I get that you want to be playing devil's advocate. But honestly, the video was painful. Playing devil's advocate doesn't mean you have go out of your way to knock something if it means you're going to end up saying really stupid things.
A million buttons? The buttons are for the HVAC, preset buttons for the radio, and heated seats. Those are the buttons you want to have instead of having to go through a menu in the infotainment system. This isn't a very good review it all.
This Guy EXACTLY! I don’t want to look down when I’m driving. Car reviews have this problem of approaching cars like the people who buy them will be using them for the first time everyday, which is exactly what they do.
The Guy ; My thoughts exactly It was like watching Dumb and Dumber doing a car review I think Jonathan Yarkony and that guy with glasses do better reviews than these 2 fools
They were making fun of BMW for having the M logo and X emblem on the back, WTF?! These guys sounded like they didn't know anything about cars and were just randomly asked to do a review. Also, It's not a fair comparison to match the XC60 to the X3 M40i because it's obvious to car enthusiasts which is better.
This comparison is a bit uneven, the BMW is an X3 M40i, The Volvo is an R-Design T6 which should be compared to a regular X3 or switch the XC60 to the T8 engine.
This is a bit of a strange comparison. A X3 M40i at $65K+ should really go head to head with something like a Macan GTS or an SQ5. It's a sporting SUV. The Volvo goes against the Lexus RX or a GLC. It's tuned for comfort and usability, not sportiness. It should obviously be the X3 xDrive30i - that'd make more sense as they're both turbo'd 2.0L 4 cylinders. The lens flare was giving me a bit of a headache by the end too.
One of the few times I've strongly disliked a review. I think this one needs a "do-over!" I'm a subscriber and I thought this video lacked finesse and balance. C'mon guys!
Judging the interior design based on color which is optional based on the owners preference is.... illogical? 🤔 he's trying too hard to be blunt, and isn't very successful. It's less constructive and more pointless.
Even looking at that R-Design interior, there wasn't any reaction to the beige contrast stitching and the alcantara? I mean, that looked quite nice in my opinion even if it's black on black.
D3X / DevolvR I absolutely agree the details are what make a good black on black interior like this stand out. Even if I didn’t like the color I would at LEAST appreciate what they did as far as design goes.
Latvietis96 The BMW maybe the better performer, but that's about it. I like everything about the Volvo. It's different, sexy, distinctive, a good infotainment system, luxurious interior and features, and it's very safe. That's just my opinion.
i work on both car company i have seen all the issue every single day what customer come in for, granted all cars have there own issue but bmw cars is the worst compare to volvo cars if i would buy one i will choose the volvo
This review accomplished very little. What did we find out? The Volvo has comfy seats, super safety features, and soft and slow dynamics. The BMW is faster, with a better engine, and great efficiency. No surprises.
Yes, sorry this was a confusing review with a lot of whining about trivial design features - you can choose options you know. Some of us like having buttons versus touch screens and once you have had the vehicle for a week, you don't need to examine the dash to find the button you need. The XC60 is expensive starting at $59K so I think the X3 a more satisfying buy. I am also surprised to hear you guys agree the design of the X3 is bland. Surely those are adjectives you reserve for Audi vehicles ? Certainly when I look at an M Package X3, it is not bland.
There’s “too many buttons” because it’s easier to find a hard button while driving than it is to press a touchscreen which doesn’t have redundant buttons! And why are pops and bangs bad!? It’s an M!40i. It does 0-60 in 4.4 seconds! Gets 27 on the highway, has more interior space, it’s quieter and more refined in normal driving, and is overall more fully featured than the Volvo. For 5 grand more, the M40 is a much better all around car!
"The story isn't as good as a straight 6." Ok AutoGuide, what does that even mean? I like the BMW better too, but the way you presented this made no sense at all. "How come there are X badges on the back?" Well, it's an X3, so... Also, if you follow your logic, why does the Volvo have "X" badges on the back? C'mon guys, we all know you're better than this! I typically like AutoGuide's reviews, but this one was an absolute mess. That's too bad, because I really was looking for a good comparison between the two cars.
