing credits than both Jisoo and Jennie she has long been the most credited writer in Blackpink and has never released a song she doesn't have a writing credit on. Under YG Lisa = 0, Jisoo = 2, Jennie = 2, Rosé = 4. Rosé has double the credit of Jennie and Jisoo so please stop lying to make them sound better give Rosé her respect because why do you have to lie to make the other members look better?
@@sonicyouth9992 "why do you have to lie to make the other members look better?" why do u have to make up assumptions and degrade other members to make rose look better? lmao
@ But it's fine to call Jennie the 'Ace' of Blackpink and Lisa bigger than Blackpink and kpop, Lisa can writer on her website that she 'trancends Blackpink' so to she says she surpassess Blackpink in music and fashion all that is okay but we call Rosé the true artist for being musician and the only member to take part in the writing of ALL of her music and we are the bad guys? Why is praise okay for any member of Blackpink but Rosé? Blinks voted for Lisa over Blackpink for an award but at Coachella a video went viral when a guy called Rosé the Beyoncé of the group they all got mad and said 'they are all Beyoncé' so LIsa and Jennie can both be praised about the group but not Rosé. Well don't go around read the mulitpe articles by The Grammy's that say just that. Grammy's wrote two article about how Ros set herself apart from both Blackpink and kpop as a whole. Jennie's the true Ace, Lisa is bigger than Blackpink, is okay but Rosé is the true artist is too far? well how about you stop using her voice to defend other members like when Lisa got caught in 4k lip syncing a born pink sound check who IP syncs a sound check? and what did blinks do to defend Lisa against Army and other stans? they used clips of Rosé's live vocals. she's fine when you want her for fans wars or to defend the group but if anyone actually praises her that's a problem.
@@jisoospatriotichusband This person is a long-time hater of the other members, especially Lisa. They use multiple user names/accounts to post nonsensical hate essays against every member (especially Lisa). I saw one of their other user names (the "v i r us") in another reply and guessed that "sonic" would also be here. Sure enough.... It's sad for Rosie what this person does in her name, which is basically constantly hurling insults at the other BP girls.
Agreed! Love all the girls but Rosé is able to show her individuality, depth and passion for this art through her vulnerable writing and vocal skills. Listening to Rosie was a rollercoaster of emotions I haven’t felt with the other solos.
That's a fact, Rosie is the best🎉
She will shine brighter this year
To be honest, Jennie's mantra is about like empowerment, independence, self love and stuff, not just being pretty and rich. The song was released on international girls day, empowering the global girls, the lyrics stand out, and repetition might be obvious, her music was nice. It did pretty well, Also gained popularity in kpop and internationally
Lisa's rockstar showcased like fame and stuff, and for new woman, it shows the women struggle and the hard life of a girl. It actually is a pretty good concept and gained alot of popularity due to the concept, lyrics and vocals.
Rosé absolutely owned this year, APT was globally immensely popular capturing the ears and hearts of almost everyone, it got popular in almost every country. Toxic till the end was also very popular showcasing a story in rosé's life and it was loved by many, number one girl has to be the third most popular and it really was a nice song. The whole album was an A++
twerking and revealing outfits is not empowerment and female feminism
@@starxaureliaavg jen hater☠️
@@jennifferss yep, if that's what it's called. I'm not like you who blindly accept everything about Jennie, but I actually give honest reviews. But if you don't have brain cells, the difference is being biased about someone or not.
