LIVE: ID v. Chad Daybell Day 26 - Doomsday Prophet Murder Trial | COURT TV
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 чер 2024
- LIVE COURT WEBEX: Day 26 - The Defense begins its case for the so-called "Doomsday Prophet" Chad Daybell. Daybell is facing the death penalty for the murders of his first wife, Tammy Daybell, and Tylee Ryan, 17, and JJ Vallow, 7, the youngest children of his second wife, Lori Vallow Daybell. He is a self-published author and prosecutors have described him as the leader of a 'Doomsday' cult.
00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 26
00:19:58 ON THE RECORD - Defense Case begins
00:25:56 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #1 Emma Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Daughter
01:25:20 BREAK
01:58:07 Direct Continues Defense #1 Emma Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Daughter
03:22:07 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #2 Garth Daybell, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son
03:35:02 Lunch Break
04:45:21 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #3 William “Forrest” Fischer, Garth Daybell’s Attorney
05:51:38 Break
06:18:47 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #4 Joseph Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son-In-Law and Emma’s Husband
#CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖️ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-dayb...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
UA-cam / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.com/trials/
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 26
00:19:58 ON THE RECORD - Defense Case begins
00:25:56 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #1 Emma Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Daughter
01:25:20 BREAK
01:58:07 Direct Continues Defense #1 Emma Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Daughter
03:22:07 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #2 Garth Daybell, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son
03:35:02 Lunch Break
04:45:21 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #3 William “Forrest” Fischer, Garth Daybell’s Attorney
05:51:38 Break
06:18:47 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #4 Joseph Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son-In-Law and Emma’s Husband
#CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-daybell/?
Prior may not have coached Garth, but someone in his office did.
So, the kids were paid by Chad to keep the lie alive. Chad gave each of them $8000, and apparently, his truck to Emma's husband. This whole family is nuts!
I have never heard anything as scripted Emma’s testimony in my life. They are soulless
I said the same thing…never heard anything so scripted. I was actually shocked!
Embarrassing and obvious.
Very scripted
Absolutely 💯 scripted! Tammy is now being violated all over again and now by her own daughter. Poor Tammy. RIP
ABSO-FKNG-LUTELY
AND SHE COULDN'T WAIT TO GET THE SCRIPT OUT!
Did NOTHING for Chad. In fact, no witnesses today, did a thing but prove this is a brainwashed, wimpy, emotionless family.
OMG - his kids sound just as drab and emotionless as their father.
Yeah. Like they’re dead and hollow.
Not one tear from CD's kids, not one. In fact, they showed no emotion at all regarding their mothers death. Or that two dead children were buried on his dad's property. These people are not the sharpest knives in the drawer. Kinda clueless and easily duped by their own father. I hope Chad gets the DP
Garth sounds like a zombie...
Totally agree! 😴😵💫
@@leftyfromtx3401 I thought the same however ......after learning (from todays hearing) that Emma actually conducted a Google search regarding 'wind direction' the day B4 Tylee was buried I now think that she's a lot more involved in this than we realize.
Emma and Garth ,these two need mental help ASAP !!!
I Can't believe they actually teach children !!! Wtf 🤯
That’s what I said. It is horrible they are teachers. I pray they aren’t teaching!
I’d pull my kid out of either of those two’s classes so fast! I’m surprised they weren’t let go.
Thank you to the Daybell spawn for putting the final nails in your father's coffin by blatantly lying on the stand.
You are so right
Exactly
I can’t listen to any more of this brainwashed garbage … OMG 🙄 The daughter sounds so coached.
I've been watching everyday, pausing and continuing even in the middle of the night. This is the only day that I fast forwarded bc I didn't need to hear the lies and it became almost embarrassing to hear the script being Fkd up so badly. Pryor himself seemed pissed. The kids blew the defense argument so much that it was cringe.
It’s unreal these children are dangerous from being brought up by this man
@@aimeefriedman822I don’t feel bad for these kids they are now adults they don’t have to believe in these things. They should be ashamed of themselves
@@brandyannsaunders6298 I don't feel badly for them at all. I could cry just THINKING about if/when my mom passed away. These kids are only concerned with whether their cheating father gets arrested and not that chopped up, smothered and burnt children are buried in his yard! I couldn't drink the water from that house and Emma moves in.
Remember, the kids have an exclusion and have been allowed to watch these proceedings and Emma has the nerve to be pissed off at the cops?