Actually, R design T6 is very not the luxury one. First, you should go to the T8, second for all the feeling of driving, the Volvo is an almost selfing drive car, that why the sensation is strange. it's made to be smooth. The most important in the test is to compare the pilot assist mode. Then you will understand why Volvo's experience is made that why. This car is not made to be driven, but it because your new sofa, and a 6 hours road is not anymore a problem
Holy hell those down thumbs, this has to be the worst I can remember in Autoguide times. I wonder if they will just pull this video and redo it or just make it private lol.
I could not agree more with the first two comments below ... nothing logical about the opinions and not helpful in outlining the features. dont know how you got the job
I had 9 Volvos. The last a XC90 V8. I said to my dealer i won´t buy 2 Volvos now to have a 8 cylinder. So after a Porsche Cayenne i have that M40i. I would never be happy with this nice but weak and miserable sounding Volvo. Each Volvo, as they have all mere 4 cylinders. And the fuel coonsumption is even more in this tortured small 4 cylinder engines.
Not sure I’ll ever buy another BMW, the safety features and noises are over the top. If you take your seatbelt off before coming to a stop, it will continue to yell at you even AFTER you put it in PARK 🤦♂️
Rules of UA-cam Autoguide comments: reviewers who are actually driving the car, have an opinion, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Volvo, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Toyota, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Honda, down vote. Not like the way a man talks, down vote. Not Craig Cole, down vote. Really hate what the viewers of this channel have become.
Ubon94 You pay for luxury. Plus most ppl lease these due to wanting the latest and greatest. At least this ($15k in 5 years) offers people like you a way to finally get into one. 😉
I get that you want to be playing devil's advocate. But honestly, the video was painful. Playing devil's advocate doesn't mean you have go out of your way to knock something if it means you're going to end up saying really stupid things.
Snowmation I agree, painfully bad review...
Oh bullshit. They do this all the time for other cars and no one ever says anything .
This was not an equal match up review. The T8 xc60 would have been a better comparison against the x3 m40i. 👎🏽
They were probably hung up on the fact its a plug in hybrid powertain vs pure dino.
A million buttons? The buttons are for the HVAC, preset buttons for the radio, and heated seats. Those are the buttons you want to have instead of having to go through a menu in the infotainment system. This isn't a very good review it all.
This Guy EXACTLY! I don’t want to look down when I’m driving. Car reviews have this problem of approaching cars like the people who buy them will be using them for the first time everyday, which is exactly what they do.
The Guy ; My thoughts exactly It was like watching Dumb and Dumber doing a car review I think Jonathan Yarkony and that guy with glasses do better reviews than these 2 fools
Dear AutoGuide, you may desire to redact the title of the video: it is named the X3 M40i, and not the X3 "M340i." Thank you.
Lucky Barber They have no clue...
Complaining about a black leather interior as if an all black BMW wouldn’t look equally as bland. 🤔🤨🙄
alliejr probably because (IIRC) when you order R-design, you are stuck with black?
alliejr Not to mention that BMW interior design is so tired like move on with something new!
But you're not stuck with the R-Design if you're not into black leather interiors.
the interior colour doesn't make it less luxurious
Not once did you mention it has the M package .....
They were making fun of BMW for having the M logo and X emblem on the back, WTF?! These guys sounded like they didn't know anything about cars and were just randomly asked to do a review. Also, It's not a fair comparison to match the XC60 to the X3 M40i because it's obvious to car enthusiasts which is better.
This comparison is a bit uneven, the BMW is an X3 M40i, The Volvo is an R-Design T6 which should be compared to a regular X3 or switch the XC60 to the T8 engine.
