What's the Best Tower Defense Game?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 січ 2025
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 153

  • @h2kwolfz572
    @h2kwolfz572 25 днів тому +56

    both are peak games. neither is better than the other

  • @angelquin1986
    @angelquin1986 25 днів тому +65

    bro this is the first time I heard someone calling battle cats a tower defense

    • @Rimuru_TheSlime
      @Rimuru_TheSlime 25 днів тому +2

      Bc it is

    • @ITS_MysteR
      @ITS_MysteR 25 днів тому +8

      What else could it be? Hero based shooter??

    • @Slushea
      @Slushea 25 днів тому +1

      @@ITS_MysteR I mean it's like, VERY far from how usual td games work despite being one.

    • @ITS_MysteR
      @ITS_MysteR 25 днів тому +4

      @@Slushea You save up money, send units to deal with a horde, upgrade random junk, go through all sorts of levels, grind for better things, get XP, and that’s why it’s a tower defense game. The only reason why people don’t see it is because it doesn’t look like a tower defense game.

    • @misterglo1394
      @misterglo1394 25 днів тому +1

      @@Slusheaso is PvZ but people still call it a tower defence

  • @MarcosAlvarenga-d8z
    @MarcosAlvarenga-d8z 25 днів тому +28

    As someone who plays both, they should get a collab. I nearly exploded in joy when I heard "Battle Cat" in the update 46 announcement video, only to find out it is Mattel's Battle Cat and not Ponos' Battle Cats.

    • @TimSkorbatiuk
      @TimSkorbatiuk 25 днів тому

      Yeah we need dart monkey in battle cats

    • @NC-oo7gr
      @NC-oo7gr 19 днів тому +1

      Lol me too I was like, 'BATTLE CATS COLLAB?!!?'

  • @linequeuing
    @linequeuing 25 днів тому +16

    Tbh you can’t rlly compare the two since bloons is actually more like the normal Tower defence people are used to (battle cats is a very different tower defence)

    • @Lario_bros
      @Lario_bros 24 дні тому

      Tbc its more like tower attack

    • @Lukaboy3335
      @Lukaboy3335 23 дні тому

      Yeah it's closer to clash of clans than bloons

  • @joearend1676
    @joearend1676 25 днів тому +53

    I play both, but battle cats is the one that really stuck

    • @MrCatz1
      @MrCatz1  25 днів тому +5

      i feel that bro same

    • @wooperdatrooper9171
      @wooperdatrooper9171 25 днів тому +4

      Same battle cats is more rewarding to play long term

    • @anglaispizza8179
      @anglaispizza8179 21 день тому +1

      @@MrCatz1 btd6 is just as grindy (maybe more so) than battle cats, btd6 also gets super boring quite quickly. alot of ur points were just bias and unfair to battle cats

  • @furballllllll7009
    @furballllllll7009 25 днів тому +8

    Imo the gameplay loop of bloons gets really repetitive very quickly compared to battle cats, along with the possibility to spend about 20 minutes on a run only to lose and have to start all over again

    • @ticket_puncher
      @ticket_puncher 24 дні тому +2

      No fr I'll occasionally go to play it than once I start playing I just get bored to death it's literally the exact same gameplay loop every time

  • @filippvarelis1999
    @filippvarelis1999 25 днів тому +6

    I personally prefer Battle Cats and feel like some of the points aren't very fair, for example the grindy nature of battle cats is annoying but you only really need to do it for the first bit of the game while if you play BTD6, you realize that it is a lot more grindy in general especially since a few achievements are just extremely grindy and simply un-fun

  • @meskonyolsen6657
    @meskonyolsen6657 13 днів тому +1

    Tower defense are so hella rare rn, aside from shovelware slop *"2 HP base vs 500 HP base",* Kingdom Rush reskins, stat stick TD reskins and Idle

  • @EpikGamer_123
    @EpikGamer_123 25 днів тому +5

    Spoiler alert it’s the game with overly violent mammals with a surprising amount of technological advancements

    • @owl365-guy
      @owl365-guy 22 дні тому

      good to know that my favourite td game is better

  • @conicthehedgehog9166
    @conicthehedgehog9166 25 днів тому +4

    i mean, both games have different aproachs to the tower defense genre, battle cats has a way more simple approach but that doesn't make it worse