It's an interesting opinion. It's not a very persuasive argument, though. For one thing, the definition of "artist" you're using is not clear. Writing songs about personal torments and experiences is one category of art. It's definitely not the only category. Performing is also an art (that's why there's a whole category of art called the "performing arts"). Working with a team to create performances that combine music, dance and visual presentations is art. You also try to imply that because Jennie's and Lisa's releases did not reach the same level of global success as Rosie's "APT" that must mean that they're doing something wrong and not getting their "art" right. Nonsense. APT (which, not incidentally, features Bruno Mars, one of the most popular musical artists in the world) indeed has reached a global level of success rarely seen since Gangnam Style. That's wonderful for Rosie. She deserves it. But it doesn't really say anything about her merits as an artist versus Lisa and Jennie. It doesn't mean that Jennie's and Lisa's songs are now suddenly failures and fizzle-outs just because Rosie had a song that was more successful. It's great that you have an opinion and express it. It's just not a very well thought-out or logical opinion.
Rose was always my favourite member; I loved her ever since 'On the Ground' and 'Gone'.
It's*ON* the ground
@@SanyaPunjabi Oh sorry mate I sometimes get confused
@The_Pigwidgeon Ok now correct it!
@@SanyaPunjabi okay!
I would 100% agree with yoiu. Rose is the only true artist that her work will be listened to 10 years from now. Rockstar is nice, but nice is like saying it's okay. Lisa seems like a super nice person but her work will be forgotten I feel due to its lack of soul. I have zero clue who the other members are of black pink. Seriously you could replace them with anyone singing those songs and it would make no difference. But Rose songs have to be sung by her to have meaning.
To you people, artistry only count when it comes along with tears. Any one actually listening to the lyrics or mantra and new woman would actually hear a lot about lisa and jennies personal journey that is unique to them, but I guess that doesn't count as soul
@@obianujuchinemelu5455 you are correct
There is only one Rose
Wait for the 3 of them to release their solo album and then you'll know
You all are just ready to downgrad the other 3 members. Everyone have their own aura and style. Mantra, new woman and rosie album are all uniquely good. It just depends on your taste in music.
My honest thoughts:
Rosé: Love her or hate her work, she is undeniably the only member in the group (perhaps of the few members along with Jennie) that actually respects music by giving the time and thought, of what she wants to express I respect her a lot and i think her album and her recent success has proven to many why she is an icon. You hear a Rosé song and you know it's her not only because of her voice, but simply her storytelling, her use of guitar and piano, she has so much passion that I am looking forward to see more of her solo projects.
Jennie: Hated all her solo releases with a passion aside for Solo, but to be honest i feel like Jennie is still discovering what she's doing with her music, finding her colors,. I think her album will be kind of decisive on how I will see her from now on. I am both excited and a bit afraid to be disappointed, but even if i don't like, I genuinely respect Jennie. I disliked Mantra but I understood her vision, so I am waiting to see her full album. Also i feel like Jennie, just like Rosie, is the kind who listens to her fans so I am guessing that she has learned a lot since mantra, so i'm really looking forward.
Ji-Soo: Disclaimer - I love Jisoo a lot, find her funny, charismatic and specially how amazingly cool she is. But in all fairness, Jisoo is your typical kpop idol. I feel like she isn't really cut or very interested in music. Sure she has a good voice, but i don't think she'll do anything groundbreaking in her next album. I see her like Nayeon from Twice, or Irene from Red Velvet - with a good company, a good team of producers and songwriters, and the perfect marketing she won't fail but I don't really hold many hopes otherwise.
Lisa: She disappointed me time, and time again. It feels like she makes music just for the sake of chasing trends or for aesthetic purposes. It doesn't help that she has always been the worse singer of te group, and even though she took most of the rap parts in the songs, without Rosé, Jennie and Jisoo, her music feels empty and meaningless just as her lyrics. It doesn't help that her marketing team focused more in forceful gimmicks and heavy, almost aggressive publicity to have us listening to her releases so I admit my opinion of Lisa fell in this era. I like Lisa in Blackpink but I dislike Lisa solo career. I don't think I'll bother to waste my money on her.