@@brandyannsaunders6298 I'd petition my church/temple/congregation to kicked them all the FK out of freaking town! Emma in particular is belligerent and disgraceful not giving a sht about her mom. Since when does being tired justify death? She SHOULD have been asking her mother why she's so depressed. I'm 100 that Tammy knew Chad was a phony and deceiving even his own children and THAT'S WHY she never told anyone how horrendous Chad was bc they wouldn't have believed her. Chad cut her off from any relatives that WOULD have believed her.
Chad was probably poisoning Tami, that's why he kept predicting the date of her death he was probably doing the math in his head. And that would explain why she was feeling sluggish and sleepy. Because you know 100% that he was trying to kill her in other ways besides the attempted shooting and strangulation seem like a last-minute ditch effort.
Yeh, there are poison chemicals that can't be traced. Unless they done the autopsy on time.
Depressed people sleep a lot too.
@@janarmbruster7161 Especially if they are over medicated on their meds.
I think he was adding something to her home remedies. Too late to analysis when she was exhumed 🤔 no evidence at home etc. Poor Tammy was on a slippery slope for months 😬
I agree, there may have been attempts on taking her life that we don't know about.
Three people were murdered, two of them children...suffocated, bound, hands and mouth taped, by their own family member...gasping inside a bag tied around the neck, cut up, sawed apart, burnt, thrown in a bucket, dumped into the ground, lied about, slaughtered with deliberation....and Garth is complaining about the mean police and detectives. He gets a dig in whenever he can about how badly HE has been treated. Selfish and self-centered. Please.
Hard to believe Chads kids are teachers of children and show NO concern about two brutally murdered children where found in their father's back yard. He acted like they were just raccoons
4. Charles was a victim of this conspiracy as well.
I wish they showed chads psychopath children those photos of the children buried. Not sure it would have made a difference but at least they could see what their brainwashed "father" is capable of.
Can’t believe these two are teachers 😱
I can. I worked at a college and they are the dumbest of the dumb too. I refuse to call any of them "professors." Also it is a trick when college applicants get "acceptance" letters. The college I worked at were very short on students each year and the locals would get their "acceptance" letters and they thought that was just the greatest thing. Just another way to fool applicants that they are "something special."
Prior keeps asking Garth if he needs a break … “I’ll take a quick sip” … these kids aren’t upset prior! They don’t need a break they show no care about their mother!
@@Kathydawn25 Yes, it's nauseating hearing him try to feign concern!
It's so pathetic. He's trying to make them sound like they have a soul. We all know they don't. The entire family is psychotic
You will never convince me that she hasn’t watched the trial! The way she offers information and honesty says nothing nice about her mom! Really weird!
Yeah I thought so too
She’s a liar anyway already proven. Did you hear that thing from court tv that Emma posted on Reddit that her town needs to shut up about dad marrying too suspiciously soon and that he had “married a family friend”
Liar.
@@kimward5746 Oowh really! I now suspect she was a lot more involved in the whole thing after learning that Emma actually conducted a Google search on wind direction the day b4 Tylee was buried. I had previously believed it was only Chad who had searched on wind direction that day.
@@Hal-jc9pzFrightening thought how far this craziness has spread. So many believers.
@@W_74_16 Yes, Chad surrounded himself with people who had very pliable minds.
After hearing Emma later say she has no concept of directions, I realize she didn't conduct the Google search on wind direction, she was just taking the hit to protect Chad (aka perjuring herself).
HEY GARTH ...Dead bodies don't roll!
Exactly…. And that was that?”thump” he heard? She wasn’t even on the floor.
I hope the jury caught his lie
He told Prior he heard nothing but his dad! He told prosecution he heard a thump.
@@KL-ou9jj He also had a conflicting story when Chad's kids did that interview a few years ago.
A body will roll if another person is in bed, and they go get get out and pull covers and the roll out, or she could have rolled out during her episode and she finished rolling more as he got out of bed.
I would never know Tammy was her Mom... she shows zero care, emotion. Its clear she will say anything to clear her Dad. Every bit of her testimony sounds scripted. Who will stand up for Tammy? So sad.
What horrible heinous brainwashed kids - well adults. Sick family.
It’s diabolical. Maybe she helped bury the children too!
Emma probably calls Prior Uncle John. It’s funny how she knows all the answers for Prior but can’t recall for Lindsey
Menopause causes extreme fatigue and tiredness not illness
My thoughts exactly!
Snap!
and depression too
Geesh if anyone's kids are "zombies" it's Chad's! Coached much?!
This sounds just disturbing to me, his kids sounds like a mal function AI ready to ease the questions by Prior and putting her mother down at every opportunity, again disturbing and pathetic.
She’s awfully cold and lacks empathy. Seems like her “dad” has brainwashed her, and most likely his other children too.