  • @Number1BoraFan
    @Number1BoraFan 25 днів тому +13

    Btd6 is more repetitive

    • @sparchamp2
      @sparchamp2 24 дні тому +1

      @@Number1BoraFan I’m the number 1 bora fan

    • @Number1BoraFan
      @Number1BoraFan 24 дні тому

      @sparchamp2 i have his strengthen talent

    • @sparchamp2
      @sparchamp2 23 дні тому +1

      @@Number1BoraFan same

  • @zxnc324
    @zxnc324 25 днів тому +6

    in my opinion they're both equally as fun, also wher did the suit go

  • @sparchamp2
    @sparchamp2 25 днів тому +11

    I’ve been scammed of my Hiroshima vs battle cats video, I need a refund, I payed my entire life savings for this! (I am now 8 billion Zimbabwean dollar in debt pls help)

  • @joseplays1409
    @joseplays1409 22 дні тому +2

    This video is the embodiment of you trusting someone and they stab you in the back in my opinion mr cat makes realy entertaining battle cats videos and now btd6 is superior btd6 is a great game but c’mon his name is mr cat just keep making battle cats content plz

  • @Dsquarius_Green_Jr.
    @Dsquarius_Green_Jr. 25 днів тому +3

    Battle cats seems like it has way more. It has so many stages to clear and things to do, but btd is just grinding monkey money and mk until youre maxed then grinding the same stages to black border. Both are good, but grinding btd6 seems much more repetitive imo as a long time player of both. This is not to discredit btd tho, since i still play to grind collection events, bosses, and more and i also still play battle cats actively.

  • @SalmonRow
    @SalmonRow 25 днів тому +1

    As someone who grew up on BTD3 on coolmathgames, i prefer battle cats due to the variety of enemies.
    Variety of enemies helps give more gameplay styles which makes the game feel less stale

  • @kirbmaster9405
    @kirbmaster9405 24 дні тому +1

    Immediately started tweaking after the copyright strike, they are 2 different types of td it’s unfair to compare

  • @My_gatt_is_ballin
    @My_gatt_is_ballin 23 дні тому +1

    Honestly, they should just do a crossover. It would be the best.

  • @rafresendenrafresenden.1644
    @rafresendenrafresenden.1644 25 днів тому +14

    One is free the other needs money.

    • @EliBrosnan
      @EliBrosnan 25 днів тому

      So true

    • @MrCatz1
      @MrCatz1  25 днів тому

      that is correct

    • @yonkai9129
      @yonkai9129 22 дні тому

      Well it was free in the past or on specific dates

  • @averageidiot1612
    @averageidiot1612 25 днів тому +1

    Both are good. BTD6 requires a lot of strategy (and farming), however I like battle cats more, since there’s a whole lot of cats with different abilities, and yknow, the enemies fight back. Both have grinding in some way, so yeah.

  • @A.Bahumat13
    @A.Bahumat13 24 дні тому +1

    Mr Cat has started his Violan Arc😈😈😈

  • @SAPBTD
    @SAPBTD 25 днів тому +2

    Why is the thumbnail have btd6 Netflix edition

  • @KeebosWonderfullLittleWorld
    @KeebosWonderfullLittleWorld 19 днів тому +1

    Both are good

  • @Zealous0ne
    @Zealous0ne 16 днів тому

    Bro where did you get the initial idea to do this video? It comes out to feel like a "eh i like BTD6 better so let me build a vid around why I like it better" instead of "these games have parallels so lets do some (actual) research and discussion and decide." Asking Chat GPT makes not only the quality instantly drop for me, but also the credibility of the talking heads in the video. Could have been excluded completely and improved the video. The sound quality feels poor at a lot of points too. A lot of the "points" made are nonarguments that draw incredibly loose aspects of each game. There's no real Pro/Con list, the complaints are quite null and boring (aka "i dont like that JP is ahead" ???). The graphics is another nonargument. The Gatcha system isnt perfect by any means, but it creates a unique approach for players since they arent just spoonfed every tool. You can just play BC and get a majority of key units and some of the free ones are OP. The quality and idea behind this video just falls so flat.