i was hoping for a video like this discussing how rosè is truly an artist but why is this so condescending to the other members
Jennie already an artist... she puts her hand in everything that she doing from music to mv to fashion - arts are broader than just singing, art also can be collaborative (coming from a perspective of a designer) - singing is not the only thing, people should educate themself about art - performative arts are also stage arts
an artist is someone who can convey a deep meaning in their album, jennie just isn't doing that but maybe she will learn to in the future meanwhile rosé for example shows the different stages of a toxic relationship in the order of her album
@@starxaureliaJennie’s new trailer is a big answer for you👌
@ girl i just saw the new trailer and its useless
@ definitely no she made art🔥
i think it's too early to make videos like this it's not even fair really cause rose's the only one with an album we should prob wait before we make vids like this...i fear jennie will prove us wrong with her album she's been teasing for the longesttt and she's never disappointed when it comes to her solo's. I like some of your other takes though
Yess
I agree everything about Rosé.. I even like all her songs in her album. She did great in her solo. Lisa is experimental but as she saidshe just want to try different things and doesn’t care about awards..so maybe she is just trying to figuring things out and her fame I think is mostly because of her fans so I think she feels that whatever she release her fans will be in full support.
After I've watched all this, i conclude that the person who made this video thinks that an "artist" has to write about love to be concidered an artist, for me all 4 blackpink girls are artists in their own way and they thrive even more together, i enjoyed watching this video😊
All four blackpink members are on fire...i dont care
why are y’all judging calling rosé the only artist when she’s the only one with an album out atm?????
It’s rly not fair on the other members
see to be honest if we don't talk about her album. Rose had announced APT on the day itself without promotions like teasers and stuff which did not create an additional hype, she did not wear any 10-15 outfits [where people make literal videos about an artists no of clothes in mv] or anything, just a fun song for people to groove to, she did not hesitate to collab with male artist even tho she is one of the kpop most famous ggs, and the main part being getting Bruno Mars on her song was just iconic, she knew what her audience needed. tbh even is bruno wasn't in the song this song would have still blasted (no hate to Bruno Mars i love that guy). I thought initially that maybe rose will lack cause all her blackpink girls opened there own company, but she just signed contrated with yg's sister company and atlantic records but did that girl prove me wrong
becasue she's the only member of the group to have writing credit on all her solo songs, she was the only member that had writing credit for their solo debut under YG. Lisa, Jennie, and Jisoo did not writer for their debuts and instead had Teddy and the YG team hand them finished songs. Rosé even talked in Billboard and on Knowing Brothers how she had to fight for the songs she co-wrote YG didn't want to release them she was sitting at home crying when she got the call that YG would allow her to release her songs. Lisa told the story of how Teddy was playing her songs and she picked them saying the would be hers telling YG that's what she'd released and they agreed since they were Teddy written songs under YGs format. Even Billboard commented to Lisa that Rosé had a very different experience. Rosé fought for the songs she co-wrote while the other members just had songs handed to them. Jennie continued to have Teddy and team write for her having You and Me and both Solo Remix and You and Me Coachella versions both being written by Teddy and Team as well. Lisa has the least writing credits in Blackpink she's the only member do not write on any Blackpink songs. Rosé is the most credited writer in Blackpink even if Jennie and Lisa released 12 track albums where they have credit on all the songs (they won't because Lisa doesn't have any credit on Moonlit Floor so that's at least one song she didn't write on her album) so even if they both were to realse 12 track albums with credit Rosé would still be the most credited member in Blackpink pulse Rosé has 3 more songs coming in a delxue. I true artist writes their songs they don't have songs handed to them for them to perform. Rosé is the most credited writer in blackpink she even has composing credits and was excuitve producer for her entire album. She owns the masters and publishing rights. you'll notice on their credits Lisa and Jennie only have P rights so for the recording Rosé has both C & P she owns everything even the lyrics so that's why she is able to sell merch like number one girl shirts she gets the most royalties. So Jennie and Lisa started labels as a from of status while Rosé quietly opened her own publishing company so she could keep ALL the rights to her music Atlantic only distrubtes it they can't even sell merch without Rosé. So Lisa and Jennie opened their own labels to own less rights for their music. She sought out music producers and booked recording sessions independently on her own dollar and rented AirBBs, coming to terms with what she really wants to bring to the table, before finally signing with Atlantic Records. she did not utter a word of her hard work until everything was ready, shocking everyone with the announcement of a self-penned twelve-track album and the sudden drop of the mega-hit “APT.” She converted her emotional turmoil into creative expression, with all twelve songs exuding intimacy and vulnerability, while also demonstrating her ability to tackle diverse genres. ‘rosie’ is filled with catchy hits and emotional gut punches, but more importantly, with artistic grit and passion, Rosé managed to find a voice to blossom in an increasingly saturated industry.
