A very nice and substantial part 2 of this Long conversation on The View from Manila Professor Richard Heydarian with retired Senior Associate Tony Carpiio. What a pleasure to listen to both of you as always. Agree with “ give credit where the credit is due!” Thanks very much gentlemen , Mabuhay po kayo ❤🇵🇭🙏!
napanood ko speech nya sa singapore, kakakilabot ramdam mo.pagmamahal sa bayan, napakalim, napakatalino, yungndiskarte nya para suportahahn ng international community ang pinas ay nakaka biib talaga, masustansiya bawat salitang sinasabi nya at parang ni lecturan lang nya world leaders sa history at importance ng pag respeto sa international law, check mate ang china sa mga salita nya at sa mga taong nakaka intindi at gumagamit ng common sense
Always a pleasure listening to former SCJ A.Carpio’s explanations about the issues we have with China. Very educational and thank you for enriching our knowledge about it . Thank you 🙏 , Richard for having fmrSCJ Carpio all the time to share his knowledge abt this ! ✊💪🇵🇭🙏💜 On point with all your questions to sir Carpio . Appreciated this conversation between the 2 of you . More power, be safe and God bless 🙏 , sir Carpio and Richard!🙏✊💪🇵🇭💜🥰
Another insightful discussion with Justice Carpio. Just an observation though, the interviewer bombards the discussion with so many "insights" when you can go straight to the point/question and let the expert indulge everyone with his answer. It is evident that you know the topic and did your research but over-explaining the question isn't needed. Carpio can very well explain the topic thoroughly. Just my two cents.
Justice Carpio, how can the Philippines apply to be part of NATO like Japan and Korea? This would ensure help in case of foreign invasion . Finland applied during Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Only president Biden is with us … and I hope he will live up to his IRON CLAD SUPPORT AS HE PROMISED….now filling the gap made by past presidents …. I think as much as we need them, they need the Philippines the most because of its strategic location !!! Philippines is very sincere and honest to deal with in the ASEAN region !!!
At present we talked about wps…and all supernations are visible roaming their ships. Mr Carpio what if thousand of chinese already scattered inside our land in luzon, cagayan, pampanga, cavite, visayas to mindanao rumors they already landed in our soil so how we could defend our country then?
its so fun watching people with no military leadership experience acting professional with military disputed areas as if war tactics has nothing to do with it.
They know their stuff even if they don’t have military leadership… Retired judge A. Carpio was an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court and Richard Heydarian is a Manila base academic, a professor - Ateneo de Manila , De La Salle University, a master of international studies - UP Diliman ( courses taught), an author, etc
@@RichardHeydarian BBM has a military background and hails from a military family. He knows well how the military operates like any officer does. You must have forgotten that our President was once a soldier. Scout Ranger officer to be exact.
@@JersDraws lol did he serve in a single combat mission? No! By your joke time logic, only Ramos is a good president (though he was better than most). In US, barrly any of their presidents since D.E had military background… same trend every major democracy from Japan to Germany
👍 indeed !!!! Philippines badly needs to Acquire advance sophisticated weapon systems and equipments to counter/deter anyone like China claiming 9, 10 or 11 dash line of the SCS historically according to them without basis …. as UNCLOS DECLARED !!! The reality is : China wants it badly because of the discovery of gas and natural oil plus it is full of fisheries They know it is never a part of their territorial territory.. they are so far from the Philippines shores … they are across the SCS !!!
Obama and Trump were not with their agenda to support Phils. During their regime especially Trump then…in that note since at this time US says it is an “Iron-Clad relationship we need to clarify and make a clear amend the treaty contract just like what japan did with their contract with the US…
Richard i know, by the way you talk that you are indeed a very intelligent guy, but sometimes it gets into you head, too bigger guy to call the PBBM president. You want the Yello/pinklawan to do well this coming election but influential people like you would keep the opposition in the bottom of the list. Carpio and the like of Trillianes could do well in the election.
what scj carpio saying is interesting and realistic... duterte admin good for nothing.. hoping Filipino never repeat there mistake again.. voting for non sense
nobody known. Chinese draw the imaginary line with no legal bases... they said it is historical without written history.. arbitration court said Philippines have legal and historical right to west Philippines sea..