  • @TimSkorbatiuk
    @TimSkorbatiuk 25 днів тому +2

    Wdym battle cats makes me suffer ,but in a good way🗿

  • @UntitledCreature
    @UntitledCreature 16 днів тому

    It depends on who is playing.

  • @Pika25-fw7fq
    @Pika25-fw7fq 24 дні тому +1

    Now compare Battle Cats and Plants vs Zombies with it being the OG tower defense game in all, and the Poster Child of all Gacha games, Genshin Impact and they’re both similar in characters.

  • @HectorHernandez-zu7ep
    @HectorHernandez-zu7ep 25 днів тому

    one is the best tradition tower defense game for mobile, and the other is the less traditional tower defense game.

  • @SAPBTD
    @SAPBTD 25 днів тому +1

    Also you said there was a trutiolal for every hero except ezile but Benjamin doesn’t have a quest too

  • @stormlord3389
    @stormlord3389 25 днів тому +1

    I don't agree with the idea of making BTD6 free. Battle Cats is like a much bigger game in like Japan, it's like a big thing there I heard and they might get a lot of money from those asian countries.
    BTD6 doesn't have that. I don't think people buy stuff from the BTD6 store. I just can't imagine that, but maybe I'm wrong.

  • @Sara-ef3tj
    @Sara-ef3tj 25 днів тому

    as someone really experienced in both in my prime top 50 consistently in races and multiple expert maps on chimps and for battle cats early ul i can say that from my opinion btd6 can be great tho it gets extremely repetitive and even frustrating later when you have to fight certain bosses on certain restrictions even tho yes it can be played in multiple different ways on a lot of levels you just do the same thing also one thing that u feel like i want to mention is how frustrating it is to lose 30 minutes of your time by either needing to log off when your going for black borders or simply by slight miscalculation on timings with chimps in harder maps

  • @Catinacan
    @Catinacan 25 днів тому

    3:24 i feel that having towers, maps, ect locked behind payed content is scummy. It could make a game pay to win. Not all payed added content is bad like elden rings dlc, bit for a game like bloons makes it feel more unfare like the pokemon sword and sheild with the isle of armor having the strongest pokemon locked behind a pay wall. Bloons is a game that makes you not regret the little money you spent on it, or if you have a Netflix subscription the game is free.

  • @The4Ham
    @The4Ham 24 дні тому

    We will be here again when battle cats 2 comes out because btd 6 is the 6th version when battle cats is still in its first version battle cats 1.

  • @Personwhoexists0701
    @Personwhoexists0701 24 дні тому

    As someone who owns both id say they’re pretty equal in how much i like them

  • @scottishhighlandersgaming
    @scottishhighlandersgaming 25 днів тому

    as a person who plays both regularly, it all comes down to personal preference’s. putting them against eachother isn’t all that fair, BC is more popular in Asian countries (atleast, i think it is anyways) and BTD6 is.. just BTD6. no regional popularity, it’s just a game for everyone i guess,
    great video regardless though!

  • @Doodlecorgi-qk8gi
    @Doodlecorgi-qk8gi 25 днів тому

    Battle cats is it’s own variant of td, battle cats is free to play and you can beat it without paying easily. As someone who bought btd, it STILL has payed transactions in there

    • @Mewtwo-d7r
      @Mewtwo-d7r 25 днів тому

      the paid transactions dont really do much (except double cash which is scummy)

  • @invader3456
    @invader3456 25 днів тому

    I played both a lot and with btd6 it always bored me in at most like a week, but battle cats has kept me hooked for months.

  • @eltonbokgren3398
    @eltonbokgren3398 25 днів тому

    Answer is both why do you need to choose.

  • @thingthingthingthingthingthing
    @thingthingthingthingthingthing 24 дні тому

    Btd have much more repetitive gameplay but has frequent updates to fix it

  • @stickey3476
    @stickey3476 19 днів тому

    Woah woah, a bad thing is that btd6 costs money? It "scared away good players"? Huh? How often does it go on sale, if not, totally free?

  • @hawgsicle
    @hawgsicle 23 дні тому +5

    this video is stupid.