@@thevirus8803are u slow. Lisa had written credit in one of her songs. Jennie is a member who has credits of songs like solo, you and me, solo remix, etc and jisoo too have writing credits. Let them at least release their own music before jumping into opinions
@@thevirus8803rosé stans are getting lame. Do u know the number of writers who helped to write each of the songs in the album? Or u just hate other 3?
@@thevirus8803let the other members release the album at least duh
I fuckin hate how ya'll are downplaying Jisoo and Jennie in these comments.
Jennie's album will outdo Rose lets be real sis
fr real
I agree jennies mantra was repetitive, but i think the ideal meaning of it instead of just rich pretty girl would be independent and self focused woman, i also don't think her album will be a lack luster she's been really quiet lately and only giving us a few peeks of her album and even flew to mexico to film... no offense but i think she'll prove you wrong in the most positive way possible. Other than that great video and great research
Yesss❤
@Krish4a-wd6im yes you get what I'm saying! Ty ❤️
its just not my cup of tea
that is perfectly fine
Bro have you heard slomo by jennie ??and you can’t judge just by some songs you have to wait for the entire albums of them all to come out before judging
Frrr
isnt slomo the other artists song
@@PheracyMirageyes but Jennie has writing credits on the song
they were covering them as lead artists Jennie is the feature on slomo just like One of the Girls they are the other artists songs.
@@sonicyouth9992 slowmo is proper collab. She is songwriter too. She and matt make that 3yrs ago,cant release it. She herself said that
I will agree for now, but I also don't think it's fair to judge Jennie and Lisa before the actual album drop. Lisa's Album is very obviously her rebelling from a stagnant image, I mean the album is called Alterego implying she is showing lots of sides of herself which explains the genre jumping in her solo's thus far. While I can't see Lisa ever really be artistic driving force behind her music I do think in many ways it is her expressing the many sides of herself. Even if it's nt artistically solid I think for Lisa it's about doing new things and exploring new genres. Jennie though I am really not sure about, mainly becuase we have very limited details and only 1 solo, but everything she tends to release feel's like it is trying to push the badass image YG gave her all the way back in 2016, and honestly that image has never felt genuinely like Jennie, I'm not saying they are completely different, but Jennie has always felt like she was forced into this image when in reality she actually cares alot more about what other people think of her and that the comments really get to her. All I want from a Jennie album is for it to seem genuine and not forcing and image
Some YG BP MVs actually have good storylines, like Lovesick Girls and HYLT. In HYLT, each set connects to show being trapped in a “dark enchanted forest” or toxic relationship and trying to break free, aligning with the lyrics. However, the MVs and music feel repetitive, always following the same structure: verses, pre-chorus buildup, killer chorus, and a dance break.
Jennie has the potential to make deeper songs like Rosé, while Lisa seems uninterested in emotional or relatable themes, which is fine. You can still be an artist without deep lyrics-Doja Cat and Megan Thee Stallion succeed through beats, not meaningful lyrics.