The long breaks and short days this court takes are ridiculous. Barely 3:30 and he stops for the day. Could Emma be more brainwashed?
She seems to have the simple mind of a toddler.
@@5GreenAcresand both of these two children are teachers! 😳
@@Peaches.523 Just like the song...Another Brick in The Wall by Pink Floyd. Hey teacher...leave those kids alone.
When I sat on a Jury, the vast majority of time was spent sitting through sidebars, with the "white noise" crackling in our ears.
@@karieschneider746 That is horrible.
His kids talk in the same cadence as their father
Yes...that halting, uneven speech
The police did not need a warrant to take Garth in for questioning. Finding the bodies on the family property was enough probable cause to warrant questioning anyone associated with that property.
Wow. His children are literal robots! 🤖 or should I say.... zombies! 🧟♀️
Yes she definitely sounds like Terminator. Very vanilla!
Nope. Thats lori kids hear Melanie gibb tell it and lori 😂😂😂😂
@@jenharper5455you do know their kids aren't all there just like jj ?!?!?! Smh
What’s with this family! She talks like she’s half asleep! 😮
Emma has been coached big time. She is also terminally boring.
Yes! 💯. Prior is exhausting. This was a whole other level.
Emma knows ever single date Pryer needs. Outrageous
Because he goes over her answers with her
Her answers about the herbal remedies and stuff were so funny just so scripted
@@TapirusT Yes that was truly CRINGE material!
Why would Emma it's her mom and dad 😢
What the actual fark am i listening to? Emma is bonkers
Why does Garth’s answers sound like questions?
What’s s scary is this guy is a teacher!
So is roboto nutto Emma. Like god almighty they are not normal..
I suspect the questioning tone is because he's seeking assurance from Prior that he's correctly following the scripted responses (as per Priors coaching.)
If two of my father's stepchildren were found, hacked and bagged and bucketed up, in my father's back yard, I sure as hell wouldn't be standing next to the police car, crying, "I love you, I love you" to him through the window. She seems to have no concern for those children.
And now living back in that house 😮
I couldn't do it and she's paying rent to Prior.
God knows the truth!!!
She has knowledge or was there.
@@michellestephenson1067yea, I think they’re all followers of crazy ass Chad.
Chad's kids and their mates are all 'towing the company line.' How could someone so sickly do Zoomba and Clogging? They won't go against the Paternal priest.
And his portal bride…
It is soooo obvious that this daughter of Tammy’s lies on the stand. She was told exactly how to answer and what to answer. Any jury would see right through her.
Strength to Tammy’s friends and family. I’m so sorry Tammy is being violated all over again and sadly by her own off spring. It’s a diabolical act.
Emma and Garth seemed to remember precisely every single date and every conversation that Prior asked of them. Prosecution's turn to cross examine about times, dates, conversations.......they both were struck with "amnesia".....don't remember....can't recall....didn't say that.....didn't happen.
Not the defence trying to use the fact that Tammy was “cheating” with her FitBit as some type of “defence” for Chad. Pathetic
Right?!? What even was that!
Weight of evidence outweighs the bias of children who speak to their dad every day and view him as the authority and leader of their family. And can I just add, Tammy clearly worked her butt off to support the family so she is entitled to like “to drive the nicest car”. What was Chad doing? Living in fantasy land and committing adultery.
You forgot his dopey writing career. LOL
@@sondragramse1770That was his practice fantasy land…then Lori became the ultimate fantasyland for him 😢
Exactly !!!
What is the relevance of 'who drove which car' & why is it so important to Prior? Have I missed something in the evidence or is it another 1 of Priors pointless 'nothing burgers' ?
As the wife and mother she was entitled to drive the nicest car. As my dad said, “Because I want my wife and children to be safe.” This was standard thinking before feminism killed chivalry.
The daughter is talking badly about her mother. It's as if she believes poor Tammy died on purpose to make pathetic chad suffer.😐
All of the Defense’s witnesses are as dumb and lurky as his client. Napoleon Dynamite horror show reruns.
Wow Emma, no consideration for your Mum at all! Oh, and perjury is a real thing. Quite adamant that you didn’t recall a specific conversation, kinda makes it look as though you do.
At what point will someone in the Daybell household do the right thing and be honest or demand honesty from their father. I cant understand how they get on the stand in Chad’s defense. He’s still married to Lori and there is no way I’d believe or defend him.
Tammy’s kids said she love animals. Why would the kill racoons. They could have moved them but they decided to murder them. If the rabbits meant so much to them why would you leave them to freeze in the winters. Not sounding very compassionate at all for animals. Chad and his kids have no emotion for the loss of their mom. Most people would break down and cry with such a horrible loss.