  • @filippvarelis1999
    @filippvarelis1999 25 днів тому

    Saying battle cats gets hard only in late game is also very dishonest. My friends who casually play the game struggled on stages such as Alaska, Japan, even chapter 2 moon
    If you know a few strategies in btd6 the game is supremely easy in almost evey case

  • @CryptoscamInvestor
    @CryptoscamInvestor 17 днів тому

    Ok i don't agree with many of these takes that much but at least i can see where they're coming from. BUT THE VISUAL ONE IS SUCH AN ASS TAKE. I am telling you almost every player I've seen appreciates the uniqueness and effort put into the designs. Im sure a lot of people started playing the game just cause they thought that the designs looked funny. The sheer diversity and uniqueness of the designs is something that i think cannot even be argued for the game, and is easily one of the best parts

  • @clobzz
    @clobzz 25 днів тому

    i dont think people event view battle cats as a tower defense, its also not *that* casual friendly, to an extent, while btd6 is, and btd6 is also far more popular

  • @HaOmTECH
    @HaOmTECH 25 днів тому

    played both, while BTD6 only lasted a few months with me, battle cats has stuck around for 4 years now,
    BTD6 is just boring due to it's lack of content, devs there are actually more lazy than mojang.

  • @Char4810
    @Char4810 25 днів тому

    Should you play battle cats or btd6 in 2024?
    Me who plays both

  • @elgeneralmanitas
    @elgeneralmanitas 25 днів тому +1

    i just play both at the same time

  • @-Burningzilla_YT-
    @-Burningzilla_YT- 25 днів тому

    btd 6 has way,way more mechanics but simpler enemies while battle cats has less mechanics but has a lot of enemies and units variation and also both are different types of tower defence where one is you place towers and protect a way and other is you send your characters to destroy the tower and protect your own

  • @Roaming_flooper_MK
    @Roaming_flooper_MK 25 днів тому

    I've played both games and can say battle cats in my opinion is better. The game is more unique and makes you think harder in your options because if you play the game without any help, you won't know which cats are good or bad and you won't know how to better handle other enemies. Btd6 base game is much more casual friendly, and battle cats is more for people looking for a challenging game that lasts so much longer. Also, although you may see btd6 as better because of how you can play other people's maps and challenge others, if you play battle cats ultimate you can do the same thing. Make stages with your choice of enemies to make a fun and challenging stage. Both games appeal to different people, but in my opinion, battle cats is better

  • @NaLian605
    @NaLian605 25 днів тому

    A little fun fact. Battle cats is in btd6. Just look it up

  • @wackussbunguss
    @wackussbunguss 25 днів тому

    Honestly I've been playing battle cats for over 5 years now and currently in zl and I've only been playing btd6 for about 4 months but I've played it a couple of times before
    And I feel like both of them have their pros and cons and are equally good

  • @certifiedbingus
    @certifiedbingus 25 днів тому +1

    Im not spending a penny on any game😭except for minecraft...

  • @SamSand-b6r
    @SamSand-b6r 19 днів тому

    Battle cat is not a Tower defense

  • @Danielsuper-i2e
    @Danielsuper-i2e 21 день тому

    Dang how did bro know I play btd6 and tbc

  • @elbakuino666
    @elbakuino666 25 днів тому +1

    “Battle cats gets hard only at the late game” what about bun bun

  • @Echo.comicsGlennon
    @Echo.comicsGlennon 25 днів тому

    Two cast is the best tower defence game sure the monkey balloon game is very good about cats is more pure and unique with its attacks instead of just having the same balloons but stronger and stronger wildcat has a strategy of money different types of stuff