So basically “I didn’t like Lisa’s and Jennie’s songs, thats why they’re not artists”, I don’t know how people cannot realise how stupid this statement is. “Lisa’s forced releases” as if she wasn’t preparing them the whole year closely participating in writing and making the whole thing, “I like New Woman but it’s really just Max Martin, so let’s just discredit the fact that Lisa is one of the main writers of the song as well”, “Jennie has no actual depth in lyrics, she’s just pretty face” Listen to slow Motion, she literally wrote her part and the chorus of the song, that’s one of the most deep blackpink solo releases. Music don’t how to be in one way to be good, sad music can be good, catchy song can be good, deep lyrics are touching, fun lyrics are for fun. Rosie did amazing, same as all the girls, they all showed their passion for music, they want to write, they want to make music themselves, they’ve all been saying “this time is different cuz I’m doing more myself” and that what musicians are, creating your art.
True. Most of western artists songs about crying about ex or s6x ,that it. They act like everyone is singing meaning full in the world. Jennie mantra is good, maybe not great. But its too good for first comeback after she left yg. This video is just to make praise rose.
Lisa new women is good but only problem with lisa is her live vocal.
And lisa is not main writer for songs
@@Asdfghjjjk I think about how good Mantra is can be really subjective, that’s the song, some might be obsessed with it, someone can’t stand it, but one thing for sure, in terms of recording quality is objectively good, cuz it’s been recorded with Columbia team. About Lisa’s writing credits, it what ASCAP says, but I guess it might be different in other sites, but she participated in writing for sure.
@@mystarjjshe literally wrote it these people just don't want to admit she is one of writers that's registered on every app
The fact that you said that Jennie can't write a song about love is so funny, you're probably one of those korean men who got jealous Jennie wrote a song about women empowerment that didn't include them, that's not an unwanted opinion of yours but you're staright up missing the point of mantra
True. Jennie can write. But Mantra is not even about women empowerment. Its not that deep. Talking about girl is
not always empowerment.
Which korean male hate that songs😂😂. It was blink theories, when kbs banned her song for using brands names.
@@Asdfghjjjkher new trailer was about woman empowerment
@@jennifferss no one speaking about her new trailer here. Its about mantra
@@Asdfghjjjk i just wanna said that she referred to it already
@@jennifferss no?? That korean men jealous about jennie empowerment songs is mantra. Blinks make that theory for mantra ,not for her new songs. Last line she said she missed the point of mantra
Rosé as a solo artist is becoming a global sensation. Rosie is a contemporary pop album written and recorded in L.A. so I don't understand the Kpop tag. It's an admirable statement from an artist just beginning to spread her wings.
I completely agree with you
Me personally mantra is an amazing song and one of my favorites and honestly most songs gets boring if you listen it on a repeat
isn't it too early to say? the other girls haven't even released their albums yet.
I'm not sure yet what to think of most of the others' releases but tbh I'm more of a casual listener of blackpink anyway and have always admired rosé, her voice and love for music. I literally fell for her the moment I heard her 1st part in kill this love (my first bp song) and since then she's been one of my all-time favourite singers and musicians. So I definitely agree on her being the most musically-talented bp member. As quite a few other people have said before: She lives and breathes music and it makes me incredibly happy to see her achieve her dreams. 💗
Still, I'm always curious to get to know the other members better as well and see what songs they release! Personally, I was almost surprised on how much I like almost all of jennie's solos and 'new woman' by lisa (in contrary to many others I've always liked the vocal parts in bp songs more than the rap parts). Excited for all their new releases!
That’s why I could only agree on Rose to be announced as the real K-pop Queen. Sorry but Lisa has nothing to do with the title her fans gave her. Rosé is all rounded and the LESS harmful member of Blackpink equally with Jisoo who is as innocent as Rose. Rose’s stage presence is true and voice quality is better than the recorded one. She shows off her feelings and that’s why I can truly agree that she’s worth the title of K-pop Queen. Cause in my opinion the queen or king is chosen out of their talent and not the biggest and most toxic solo fanbase. Blackpink might be called the queens of K-pop but if we look inside it, Lisa is the last member to show the worth to be a queen.