This is one sick family
Coach Pryor didn’t prepare her for this savage cross examination 😂
Didnt miss once! I love her!
She was depressed, wondering about her husband's infidelity
Exactly!
Emma is forthright in her speech, when the questions are not important. When things get closer to the bone, she sounds rehearsed, or she defaults to her father's way of speaking...faltering, as though searching for words.
She's trying to remember her 'coached' lines.
Wth do the kids speak like they’re half baked or dead? Zero personality. They clearly take after their father. Poor Garth doesn’t even know if he’s answering a question or asking one.
Poor Tammy. They just completely turned on her as if she didn’t birth them. I’m glad her family stood up for her.
Is it just me or does this kid sound like a computer is speaking? This whole direct sounds like it was rehearsed over and over again.
Those kids need a reality check from Dr John!
There’s that word! “UPSTAIRS”.
Oops Garth
Gotta get your story straight with Prior
EMMA LIVES IN THE HOUSE WERE JJ AND THY ARE KILLED.THAT IS SOOOO SICK
I think Chad's kids were brain washed.
There's no way they weren't. No one sticks up for their parent who has two innocent children buried in the backyard unless they are fucked in the head, too. The whole family is a twisted nightmare
Garth told the truth the first thing he said about who drove the dodge.
I burst out laughing when Emma said (in her dull, drawn-out, monotone voice) “we were in a section of the gym that had light-weight dumbbells” - Whatever part of the gym the Daybell’s are in ‘is’ the ‘light-weight dumbbell section’ Emma! 😜😂
This Daybell family is so unfit !
I went into the defense really trying to be open minded with Chad's children. To me it seemed they were trying too much to fight for Chad and Chad's narrative of the events. So it came across as not genuine to the truth. I think it would have just been better for them to be honest and causal about the events because I don't believe they really knew the truth. So, I really lost credibility with Emma, Garth and Joe so far. Seemed more like Chad won't take the stand and sent his children to try and speak for him.
Now we know why Lori got rid if JJ's dog..."my father doesn't like dogs"
Lindsay Blake is throwing in a lil Prior’s forceful “CORRECT? “
LIVING for her clap backs
It is scary to think that Chads children are teachers. If I had kids where they teach I would be transferring them immediately
I hope the kids realise their father isnt going home . Community wont take lightly to people who lie , especially where dead children are involved .
When I was 49 I would be tired after working all day! OMG and I love a good Big Mac too! Ugh!
When I was 29 I would be tired after working all day…and at 19 and 9. These people are bizarro.
The defense lawyer was hoping for the daughter to cry (please use tissue water ...) when mentioning her mother. just to make her a bit more believable. because she sounds like a robot.
She just sounded pissed that nobody believed her dad. She wasn't even crying about bodies chopped, smothered and burnt in her yard. She just cried bc Chad was arrested!
This jury is probably blown away by how absurd Emma’s testimony is.
Her father did bury and burn “racoons’ he shot while they ran away frantically. I’m positive he was referring to sweet Tylee in those texts
I was shocked by the Daybell spawns testimony! I knew they’d lie for their dad but I never imagined it would be so obvious, they may as well have been reading off of a script in front of them.
And Prior was sure to mention both times that HE didn’t tell them what to say…he never said “did your DAD tell you what to say on your daily conversations with him?” I hope prosecution brings in jail calls on rebuttal to impeach them.
Their father led a cult and brainwashed multiple people, including coercing his brother in law to kill several humans. It’s to be expected that he maintains significant control of his children and their thinking. I feel sorry for them. They sound devoid of independent thought and little emotion.
Garth and the dodge Dakota… and the way Pryor has to water down his questions for these kids because they are both coached and … well.. they don’t seem all there in the head
Did Emma say you’d have to go upstairs 🤔 didn’t Prior freak out on someone for saying chad mentioned stairs because there weren’t any???
Yes....the 'stair' issue became an ongoing battle for days in court. Ultimately it was proven over & over again that the stairs do exist & Prior is a blatant liar. Emma momentarily forgot that she was suppose to lie about the stairs (as well as everything else).
@@Hal-jc9pzthank you!! I thought so. I wish they would of called her out about that slip up while she was testifying or testilying 😂
Give them hell Miss Blake. Those children of Chad's are lying!
It’s obvious Emma and Garth concocted a story or were coached on what to say. They volunteer more information than asked for and use the same verbiage to explain things.
Woah how did they treat their mother when she was alive? This behaviour is horrendous. Chad is guilty as sin.