  • @hoglin7
    @hoglin7 25 днів тому

    Never played btd6 so i cant really say

  • @Aura_BCP
    @Aura_BCP 25 днів тому

    I'll be real some of the points you brought up just sound unnecessary
    "So one thing that's really bad about Bloons right of the bat is you have to actually pay 7$", ok and original PvZ costs about 4$ and despite being a casual game it's regarded as one of the best and influencial tower defense game, why is the price of a relatively casual game brought up while also saying that it's a light game not an MMO which i bet most MMOs would cost far more than just 7$ because they have much higher budget than a game costs 7$, and what kind of broke person would be scared of 7$ price tag, a person who can't even afford a cheap game wouldn't even go to steam in the first place
    When talking about gacha you brought up Ramen Cat and how someone might struggle if fhey dont get him early on, ok but how early on are we talking, if it's ITF then i don't think you would really stuggle early on without Ramen because Angels aren't really strong at that point and you will probably get him later relatively quickly since it's just a rare cat, also that one person who didn't get Ramen Cat, how impactuful would that argument be if it's just one person alongside 100 other people who at least have Rocker, it's Rocker Cat we're talking about a rare cat not some Uber
    The RNG in games is frustrating but you can't just outright say it's actually bad for the game, yes too much RNG is very bad for the gameplay but the right amount of it is just what makes majority of Battle Cats enjoyable, a lot of stages would be very similar to each other if jt wasn't for the RNG factor, for example Floor 30 is regarded as one of the best stage in the game and it does actually revoleve around some RNG when it spawns enemies, each run different player go through will be interchangeable because of that RNG factor, there's a lot of stages that have RNG to it and a kot of the time that RNG is needed to try and make a stage stand out
    I would also say something more about BTD but I never played any of the games, I did played it once but even then I don't recall it being as enjoyable as battle cats, mind you was much younger at the time so generally I would enjoy most mobile games

  • @Prin-q4s
    @Prin-q4s 19 днів тому

    Bro forgot plant vs zombies

    • @Zegiomio
      @Zegiomio 17 днів тому

      I’m sorry battle cats slaughters plants vs zombies. Especially with that latest update to the mobile version.

  • @X3m.Gaming
    @X3m.Gaming 25 днів тому

    battle cats is not a tower defence game. in battle cats you need to both defend and attack to win. not just defend. it just got tower defence genre slaped on to it for no reason. this is like arguing that gta is a racing game when in reality its a shooter game... exept i lied because its actually open world adventure game.

    • @Aura_BCP
      @Aura_BCP 25 днів тому

      It is a tower defense, it's just not the exact same type of concept people are familiar with, battle cats has a lot of mechanics that are also present in Bloons, upgrading the wallet is in a way similar to upgrading the units since you're storing more money to get more expensive cats on the field, you send out cats and they work on their own, and honestly if battle cats isn't a tower defense what would you consider battle cats to actually be

    • @X3m.Gaming
      @X3m.Gaming 25 днів тому

      if i had to give battle cats a real genre that exists it would be rts. problem is that i feel like its too complex for a simple game like battle cats. i feel like it would have to have a name that means something more simple than those real army city building games. kinda like how metrovania is just a platformer with extra steps. there is no simplier word for rts but i did seen games like this getting called army or war in genre but thats still too abstract like zombie also being a genre for some reason

  • @jackwest-s5h
    @jackwest-s5h 25 днів тому

    i play both games and love both i was playing btd6 when my friend told me about battle cats so its kinda funny because these are two of my favorite games

  • @kapselpl7290
    @kapselpl7290 25 днів тому

    Btd 6 is getting boring really fast yet battle cats not

  • @ZenithGlobe665
    @ZenithGlobe665 23 дні тому

    Unc got one còpyright strike and now he thinks hes batman 😹😹😹

  • @StandName
    @StandName 25 днів тому

    Tbf its Personal preference, none are better either, both has flaws as well

  • @SayeduzZaman-u7c
    @SayeduzZaman-u7c 24 дні тому

    Pvz2 vs btd6?

  • @avi_ber
    @avi_ber 25 днів тому

    Both, both are good.

  • @filippohl9097
    @filippohl9097 25 днів тому

    You should have compared The Battle Bricks since its much closer to Battle Cats than BTD6.

    • @john_ping
      @john_ping 24 дні тому

      BATTLE BRICKS MENTIONED!.💥🔥💥🔥💥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥RAHHHHHH IN TIME TO BRING DOOM TO THE DOOMBRINGER🗣️🗣️👣👣👣🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🗣️🔥🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🗣️💥🗣️💥👣🗣️💥🗣️💥👣👣

  • @mreblox1real
    @mreblox1real 23 дні тому +1

    battle cats is still better in my opinion

  • @theanime0069
    @theanime0069 23 дні тому

    Both games are great they are my childhood games

  • @pabloplayzxd1893
    @pabloplayzxd1893 25 днів тому

    Btd battles 2 and 1 are just as good as btd6 so like that’s my opinion. Battle cat is better tho imo bc of gambling but the tedious grind can still take its toll on the games reputation (barely) but btd 6 has that grind too.