This highly critical commentary is unpleasant due to its comparative nature and represents a solitary viewpoint. It is destructive by nature, rude and incorrect for over 100000000 listeners (Blackpink UA-cam @ 95mil is ranked 14 as the most subscribed to channel). It is dialogue at its worst and can be best described as hate speech, not constructive analysis. This type of dialogue can lead to ruination, depression, suicide, war, minx bitching etc etc and can ultimately result in lawsuit. It is the antithesis of what these Artists have contributed and will continue to contribute to the Arts.❤
nah
Rosé is the best
Its weird to agree and say that because none of the blackpink members have released an OFFICIAL FULL LENGTH STUDIO ALBUM only rosè did that how about lets wait a month and say what you want?
If you say "Musician" (and even tho not so much good as she could be) I could, maybe, agree (Let's see/hear what Jennie will release in this year). But the only "ARTIST". I COMPLETELY AND STRONGLY DISAGREE! It's clearly a UNFAIR saying... If you want to say they are not good artists saying this, it's a thing. It's your opinion that I disagree but respect. But an artist is an artist being good or bad one. Lisa is better dancer which is a art. Jisoo is a better actress which is other type of artistic practice. Jennie I think is a little of each thing (and has been hidden her "treasure"). I think she would be better being a rocker (so I'm very exciting & curious to hear her album solo. I pretty sure would be very good ~ and shocking like she said it could be! )
agree with u……… i feel the soul and clear theme inside Rosè Album…… we see she is just simply enjoy her music which inspires the listener ….. hope our other Blackpink members can have clear goal . I have more expectations on Jennie coz she has multiple talents…. Can’t wait to hear there album very soon.
Rosé and jennie i like them the most and i think both have potential and singing abilities unlike jisoo or lisa
You saying that Jennie only tried when it came to the US performances is problematic. And she revealed in the documentary that she easily gets sick and she was not good at performing in heels. Let’s see how you dance in heels while also singing exactly like the studio version.😒 L opinion
7:22 i liked that line quite more than i should damn who wrote the script?
Rosé ofc
Iisa is still experimenting and finding her own style its too early to judge her lets wait and see❤
rockstar and isn't a bad song on its own, its just that lisa sang it bad, so it sounds soulless in the studio version
Its bad. Lyrics is random ,repitative and childish, only beat is good.
As a Chaesoo bias, I'm not going to pretend say she's better than her. Each of the girls have what it takes to being an artists seeings everyone is into different things. There is no one way to be an artist. Now I would be open to seeing a video when the other three actually release an album or a body of work outside of being blackpink. Until its premature to say only Rosé will be an artist.
Jennie's song is about Korean women!
No?? Its Generally about girls
@Asdfghjjjk well yeah, girls that are insecure! This song is too help them.
If Lisa doesn't embrace rapping she will not have much of a future outside of her current fanbase. Jennie is much more suited to be a pop star but she too should stay rapping is what they are best at. Rosé is the type of artist that can really stick around 10 20 years from now.
Random thought but I wonder if she would have the save impact if she wasn't blonde 🤔
shes the only one who can sing but shes also the only with the MOST help considering all the labels shes now tied to then straight out the gate a ft from BRUNO MARS
Jisoo and Jennie can sing too
uh oh definitely NOT! Lisa definitely has the most help considering her being linked with Frederick Arnault and her getting promotions with big western magazines, shows and artists nonstop without being a prominent figure yet in the western industry.
Lisa has Freddy buing her stages and spots on French Shows for singers. How is Lisa who has been slammed on nearly all her stages for lip sync going to go and tell people on a French show about singing? her rich French boyfriend got the job for her just like everything else. Also Rosé was smart instead of opening a label for staus she opened a publishing company so she could retain all the rights to her music. she has both P & C credits while Jennie and Lisa have only P. So Jennie and Lisa opened their own labels to own less rights to their music. As well Jennie is signed with Colombia and Lisa wit RCA both huge labels Rosé of course we all know rejected Colombia as that went viral her sitting down with the president for lunch Colombia tried to get Rosé but she wanted Atlantic instead. Warner/Chappell music signed her because she's a songwriter not a performer.