@@marlond1321 yes, True, 100% correct.,. it is look like bbm lectured Chinese official what is the bases philippiness historical.and legal rights. they can not rebuttal those legal rights. and the whole world are watching.. what a shame for china..
Why is Richard has so much doubt on US? For now it's the best advantage for the Philippines the US Presence & extending military assistance bcoz admittedly we are not capable in defending our country. Our past administrations did not modernized the AFP but even sided with China to easily grab our territorial sovereignty. Well, maybe Obama & Trump did not have positive impact for our advantage but u see a change in administrations also have effect in changing policies. For now, let's be happy that US assures us their support, while we build our own military capability.
We will protect Taiwan 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼BECAUSE WE HAVE 300000-400000 PILIPINO OVERSEAS WORKERS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO OUR DOLLAR RESERVES🇵🇭❤️🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭❤️OFWs RULE ccp hegemony NOOOOO!!! USA 🇺🇸YESS!!!!!!!!!🇺🇸❤️🇵🇭🇹🇼🇯🇵🇺🇸🇯🇵❤️🇵🇭🇰🇷🇵🇭❤️🇹🇼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇯🇵🇯🇵🇹🇼🇹🇼🇵🇭🇵🇭
Liar trying to fool naive Filipinos here. Philippines people must wake up to the fact that eez is not Philippines territory. It's international waters. While SCS belongs to china and Taiwan territory since 1947 when unclos and Philippines independence does not even exsisted. China do not need unclos law to own their scs.
You have so many contradicting statements, Wumao. You say the Philippine EEZ is international waters, but China also claims most of it as part of their territory, so how is that international waters? The Philippines officially recognizes its year of independence as 1898 from Spain, and it would have been so if not for the American and Japanese occupations that followed. The Philippines did eventually gain full independence in 1946, which is still a year before the 1947 9-10 dash line claim of the PRC and ROC. China is also a signatory of UNCLOS; therefore, China is bound to its rules.
Both of you is so ibvious against The former president Duterte not to defend him against his foreign policy which I myself do not agree also…but let put the proper context, why Digong turned against the West…it was the doing of Obama….not only his sentiment with us even was evident with the times of Penoy but also his or Obama’s criticizing Duterte’s drug war…which up to now USA has big problem with drugs. So that time you would see Duterte starting to stay away with the west especially with USA.
We will protect Taiwan 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼BECAUSE WE HAVE 300000-400000 PILIPINO OVERSEAS WORKERS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO OUR DOLLAR RESERVES🇵🇭❤️🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭❤️OFWs RULE ccp hegemony NOOOOO!!! USA 🇺🇸YESS!!!!!!!!!🇺🇸❤️🇵🇭🇹🇼🇯🇵🇺🇸🇯🇵❤️🇵🇭🇰🇷🇵🇭❤️🇹🇼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇯🇵🇯🇵🇹🇼🇹🇼🇵🇭🇵🇭
Very educational conversation! Thumbs up Richard👍👍👍
CARPIO FOR SENATOR
Great and intelligent discussion is what this country needs ☺Really love your views Sir Richard! God bless you and keep you safe always Sir!
A very nice and substantial part 2 of this Long conversation on The View from Manila Professor Richard Heydarian with retired Senior Associate Tony Carpiio. What a pleasure to listen to both of you as always. Agree with “ give credit where the credit is due!” Thanks very much gentlemen , Mabuhay po kayo ❤🇵🇭🙏!
napanood ko speech nya sa singapore, kakakilabot ramdam mo.pagmamahal sa bayan, napakalim, napakatalino, yungndiskarte nya para suportahahn ng international community ang pinas ay nakaka biib talaga, masustansiya bawat salitang sinasabi nya at parang ni lecturan lang nya world leaders sa history at importance ng pag respeto sa international law, check mate ang china sa mga salita nya at sa mga taong nakaka intindi at gumagamit ng common sense
Ang magand a duin yun dash line tinawag niyang IMAGINATIONs LOL
Always a pleasure listening to former SCJ A.Carpio’s explanations about the issues we have with China. Very educational and thank you for enriching our knowledge about it . Thank you 🙏 , Richard for having fmrSCJ Carpio all the time to share his knowledge abt this ! ✊💪🇵🇭🙏💜 On point with all your questions to sir Carpio . Appreciated this conversation between the 2 of you . More power, be safe and God bless 🙏 , sir Carpio and Richard!🙏✊💪🇵🇭💜🥰
Justice Carpio I wish you are one of PBBM’s advisors ! Can you??