This rubbish with the kids is a set up. They have got together to get him off
You found out he was having an affair after his arrest? Umm you went on a whole trip to CA together with her.
Really??? Where did you read or hear that? I thought I read or watched most everything on this ... crazyness
@@sondragramse1770Emma testified to it today.
Yes. I wonder why that’s not been jumped on
@@spare2785 I think he probably was never honest with the children that it was an affair until it got exposed. Just the totally normal thing of marrying a new woman a week after your wife’s death.
We are all just wasting time.. This guy is 100% guilty..
It is so obvious that the kids are prepared to lie to help their dad from getting the death penalty.
Emma is soooo rehearsed. She has an answer for everything. How creepy that she sounds just like Chad.
Chad is controlling Emma in the daily phone conversations.
Emma speaks like a teenager. Can she really be a teacher?
Doctors, teachers volunteers 🙋♀️ lawyers mothers sons uncles you name it. Tammy and Chad raised their kids off castings.
Lori killed hers smh 🤦 😪 tylee and jj were killed by their mom and she planted then in that man's backyard cause she killed her kids amd wanted Chad to help her like Alex had done it. Ain't no way that man would have allowed anyone to do that bruh. Alex did it with gibb lori and zulema. That's how they found the bodies. With lori help too. Cause why is chad charged with death row and not the mother of the kids, the protector. Like lori wouldn't have let nothing happen to her kids but she wanted them dead at whatever cost and alex melanie and zulmena had a hand in it. But Chad was never there and even the arrest warrant states jj died when ?!?!?! How is that an error ... no way they thought they was pulling a blind eye and that is untrue evidence so the jury will bot know when jj died. So can't place Chad there at jj deaths. Smh nor tylees.
Frightening! And she didn’t know what “literalist” means…. Prior had to define it. God, I feel awful for any child attempting to be educated by this person.
Pryor’s walking to the sidebars as a kid go for punishment 😂😂
So Emma doesn't cry bc there are children chopped, smothered, burnt in her yard; she doesn't cry that her dad cheated in her mom; doesn't cry that her mom is dead and thinks her mother was SO INCREDIBLY SICK that she just poof! Died!?!!!
SHE HAS AN EXCLUSION AND DEFINITELY HAS BEEN WATCHING ALL THIS AND STILL BELIEVES HER FATHER??!!
DISGRACEFUL!
Was Chad a fundamentalist? Did he want a polygamist lifestyle? Maybe Tammy was not into that.
I have always wondered the same thing, but then I think, would Lori really have been down? I feel like she was getting a little jealous of Zulema texting Chad as is....
Was watching live and the news camera followed daybelk taking offfrom the house so yes he was fleeing
These two are teaching our kids!
Chud’s kids are as mature as 8 year olds
Bedroom arrangements are not necessarily known by kids. Every time my husband was mad at me, he would sleep in the other room and then come into our room before the kids got up. I would just roll my eyes, but now I miss his childish ways... not the point. The point is the kids never knew he slept anywhere other than next to me.
Since She seemed so interested in googling wind direction maybe she was the one by the fire pit ??
So rehearsed
His kids lied for him
The daughter is just trying to protect her dad.. Don’t believe anything she says.. It’s so clear and obvious
Emma's husband is so inarticulate that it's painful to listen.
if this wasnt so uckin tragic Emma testifying would be hysterical.
I am sure Tammy went to bed to get away from Dumbell and her disloyal kids
And somehow this dead and cold body rolled off the bed…. Can’t make it make sense.
Mental telepathy Chad can do that to🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂😂
Garth is sounding like she’s trying to make a story sound plausible. The darkness outside on night of the shooting vs her clearly seeing a paintball gun. Him staying up to 3am. His seeing her winded. I mean it’s so fabricated
Chad and his children seem as if they might have a variety of delayed developments.
Follows with his mom as well. She did nothing to humanize Chad either.
Could Tammy have been stiff that soon???
And right, they need therapy !
Garth answers a lot of questions with an uptick in his voice. Very odd.
Poor Garth looks like a smaller version of his father.
PERJURY
Emma says she’s not good with directions but then says she was the one who googled south west winds. Very contradictory
Garth has that annoying way of talking uphill...every sentence ends like a question, like a contestant on a game show who answers a question, but is uncertain of the answer.
That's how Gen-Zers talk.
He's probably seeking re-assurance from Prior that he's answered the question correctly (as per Priors coaching).
Great description if it. A clear sign he was coached.
It wasn’t worth it just to have your “storm” gripped, was it Chubb?
We all know it was less than a mild breeze.