Good review. But you need to update your evaluation of Jennie's artistry after watching her new "Zen" music video, which IMO is the most artistic, most Avante guard mv I have ever seen in Kpop.
I thought Lisa was the most talented member in bp just by looking at her followers but now I know the most unpopular member Rosé is the most talented. Jennie second. I've lost all my hopes or interest on Jisoo and Lisa
Jennie is the most talented one
APT was famous js bcz of bruno ik rose also worked hard for that but the credit goes to bruno and rose's stans also know that but they js wanna deny it and talking about the lyrics of APT i think mantra made more sense than APT and jennie too wrote the lyrics of mantra and her full length album have 15 songs which i think are absolutely gonna be a hit and what made it more special was that jennie wrote all her songs and u were wrong when u said rose have the most monthly listeners on spotify beating BTS but no this record was held by jennie before and not BTS. and same with jisoo i think that her album will be a hit too and u didn't mention jennies performances of mantra like she literally slayed those performances and sang the whole song live and danced energetically.
It's really premature to say that Rosè is the only artist while all of them have just started their solo careers . Jennie has the insane creativity and styles in mv, too . Despite APT, I liked No. One girls more .
When you said rosé perfected her mv and song on the first try unlike lisa, it sounded like a bad thing even tho it isn't, it's important to make mistakes and learn from them
Please more ranking videos please, of groups etc.
Lip syncing is the only thing that ruined Lisa's 2024
Really ! Good promoting her😅
Why ??? Not underground ?
tell me u hate other balckpink memeber without telling : 💀
blah blah blah you should stop giving hate to the blackpink girls cause you like rose only, no one cares bout your reveiws😅😅
She is not giving hate, she is only telling the truth. Eversince Lisa went solo, her name has been embroiled in many controversy. Stop labelling truth as hate.
@@compilations5515 others members even don't release their solo album lol, it's so unfair to compare them too early 🙏🏼
@@compilations5515 She hasn't been "embroiled" in any legitimate "controversy". Because she's generally been the highest profile, most-followed member for years (and of course all the members are also super popular), she's always also gotten the most hate from people who hate seeing her at the top of anything. The "controversy" is mainly just haters saying stuff to make up controversies. You also can't say that this video maker's opinions are "the truth". They're just opinions. Rosie got Gangnam Style levels of success with APT (and only with APT). People who hate the other members are using that as an excuse to label Jennie's and Lisa's songs as "failures" or "attempts" (as this video does). That's of course nonsense. By any reasonable measurement, both Jennie's and Lisa's songs released so far have been quite successful...and as successful of any of Rosie's songs other than APT. If you don't like Lisa's songs or Jennie's songs, that's fine. Just don't pretend that saying that they aren't "artists" is "THE TRUTH" that everyone else has to accept.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N Stop being in denial. Lisa definitely needs to improve her live singing abilities because she wasnt only lipsyncing once, but all of her performances since she went solo were never praised. If you are a trur fan, you would want her to improve. Especially that her fans label her as the queen of kpop, yet she is always associated as a singer who always lipsyncs.
@@compilations5515 Your penchant for hyperbole is getting the best of you. She is not "always associated as a singer who always lip-syncs". That's mainly a bandwagon that haters have, with mixed results, worked overtime trying to pin on her. She has indeed used a backing track in her live performances (as do a majority of the performers who have performed at similar venues). She has combined live singing with the backing track and typically makes no attempt to lip-sync when she's not singing. The "gotcha" moments that the haters typically point to are the moments when the backing track plays and she is clearly not singing along. You'd be hard pressed to find moments where she is not singing live at all, but only lip-syncing. You also claim that "all of her performances since she went solo were never praised". Utter nonsense. It appears that you think that you represent everyone on earth when you make such claims. You can find people praising her performance in less than 5 seconds of honest searching. You can find examples of her singing live also. Of course YOU will say that anyone who ever praised her is delusional and in denial and anytime that she is obviously singing live she really isn't. Of course she could improve. Saying that doesn't mean your delusional hate campaign has any merit.