This is a bit of a strange comparison. A X3 M40i at $65K+ should really go head to head with something like a Macan GTS or an SQ5. It's a sporting SUV. The Volvo goes against the Lexus RX or a GLC. It's tuned for comfort and usability, not sportiness. It should obviously be the X3 xDrive30i - that'd make more sense as they're both turbo'd 2.0L 4 cylinders. The lens flare was giving me a bit of a headache by the end too.
I think you mean NX lol. RX is more 6 cylinder X5 size
One of the few times I've strongly disliked a review. I think this one needs a "do-over!" I'm a subscriber and I thought this video lacked finesse and balance. C'mon guys!
Kevin Sewell same! All he did was nit pick the volvo
Why are y’all complaining about buttons when you live with the car you eventually learn the car.....
ICEMAN™ Ryan Agreed. I have a 2017 X5 and owned a 2014 3 Series. iDrive and the infotainment system is the best.
Do you guys do homework before making a video? These two cars are not a match. And the Uber Volvo XC90 had the Volvo's safety features removed.
Judging the interior design based on color which is optional based on the owners preference is.... illogical? 🤔 he's trying too hard to be blunt, and isn't very successful. It's less constructive and more pointless.
Tyler Hampton Exactly I totally agree!
Tyler Hampton Agree...
Even looking at that R-Design interior, there wasn't any reaction to the beige contrast stitching and the alcantara? I mean, that looked quite nice in my opinion even if it's black on black.
D3X / DevolvR I absolutely agree the details are what make a good black on black interior like this stand out. Even if I didn’t like the color I would at LEAST appreciate what they did as far as design goes.
Not a good review. Nit-picking at the Volvo when it's the better choice..Whoever that guy is, is not good.
Latvietis96 The BMW maybe the better performer, but that's about it. I like everything about the Volvo. It's different, sexy, distinctive, a good infotainment system, luxurious interior and features, and it's very safe. That's just my opinion.
Latvietis96 Yeah, only in your opinion though.
i work on both car company i have seen all the issue every single day what customer come in for, granted all cars have there own issue but bmw cars is the worst compare to volvo cars if i would buy one i will choose the volvo
Love the negative dude nice review
I can see the positive in any add
This was what we needed
I agree with almost all the bad reviews of this video. Any other review is much better.
This review accomplished very little. What did we find out? The Volvo has comfy seats, super safety features, and soft and slow dynamics. The BMW is faster, with a better engine, and great efficiency. No surprises.
Yes, sorry this was a confusing review with a lot of whining about trivial design features - you can choose options you know. Some of us like having buttons versus touch screens and once you have had the vehicle for a week, you don't need to examine the dash to find the button you need. The XC60 is expensive starting at $59K so I think the X3 a more satisfying buy. I am also surprised to hear you guys agree the design of the X3 is bland. Surely those are adjectives you reserve for Audi vehicles ? Certainly when I look at an M Package X3, it is not bland.
What is the temperature lol? Its must me really cold
There’s “too many buttons” because it’s easier to find a hard button while driving than it is to press a touchscreen which doesn’t have redundant buttons! And why are pops and bangs bad!? It’s an M!40i. It does 0-60 in 4.4 seconds! Gets 27 on the highway, has more interior space, it’s quieter and more refined in normal driving, and is overall more fully featured than the Volvo. For 5 grand more, the M40 is a much better all around car!
"The story isn't as good as a straight 6."
Ok AutoGuide, what does that even mean? I like the BMW better too, but the way you presented this made no sense at all.
"How come there are X badges on the back?"
Well, it's an X3, so... Also, if you follow your logic, why does the Volvo have "X" badges on the back?
C'mon guys, we all know you're better than this! I typically like AutoGuide's reviews, but this one was an absolute mess. That's too bad, because I really was looking for a good comparison between the two cars.
The video title is wrong...
This was not a fair test as the volvo was not top of the spec being on t6 not t8 but bmw was
Maybe the would be more equivalent comparison?