Yes...he should!
Kudos justice carpio. i admire your wit. Informative topic. Thanks
Interesting discussion. Always a fan of these 2.
Thanks guys. May we have more of your brilliant analysis
Very well explained .Thank Chief Justice Carpio !
Am glad SCJ Carpio is talking now about wps sovereighnity. Thank you.
Interesting discussion….we ca explain YOUR TOPIC IN THE ELEMENTARY STUDENTs with pictures….thank you , Atty Antonio Carpio and Richard Heydarin. .
Very informative discussion. Kudos.
so very informative discussion. kudos to Justice Carpio.
Give credit where the credit is due, TAMA si Carpio, give credit to MARCOS SR, he has the foresight of the importance of the WPS to the country.
IDOL RICHARD!!! MABUHAY PO KAYO!! SANA TUMAKBO PO SI MR.CARPIO FOR SENATOR 2025!!!! PLS PO,,🙏 ,,, PLS PO ..🙏
Yes please tama na ang mga likes ni Robin
Another insightful discussion with Justice Carpio. Just an observation though, the interviewer bombards the discussion with so many "insights" when you can go straight to the point/question and let the expert indulge everyone with his answer. It is evident that you know the topic and did your research but over-explaining the question isn't needed. Carpio can very well explain the topic thoroughly. Just my two cents.
i like the host. He is smart. But he talks too long that his guests can't speak much. Sorry..
3:48
LIAMAS FOR SENATOR AND CARPIO FOR SENATOR FOR 2025!!!!!! ❤❤❤
Justice Carpio, how can the Philippines apply to be part of NATO like Japan and Korea? This would ensure help in case of foreign invasion . Finland applied during Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Only president Biden is with us … and I hope he will live up to his IRON CLAD SUPPORT AS HE PROMISED….now filling the gap made by past presidents …. I think as much as we need them, they need the Philippines the most because of its strategic location !!! Philippines is very sincere and honest to deal with in the ASEAN region !!!
Sir Richard kamuka mo ung host nila sa China uncensored na channel
I thought so as well
Agree with Justice Carpio
At present we talked about wps…and all supernations are visible roaming their ships. Mr Carpio what if thousand of chinese already scattered inside our land in luzon, cagayan, pampanga, cavite, visayas to mindanao rumors they already landed in our soil so how we could defend our country then?
its so fun watching people with no military leadership experience acting professional with military disputed areas as if war tactics has nothing to do with it.
They know their stuff even if they don’t have military leadership… Retired judge A. Carpio was an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court and Richard Heydarian is a Manila base academic, a professor - Ateneo de Manila , De La Salle University, a master of international studies - UP Diliman ( courses taught), an author, etc
I beg to disagree. I will not follow them to lead my life if war happens. A soldier is still your best informant in times of war.
Lol presidents - civilians - are commander in chief 😂 how many great presidents were ex generals again?
@@RichardHeydarian BBM has a military background and hails from a military family. He knows well how the military operates like any officer does. You must have forgotten that our President was once a soldier. Scout Ranger officer to be exact.
@@JersDraws lol did he serve in a single combat mission? No! By your joke time logic, only Ramos is a good president (though he was better than most). In US, barrly any of their presidents since D.E had military background… same trend every major democracy from Japan to Germany
Comprehensive archipelagic defense capacity = Defense expenditure is a good investment policy for any self respecting country.
stratbase ADR. financed by the owner of the concession in reed bank
👍 indeed !!!! Philippines badly needs to Acquire advance sophisticated weapon systems and equipments to counter/deter anyone like China claiming 9, 10 or 11 dash line of the SCS historically according to them without basis …. as UNCLOS DECLARED !!! The reality is : China wants it badly because of the discovery of gas and natural oil plus it is full of fisheries
They know it is never a part of their territorial territory.. they are so far from the Philippines shores … they are across the SCS !!!
So we should keep US and other to guard wps?