If jennie and lisa released a full solo album they’d lose their aura 😭 their “music” is better digested as events to “drop” for fans. Like MCU films.
Jennie has always good songs👌just listen slow motion,solo
i believe that Rosé could truly become the biggest act buT mevv was nom for best artist at mama and atlantic was just called out for their inflation of accomplishments by buying them so her accomplishments are really still questionable until she steps out on her own truly.
I will laugh at that video when the other members release their albums and actually put some originality and not Taylor Swift's leftovers from 2014
Lisa has already 3 songs and 2 of them are literally meaningless, the third one is just a remake of other song, she can't sing, and she doesn't write, she's just a face and a body, cuz she dance.
On the other side, Jennie can rap, she can't sing very well, but she has a style, maybe her album will be more authentic, but Rosé is the most authentic and original member of Blackpink.
Rosé’s debut effort was authentic and you can’t take that away from it. While all the other solo songs so far sound like blackpink rejects, Rosé came out the gate with something fresh and exciting like apt
@@Mushroom_foru im not a fan, but you can say easily that lisa is just a product, the girl is always lipsinging, she cant do anything else than look good and dance, her songs are just a joke.
@@Mushroom_foru
Rosé is really the golden vocalist of kpop. Her voice and vocals are unique and such a great vibe. I hope 2025 is also Rosé's year. Jennie can shine too according to me. Lisa should make rap songs instead of these songs which she isn't able to sing live. On recent thai performance, Lisa wasn't lip syncing but backtrack was very loud. At least she didn't lip sync this time. I'm looking forward to Jisoo's. I really liked her flower and all eyes on me. Jisoo's second solo is on 14th feb on valentine's Day 🤭. Don't forget to give it a chance.
And look at Taylor, so successful. Laugh at your fave's live vocals first, because no matter how many albums she release, if she cant sing, she will always be remembered as worst lipsyncer. 😂
Well her APT song was only popular because of Bruno mars!..no hate to Rosie stating a fact plus the sound of that song is another interpolation of other songs!be original rosie!
Hate her all you want, but that doesnt change the fact that she is more successful and CAN SING LIVE than your fave. 😝
@@compilations5515 You clearly are one of those weird solo stans who thinks that it's all a zero-sum game and you have to disrespect and hate on the other members in order for Rosie to be the "best" . You're not taking principled positions. Of course Rosie and Bruno share credit for the success of APT. You can't pretend that Bruno was irrelevant. But Rosie was of course also essential to the success of the song. Lisa doesn't sing live as fully or extensively as Rosie does. I don't think anyone would expect otherwise. (You keep claiming that she doesn't sing live at all, which is manifestly not true.) By contrast, Rosie doesn't put on much of a show at all, with regard to choreography, stage movement etc. That's fine with me. They each have their strengths. People expect Lisa to put on a whole performance that uses an entire stage, if not multiple stages. People expect Rosie's focus to be mainly on her singing. You don't have to disrespect one in order for the other to be the "winner".
@@TEAM__POSEID0N bro lisa can't even sing while standing.....
She literally lip syc in her "moonlit floor " song! !!!!
If rosé didn't write the whole damn song..... This couldn't have happened. ..... This success is 80% because of rosé
@nafisanaheed6984 They try so hard to discredit Rosé and her songwriting skills. They are just mad coz their fave cant sing, and cant also write a song. 😂
Well !! You will see if they're independent, I see Lisa more popular, more pretty, good dancer, smartest . Anyways they all good in the group.