  • @comanderSHANORIZ
    @comanderSHANORIZ 21 день тому

    i think the battle cat is better cause im pro at the battle cat:)

  • @B9lox9
    @B9lox9 25 днів тому

    Both, both is good.

  • @flaviamurgida9469
    @flaviamurgida9469 25 днів тому +1

    both, both are good

  • @PolishCatWall
    @PolishCatWall 23 дні тому

    ragebait thumbnail, love it lol

  • @timotejgrbec3355
    @timotejgrbec3355 25 днів тому

    BATTLE CATS EASILY WINS THERE. IS. NO. COMPETITION.

  • @plushtrapthebunny8356
    @plushtrapthebunny8356 25 днів тому

    I typically just like Battle cats more

  • @shalabrenaeandrews8196
    @shalabrenaeandrews8196 25 днів тому +1

    You need to pay to win battle cats

    • @Wrongaple
      @Wrongaple 24 дні тому

      No, I've been playing for like 4 years, endgame player, a lot of Ubers, and never spent a penny on this game

    • @CatuFood
      @CatuFood 24 дні тому

      I'm pretty sure you can play Battle Cats without spending money. It's all about strategies and timings and a Lotta other stuff.

  • @Acepiecesone
    @Acepiecesone 24 дні тому

    I think battle cats might win against btd6 let me explain
    Because the units in battle cats aren't that powerful but
    The enemies...... Are merciless
    The amount of enemies are there it feels like they are the skibide toilets and they are very very strong and they all work together there are the boss who Do thousands of damage from one attack and they get reinforcement who deal a few thousand of damage per second and can Destroy you line up and there are the small enemies who foursome reason have the same hp ass the boss and there is alien filibuster who can Destroy the entire map and one shot your unit

  • @dywaneamboy4059
    @dywaneamboy4059 25 днів тому

    Btd6 is kinda a game i play with an apk most of the time i played it before i got addicted to battle cats and battle cats has gambling and btd6 doesn't

  • @MrAssassin69
    @MrAssassin69 25 днів тому

    Btd6 is harder but over time you learn shit i like battle cats but it takes less skill if you have a op uber.

  • @mitsuri3096
    @mitsuri3096 25 днів тому

    Nither. They both take up your time and make you rot/ spend money make friends and save your money everyone dont take advice like this

    • @petre69
      @petre69 25 днів тому

      I’ve been doing it for years and still a skilled player (reason i made another comment is because it wouldn’t let me edit) and also don’t spend money free to play is a better thing

  • @Shnsxofc
    @Shnsxofc 25 днів тому

    BTD6 perde muitas oportunidades

  • @PembuatKomentarHandal
    @PembuatKomentarHandal 25 днів тому

    Not biased 😮

  • @anglaispizza8179
    @anglaispizza8179 22 дні тому

    battle cats is just better tho

  • @NigoraYarasheva-r7n
    @NigoraYarasheva-r7n 25 днів тому

    Easy mechanic 48

  • @krtc4102
    @krtc4102 22 дні тому

    Both games are goated

  • @alexanderurumov6737
    @alexanderurumov6737 25 днів тому +2

    I'm unsubscribing simply because of the thumbnail.

    • @alexanderurumov6737
      @alexanderurumov6737 25 днів тому

      Btd6 is garbage

    • @averageidiot1612
      @averageidiot1612 25 днів тому +2

      What does he have against BTD6??

    • @HdheDheu
      @HdheDheu 25 днів тому

      Whoa whoa

    • @michaelbell3612
      @michaelbell3612 25 днів тому

      Bruh it’s just one video

    • @bunxzer2116
      @bunxzer2116 25 днів тому +1

      Nobody cares if you unsubscribe buddy he has thousands of subscribers you won't make a difference

  • @vlob-x7
    @vlob-x7 25 днів тому

    G'ayratli do'st 05

  • @foxfoxovec7223
    @foxfoxovec7223 25 днів тому +1

    So u pay with nis so that means u are from Israel

  • @vlob-x7
    @vlob-x7 25 днів тому

    G'ayratli do'st 05