Looking for Travel Tripod Love: Sirui vs Leofoto vs Aoka

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 25

  • @brgphotography
    @brgphotography 2 роки тому +9

    This is a really clever way to do a review video. I don’t think I’ve seen anyone else do this kind of interview style review. Very cleaver. Nice work!!!

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  2 роки тому +1

      Hey thanks for watching! It was fun to make so I'm glad at least some people have enjoyed it 🙂

  • @mikewilson9601
    @mikewilson9601 Рік тому

    I have a Sirui ST-124. It really is a superb piece of kit. Excellent working hight without needing the centre column. Super light but very rigid, folds up quite small, very portable. All in all, great tripod, excellent quality, as all Sirui products are. (I also have 2 Sirui monopods, one with feet which is amazing.)
    My ST-124 was £230. Absolute bargain.

  • @garyrowe58
    @garyrowe58 Рік тому

    God that was heart-wrenching about Joby ... I'm sorry for your loss.

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  Рік тому

      It was a sad day for all... Thanks for watching!

  • @pblogic007
    @pblogic007 Рік тому +1

    Fun video format. Really enjoyed it.

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  Рік тому

      Hey thanks for watching! Glad it was entertaining

  • @youknowitstrue3403
    @youknowitstrue3403 Рік тому +4

    I’m 4 years into my leofoto 324 cex as a landscape photographer. That said it’s been in rivers, rocky deserts, mud, you name it. I have NEVER cleaned it and it works like a champ to this day. So while your assessment of less substantial joint shims may be your reason for not choosing it, I assure you it’s beyond adequate. Another note is that I have not experienced the grainy joint twist you mentioned on any of my 3 leofoto tripods. I too considered the suri in other past tripod purchases.

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  Рік тому

      hey thanks for watching! That's fair; it's very possible my copy was defective in some way and that's why it didn't inspire as much confidence as the Sirui. I've seen many reviews where people were super happy with their Leofoto. It was very, very close in the end and my reasons for choosing the Sirui were really nitpicky, admittedly 😂

    • @georgedavall9449
      @georgedavall9449 11 місяців тому +1

      Either this Guy is smokin some good stuff, and/ or he got a bad copy of the Leofoto. I’m with You, and I would say without hesitation, Leofoto tops Sirui ( Sue- Ray) I’m not familiar with the other brand. I’ve owned Sirui tripods and monopods, and their shims are INFERIOR to Leo! It took me 45 minutes to get my Carbon fiber Sirui back together once. I used to be a big Sirui fan, but no longer. Peace and appreciate your comment

  • @knowyouryoga
    @knowyouryoga Рік тому +2

    Hello is leofoto ls 364c a good choice for wildlife videography

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  Рік тому +1

      Hey thanks for watching! The Leofoto will provide exceptional stability if you don't mind the size & weight. But for serious wildlife with large, heavy telephoto lenses which are typically obscenely expensive, I'd invest in a brand with more of a track record personally.

    • @knowyouryoga
      @knowyouryoga Рік тому

      @@andreas1701d Thanks a lot for your reply. Would you recommend something for me in about 500$

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  Рік тому

      If I could justify spending more than I did on a tripod, my brand of choice would be either 3 legged thing in that price range. Love their products. Which model really depends on the features you'll need.

    • @georgedavall9449
      @georgedavall9449 11 місяців тому

      YES! Their Ranger sticks with 32 mm legs are already fairly stiff, and 36mm is even better. I have an LS-364C with the 40 ball head, and have had a gripped DSLR with Sigma 50-100 f/1.8 and it don't move! That lens, btw, is heavier than a typical 70-200 f/2.8! I plan on using it with a gimbal, and a 150-600 lens, without hesitation. Peace

  • @brgphotography
    @brgphotography 2 роки тому +1

    I just figured out your were doing a bachelor parody. Ever more clever! You should do a lot more of these kind of videos!

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  2 роки тому +1

      That also tells me I should lean into the parody more and make it more obvious, lol.

  • @poppacapnurass2608
    @poppacapnurass2608 6 місяців тому

    Vid is a thumbs down for me
    Yes, it's an interesting review method, which has an appeal of a strike out comp on reality TV. However it discounts a lot of user needs and functions.
    How was the Aoka without the extension? Was it OK indoors, but not so great outdoors?

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  6 місяців тому

      Hey thanks for watching... It's not everyone's cup of tea, I get that. I had fun with it though. It was never meant to be a comprehensive review. Just how it felt trying them out.

  • @georgedavall9449
    @georgedavall9449 11 місяців тому

    I appreciate you trying to be fair and objective, but having owned both Sirui tripods and monopods, and now Leofoto, I have to call you out Sir. Leofoto simply outclasses Sirui. Not saying Sirui is bad choice, just that Leofoto is better.
    My first Leofoto purchase was a $69.00 Carbon fiber Monopod from B&H. Thought it would be a ‘cheap’ way to check it the brand? That little stick is stiffer than my ROBUS, and my big Sirui Monopod, which I DO like. So I ordered up a couple of Leofoto legs, and with the ball heads as a package, and am even more impressed. The fit and finish and packaging and attention to detail are really good. Twist locks are butter smooth ( You must have had a bad copy! ) and they lock down tight, little to no flex. And Leofoto USA are now based out of Louisiana, and I have received excellent Customer Support. Of course, YMMV
    Good review, I try and be fair but objective and realistic in my comments. Stay safe and Happy Shooting!

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  11 місяців тому

      Hey thanks for watching! In fact, this was anything but an objective choice. I liked the leofoto, I just preferred the sirui. I totally could see how someone would prefer the opposite though. Could be down to QC as well; maybe I just got a bad leofoto and good sirui.

  • @bigallee3
    @bigallee3 2 роки тому

    🤣 thanks for the video. I bought a Joby for my point and shoot years ago but I never liked it. What’s annoying is that you could never get the legs straight because there are just too many pieces!
    I also have an old Sirui T-025x. It is super light and fits inside my bag. Great for traveling but it is not the most steady (the last leg section is not that stiff due to it being super thin).
    I saw an interesting new tripod from Ulanzi x Coman. I think it is the Zero XY. It is very similar to the Peak Design. You should check it out if you are still looking.

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  2 роки тому

      Hey thanks for watching! For now the sirui does the job... But yes I saw that ulanzi... Looks like a great budget alternative to the peak design

  • @unlvqasl
    @unlvqasl 9 місяців тому

    You talk about not liking what a tripod looks like. A tripod is just another took just like a hammer. When you buy a hammer do you worry about what your new hammer looks like or just about how well you can hit things with it.

    • @andreas1701d
      @andreas1701d  9 місяців тому

      A product's appeal varies from person to person. Some people attribute greater value to design & feel than others.
      Like your hammer example, decent quality tripods all accomplish their primary function reasonably well. Given that, their secondary attributes enter the discussion: materials, feel, and yes, aesthetics.