Almost mistaken the Volvo for the Mazda CX-5
Really Volvo xc60 4 cylinders to compare the Volvo should have been t8
Crazy that paying over $55K can’t get you a great car without stupid issues
I hate when people say wake the neighbors.
Do a Buick review pls..
Actually, R design T6 is very not the luxury one. First, you should go to the T8, second for all the feeling of driving, the Volvo is an almost selfing drive car, that why the sensation is strange. it's made to be smooth.
The most important in the test is to compare the pilot assist mode. Then you will understand why Volvo's experience is made that why. This car is not made to be driven, but it because your new sofa, and a 6 hours road is not anymore a problem
I have XC90. The rough gear changes goes away if u go for Polestar upgrade ..
Adnan Kashwani
Polestar is the shiz-net.
Wow. I gave AutoGuide multiple tries, but it's time to unsubscribe. Craig and Jodi, or nothing. Bye.
Sporty Gimmicks.... Hmmm.. An SUV going 0-60 in 4.5 seconds sounds for real..
It's an M40i not M340i, also the button complaining is sort of silly when 3/4 the buttons are radio presets or hvac controls.
You two are absolutely hilarious
I quite liked this review...in contrast to apparently the last 5 comments. The back and forth was engaging and the new guy was nice to look at lol.
This Sebastian guy is super funny!
The XC60 has much more avant-garde.
The Volvo's interiors are badly designed, says the guy wearing a balloon for a jacket.
Holy hell those down thumbs, this has to be the worst I can remember in Autoguide times. I wonder if they will just pull this video and redo it or just make it private lol.
guys, talk about the cars!!!
Thank you for an honest review.
Love the review! Great job guys
Wtf. Volvo is incredible. What's up with the reviewer? All other brands are simply boring
Well I'm down with AutoGuide and I liked this video....I like'em all actually..... I would like to see track testing tho.
I could not agree more with the first two comments below ... nothing logical about the opinions and not helpful in outlining the features. dont know how you got the job
It's funny how the guys at Car and Drive like the XC60, but you amateurs don't. LOL OK
I had 9 Volvos. The last a XC90 V8. I said to my dealer i won´t buy 2 Volvos now to have a 8 cylinder. So after a Porsche Cayenne i have that M40i. I would never be happy with this nice but weak and miserable sounding Volvo. Each Volvo, as they have all mere 4 cylinders. And the fuel coonsumption is even more in this tortured small 4 cylinder engines.
No drag no fun...
Hmm in between the bmw and Volvo Audi ? Lol
Guys, stick to reviewing American cars....
horrible review tbh
I found this a stupid review. No detailed specifications
Ah man, such forced false banter and gimmicky wannabe host dynamics. A bit cringe.
I hate the lisping guy. He needs to go away. The xc60 is fantastic and more modern. Although the bmw is gonna be more fun to drive
They are right about the nanny safety features but... You can turn them off. Tragic hipster review, they should review clothes and that's about it.
I agree with the guy not driving. To me the Volvo looks boring the BMW looks better inside and out.
The other guy OVER praises many cars.
Just bad
exterior does not look like the R design
Not sure I’ll ever buy another BMW, the safety features and noises are over the top. If you take your seatbelt off before coming to a stop, it will continue to yell at you even AFTER you put it in PARK 🤦♂️
Rules of UA-cam Autoguide comments: reviewers who are actually driving the car, have an opinion, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Volvo, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Toyota, down vote. The reviewers say something bad about Honda, down vote. Not like the way a man talks, down vote. Not Craig Cole, down vote. Really hate what the viewers of this channel have become.
Hey, thanks for having our backs!
Negative Nancy’s!
Terrible
5 years later price is at $15,000.
Ubon94 You pay for luxury. Plus most ppl lease these due to wanting the latest and greatest. At least this ($15k in 5 years) offers people like you a way to finally get into one. 😉
These 2 guys are not good at being on camera.
horrible review tbh