Obama and Trump were not with their agenda to support Phils. During their regime especially Trump then…in that note since at this time US says it is an “Iron-Clad relationship we need to clarify and make a clear amend the treaty contract just like what japan did with their contract with the US…
Richard i know, by the way you talk that you are indeed a very intelligent guy, but sometimes it gets into you head, too bigger guy to call the PBBM president. You want the Yello/pinklawan to do well this coming election but influential people like you would keep the opposition in the bottom of the list. Carpio and the like of Trillianes could do well in the election.
what scj carpio saying is interesting and realistic... duterte admin good for nothing.. hoping Filipino never repeat there mistake again.. voting for non sense
So who approved 10-dash line ruling? Pres. BBM keeps uttering 9-dash line thats the line we won arbitration from unclos?
nobody known. Chinese draw the imaginary line with no legal bases... they said it is historical without written history.. arbitration court said Philippines have legal and historical right to west Philippines sea..
@@leonortenorio6604 it is what we call the Chinese Illusion..
@@marlond1321 yes, True, 100% correct.,. it is look like bbm lectured Chinese official what is the bases philippiness historical.and legal rights. they can not rebuttal those legal rights. and the whole world are watching.. what a shame for china..
brownout na nga, wala pang tubig 😂😂😂😂😂
Why is Richard has so much doubt on US? For now it's the best advantage for the Philippines the US Presence & extending military assistance bcoz admittedly we are not capable in defending our country. Our past administrations did not modernized the AFP but even sided with China to easily grab our territorial sovereignty. Well, maybe Obama & Trump did not have positive impact for our advantage but u see a change in administrations also have effect in changing policies. For now, let's be happy that US assures us their support, while we build our own military capability.
Rttf
We will protect Taiwan 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼BECAUSE WE HAVE 300000-400000 PILIPINO OVERSEAS WORKERS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO OUR DOLLAR RESERVES🇵🇭❤️🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭❤️OFWs RULE ccp hegemony NOOOOO!!! USA 🇺🇸YESS!!!!!!!!!🇺🇸❤️🇵🇭🇹🇼🇯🇵🇺🇸🇯🇵❤️🇵🇭🇰🇷🇵🇭❤️🇹🇼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇯🇵🇯🇵🇹🇼🇹🇼🇵🇭🇵🇭
Colonial talking heads.
stratbase ADR making their money work
and then joint patrol? then what happened? may drilling na ba? wala, mas lumala sitwasyon sa Pilipinas 😂😂😂😂
Liar trying to fool naive Filipinos here. Philippines people must wake up to the fact that eez is not Philippines territory. It's international waters. While SCS belongs to china and Taiwan territory since 1947 when unclos and Philippines independence does not even exsisted.
China do not need unclos law to own their scs.
Grossly bad info! Where did you get it?
@@joelperez4024 from my research on south china sea and international law.
You have so many contradicting statements, Wumao. You say the Philippine EEZ is international waters, but China also claims most of it as part of their territory, so how is that international waters? The Philippines officially recognizes its year of independence as 1898 from Spain, and it would have been so if not for the American and Japanese occupations that followed. The Philippines did eventually gain full independence in 1946, which is still a year before the 1947 9-10 dash line claim of the PRC and ROC. China is also a signatory of UNCLOS; therefore, China is bound to its rules.
Both of you is so ibvious against The former president Duterte not to defend him against his foreign policy which I myself do not agree also…but let put the proper context, why Digong turned against the West…it was the doing of Obama….not only his sentiment with us even was evident with the times of Penoy but also his or Obama’s criticizing Duterte’s drug war…which up to now USA has big problem with drugs. So that time you would see Duterte starting to stay away with the west especially with USA.
We will protect Taiwan 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼BECAUSE WE HAVE 300000-400000 PILIPINO OVERSEAS WORKERS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO OUR DOLLAR RESERVES🇵🇭❤️🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭❤️OFWs RULE ccp hegemony NOOOOO!!! USA 🇺🇸YESS!!!!!!!!!🇺🇸❤️🇵🇭🇹🇼🇯🇵🇺🇸🇯🇵❤️🇵🇭🇰🇷🇵🇭❤️🇹🇼🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇯🇵🇯🇵🇹🇼🇹🇼🇵🇭🇵🇭